Opinion

Pool v. . Trexler

  • 76 N.C. 297
Court
Supreme Court of North Carolina
Filed
Jan 5, 1877
Status
Published
Author
Pearson
On the bench
Pearson
Cited by
8 cases
Authority
More cited than 82.7%

The opinion

Pearson, C. J.

Every citizen holds his land subservient' to such “police regulations” as the General Assembly may in its wisdom enact in order to promote the general welfare.

Brown

v.

Keener,

74 N. C. 714 .

I take this proposition to be settled and will not attempt to make “a rehash” of the cases set out by Cooley, ch. 16,. “Constitutional Limitations.”

If the General Assembly has power to make regulations for draining a swamp containing 10,000 acres it has the same

*298

power in regard to a swamp containing 1,000 acres. So of 100 acres, so of 1 acre.

There is no distinction in the principle; the only differ•ence is in regard to the degree.

We declare our opinion to be that the police power of the General Assembly authorized it to pass the Act under which this action is brought, to-wit; the Act entitled “Draining wet lands.” Bat. Rev. ch. 39.

It is said the General Assembly has no power to take one acre of the land of A and give it to B, on the ground that B is the better farmer of the two and will make the one acre produce more. That proposition is granted except when “the power of eminent domain” is exerted for public purposes ; as when land is taken for a railroad. These two powers “eminent domain” and “police regulations” are distinct .and yet they are frequently confounded. By the one, the property of A is given to B. By the other, the property of A is left in him, but is made subservient to the general welfare. “Cart ways,” Bat. Rev. ch. 104, § 38, furnishes an .analogy. Under the power to make “police regulations” the land of A is made subservient to the land of B for the purposes of a road. After some contestation the question of the power of the General Assembly was yielded. So in our ■case the power of the General Assembly to make the land of A ■•subservient to the land of B for the purpose of drainage must also be yielded upon the authorities and upon the reason of the Bring.

Error.

Per Curiam. Judgment reversed, and

procedendo.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.