Opinion

Plotke v. White

  • 405 F.3d 1092
  • 86 Empl. Prac. Dec. (CCH) 41,953
  • 95 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 1025
  • 2005 U.S. App. LEXIS 7344
  • 2005 WL 984363
Court
Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit
Filed
Apr 28, 2005
Status
Published
Author
Tymkovich
On the bench
Seymour, McKay, Tymkovich
Cited by
312 cases
Authority
More cited than 24.4%

explaining that “the fourth element of a prima facie case is a flexible one that can be satisfied differently in varying scenarios” and “[t]he critical prima facie inquiry in all cases is whether the plaintiff has demonstrated that the adverse employment action occurred under circumstances which give rise to an inference of unlawful discrimination” (internal citations and quotation marks omitted)

How later courts described this case

  • explaining that “the fourth element of a prima facie case is a flexible one that can be satisfied differently in varying scenarios” and “[t]he critical prima facie inquiry in all cases is whether the plaintiff has demonstrated that the adverse employment action occurred under circumstances which give rise to an inference of unlawful discrimination” (internal citations and quotation marks omitted)
  • holding that employer’s reliance on a belief that plaintiff intended to deceive the employer was evidence of pretext when the decisionmakers admitted plaintiff “very well may not have attempted to deceive them” and that “they had no real solid proof that was her intent”
  • explaining that a variety of circumstances can give rise to inference of discriminatory motive, including actions or remarks made by decisionmakers that could be viewed as reflecting discriminatory animus and preferential treatment to employees outside protected class
  • stating that a jury could infer discrimination where, among other things, a supervisor subjectively believed the employee was not trustworthy but had no proof that the employee intended to deceive her employer

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

TYMKOVICH, Circuit Judge,

concurring.

I concur in the result, but differ with the majority in two areas.

First, I conclude that reversal is necessary because there is a genuine issue of fact concerning whether Dr. Plotke’s position was actually eliminated. See Op. at n. 9. I would not stray from the teaching of Kendrick v. Penske Transp. Servs., Inc., 220 F.3d 1220, 1229 (10th Cir.2000), that a plaintiff bears the burden of showing that her position was not in fact eliminated after discharge. Here, I am satisfied that the evidence is uncertain enough as to whether the Army eliminated her position, and if so, whether the elimination occurred long enough after the alleged discriminatory conduct such that the Kendrick test has been met. In any event, it appears the Army has at no point argued that it in fact fired her because it was eliminating her position.

While I also agree that Dr. Plotke has shown enough “inconsistencies” and “contradictions” in the Army’s proferred explanation of her termination to show disputed facts as to pretext, I differ with the majority’s characterization of some of the evidence. Dr. Plotke is entitled to show at trial that the defendants were biased against her and made the termination decision because of her sex. But many of the examples showing pretext are generalized statements of personal dislike. Personal dislike does not necessarily equate with intentional discrimination. Although statements or comments “may serve as circumstantial evidence of [pretext], the plaintiff must still show some nexus between the statements and the defendant’s decision to terminate the employee.” Shorter v. ICG Holdings, Inc., 188 F.3d 1204, 1209-10 (10th Cir.1999). I am confident that the district court at trial will be able to assess the relevancy of any proffered testimony to the alleged discriminatory conduct.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.