Showing The Reference Is Describing An Inventor's Or At Least One Joint Inventor's Own Work
FederalAgency guidance
Ask Donna
How this section applies to your facts.
USPTO MPEP › Chapter 2100 - Patentability › MPEP § 2136.05(b)
Text
[Editor Note: This MPEP section is
not
applicable
to applications subject to examination under the first
inventor to file (FITF) provisions of the AIA as set forth in
35 U.S.C. 100
(note)
. See
MPEP §
2159
et seq. to determine whether an application is
subject to examination under the FITF provisions, and
MPEP §
2150
et seq. for examination of applications subject to
those provisions. Information pertaining to overcoming
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C.
102(e)
rejections has been moved to
MPEP §
2136.05(a)
for affidavits or declarations under
37 CFR
1.131
.]
A rejection based on
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(e)
can be
overcome by filing an affidavit or declaration under
37 CFR 1.132
showing that the reference invention is not by “another.” “The fact that an
application has named a different inventive entity than a patent does not necessarily
make that patent prior art.”
Applied Materials Inc. v. Gemini Research
Corp.,
835 F.2d 279, 15 USPQ2d 1816 (Fed. Cir. 1988). The issue turns on
what the evidence of record shows as to
who
invented the
subject matter.
In re Whittle,
454 F.2d 1193, 1195, 172 USPQ 535,
537 (CCPA 1972). In fact, even if an inventor's or at least one joint inventor's work
was publicly disclosed prior to the patent application, the inventor's or at least
one joint inventor's own work may not be used against the application subject to
pre-AIA 35
U.S.C. 102
unless there is a time bar under
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C.
102(b)
.
In re DeBaun,
687 F.2d 459, 214 USPQ
933 (CCPA 1982) (citing
In re Katz,
687 F.2d 450, 215 USPQ 14
(CCPA 1982)). However, an affidavit or declaration under
37 CFR 1.132
that is only a naked assertion of inventorship and that fails to provide any context,
explanation or evidence to support that assertion is insufficient to show that the
relied-upon subject matter was the inventor’s own work. See
EmeraChem
Holdings, LLC v. Volkswagen Grp. of Am., Inc.,
859 F.3d 1341, 123 USPQ2d
1146 (Fed. Cir
14
(CCPA 1982)). However, an affidavit or declaration under
37 CFR 1.132
that is only a naked assertion of inventorship and that fails to provide any context,
explanation or evidence to support that assertion is insufficient to show that the
relied-upon subject matter was the inventor’s own work. See
EmeraChem
Holdings, LLC v. Volkswagen Grp. of Am., Inc.,
859 F.3d 1341, 123 USPQ2d
1146 (Fed. Cir. 2017) (finding that a declaration submitted by inventor Campbell
insufficient to establish that he and Guth (now deceased) were inventors of the
subject matter disclosed in a patent naming Campbell, Guth, Danziger, and Padron
because “[n]othing in the declaration itself, or in addition to the declaration,
provides any context, explanation, or evidence to lend credence to the inventor's
bare assertion” and more than twenty years had passed since the alleged events
occurred.
Id.
at 1345; 123 USPQ2d at 1149). Therefore, when the
unclaimed subject matter of a reference is an inventor's or at least one joint
inventor's own invention, a
prima facie
case based on the patent,
U.S. patent application publication, or international application publication, may be
overcome by showing that the disclosure is a description of the inventor's or at
least one joint inventor's own previous work. Such a showing can be made by proving
that the inventor(s) of the U.S. patent, U.S. patent application publication, or the
international application publication, was associated with applicant (e.g., same
assignee) and learned of the inventor's or at least one joint inventor's invention
from the inventor or at least one joint inventor directly or indirectly.
In
re Mathews,
408 F.2d 1393, 161 USPQ 276 (CCPA 1969).
In the situation where one application is first filed
naming sole inventor X and then a later application is filed naming joint inventors X
& Y, it must be proven that the joint invention was made first, was thereafter
described in the sole inventor's patent, or was thereafter described in the sole
inventor's U.S
entor directly or indirectly.
In
re Mathews,
408 F.2d 1393, 161 USPQ 276 (CCPA 1969).
In the situation where one application is first filed
naming sole inventor X and then a later application is filed naming joint inventors X
& Y, it must be proven that the joint invention was made first, was thereafter
described in the sole inventor's patent, or was thereafter described in the sole
inventor's U.S. patent application publication or international application
publication, and then the joint application was filed.
In re Land,
368 F.2d 866, 151 USPQ 621 (CCPA 1966).
In
In re Land,
separate U.S. patents to Rogers
and to Land were used to reject a joint application to Rogers and Land under
pre-AIA 35
U.S.C. 102(e)
/
103
. The inventors worked for the
same company (Polaroid) and in the same laboratory. All the patents flowed from the
same research. In addition, the patent applications were prepared by the same
attorneys, were interrelated and contained cross-references to each other. The court
affirmed the rejection because (1) the inventive entities of the patents (one to
Rogers and one to Land) were different from the inventive entity of the joint
application (Rogers and Land) and (2) Land and Rogers brought their knowledge of
their individual work with them when they made the joint invention. There was no
indication that the portions of the references relied on disclosed anything they did
jointly. Nor was there a showing that what they did
jointly
was done before the filing of the reference patent applications.
See also
In re Carreira,
532 F.2d 1356, 189 USPQ
461 (CCPA 1976) (The examiner rejected claims to a joint application to Carreira,
Kyrakakis, Solodar, and Labana under
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(e)
and 103
in view of a U.S. patent issued to Tulagin and Carreira or a patent issued to Clark
Nor was there a showing that what they did
jointly
was done before the filing of the reference patent applications.
See also
In re Carreira,
532 F.2d 1356, 189 USPQ
461 (CCPA 1976) (The examiner rejected claims to a joint application to Carreira,
Kyrakakis, Solodar, and Labana under
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(e)
and 103
in view of a U.S. patent issued to Tulagin and Carreira or a patent issued to Clark.
The applicants submitted declarations under
37 CFR 1.132
by Tulagin and Clark
in which each declarant stated he was “not the inventor of the use of compounds
having a hydroxyl group in a position ortho to an azo linkage.” The court held that
these statements were vague and inconclusive because the declarants did not disclose
the use of this generic compound but rather species of this generic compound in their
patents and it was the species which met the claims. The declaration that each did
not invent the use of the generic compound does not establish that Tulagin and Clark
did not invent the use of the species.)
MPEP §
715.01(a)
,
§ 715.01(c)
, and
§
716.10
set forth more information pertaining to the
contents and uses of affidavits and declarations under
37 CFR 1.132
for antedating references. See
MPEP § 2146
for information
pertaining to rejections under
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C.
102(e)
/
103
and the applicability of
pre-AIA 35
U.S.C. 103(c)
.
I.
APPLICANT NEED NOT SHOW DILIGENCE OR REDUCTION TO PRACTICE WHEN THE SUBJECT
MATTER DISCLOSED IN THE REFERENCE IS APPLICANT’S OWN WORK
When the reference reflects an inventor's or at least one joint
inventor's own work, evidence of diligence or reduction to practice does not need
to be provided in order to establish that the inventor or at least one joint
inventor invented the subject matter disclosed in the reference. A showing that
the reference disclosure arose from an inventor's or at least one joint inventor's
work coupled with a showing of conception by the inventor or at least one joint
inventor before the filing date of the reference will overcome the
pre-AIA 35
U.S.C
be provided in order to establish that the inventor or at least one joint
inventor invented the subject matter disclosed in the reference. A showing that
the reference disclosure arose from an inventor's or at least one joint inventor's
work coupled with a showing of conception by the inventor or at least one joint
inventor before the filing date of the reference will overcome the
pre-AIA 35
U.S.C. 102(e)
rejection. The showing can be made by
submission of an affidavit under
37 CFR 1.132
by the inventor
or at least one joint inventor who invented the subject matter. The other joint
inventors, if applicable, need not submit an affidavit disclaiming inventorship,
but, if submitted, a disclaimer by all other joint inventors should be considered
by the examiner.
In re DeBaun,
687 F.2d 459, 214 USPQ 933 (CCPA
1982) (Declaration submitted by DeBaun stated that he was the inventor of subject
matter disclosed in the U.S. patent reference of DeBaun and Noll. Exhibits were
attached to the declaration showing conception and included drawings DeBaun had
prepared and given to counsel for purposes of preparing the application which
issued as the reference patent. The court held that, even though the evidence was
not sufficient to antedate the prior art patent under
37 CFR
1.131
, diligence and/or reduction to practice was not
required to show DeBaun invented the subject matter. Declarant’s exhibits and
statement that he conceived the invention was enough to show that the subject
matter in the U.S. patent reference was declarant’s own invention.).
II.
CLAIMING OF INDIVIDUAL ELEMENTS OR SUBCOMBINATIONS IN A COMBINATION CLAIM
OF THE REFERENCE DOES NOT ITSELF ESTABLISH THAT THE INVENTOR OR AT LEAST ONE
JOINT INVENTOR INVENTED THOSE ELEMENTS
The existence of combination claims in a reference is not
evidence that the inventor or at least one joint inventor invented the individual
elements or subcombinations included if the elements and subcombinations are not
separately claimed apart from the combination
COMBINATION CLAIM
OF THE REFERENCE DOES NOT ITSELF ESTABLISH THAT THE INVENTOR OR AT LEAST ONE
JOINT INVENTOR INVENTED THOSE ELEMENTS
The existence of combination claims in a reference is not
evidence that the inventor or at least one joint inventor invented the individual
elements or subcombinations included if the elements and subcombinations are not
separately claimed apart from the combination.
In re DeBaun,
687 F.2d 459, 214 USPQ 933 (CCPA 1982) (citing
In re Facius,
408 F.2d 1396, 1406, 161 USPQ 294, 301 (CCPA 1969)).
See also
In re Mathews,
408 F.2d 1393, 161
USPQ 276 (CCPA 1969) (On September 15, 1961, Dewey filed an application disclosing
and claiming a time delay protective device for an electric circuit. In disclosing
the invention, Dewey completely described, but did not claim, a “gating means 19”
invented by Mathews which was usable in the protective device. Dewey and Mathews
were coworkers at General Electric Company, the assignee. Mathews filed his
application on March 7, 1963, before the Dewey patent issued but almost 18 months
after its filing. The Mathews application disclosed that “one illustration of a
circuit embodying the present invention is shown in copending patent application
S.N. 138,476-Dewey.” The examiner used Dewey to reject all the Mathews claims
under
pre-AIA
35 U.S.C. 102(e)
. In response, Mathews submitted an
affidavit by Dewey under
37 CFR 1.132
. In the
affidavit, Dewey stated that he did not invent the gating means 19 but had learned
of the gating means through Mathews and that GE attorneys had advised that the
gating means be disclosed in Dewey’s application to comply with
35 U.S.C.
112
, first paragraph. The examiner argued that the only way
to overcome a
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(e)
rejection was by submitting an
affidavit or declaration under
37 CFR 1.131
to antedate the
filing date of the reference
ng means 19 but had learned
of the gating means through Mathews and that GE attorneys had advised that the
gating means be disclosed in Dewey’s application to comply with
35 U.S.C.
112
, first paragraph. The examiner argued that the only way
to overcome a
pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(e)
rejection was by submitting an
affidavit or declaration under
37 CFR 1.131
to antedate the
filing date of the reference. The court reversed the rejection, holding that the
totality of the evidence on record showed that Dewey derived his knowledge from
Mathews who is “the original, first and sole inventor.”).
[top]
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.