analyzing Ninth Circuit cases and concluding that unavailability of witness does not constitute denial of due process “unless the unavailability ... is the result of unilateral, overt action by the government”
How later courts described this case
- analyzing Ninth Circuit cases and concluding that unavailability of witness does not constitute denial of due process “unless the unavailability ... is the result of unilateral, overt action by the government”
- recognizing “heavy ride” of a car as one element supporting founded suspicion to stop vehicle
- founded suspicion where two cars seen driving in tandem on road frequently used to bypass immigration checkpoint, one car appeared heavily loaded, and cars separated on sight of the patrol car
- alien secured release by border patrol by impersonating another alien who was qualified to be voluntarily returned to Mexico
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
WALLACE, Circuit Judge,
concurring:
I join in the majority opinion except for the issue as to whether Hernandez-Gonzalez was prejudiced due to the absence of the fifth alien. While the law was properly stated by the majority, I would not reach the issue. The unavailability of the alien was not due to the unilateral action of the government and on that basis alone, Hernandez-Gonzalez’s Mendez-Rodriguez claim is flawed.