explaining that in conducting frivolity review, “wildly implausible allegations in the complaint should not be taken to be true, but the court ought not penalize the litigant for linguistic imprecision in the more plausible allegations”
How later courts described this case
- explaining that in conducting frivolity review, “wildly implausible allegations in the complaint should not be taken to be true, but the court ought not penalize the litigant for linguistic imprecision in the more plausible allegations”
- explaining that to “counter such threat and to protect its jurisdiction, the district courts are authorized by the All Writs Act . . . to restrict access to vexatious and abusive litigants”
- vacating an injunction that “[went] beyond what [was] sufficient to protect the ... court’s jurisdiction from [the prisoner’s] repetitive filings related to the condi tions of his confinement, and fail[ed] to uphold [the prisoner’s] right of access to the courts,” and concluding that “[t]he ... limited exceptions in the injunction, taken together, do not provide [the prisoner] with meaningful access.”
- noting that a “blanket injunction” prohibiting all in forma pauperis filings “would be overinclusive” and, thus, Congress tailored the limits on in forma pauperis filings “to minimize the exclusion of valid claims that involve fundamental interests”
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
BLACK, Circuit Judge, specially
concurring:
The district court’s injunction flowed from a mistaken finding of frivolity. I would vacate the injunction on that ground alone; therefore, I join in part III of the majority opinion.