How later courts described this case
- holding that an allegation “that large fluorescent lights directly in front of and behind [an inmate’s] cell shone into his cell 24 hours a day, so that his cell was ‘constantly illuminated, and [he] had no way of telling night or day,’ and that this condition caused him ‘grave sleeping problems’ and other mental and psychological problems” was sufficient to state a claim of cruel and unusual punishment
- holding that an allegation “that large florescent lights directly in front of and behind [an inmate’s] cell shone into his cell 24 hours a day, so that his cell was ‘constantly illuminated, and [he] had no way of telling night or day,’ and that this condition caused him ‘grave sleeping problems’ and other mental and psychological problems” was sufficient to state a claim of cruel and unusual punishment
- holding that the plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment claim based on 24-hour lighting presented a triable issue of fact
- finding a disputed issue of fact 17 where the plaintiff alleged the defendants gave him personal hygiene items only when he 18 could pay for them and that his indigency forced him to choose between hygiene items and 19 legal supplies
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
RYMER, Circuit Judge,
Dissenting:
Under Sandin v. Conner, — U.S. -, 115 S.Ct. 2293 , 132 L.Ed.2d 418 (1995), Keenan’s transfer into the IMU does not implicate a liberty interest unless his confinement there “impose[d] atypical and significant hardship on [him] in relation to the ordinary incidents of prison life.” Id. at -, 115 S.Ct. at 2300 . Transfer from the general population to maximum security is “within the normal limits or range of custody which the conviction has authorized the State to impose,” even when the conditions in maximum security are “substantially more burdensome.” Meachum v. Fano, 427 U.S. 215, 225 , 96 S.Ct. 2532, 2538-39 , 49 L.Ed.2d 451 (1976). As Keenan’s confinement in maximum security was “within the normal limits or range of custody,” it follows that it could not have imposed an “atypical and significant hardship” on him. For the reasons stated by the district court, I also cannot agree that Keenan’s claims regarding the conditions of his confinement survive summary judgment. I therefore dissent.