Opinion

Scanlan v. Geddes

  • 112 Mass. 15
Court
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
Filed
Mar 15, 1873
Status
Published
Author
Ames
On the bench
Ames
Cited by
27 cases
Authority
More cited than 98.0%

The opinion

Ames, J.

This case is substantially disposed of by the decision in Hurley v. Brown, 98 Mass. 545 . It was there held that a written promise to convey an estate in a certain street would be presumed to relate to an estate owned by the party making the promise. If he owned but one estate answering that description, that is to be regarded as the one to which the description refers. The written memorandum therefore has the same meaning as if the expression had been “ my house between D and E streets,” which would have been a sufficient description. Bird v. Richardson, 8 Pick. 252 . Phelps v. Sheldon, 13 Pick. 50 . Atwood v. Cobb, 16 Pick. 227 .

It is equally clear also that the house was to be conveyed, not as mere personal property with an easement in land, but by a warranty deed, and as real estate. Esty v. Currier, 98 Mass. 500 , and cases there cited. The proper construction of the agreement is that the house was to be conveyed, with the land upon which it stood, and so much more as was necessary to its beneficial enjoyment, and within the power of the defendant to convey. Forbush v. Lombard, 13 Met. 109 . Johnson v. Rayner, 6 Gray, 107 . Wooley v. Groton, 2 Cush. 305 . Greenwood v. Murdock, 9 Gray, 20 .

As the defendant distinctly refused to fulfil the contract, nothing was necessary on the plaintiff’s part except a readiness and willingness, accompanied with an ability, to do all that the agreement required of him, provided the defendant would concurrently do what was required of him; and provided, also, this readiness, willingness and ability were duly made known to the defendant. No more formal tender was necessary than was made by the plaintiff. Cook v. Doggett, 2 Allen, 439 ., and cases there cited.

Judgment for the plaintiff; damages to be assessed in the Superior Court.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.