Opinion

Brown v. Farnham

  • 48 Minn. 317
  • 51 N.W. 377
  • 1892 Minn. LEXIS 413
Court
Supreme Court of Minnesota
Filed
Feb 3, 1892
Status
Published
Author
Vanderburgh
On the bench
Vanderburgh
Cited by
5 cases
Authority
More cited than 79.9%

The opinion

Vanderburgh, J.

The mutual agreement, under seal, entered into by the defendant with his creditors, including the plaintiff, which is set forth in the record, and under which he agreed to surrender and transfer certain property to the trustee therein named, to be disposed of and divided among such creditors in satisfaction and discharge of their claims, is a valid composition deed, and a bar to this action. The cause of action on the note sued on is superseded by the new agreement, and the plaintiff’s rights and remedies must be determined by it. The reason of this is apparent. The composition deed is an agreement between the creditors and the defendant, which involves rights and interests common to all the creditors who join in it. It is an agreement that each shall receive the amount or consideration stipulated for, and nothing more, as the basis of the debtor’s discharge from the debts due to such creditors. Each creditor must be presumed to act on the faith of the engagement of the others, and the beneficial consideration to each is the obligation of the rest to forbear; and the debtor secures to them a common fund-for the benefit of all, so that all are mutually *319 bound; and there is a consideration as between themselves, of which the debtor is also entitled to avail himself. White v. Kuntz, 107 N. Y. 518 , (14 N. E. Rep. 423,) and cases; Perkins v. Lockwood, 100 Mass. 249 ; Good v. Cheesman, 2 Barn. & Adol. 328; Goodrich v. Stanley, 24 Conn. 613, 621 .

Judgment affirmed.

(Opinion published 51 N. W. Rep. 377 .)

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.