Opinion

United Steel v. Mine Safety & Health Admin.

  • 925 F.3d 1279
Court
Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
Filed
Jun 11, 2019
Status
Published
On the bench
Henderson, Rogers, Katsas
Cited by
65 cases
Authority
More cited than 7.9%

explaining that an agency acts arbitrarily if it provides “no explanation for the change” in its policies or “completely ignores its 14 previous finding[s]”

How later courts described this case

  • explaining that an agency acts arbitrarily if it provides “no explanation for the change” in its policies or “completely ignores its 14 previous finding[s]”
  • explaining that vacatur is the ordinary course in the context of the Administrative Procedure Act’s similar remedial language
  • The agency “explains neither how the [agency action] can be saved nor how vacatur will cause disruption. We therefore take the normal course and vacate.”
  • agency shift from a policy requiring certain examination to take place prior to a miner’s shift to a policy permitting a miner to begin working before the examination had taken place

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

United States Court of Appeals

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

Argued March 12, 2019 Decided June 11, 2019

No. 18-1116

UNITED STEEL, PAPER AND FORESTRY, RUBBER,

MANUFACTURING,

ENERGY, ALLIED INDUSTRIAL AND SERVICE WORKERS

INTERNATIONAL UNION,

AFL-CIO-CLC AND UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA

INTERNATIONAL UNION,

PETITIONERS

v.

MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION AND

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA, SECRETARY OF LABOR,

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR,

RESPONDENTS

On Petition for Review of a Final Rule of

the Mine Safety & Health Administration

Laura Karr argued the cause for the petitioner United

Mine Workers. Susan J. Eckert argued the cause for the

petitioner United Steelworkers. Joseph M. Santarella, Jr. and

Andrew D. Roth were with them on brief.

Emily Toler Scott, Attorney, Mine Safety & Health

Administration, argued the cause for the respondents. Ali A.

Beydoun, Counsel, Appellate Litigation, was with her on brief.

2

Before: HENDERSON, ROGERS and KATSAS, Circuit

Judges.

Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit Judge HENDERSON.

Opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part filed by

Circuit Judge KATSAS.

KAREN LECRAFT HENDERSON, Circuit Judge: The Mine

Safety and Health Administration (MSHA), housed in the

United States Department of Labor (Labor), sets health and

safety standards for mine operations. Its regulatory authority

is subject to a unique limitation: “[n]o mandatory health or

safety standard . . . shall reduce the protection afforded miners

by an existing mandatory health or safety standard.” 30

U.S.C. § 811(a)(9). The no-less-protection standard occupies

center stage in the case before us. In 2017, MSHA

promulgated a safety standard that requires mine operators to

examine all areas before miners begin work and to record all

“conditions that may adversely affect safety or health”

discovered during the examination. Examinations of Working

Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. 7680, 7682

(Jan. 23, 2017) (2017 Standard). Fourteen months later,

however, MSHA amended the requirements, allowing

examinations to occur before or as miners begin work and

allowing mine operators to exclude from their records adverse

conditions that are promptly corrected. Examinations of

Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg.

15,055 (Apr. 9, 2018) (codified at 30 C.F.R. §§ 56.18002(a)–

(c), 57.18002(a)–(c)) (2018 Amendment). We are called upon

to decide whether MSHA explained adequately how the

amendments to the 2017 Standard comply with the no-less-

protection standard.

3

I. BACKGROUND

The Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977, Pub. L.

No. 91-173, 83 Stat. 742 (codified as amended at 30 U.S.C.

§§ 801 et seq.) (Mine Act), directs the Labor Secretary to

“develop, promulgate, and revise as may be appropriate,

improved mandatory health or safety standards for the

protection of life and prevention of injuries in coal or other

mines.” 30 U.S.C. § 811(a). The Secretary discharges his

Mine Act responsibilities through MSHA. The Mine Act

includes a no-less-protection standard, which provides that

“[n]o mandatory health or safety standard . . . shall reduce the

protection afforded miners by an existing mandatory health or

safety standard.” Id. § 811(a)(9). This unusual limitation

“expressly mandates that no reductions in the level of safety

below existing levels be permitted, regardless of the benefits

accruing to improved efficiency.” United Mine Workers of

Am., Int’l Union v. Dole, 870 F.2d 662, 666 (D.C. Cir. 1989).

MSHA has for decades required examinations of mine

workplaces and imposed recordkeeping requirements on mine

operators. From 1979 to 2017, MSHA required “[a]

competent person designated by the operator” to “examine

each working place at least once each shift for conditions which

may adversely affect safety or health.” 30 C.F.R. § 56.18-2(a)

(1980); see also id. § 57.18-2(a) (same requirements for

underground mines). The examination could occur anytime

during the shift. Id. The standard also mandated that

operators keep “[a] record that [] examinations were

conducted.” Id. § 56.18-2(b); see also id. § 57.18-2(b)

(underground mines).

In 2017, MSHA decided to impose more stringent

requirements. Examinations of Working Places in Metal and

Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. at 7680–81. It adopted a new

4

standard for workplace examinations: “[a] competent person

designated by the operator shall examine each working place

at least once each shift before miners begin work in that place,

for conditions that may adversely affect safety or health.” 30

C.F.R. § 56.18002(a) (2017) (emphasis added) (2017

Standard); see also id. § 57.18002(a) (underground mines). It

also added more detailed recordkeeping requirements,

demanding for the first time that a record of an examination

include (as relevant here): a “description of each condition

found that may adversely affect the safety or health of miners.”

Id. § 56.18002(b); see also id. § 57.18002(b) (underground

mines). The 2017 Standard was originally slated to take effect

on May 23, 2017. MSHA twice delayed the effective date.

See Examinations of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal

Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. 15,173 (March 27, 2017); Examinations

of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg.

23,139 (May 22, 2017). After a three-day period of

effectiveness in October 2017, MSHA temporarily withdrew

the 2017 Standard and delayed its effective date for a third

time. See Examinations of Working Places in Metal and

Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. 46,411 (Oct. 5, 2017).

In April 2018, MSHA promulgated a final rule amending

the requirements of the 2017 Standard. Examinations of

Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at

15,055 (2018 Amendment). Under the 2018 Amendment, a

competent person must “examine each working place at least

once each shift before work begins or as miners begin work in

that place[] for conditions that may adversely affect safety or

health.” 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002(a) (emphasis added); see also

id. § 57.18002(a) (underground mines). Unlike the 2017

Standard, then, the 2018 Amendment gives mine operators the

option to conduct examinations as miners begin work in an

area. Id. The 2018 Amendment also modifies the

recordkeeping requirement to mandate that a “record shall

5

contain the . . . description of each condition found that may

adversely affect the safety or health of miners and is not

corrected promptly.” Id. § 56.18002(b) (emphasis added); see

also id. § 57.18002(b) (underground mines). The new

language allows a mine operator to omit from its records

promptly corrected adverse conditions. Id. The 2018

Amendment went into effect on June 2, 2018.

Petitioners the United Steel, Paper and Forestry, Rubber,

Manufacturing, Energy, Allied Industrial and Service Workers

International Union, AFL-CIO/CLC, and the United Mine

Workers of America International Union filed a timely petition

for review of the 2018 Amendment. They claim that the 2018

Amendment violates both the Mine Act’s no-less-protection

standard, 30 U.S.C. § 811(a)(9), and the Administrative

Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. §§ 701 et seq.

II. ANALYSIS

The Mine Act requires MSHA to “state the basis for its

conclusion” that a new health or safety standard satisfies the

no-less-protection standard. Nat’l Min. Ass’n v. MSHA, 116

F.3d 520, 536 (D.C. Cir. 1997) (per curiam) (no-less-protection

standard “requires the agency to state the basis for its

conclusion that the [standard] has been satisfied”). The

statement is subject to review under the Administrative

Procedure Act and must manifest that MSHA engaged in

reasoned decisionmaking. See id.; see also Rosebud Mining

Co. & Parkwood Res., Inc. v. MSHA, 827 F.3d 1090, 1101

(D.C. Cir. 2016) (MSHA action reviewed under

Administrative Procedure Act). Our review “is, as always,

‘highly deferential and presumes the validity of agency

action.’” Nat’l Min. Ass’n, 116 F.3d at 536 (quoting Dole, 870

F.2d at 666).

6

A. EXAMINATION REQUIREMENT

The petitioners first claim that MSHA failed to explain

adequately how the 2018 Amendment’s examination

requirement complies with the no-less-protection standard.

As noted, the 2017 Standard required examinations to occur

before miners begin work in an area. 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002(a)

(2017); see also id. § 57.18002(a). By contrast, the 2018

Amendment “allows miners to enter a working place at the

same time a competent person examines for adverse

conditions.” Examinations of Working Places in Metal and

Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,058. On its face, this

change appears to increase miners’ exposure to health and

safety risks. As the Labor Secretary has observed, a careful

person does not check the sturdiness of his ladder after

climbing half the rungs nor does a careful mine operator check

the safety of an area while allowing miners to work there. See

Secretary of Labor’s Response Brief at 18–19, Nat’l Mining

Ass’n et al. v. MSHA, No. 17-11207 (11th Cir. July 19, 2017)

(invoking ladder analogy for mine safety argument). Even so,

MSHA claims the no-less-protection standard is satisfied

because under the 2018 Amendment, as under the 2017

Standard, adverse conditions will be “identified and miner

notification provided before miners are potentially exposed to

the conditions.” 1 Examinations of Working Places in Metal

and Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,058.

1

MSHA contends on brief to us that the new examination

requirement creates additional safety benefits by reducing “the risk

that, between the time of the examination and the time miners begin

work, conditions will have changed and created new or different

hazards.” The contention does not appear in the administrative

record and so we do not consider it. See PG&E Gas Transmission,

Nw. Corp. v. FERC, 315 F.3d 383, 388 (D.C. Cir. 2003) (“[T]his

Court cannot consider . . . post hoc justifications” and “may only

7

The problem with this explanation is that the 2018

Amendment does not allow for notification before exposure.

Its notification provisions state: “[t]he operator shall promptly

notify miners in any affected areas of any conditions found that

may adversely affect safety or health” and “[c]onditions noted

by the person conducting the examination that may present an

imminent danger shall be brought to the immediate attention of

the operator.” 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002(a)(1)–(2). These

provisions require notification as soon as an adverse condition

is discovered. Id. Nowhere do they require notification

before miners are exposed. See id. Because the 2018

Amendment allows miners to work in an area before the

examination is completed, there is the likelihood that miners

may be exposed to an adverse condition before it is discovered.

Id. § 56.18002(a) (“A competent person . . . shall examine

each working place at least once each shift before work begins

or as miners begin work in that place.”). MSHA’s attempt to

explain how the examination requirement complies with the

no-less-protection standard relies on a non-existent

notification-before-exposure duty and is therefore arbitrary and

capricious. 2 Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n of U.S., Inc. v. State

consider the grounds on which the [agency] actually relied in making

its decision.”).

2

It is no answer to say, as MSHA does, that the preamble to the

2018 Amendment expresses MSHA’s intention that miners receive

notification before being exposed to adverse conditions.

Examinations of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 83

Fed. Reg. at 15,058 (“MSHA intends for adverse conditions to be

identified and miner notification provided before miners are

potentially exposed to the conditions.”). Mine operators must

comply with the notification requirements of the 2018 Amendment,

not MSHA’s statements “from the preamble, which itself lacks the

force and effect of law.” See Saint Francis Med. Ctr. v. Azar, 894

F.3d 290, 297 (D.C. Cir. 2018).

8

Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29, 43 (1983) (action is

arbitrary and capricious “if the agency has . . . offered an

explanation . . . so implausible that it could not be ascribed to

a difference in view or the product of agency expertise”).

The explanation is arbitrary and capricious for a second

reason: it cannot be reconciled with factual findings that

MSHA made in support of the 2017 Standard. An agency is

generally free to change positions so long as it can “show that

there are good reasons for the new policy,” not “that the reasons

for the new policy are better than the reasons for the old one.”

FCC v. Fox Television Stations, Inc., 556 U.S. 502, 515 (2009).

This flexibility has limits. If the “new policy rests upon

factual findings that contradict those which underlay its prior

policy,” the agency must offer “a reasoned explanation . . . for

disregarding facts and circumstances that underlay . . . the prior

policy.” Id. at 515–16. In promulgating the 2017 Standard,

MSHA found that “[i]f the examination is performed after

miners begin work, miners may be exposed to conditions that

may adversely affect their safety and health.” Examinations

of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg.

at 7689. For that reason, MSHA explained, the 2017 Standard

“requires that a competent person conduct an examination

before work begins so that conditions that may adversely affect

miners’ safety and health are identified before they begin work

and are potentially exposed.” Id. at 7683 (emphasis added).

MSHA took a new contrary-to-fact position in the 2018

Amendment: miners can begin work before the required

examination is completed without being exposed to adverse

conditions. Examinations of Working Places in Metal and

Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,058. It gave no

explanation for the change.

There is another unexplained departure. From 1979 to

2017, MSHA’s safety standard allowed operators to conduct an

9

examination anytime during a shift. See 30 C.F.R. § 56.18-

2(a) (1980); see also id. § 57.18-2(a) (underground mines).

This flexibility, in MSHA’s “experience,” created “a

significant degree of variability in how safety programs are

operationalized.” Examinations of Working Places in Metal

and Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. at 7689. MSHA

introduced the 2017 Standard, in part, to “reduce the variability

in how operators conduct examinations of working places and

thereby improve miners’ safety and health.” Id. The 2018

Amendment reintroduced that very same variability by

allowing examinations to occur before or while miners begin

work. E.g., 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002(a). Despite citing

increased flexibility as a boon for mine operators, MSHA

completely ignored its previous finding that increased

flexibility (read: variability) does not improve miner safety.

Examinations of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal

Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,058. For these reasons, we agree

with the petitioners that MSHA has failed to explain adequately

how the 2018 Amendment’s examination requirement

complies with the statutory no-less-protection standard.

B. RECORDKEEPING REQUIREMENT

The petitioners next argue that MSHA failed to provide a

reasoned explanation why the recordkeeping requirement of

the 2018 Amendment satisfies the no-less-protection standard.

In the preamble to the 2017 Standard, MSHA determined that

“recording all adverse conditions, even those that are

corrected immediately, will be useful as a means of identifying

trends,” which “should help inform mine management

regarding areas or subjects that may benefit from increased

safety emphasis.” See Examinations of Working Places in

Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. at 7686 (emphasis

added). MSHA acknowledged this determination in the

preamble to the 2018 Amendment. Examinations of Working

10

Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,059.

It nonetheless concluded that “a recording exception for

adverse conditions that are corrected promptly,” like the one

created by the 2018 Amendment, “will yield as much or more

in safety benefits, because it encourages prompt correction of

adverse conditions.” Id.

MSHA’s unsupported explanation does not withstand

scrutiny. An agency must “articulate a satisfactory

explanation for its action including a ‘rational connection

between the facts found and the choice made.’” State Farm

Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 463 U.S. at 43 (quoting Burlington Truck

Lines v. United States, 371 U.S. 156, 168 (1962)). MSHA

recognized that the recordkeeping requirements of both the

2017 Standard and the 2018 Amendment provide safety

benefits. Examinations of Working Places in Metal and

Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,059. Under the no-less-

protection standard, then, MSHA’s burden was to explain why

the benefits of the 2018 Amendment equal or exceed those of

the 2017 Standard. See 30 U.S.C. § 811(a)(9). MSHA

instead declared, without further elaboration, that the 2018

Amendment “will yield as much or more in safety benefits,

because it encourages prompt correction of adverse

conditions.” Examinations of Working Places in Metal and

Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,059. This reasoning—the

2018 Amendment will yield better safety protection by

incentivizing mine operators to promptly correct adverse

conditions—is, at best, specious. The 2017 Standard already

requires mine operators to “promptly initiate appropriate action

to correct [adverse] conditions.” 30 C.F.R.

§§ 56.18002(a)(1), 57.18002(a)(1). MSHA cannot, without

explanation, justify the 2018 Amendment on the basis that it

will encourage mine operators to follow safety measures

already required by law in the very same regulation.

Moreover, MSHA has offered no basis for its conclusion that

11

those supposed benefits will equal or exceed those yielded by

the 2017 Standard. Because the record lacks a reasonable

justification for the recordkeeping requirement’s supposed

safety benefits and any comparative analysis whatsoever,

MSHA’s explanation is arbitrary and capricious. See Amerijet

Int’l, Inc. v. Pistole, 753 F.3d 1343, 1350 (D.C. Cir. 2014)

(“conclusory statements will not do” under arbitrary and

capriciousness standard). 3

3

MSHA’s brief makes two additional arguments in support of

the recordkeeping requirement. It “reduces the risk of inundating

miners with information” and is “narrow” enough to lack safety

implications. But these arguments do not appear in the

administrative record and thus we do not consider them. SEC v.

Chenery Corp., 318 U.S. 80, 87 (1943) (“The grounds upon which

an administrative order must be judged are those upon which the

record discloses that its action was based.”).

Our dissenting colleague believes MSHA’s preamble statement

about “overwhelm[ing] the record with minor housekeeping issues”

counts as expressing concern about “inundating miners with

information.” Dissent at 7–8. We see no basis for concluding that

MSHA meant something other than what it said, especially

considering (1) the statement about “overwhelm[ing] the record”

appears in a paragraph regarding mine operator burdens,

Examinations of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 83

Fed. Reg. at 15,059, and (2) mine operators, not miners, maintain the

examination records, 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002(d) (“The operator shall

maintain the examination records for at least one year . . . .”).

Insofar as commenters raised a concern regarding the safety

implications of “cluttering the examination record,” Dissent at 8

(citing J.A. 769, 911), MSHA never adopted that concern as its own,

despite going out of its way to expressly adopt others. See

Examinations of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 83

Fed. Reg. at 15,059.

12

The dissent would uphold MSHA’s conclusory

explanation and repeatedly takes us to task for not affording

MSHA enough deference. Dissent at 3–8. The dissent

locates its deference principle in National Mining Association

v. MSHA, 116 F.3d 520 (D.C. Cir. 1997) (per curiam), a case

in which we rejected no-less-protection standard challenges to

an MSHA safety standard, id. at 535–49. Importantly,

however, the petitioners there challenged MSHA’s factual

determinations that the new standard provided miners with as

much protection as the old standard. E.g., id. at 542 (“The

Union’s remaining challenges under the no-less protection rule

require only brief comment because they too involve

challenges to the Secretary’ net effects determinations that the

new regulation will not diminish the level of safety for miners

that existed under the prior regulations.” (emphases added)).

Applying “well-established principles of deference to agency

action,” id. at 536, we rejected the challenges because “we are

required to defer to the agency on factual determinations

underlying its decision,” including a net safety effects

determination, id. at 537. A deference standard for “factual

determinations” has little to do with the arbitrary and

capriciousness challenge before us.

In addition, the dissent claims that, because MSHA’s thin

explanation for its compliance with the no-less-protection

standard in National Mining Association survived judicial

review, MSHA’s even thinner explanation here must do so as

well. Dissent at 4–5. Our colleague overlooks two crucial

points. First, the National Mining Association petitioners did

not challenge the adequacy of MSHA’s explanation for its

compliance with the no-less-protection standard and therefore

we did not decide whether that explanation would survive

arbitrary and capriciousness review. See Nat’l Mining Ass’n,

116 F.3d at 535–49. Any inferences the dissent divines from

National Mining Association regarding this issue are therefore

13

dicta. Second, National Mining Association upheld many

aspects of the challenged regulation, including those recited by

the dissent, see Dissent at 4–5, based on the petitioners’ failure

to provide evidence contradicting MSHA’s findings or

persuasive reasons for doubting its determinations. See, e.g.,

Nat’l Mining Ass’n, 116 F.3d at 539 (“The Union does not offer

any evidence to dispute the Secretary’s position.”); id. at 542

(“The Union has pointed to no reason to conclude that the

Secretary’s determination . . . is outweighed . . . .”); id. at 543

(finding “unpersuasive the Union’s contention that the new

regulation removes [] incentive[s] . . . .”). Here, by contrast,

MSHA had to contend with its own previous findings in

promulgating the 2017 Standard that requiring mine operators

to record all adverse conditions, including those that are

immediately corrected, helps “expedite[] the correction of

these conditions” and “identify[] trends” and “areas or subjects

that may benefit from increased safety emphasis.”

Examinations of Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal

Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. at 7686. Thus, an explanation that might

have sufficed in National Mining Association with MSHA

writing on a blank slate is inapplicable here with MSHA’s 2017

findings already on the books.

In sum, MSHA failed to offer a reasoned explanation why

the examination and recordkeeping requirements of the 2018

Amendment satisfy the no-less-protection standard. The 2018

Amendment is therefore ultra vires and unenforceable. See 5

U.S.C. § 706(2)(A). The ordinary practice is to vacate

unlawful agency action. See id. § 706(2) (“The reviewing

court shall . . . set aside agency action . . . found to be”

unlawful). In rare cases, however, we do not vacate the action

but instead remand for the agency to correct its errors. MSHA

asks us to do so here. The appropriateness of the remand-

without-vacatur remedy turns on two factors: “(1) the

seriousness of the deficiencies of the action, that is, how likely

14

it is the agency will be able to justify its decision on remand;

and (2) the disruptive consequences of vacatur.” Heartland

Reg’l Med. Ctr. v. Sebelius, 566 F.3d 193, 197 (D.C. Cir. 2009)

(internal quotation marks, brackets, and ellipses omitted)

(quoting Fox Television Stations, Inc. v. FCC, 280 F.3d 1027,

1048–49 (D.C. Cir. 2002)). MSHA explains neither how the

2018 Amendment can be saved nor how vacatur will cause

disruption. We therefore take the normal course and vacate

the 2018 Amendment. 4

The complicated procedural history of this case raises a

question about what standard governs after vacatur. See supra

at 4. We agree with the parties that vacatur of the 2018

Amendment automatically resurrects the 2017 Standard. The

2018 Amendment modifies the terms of the 2017 Standard and

so vacatur of the 2018 Amendment simply undoes those

modifications. Examinations of Working Places in Metal and

Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,056 (2018 Amendment

“makes changes to” Code of Federal Regulations provisions

“as amended by the Agency’s final rule on examinations of

working places that was published on January 23, 2017”). To

avoid any confusion, we order MSHA to reinstate the 2017

Standard upon issuance of the mandate attendant on this

opinion.

For the foregoing reasons, we vacate the 2018 Amendment

and order the 2017 Standard reinstated.

So ordered.

4

Because we vacate the 2018 Amendment based on MSHA’s

failure to explain adequately its compliance with the no-less-

protection standard, we need not—and hence do not—consider the

petitioners’ remaining APA and Mine Act arguments.

KATSAS, Circuit Judge, concurring in part and dissenting

in part: The Mine Safety and Health Administration

promulgated a regulation requiring mine operators to

(1) “examine each working place at least once each shift before

miners begin work in that place” and (2) prepare a “record”

describing “each condition found that may adversely affect the

safety or health of miners.” Examinations of Working Places

in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 82 Fed. Reg. 7680, 7695 (Jan.

23, 2017) (Mine Examinations I). After further review, MSHA

amended the regulation in two respects. Examinations of

Working Places in Metal and Nonmetal Mines, 83 Fed. Reg.

15,055, 15,057–58 (Apr. 9, 2018) (Mine Examinations II).

Operators now may conduct the examination “before work

begins or as miners begin work,” 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002(a)(1),

and the recording requirement now applies only to adverse

conditions that are “not corrected promptly,” id. § 56.18002(b).

I believe that MSHA adequately explained the second change

but not the first.

The Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977 contains

what has been described as a no-less-protection rule: “No

mandatory health or safety standard promulgated under this

subchapter shall reduce the protection afforded miners by an

existing mandatory health or safety standard.” 30 U.S.C.

§ 811(a)(9). When amending safety regulations, MSHA must

“state the basis for its conclusion that the rule has been

satisfied.” Nat’l Mining Ass’n v. MSHA, 116 F.3d 520, 536

(D.C. Cir. 1997) (per curiam). Our review of this

determination is “highly deferential and presumes the validity

of agency action.” Id. (quotation marks omitted). So, we do

not lightly reject MSHA’s evaluation of the “net safety effects

of a change in a regulation,” id. at 542, or the “factual

determinations underlying its decision,” id. at 537.

I agree with my colleagues that, even under this deferential

standard of review, MSHA failed to justify the amendment to

2

the examination requirement. MSHA asserted that miners

“will be notified” of adverse conditions “before they are

potentially exposed,” regardless of whether the examination is

conducted before or as they begin work. Mine Examinations

II, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,058. But the regulation itself requires

only that operators “promptly notify” miners of adverse

“conditions found.” 30 C.F.R. § 56.18002(a)(1). It does not

guarantee that such conditions will be found before exposure—

which hardly seems inevitable if the examination is conducted

as miners begin work rather than before. Because MSHA did

not explain how miners would be notified of hazards before

exposure, its decision was arbitrary and capricious.

In this Court, MSHA advanced more developed and more

plausible justifications for the amendment. Perhaps it would

be safe to conduct the examination as work begins, if the

inspector is always “just ahead” of the miners and warns them

of hazards “in real time.” Respondents’ Br. at 14. Perhaps this

would even improve safety, by minimizing “the risk that

conditions will be so changed” between the examination and

the beginning of work. Id. at 12. But MSHA did not assert

these justifications during the 2018 rulemaking. True, it noted

that mines have “dynamic work environments where

conditions are always changing.” Mine Examinations II, 83

Fed. Reg. at 15,057. But it did so only to urge a “best practice”

of conducting examinations “throughout the shift,” not to

suggest that examinations conducted as work begins are as safe

or safer than ones conducted before. See id. Of course, we

cannot uphold the amendment based on rationales that MSHA

first articulated in litigation, see Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n v.

State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29, 50 (1983), but the

agency remains free to consider them on remand.

Unlike my colleagues, I would uphold the amendment

limiting the recording requirement to hazards that are not

3

promptly corrected. MSHA’s analysis of this amendment

balanced three competing safety considerations. First, MSHA

recognized that “recording all adverse conditions, even those

that are corrected promptly, would be useful in identifying

trends and areas that could benefit from an increased safety

emphasis.” Mine Examinations II, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,059. But

MSHA then identified two countervailing considerations. It

reasoned that “a recording exception for adverse conditions

that are corrected promptly … encourages prompt correction of

adverse conditions.” Id. And it concluded that “requiring all

adverse conditions [to] be recorded in the examination record

would overwhelm the record with minor housekeeping issues.”

Id. The latter considerations are reasonable. Encouraging

prompt correction of hazards would seem to have obvious

safety benefits. Moreover, this Court has noted the risk of

“information overload,” Bldg. & Constr. Trades Dep’t, AFL-

CIO v. Brock, 838 F.2d 1258, 1277 (D.C. Cir. 1988) (quotation

marks omitted), and other federal agencies have acted to

prevent it, see, e.g., Truth in Lending, 74 Fed. Reg. 5244, 5281

(Jan. 29, 2009); Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards;

Occupant Crash Protection, 58 Fed. Reg. 46,551, 46,554

(Sept. 2, 1993).

My colleagues object that the record lacks “any

comparative analysis.” Ante at 11. But MSHA did compare

the competing safety considerations. It concluded that the

amended recording rule would produce “as much or more in

safety benefits” by heightening incentives to correct hazards

promptly, and that decluttering examination records would

provide further safety benefits. Mine Examinations II, 83 Fed.

Reg. at 15,059. My colleagues respond that MSHA’s safety

assessment was too “conclusory.” Ante at 12. National Mining

indicates otherwise. There, we upheld various amendments to

mine-safety regulations challenged as inconsistent with the no-

4

less-protection rule. In four instances, MSHA’s explanation

was not materially different from the one at issue here.

First, we upheld an amendment permitting the use of

electricity for vehicles to evacuate miners if a ventilation fan

shuts down. Commenters objected that electricity would be

dangerous in that circumstance, but MSHA asserted without

elaboration that the amendment would facilitate evacuations.

See Safety Standards for Underground Coal Mine Ventilation,

61 Fed. Reg. 9764, 9772 (Mar. 11, 1996) (Ventilation

Standards). We accepted the assertion and thought ourselves

“required to defer to the agency.” 116 F.3d at 537. We

explained: “In this case, the agency has determined that the

safety benefit gained by rapid evacuation of miners outweighs

the risk of ignition. We are poorly positioned to second-guess

the agency on the balancing of these two concerns.” Id.

Second, we upheld an amendment limiting pre-shift

inspections to violations of rules presenting an immediate

hazard to miners. MSHA asserted that narrowing the

inspections would improve safety, because “look[ing] for

violations that might become a hazard could distract examiners

from their primary duties.” Ventilation Standards, 61 Fed.

Reg. at 9793. We accepted the explanation without plumbing

the record for more. 116 F.3d at 540.

Third, we upheld an amendment permitting less frequent

inspection of fans that use an automated monitoring system.

MSHA asserted that the improved technology would “provide

greater safety” on balance. Safety Standards for Underground

Coal Mine Ventilation, 57 Fed. Reg. 20,868, 20,874 (May 15,

1992). Our response: “Where an evaluation is to be made of

the net safety effects of a change in a regulation, the court

properly defers to [MSHA’s] evaluation.” 116 F.3d at 542.

5

Fourth, we upheld an amendment that narrowed another

inspection recording rule to exclude defects “corrected by the

end of th[e] shift.” 30 C.F.R. § 75.312(g)(1). Commenters

objected that the amendment would reduce safety by

eliminating information about “recurring problems that may

lead to bigger problems.” Ventilation Standards, 61 Fed. Reg.

at 9772. MSHA disagreed and asserted that “no safety purpose

is served by requiring examiners to record problems” that had

been promptly corrected. Id. We upheld the amendment, once

again based on “our deference to [MSHA’s] determination of

net effects.” 116 F.3d at 543.

Given these holdings, we should accept MSHA’s

explanation in this case. The agency correctly understood the

governing legal question—whether the amendment reduced

health or safety protections for miners. It identified

considerations reasonably bearing on that question. And it

compared the competing considerations to make an explicit

assessment of the “net safety effects of a change in a

regulation.” 116 F.3d at 542. As National Mining recognized,

we are “poorly positioned to second-guess the agency on the

balancing” of the relevant safety risks and benefits. Id. at 537.

My colleagues object that the petitioners in National

Mining did not challenge “the adequacy of MSHA’s

explanation,” but only the “factual determinations that the new

standard provided miners with as much protection as the old

standard.” Ante at 12. Our opinion did not suggest that

distinction. Rather, it was framed as a review of MSHA’s

explanations: we held that MSHA must “state the basis for its

conclusion that the [no-less-protection] rule has been

satisfied;” then, we found “[i]n each case … no grounds to

conclude that the Secretary failed to engage in reasoned

decisionmaking.” 116 F.3d at 536. Moreover, there was no

reason to distinguish between MSHA’s explanation and its

6

factfinding. For each challenged regulation, the agency

identified safety benefits to the amended rule, acknowledged

countervailing costs, and concluded that the benefits

outweighed the costs. Those “factual determinations,” as my

colleagues describe them, were the agency’s explanation of

why each proposed amendment was consistent with the no-

less-protection rule. And as shown above, they were neither

different in kind from, nor more fully developed than, the

determination made here by MSHA.

My colleagues further contend that MSHA failed to

address “its own previous findings” regarding the 2017

recording rule. Ante at 13. But MSHA did address its key prior

finding. In 2017, MSHA concluded that “recording all adverse

conditions, even those that are corrected immediately, will be

useful as a means of identifying trends.” Mine Examinations I,

82 Fed. Reg. at 7686. In assessing the 2018 amendment,

MSHA recognized that benefit of the 2017 rule, but concluded

that two competing safety considerations outweighed it. Mine

Examinations II, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,059. In that respect, the

two analyses are consistent. In 2017, MSHA further stated: “a

record that notes the adverse conditions prior to miners

working in an area expedites the correction of these conditions

notwithstanding the regularity in which the adverse conditions

occur.” Mine Examinations I, 82 Fed. Reg. at 7686. That

statement addressed a suggestion to exclude from the recording

requirement uncorrected hazards that were “regularly

recurring.” See id. In 2018, no further comment on this point

was necessary, as there was no proposal to revisit the issue. In

2017, one commenter argued that excluding “immediately

corrected” hazards from the recording requirement “would

provide an incentive to immediately correct” them. Id. But

MSHA did not respond to this point, let alone compare the

safety benefits of that proposal to those of the rule adopted. See

id. Nor did MSHA need to make such a comparison—between

7

the 2017 rule and its eventual 2018 successor—in order to

conclude that the 2017 rule was safer than its 1979 predecessor.

As for the two safety benefits noted by MSHA in 2018, my

colleagues question whether the 2018 rule will incentivize

mine operators to correct adverse conditions promptly, because

other regulations already require them to do so. Ante at 10. But

there is nothing unreasonable about providing increased

incentives for compliance, by reducing the recording

obligations of operators who do comply.

Finally, my colleagues conclude that “the risk of

inundating miners with information” does not “appear in the

administrative record.” Ante at 11 n.3 (quotation marks

omitted). I read the record differently. As MSHA recounted,

some commenters warned that “requiring all adverse

conditions [to] be recorded in the examination record would

overwhelm the record with minor housekeeping issues.” Mine

Examinations II, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,059. MSHA “agree[d]

with these commenters and conclude[d] that requiring mine

operators to record only those adverse conditions that are not

corrected promptly is as protective as the January 2017 rule.”

Id. Moreover, the commenters’ concern was a safety one.

They explained that a cluttered record risked “‘alarm fatigue,’

whereby too many warnings become background noise and no

one really hears them.” J.A. 911; see also J.A. 769. MSHA

reasonably credited that concern here—just as, in National

Mining, it reasonably credited the concern that an examination

record filled with corrected hazards might “distract [mine

operators] from the primary focus” of identifying ongoing

safety risks. 116 F.3d at 539.

My colleagues note that MSHA adopted the relevant

comments “in a paragraph regarding mine operator burdens.”

Ante at 11 n.3. But the surrounding discussion does not change

8

the fact that MSHA agreed with commenters who expressed

concern that cluttering the examination record would harm

miner safety. Moreover, MSHA adopted these comments to

make a clear safety determination: “requiring mine operators

to record only those adverse conditions that are not corrected

promptly is as protective as the January 2017 rule.” Mine

Examinations II, 83 Fed. Reg. at 15,059. Under these

circumstances, “the agency’s path may reasonably be

discerned,” so we must “uphold the decision even if it is of less

than ideal clarity.” Press Commc’ns LLC v. FCC, 875 F.3d

1117, 1122 (D.C. Cir. 2017) (quotation marks omitted).

In sum, I believe that MSHA adequately explained why

the 2018 amendment to the recording regulation is consistent

with the no-less-protection rule. Because my colleagues

conclude otherwise, I respectfully dissent from Part II.B of the

Court’s opinion.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.