Opinion

National Labor Relations Board v. Brown

  • 380 U.S. 278
  • 58 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2663
  • 85 S. Ct. 980
  • 13 L. Ed. 2d 839
  • 1965 U.S. LEXIS 2306
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Filed
Mar 29, 1965
Status
Published
Author
Goldberg
On the bench
Brennan, Goldberg, White
Cited by
614 cases
Authority
More cited than 24.0%

holding that the “Court will not defer to the agency’s conclusory or unsupported assertions”

How later courts described this case

  • holding that the “Court will not defer to the agency’s conclusory or unsupported assertions”
  • explaining that a reviewing court owes no deference “when the agency simply has not exercised its expertise”
  • approving finding of Sec. 8(a)(1) violation when "employers' conduct is demonstrably so destructive of employee rights and so devoid of significant service to any legitimate business end that it cannot be tolerated consistently with the Act"
  • approving finding of § 8(a)(1) violation when “employers’ conduct is demonstrably so destructive of employee rights and so devoid of significant service to any legitimate business end that it cannot be tolerated consistently with the Act”

Written by the judges who cited it.

Distinguished

  • Distinguished by International Brotherhood of Boilermakers v. National Labor Relations Board, 858 F.2d 756 (1988)

    The Union contends that Brown is inapplicable because the employers in Brown acted “defensively” to preserve the integrity of the multiemployer bargaining unit in the face of a whipsaw strike, whereas in this case the Company used the tactic “offensively” to increase its bargaining power.
    Court of Appeals for the D.C. CircuitSep 30, 1988Read it

The opinion

Mr. Justice Goldberg,

whom The Chief Justice joins,

concurring.

I agree with the Court that, given the Buffalo Linen case, Labor Board v. Truck Drivers Union, 353 U. S. *293 87 , and applying it in light of the actualities of industrial relations, the employers’ conduct here is shown to be justified and necessary to preserve the integrity of the employers’ bargaining unit. After the union attempted a whipsaw strike against one member of the multiemployer bargaining unit, the other members locked out their employees. The struck employer attempted to carry on business by using management personnel, relatives of such personnel, and a few temporary employees. To avoid the whipsaw effect of the strike, the nonstruck employers then did the same. During the period of the lockout, all of the employers, struck as well as nonstruck, bargained with the union and, when agreement was reached, in all cases the temporary employees were dismissed and the union employees returned to their jobs.

As the Court seems to recognize, ante, p. 292, n. 6, this would be an entirely different case had the nonstruck employers locked out their employees and hired permanent replacements even if the struck employer had exercised his right to hire permanent replacements under the doctrine of Labor Board v. Mackay Radio & Telegraph Co., 304 U. S. 333 . If the Labor Board determined in such a case that the interference with employee rights was not justified by the legitimate economic interests of the employer, the Labor Board determination might well be controlling. See my concurring opinion in American Ship Building Co. v. Labor Board, post, at 327. Cf. Labor Board v. Erie Resistor Corp., 373 U. S. 221 . There would be grave doubts as to whether the act of locking out employees and hiring permanent replacements is justified by any legitimate interest of the nonstruck employers, for Buffalo Linen makes clear that the test in such a situation is not whether parity is achieved between struck and nonstruck employers, but, rather, whether the nonstruck employers’ actions are necessary to counteract the whipsaw effects of the strike and to preserve the em *294 ployer bargaining unit. Since in this case the nonstruck employers did nothing more than hire temporary replacements, an activity necessary to counter whipsawing by the union and to preserve the bargaining unit, I agree that, applying Buffalo Linen, the judgment of the Court of Appeals should be affirmed.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.