The opinion
*617 GARRETT, Chief Judge,
(specially concurring) .
In the contemporaneously decided case of Ex parte Dalton, 188 F.2d 170 , 38 C.C.P.A., Patents,-, a specially concurring opinion has been filed relating to the matter of the affidavits discussed there as here in both the majority and dissenting opinions. The issue in all material aspects is the same here as there and reference is made here to the specially concurring opinion there filed.