Opinion

Mariani v. Trustees of Tufts College

  • 1 Mass. App. Ct. 869
  • 306 N.E.2d 833
  • 1974 Mass. App. LEXIS 713
Court
Massachusetts Appeals Court
Filed
Feb 5, 1974
Status
Published
Cited by
1 cases
Authority
More cited than 47.5%

The opinion

By these proceedings, commenced in 1972, the petitioner seeks a writ of *870 mandamus to compel the respondent (1) to readmit the petitioner as a student in the doctoral program of the respondent’s graduate school of arts and sciences and (2) to examine the petitioner on a doctoral thesis submitted by him in 1961. The petitioner has appealed from an order sustaining (without leave to amend) the respondent’s demurrer to the petition. One of the grounds of the demurrer (see Channel Fish Co. Inc. v. Boston Fish Market Corp. 359 Mass. 185, 187 [1971]), is that mandamus does not lie to compel a private institution such as the respondent to perform the acts prayed for in the petition. An examination of the respondent’s charter (St. 1852, c. 141, as from time to time amended), of which we can and do take judicial notice (American Steel & Wire Co. v. Bearse, 194 Mass. 596, 600-601 [1907]; Baizen v. Board of Pub. Works of Everett, ante, 602, 604, n. 5 [1973], and cases cited), discloses that the respondent is a private educational corporation 1 in or in the property of which the petitioner has no rights personal to himself (cf. Moustakis v. Hellenic Orthodox Soc. of Salem & Peabody, 261 Mass. 462, 467-468 [1928]). An examination of the petition in this matter discloses, as the petitioner all but admits in his brief, that the rights here sought to be vindicated are purely private and contractual in nature. Compare Curry v. Lasell Seminary Co. 168 Mass. 7 (1897); Hall v. Mount Ida School for Girls, Inc. 258 Mass. 464 (1927); Hood v. Tabor Academy, 296 Mass. 509 (1937). Mandamus does not lie for the vindication of such rights. Parrotta v. Hederson, 315 Mass. 416, 418-419 (1944).

JohnP. Dowcett forthe petitioner.

Michael J. Liston for the respondent.

Order sustaining demurrer affirmed.

We are not here concerned with any relationships which the respondent may from time to time have with an agency of government. Contrast Trustees of Tufts College v. Volpe Constr. Co. Inc. 358 Mass. 331 (1970).

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.