Opinion

Canon-McMillan School District v. Bioni

  • 110 Pa. Commw. 584
  • 533 A.2d 179
  • 1987 Pa. Commw. LEXIS 2591
Court
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Filed
Oct 30, 1987
Status
Published
Author
Crumlish
On the bench
Barry, Colins, Craig, Crumlish, Doyle, MacPhail, Palladino
Cited by
10 cases
Authority
More cited than 9.2%

The opinion

Dissenting Opinion by

President Judge Crumlish, Jr:

I respectfully dissent.

The majority’s conclusion that the verdict is contrary to the weight of the evidence is an arrogation of the jury’s factfinding function. It must be emphasized that a new trial is to be ordered only where the verdict is so contrary to the weight of the evidence as to shock orie’s *601 sense of justice. Merely conflicting evidence is not sufficient. Kopeika v. Medical Services Association, 347 Pa. Superior Ct. 500 , 500 A.2d 1168 (1985).

As conceded by the majority, the issue of whether the lathe was realty or personalty was a factual question properly submitted to the jury. The majority has chosen, however, to give controlling weight to certain testimony indicating the School Districts intent to maintain the lathe as personalty. Specifically, the majority cites the School Districts flexibility in accommodating changing educational needs and the fact that the lathe was not bolted to the floor and had been moved.

Conversely, the jury relied on the lathes sheer weight, the relative permanence of its electrical connections, and testimony that the lathe had been moved only once in six years, to conclude that it had become a permanent fixture for governmental immunity purposes. I believe, therefore, that the jury’s verdict is amply supported by the evidence and that the repetition of a new trial is unnecessary.

Judge Doyle joins in this dissent.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.