Letter concludes that a national bank's custody activities with respect to the described Custody Trust Ledger Deposit Account Program are permissible, and that the program's non-cash earnings credit feature is not inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices. The program provides for the deposit by broker-dealers of customer funds in accordance with SEC Rule 15c3-3 (special reserve bank account for the exclusive benefit of customers), in accounts maintained in the bank's trust department.
FederalAgency guidance
Ask Donna
How this section applies to your facts.
OCC Interpretive Letters › Letter concludes that a national bank's custody activities with respect to the described Custody Trust Ledger Deposit Account Program are permissible, and that the program's non-cash earnings credit feature is not inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices. The program provides for the deposit by broker-dealers of customer funds in accordance with SEC Rule 15c3-3 (special reserve bank account for the exclusive benefit of customers), in accounts maintained in the bank's trust department.
Text
O
Comptroller of the Currency
Administrator of National Banks
Washington, DC 20219
Interpretive Letter #1078
May 2007
April 19, 2007 12 USC 92a
12 USC 24(7)
Re: Custody Trust Ledger Deposit Account Program
Dear [ ]:
This letter is in response to [ ]’s (“Bank’s”) proposal to engage in a Custody Trust
Ledger Deposit Account Program (the “Program”) involving the deposit of cash from a broker-
dealer (“Broker-Dealer”) in the Bank’s Trust Department. As described by the Bank, the
Program provides for the deposit by broker-dealers of customer funds in accordance with
Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) Rule 15c3-3. Based on our review of the
information you have provided, including two legal opinions from outside bank counsel, we find
that the Bank’s participation in the described Program constitutes permissible custody activities
for a national bank and, as discussed below, is not inconsistent with safe and sound banking
practices.
Background and Description of the Program
The Bank is proposing a relationship between Broker-Dealer and the Bank’s Trust Department
involving the deposit of cash in the Trust Department under the requirements of SEC Rule 15c3-
3(e) (special reserve bank account for the exclusive benefit of customers).1 The Bank also
indicates the Program may be expanded to include other broker-dealers.
Under the proposed Program, a broker-dealer will place its funds in a Custody “Trust Ledger
Deposit Account” (“TLDA”) maintained in the Trust Department, and housed and recorded on
the Trust Department’s accounting system. The TLDA is separate from any other bank account
of the respective broker-dealer and, under the securities laws, is designed to be for the exclusive
1 17 C.F.R. § 240.15c3-3(e)
its funds in a Custody “Trust Ledger
Deposit Account” (“TLDA”) maintained in the Trust Department, and housed and recorded on
the Trust Department’s accounting system. The TLDA is separate from any other bank account
of the respective broker-dealer and, under the securities laws, is designed to be for the exclusive
1 17 C.F.R. § 240.15c3-3(e). SEC Rule 15c3-3 provides for the protection of customers’ funds and relates to the
broker-dealer’s net capital under SEC Rule 15c3-1. Rule 15c3-3 sections (e) and (f) require that the agreement
between the Bank and a broker-dealer contain certain terms specified in the regulation. You have represented that
the agreements between Broker-Dealer and the Bank will contain the required terms, however, we express no
opinion on whether the Program satisfies SEC Rule 15c3-3 requirements.
- -
2
benefit of the broker-dealer’s customers. The broker-dealer will make periodic deposits to and
withdrawals from the TLDA by wire transfer and, as required by Rule 15c3-3, withdrawals will
be available on demand by the broker-dealer. Bank counsel opines the TLDA is a deposit
obligation of the Trust Department and the TLDA represents a claim against the Trust
Department.2 The Trust Department will compensate the broker-dealer monthly in the form of a
payment of interest based upon the level of balances maintained by the broker-dealer in the Trust
Department’s TLDA at an agreed upon rate.
You have represented that the Trust Department plans to deposit the TLDA funds in a Money
Market Deposit Account (“MMDA”) in the Bank’s Commercial Department in the name of the
Trust Department, although it is under no contractual obligation to do so. The Trust Department
may receive a non-cash earnings credit3 as part of the Bank’s internal allocation
s TLDA at an agreed upon rate.
You have represented that the Trust Department plans to deposit the TLDA funds in a Money
Market Deposit Account (“MMDA”) in the Bank’s Commercial Department in the name of the
Trust Department, although it is under no contractual obligation to do so. The Trust Department
may receive a non-cash earnings credit3 as part of the Bank’s internal allocation. Bank counsel
represents that each MMDA will meet the requirements for MMDAs as set forth in the Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System’s Regulation D (12 C.F.R. § 204.2(d)(2)). The Bank
represents that it has conducted a thorough review of the proposal, including presenting the
proposed Program to its internal complex transactions committee for approval, and review by the
Bank’s asset and liabilities area.4
Discussion
The Program is structured to meet various regulatory requirements of the OCC, SEC, Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System (“Board”), and Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
(“FDIC”). The Bank provided opinions of outside bank counsel concluding that the described
Program is not subject to or meets various legal and regulatory requirements.5
Permissible Custody Activities
The Program contemplates that the Bank’s Trust Department will hold the broker-dealer’s cash
assets in a custodial capacity through the TLDAs, in accordance with SEC Rule 15c3-3
2 The Bank has submitted a draft contract titled “SEC Rule 15c3-3 – Reserve Bank Account Custody Agreement,”
which addresses the deposit of funds and establishment of custody accounts in the Bank’s Trust Department under
the Program. The Bank agrees to maintain such deposits as obligations of the Bank’s Trust Department as cash
deposits and not use the funds to engage in reverse repurchase agreements with any party
ed a draft contract titled “SEC Rule 15c3-3 – Reserve Bank Account Custody Agreement,”
which addresses the deposit of funds and establishment of custody accounts in the Bank’s Trust Department under
the Program. The Bank agrees to maintain such deposits as obligations of the Bank’s Trust Department as cash
deposits and not use the funds to engage in reverse repurchase agreements with any party. The contract recognizes
the ability of the Trust Department, on its own behalf, to make the funds available to other departments of the Bank
as permitted under applicable law.
3 You represent that this “earnings credit” would be an internal imputed earnings entry used by the Bank to track
relative financial performance and contributions from its different activities. It would not involve the movement of
any actual funds.
4 The Bank has adopted internal limits per customer for TLDA account balances, and an overall cap on the
Program’s total balances. The Bank has represented that arrangements with some similarities to the Program are in
effect at other institutions.
5 The scope of this letter is limited to application of national banking laws under the jurisdiction of the OCC, and is
not intended to express any opinion on applicable requirements of other regulatory agencies.
- -
3
requirements. We believe that it is within the scope of permissible custody activities for the
Bank’s Trust Department to hold and to pay interest upon these deposits.
National banks’ custody activities developed from providing safekeeping and settlement services
to customers for a fee, and historically are viewed as permissible incidental activities under
12 U.S.C
requirements. We believe that it is within the scope of permissible custody activities for the
Bank’s Trust Department to hold and to pay interest upon these deposits.
National banks’ custody activities developed from providing safekeeping and settlement services
to customers for a fee, and historically are viewed as permissible incidental activities under
12 U.S.C. § 24(Seventh), and often are in conjunction with the delivery of fiduciary services.6
A custody relationship is a contractual arrangement, and the services performed for customers
vary.7 Services traditionally provided include the settlement, safekeeping, and reporting of
customers’ marketable securities and cash. A custodian also may invest cash balances as
directed, collect income, process corporate actions, price securities positions, and provide
recordkeeping services.8 As custody services are contractual in nature, a bank must ensure
compliance with the provisions of all applicable agreements.9 The custody industry has grown
significantly in recent years, and now global custodians control trillions of dollars in assets in
offices around the world.10
Based on the Bank’s representations and submissions, the parties have agreed as a matter of
contract that Broker-Dealer’s deposits are to be held in custody in the Bank’s Trust Department.
Broker-Dealer authorizes the Bank as part of this custodial arrangement, if the Bank so
determines, to transfer the deposits to the commercial side of the Bank. Further, the draft
contract provides that the Bank will pay to the Broker-Dealer a return (“Interest”) on the
amounts held in the accounts based on a Fed Funds rate, and that the Bank will receive fees and
compensation pursuant to the agreement from time to time
Bank as part of this custodial arrangement, if the Bank so
determines, to transfer the deposits to the commercial side of the Bank. Further, the draft
contract provides that the Bank will pay to the Broker-Dealer a return (“Interest”) on the
amounts held in the accounts based on a Fed Funds rate, and that the Bank will receive fees and
compensation pursuant to the agreement from time to time. The custodial contract establishes
the legal duties, obligations, and responsibilities of the parties.11 We are not aware of any
banking laws or restrictions that preclude this type of contractual custodial arrangement
involving the holding and paying of interest on the deposited funds.
6 See Comptroller’s Handbook, Custody Services 1-2 (Jan. 2002); Comptroller’s Handbook, Asset Management 4
(Jan. 2000). The OCC has indicated it does not treat non-discretionary custodial activities as fiduciary, and that
those activities are authorized under 12 U.S.C. § 24(Seventh). See 61 Fed. Reg. 68543, 68545 (Dec. 30, 1996) (final
rule revisions to 12 C.F.R. part 9).
7 See Comptroller’s Handbook, Custody Services at 1-2.
8 See Comptroller’s Handbook, Custody Services at 1-2; American Banker’s Ass’n, Trust Operations 25-26 (2000)
(discussing custodial accounts and listing a custody agent’s administrative duties, which includes daily sweeps and
investment of idle cash). A custodian is not a trustee, and generally is not subject to the strict fiduciary standards
that govern the relationship between a trustee and beneficiary. See, e.g., Interpretive Letter No. 769 (Jan. 28, 1997)
(clarifying part 9 does not apply to client-directed investment activities where the fee does not depend on the
provision of investment advice); 61 Fed. Reg. at 68545.
9 See Comptroller’s Handbook, Custody Services at 4. Effective internal controls are essential to a bank’s
management of the risks found in custody services. Id. at 6.
10 See Comptroller’s Handbook, Custody Services at 14
ying part 9 does not apply to client-directed investment activities where the fee does not depend on the
provision of investment advice); 61 Fed. Reg. at 68545.
9 See Comptroller’s Handbook, Custody Services at 4. Effective internal controls are essential to a bank’s
management of the risks found in custody services. Id. at 6.
10 See Comptroller’s Handbook, Custody Services at 14.
11 The Bank’s legal counsel opines that the Bank’s holding of funds as proposed under the Program is consistent
with the role of a national bank as custodian, including the proposal’s fact specific details of deposit-taking and
interest-paying.
- -
4
For banking law purposes, the authority of national banks to engage in custody activities derives
from the general business of banking, and incidental powers language in 12 U.S.C.
§ 24(Seventh). The Supreme Court has recognized that this authority is a broad grant of power
to engage in the business of banking and that the concept evolves over time as business practices
develop and change.12 As a practical matter, the OCC has indicated that custody essentially is a
contractual matter. Based on the information provided, we find that the Bank’s specific activities
with respect to the Program fall within the scope of permissible custodial arrangements for
national banks.13
Activities Are Consistent With 12 U.S.C. § 92a(d)
The National Bank Act provides in part that “[n]o national bank shall receive in its Trust
Department deposits of current funds subject to check or the deposit of checks, drafts, bill of
exchange, or other items for collection or exchange purposes.”14 Under the Program, a broker-
dealer may not make withdrawals by check, and withdrawals ordered by the broker-dealer are
paid by originating wire transfers or other payment instruments
that “[n]o national bank shall receive in its Trust
Department deposits of current funds subject to check or the deposit of checks, drafts, bill of
exchange, or other items for collection or exchange purposes.”14 Under the Program, a broker-
dealer may not make withdrawals by check, and withdrawals ordered by the broker-dealer are
paid by originating wire transfers or other payment instruments. TLDA deposits may not be
made by deposits of checks, drafts, bills of exchange or other items for collection or exchange
purposes.15 Accordingly, the Program’s funds may constitute deposits in this context, but as
described do not violate 12 U.S.C. § 92a(d) prohibitions.16
Non-cash Earnings Credits and Payment of Interest
As noted above, the Bank’s Trust Department will transfer funds placed in the TLDAs into an
MMDA in the Bank's commercial side. The Bank’s commercial side will not pay the Trust
Department explicit interest on the MMDA, although the Trust Department will receive
“earnings credits” on such funds. You have represented that the earnings credits are non-cash
credits used by the Bank’s management to measure the relative financial performance of the
12 See Nationsbank v. Variable Annuity Life Ins. Co., 513 U.S. 251 (1995); see also American Ins. Ass’n v. Clarke,
865 F.2d 278, 282 (2nd Cir. 1988); M & M Leasing Corp. v. Seattle First Nat’l Bank, 563 F.2d 1377, 1382 (9th Cir.
1977), cert denied, 436 U.S. 956 (1978).
13 The proposed arrangement as described constitutes the holding of funds and there is no order-taking that would
raise implications under the Board’s and SEC’s proposed Regulation R. See 71 Fed. Reg. 77522 (Dec. 26, 2006).
14 12 U.S.C. § 92a(d). This provision was adopted in 1918 and relates to the customary commercial banking
practices at that time and efforts to establish the Federal Reserve System.
15 See e.g., Trust Interpretive Letter No. 76 (Feb
nd there is no order-taking that would
raise implications under the Board’s and SEC’s proposed Regulation R. See 71 Fed. Reg. 77522 (Dec. 26, 2006).
14 12 U.S.C. § 92a(d). This provision was adopted in 1918 and relates to the customary commercial banking
practices at that time and efforts to establish the Federal Reserve System.
15 See e.g., Trust Interpretive Letter No. 76 (Feb. 24, 1987) (checks drawn on separate DDA did not violate “subject
to check” language of section 92a(d)).
16 Bank counsel concludes that the funds held by the Trust Department, as custodian, in the TLDAs, should be
considered “trust funds” under the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (“FDI Act”) and, therefore, should constitute
deposits under the FDI Act. Under the FDI Act, the definition of the term “deposit” includes “trust funds” whether
held in the trust department or in any other bank department. See 12 U.S.C. § 1813(l)(2). The FDIC staff has
determined the funds held by a bank’s trust department as agent for its customer would constitute “trust funds”
notwithstanding the fact that the relationship between the two is one of agency. See FDIC Interpretive Letter (Sept.
14, 1988).
- -
5
Bank’s various activities. The Board has recognized that imputed earnings in the form of
“earnings credit” do not constitute a payment of interest and therefore are permissible under
Regulation Q so long as the bank does not make an actual payment or credit the account.17 The
Bank represents that the Commercial Department does not make an actual payment or credit to
the MMDA.18
With respect to the Trust Department’s payment of interest to Broker-Dealer on the TDLA
balances, Bank counsel asserts that this practice is consistent with safe and sound banking
practices
er
Regulation Q so long as the bank does not make an actual payment or credit the account.17 The
Bank represents that the Commercial Department does not make an actual payment or credit to
the MMDA.18
With respect to the Trust Department’s payment of interest to Broker-Dealer on the TDLA
balances, Bank counsel asserts that this practice is consistent with safe and sound banking
practices. The actual cash comes from the Bank’s general funds, and the expense is allocated to
the Trust Department as an operating expense, as are all other expenses of the Trust Department,
consistent with industry practices. The Bank generates earnings on the investments it makes
with the Broker-Dealers’ deposits, and the Bank incurs an expense as a result of the interest paid
on the deposit. Accordingly, in this context, the interest payment is not inconsistent with safe
and sound banking practices.
Conclusion
We conclude that the Bank’s custody activities with respect to the proposed Program are
permissible for a national bank, and that the Program’s non-cash earnings credit feature is not
inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices. Our conclusions herein are specifically
based on the Bank’s representations and the written submissions describing the facts and
circumstances of the proposed Program. Any change in the facts or circumstances could result in
different conclusions. If you should have any questions concerning this letter, please contact
Suzette H. Greco, Senior Counsel, in the Securities and Corporate Practices Division at 202-874-
5210.
Sincerely,
/s/
Julie L. Williams
First Senior Deputy Comptroller and Chief Counsel
17 See Federal Reserve Regulatory Service (F.R.R.S.) ¶ 2-543.
18 Bank counsel opines that the MMDA is subject to the Board’s Regulations D and Q, however, counsel notes that
currently there are no applicable reserve requirements for MMDAs and that the Bank is not paying interest on the
MMDA
Sincerely,
/s/
Julie L. Williams
First Senior Deputy Comptroller and Chief Counsel
17 See Federal Reserve Regulatory Service (F.R.R.S.) ¶ 2-543.
18 Bank counsel opines that the MMDA is subject to the Board’s Regulations D and Q, however, counsel notes that
currently there are no applicable reserve requirements for MMDAs and that the Bank is not paying interest on the
MMDA. The OCC expresses no opinion as to whether the funds maintained by the broker-dealer in the Trust
Department’s TLDAs should be considered deposits subject to Regulation D’s reserve requirements (12 C.F.R. part
204) or demand deposits subject to Regulation Q’s prohibition against the payment of interest (12 C.F.R. part 217).
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.