Fisheries of the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico, and South Atlantic; Shrimp Fishery of the Gulf of Mexico; Amendment 9

FederalRegulations

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

Federal Register › Vol. 63 › 63 FR 18139

This text was captured on Sep 30, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

50 CFR Part 622

[Docket No. 970523122-8022-02 ; I.D. 041897B]

RIN 0648-AH52

Fisheries of the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico, and South Atlantic;

Shrimp Fishery of the Gulf of Mexico; Amendment 9

AGENCY: National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and

Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Commerce.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: NMFS issues this final rule to implement Amendment 9 to the

Fishery Management Plan for the Shrimp Fishery of the Gulf of Mexico

(FMP). Amendment 9 requires, with limited exceptions, the use of

certified bycatch reduction devices (BRDs) in shrimp trawls in the

exclusive economic zone (EEZ) in the Gulf of Mexico shoreward of the

100-fathom (fm) (183-m) depth contour west of 85 deg.30' W. long.; sets

the bycatch reduction criterion for the certification of BRDs; and

establishes an FMP framework procedure for modifying the bycatch

reduction criterion, for establishing and modifying the BRD testing

protocol and its specifications, and for certifying and decertifying

BRDs. The intended effect is to reduce the bycatch mortality of

juvenile red snapper, while, to the extent practicable, not adversely

affecting the shrimp fisheries in the Gulf of Mexico.

DATES: This rule is effective May 14, 1998.

ADDRESSES: Copies of the final regulatory flexibility analysis and

NMFS' Supplement to the Economic Analysis of Amendment 9 to the Fishery

Management Plan for the Shrimp fishery of the Gulf of Mexico, U.S.

Waters (March 20, 1998) may be obtained from the Southeast Regional

Office, NMFS, 9721 Executive Center Drive N., St. Petersburg, FL 33702.

Copies of Amendment 9, which includes a regulatory impact review, a

social impact assessment, a fishery impact statement, and a

supplemental final environmental impact statement, may be obtained from

the Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council, 3018 U.S. Highway 301

North; Suite 1000, Tampa, FL 33619-2266; Phone: 813-228-2815; Fax: 813-

225-7015.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Michael E. Justen, 813-570- 5305.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The FMP was prepared by the Gulf of Mexico

Fishery Management Council (Council) and is implemented under the

authority of the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management

Act (Magnuson-Stevens Act) by regulations at 50 CFR part 622.

On April 29, 1997 (62 FR 23211), NMFS announced the availability

for public review and comment of (1) Amendment 9, including a

regulatory impact review (RIR), an initial regulatory flexibility

analysis (IRFA), a social impact assessment (SIA), a fishery impact

statement (FIS), and final supplemental environmental impact statement

(FSEIS), as prepared and submitted by the Council for review, approval

and implementation, and (2) a minority report submitted by three

Council members. On July 2, 1997, NMFS published a proposed rule to

implement the measures in Amendment 9 and requested comments on the

proposed rule (62 FR 35774). The background and rationale for the

measures in Amendment 9 and the proposed rule are contained in the

preamble to the proposed rule and are not repeated here. After

consideration of the comments on Amendment 9 and the proposed rule,

NMFS approved Amendment 9 on July 30, 1997. In support of this final

rule, NMFS prepared a supplement to the economic analysis of Amendment

9 (March 20, 1998) (See ADDRESSES).

Comments and Responses

Comments were received from 3,329 entities on Amendment 9 and its

proposed rule. These entities consisted of 3,279 private individuals,

shrimp vessel owners and crews, industry support personnel, and

business owners; 16 U.S. Congressmen; 14 conservation organizations;

eight commercial fishing or business- related organizations; three

recreational fishing organizations; three members of the Council; two

cities (Port Isabel and Aransas Pass, TX); one bank; and three Federal

agencies.

Approval and Implementation of Amendment 9

Comment: Five hundred sixty-six entities supported approval and

implementation of Amendment 9. These entities endorsed the use of NMFS-

certified BRDs in shrimp trawls to reduce shrimp trawl bycatch as a

means of facilitating the recovery of impacted fish populations, such

as red snapper, in the Gulf of Mexico. These entities consisted of 546

private individuals, three Federal agencies, three recreational fishing

organizations, and 14 conservation organizations.

Response: NMFS agrees, and approved Amendment 9, which is

implemented by this final rule.

Required Use of BRDs in Shrimp Trawls in the Waters East of

85 deg.30' W. Long.

Comment: Eight conservation organizations recommended that NMFS

require the use of BRDs in shrimp trawls in the waters east of

85 deg.30' W. long., (i.e., east of Cape San Blas, FL) to reduce the

incidental catch of finfish in this area. This would facilitate the

recovery of impacted finfish populations.

Response: NMFS disagrees. The Council limited the geographical

scope of the BRD requirement under Amendment 9 to west of Cape San

Blas,

FL, because most red snapper bycatch in the shrimp fisheries occurs in

this area. If new scientific information indicates that the use of BRDs

should be expanded to beyond east of Cape San Blas, FL, the Council may

then propose such action by preparing an FMP amendment, supported by an

appropriate administrative record, that would be submitted to NMFS for

review, approval, and implementation.

The Council Minority Report and Other Opposition to Amendment 9

Comment: Three Council members submitted a minority report opposing

Amendment 9 that contended that: (1) The Council did not consider best

available scientific data; (2) the Council made serious procedural and

legal errors in proceeding with submission of Amendment 9 for review by

NMFS because its Scientific and Statistical Committee (SSC) did not

have a quorum when it met to review Amendment 9 prior to the Council

meeting in November 1996 when it adopted Amendment 9, and because

Amendment 9 does not assess the impact of BRDs on Gulf of Mexico

communities; (3) Amendment 9 is not necessary for the recovery of red

snapper; (4) the shrimp industry is being required to bear an unfair

regulatory burden compared to the participants in the directed red

snapper fisheries; and (5) the economic impacts of requiring BRDs in

shrimp trawls will severely affect the shrimp industry and the United

States economy.

Opposition to Amendment 9 from the remaining commenters focused on

one or more of the same concerns stated in the minority report. Sixteen

Congressmen filed comments and 2,682 private individuals, shrimp vessel

owners and crews, industry support personnel, and business owners

submitted form letters opposing Amendment 9. Eight commercial fishing

or business- related associations, owners of 14 companies, one bank, 36

private individuals, and the cities of Port Isabel and Aransas Pass,

TX, submitted letters opposing approval of Amendment 9.

Response (1): NMFS disagrees that Amendment 9 is not based on the

best available scientific information. The Director, Southeast

Fisheries Science Center, determined that Amendment 9 was based on the

best available scientific information. The General Linear Model (GLM)

method of analyzing bycatch data was peer reviewed in 1990, 1992, and

1997. The 1990 peer review was at the request of the Council. The 1992

peer review was done under the direction of the Technical Steering

Committee of the regional Cooperative By catch Research Program,

administered by the Gulf and South Atlantic Fisheries Development

Foundation, Inc., a non-profit, educational and scientific research

organization. In each case, the recommendation of the peer reviewers

was to use the GLM method. The 1997 peer review was done under the

direction of the Council at the request of Texas Shrimp Association

(TSA) representatives. This review was conducted in two phases. The

first phase consisted of the presentation of data and analyses by NMFS

and TSA's consultant, LGL Ecological Research Associates, Inc. (LGL),

to a peer review panel for evaluation by each individual panel member.

In the second phase, these panel members' evaluations, along with

responses from LGL and NMFS, were then presented to the Council's Stock

Assessment Panel (SAP) for its review and recommendations to the

Council's SSC and to the Council.

The 1997 peer review panel members generally supported the GLM

approach but provided recommendations on alternative means of using the

available data that might improve the red snapper by catch estimates.

NMFS addressed these recommendations in a presentation to the SAP. The

peer review panel members' recommendations usually resulted in

increases in the red snapper bycatch estimates, not decreases as had

been assumed by LGL. The conclusion of the SAP, the SSC, and the

Council was that the original red snapper bycatch estimates represented

the best available scientific data.

In addition to the 1997 peer review of the bycatch estimates, the

Council contracted with Dr. Phil Goodyear, a prominent stock assessment

biologist, to review the 1995 stock assessment and to determine the

effects of over-estimates of red snapper bycatch on the scientific

advice that bycatch had to be reduced to recover this species. Dr.

Goodyear's sensitivity analysis showed that even with overestimates of

bycatch up to 33 percent, red snapper bycatch in the shrimp fisheries

still had to be reduced significantly for red snapper stock recovery.

Based on these peer review results and on all other available

information, the Council concluded that Amendment 9 is based on the

best available scientific information.

Response (2): NMFS disagrees that the Council made serious

procedural and legal errors in submitting Amendment 9 for agency review

and approval. NMFS reviewed the administrative record and determined

that there were no legal or procedural impediments to approval and

implementation of Amendment 9. The SSC and Reef Fish SAP met after the

Council's November 1996 meeting and endorsed Amendment 9. The Council

was aware the SSC lacked a quorum and considered that fact. The SSC's

recommendations are not binding on the Council; however, in this

instance, they were consistent with the Council's action and

administrative record.

Regarding the assessment of Amendment 9 regulatory impacts on Gulf

of Mexico communities, the Council prepared the following analyses of

impacts in support of its proposed amendment: IRFA, RIR, FIS, SIA, and

FSEIS. The IRFA thoroughly assessed the economic impact of BRDs in

shrimp trawls on small entities as required under the Regulatory

Flexibility Act and concluded that Amendment 9 would adversely impact a

substantial number of small entities in the Gulf of Mexico shrimp

fisheries. The RIR clearly estimated the economic and social impacts of

requiring the installation of BRDs in shrimp trawls on Gulf of Mexico

shrimp fisheries as well as the economic impacts of alternatives

considered by the Council. The RIR concluded that there would be

adverse economic impacts on the Gulf shrimp fisheries as well as

potential long-term economic benefits to the commercial red snapper

fisheries. As noted in the SIA, participants in the shrimp fisheries

believe that impacts associated with requiring BRDs will be negative.

The Council was aware of the potential adverse economic impact of BRDs

on the shrimp fisheries, but believed that reduction of the red snapper

bycatch was necessary to allow the directed red snapper fisheries to

continue while allowing rebuilding of the overfished red snapper

resource. In complying with national standard 9 (minimizing bycatch

mortality to the extent practicable), the Council, consistent with

national standard 8, minimized the adverse economic and social impacts

on the shrimp fisheries, including fishing communities, by limiting the

BRD requirement to the geographical area where red snapper and shrimp

are found together; namely, Federal waters west of Cape San Blas, FL,

out to 100 fm (183 m) to the border with Mexico. With this geographical

limitation, the Council concluded that the adverse economic and social

impacts of BRDs on the Gulf of Mexico shrimp fisheries would be offset

by positive biological, ecological, economic, and social impacts of the

Gulf of Mexico red snapper fisheries based on a rebuilt red snapper

stock. Finally, the FIS succinctly states the overall impact of

Amendment 9 on fishery participants

and fishing communities regarding both Gulf of Mexico shrimp and red

snapper fisheries.

Response (3): NMFS disagrees that implementation of Amendment 9 is

unnecessary for the recovery of the red snapper resource in the Gulf of

Mexico. Stock assessments prepared in 1988, 1990, and 1995 determined

the status of the stock and clearly indicated that red snapper could

not recover to the 20- percent spawning potential ratio (SPR) level by

2019 without a significant reduction in bycatch. At the 20-percent SPR

level, the stock would no longer be considered overfished under the

current provisions of the Fishery Management Plan for the Reef Fish

Resources of the Gulf of Mexico (Reef Fish FMP). The year 2019 is the

Reef Fish FMP's target date for recovery of the stock to the 20-percent

SPR level. Under the 1996 amendments to the Magnuson-Stevens Act, the

red snapper stock will, in all likelihood, have to be rebuilt to a

level above 20-percent SPR. Regulatory actions to date to rebuild the

red snapper stock have been limited to controlling the directed

recreational and commercial harvest of red snapper. There is also a

need to control the significant bycatch of juvenile red snapper in

trawls.

Response (4): NMFS disagrees that the shrimp industry is being

required to bear an unfair regulatory burden compared to the

participants in the directed red snapper fisheries. Shrimp trawls have

a significant bycatch of non-target finfish and invertebrates, most of

which are discarded dead. Scientific survey results indicate that the

ratio of the weight of finfish bycatch to that of shrimp caught is

about 4.2 to 1. The best available information indicated that

elimination of the directed harvest for red snapper would not allow the

overfished resource to recover by 2019. Therefore, some device is

needed that would reduce the incidental catch of juvenile red snapper

in shrimp trawls by 44 percent to allow the overfished red snapper

stock to recover.

Response (5): NMFS and the Council agree that requiring the use of

BRDs in the Gulf of Mexico shrimp fisheries will result in negative

economic impacts on the shrimp industry. The IRFA concluded that

Amendment 9 would result in significant adverse impacts on a

substantial number of small business entities that participate in the

Gulf of Mexico shrimp fisheries. In particular, the IRFA concluded that

revenues of a large portion of the small businesses in the shrimp

fisheries would be reduced by at least 5 percent and that from 0.3 to

7.8 percent of the shrimp-harvesting businesses could cease operations

(depending on the type of BRD they elected to use) if the rule is

implemented.

The RIR estimated that if the use of BRDs in shrimp trawls is

required, there would be a long-term net loss in benefits to the shrimp

fisheries of $117 million assuming that all shrimpers use the fisheye

BRD and that the shrimp loss rate with that BRD is 3 percent. If other

BRDs are certified with higher or lower shrimp loss rates, the net loss

would differ depending on the mix of BRDs used. The analysis in

Amendment 9 was based on an expectation that this $117 million net loss

to the shrimp fisheries would be offset by a net benefit to the

commercial red snapper fisheries of roughly $118 million, assuming that

these fisheries are managed to maximize economic benefits (e.g., under

an individual transferable quota (ITQ) management system). In the

short-term (i.e., 1-4 years), annual adverse impacts on the shrimp

fisheries due to use of the fisheye BRD would range from about $40

million in the first year to $20 million in the fourth year. Most of

the net loss to the shrimp fisheries would have occurred by 2019, the

current target date for rebuilding the overfished red snapper resource.

The net loss to the shrimp fisheries includes adverse impacts on the

shrimp industry and consumers, although the greatest proportion of the

adverse impacts would be borne by the shrimp industry. Subsequently,

NMFS prepared a supplement to the economic analysis for Amendment 9 to

further examine the effects on the red snapper commercial fisheries

from 1998 though 2019 (see ADDRESSES). Executive Order 12866 typically

requires that all changes in net benefits be measured against the

status quo. In the case of the red snapper and shrimp fisheries, the

staus quo is a total allowable catch (TAC) of 9.12 million lb and no

BRD requirement. In addition to analyzing the effects under scenarios

of ITQ management and no ITQ management, and under TACs for red snapper

of 9.12 million lb and 6.0 million lb, benefits were also measured for

a baseline of a zero TAC for red snapper. The benefit of the status quo

alternative of no BRD requirement and a TAC of 9.12 million lb would be

$58 million. If ITQ management is added to that baseline, the benefit

of the BRD rule to the red snapper fisheries would be an increase of

$35 million or a total of $93 million. In summary, using the 1998

status quo TAC of 9.12 million lb for red snapper, the benefits to the

commercial red snapper fisheries as measured against the zero TAC

baseline amounts to an increase of $93 million with ITQ management and

$58 million without ITQ management. The expanded analysis made no

determination regarding changes in benefits to the recreational red

snapper fisheries, did not include benefits accruing after 2019 when a

larger TAC is expected, and also did not attempt to calculate benefits

to the finfish stocks that would benefit in a biological sense from by

catch reduction.

The SIA concluded that Gulf of Mexico shrimp fishermen were

experiencing a high level of work-related stress in 1994 versus 1987

due to a variety of factors, including the required use of turtle

excluder devices (TEDs), and that additional regulations, such as

requiring the use of BRDs, would further raise fishermen's stress

levels. The SIA also found that if BRD use increases shrimping

efficiency and reduces fishermen's workload (because of a reduced need

to cull finfish from the shrimp catch), then stress levels may

decrease. Further, according to the SIA, if fishermen take advantage of

public hearings and other opportunities (i.e., workshops) to become

fully involved in the further development and testing of BRDs and in

modifying the bycatch criteria, they should be more willing to accept

and comply with bycatch regulations.

The FIS summarized the overall negative impact of Amendment 9 on

the shrimp fisheries and summarized the relevant findings of the IRFA,

RIR, and SIA.

As required by national standard 8 of the Magnuson-Stevens Act, the

Council considered the importance of the shrimp fisheries to the

fishing communities and provided for the sustained participation of

such communities. Also, the Council minimized adverse economic and

social impacts on the shrimp fisheries and associated communities by

requiring the use of BRDs only to the area where juvenile red snapper

currently are concentrated (Federal waters shoreward of the 100 fm (183

m) curve and west of Cape San Blas, FL, to the Mexican border).

Additionally, certain shrimping operations were exempted from the BRD

requirements because they do not result in significant mortalities of

juvenile red snapper. A shrimp trawler is exempted from the requirement

to have a certified BRD: 1) Installed in each net provided that at

least 90 percent (by weight) of all shrimp on board or offloaded from

such trawler are royal red shrimp; 2) installed in a single try net

with a headrope length of 16 ft (4.9 m) or less provided the single try

net is either pulled immediately in front of another net or is not

connected to another net; or 3)

installed in up to two rigid- frame roller trawls that are 16 ft (4.9

m) or less in length used or possessed on board. Finally, the Council

held 14 public hearings where commercial shrimping associations made

numerous presentations that the Council carefully considered before

adopting final measures to reduce the shrimp trawl fishery finfish

bycatch.

Commercial Shrimp Fisheries Are Major Sources of Employment and

Businesses to Residents of the Coastal Areas of the Gulf of Mexico

Comment: Sixteen congressmen, 2,682 shrimp fishermen, support

industry personnel, vessel owners, and private individuals, 8

commercial associations, owners of 14 companies, one bank, 36 private

individuals, and the cities of Port Isabel, and Aransas Pass, Texas,

stated that commercial shrimp fisheries are major sources of employment

and businesses for hundreds of thousands of residents.

Response: NMFS recognizes the importance of the shrimp and red

snapper fisheries to fishermen, support industries, businessmen,

coastal communities, and states.

Number of BRDs Available

Comment: Sixteen Congressmen and one commercial shrimp association

objected that, with the decertification of the Andrews TED in December

1997, there is only one BRD, the fisheye, available for fishermen to

use.

Response: Since the Council adopted Amendment 9 on November 14,

1996, for submission to NMFS, the Southeast Fisheries Science Center

has analyzed the data on the performance of a new BRD (Jones-Davis) and

has recommended that the Regional Administrator, Southeast Region, NMFS

(Regional Administrator), certify this BRD as meeting the bycatch

reduction criterion of Amendment 9. Upon promulgation of a BRD testing

and certification protocol by separate final rule in early 1998, this

BRD may be certified for use under the FMP's framework procedure for

regulatory adjustments. Additionally, three modified Andrews TEDs

recently passed field tests for the exclusion of turtles, and it is

anticipated that at least one of these TEDs may be certified as a BRD

early in 1998.

Neutral Panel to Review Status of Red Snapper and Impact of Shrimp

Trawl Bycatch

Comment: One Congressman, two commercial shrimping associations,

and one shrimp business owner recommended that NMFS and LGL present

their respective conflicting scientific information on the status of

the red snapper resource, data problems, and other technical issues to

a neutral scientific panel for review and evaluation. This panel would

render an opinion on the quality of the science and the need for the

BRD requirement.

Response: Further reviews are not needed. There have been three

assessments of the red snapper stock (1988, 1990, and 1995) in the Gulf

of Mexico. Each assessment report concluded that the red snapper

resource was overfished and the major contributing factor was shrimp

trawl bycatch. In addition, the juvenile red snapper bycatch estimating

procedures were peer reviewed in 1990, 1992, and 1997, and the

Council's SAP and SSC participated in reviewing all of the scientific

information and data associated with the red snapper assessments. See

the response above regarding the best available data and the three

independent peer review panels and their review of the shrimp fishery

bycatch data and the analytic models used for bycatch estimation.

Furthermore, two congressionally-mandated studies on the red

snapper stock and shrimp fishery bycatch were completed in December

1997. The first study, as required by the Magnuson- Stevens Act,

consisted of a thorough and independent peer review of the scientific

and management bases for conserving and managing the red snapper

fisheries in the Gulf of Mexico. The final consolidated peer review

report concluded that the red snapper stock in the Gulf of Mexico is

severely overfished, and that both directed fishing effort and juvenile

red snapper bycatch in the shrimp fisheries must be reduced in order

for the red snapper stock to recover. These peer review conclusions

were based, in part, on a review of the results of the second study.

The second study was an independent red snapper stock assessment

required by agency appropriations legislation. This independent red

snapper stock assessment noted that the shrimp fishery bycatch of red

snapper is significant, but concluded that the stock appears to be

healthy in that average red snapper size may be increasing and that

recruitment appears to be increasing in recent years. The Science and

Management Panel, one of three independent review panels, reviewed the

preliminary results of this independent red snapper stock assessment.

That panel concluded the analysis was incomplete because it did not

correctly factor in the impact of the large red snapper bycatch in the

Gulf of Mexico shrimp fishery.

Cumulative Cost of TEDs and BRDs to Shrimpers

Comment: Sixteen congressmen, one commercial shrimping association,

and one shrimp fleet owner stated that the shrimp industry is bearing

large costs associated with reducing their incidental catch and kill of

endangered or threatened sea turtles, and Amendment 9 does not quantify

the cost to industry associated with TEDs.

Response: The baseline for Amendment 9's economic analysis of the

impacts of the BRD requirements on the shrimp industry is the industry

with its present regulatory burden. The RIRs done as part of the rules

that implemented the TED requirements detail the economic impacts

expected to result from the TED requirements on the Southeast shrimp

fisheries.

Statement of Dr. Phil Goodyear Regarding Role of Shrimp Fishery in

Causing Overfished Condition of Red Snapper

Comment: One commercial fishing association and one shrimp fleet

owner contended that at the Council meeting held on May 12, 1997, Dr.

Phil Goodyear, a reef fish biologist under contract to the Council,

stated that the commercial shrimp fishery was not responsible for the

overfished condition of the red snapper resource and that, instead, the

fishermen in the directed fishery for red snapper were responsible.

Response: NMFS disagrees. Dr. Goodyear stated at this meeting that

the combined effect of excessive mortalities caused by directed fishing

by the red snapper fisheries and bycatch by the shrimp fisheries are

causing the overfished condition of the resource. NMFS points out that

the shrimp trawl fishery removes about 88 percent of the red snapper

population. The remaining 12 percent is the basis for the spawning

stock and the directed fishery.

Modification of the Bycatch Reduction Criterion

Comment: One shrimp vessel owner contended that the establishment

of the Special BRD Advisory Panel (AP) is redundant and will supplant

the Shrimp and Reef Fish APs.

Response: NMFS disagrees. This BRD AP will be composed of

scientists, engineers, environmentalists, fishermen, or others with

knowledge of BRDs and their ability to reduce bycatch of red snapper

and will advise the Council on the need for adjustments in the bycatch

reduction criterion. Amendment 9 does not contain any statement that

the Council intends for this panel to replace or to override the

recommendations of the Shrimp and Reef Fish APs or vice versa.

Shrimp Vessel Costs and Returns

Comment: One commercial shrimping association and one shrimp vessel

owner stated that the preamble to the proposed rule contained

information that would allow a reader to conclude that the annual pre-

tax profit margin per shrimp vessel is $102,000 or 51 percent of annual

revenue. The commenters indicated that this figure is not correct and

gives the impression that shrimpers can easily afford to use BRDs in

their nets. Furthermore, they contend that new information on vessel

costs and returns in a NMFS report of May 1997 should have been used.

They claim this new information shows that shrimpers are not

financially able to withstand the income losses associated with BRDs.

Response: NMFS agrees that the information in the preamble to the

proposed rule (62 FR 35778) could allow a reader to conclude that the

pre-tax profit margin per vessel is $102,000 or 51 percent of annual

revenue. However, Amendment 9 contains the appropriate cost and earning

information for shrimp vessels (Table R-4). The range in annual gross

revenue per vessel is from $8,389 to $220,412, with an average of

$43,002. Annual net revenue per vessel ranged from $2,249 to $41,881,

with an average of $6,564. The net revenue figures did not include

taxes so they roughly estimate the pre-tax profit margin. Thus, the

average pre-tax margin was 15 percent, not 51 percent of revenue. When

the Council finalized Amendment 9 in November 1996, the May 1997 report

was not available. For information on the adverse impact of BRDs on the

shrimp fishery, see the above response regarding economic impacts on

the shrimp industry and the United States.

Exemption for Vessels Using Rigid-Frame Roller Trawls

Comment: One shrimp fisherman questioned why the exemption from the

BRD requirement for rigid-frame roller trawls should not apply to his

gear. This fisherman fishes off Pasco, Hernando, and Citrus Counties,

FL, and uses four rigid-frame roller trawls. He states that his four-

trawl rig scares fish away and thereby minimizes bycatch.

Response: The exemption for rigid-frame roller trawls applies only

to the use of up to two such trawls. However, the BRD requirement

applies only west of Cape San Blas, FL. BRDs are not required in waters

east of Cape San Blas, FL.

Changes From the Proposed Rule

Certification of the Andrews TED as a BRD is removed in this final

rule. In the proposed rule, the Andrews TED was proposed to be

certified as a BRD ``only during a time when and in a geographical area

where it is an approved TED.'' Effective December 19, 1997, approval of

the Andrews TED was withdrawn.

Classification

The Regional Administrator, with concurrence by the Assistant

Administrator for Fisheries, NOAA, has determined that Amendment 9 is

necessary for the conservation and management of the shrimp fisheries

of the Gulf of Mexico and that it is consistent with the Magnuson-

Stevens Act and other applicable law.

This rule has been determined to be significant for purposes of

E.O. 12866.

The Council prepared an FSEIS for Amendment 9; a notice of its

availability was published by the Environmental Protection Agency on

June 6, 1997 (62 FR 31098). The FSEIS assesses the impacts on the human

environment of both the Gulf shrimp fisheries and the Council's

proposed and alternative management measures for reducing bycatch in

the shrimp fisheries. Those impacts were summarized in the proposed

rule and are not repeated here. No comments were received on the FSEIS.

NMFS prepared a FRFA based on the Council-prepared IRFA that

described the impacts the proposed rule would have on small entities,

if adopted. Based on the IRFA, NMFS concluded that Amendment 9, if

approved and implemented through final regulations, would have

significant economic impacts on a substantial number of small entities.

During the public comment periods on Amendment 9 and its proposed

implementing regulations, no public comments were received that

disagreed with the analysis or conclusions of the IRFA; no additional

information was received that would change the analysis or conclusions

of the IRFA regarding the impacts on small entities. Accordingly, the

FRFA is based on the IRFA and is not substantively changed. Copies of

the FRFA are available (see ADDRESSES). A summary of the FRFA follows.

Amendment 9 will affect most of the roughly 5,000 shrimp vessels

that operate in the Gulf, because the vast majority of such vessels

operate in the EEZ for at least part of the year. It will also affect a

substantial, but unknown, number of shrimp boats that are smaller than

the typical offshore shrimp vessel (smaller craft that are not required

to be documented by the U.S. Coast Guard) but operate in the EEZ during

periods of favorable weather when harvestable shrimp populations are

found in the near-shore portion of the EEZ. All of the vessels and

boats that would be affected by Amendment 9 are considered small

business entities for the purposes of the Regulatory Flexibility Act,

because their individual annual gross revenues are less then $3

million. The small entities that would be affected by Amendment 9

generate annual gross revenues per vessel ranging from $8,389 to

$220,412. Net revenue per vessel ranges from $2,249 to $41,881.

The shrimp loss from using BRDs would cause at least a 5- percent

reduction in gross revenues for a large, but unknown, number of shrimp

vessels, assuming such vessels use a BRD with a shrimp loss rate equal

to that of the Fisheye BRD (3 percent), presently the only certified

BRD. If other BRDs are developed and certified with higher or lower

shrimp loss rates, the reduction in gross revenues would differ

depending on the mix of BRDs used by the industry. It should be noted

that NMFS is in the process of certifying a number of additional BRDs

in order to provide a wider choice to fishermen. Certification of BRDs

will be based on bycatch reduction criterion and not on the expected

shrimp loss rates. The owners of affected shrimp fishing vessels and

boats will have to purchase and use certified BRDs; vessels and boats

may fish with 1-5 nets. In addition, affected small entities would

incur annual increases in operating costs ranging from 0.2 to 10

percent; these costs generally would be less than 5 percent. The FRFA

indicated that, depending on the type of certified BRD shrimpers use,

between 9 and 240 full-time shrimp vessels (i.e., between 0.3 and 7.8

percent of the shrimp fleet) would leave the shrimp fishery because of

the effects of the BRD requirements. There was a higher end of the

range associated with the Andrews TED that had qualified as a BRD, but

the Andrews TED is currently not a legal TED and therefore cannot be

used.

Several alternatives to the proposed measures of Amendment 9 were

considered by the Council. The status quo, which would have no negative

economic effects on the shrimp trawling industry, was rejected because

the critical bycatch reduction objective cannot be met without some

action to reduce the shrimp fishery bycatch of red snapper. The

alternative of closing the shrimp season for a portion of the year was

rejected because this likely would not result in a large enough

reduction of red snapper bycatch and because the negative impacts on

the shrimp industry would be significant. The alternative of meeting

the bycatch reduction objective through permanently closing some shrimp

trawling areas where juvenile red snapper are concentrated was

rejected because the projected economic losses to the shrimp industry

were greater than the preferred alternative. The final rule provides

certain exemptions from the BRD requirements to reduce negative

economic impacts on shrimp fishermen while still meeting the bycatch

reduction objectives.

This rule does not establish any new reporting or recordkeeping

requirements. The BRD testing protocol is expected to include a new

collection-of-information requirement subject to the PRA--namely, the

BRD certification process, consisting of an application for the testing

of a new BRD, the testing itself, and the submission of the test

results. The estimated burden hours (i.e., response time) for this

requirement has not been determined. When determined, the new

collection-of-information requirement will be submitted to the Office

of Management and Budget for approval. The requirement and its response

time/burden hours will be contained in a proposed rule containing the

BRD testing protocol to be published subsequently in the Federal

Register with an opportunity for public comment.

List of Subjects in 50 CFR Part 622

Fisheries, Fishing, Puerto Rico, Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements, Virgin Islands.

Dated: April 8, 1998.

Rolland A. Schmitten,

Assistant Administrator for Fisheries, National Marine Fisheries

Services.

For the reasons set out in the preamble, 50 CFR part 622 is amended

as follows:

PART 622--FISHERIES OF THE CARIBBEAN, GULF, AND SOUTH ATLANTIC

1. The authority citation for part 622 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1801 et seq.

2. In Sec. 622.2, a definition for ``Shrimp trawler'' is added in

alphabetical order to read as follows:

Sec. 622.2 Definitions and acronyms.

* * * * *

Shrimp trawler means any vessel that is equipped with one or more

trawl nets whose on-board or landed catch of shrimp is more than 1

percent, by weight, of all fish comprising its on-board or landed

catch.

* * * * *

3. In Sec. 622.41, paragraph (h) is added to read as follows:

Sec. 622.41 Species specific limitations.

* * * * *

(h) Shrimp in the Gulf--(1) BRD requirement. (i) Except as exempted

in paragraphs (h)(1)(ii) through (iv) of this section, on a shrimp

trawler in the Gulf EEZ shoreward of the 100-fathom (183-m) depth

contour west of 85 deg.30' W. long., each net that is rigged for

fishing must have a certified BRD installed. A trawl net is rigged for

fishing if it is in the water, or if it is shackled, tied, or otherwise

connected to a sled, door, or other device that spreads the net, or to

a tow rope, cable, pole, or extension, either on board or attached to a

shrimp trawler.

(ii) A shrimp trawler is exempt from the requirement to have a

certified BRD installed in each net provided that at least 90 percent

(by weight) of all shrimp on board or offloaded from such trawler are

royal red shrimp.

(iii) A shrimp trawler is exempt from the requirement to have a BRD

installed in a single try net with a headrope length of 16 ft (4.9 m)

or less provided the single try net is either pulled immediately in

front of another net or is not connected to another net.

(iv) A shrimp trawler is exempt from the requirement to have a

certified BRD installed in up to two rigid-frame roller trawls that are

16 ft (4.9 m) or less in length used or possessed on board. A rigid-

frame roller trawl is a trawl that has a mouth formed by a rigid frame

and a grid of rigid vertical bars; has rollers on the lower horizontal

part of the frame to allow the trawl to roll over the bottom and any

obstruction while being towed; and has no doors, boards, or similar

devices attached to keep the mouth of the trawl open.

(2) Certified BRDs. The fisheye BRD is certified for use by shrimp

trawlers in the Gulf EEZ. Specifications of the fisheye BRD are

contained in Appendix D of this part.

4. In Sec. 622.48, paragraph (i) is added to read as follows:

Sec. 622.48 Adjustment of management measures.

* * * * *

(i) Gulf shrimp. Bycatch reduction criteria, BRD certification and

decertification criteria, BRD testing protocol, certified BRDs, and BRD

specifications.

[FR Doc. 98-9767 Filed 4-9-98; 11:41 am]

BILLING CODE 3510-22-F

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Fisheries of the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico, and South Atlantic; Shrimp Fishery of the Gulf of Mexico; Amendment 9 · 63 FR 18139 | Frix