Opinion

State v. Meyer

  • 246 Mo. 596
  • 152 S.W. 331
  • 1912 Mo. LEXIS 206
Court
Supreme Court of Missouri
Filed
Dec 20, 1912
Status
Published
Author
Brown
On the bench
Brown, Ferriss, Kennish
Cited by
1 cases
Authority
More cited than 49.5%

The opinion

BROWN, P. J

Defendant was charged by information with the crime of disturbing the peace of an individual. Prom a judgment of the circuit court of Montgomery pounty quashing the information, the State appeals.

No constitutional question was lodged in the case in any manner. The affidavit for appeal is in the usual form, except that it concludes with a prayer that plaintiff be granted an appeal to the Supreme Court.

Since the filing of the transcript in this court the defendant and the prosecuting attorney of Montgomery county have each filed motions praying that the appeal be transferred to the St. Louis Court of Appeals.

If the appeal was properly granted to this court, then it must remain here for final determination. Jurisdiction cannot be conferred upon our courts of appeals by consent of the parties. [State ex rel. v. Nixon et al., 232 Mo. 496 .]

It is manifest that this appeal was granted to this court pursuant to Sec. 5305, R. S. 1909, which specifically provides for an appeal by the State to the Supreme Court in all cases where an indictment or information is quashed.

Upon examination, we find that said Sec. 5305, R. S. 1909, was enacted in substantially its present form prior to the year 1855. [Sec. 14, Ch. 127, p. 1204, R. S. 1855]. This was at least twenty years before any of our courts of appeals were created, and a still longer period before the St. Louis Court of Appeals was given jurisdiction of appeals from Montgomery county.

In 1875 the St. Louis Court of Appeals was created. [Sec. 12, Art. 6, Constitution of 1875; R. S. 1909, p. 88.]

By said Constitution of 1875 and the amendment thereto of 1884 (R. S. 1909, p. 101), said courts of appeals were given jurisdiction to hear and determine all appeals in misdemeanor cases from the circuit *598 courts of their respective districts. [State v. Ramsey, 110 Mo. 212 ; State v. Zinn, 141 Mo. 329 ; State v. McKee, 196 Mo. 106 ; State v. Cook, 217 Mo. 326 .]

It follows that the constitutional provisions last above named have modified the provisions of Sec. 5305, R. S. 1909 (originally enacted prior to 1875), so as to vest in the courts of appeals jurisdiction to hear and determine appeals by the State from judgments quashing informations and indictments, in all cases where the crime charged is only a misdemeanor.

It is therefore ordered that this case be transferred to the St. Louis Court of Appeals.

Ferriss and Kennish, JJ., concur.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.