Opinion

Duffy v. . Phipps

  • 180 N.C. 313
  • 104 S.E. 655
  • 1920 N.C. LEXIS 86
Court
Supreme Court of North Carolina
Filed
Nov 10, 1920
Status
Published
Author
Glare
On the bench
Glare
Cited by
3 cases
Authority
More cited than 68.2%

The opinion

Glare, O. J.

Tbe defendant’s contract to sell tbe plaintiff “about 204 acres of land, known as tbe Buffalo farm, and adjoining tbe lands of Cicero Moore, C. D. Benbow, Thomas Pemberton, and others, at $100 per acre” was a sale by tbe acre, and tbe plaintiff is entitled to a rebate, or a return, of tbe amount overpaid.

Henofer v. Realty Co.,

178 N. C., 584 .

Tbe defendant contends tbat tbe contract was merged in tbe deed, and therefore tbe complaint does not state a cause of action. Tbe deed representing tbat tbe acreage was 197 acres was tbe act of tbe defendant in

assumed

execution of tbe contract and tbe acceptance of it by the plaintiff does not estop him from showing a shortage in tbe acreage and from a recovery of tbe amount overpaid.

McGee v. Craven,

106 N. C., 353 ;

Brown v. Hobbs,

147 N. C., 77 ;

Kendricks v. Ins. Co.,

124 N. C., 318 .

Tbe deed was made in pursuance of tbe contract, and tbe estimate in tbe contract, “about 204 acres,” and tbe estimate in tbe deed, “197 acres,” and tbe estimate in tbe contract of $20,000 are all subsidiary to tbe contract of sale “at $100 per acre.” "Whenever tbe true acreage was ascertained, whether it was more than tbe above estimates or less, tbe amount of tbe purchase monby was to be ascertained by multiplying such acreage by $100. This is tbe basis' of tbe contract. If it bad turned out tbat tbe true acreage was more than this estimate, tbe plaintiff would have bad to pay tbe increased amount. It proving to be less, tbe defendant must refund tbe overpayment.

Affirmed.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.