determining that the appellant had failed to raise a discernible argument with regard to any factual errors contained in the trial court's findings because it did not point to any specific finding as being incorrect, but rather raised a general objection to them, thereby "shift[ing] the burden upon this court to comb through the 249 [findings] and determine which of the [findings] are erroneous"
How later courts described this case
- determining that the appellant had failed to raise a discernible argument with regard to any factual errors contained in the trial court's findings because it did not point to any specific finding as being incorrect, but rather raised a general objection to them, thereby "shift[ing] the burden upon this court to comb through the 249 [findings] and determine which of the [findings] are erroneous"
- explaining that “a plaintiff may recover for [the negligent infliction of emotional distress], absent any physical manifestation of his or her psychological injury or actual physical presence within a zone of danger, where a reasonable person, normally constituted, would be unable to adequately cope with the mental stress engendered by the circumstances of the case”
- determining that the Restatement exception regarding a "potential adverse impact of the determination on the public interest [,] or "because the party sought to be precluded ... did not have an adequate opportunity or incentive to obtain full and fair adjudication in the initial action” did not apply to the facts of the case
- ruling on “the question of whether [Hawai'i Revised Statutes (HRS) ] § 663-10.5 superseded HRS § 663-10.9(1)” even though “the court never ruled on the issue” because it was “an issue of law that can be determined by this court without remand”
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
Concurring Opinion by
LEVINSON, J.
I fully concur in the opinion of the court, including its citation of Lee v. Corregedore, 83 Hawai'i 154, 159 , 925 P.2d 324, 329 (1996), for the proposition that “a ‘special relationship’ between DHS and Minor is required to give rise to a duty on DHS’s part to protect Minor from harm.” Opinion of the court at 287, 178 P.3d at 563. I write additionally, however, solely to emphasize that I continue to adhere to my disagreement in Lee v. Corregedore, “for at least four reasons, with the calculus employed by the majority in [that] case in determining whether ... a ‘special relationship’ ” existed between Corregedore, the Veterans Services Counselor employed by the State of Hawaii Department of Defense, and Perreira, the deceased veteran-counselee. See id. at 173-87, 925 P.2d at 343-57 (Levinson, J., dissenting, joined by Klein, J.). As such, I still believe that that appeal was wrongly decided.