holding that employee interviews conducted by outside firm relating to claim that corporation had a “slush” fund used to bribe purchasing agents were confidential communications and were protected by attorney- client privilege: while interviews could have been conducted by lay investigators, and accountants could have done audit, “neither would have had the training, skills and background necessary to make the independent analysis and recommendations which the Board felt essential to the future welfare of the corporation.”
How later courts described this case
- holding that employee interviews conducted by outside firm relating to claim that corporation had a “slush” fund used to bribe purchasing agents were confidential communications and were protected by attorney- client privilege: while interviews could have been conducted by lay investigators, and accountants could have done audit, “neither would have had the training, skills and background necessary to make the independent analysis and recommendations which the Board felt essential to the future welfare of the corporation.”
- finding that Diversified’s disclosure of documents in a nonpublic SEC investigation did not constitute a full waiver of the privilege because, holding otherwise, "may have the effect of thwarting the developing procedure of corporation to employ independent outside counsel to investigate and advise them in order to protect stockholders, potential stockholders and customers.”
- explaining that, for a communication to an attorney to be privileged, “the attorney must have been engaged or consulted by the client for the purpose of obtaining legal services or advice services or advice that a lawyer may perform or give in his capacity as a lawyer, not in some other capacity”
- holding that for policy reasons communications between a corporation and outside legal counsel for the purpose of corporate housecleaning retained attorney-client privilege despite disclosure to the SEC
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
BRIGHT, Circuit Judge,
dissenting:
As noted in my brother Henley’s dissent, Weatherhead, the plaintiff in the underlying action against Diversified, now advises us it (Weatherhead) has obtained the information here, in question from Diversified’s reports filed with the SEC. This change in circumstances in the litigation, in my opinion, moots this controversy and renders improper any issuance of a writ of mandamus to Chief District Judge Meredith, the respondent herein.
Although reluctant to express an opinion on the merits because of my view that the controversy is moot, I agree in the main with the dissenting views of Judge Henley.