Opinion

J.H. France Refractories Co. v. Allstate Insurance

  • 372 Pa. Super. 575
  • 539 A.2d 1345
  • 1988 Pa. Super. LEXIS 972
Court
Superior Court of Pennsylvania
Filed
Apr 6, 1988
Status
Published
Author
Cirillo
On the bench
Brosky, Cavanaugh, Cirillo, Files, Johnson, Kelly, Montemuro, Popovich, Sole, Tamilia
Cited by
6 cases
Authority
More cited than 7.5%

Reversed by J.H. France Refractories Co. v. Allstate Insurance, 521 Pa. 91 (1989)

The opinion

CIRILLO, President Judge,

dissenting:

I join Judge Brosky’s dissenting opinion. I write separately only to emphasize my disagreement with the majority’s implication that a court’s jurisdiction in a declaratory judgment action hinges on whether or not new plaintiffs will file new lawsuits during the pendency of the action.

In Vale Chemical Co. v. Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co., 512 Pa. 290 , 516 A.2d 684 (1986), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court dismissed the declaratory judgment action for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Sandra Smith, the tort plaintiff involved in the original case, was not joined in the subsequent declaratory judgment action. The court stated: “While we recognize the importance of the ques *585 tions involved in this matter, importance alone does not confer jurisdiction where it does not otherwise exist.” Id., 512 Pa. at 296 , 516 A.2d at 687-88 (emphasis added). In the case before us, unlike the situation in Vale, the court had jurisdiction at the time the action was filed. It was only since the filing of the declaratory judgment action that additional lawsuits were filed. I agree with Judge Brosky that the filing of additional lawsuits cannot divest a court of jurisdiction where it otherwise exists. See generally 20 Am.Jur.2d, Courts § 147.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.