Opinion

Underwood v. Medical Clinic Board for Montgomery

  • 904 So. 2d 264
  • 2004 Ala. LEXIS 352
  • 2004 WL 3017027
Court
Supreme Court of Alabama
Filed
Dec 30, 2004
Status
Published
Author
Harwood
On the bench
Stuart, Nabers, Houston, See, Lyons, Johnstone, Woodall, Harwood, Brown
Cited by
1 cases

The opinion

HARWOOD, Justice

(concurring specially).

I concur in the main opinion. I write specially to underscore why “all property” of a medical clinic board is exempt from ad valorem taxes under § 11-58-14, Ala. Code 1975. Under § 11-5-5(4) a medical clinic board is authorized “[t]o acquire ... one or more medical clinics and any necessary or desirable clinical facilities.” The statutory definition of a “medical clinic,” found at § 11-58-1(3), is quoted in the main opinion. “Clinical facilities” are defined at § 11-58-1(1) as:

“Real property for the location or better utilization of a medical clinic, buildings, parking areas, garages, storage facilities, outbuildings, machinery, equipment, furniture, and fixtures useful or desirable in the operation of a medical clinic.”

Accordingly, “all property” a medical clinic owns presumably will fit within those statutory parameters. Consistent with that proposition, a medical clinic board is authorized to lease “to others” only “medical clinics or parts of clinics and any clinical facilities_” § 11-58-5(6). Therefore, the exempted “all property” of a medical clinic board, leased to a third party, must necessarily consist of a medical clinic or clinical facilities. I agree that it is only that ownership, and the first-party lease by the medical clinic board, that we should look to in determining whether the exemption from taxation found in § 11-58-14 is available.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.