Opinion

Maryland Attorney General Opinion 108OAG121

Court
Maryland Attorney General Reports
Filed
Dec 21, 2023
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Gen. 121] 121

HEALTH

BOARD OF MORTICIANS – HEALTH OCCUPATIONS –

CREMATION – WHETHER THE BOARD OF MORTICIANS AND

OFFICE OF CEMETERY OVERSIGHT HAVE AUTHORITY

UNDER EXISTING LAW TO LICENSE ALKALINE

HYDROLYSIS AS A TYPE OF CREMATION TO DISPOSE OF

HUMAN REMAINS

December 21, 2023

The Honorable Anne R. Kaiser

The Maryland House of Delegates

State law requires two funerary agencies—the Board of

Morticians and Funeral Directors (“Board of Morticians”) and the

Office of Cemetery Oversight (“Cemetery Office”)—to regulate

and license facilities in which human bodies are disposed of by

cremation. You have asked whether the existing statutory authority

of these agencies over cremation services also grants them the

authority to regulate and license the use of an alternative

technology called alkaline hydrolysis to dispose of human bodies.

For the reasons that follow, we conclude that the disposal of

a human body by alkaline hydrolysis is generally illegal in

Maryland and that the funerary agencies therefore do not have

authority to regulate, license, or otherwise permit the use of this

technology. The Health-General Article prohibits the disposal of

human bodies except by certain enumerated methods. Alkaline

hydrolysis is not one of the enumerated methods. And while the

funerary agencies have a statutory responsibility to regulate

“cremation,” their governing statutes define “cremation” in a way

that excludes alkaline hydrolysis.1

1

We received two sets of comments on this opinion request, both in

support of the legality of alkaline hydrolysis under current State law.

Letter from Chris Palmer, Vice President, Funeral Consumers Alliance

of Maryland and Environs, et al., to Patrick B. Hughes, Chief Counsel

for Opinions & Advice (Dec. 1, 2023) (“FCAME Comments”); Letter

from Adrian R. Gardner, Co-Founder, Green Legacy Brands LLC, to

Patrick B. Hughes, Chief Counsel for Opinions & Advice (Dec. 1, 2023)

(“Green Legacy Comments”). We thank the commenters for their views,

which we have considered carefully.

122 [108 Op. Att’y

I

Background

Alkaline hydrolysis, sometimes called “liquid cremation” or

“aquamation,” reduces a dead body to bone fragments by

dissolving it in a solution of water and alkaline chemicals. See

Cremation Ass’n of N. Am., Alkaline Hydrolysis,

https://www.cremationassociation.org/page/alkalinehydrolysis (last

visited Dec. 19, 2023) (“CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page”); Philip

R. Olson, Flush and Bone: Funeralizing Alkaline Hydrolysis in the

United States, 39 Sci., Tech., & Human Values 666, 667-68 (2014).

The body is placed into an airtight chamber with this liquid

solution. To speed up the process by which the chemicals dissolve

the body, pressure and heat—in the range of 200 to 300 degrees

Fahrenheit—are typically applied to the contents of the chamber.

CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page; H. Leon Thacker, Alkaline

Hydrolysis 1, in Nat’l Agric. Biosecurity Ctr. Consortium, Carcass

Disposal: A Comprehensive Review (2004).

The process takes anywhere from three to sixteen hours,

depending on the amount of heat and pressure used. CANA

Alkaline Hydrolysis Page; Olson, supra, at 668, 686. The

dissolution process yields a substantial amount of liquid that is

commonly referred to in technical literature as a “sterile effluent”

and that is typically discharged into wastewater systems. Olson,

supra, at 667-68; Thacker, supra, at 1; CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis

Page. The bone fragments that remain after the process is complete

are pulverized with a device called a cremulator and returned to the

next of kin in an urn. Kent Hansen, Choosing to Be Flushed Away,

5 Est. Plan. & Community Prop. L.J. 145, 150 (2012); CANA

Alkaline Hydrolysis Page. Alkaline hydrolysis is often described

as an “environmentally friendly” method of disposing of human

remains. CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page. It does not emit

pollutants into the air, and it uses less energy and produces less

carbon than burial or traditional cremation. Id.; cf. Olson, supra,

at 678-79 (analyzing the environmental and public health impacts

of alkaline hydrolysis).

By contrast, in the traditional cremation process—sometimes

called “flame-based” cremation—the body is incinerated.

Cremation Ass’n of N. Am., Cremation Process,

https://www.cremationassociation.org/page/CremationProcess (last

visited Dec. 19, 2023) (“CANA Cremation Process Page”)

(“Flame-based cremation uses flame and heat to reduce the human

remains to bone fragments, or cremated remains.”). This

traditional process uses temperatures of between 1400 to 1800

Gen. 121] 123

degrees Fahrenheit. Id. (putting the temperature at “between 1400

and 1600 degrees”); Natalie Banta Lynner, Death in a Pandemic,

70 UCLA L. Rev. 154, 185 (2023) (putting it at 1800 degrees).

Unlike alkaline hydrolysis, traditional cremation produces air

emissions because it converts the body’s fat and tissues into gases

rather than liquids. CANA Cremation Process Page (“The process

of [flame-based] cremation is essentially the conversion of a solid

to a gas.”); Lynner, supra, at 185.2 As with alkaline hydrolysis,

traditional cremation results in bone fragments that are pulverized

and then placed in an urn. CANA Cremation Process Page.

Traditional cremation for human remains has long been in

widespread commercial use and has grown in popularity in recent

decades. See Revised Fiscal & Policy Note, H.B. 995, 2010 Leg.,

Reg. Sess. at 4. Alkaline hydrolysis, on the other hand, is still an

emerging technology in the funeral industry. As far as we know,

no facility of any type in Maryland currently uses it for human

remains. In the United States, the process was first used by the

funeral industry only in 2011—in Ohio and Florida—although it

had previously been used on farms (for animal remains) and at

some universities and hospitals (for human bodies donated to

science). CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page. Today, nationwide,

the process is offered by about thirty funeral services providers in

fifteen states, according to the Cremation Association of North

America (“Cremation Association”). Id.

The General Assembly, so far as we are aware, has never

considered legislation to explicitly address the legal status of

alkaline hydrolysis in Maryland. The Legislature has, in recent

years, considered bills about other emerging methods for breaking

down a human body. One unenacted bill would have legalized

“natural organic reduction,” a method that involves the “controlled,

accelerated conversion of human remains to soil.” See H.B. 1060,

2023 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Senate First Reader). Another unenacted

bill would have explicitly authorized State agencies to license and

2

Because of these air emissions, traditional crematories require not

only the approval of one of the funerary agencies (the Board of

Morticians or the Cemetery Office), but also that of the Maryland

Department of the Environment. See Kor-Ko Ltd. v. Maryland Dep’t of

Envir., 451 Md. 401, 413 (2017). Although alkaline hydrolysis does not

produce air emissions, the wastewater discharges it causes would

similarly require the approval of federal, State, or local environmental

regulators (depending on the type of discharge) if the technology were

otherwise legal. See generally Maryland Dep’t of Envir., Wastewater

Permits Program, https://mde.maryland.gov/programs/water/wwp/pages/

index.aspx (last visited Dec. 19, 2023).

124 [108 Op. Att’y

regulate “cold cremation,” which is the “process of reducing

human remains to fragments through deep freezing.” See H.B. 872,

2012 Leg., Reg. Sess. (First Reader). But the only legislative

proposal we have found that mentions alkaline hydrolysis is an

unenacted bill from the 2023 session that would have required a

group of State agencies to study certain funeral practices, including

alkaline hydrolysis and natural organic reduction. H.B. 869, 2023

Leg., Reg. Sess. (Senate Third Reader).

II

Analysis

Your question implicates various State statutes governing the

disposition of human bodies. In interpreting these statutes, we seek

to determine the intent of the General Assembly by examining the

plain meaning of the statutory text in proper context, along with

relevant legislative history and other indicators of legislative intent.

See, e.g., 108 Opinions of the Attorney General 108, 111 (2023);

108 Opinions of the Attorney General 81, 92 (2023). For several

reasons, our statutory analysis leads us to conclude that, under

current law, alkaline hydrolysis is generally illegal in Maryland and

that the Board of Morticians and the Cemetery Office therefore do

not have authority to license it.3

To begin, a section of the Health-General Article prohibits the

disposal of a human body except through certain specified means,

and those means do not include alkaline hydrolysis. Md. Code

Ann., Health-Gen. (“HG”) § 5-514. That section provides as

follows:

(a) An individual may not bury or dispose

of a body except:

(1) In a family burial plot or other area

allowed by a local ordinance;

(2) In a crematory;

(3) In a cemetery;

(4) By donating the body to medical

science; or

3

In a March 2023 advice letter to you, the unit of our Office that

represents the General Assembly reached the opposite conclusion.

Having had occasion to thoroughly reconsider the issue in response to

your request for an official opinion, we disagree with the conclusion in

that letter and decline to follow it here.

Gen. 121] 125

(5) By removing the body to another state

for final disposition in accordance with the

laws of the other state.

(b) An individual who violates this section

is guilty of a misdemeanor and on conviction

is subject to imprisonment not exceeding 1

year or a fine not exceeding $5,000 or both.

Id.

Although disposal “in a crematory” is listed as one of the

permissible means of disposal, the term is defined under the statute

in a way that excludes alkaline hydrolysis. More specifically, a

“crematory” is defined as “a building in which cremations are

performed,” HG § 5-508(d), and cremation, in turn, is defined as

“the disposition of a dead human body by means of incineration,”

id. § 5-508(c) (emphasis added). In summary, then, § 5-514 makes

it a misdemeanor for any individual to dispose of a human body

except in one of five enumerated ways that include cremation by

incineration but not alkaline hydrolysis, which does not use

incineration. See Incinerate, Merriam-Webster Dictionary,

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/incinerate (last

visited Dec. 19, 2023) (“to cause to burn to ashes”). Alkaline

hydrolysis is therefore illegal under § 5-514.4

One might argue that this provision governs only the location

of a body’s disposition, not the process used to dispose of the body.

Under this argument, alkaline hydrolysis would be legal so long as

it occurs inside a building in which cremations by incineration also

occur (or, by the same reasoning, on the grounds of a cemetery or

family burial plot). See HG § 5-514(a).

4

We note that § 5-514 does not purport to govern the disposition of a

body beyond the point that it is donated to medical science. Because

your question concerns the regulatory authority of the Board of

Morticians and the Cemetery Office, and because these agencies

generally do not regulate institutions of medical science, we have no

occasion here to consider whether such institutions may dispose of

bodies with alkaline hydrolysis in Maryland. See Md. Code Ann., Health

Occ. § 7-101 (t), (u) (defining the practice of funeral direction and

mortuary science to include the act of making final disposition of a

human body, but only for compensation), § 7-102(b)(2)(iii) (exempting

any crematory at “a licensed medical facility or educational institution”

from the jurisdiction of the Board of Morticians); Md. Code Ann., Bus.

Reg. § 5-102(b)(3) (same exemption for the jurisdiction of the Cemetery

Office).

126 [108 Op. Att’y

That interpretation, however, would not be consistent with the

broader statutory scheme. The Health-General Article treats

cremation as a way to accomplish the “disposition of a dead human

body.” HG § 5-508(c); id. § 5-508(b) (referring to cremation as a

method of “final disposition”). Given this language, we think it

clear that when § 5-514 makes it a crime to “bury or dispose of a

body” by unenumerated means, it refers to the processes by which

a body may be broken down as well as the locations where a body

may be left. See Lockett v. Blue Ocean Bristol, LLC, 446 Md. 397,

422 (2016) (“When a word susceptible of more than one meaning

is repeated in the same statute or sections of a statute, it is presumed

that it is used in the same sense.” (quoting Whack v. State, 338 Md.

665, 673 (1995) (alteration omitted))). Means of disposal that are

not enumerated in § 5-514 would thus require legislation to become

legal. Cf. H.B. 1060, 2023 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Senate First Reader)

(unenacted legislation that, in order to legalize natural organic

reduction, would have added it to the definition of cremation that

applies to HG § 5-514).

More generally, reading § 5-514 to govern only the location

of a body’s disposition would produce unusual consequences.

First, this reading would tether the use of emerging funerary

practices to the use of traditional practices in a way that the General

Assembly probably did not intend. Specifically, the statute would

prohibit funeral services providers from using emerging or

experimental methods to dispose of bodies unless they employed

such methods in a building where they also happen to incinerate

bodies or on the site of cemetery. Put differently, a provider

wishing to offer alkaline hydrolysis would have to offer a

traditional method of disposition in the same location. Second,

pursuant to this reading, wrongdoers could dump bodies illicitly (a

practice that, as discussed next, the General Assembly clearly

sought to outlaw) without running afoul of the statute, so long as

they did so at cemeteries or crematories. We find these

consequences of the location-based reading illogical. See Smith v.

State, 425 Md. 292, 299 (2012) (“In every case, a statute must be

given ‘a reasonable interpretation, not one that is absurd, illogical,

or incompatible with common sense.’” (quoting Robinson v.

Baltimore Police Dep’t, 424 Md. 41, 51 (2011)). We think instead

that § 5-514 makes cremation by incineration a legal method of

disposition but does not extend that treatment to alkaline hydrolysis

or other emerging processes by which a body may be broken down.

The legislative history of this provision does not alter our

view of its plain meaning. The General Assembly enacted it only

recently, in 2015, apparently in response to an incident in which a

Gen. 121] 127

body was dumped on the side of the road in Washington County.

2015 Md. Laws, ch. 419; Hearing on H.B. 431 Before the House

Health & Gov’t Operations Comm., 2015 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Feb.

24, 2015) (written testimony of victim’s family). That incident laid

bare to the General Assembly that Maryland law did not contain

any general prohibition of the improper disposal of a body. See

Revised Fiscal & Policy Note, H.B. 431, 2015 Leg., Reg. Sess. at

1-2. It is true that the acute concern that appears to have motivated

the legislation—the need to outlaw body dumping—is not directly

related to alternative methods of cremation. Nonetheless, the law

that the General Assembly enacted does not narrowly outlaw body

dumping. Instead, by its plain language, it writes a broader

limitation into State law: It states that there are only five legal ways

to “bury or dispose of” a body in Maryland. HG § 5-514(a). In

light of that plain language—which reaches beyond the acute

legislative concern with body dumping but is by no means

inconsistent with it—unenumerated methods of disposition,

including alkaline hydrolysis, are prohibited. See State v. Bey, 452

Md. 255, 265 (2017) (in interpreting a statute, courts consider the

statutory text in the context of “the purpose, aim, or policy of the

Legislature” but generally do not “add [or] delete language so as to

reflect an intent not evidenced in the plain and unambiguous

language of the statute” (quoting State v. Johnson, 415 Md. 413,

421-22 (2010))).

It is also true that the definition of “cremation” that applies to

HG § 5-514 and equates the term with incineration was originally

enacted in legislation with a different primary purpose.

Specifically, the General Assembly enacted the definition in 1994

in an act that created procedures for private cremation decisions.

1994 Md. Laws, ch. 517. Among other things, the legislation

established a priority order of family members and other

individuals with authority to choose cremation for the deceased.

Id. As such, when the General Assembly crafted the “incineration”

definition, it did so as part of an effort to resolve “differences and

disputes” over cremation decisions—not in an effort to prohibit

other forms of disposition. See id. (Preamble).

Nonetheless, the 1994 legislation made the definition

applicable to an entire subtitle: Subtitle 5 of Title 5 of the Health

General Article. Id. That subtitle already included other types of

requirements about cremation. See, e.g., id. (making conforming

amendments to HG § 5-502, which already prohibited the

cremation of an unidentified body); HG § 5-503 (added in 1982

and providing that a “person may not cremate a body until at least

12 hours after death”); id. § 5-504 (added in 1982 and providing

128 [108 Op. Att’y

that a “person may not transport a body to a crematory without

using a cot and pouch or receptacle”). Subsequently, the General

Assembly enacted still other types of rules about cremation into the

same subtitle without amending the “incineration” definition. See

2012 Md. Laws, ch. 500 (imposing storage and transportation

requirements on crematories and funeral establishments). As a

result, the definition applies generally to a range of rules about

cremation and crematories—not only to the rules enacted in 1994

about decision-making. Most importantly for our purposes, when

the Legislature enacted the prohibition on unenumerated methods

of disposition in 2015 and added it to Subtitle 5 as § 5-514, it used

a defined term (“crematory”) and did not amend the definition (that

a crematory is a place where cremations by “means of incineration”

are performed). 2015 Md. Laws, ch. 419; HG § 5-508(c)-(d). We

must presume that the General Assembly understood and intended

that this definition would apply to § 5-514 and would exempt only

cremation by incineration from the statute’s prohibition. See State

v. Neiswanger Mgmt. Servs., LLC, 457 Md. 441, 476 (2018) (“We

presume the Legislature was aware of its own laws.”).

We recognize that, outside of the Health-General Article,

Maryland law also contains a different—and arguably broader—

definition of “cremation.” That definition appears in the provisions

of the Health Occupations Article and the Business Regulation

Article that require the Board of Morticians and the Cemetery

Office to regulate crematories. Md. Code Ann., Health Occ.

(“HO”) §§ 7-101(h), 7-205(c); Md. Code Ann., Bus. Reg. (“BR”)

§§ 5-101(e), 5-204(a)(2).5 These occupational statutes state that

cremation “means the process of reducing human remains to bone

fragments through intense heat and evaporation, including any

mechanical or thermal process.” HO § 7-101(h); BR § 5-101(e).

It is admittedly odd that the occupational statutes and the

Health-General Article define cremation differently, especially

given that the definitions have overlapping implications in that they

both apply to statutes that govern the safe and fair operation of

crematories. Compare HO § 7-205(c) (requiring the Board of

Morticians to create “a process for regulating crematories” and to

ensure that crematories are operated in conformity with “public

health and safety”) and BR § 5-204(a)(2) (same requirements for

the Cemetery Office), with HG § 5-503 (12-hour time restriction

5

Each agency regulates those crematories in which its licensees—

morticians and funeral directors in the case of the Board, cemeterians in

the case of the Cemetery Office—hold primary ownership, while the

Cemetery Office also regulates independent crematories. BR § 5-

102(b)(2); HO § 7-102(b)(2)(ii).

Gen. 121] 129

for cremation), and HG § 5-505 (“[A] person may not require that

a cremation be performed with a casket.”). The General Assembly

enacted the definition in the occupational statutes in 2010, sixteen

years after it enacted the Health-General definition. 2010 Md.

Laws, ch. 450; 1994 Md. Laws, ch. 517. It seems likely that the

General Assembly based the 2010 definition on a model provision

that the International Cemetery, Cremation & Funeral Association

(“ICCFA”), a trade group, published in 1998. See ICCFA, Glossary

of Terms, https://iccfa.com/blog/glossary-of-terms/ (last visited

Dec. 19, 2023) (“ICCFA Glossary”).6 Though not an exact match,

this model definition contains two of the same key phrases—

“reducing human remains to bone fragments through intense heat

and evaporation” and “mechanical and thermal process”—as the

definition that the General Assembly enacted in 2010. Compare

id., with HO § 7-101(h), and BR § 5-101(e).7 Thus, as far as we

can tell, the General Assembly appears to have deviated from the

Health-General definition in 2010 in order to follow a model

definition that did not exist when the Health-General definition was

enacted. We are not absolutely certain of this explanation,

however, because the legislative history of the 2010 law does not

mention the source of the definition it enacted nor otherwise

address why the General Assembly chose to deviate from the

Health-General definition without amending it.

In any event, this peculiarity does not affect the answer to your

question. Although the definition in the occupational statutes does

not explicitly equate cremation with “incineration,” it still excludes

alkaline hydrolysis. Under the newer definition, cremation must

employ both “intense heat and evaporation” to “reduc[e] human

remains to bone fragments.” HO § 7-101(h); BR § 5-101(e). Unlike

traditional flame-based cremation, alkaline hydrolysis does not

employ evaporation for this purpose. It does not, in other words,

convert anything in the body to gas or vapor when reducing it to bone

fragments. See Evaporation, Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary, https://

6

In full, the ICCFA definition of cremation reads as follows: “The

irreversible process of reducing human remains to bone fragments

through intense heat and evaporation, in a specifically designed furnace

or retort, which may include any other mechanical or thermal process

whereby the bone fragments are pulverized, or otherwise further reduced

in size or quantity. Cremation is a process and is not a method of final

disposition.” Id. The Glossary in which this definition appears forms

part of the ICCFA’s “model guidelines for state laws and regulations.”

ICCFA, Model Guidelines, https://iccfa.com/model-guidelines/; see

Hansen, supra, at 168.

7

The laws of at least two other states follow the ICCFA definition

closely. See N.M. Stat. Ann. § 58-17-3H; Ala. Code § 27-17A-2(20).

130 [108 Op. Att’y

www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/evaporation (last visited Dec.

19, 2023) (“change from a liquid to a vapor”); CANA Cremation

Process Page (explaining that in flame-based cremation, “[t]issue,

organs, body fat, and casket or other container materials burn off

as gases”). Instead, alkaline hydrolysis does the opposite; it

converts most of the body into a liquid, producing a “sterile

effluent” that must be handled as wastewater and leaving a remnant

of bones as the only remaining solid material. Olson, supra, at 667.

The technology produces no air emissions. Thacker, supra, at 1.

To be sure, we claim no scientific expertise, and we would

typically hesitate to base a statutory interpretation on a point of

science. In this instance, however, we think it clear that alkaline

hydrolysis does not, in fact, employ evaporation to break down the

body to bone fragments. The technology works by dissolving

human remains into a liquid, not by converting remains into gas or

vapor. CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page (“Just like flame

cremation, [in alkaline hydrolysis] fat and tissues are converted to

basic organic compounds. In flame cremation these harmless

compounds, mainly carbon dioxide and water vapor, are released

into the air. In alkaline hydrolysis, the harmless compounds

formed include salts and amino acids, and are released with the

water.”). Indeed, the only argument we have encountered about

the use of evaporation in alkaline hydrolysis concerns the treatment

of the remaining bone fragments after the body has been dissolved,

not the dissolution process itself. The argument is that, after the

alkaline hydrolysis process has reduced the body to bone

fragments, the fragments are typically dried before being

pulverized. This drying of the fragments, it is contended, involves

evaporation. FCAME Comments at 4; Green Legacy Comments

at 5. We assume this contention is correct. Even so, the incidental

use of evaporation at this stage to remove the “sterile effluent” from

the bone fragments does not bring alkaline hydrolysis within the

definition of the occupational statutes because, by this point, the

body has already been reduced to bone fragments. See HO § 7-

101(h); BR § 5-101(e). In other words, any evaporation that occurs

in the drying of the bone fragments after the rest of the body has

been dissolved into liquid does not form part of the process by

which alkaline hydrolysis “reduc[es] human remains to bone

fragments.” HO § 7-101(h); BR § 5-101(e). That is important

because the statutory definition specifically requires that

evaporation be used to “reduc[e] [the] remains to bone fragments,”

not just at any point in the process. Id.

We also have questions about whether alkaline hydrolysis

may be said to employ “intense heat” within the meaning of this

Gen. 121] 131

definition. As explained above, the procedure for traditional

cremation reaches temperatures of between 1400 and 1800 degrees

Fahrenheit, whereas alkaline hydrolysis generally reaches

temperatures of only 200 to 300 degrees Fahrenheit. See Part I,

supra. We are not sure that a specialized mechanical process that

employs only the level of heat of a standard household appliance

can be described as using “intense heat,” especially given that the

phrase manifestly covers the much higher temperatures of

traditional cremation. See, e.g., Rowe v. Maryland Comm’n on

Civil Rights, 483 Md. 329, 342 (2023) (statutory terms must be read

in context). Ultimately, however, we need not reach a firm

conclusion on that point. Because alkaline hydrolysis does not

employ evaporation to reduce the body to bone fragments, it does

not meet the definition of “cremation” in the occupational statutes

for that reason alone. See HO § 7-101(h); BR § 5-101(e).

Granted, the definition in the occupational statutes also

contains the broad phrase “including any mechanical or thermal

process.” HO § 7-101(h); BR § 5-101(e). This phrase, appended

to the end of the definition, apparently has led some commentators

to assume that alkaline hydrolysis is legal in Maryland. See, e.g.,

CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page (categorizing Maryland as a state

that has legalized the technology but lacks practitioners); Olson,

supra, at 667 (same); Kantele Franko, States Consider: Is It Legal

to Dissolve Bodies?, NBC News (June 2, 2011),

https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna43257762 (stating that the 2010

legislation would allow alkaline hydrolysis). After all, alkaline

hydrolysis is a “mechanical process” in the sense that it uses a

machine, see Mechanical, Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary,

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mechanical (last

visited Dec. 19, 2023) (“of or relating to machinery . . . or tools”),

and potentially a “thermal” process as well, in the sense that it uses

some heat, see Thermal, Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary,

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/thermal (last visited

Dec. 19, 2023) (“of, relating to, or caused by heat”). In addition,

as already explained, the General Assembly chose to incorporate a

definition with this broad phrase into the occupational statutes

instead of using the pre-existing “incineration” definition from the

Health-General Article. See 2010 Md. Laws, ch. 450. This

somewhat mysterious choice may have caused confusion about the

legal status of alkaline hydrolysis in Maryland by creating the

impression that the General Assembly intended the broad

“including” phrase in the new definition to encompass some

alternative practices.

132 [108 Op. Att’y

Yet we think it clear, as a matter of statutory interpretation,

that this broad “including” phrase cannot be read to bring alkaline

hydrolysis or any other process that does not employ evaporation

to reduce the body to bone fragments within the sweep of the

definition. Put simply, the “including” clause should not be

interpreted to negate the definition’s evaporation requirement. See

State v. Krikstan, 483 Md. 43, 98 (2023) (“We avoid statutory

interpretations that render language meaningless, surplusage,

superfluous or nugatory.” (internal quotation marks omitted)).

State legislative resources expand upon this point. The definition

in the occupational statutes is what is known as a composite

definition because it contains a “means” clause followed by an

“includes” or “including” clause. Department of Legislative

Services, Maryland Style Manual for Statutory Law 35 (2018)

(“DLS Manual”);8 see also Md. Code Ann., Gen. Provis. (“GP”)

§ 1-110 (treating “includes” and “including” as synonymous

terms). Under the General Assembly’s practices, the “includes”

clause in this type of definition does not expand or overwrite the

“means” clause but instead merely illustrates its meaning. DLS

Manual at 35; see also GP § 1-110 (“‘Includes’ or ‘including’

means includes or including by way of illustration and not by way

of limitation.” (emphasis added)).

As such, rather than read the phrase “including any

mechanical or thermal process” to mean that a process may satisfy

the definition even if it does not use “intense heat and evaporation,”

we must read it to mean that any “mechanical or thermal process”

used as part of cremation is included within the scope of the

definition so long as the overall process uses intense heat and

evaporation to reduce the body to bone fragments. This means, for

example, that the use of a cremulator to pulverize bone fragments

remaining after the traditional, flame-based incineration of a body

fits within the definition, because the overall process employs

“intense heat and evaporation” to break down the body. HO § 7-

101(h); BR § 5-101(e); see also ICCFA Glossary (clarifying that

cremation “may include any other mechanical or thermal process

whereby the bone fragments are pulverized” (emphasis added)).9

8

The DLS Manual is a useful resource for understanding the General

Assembly’s drafting practices. See, e.g., Elsberry v. Stanley Martin

Cos., 482 Md. 159, 184 (2022) (relying on the manual in interpreting a

statute). The Manual is available at https://dls.maryland.gov/pubs/prod/

LegisBillDrafting/MarylandStyleManualforStatutoryLaw2018.pdf.

9

The General Assembly’s objective in including the phrase “any

mechanical or thermal process” in this definition, and the ICCFA trade

Gen. 121] 133

But alkaline hydrolysis does not fit within the definition because it

does not employ evaporation (and likely cannot be considered to

employ intense heat) for this purpose.

The legislative history of the definition in the occupational

statutes supports our reading of its plain language. The 1998

ICCFA model law on which this definition appears to be based was

written thirteen years before alkaline hydrolysis went into use by

the funeral industry anywhere in the country, see CANA Alkaline

Hydrolysis Page, and for that historical reason presumably was not

crafted to sweep in alkaline hydrolysis, see Hansen, supra, at 168

(citing the ICCFA definition as an example of a definition that

excludes alkaline hydrolysis). And while we may not know with

absolute certainty that the General Assembly based its own

“intense heat and evaporation” definition on the ICCFA definition,

we do know something else—the definition that the General

Assembly ultimately enacted in 2010 appeared in nearly identical

form in legislative proposals stretching back to 2001. E.g., H.B.

906, 2001 Leg., Reg. Sess. (First Reader); S.B. 143, 2002 Leg.,

Reg. Sess. (First Reader); S.B. 484, 2003 Leg., Reg. Sess. (First

Reader). So, as with the ICCFA definition, it appears that the

General Assembly did not craft the definition for the specific

purpose of encompassing alkaline hydrolysis. In 2001, alkaline

hydrolysis for human remains was not in use by the funeral industry

anywhere in the country and would not be for another ten years.

CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page.

By contrast, we find it instructive to consider a definition of

cremation that clearly does cover alkaline hydrolysis. In 2010,

another trade group—the Cremation Association—updated the

definition of cremation in its own model law for the specific

purpose of bringing “processes like alkaline hydrolysis” within its

scope. CANA Alkaline Hydrolysis Page; see FCAME Comments

at 4 (discussing this update); Green Legacy Comments at 6 (same).

Before this update, the Association’s definition of cremation

resembled the definition in Maryland’s occupational statutes in an

important sense—it specified that cremation worked “through heat

group’s objective in including a similar phrase in its model definition,

may have been to clarify that agency regulatory authority extends to the

pulverization of the bone fragments and is not limited to the incineration

process itself. See HO §§ 7-101(h), 7-205(c); BR §§ 5-101(e), 5-

204(a)(2) (requiring the Board of Morticians and the Cemetery Office to

regulate cremation). Because the definition in the Health-General

Article does not govern the scope of the funerary agencies’ regulatory

authority, it would make some sense that the phrase appears only in the

definition in the occupational statutes.

134 [108 Op. Att’y

and evaporation.” Cremation Ass’n of N. Am., Model Cremation

Law and Explanation 2 (2003) (“2003 CANA Model Law”).10

Tellingly, the Association dropped this phrase when crafting a

definition to encompass alkaline hydrolysis. It opted instead to

define cremation as follows: “The mechanical and/or thermal or

other dissolution process that reduces human remains to bone

fragments. Cremation includes the processing and usually includes

the pulverization of the bone fragments.” Cremation Ass’n of N.

Am., Model Cremation Law and Explanation 3 (2017). This broad

definition leaves no doubt that it covers alternatives to incineration,

not least because of its intentional omission of any reference to heat

and evaporation. See id.; Kan. Op. Att’y Gen. No. 2019-9, 2019

WL 6458254 at *2 (Nov. 26, 2019) (interpreting this definition,

which Kansas enacted, to cover processes that separate “flesh from

bone by the destruction of the flesh”). We think the history of this

model definition reinforces the point that a definition intended to

encompass alkaline hydrolysis would not logically require that

cremation employ “intense heat and evaporation.” HO § 7-101(h);

BR § 5-101(e).

10

This earlier version of the Cremation Association’s model

definition plainly focused on incineration. 2003 CANA Model Law, at

2 (“The technical process, using direct flame and heat, that reduces

human remains to bone fragments. The reduction takes place through

heat and evaporation. Cremation includes the processing and usually

includes the pulverization of the bone fragments.”) (emphasis added);

see also Cremation Ass’n of N. Am., Model Cremation Law and

Explanation (1999) (containing same definition of cremation as the 2003

version). The legislative history for the 2001 and 2002 Maryland bills

suggests that they sought to follow the provisions of the Cremation

Association’s model law from this era. Hearing on H.B. 906 Before the

House Economic Matters Comm., 2001 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Mar. 7, 2001)

(written testimony of the Cemetery Office) (“The Bill’s content is

reflective of the recommendations made by the Cremation Association .

. . in its proposed model state cremation regulation.”); Hearing on S.B.

143 Before the Senate Finance Comm., 2002 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Feb. 7,

2002) (written testimony of Del. Cadden) (“As recommended by [the

Cremation Association], enactment of this legislation would provide for

uniform statutory provisions that would render protection to the public .

. . .”). The definition of cremation that the bills contained, however, is

not a close match for the Cremation Association language from that era,

but instead mirrors parts of the ICCFA language. See supra notes 6 & 7

and accompanying text (quoting the ICCFA language and comparing it

to the occupational statutes). In any event, neither model that the General

Assembly may have followed—the pre-2010 Cremation Association

definition or the ICCFA definition—accommodated alkaline hydrolysis.

See Hansen, supra, at 168 (noting that the ICCFA definition excludes

alkaline hydrolysis); 2003 CANA Model Law, at 2 (requiring “direct

flame and heat”).

Gen. 121] 135

More broadly, the legislative history of the Maryland bills

containing the “intense heat and evaporation” definition, including

the successful 2010 legislation, also does not evince any legislative

interest in non-traditional forms of cremation. Instead, the

historical materials reveal a keen focus on traditional cremation,

which had not previously been subject to significant regulation or

oversight. See Revised Fiscal & Policy Note, H.B. 995, 2010 Leg.,

Reg. Sess. at 3-4 (noting that in Maryland, as of the bill’s

introduction, cremation was “growing in popularity” but

“minimally regulated”). To safeguard the public welfare, the

General Assembly made the regulation of traditional crematories

the explicit responsibility of the Board of Morticians and the

Cemetery Office. Id. at 1; see Hearing on S.B. 143 Before the

Senate Finance Comm., 2002 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Feb. 7, 2002)

(written testimony of CEO of Eternal Justice, a nonprofit)

(describing abuses committed by an unregulated crematory in

Georgia); Bill File on H.B. 906, 2001 Leg., Reg. Sess. (containing

a newspaper article describing similar abuses at a crematory in

California). Alkaline hydrolysis and other emerging techniques did

not appear to factor into the legislative intent one way or the other.

To be clear, the conclusion that alkaline hydrolysis is not a

form of cremation within the meaning of the occupational statutes

is not particularly meaningful on its own. It simply means that the

funerary agencies are not required to regulate the practice, see HO

§ 7-205(c) (mandating that the Board of Morticians regulate

crematories); BR § 5-204 (same for the Cemetery Office), but it

says nothing about whether they may regulate it as part of their

broader authority to enforce laws governing the disposition of

human bodies, see, e.g., HO § 7-301(a) (providing that “an

individual shall be licensed by the Board before the individual may

practice mortuary science in this State”), nor whether their

licensees may employ the technology under currently existing laws

and regulations. Instead, it is HG § 5-514 that answers the latter

two questions in the negative by prohibiting the use of alkaline

hydrolysis on human remains in Maryland.11

III

Conclusion

Alkaline hydrolysis is considered by many to be an

environmentally friendly alternative to traditional funeral

practices, and it is legal in some other states. We express no view

11

We do not decide here whether, in the absence of HG § 5-514, the

Board of Morticians or the Cemetery Office could choose to authorize

the practice.

136 [108 Op. Att’y

on whether the practice should be authorized as a matter of policy.

But, as Maryland law currently stands, we do not think that the

Board of Morticians and the Cemetery Office have the power to

authorize, license, or regulate this technology. The disposal of a

human body by alkaline hydrolysis is generally illegal under § 5-

514 of the Health-General Article and does not fall within the

agencies’ responsibility for regulating cremation under the Health

Occupations and Business Regulation Articles.

Anthony G. Brown

Attorney General of Maryland

Ben Harrington

Assistant Attorney General

Patrick B. Hughes

Chief Counsel, Opinions and Advice

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.