sentence of three years set aside where it was imposed upon defendant who was merely an accessory and who had no record of prior convictions but who had pleaded not guilty and asked for a trial, and where the ringleader who had four prior felony convictions and who had pleaded guilty was sentenced to only two years imprisonment
How later courts described this case
- sentence of three years set aside where it was imposed upon defendant who was merely an accessory and who had no record of prior convictions but who had pleaded not guilty and asked for a trial, and where the ringleader who had four prior felony convictions and who had pleaded guilty was sentenced to only two years imprisonment
- appellate court set aside sentence which trial court had reimposed contrary to intimations in prior appellate opinion that sentence should be reduced
- The record shows that the trial judge imposed a heavier sentence on defendant who stood trial than on the codefendant who pleaded guilty
- abuse of discretion for trial court to enhance sentence because a defendant “availed himself of his right to a trial,” at least when the defense is not frivolous
Written by the judges who cited it.
Later courts went against this
Limited by United States v. Lawrence Janiec, in No. 74-1281 Appeal of Samuel Laytham, in No. 74-1282, 505 F.2d 983 (1975)
United States v. Wiley, 278 F.2d 500 (7th Cir. 1960), relied on by movants, is factually inapplicable to this record and it has been limited to its facts.
The opinion
DUFFY, Circuit Judge
(concurring).
The trial judge announced from the bench that it was the standard policy in his court that once a defendant stands trial, probation for such a defendant would not be considered. This policy or rule is self-imposed. It is contrary to the statute and the rule of criminal procedure authorizing probation. Such a rule should not be followed. A defendant m a criminal case should not be punished by a heavy^ sentence merely because he exercises his constitutional right to be tned before an impartial judge or jury.
In the case at bar, McGhee, the four-time convicted felon, and the ringleader, received a two-year term. The three defendants other than Wiley, all of whom had criminal records, received sentences of one year and a day. Yet, Wiley, who had a good previous record except for one juvenile matter when he was thirteen years old, received a three-year term. A realistic appraisal of the situation comPels the conclusion that Wiley’s comparalively severe sentence was due to the fact that he stood trial- No other P0SS1' ble basis is suggested for the disparity, Consciously or not, the learned trial judge again applied the standard of his rule when he reimposed the three-year , T ... , , sentence. I agree this sentence should ,, ... , , , , not be permitted to stand.