Opinion

Fay v. Jones

  • 38 Tenn. 442
Court
Tennessee Supreme Court
Filed
Dec 15, 1858
Status
Published
Author
Wright
On the bench
Wright
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Wright, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The Chancellor dismissed the bill upon demurrer, and the question is, whether his decree can be. maintained ?

We shall treat the bill and amended bill as one, because they were filed at the same time, and the Chancellor’s decree is upon both, and so we suppose the demurrer was intended.

So far as the complainant seeks relief, as the surety or stayor of Jones, the bill is demurrable, because it made no case for the issuance of an attachment under the acts of 1836 and 1843.

Jones is shown to be ■ a citizen of Bedford county, and it is not alleged that he is about to remove, or any other cause for an attachment stated.

If, therefore, the demurrer had been confined to this part of the bill, it would have been well taken.

*444 But this was not the case. It is a general demurrer to the whole bill. And it appears that the defendant, Jones, is indebted to complainant in the sum of $2880.00, and it is alleged, that he had made a fraudulent conveyance of fifty-two acres of land -to the defendants, Brome and Jett, to hinder and delay his creditors; and the bill seeks a sale of this land, as well to pay this debt, as complainant’s liabilities, as surety and stayor.

As a creditor, whether in judgment or not, the bill was maintainable by complainant, under the act of 1852, ch. 365, sec. 10; and the demurrer being too broad, lost its effect upon every part of the bill. Story’s Eq. Pl., § 443.

But it is said the bill is multifarious, because it also seeks to subject Jones’ interest in another tract of land, but we do not think this is so, under the rule laid down in Johnson v. Brown et al., 2 Hum., 327 .

But if it were, we apprehend the objection could only be taken by special demurrer. Story’s Eq. Pl., § 455.

We reverse the decree, overrule the demurrer, and remand the cause, that defendants may answer.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.