stating that “[i]t would be nice if after appropriate medical attention pain would immediately cease, its purpose fulfilled; but life is not so accommodating. Those recovering from even the best treatment can experience pain. To say the Eighth Amendment requires prison doctors to keep an inmate pain-free in the aftermath of proper medical treatment would be absurd.”
How later courts described this case
- stating that “[i]t would be nice if after appropriate medical attention pain would immediately cease, its purpose fulfilled; but life is not so accommodating. Those recovering from even the best treatment can experience pain. To say the Eighth Amendment requires prison doctors to keep an inmate pain-free in the aftermath of proper medical treatment would be absurd.”
- holding that “an inch or two of water in the shower ... is not ‘an excessive risk to inmate health or safety,’ nor the ‘denial of the minimal civilized measure of life’s necessities’” (quoting Farmer, 511 U.S. at 834, 837, 114 S.Ct. 1970)
- holding that a procedure “involves a number of minor medical decisions . . . [that are] classic example[s] of matter[s] for medical judgment” and that the entire procedure must be viewed as a whole
- holding that an inch or two of standing water in the shower does not constitute an excessive risk of harm, such as contracting a communicable disease, even when the inmate had wound on foot
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
ILANA DIAMOND ROVNER, Circuit Judge,
concurring.
Snipes did not reply to defendants’ summary judgment motion and, even in his late filing, offered no evidence regarding Dr. Eh-rhardt’s decision to treat Snipes’ toenail without administering anesthetic. Snipes therefore failed to raise a factual question as to either Dr. Ehrhardt’s mental state or the propriety of his treatment method. I would leave the matter there and refrain from our own evaluation of medical procedures about which we are without evidence or expertise.