Appraisal Threshold for Commercial Real Estate Transactions

FederalAgency guidance

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

FDIC Financial Institution Letters › Appraisal Threshold for Commercial Real Estate Transactions

This text was captured on Aug 14, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

35478

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

technical difficulties and cannot contact

you for clarification, DOE may not be

able to consider your comment.

However, your contact information

will be publicly viewable if you include

it in the comment or in any documents

attached to your comment. Any

information that you do not want to be

publicly viewable should not be

included in your comment, nor in any

document attached to your comment.

Persons viewing comments will see only

first and last names, organization

names, correspondence containing

comments, and any documents

submitted with the comments.

Do not submit to http://

www.regulations.gov information for

which disclosure is restricted by statute,

such as trade secrets and commercial or

financial information (hereinafter

referred to as Confidential Business

Information (CBI)). Comments

submitted through http://

www.regulations.gov cannot be claimed

as CBI. Comments received through the

Web site will waive any CBI claims for

the information submitted. For

information on submitting CBI, see the

Confidential Business Information

section.

DOE processes submissions made

through http://www.regulations.gov

before posting. Normally, comments

will be posted within a few days of

being submitted. However, if large

volumes of comments are being

processed simultaneously, your

comment may not be viewable for up to

several weeks. Please keep the comment

tracking number that http://

www.regulations.gov provides after you

have successfully uploaded your

comment.

Submitting comments via email, hand

delivery, or mail. Comments and

documents submitted via email, hand

delivery, or mail also will be posted to

http://www.regulations.gov. If you do

not want your personal contact

information to be publicly viewable, do

not include it in your comment or any

accompanying documents. Instead,

provide your contact information on a

cover letter

our

comment.

Submitting comments via email, hand

delivery, or mail. Comments and

documents submitted via email, hand

delivery, or mail also will be posted to

http://www.regulations.gov. If you do

not want your personal contact

information to be publicly viewable, do

not include it in your comment or any

accompanying documents. Instead,

provide your contact information on a

cover letter. Include your first and last

names, email address, telephone

number, and optional mailing address.

The cover letter will not be publicly

viewable as long as it does not include

any comments.

Include contact information each time

you submit comments, data, documents,

and other information to DOE. If you

submit via mail or hand delivery, please

provide all items on a CD, if feasible. It

is not necessary to submit printed

copies. No facsimiles (faxes) will be

accepted.

Comments, data, and other

information submitted to DOE

electronically should be provided in

PDF (preferred), Microsoft Word or

Excel, WordPerfect, or text (ASCII) file

format. Provide documents that are not

secured, written in English and free of

any defects or viruses. Documents

should not contain special characters or

any form of encryption and, if possible,

they should carry the electronic

signature of the author.

Campaign form letters. Please submit

campaign form letters by the originating

organization in batches of between 50 to

500 form letters per PDF or as one form

letter with a list of supporters’ names

compiled into one or more PDFs. This

reduces comment processing and

posting time.

Confidential Business Information

nd, if possible,

they should carry the electronic

signature of the author.

Campaign form letters. Please submit

campaign form letters by the originating

organization in batches of between 50 to

500 form letters per PDF or as one form

letter with a list of supporters’ names

compiled into one or more PDFs. This

reduces comment processing and

posting time.

Confidential Business Information.

According to 10 CFR 1004.11, any

person submitting information that he

or she believes to be confidential and

exempt by law from public disclosure

should submit via email, postal mail, or

hand delivery two well-marked copies:

one copy of the document marked

confidential including all the

information believed to be confidential,

and one copy of the document marked

‘‘non-confidential’’ with the information

believed to be confidential deleted.

Submit these documents via email or on

a CD, if feasible. DOE will make its own

determination about the confidential

status of the information and treat it

according to its determination.

Factors of interest to DOE when

evaluating requests to treat submitted

information as confidential include (1) a

description of the items, (2) whether

and why such items are customarily

treated as confidential within the

industry, (3) whether the information is

generally known by or available from

other sources, (4) whether the

information has previously been made

available to others without obligation

concerning its confidentiality, (5) an

explanation of the competitive injury to

the submitting person which would

result from public disclosure, (6) when

such information might lose its

confidential character due to the

passage of time, and (7) why disclosure

of the information would be contrary to

the public interest.

It is DOE’s policy that all comments

may be included in the public docket,

without change and as received,

including any personal information

provided in the comments (except

information deemed to be exempt from

public disclosure)

ormation might lose its

confidential character due to the

passage of time, and (7) why disclosure

of the information would be contrary to

the public interest.

It is DOE’s policy that all comments

may be included in the public docket,

without change and as received,

including any personal information

provided in the comments (except

information deemed to be exempt from

public disclosure).

DOE considers public participation to

be a very important part of the process

for developing test procedures. DOE

actively encourages the participation

and interaction of the public during the

comment period in each stage of the

rulemaking process. Interactions with

and between members of the public

provide a balanced discussion of the

issues and assist DOE in the rulemaking

process. Anyone who wishes to be

added to the DOE mailing list to receive

future notices and information about

this rulemaking should contact

Appliance and Equipment Standards

Program staff at (202) 586–6636 or via

email at

ApplianceStandardsQuestions@

ee.doe.gov.

Issued in Washington, DC, on July 14,

2017.

Kathleen B. Hogan,

Deputy Assistant Secretary for Energy

Efficiency, Energy Efficiency and Renewable

Energy.

[FR Doc. 2017–15848 Filed 7–28–17; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 6450–01–P

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY

Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency

12 CFR Part 34

[Docket No. OCC–2017–0011]

RIN 1557–AE18

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

12 CFR Part 225

[Docket No. R–1568; RIN 7100 AE–81]

FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE

CORPORATION

12 CFR Part 323

RIN 3064 AE–56

Real Estate Appraisals

AGENCY: Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency, Treasury (OCC); Board of

Governors of the Federal Reserve

System (Board); and Federal Deposit

Insurance Corporation (FDIC).

ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking

and request for comment.

SUMMARY: The OCC, Board, and FDIC

(collectively, the agencies) are inviting

comment on a proposed rule to amend

the agencies’ regulations requiring

appraisals of real estate for certain

transactions

cy, Treasury (OCC); Board of

Governors of the Federal Reserve

System (Board); and Federal Deposit

Insurance Corporation (FDIC).

ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking

and request for comment.

SUMMARY: The OCC, Board, and FDIC

(collectively, the agencies) are inviting

comment on a proposed rule to amend

the agencies’ regulations requiring

appraisals of real estate for certain

transactions. The proposal would

increase the threshold level at or below

which appraisals would not be required

for commercial real estate transactions

from $250,000 to $400,000. This

proposed change to the appraisal

threshold reflects comments the

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00011

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35479

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

agencies received through the regulatory

review process required by the

Economic Growth and Regulatory

Paperwork Reduction Act (EGRPRA)

and completed in early 2017. For

commercial real estate transactions with

a value at or below the proposed

threshold, the amended rule would

require institutions to obtain an

evaluation of the real property collateral

that is consistent with safe and sound

banking practices if the institution does

not obtain an appraisal by a state

certified or licensed appraiser.

DATES: Comments must be received by

September 29, 2017.

ADDRESSES: Interested parties are

encouraged to submit written comments

jointly to all of the agencies.

Commenters should use the title ‘‘Real

Estate Appraisals’’ to facilitate the

organization and distribution of

comments among the agencies.

Interested parties are invited to submit

written comments to:

Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency: Because paper mail in the

Washington, DC area and at the OCC is

subject to delay, commenters are

encouraged to submit comments by the

Federal eRulemaking Portal or email, if

possible

Estate Appraisals’’ to facilitate the

organization and distribution of

comments among the agencies.

Interested parties are invited to submit

written comments to:

Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency: Because paper mail in the

Washington, DC area and at the OCC is

subject to delay, commenters are

encouraged to submit comments by the

Federal eRulemaking Portal or email, if

possible. Please use the title ‘‘Real

Estate Appraisals’’ to facilitate the

organization and distribution of the

comments. You may submit comments

by any of the following methods:

• Federal eRulemaking Portal—

Regulations.gov: Go to

www.regulations.gov. Enter ‘‘Docket ID

OCC–2017–0011’’ in the Search Box and

click ‘‘Search.’’ Click on ‘‘Comment

Now’’ to submit public comments.

• Click on the ‘‘Help’’ tab on the

Regulations.gov home page to get

information on using Regulations.gov,

including instructions for submitting

public comments.

• Email: regs.comments@

occ.treas.gov.

• Mail: Legislative and Regulatory

Activities Division, Office of the

Comptroller of the Currency, 400 7th

Street SW., Suite 3E–218, Mail Stop

9W–11, Washington, DC 20219.

• Fax: (571) 465–4326.

• Hand Delivery/Courier: 400 7th

Street SW., Suite 3E–218, Mail Stop

9W–11, Washington, DC 20219.

Instructions: You must include

‘‘OCC’’ as the agency name and ‘‘Docket

ID OCC–2017–0011’’ in your comment.

In general, OCC will enter all comments

received into the docket and publish

them on the Regulations.gov Web site

without change, including any business

or personal information that you

provide such as name and address

information, email addresses, or phone

numbers. Comments received, including

attachments and other supporting

materials, are part of the public record

and subject to public disclosure. Do not

enclose any information in your

comment or supporting materials that

you consider confidential or

inappropriate for public disclosure

r personal information that you

provide such as name and address

information, email addresses, or phone

numbers. Comments received, including

attachments and other supporting

materials, are part of the public record

and subject to public disclosure. Do not

enclose any information in your

comment or supporting materials that

you consider confidential or

inappropriate for public disclosure.

You may review comments and other

related materials that pertain to this

proposed rule by any of the following

methods:

• Viewing Comments Electronically:

Go to www.regulations.gov. Enter

‘‘Docket ID OCC–2017–0011’’ in the

Search box and click ‘‘Search.’’ Click on

‘‘Open Docket Folder’’ on the right side

of the screen and then ‘‘Comments.’’

Comments can be filtered by clicking on

‘‘View All’’ and then using the filtering

tools on the left side of the screen.

• Click on the ‘‘Help’’ tab on the

Regulations.gov home page to get

information on using Regulations.gov.

Supporting materials may be viewed by

clicking on ‘‘Open Docket Folder’’ and

then clicking on ‘‘Supporting

Documents.’’ The docket may be viewed

after the close of the comment period in

the same manner as during the comment

period.

• Viewing Comments Personally: You

may personally inspect and photocopy

comments at the OCC, 400 7th Street

SW., Washington, DC. For security

reasons, the OCC requires that visitors

make an appointment to inspect

comments. You may do so by calling

on ‘‘Supporting

Documents.’’ The docket may be viewed

after the close of the comment period in

the same manner as during the comment

period.

• Viewing Comments Personally: You

may personally inspect and photocopy

comments at the OCC, 400 7th Street

SW., Washington, DC. For security

reasons, the OCC requires that visitors

make an appointment to inspect

comments. You may do so by calling

(202) 649–6700 or, for persons who are

deaf or hard of hearing, TTY, (202) 649–

5597. Upon arrival, visitors will be

required to present valid government-

issued photo identification and to

submit to security screening in order to

inspect and photocopy comments.

Board of Governors of the Federal

Reserve System: You may submit

comments, identified by [Docket No. R–

1568 and RIN 7100 AE–81], by any of

the following methods:

• Agency Web site: http://

www.federalreserve.gov. Follow the

instructions for submitting comments at

http://www.federalreserve.gov/

generalinfo/foia/ProposedRegs.cfm.

• Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://

www.regulations.gov. Follow the

instructions for submitting comments.

• Email: regs.comments@

federalreserve.gov. Include the docket

number and RIN number in the subject

line of the message.

• Fax: (202) 452–3819 or (202) 452–

3102.

• Mail: Address to Ann E. Misback,

Secretary, Board of Governors of the

Federal Reserve System, 20th Street and

Constitution Avenue NW., Washington,

DC 20551.

All public comments will be made

available on the Board’s Web site at

http://www.federalreserve.gov/

generalinfo/foia/ProposedRegs.cfm as

submitted, unless modified for technical

reasons. Accordingly, comments will

not be edited to remove any identifying

or contact information. Public

comments may also be viewed

electronically or in paper form in Room

3515, 1801 K Street NW. (between 18th

and 19th Streets NW.), Washington, DC

20006 between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.

on weekdays

serve.gov/

generalinfo/foia/ProposedRegs.cfm as

submitted, unless modified for technical

reasons. Accordingly, comments will

not be edited to remove any identifying

or contact information. Public

comments may also be viewed

electronically or in paper form in Room

3515, 1801 K Street NW. (between 18th

and 19th Streets NW.), Washington, DC

20006 between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.

on weekdays.

Federal Deposit Insurance

Corporation: You may submit

comments, identified by RIN 3064–

AE56, by any of the following methods:

• Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://

www.regulations.gov. Follow the

instructions for submitting comments.

• Agency Web site: http://

www.FDIC.gov/regulations/laws/

federal/propose.html.

• Mail: Robert E. Feldman, Executive

Secretary, Attention: Comments/Legal

ESS, Federal Deposit Insurance

Corporation, 550 17th Street NW.,

Washington, DC 20429.

• Hand Delivered/Courier: The guard

station at the rear of the 550 17th Street

Building (located on F Street) on

business days between 7:00 a.m. and

5:00 p.m.

• Email: Comments@FDIC.gov.

Comments submitted must include

‘‘FDIC’’ and ‘‘Real Estate Appraisals.’’

Comments received will be posted

without change to http://www.fdic.gov/

regulations/laws/federal/propose.html

including any personal information

provided.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

OCC: G. Kevin Lawton, Appraiser

(Real Estate Specialist), (202) 649–7152,

Mitchell E. Plave, Special Counsel,

Legislative and Regulatory Activities

Division, (202) 649–5490, for persons

who are deaf or hard of hearing, TTY,

be posted

without change to http://www.fdic.gov/

regulations/laws/federal/propose.html

including any personal information

provided.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

OCC: G. Kevin Lawton, Appraiser

(Real Estate Specialist), (202) 649–7152,

Mitchell E. Plave, Special Counsel,

Legislative and Regulatory Activities

Division, (202) 649–5490, for persons

who are deaf or hard of hearing, TTY,

(202) 649–5597, or Christopher

Manthey, Special Counsel, or Joanne

Phillips, Attorney, Bank Activities and

Structure Division, (202) 649–5500,

Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency, 400 7th Street SW.,

Washington, DC 20219.

Board: Anna Lee Hewko, Associate

Director, (202) 530–6260, or Carmen

Holly, Senior Supervisory Financial

Analyst, (202) 973–6122, Division of

Supervision and Regulation; or Gillian

Burgess, Senior Counsel, (202) 736–

5564, Matthew Suntag, Senior Attorney,

(202) 452–3694, or Kirin Walsh,

Attorney, (202) 452–3058, Legal

Division, Board of Governors of the

Federal Reserve System, 20th and C

Streets NW., Washington, DC 20551.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00012

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35480

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

1 12 U.S.C. 3331 et seq.

2 ‘‘Federal financial institutions regulatory

agency’’ means the Board, the FDIC, the OCC, the

National Credit Union Association (NCUA), and,

formerly, the Office of Thrift Supervision. 12 U.S.C.

3350(6).

3 These interests include those stemming from the

federal government’s roles as regulator and deposit

insurer of financial institutions that engage in real

estate lending and investment, guarantor or lender

on mortgage loans, and as a direct party in real

estate-related financial transactions. These federal

financial and public policy interests have been

described in predecessor legislation and

accompanying Congressional reports

from the

federal government’s roles as regulator and deposit

insurer of financial institutions that engage in real

estate lending and investment, guarantor or lender

on mortgage loans, and as a direct party in real

estate-related financial transactions. These federal

financial and public policy interests have been

described in predecessor legislation and

accompanying Congressional reports. See Real

Estate Appraisal Reform Act of 1988, H.R. Rep. No.

100–1001, pt. 1, at 19 (1988); 133 Cong. Rec. 33047–

33048 (1987).

4 12 U.S.C. 3331.

5 12 U.S.C. 3339. The agencies’ Title XI appraisal

regulations apply to transactions entered into by the

agencies or by institutions regulated by the agencies

that are depository institutions or bank holding

companies or subsidiaries of depository institutions

or bank holding companies. OCC: 12 CFR part 34,

subpart C; Board: 12 CFR 225.61(b); 12 CFR part

208, subpart E; FDIC: 12 CFR part 323.

6 USPAP is written and interpreted by the

Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal

Foundation. Adopted by Congress in 1989, USPAP

contains generally recognized ethical and

performance standards for the appraisal profession

in the United States, including real estate, personal

property, and business appraisals. See http://

www.appraisalfoundation.org/imis/TAF/Standards/

Appraisal_Standards/Uniform_Standards_of_

Professional_Appraisal_Practice/TAF/

USPAP.aspx?hkey=a6420a67-dbfa-41b3-9878-

fac35923d2af.

7 12 U.S.C. 3350(4) (defining ‘‘federally related

transaction’’).

8 12 U.S.C. 3350(5).

9 See 59 FR 29482 (June 7, 1994).

10 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(a); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a).

11 Housing and Community Development Act of

1992, Public Law 102–550, sec. 954, 106 Stat. 3894

(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341).

12 Public Law 111–203, 124 Stat.1376.

13 Dodd-Frank Act, sec. 1473, 124 Stat. 2190

(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)).

14 See 59 FR 29482 (June 7, 1994). The NCUA

promulgated a similar rule with similar thresholds

in 1995

(a); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(a); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a).

11 Housing and Community Development Act of

1992, Public Law 102–550, sec. 954, 106 Stat. 3894

(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341).

12 Public Law 111–203, 124 Stat.1376.

13 Dodd-Frank Act, sec. 1473, 124 Stat. 2190

(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)).

14 See 59 FR 29482 (June 7, 1994). The NCUA

promulgated a similar rule with similar thresholds

in 1995. 60 FR 51889 (October 4, 1995).

15 For loans and extensions of credit, the

transaction value is the amount of the loan or

extension of credit. For sales, leases, purchases,

investments in or exchanges of real property, the

transaction value is the market value of the real

property. For the pooling of loans or interests in

real property for resale or purchase, the transaction

value is the amount of each such loan or the market

value of each such real property, respectively. See

OCC: 12 CFR 34.42(m); Board: 12 CFR 225.62(m);

FDIC: CFR 323.2(m).

16 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(1) and (5); Board: 12

CFR 225.63(a)(1) and (5); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(1)

and (5).

17 OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(5); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(a)(5); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(5).

18 Transactions that involve an existing extension

of credit at the lending institution are exempt from

the Title XI appraisal requirements, but are required

to have evaluations, provided that there has been

no obvious and material change in market

conditions or physical aspects of the property that

threatens the adequacy of the institution’s real

estate collateral protection after the transaction,

even with the advancement of new monies; or there

is no advancement of new monies, other than funds

necessary to cover reasonable closing costs. See

OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(7) and (b); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(a)(7) and (b); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(7) and

ons or physical aspects of the property that

threatens the adequacy of the institution’s real

estate collateral protection after the transaction,

even with the advancement of new monies; or there

is no advancement of new monies, other than funds

necessary to cover reasonable closing costs. See

OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(7) and (b); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(a)(7) and (b); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(7) and

(b).

FDIC: Beverlea S. Gardner, Senior

Examination Specialist, Division of Risk

Management and Supervision, at (202)

898–3640, Mark Mellon, Counsel, Legal

Division, at (202) 898–3884, Kimberly

Stock, Counsel, Legal Division, at (202)

898–3815, Benjamin K. Gibbs, Counsel,

at (202) 898–6726, or Lauren Whitaker,

Senior Attorney, at (202) 898–3872,

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation,

550 17th Street NW., Washington, DC

20429.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Introduction

A. Background

Title XI of the Financial Institutions

Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act

of 1989 (Title XI) 1 directs each federal

financial institutions regulatory agency 2

to publish appraisal regulations for

federally related transactions within its

jurisdiction. The purpose of Title XI is

to protect federal financial and public

policy interests 3 in real estate-related

transactions by requiring that real estate

appraisals used in connection with

federally related transactions (Title XI

appraisals) be performed in accordance

with uniform standards, by individuals

whose competency has been

demonstrated and whose professional

conduct will be subject to effective

supervision.4

Title XI directs the agencies to

prescribe appropriate standards for Title

XI appraisals under the agencies’

respective jurisdictions,5 including, at a

minimum, that Title XI appraisals be:

itle XI

appraisals) be performed in accordance

with uniform standards, by individuals

whose competency has been

demonstrated and whose professional

conduct will be subject to effective

supervision.4

Title XI directs the agencies to

prescribe appropriate standards for Title

XI appraisals under the agencies’

respective jurisdictions,5 including, at a

minimum, that Title XI appraisals be:

(1) Performed in accordance with the

Uniform Standards of Professional

Appraisal Practice (USPAP); 6 (2)

written appraisals, as defined by the

statute; and (3) subject to appropriate

review for compliance with USPAP. All

federally related transactions must have

Title XI appraisals.

Title XI defines a ‘‘federally related

transaction’’ as a real estate-related

financial transaction that is regulated or

engaged in by a federal financial

institutions regulatory agency and

requires the services of an appraiser.7 A

real estate-related financial transaction

is defined as any transaction that

involves: (i) The sale, lease, purchase,

investment in or exchange of real

property, including interests in

property, or financing thereof; (ii) the

refinancing of real property or interests

in real property; and (iii) the use of real

property or interests in real property as

security for a loan or investment,

including mortgage-backed securities.8

The agencies have authority to

determine those real estate-related

financial transactions that do not

require the services of a certified or

licensed appraiser and are therefore

exempt from the appraisal requirements

of Title XI

in real property; and (iii) the use of real

property or interests in real property as

security for a loan or investment,

including mortgage-backed securities.8

The agencies have authority to

determine those real estate-related

financial transactions that do not

require the services of a certified or

licensed appraiser and are therefore

exempt from the appraisal requirements

of Title XI. These real estate-related

financial transactions are not federally

related transactions under the statutory

or regulatory definitions because they

are not required to have Title XI

appraisals.9

The agencies have exercised this

authority by exempting several

categories of real estate-related financial

transactions from the appraisal

requirements.10 The agencies have

determined that these categories of

transactions do not require appraisals by

state certified or licensed appraisers in

order to protect federal financial and

public policy interests or to satisfy

principles of safe and sound banking.

In 1992, Congress amended Title XI,

expressly authorizing the agencies to

establish a threshold level at or below

which an appraisal by a state certified

or licensed appraiser is not required in

connection with federally related

transactions if the agencies determine in

writing that the threshold does not

represent a threat to the safety and

soundness of financial institutions.11 In

the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and

Consumer Protection Act (the Dodd-

Frank Act),12 Congress amended the

threshold provision to require

concurrence ‘‘from the Bureau of

Consumer Financial Protection that

such threshold level provides

reasonable protection for consumers

who purchase 1–4 unit single-family

residences.’’ 13 As noted above,

transactions at or below the threshold

level are exempt from the Title XI

appraisal requirements and thus are not

federally related transactions

mended the

threshold provision to require

concurrence ‘‘from the Bureau of

Consumer Financial Protection that

such threshold level provides

reasonable protection for consumers

who purchase 1–4 unit single-family

residences.’’ 13 As noted above,

transactions at or below the threshold

level are exempt from the Title XI

appraisal requirements and thus are not

federally related transactions.

Under the current thresholds, which

were established by rulemaking in

1994,14 all real estate-related financial

transactions with a transaction value 15

of $250,000 or less, as well as certain

real estate-secured business loans

(qualifying business loans) with a

transaction value of $1 million or less,

do not require appraisals.16 Qualifying

business loans are business loans that

are real estate-related financial

transactions and that are not dependent

on the sale of, or rental income derived

from, real estate as the primary source

of repayment.17

For real estate-related financial

transactions that are exempt from the

appraisal requirement because they are

within the applicable thresholds or

qualify for the exemption for certain

existing extensions of credit,18 the

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00013

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35481

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

19 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(b); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(b); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(b).

20 75 FR 77450 (Dec. 10, 2010). See also

Interagency Advisory on the Use of Evaluations in

Real Estate-Related Financial Transactions, OCC

Bulletin 2016–8 (March 4, 2016); Board SR Letter

16–5 (March 4, 2016); Supervisory Expectations for

Evaluations, FDIC FIL–16–2016 (March 4, 2016).

21 Public Law 104–208, Div. A, Title II, sec. 2222,

110 Stat. 3009–414, (1996) (codified at 12 U.S.C.

3311)

0 75 FR 77450 (Dec. 10, 2010). See also

Interagency Advisory on the Use of Evaluations in

Real Estate-Related Financial Transactions, OCC

Bulletin 2016–8 (March 4, 2016); Board SR Letter

16–5 (March 4, 2016); Supervisory Expectations for

Evaluations, FDIC FIL–16–2016 (March 4, 2016).

21 Public Law 104–208, Div. A, Title II, sec. 2222,

110 Stat. 3009–414, (1996) (codified at 12 U.S.C.

3311). The FFIEC is an interagency body comprised

of the Board, OCC, FDIC, NCUA, Bureau of

Consumer Financial Protection (CFPB) and State

Liaison Committee. Of these, only the Board, OCC

and FDIC are statutorily required to undertake the

EGRPRA review. The FFIEC does not issue

regulations that impose burden on financial

institutions and therefore its regulations were not

included in the EGRPRA review. The NCUA is not

required to participate in the EGRPRA review, but

elected to review its regulations pursuant to the

goals of EGRPRA, as it did during the agencies’ first

EGRPRA review 10 years ago. Accordingly, the

NCUA participated in the recent EGRPRA review

process with the Board, OCC and FDIC. The results

of the NCUA’s review are included in Part II of the

EGRPRA Report, described below. The CFPB is

required to review its significant rules and publish

a report of its review no later than five years after

the rules takes effect. See 12 U.S.C. 5512(d).

22 Earlier this year, the agencies and the NCUA

issued an advisory on appraiser availability that

points to alternatives that may help in areas facing

a shortage of appraisers. Interagency Advisory on

the Availability of Appraisers. See OCC Bulletin

2017–19 (May 31, 2017); Board SR Letter 17–4 (May

31, 2017); FDIC FIL–19–2017 (May 31, 2017).

23 FFIEC, Joint Report to Congress: Economic

Growth and Regulatory Paperwork Reduction Act,

(March 2017), (EGRPRA Report), available at

https://www.ffiec.gov/pdf/2017_FFIEC_EGRPRA_

Joint-Report_to_Congress.pdf

e of appraisers. Interagency Advisory on

the Availability of Appraisers. See OCC Bulletin

2017–19 (May 31, 2017); Board SR Letter 17–4 (May

31, 2017); FDIC FIL–19–2017 (May 31, 2017).

23 FFIEC, Joint Report to Congress: Economic

Growth and Regulatory Paperwork Reduction Act,

(March 2017), (EGRPRA Report), available at

https://www.ffiec.gov/pdf/2017_FFIEC_EGRPRA_

Joint-Report_to_Congress.pdf.

24 The $250,000 threshold in the current Title XI

appraisal regulations applies, by its terms, to all real

estate-related financial transactions, whether or not

the borrower is a consumer.

25 Other Federal Government agencies involved

in the residential mortgage market include the U.S.

Department of Housing and Urban Development

(HUD), the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, and

the Rural Housing Service of the U.S. Department

of Agriculture. These agencies, along with the GSEs

(which are regulated by the Federal Housing

Finance Agency (FHFA)), have the authority to set

separate appraisal requirements for loans they

originate, acquire, or guarantee, and generally

require an appraisal by a certified or licensed

appraiser for residential mortgages regardless of the

loan amount.

26 See FFIEC, Home Mortgage Disclosure Act,

www.ffiec.gov/hmda/.

27 The agencies posited in the 1994 amendments

to the Title XI appraisal regulations that the timing

of the appraisal may provide limited consumer

protection. Changes to consumer protection

regulations since 1994 now ensure that a consumer

receives a copy of appraisals and other valuations

used by a creditor to make a credit decision at least

three business days before consummation of the

transaction (for closed-end credit) or account

opening (for open-end credit). See 12 CFR 1002.14

(for business or consumer credit secured by a first

lien on a dwelling).

28 15 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.

29 Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111–203, Title

XIV, sec. 1473(a), 124 Stat. 2190 (2010), (codified

at 12 U.S.C

itor to make a credit decision at least

three business days before consummation of the

transaction (for closed-end credit) or account

opening (for open-end credit). See 12 CFR 1002.14

(for business or consumer credit secured by a first

lien on a dwelling).

28 15 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.

29 Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111–203, Title

XIV, sec. 1473(a), 124 Stat. 2190 (2010), (codified

at 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)), as discussed earlier in this

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION.

30 ‘‘Higher-risk mortgages’’ are certain mortgages

with an annual percentage rate that exceeds the

average prime offer rate by a specified percentage.

See Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111–203, Title

XIV, sec. 1471, 124 Stat. 2185 (2010), which added

section 129H to TILA, (codified at 15 U.S.C. 1639h).

Continued

appraisal regulations require financial

institutions to obtain an evaluation of

the real property collateral that is

consistent with safe and sound banking

practices.19 An evaluation should

contain sufficient information and

analysis to support the financial

institution’s decision to engage in the

transaction. However, evaluations need

not be performed in accordance with

USPAP or by certified or licensed

appraisers. The agencies have provided

supervisory guidance for conducting

evaluations in a safe and sound manner

in the Interagency Appraisal and

Evaluation Guidelines (Guidelines).20

B. The EGRPRA Process

In early 2017, the agencies completed

a review of their regulations pursuant to

EGRPRA, which requires that, not less

than once every 10 years, the Federal

Financial Institutions Examination

Council (FFIEC), Board, OCC, and FDIC

conduct a review of their regulations to

identify outdated or otherwise

unnecessary regulatory requirements

imposed on insured depository

institutions (IDIs).21

As part of the EGRPRA review, the

agencies received numerous comments

from bankers, banking trade

associations, associations of appraisers,

and other commenters related to the

Title XI appraisal regulations

Board, OCC, and FDIC

conduct a review of their regulations to

identify outdated or otherwise

unnecessary regulatory requirements

imposed on insured depository

institutions (IDIs).21

As part of the EGRPRA review, the

agencies received numerous comments

from bankers, banking trade

associations, associations of appraisers,

and other commenters related to the

Title XI appraisal regulations. These

comments included recommendations

to increase the thresholds at or below

which real estate-related financial

transactions are exempt from the Title

XI appraisal requirements. Some

commenters noted that the current

thresholds have not been adjusted since

they were established in 1994, even

though property values have increased,

and that the time and cost associated

with the appraisal process impose an

unnecessary burden in the completion

of smaller-dollar amount real estate-

related transactions. Some commenters

also argued that the time and financial

costs attributed to meeting the appraisal

requirements at the current threshold

levels particularly affect banks in rural

markets. These commenters contended

that it is often difficult to find state

certified and licensed appraisers to

complete assignments for properties in

rural areas.22

In March 2017, the agencies

submitted a joint EGRPRA report to

Congress (EGRPRA Report) that

identified potential initiatives to reduce

regulatory burden.23 In the EGRPRA

Report, the agencies addressed

comments received concerning the

appraisal thresholds and stated that the

agencies would propose an increase to

the threshold for commercial real estate

transactions from $250,000 to

$400,000.24 Section II of this

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION invites

comments on this proposed increase

dentified potential initiatives to reduce

regulatory burden.23 In the EGRPRA

Report, the agencies addressed

comments received concerning the

appraisal thresholds and stated that the

agencies would propose an increase to

the threshold for commercial real estate

transactions from $250,000 to

$400,000.24 Section II of this

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION invites

comments on this proposed increase.

The agencies also stated their intention

to gather more information about the

appropriateness of increasing the $1

million threshold for qualifying

business loans, which is being done

through a request for comment in

Section III of the SUPPLEMENTARY

INFORMATION.

In the EGRPRA Report, the agencies

also addressed whether it would be

appropriate to increase the current

$250,000 threshold for transactions

secured by residential real estate. The

agencies determined that it would not

be appropriate to increase the threshold

for this category of transactions at this

time based on three considerations.

First, the agencies observed that any

increase in the threshold for residential

transactions would have a limited

impact on burden, as appraisals would

still be required for the vast majority of

these transactions pursuant to rules of

other federal government agencies and

the government-sponsored enterprises

(GSEs).25 As reflected in the 2015 Home

Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA)

data,26 at least 90 percent of residential

mortgage loan originations had loan

amounts at or below the threshold, were

eligible for sale to GSEs, or were insured

by the Federal Housing Administration

or the United States Department of

Veterans Affairs. Those transactions are

not subject to the Title XI appraisal

regulations, but the majority of those

transactions are subject to the appraisal

requirements of other government

agencies or the GSEs. Therefore, raising

the appraisal threshold for residential

transactions in the Title XI appraisal

regulations would have limited impact

on burden

e United States Department of

Veterans Affairs. Those transactions are

not subject to the Title XI appraisal

regulations, but the majority of those

transactions are subject to the appraisal

requirements of other government

agencies or the GSEs. Therefore, raising

the appraisal threshold for residential

transactions in the Title XI appraisal

regulations would have limited impact

on burden.

Second, appraisals can provide

protection to consumers by helping to

assure the residential purchaser that the

value of the property supports the

purchase price and the mortgage

amount.27 The consumer protection role

of appraisals is reflected in amendments

made to Title XI and the Truth in

Lending Act (TILA) 28 through the

Dodd-Frank Act governing the scope of

transactions requiring the services of a

certified or licensed appraiser. These

include the addition of the CFPB to the

group of agencies assigned a role in the

appraisal threshold-setting process for

Title XI,29 and a new TILA provision

requiring appraisals for loans involving

‘‘higher-risk mortgages.’’ 30

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00014

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35482

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

See also Appraisals for Higher-Priced Mortgage

Loans, 78 FR 78520 (December 26, 2013)

(interagency rule implementing appraisal

requirements for higher-priced mortgage loans).

31 The agencies have coordinated with the NCUA

in developing this proposal. The agencies

understand that the NCUA is evaluating options to

develop a separate proposal to provide comparable

relief for federally insured credit unions.

32 The Riegle Community Development and

Regulatory Improvement Act of 1994, Public Law

103–325, 108 Stat

aisal

requirements for higher-priced mortgage loans).

31 The agencies have coordinated with the NCUA

in developing this proposal. The agencies

understand that the NCUA is evaluating options to

develop a separate proposal to provide comparable

relief for federally insured credit unions.

32 The Riegle Community Development and

Regulatory Improvement Act of 1994, Public Law

103–325, 108 Stat. 2163 (Riegle Act) provides that

rules imposing additional reporting, disclosures, or

other new requirements on IDIs generally must take

effect on the first day of a calendar quarter that

begins on or after the date on which the regulations

are published in final form. 12 U.S.C. 4802(b). As

discussed further in the Section IV of the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, the proposed rule

does not impose any new requirements on IDIs,

and, as such, the effective date requirement of the

Riegle Act is inapplicable. Additionally, the 30-day

delayed effective date required under the

Administrative Procedure Act (APA) is waived

pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 553(d)(1), which provides a

waiver when a substantive rule grants or recognizes

an exception or relieves a restriction. The proposed

rule would exempt certain transactions from the

Title XI appraisal requirements. Consequently, the

proposed rule meets the requirements for waiver set

forth in the APA.

33 A 1-to-4 family residential property is a

property containing one, two, three, or four

individual dwelling units, including manufactured

homes permanently affixed to the underlying land

(when deemed to be real property under state law).

See OCC: 12 CFR part 34, subpart D, appendix A;

Board: 12 CFR part 208, appendix C; FDIC: 12 CFR

part 365, subpart A, appendix A.

34 The second part of the definition is intended

to clarify, not be an exception to, the first part.

35 ‘‘Initial construction’’ refers to construction of

a new dwelling, as opposed to improvements on an

existing dwelling

ed to be real property under state law).

See OCC: 12 CFR part 34, subpart D, appendix A;

Board: 12 CFR part 208, appendix C; FDIC: 12 CFR

part 365, subpart A, appendix A.

34 The second part of the definition is intended

to clarify, not be an exception to, the first part.

35 ‘‘Initial construction’’ refers to construction of

a new dwelling, as opposed to improvements on an

existing dwelling. This is intended to be consistent

with the meaning of this phrase in provisions of

TILA and its implementing regulation, Regulation

Z. See, e.g., 15 U.S.C. 1602(x); 12 CFR 1026.2(a)(24).

36 The agencies propose to exclude consumer

‘‘construction-to-permanent’’ loans because these

loans are, in effect, for the purchase of 1-to-4 family

residential property, which would otherwise be

subject to the $250,000 threshold. This carve-out for

construction-to-permanent financing would avoid

the anomaly of requiring appraisals for permanent

financing of 1-to-4 family residential properties

above $250,000 while allowing an evaluation for

permanent financing (at or below $400,000) that is

preceded by a construction phrase.

37 See https://www.ffiec.gov/pdf/FFIEC_forms/

FFIEC031_201703_f.pdf.

During the EGRPRA process, the staff

of the agencies conferred with the CFPB

regarding comments the agencies

received supporting an increase in the

threshold for 1-to-4 family residential

transactions. CFPB staff shared the view

that appraisals can provide consumer

protection benefits and their concern

about potential risks to consumers

resulting from an expansion of the

number of residential mortgage

transactions that would be exempt from

the Title XI appraisal requirement.

Third, the agencies considered safety

and soundness concerns that could

result from a threshold increase for

residential transactions. As the EGRPRA

Report noted, the 2008 financial crisis

showed that, like other asset classes,

imprudent residential mortgage lending

can pose significant risks to financial

institutions

sactions that would be exempt from

the Title XI appraisal requirement.

Third, the agencies considered safety

and soundness concerns that could

result from a threshold increase for

residential transactions. As the EGRPRA

Report noted, the 2008 financial crisis

showed that, like other asset classes,

imprudent residential mortgage lending

can pose significant risks to financial

institutions.

For these reasons, the agencies

concluded in the EGRPRA Report that a

change to the current $250,000

threshold for residential mortgage loans

would not be appropriate at the present

time. The agencies are interested in

comment on whether there are other

factors that should be considered in

evaluating the current threshold for 1-

to-4 family residential transactions and

whether the threshold can and should

be raised, consistent with consumer

protection, safety and soundness, and

reduction of unnecessary regulatory

burden. The agencies will also continue

to consider possibilities for relieving

burden related to appraisals for

residential mortgage loans, such as

coordination of the agencies’ Title XI

appraisal regulations with the practices

of HUD, the GSEs, and other federal

participants in the residential real estate

market.

II. Revisions to the Title XI Appraisal

Regulations

A. Threshold Increase for Commercial

Real Estate Transactions

Overview of Proposal

The agencies propose to amend the

Title XI appraisal regulations to increase

the monetary threshold for commercial

real estate transactions at or below

which a Title XI appraisal would not be

required.31 The proposal would

establish a separate threshold for

commercial real estate transactions of

$400,000, which represents an increase

from the current threshold of $250,000

for all real estate-related financial

transactions

itle XI appraisal regulations to increase

the monetary threshold for commercial

real estate transactions at or below

which a Title XI appraisal would not be

required.31 The proposal would

establish a separate threshold for

commercial real estate transactions of

$400,000, which represents an increase

from the current threshold of $250,000

for all real estate-related financial

transactions.

In considering whether to propose an

increased threshold for commercial real

estate transactions, the agencies

considered the comments received

through the EGRPRA process, and took

into account whether changes to the

threshold would be appropriate to

reduce regulatory burden consistent

with the federal financial and public

policy interests in real estate-related

financial transactions and the safety and

soundness of regulated institutions.

As stated, the threshold for exempt

transactions was last modified in 1994.

Given increases in commercial property

values since that time, the current

threshold requires institutions to obtain

Title XI appraisals on a larger

proportion of commercial real estate

transactions than in 1994. This increase

in the number of appraisals required

may contribute to the increased burden

in time and cost described by the

EGRPRA commenters.

Based on supervisory experience and

available data, the agencies propose to

increase the threshold for commercial

real estate transactions, as defined

below, to $400,000. This proposal

would reduce burden for both rural and

non-rural institutions and, as discussed

below, would not pose a threat to the

safety and soundness of financial

institutions. The agencies are consulting

with the CFPB regarding this proposal

and will continue this consultation in

developing a final rule.

The agencies propose to make the

proposal, if adopted, effective on

publication of the final rule in the

Federal Register.32

Question 1

-rural institutions and, as discussed

below, would not pose a threat to the

safety and soundness of financial

institutions. The agencies are consulting

with the CFPB regarding this proposal

and will continue this consultation in

developing a final rule.

The agencies propose to make the

proposal, if adopted, effective on

publication of the final rule in the

Federal Register.32

Question 1. The agencies invite

comment on the proposed effective date,

including whether this time period is

appropriate and, if not, why.

Definition of Commercial Real Estate

Transaction

The proposed $400,000 threshold

would apply only to transactions

defined as ‘‘commercial real estate

transactions.’’ Under the proposed

definition, a commercial real estate

transaction would include any ‘‘real

estate-related financial transaction,’’ as

defined in the Title XI appraisal

regulations, excluding any loans

secured by a 1-to-4 family residential

property,33 but including loans that

finance the construction of buildings

with 1-to-4 dwelling units and that do

not include permanent financing.34

Accordingly, the definition would

include a loan extended to a consumer

to finance the initial construction 35 of

the consumer’s dwelling, but exclude

loans that provide both initial

construction funding and permanent

financing.36

The proposed definition would

largely capture the following four

categories of loans secured by real estate

in the Consolidated Reports of

Condition and Income (Call Report) 37

(FFIEC 031; RCFD 1410), namely loans

that are: (1) For construction, land

development, and other land loans; (2)

secured by farmland; (3) secured by

residential properties with five or more

units; or (4) secured by nonfarm

nonresidential properties. However,

loans that provide both initial

construction funding and permanent

financing and are reported as

construction, land development, and

other land loans during the construction

phase would be excluded from the

definition

and other land loans; (2)

secured by farmland; (3) secured by

residential properties with five or more

units; or (4) secured by nonfarm

nonresidential properties. However,

loans that provide both initial

construction funding and permanent

financing and are reported as

construction, land development, and

other land loans during the construction

phase would be excluded from the

definition.

The definition generally aligns with

the categories of transactions to which

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00015

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35483

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

38 Real Estate Lending: Interagency Statement on

Prudent Risk Management for Commercial Real

Estate Lending, OCC Bulletin 2015–51 (December

18, 2015); Statement on Prudent Risk Management

for Commercial Real Estate Lending, Board SR

Letter 15–17 (December 18, 2015); Statement on

Prudent Risk Management for CRE Lending, FDIC

FIL–62–2015 (December 18, 2015); Guidance on

Prudent Loan Workouts, OCC Bulletin 2009–32

(October 30, 2009); Policy Statement on Prudent

Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts, Board SR

Letter 09–07 (October 30, 2009); Policy Statement

on Prudent Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts,

FDIC FIL–61–2009 (October 30, 2009);

Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending,

Sound Risk Management Practices, 71 FR 74580

(December 12, 2006)

n

Prudent Loan Workouts, OCC Bulletin 2009–32

(October 30, 2009); Policy Statement on Prudent

Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts, Board SR

Letter 09–07 (October 30, 2009); Policy Statement

on Prudent Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts,

FDIC FIL–61–2009 (October 30, 2009);

Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending,

Sound Risk Management Practices, 71 FR 74580

(December 12, 2006).

39 78 FR 10368 (February 13, 2013) (exempting

transactions to finance the initial construction of a

dwelling from the higher-priced mortgage appraisal

rule); 78 FR 4725 (January 22, 2013) (exempting

transactions to finance the initial construction of a

dwelling from the higher-priced mortgage escrow

requirements); 78 FR 6408 (January 30, 2013)

(exempting transactions to finance the initial

construction of a dwelling from the ability-to-repay

requirements); 78 FR 6856 (January 31, 2013)

(exempting transactions to finance the initial

construction of a dwelling from the high-cost

mortgage loan term restrictions and disclosure

requirements in the Home Ownership and Equity

Protections Act); 76 FR 79772 (December 22, 2011)

(exempting loans with maturity of 12 months or less

for the construction primary dwelling from the

balloon payment limitations).

40 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(d); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(d)(2); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(d)(2). The

agencies have long subjected such loans to this

requirement, as opposed to permitting licensed

appraisers, which is the case for typical 1-to-4

family residential properties.

41 See series RCFD F158 and F159.

42 The Board publishes data on the flow of funds

and levels of financial assets and liabilities, by

sector and financial instrument; full balance sheets,

including net worth, for households and nonprofit

organizations, nonfinancial corporate businesses,

and nonfinancial noncorporate businesses;

Integrated Macroeconomic Accounts; and

additional supplemental detail

series RCFD F158 and F159.

42 The Board publishes data on the flow of funds

and levels of financial assets and liabilities, by

sector and financial instrument; full balance sheets,

including net worth, for households and nonprofit

organizations, nonfinancial corporate businesses,

and nonfinancial noncorporate businesses;

Integrated Macroeconomic Accounts; and

additional supplemental detail. See, Board of

Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Financial

Accounts of the United States, https://

www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/current/

default.htm.

43 The CRE Index is quarterly and not seasonally

adjusted. See Board of Governors of the Federal

Reserve System, Series analyzer for

FL075035503.Q, https://www.federalreserve.gov/

apps/fof/SeriesAnalyzer

.aspx?s=FL075035503&t=&bc=:FI075035503,

FL075035503&suf=Q; Board of Governors of the

Federal Reserve System, Series Structure, https://

www.federalreserve.gov/apps/fof/

SeriesStructure.aspx.

44 Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve

System, Series analyzer for FL075035503.Q, https://

www.federalreserve.gov/apps/fof/SeriesAnalyzer

.aspx?s=FL075035503&t=&bc=:FI075035503,

FL075035503&suf=Q. Data for years prior to 1996

are comprised of a weighted average of three

appraisal-based commercial property series from

National Real Estate Investor. Id.

45 CoStar, Federal Reserve’s Flow of Funds to

Incorporate CoStar Group’s Price Indices, CoStar

(June 4, 2012), http://www.costar.com/News/

Article/Federal-Reserves-Flow-of-Funds-To-

Incorporate-CoStar-Groups-Price-Indices/138998.

46 See id.

agency guidance on commercial real

estate lending applies.38 The agencies

are treating construction-only loans to

consumers as commercial real estate

transactions to maintain consistency

with other regulations and guidance that

address construction loans to consumers

in other contexts

/

Article/Federal-Reserves-Flow-of-Funds-To-

Incorporate-CoStar-Groups-Price-Indices/138998.

46 See id.

agency guidance on commercial real

estate lending applies.38 The agencies

are treating construction-only loans to

consumers as commercial real estate

transactions to maintain consistency

with other regulations and guidance that

address construction loans to consumers

in other contexts.

Supervisory experience indicates that

financial institutions generally

administer construction loans to

consumers in a way similar to

construction loans to businesses.

Therefore, subjecting most construction

loans to the same threshold would

minimize regulatory burden. This

treatment would also be consistent with

other mortgage-related rules, which

exempt consumer construction loans

from various consumer protection

requirements.39 The agencies believe

that promoting consistency in

definitions and structure across

different regulations can reduce

confusion and regulatory burden for

financial institutions.

Moreover, including all 1-to-4 family

residential construction-only loans in

the proposed definition of commercial

real estate transactions is consistent

with the agencies’ longstanding practice

under the Title XI appraisal regulations

of treating construction loans for 1-to-4

family residential properties as

‘‘nonresidential’’ for purposes of the

requirement that certified appraisers be

used for ‘‘nonresidential’’ federally

related transactions.40

As discussed further below, financial

institutions report information about

consumer construction loans aggregated

with other construction loans through

the Call Report.41 Thus, much of the

supervisory information that the

agencies receive, including the basis for

the analysis presented below, aggregates

consumer construction loans with other

construction loans secured by 1-to-4

residential properties.

Question 2. The agencies invite

comment on the proposed definition of

commercial real estate transaction.

Question 3

ction loans through

the Call Report.41 Thus, much of the

supervisory information that the

agencies receive, including the basis for

the analysis presented below, aggregates

consumer construction loans with other

construction loans secured by 1-to-4

residential properties.

Question 2. The agencies invite

comment on the proposed definition of

commercial real estate transaction.

Question 3. The proposed definition

of commercial real estate transaction

would include loans to consumers for

the initial construction of their dwelling

or transactions financing the

construction of any building with 1-to-

4 dwelling units, so long as the loan

does not include permanent financing,

with the effect of permitting these loans

to qualify for the higher $400,000

threshold. The agencies invite comment

on the consumer, regulatory burden,

and other implications of the proposal.

What would be the implications of not

including these loans in the definition,

which would leave the current $250,000

threshold in place?

Question 4. The agencies invite

comment on the consumer, regulatory

burden, and other implications of the

proposed exclusion of construction-to-

permanent loans from the definition of

commercial real estate transaction,

meaning that the current $250,000

threshold would apply. What would be

the implications of including

construction-to-permanent loans in the

definition of commercial real estate

transaction, thus allowing these loans to

qualify for the higher $400,000

threshold?

Threshold Increase

The agencies propose to increase the

threshold in the Title XI appraisal

regulations for commercial real estate

transactions from $250,000 to $400,000.

In determining the level of increase, the

agencies considered the change in

prices for commercial real estate

measured by the Federal Reserve

Commercial Real Estate Price Index

(‘‘CRE Index’’)

gher $400,000

threshold?

Threshold Increase

The agencies propose to increase the

threshold in the Title XI appraisal

regulations for commercial real estate

transactions from $250,000 to $400,000.

In determining the level of increase, the

agencies considered the change in

prices for commercial real estate

measured by the Federal Reserve

Commercial Real Estate Price Index

(‘‘CRE Index’’). The CRE Index 42 is a

direct measure of the changes in

commercial real estate prices in the

United States.43 The CRE Index is

comprised of data from the CoStar

Commercial Repeat Sale Index,44 which

uses repeat sale regression analysis of

1.7 million commercial property sales

records to compare the change in price

for the same property between its most

recent and previous sale transactions.45

The data incorporated into this index

covers properties across the country and

across all price ranges,46 from before

1994 through the present.

Based on a review of the CRE Index,

prices for commercial real estate have

increased since 1994, resulting in an

increased proportion of commercial real

estate transactions exceeding the

threshold level today compared to 1994.

Based on the change in the CRE Index,

a commercial property that sold for

$250,000 as of June 30, 1994 would be

expected to sell for approximately

$830,000 as of December 2016.

However, as shown below in Table 1,

the price of commercial real estate can

be particularly volatile. For example,

the CRE Index indicates a commercial

property that sold for $250,000 in 1994

would be expected to sell for

approximately $412,000 in December

2003, $711,000 in December 2007, and

$423,000 in March 2010, when

commercial real estate prices were at

their lowest point in the most recent

downturn.

In proposing to raise the commercial

real estate threshold to $400,000 the

agencies are approximating prices at the

low point of the most recent cycle,

which occurred in 2010

uld be expected to sell for

approximately $412,000 in December

2003, $711,000 in December 2007, and

$423,000 in March 2010, when

commercial real estate prices were at

their lowest point in the most recent

downturn.

In proposing to raise the commercial

real estate threshold to $400,000 the

agencies are approximating prices at the

low point of the most recent cycle,

which occurred in 2010. This more

conservative approach is appropriate

because it takes into consideration the

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00016

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35484

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

47 The CPI, which is published by the Bureau of

Labor Statistics (BLS), is a measure of the average

change over time in the prices paid by urban

consumers for a market basket of goods and

services. This series is published monthly and is

not seasonally adjusted. See U.S. Dept. of Labor

Statistics, Consumer Price Index, https://

www.bls.gov/cpi/.

48 The PCE, which is published by the Bureau of

Economic Analysis within the U.S. Department of

Commerce, is the broadest measure of the average

change over time of the price of consumer goods

and services. This series is published monthly and

is seasonally adjusted. See U.S. Department of

Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis,

Consumer Spending, https://www.bea.gov/national/

consumer_spending.htm; Federal Reserve Bank of

San Francisco, PCE Inflation Dispersion, http://

www.frbsf.org/economic-research/indicators-data/

pce-personal-consumption-expenditure-price-

index-pcepi/.

49 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)

is series is published monthly and

is seasonally adjusted. See U.S. Department of

Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis,

Consumer Spending, https://www.bea.gov/national/

consumer_spending.htm; Federal Reserve Bank of

San Francisco, PCE Inflation Dispersion, http://

www.frbsf.org/economic-research/indicators-data/

pce-personal-consumption-expenditure-price-

index-pcepi/.

49 12 U.S.C. 3341(b).

50 See, e.g., FDIC, History of the Eighties—Lessons

for the Future, Chapter 3: Commercial Real Estate

and the Banking Crises of the 1980s and Early

1990s, available at https://www.fdic.gov/bank/

historical/history/137_165.pdf; FDIC, Office of the

Inspector General, EVAL–13–002, Comprehensive

Study on the Impact of the Failure of Insured

Depository Institutions 50, Table 6 (January 2013),

available at https://www.fdicig.gov/reports13/13-

002EV.pdf.

51 Section 38(k) of the FDI Act, as amended,

provides that if the Deposit Insurance Fund incurs

a ‘‘material loss’’ with respect to an IDI, the

Inspector General of the appropriate regulator

(which for the OCC is the Inspector General of the

Department of the Treasury) shall prepare a report

to that agency, identifying the cause of failure and

reviewing the agency’s supervision of the

institution. 12 U.S.C. 1831o(k).

52 Acquisition, development and construction

refers to transactions that finance construction

projects including land, site development, and

vertical construction. This type of financing is

typically recorded in the land or construction

categories of the Call Report.

53 The agencies have examined data from a

number of different sources to evaluate the impact

of the proposed change in the appraisal threshold

on the safety and soundness of financial

institutions, as no single data source is sufficient

alone to fully analyze the impact.

volatility in actual prices of commercial

real estate over time

the land or construction

categories of the Call Report.

53 The agencies have examined data from a

number of different sources to evaluate the impact

of the proposed change in the appraisal threshold

on the safety and soundness of financial

institutions, as no single data source is sufficient

alone to fully analyze the impact.

volatility in actual prices of commercial

real estate over time.

This figure is also consistent with

general measures of inflation across the

economy since 1994, when the current

threshold of $250,000 was set. The

agencies considered general inflation

indices, including the Consumer Price

Index (CPI) 47 and the Personal

Consumption Expenditures Price Index

(PCE).48 Certain price changes tracked

by these general indices indirectly affect

commercial real estate values. For

example, the change in rents for

multifamily housing affects the value of

underlying properties, and the change

in prices of consumer products affects

the value of retail and warehouse space.

While these indices are not directly

based on changes in commercial real

estate prices, general inflation is a

component of the change in commercial

real estate values.

As indicated in the table below, when

adjusting a $250,000 basket of goods

under the CPI and PCE from 1994

dollars to 2017 dollars and using a

lowest point in the cycle adjustment for

the prices for commercial real estate

under the CRE Index, each of the

indices considered approximately tracks

the $400,000 proposed threshold.

TABLE 1—INFLATION ADJUSTMENTS OF $250,000 AT JUNE 30, 1994, FOR THE CRE INDEX; JULY 1994 FOR THE CPI

INDEX AND JULY 1, 1994, FOR THE PCE INDEX

Index source:

Index series:

Dated adjusted to

Adjusted

amount

CRE Index ..................................

Flow of Funds ................................................

December 2016 .............................................

$830,674

March 2010 ...................................................

, 1994, FOR THE CRE INDEX; JULY 1994 FOR THE CPI

INDEX AND JULY 1, 1994, FOR THE PCE INDEX

Index source:

Index series:

Dated adjusted to

Adjusted

amount

CRE Index ..................................

Flow of Funds ................................................

December 2016 .............................................

$830,674

March 2010 ....................................................

423,659

December 2007 .............................................

711,367

December 2003 .............................................

412,194

CPI ..............................................

All items, US ..................................................

March 2017 ....................................................

401,166

PCE ............................................

All products ....................................................

March 2017 ....................................................

373,706

Question 5. The agencies invite

comment on the proposed level of

$400,000 for the threshold at or below

which regulated institutions would not

be required to obtain appraisals for

commercial real estate transactions.

Question 6. How would having three

threshold levels ($250,000 for all

transactions, $400,000 for commercial

real estate transactions, and $1 million

for qualifying business loans) rather

than two threshold levels applicable to

Title XI appraisals within the appraisal

regulations affect burden to applicable

institutions?

Safety and Soundness Considerations

for Increasing the Threshold for

Commercial Real Estate Transactions

Under Title XI, the agencies may set

a threshold at or below which an

appraisal performed by a state certified

or licensed appraiser is not required if

they determine in writing that such a

threshold level does not pose a threat to

the safety and soundness of financial

institutions.49 Analysis of supervisory

experience and available data indicates

that the proposed threshold level of

$400,000 for commercial real estate

transactions would not pos

w which an

appraisal performed by a state certified

or licensed appraiser is not required if

they determine in writing that such a

threshold level does not pose a threat to

the safety and soundness of financial

institutions.49 Analysis of supervisory

experience and available data indicates

that the proposed threshold level of

$400,000 for commercial real estate

transactions would not pose a threat to

the safety and soundness of financial

institutions.

Many variables, including changing

market conditions and various loan

underwriting practices, may affect an

institution’s loss experience. The

$250,000 threshold has been applicable

to commercial real estate transactions

since 1994. Analysis of supervisory

information concerning losses on

commercial real estate transactions

suggests that faulty valuations of the

underlying real estate collateral have

not been a material cause of losses in

connection with transactions at or

below $250,000. In the last three

decades, the banking industry suffered

two crises in which poorly underwritten

and administered commercial real estate

loans were a key feature in elevated

levels of loan losses and bank failures.50

Supervisory experience and a review of

material loss reviews 51 covering those

decades suggest that larger acquisition,

construction, and development 52

transactions were more likely to be

troublesome due to the lack of

appropriate underwriting and

administration of issues unique to larger

properties, such as longer construction

periods, extended ‘‘lease up’’ periods

(the time required to lease a building

after construction), and the more

complex nature of the construction of

such properties. The agencies have no

evidence that increasing the appraisal

threshold to $400,000 for commercial

real estate transactions would materially

increase the risk of loss on such

transactions

operties, such as longer construction

periods, extended ‘‘lease up’’ periods

(the time required to lease a building

after construction), and the more

complex nature of the construction of

such properties. The agencies have no

evidence that increasing the appraisal

threshold to $400,000 for commercial

real estate transactions would materially

increase the risk of loss on such

transactions.

Coverage of the Threshold

The agencies’ analysis of available

data 53 related to commercial real estate

lending at financial institutions suggests

that an increase in the threshold would

not pose a safety and soundness risk to

financial institutions.

In order to consider the potential

impact of the proposed threshold

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00017

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35485

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

54 The agencies used data reported on Schedule

RC–C and RC–C Part II of the Call Report. Schedule

RC–C includes the dollar volume of all loans

secured by real estate, reported in the five

categories: (1) For construction, land development,

and other land loans (RCFD F158 and F159); (2)

secured by farmland (RCFD 1420); (3) secured by

residential properties with five or more units (RCFD

1460); or (4) secured by nonfarm nonresidential

properties (RCFD F160 and F161); and (5) secured

by residential properties with fewer than five

dwelling units (RCFD 1797, 5367, and 5368). As

discussed earlier in this SUPPLEMENTARY

INFORMATION, the fifth category would not be

included in the definition of commercial real estate

transaction

esidential properties with five or more units (RCFD

1460); or (4) secured by nonfarm nonresidential

properties (RCFD F160 and F161); and (5) secured

by residential properties with fewer than five

dwelling units (RCFD 1797, 5367, and 5368). As

discussed earlier in this SUPPLEMENTARY

INFORMATION, the fifth category would not be

included in the definition of commercial real estate

transaction. Schedule RC–C Part II, Loans to Small

Businesses and Farms, includes the number and

amount currently outstanding in each case reported

in groupings by loan amount of loans secured by

nonfarm, nonresidential real estate (NFNR), with

original amounts of $1,000,000 or less and loans

secured by farmland with original amounts of

$500,000 or less. Institutions do not report

information on the size of land and construction or

multifamily loans. See FFIEC, Consolidated Reports

of Condition and Income for a Bank with Domestic

and Foreign Offices—FFIEC 031, https://

www.ffiec.gov/pdf/FFIEC_forms/FFIEC031_201703_

f.pdf.

55 See FDIC, Bank Financial Reports,

Consolidated Reports of Condition and Income,

https://www.fdic.gov/regulations/resources/call/

index.html. (‘‘Every national bank, state member

bank, insured state nonmember bank, and savings

association (‘institution’) is required to file a Call

Report as of the close of business on the last day

of each calendar quarter, i.e., the report date. The

specific reporting requirements depend upon the

size of the institution, the nature of its activities,

and whether it has any foreign offices.’’).

56 Although farmland is reported by size of loan,

such loans were also excluded from the analysis,

because they comprise a very small percent of

overall commercial real estate transactions and are

unlikely to materially affect the analysis. Moreover,

the majority of farmland loans are considered

qualifying business loans and are eligible for the

higher $1,000,000 threshold

ign offices.’’).

56 Although farmland is reported by size of loan,

such loans were also excluded from the analysis,

because they comprise a very small percent of

overall commercial real estate transactions and are

unlikely to materially affect the analysis. Moreover,

the majority of farmland loans are considered

qualifying business loans and are eligible for the

higher $1,000,000 threshold.

57 The CoStar Comps database is comprised of

sales data involving commercial real estate

properties. The agencies have limited their analysis

to arms-length completed sales, where the price is

provided. The agencies have also limited the

sample to properties that were financed. Owner-

occupied properties and sales of coops and

condominiums were excluded. The sample was also

limited to existing buildings. Land includes only

raw land defined as land held for development or

held for investment.

change on safety and soundness, the

agencies considered how the coverage of

transactions exempted by the threshold

would change, both in terms of number

of transactions and aggregate value. The

agencies considered three different

metrics to estimate the overall coverage

of the existing threshold and the

proposed threshold: The number of

commercial real estate transactions at or

under the threshold as a share of the

number of all commercial real estate

transactions; the dollar volume of

commercial real estate transactions at or

under the threshold as a share of the

total dollar volume of all commercial

real estate transactions; and the dollar

volume of commercial real estate

transactions at or under the threshold

relative to IDIs’ capital and the

allowance for loan and lease losses,

which act as a buffer to absorb losses,

as explained below. The agencies

examined data reported on the Call

Report 54 and data from the CoStar

Comps database to estimate the volume

of commercial real estate transactions

covered by the existing threshold and

increased thresholds

transactions at or under the threshold

relative to IDIs’ capital and the

allowance for loan and lease losses,

which act as a buffer to absorb losses,

as explained below. The agencies

examined data reported on the Call

Report 54 and data from the CoStar

Comps database to estimate the volume

of commercial real estate transactions

covered by the existing threshold and

increased thresholds.

Analysis of Call Report Data

The agencies’ analysis of data

reported on the Call Report suggests that

the threshold for commercial real estate

transactions could be raised without

exceeding the risk that these

transactions posed when the thresholds

were established in 1994.

All FDIC-insured depository

institutions report information about

loans on their balance sheets by

category of loan,55 but because IDIs do

not report on loans in all of the

categories that would be included in the

definition of commercial real estate

transaction by loan size, the agencies

used loans secured by NFNR as a proxy

for commercial real estate transactions

in this analysis.56 Data on NFNR loans

are an effective proxy because the vast

majority of commercial real estate

transactions are in the NFNR category.

NFNR loans should mirror trends across

all categories of commercial real estate

transactions.

IDIs report information on NFNR

loans in the Call Report by three

separate size categories: (1) Loans with

original amounts of $100,000 or less; (2)

loans with original amounts of more

than $100,000, but $250,000 or less; and

rity of commercial real estate

transactions are in the NFNR category.

NFNR loans should mirror trends across

all categories of commercial real estate

transactions.

IDIs report information on NFNR

loans in the Call Report by three

separate size categories: (1) Loans with

original amounts of $100,000 or less; (2)

loans with original amounts of more

than $100,000, but $250,000 or less; and

(3) loans with original amounts of more

than $250,000, but $1,000,000 or less.

They separately report the dollar

amount of all NFNR loans, including

those over $1,000,000. Using this data,

the agencies calculated the dollar

amount of NFNR loans at or under the

current $250,000 threshold as a

percentage of the dollar amount of all

NFNR loans.

According to Call Report data, when

the threshold for real-estate related

financial transactions was raised from

$100,000 to $250,000 in 1994,

approximately 18 percent of the dollar

volume of all NFNR loans reported by

IDIs had original loan amounts of

$250,000 or less. As of the fourth

quarter of 2016, approximately 4

percent of the dollar volume of such

loans had original loan amounts of

$250,000 or less. This analysis suggests

that a larger proportion of commercial

real estate transactions now require

appraisals than when the threshold was

last raised.

In contemplating an increase in the

threshold for commercial real estate

transactions, the agencies also used Call

Report data to consider the transactions

exempted from the appraisal threshold

as a share of equity capital plus the

allowance for loan and lease losses (the

allowance), which is a measure of the

potential concentration risk that these

transactions could pose to the financial

well-being of institutions as a whole. In

1994, NFNR loans with original loan

amounts of $250,000 or less represented

in the aggregate approximately 14

percent of IDIs’ equity capital plus the

allowance

of equity capital plus the

allowance for loan and lease losses (the

allowance), which is a measure of the

potential concentration risk that these

transactions could pose to the financial

well-being of institutions as a whole. In

1994, NFNR loans with original loan

amounts of $250,000 or less represented

in the aggregate approximately 14

percent of IDIs’ equity capital plus the

allowance. By the fourth quarter of

2016, such loans represented only about

3 percent of IDIs’ equity capital plus the

allowance.

To determine whether concentration

risk would be similar for small

institutions, the agencies separately

considered the percentage of NFNR

transactions exempted from the

appraisal threshold as a share of equity

capital plus the allowance for IDIs with

assets of less than $1 billion. This

analysis produced similar results.

Approximately 30 percent of the dollar

volume of all NFNR loans in such

smaller institutions had original loan

amounts of $250,000 or less in 1994. By

the fourth quarter of 2016, however,

only about 11 percent of the dollar

volume of such loans had original loan

amounts of $250,000 or less. In 1994,

the dollar volume of smaller IDIs’ NFNR

loans with original loan amounts of

$250,000 or less represented

approximately 33 percent of equity

capital plus the allowance. These loans

represented only about 18 percent of

IDIs’ equity capital plus the allowance

by the fourth quarter of 2016.

Because IDIs report loans on the Call

Report aggregated into only the three

categories mentioned above (less than

$100,000, $100,000 to $250,000, and

$250,000 to $1,000,000), the agencies

cannot use Call Report data to

determine the precise percentage or

number of transactions that would be

exempted by the proposed $400,000

threshold or the precise impact of a

$400,000 threshold on equity capital

plus the allowance.

Analysis of CoStar Comps Data

As described below, the agencies have

used the CoStar Comps database to

estimate this impact

0,000 to $1,000,000), the agencies

cannot use Call Report data to

determine the precise percentage or

number of transactions that would be

exempted by the proposed $400,000

threshold or the precise impact of a

$400,000 threshold on equity capital

plus the allowance.

Analysis of CoStar Comps Data

As described below, the agencies have

used the CoStar Comps database to

estimate this impact. The CoStar Comps

database 57 provides sales value data on

specific commercial real estate

transactions. While there are some

limitations regarding use of the CoStar

Comps database, as detailed below, the

database contains information on sales

values for individual transactions, so it

can be used to estimate the number and

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00018

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35486

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

58 This same analysis could not be performed

using Call Report data because, as described above,

transactions reported for purposes of the Call

Report are either reported in groupings of large

value ranges or not reported by size at all.

59 The Interagency Guidelines for Real Estate

Lending provides that institutions’ loan-to-value

limits should not exceed 85 percent for loans

secured by improved property and 65 percent for

loans secured by raw land. See OCC: 12 CFR part

34, subpart D, appendix A; Board: 12 CFR part 208,

appendix C; FDIC: 12 CFR part 365, subpart A,

appendix A.

60 For example, the database tends to

underrepresent sales of smaller properties and

transactions in rural markets, and includes

transactions that are not financed by depository

institutions.

61 Net charge-offs are charge-offs minus

recoveries.

62 Net charge-offs represent losses to financial

institutions, which, in the aggregate, can pose a

threat to safety and soundness

A,

appendix A.

60 For example, the database tends to

underrepresent sales of smaller properties and

transactions in rural markets, and includes

transactions that are not financed by depository

institutions.

61 Net charge-offs are charge-offs minus

recoveries.

62 Net charge-offs represent losses to financial

institutions, which, in the aggregate, can pose a

threat to safety and soundness.

63 When a below-threshold transaction also

qualifies for an exemption from the appraisal

requirements for a reason other than being below

one of the thresholds or a qualifying existing

extension of credit, no evaluation is required.

percentage of transactions that would

become exempt under the proposed

threshold change (i.e., those above

$250,000, but less than $400,000).58

The CoStar Comps database contains

data for transactions involving

nonresidential commercial mortgages,

multifamily and land. The CoStar

Comps database is derived from sales

data and reflects the total transaction

amount, as opposed to the loan amount.

For purposes of this analysis, the

agencies included only financed

transactions and assumed a loan-to-

value ratio of 85 percent for

nonresidential and multifamily

commercial mortgages and a loan-to-

value ratio of 65 percent for raw land

transactions 59 to arrive at an estimated

loan amount which would be equivalent

to the ‘‘transaction value’’ under the

Title XI appraisal regulations. While the

CoStar Comps database has some

limitations for the purposes of

evaluating the proposed increase,60 it

provides information that can be used to

estimate the dollar volume and number

of commercial real estate transactions

that would potentially be exempted by

the proposed threshold increase

would be equivalent

to the ‘‘transaction value’’ under the

Title XI appraisal regulations. While the

CoStar Comps database has some

limitations for the purposes of

evaluating the proposed increase,60 it

provides information that can be used to

estimate the dollar volume and number

of commercial real estate transactions

that would potentially be exempted by

the proposed threshold increase.

An analysis of the CoStar Comps

database suggests that increasing the

threshold to $400,000 would

significantly increase the number of

commercial real estate transactions

exempted from the Title XI appraisal

requirements, but the portion of the

total dollar size of commercial real

estate transactions that would remain

exempted by the threshold would be

minimal. The percentage of commercial

properties with loans in the CoStar

Comps database that would be

exempted from the Title XI appraisal

regulations by the threshold would

increase from 17 percent to 28 percent

if the threshold were raised from

$250,000 to $400,000. However, the

total dollar volume of loans for

commercial properties in the CoStar

Comps database would only increase

from 0.7 percent to 1.5 percent.

Exempting an additional 11 percent of

commercial real estate transactions

would provide burden relief as sought

by some of the EGRPRA commenters.

The 0.8 percentage point increase in the

dollar volume of commercial real estate

transactions that the CoStar data

suggests would be exempted from the

appraisal requirements under the

proposed threshold is unlikely to

expose financial institutions to

increased safety and soundness risk.

Analysis of Charge-Off Rates

In addition to assessing changes in the

magnitude of transactions covered by

the appraisal threshold, the agencies

assessed trends in the loss rate

experience of commercial real estate

transactions

ould be exempted from the

appraisal requirements under the

proposed threshold is unlikely to

expose financial institutions to

increased safety and soundness risk.

Analysis of Charge-Off Rates

In addition to assessing changes in the

magnitude of transactions covered by

the appraisal threshold, the agencies

assessed trends in the loss rate

experience of commercial real estate

transactions.

While the agencies do not regularly

collect data on rates of loss for

commercial real estate by the size of

loans, they do collect net charge-off 61

data for commercial real estate loans on

the Call Report. The agencies

considered aggregate net charge-off rates

for commercial real estate loans in

determining whether the threshold

would pose a threat to the safety and

soundness of financial institutions.62

In order to evaluate the impact of

commercial real estate lending on the

safety and soundness of the banking

system generally, the agencies compared

peak net charge-off rates for two

periods: 1991 to 1994 and 2007 to 2012.

These periods represent two distress

cycles when aggregate net charge-offs

rose to their highest levels. The agencies

separately examined charge-off rates on

lending for all commercial real estate

categories covering construction,

multifamily, nonfarm, nonresidential,

and farmland. In order to evaluate

whether commercial real estate lending

may have a disparate impact on the

safety and soundness of IDIs of varying

sizes, the agencies examined peak

charge-off rates on loans for all IDIs, IDIs

under one billion dollars in total assets,

IDIs with total assets between one

billion dollars and ten billion dollars,

and IDIs with total assets of more than

ten billion dollars.

The analysis showed that aggregate

peak net charge-off rates for the most

recent cycle were generally no worse

than those recorded for the prior cycle,

with the exception of construction

loans

r all IDIs, IDIs

under one billion dollars in total assets,

IDIs with total assets between one

billion dollars and ten billion dollars,

and IDIs with total assets of more than

ten billion dollars.

The analysis showed that aggregate

peak net charge-off rates for the most

recent cycle were generally no worse

than those recorded for the prior cycle,

with the exception of construction

loans. Moreover, aggregate commercial

real estate loan loss rates for banks less

than $1 billion (which would

reasonably be expected to have a larger

proportion of small loans, given their

lower legal lending limits due to their

smaller size) were lower than for larger

banks as a group.

This data suggests that the loss

experience associated with commercial

real estate loans for the banking system

as a whole has stayed at a relatively

consistent rate through multiple credit

cycles. Thus, banking system safety and

soundness concerns associated with the

commercial real estate loan loss rates

have not increased. However,

commercial real estate loan charge-off

rates during periods of economic stress

have and will continue to vary across

individual IDIs based on location,

collateral, quality of underwriting and

risk management, and other factors.

Thus commercial real estate loan

concentration risk at individual

institutions remains a focus for the

banking agencies.

Question 7. The agencies invite

comment on the safety and soundness

impact of the proposed $400,000

threshold for commercial real estate

transactions.

Question 8. The agencies invite

comment on the data used in this

analysis, and what alternative sources of

data would be appropriate for this

analysis.

B

ntration risk at individual

institutions remains a focus for the

banking agencies.

Question 7. The agencies invite

comment on the safety and soundness

impact of the proposed $400,000

threshold for commercial real estate

transactions.

Question 8. The agencies invite

comment on the data used in this

analysis, and what alternative sources of

data would be appropriate for this

analysis.

B. Use of Evaluations

The Title XI appraisal regulations

require regulated institutions to obtain

evaluations for three categories of real

estate-related financial transactions that

the agencies have determined do not

require a Title XI appraisal, including

real-estate related financial transactions

at or below the $250,000 threshold and

qualifying business loans at or below

the $1,000,000 threshold. Similarly, the

agencies propose to require that

institutions entering into commercial

real estate transactions at or below the

proposed $400,000 threshold obtain

evaluations that are consistent with safe

and sound banking practices for such

transactions.63

An evaluation provides a general

estimate of the value of real estate, but

is not subject to the same requirements

as a Title XI appraisal. An evaluation

should provide appropriate information

to enable the institution to make a

prudent decision regarding the

transaction. Through the Guidelines, the

agencies have provided guidance to

regulated institutions on their

expectations regarding when and how

evaluations should be used. The

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00019

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

e the institution to make a

prudent decision regarding the

transaction. Through the Guidelines, the

agencies have provided guidance to

regulated institutions on their

expectations regarding when and how

evaluations should be used. The

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00019

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35487

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

64 Guidelines at 75 FR 77461.

65 Interagency Appraisal and Evaluations

Guidelines, 75 FR 77450, at 77458 (December 10,

2010).

66 Interagency Advisory on Use of Evaluations in

Real Estate-Related Financial Transactions, OCC

Bulletin 2016–8 (March 4, 2016); Board SR Letter

16–05 (March 4, 2016); Supervisory Expectations

for Evaluations, FDIC FIL–16–2016 (March 4, 2016).

67 Guidelines at 75 FR 77457–58. See also

Valuation Independence rules in Regulation Z,

which apply to all creditors and cover extensions

of consumer credit that are or will be secured by

a consumer’s principal dwelling: Board: 12 CFR

226.42; CFPB: 12 CFR 1026.42.

68 OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(d); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(d)(2); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(d)(2).

Guidelines describe the transactions for

which financial institutions are required

to obtain an evaluation, and recommend

that institutions develop policies and

procedures for identifying when to

obtain appraisals for such transactions

a consumer’s principal dwelling: Board: 12 CFR

226.42; CFPB: 12 CFR 1026.42.

68 OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(d); Board: 12 CFR

225.63(d)(2); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(d)(2).

Guidelines describe the transactions for

which financial institutions are required

to obtain an evaluation, and recommend

that institutions develop policies and

procedures for identifying when to

obtain appraisals for such transactions.

Institutions should conduct

evaluations consistent with the

provisions in the Guidelines.64 As

described in the Guidelines, evaluations

should be performed by persons who

are competent and have the relevant

experience and knowledge of the

market, location, and type of real

property being valued.65 Evaluations

may be completed by a bank employee

or by a third party, as explained by the

Interagency Advisory on Use of

Evaluations in Real Estate-Related

Financial Transactions.66 Guidance on

achieving independence in the

collateral valuation program can be

found in the Guidelines, among other

sources.67 The Guidelines state that an

evaluation should provide an estimate

of the property’s market value or

sufficient information and analysis to

support the credit decision. The

Guidelines also describe the minimum

content that an evaluation should

contain.

In evaluating this proposal, the

agencies considered the impact to the

financial system of the proposal, and

specifically the impact to financial

institutions and borrowers of obtaining

evaluations instead of Title XI

appraisals. Based on information from

industry participants, the cost of third-

party evaluations of commercial real

estate generally ranges from $500 to

over $1,500, whereas the cost of

appraisals of such properties generally

ranges from $1,000 to over $3,000

of the proposal, and

specifically the impact to financial

institutions and borrowers of obtaining

evaluations instead of Title XI

appraisals. Based on information from

industry participants, the cost of third-

party evaluations of commercial real

estate generally ranges from $500 to

over $1,500, whereas the cost of

appraisals of such properties generally

ranges from $1,000 to over $3,000.

Commercial real estate transactions with

transaction values above $250,000 but at

or below $400,000 (affected

transactions), are likely to involve

smaller and less complex properties,

and appraisals and evaluations on such

properties would likely be at the lower

end of the cost range. This third-party

pricing information suggests a savings of

several hundred dollars per affected

transaction.

The agencies also considered the costs

in terms of time to obtain and process

appraisals and evaluations. There may

be less delay in finding appropriate

personnel to perform an evaluation than

to perform a Title XI appraisal,

particularly in rural areas. As described

in the Guidelines, financial institutions

should review the property valuation

prior to entering into the transaction.

Financial institutions require less time

to review evaluations than to review

appraisals, because evaluations contain

less detailed information. The agencies

estimate that, on average, the review

process for an appraisal would take

approximately forty minutes and the

review process for an evaluation would

take approximately ten minutes. Thus,

for affected transactions, the proposed

rule would alleviate approximately

thirty minutes of employee time per

transaction, in addition to the reduced

delay and the cost savings of obtaining

an evaluation instead of an appraisal.

In considering the aggregate effect of

this proposal, the agencies considered

the number of affected transactions

on would

take approximately ten minutes. Thus,

for affected transactions, the proposed

rule would alleviate approximately

thirty minutes of employee time per

transaction, in addition to the reduced

delay and the cost savings of obtaining

an evaluation instead of an appraisal.

In considering the aggregate effect of

this proposal, the agencies considered

the number of affected transactions. As

previously discussed, the agencies

estimate that the number of commercial

real estate transactions that would be

exempted by the threshold is expected

to increase by approximately 11 percent

under the proposed rule. Thus, while

the precise number of affected

transactions and the precise cost

reduction per transaction cannot be

determined, the proposed rule is

expected to lead to significant cost

savings for institutions that engage in

commercial real estate lending.

Question 9. The agencies invite

comment on the proposed requirement

that regulated institutions obtain

evaluations for commercial real estate

transactions at or below the $400,000

threshold.

Question 10. What type of additional

guidance, if any, do institutions need to

support the increased use of

evaluations?

Question 11. To what extent does the

use of evaluations reduce burden and

cost over the use of appraisals? To what

extent are evaluations currently done by

in-house staff versus outsourced to

appraisers or other qualified

professionals?

C

low the $400,000

threshold.

Question 10. What type of additional

guidance, if any, do institutions need to

support the increased use of

evaluations?

Question 11. To what extent does the

use of evaluations reduce burden and

cost over the use of appraisals? To what

extent are evaluations currently done by

in-house staff versus outsourced to

appraisers or other qualified

professionals?

C. State Certified Appraiser Required

The current Title XI appraisal

regulations, require that ‘‘[a]ll federally

related transactions having a transaction

value of $250,000 or more, other than

those involving appraisals of 1-to-4

family residential properties, shall

require an appraisal prepared by a State

certified appraiser.’’ 68 In order to make

this paragraph consistent with the other

proposed changes to the appraisal

regulations, the agencies are proposing

a change to its wording to introduce the

$400,000 threshold and use the term

‘‘commercial real estate transaction.’’

The amendment to this provision would

be a technical change that would not

alter any substantive requirement.

III. Appraisal Threshold for Qualifying

Business Loans

As noted above, in the 2017 EGRPRA

Report to Congress, the agencies stated

their intention to gather more

information about the appropriateness

of increasing the $1 million threshold

for qualifying business loans. The

agencies are not proposing an increase

in the business loan threshold at this

time, but the agencies invite comment

on the following questions concerning

the qualifying business loan exemption:

Question 12. The agencies invite

comment and supporting data on the

appropriateness of raising the current

$1,000,000 threshold for qualifying

business loans and the associated

implications for safety and soundness.

Question 13. What unique risks do

institutions associate with qualifying

business loans?

Question 14

e following questions concerning

the qualifying business loan exemption:

Question 12. The agencies invite

comment and supporting data on the

appropriateness of raising the current

$1,000,000 threshold for qualifying

business loans and the associated

implications for safety and soundness.

Question 13. What unique risks do

institutions associate with qualifying

business loans?

Question 14. What percentage of total

real estate lending at financial

institutions, by number of loans and

dollar volume of lending, are qualifying

business loans?

Question 15. What is the average size

of a qualifying business loan at financial

institutions? What are the incidences of

default on qualifying business loans

compared to other commercial real

estate transactions that institutions have

observed over time?

Question 16. The agencies invite

comment on the clarity of the

application of the current threshold for

qualifying business loans, and on any

difficulty that financial institutions have

experienced in interpreting the

limitation on source of repayment.

IV. Request for Comments

The Agencies invite comment on all

aspects of the proposed rulemaking.

Question 17. As discussed earlier, the

agencies have articulated several bases

for declining to propose an increase in

the residential threshold. The agencies

request comment on whether there are

other factors that should be considered

in evaluating the current appraisal

threshold for 1-to-4 family residential

properties.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00020

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

ing to propose an increase in

the residential threshold. The agencies

request comment on whether there are

other factors that should be considered

in evaluating the current appraisal

threshold for 1-to-4 family residential

properties.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00020

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35488

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

69 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.

70 For its RFA analysis, the Board considered all

Board-regulated creditors to which the proposed

rule would apply.

71 U.S. SBA, Table of Small Business Size

Standards Matched to North American Industry

Classification System Codes, available at https://

www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/files/Size_

Standards_Table.pdf.

72 Asset size and annual revenues are calculated

according to SBA regulations. See 13 CFR 121 et

seq.

73 12 U.S.C. 3341(b).

V. Regulatory Analysis

A. Regulatory Flexibility Act

OCC: The Regulatory Flexibility Act

(RFA), 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq., generally

requires that, in connection with a

rulemaking, an agency prepare and

make available for public comment a

regulatory flexibility analysis that

describes the impact of the rule on small

entities. However, the regulatory

flexibility analysis otherwise required

under the RFA is not required if an

agency certifies that the rule will not

have a significant economic impact on

a substantial number of small entities

(defined in regulations promulgated by

the Small Business Administration

(SBA) to include commercial banks and

savings institutions, and trust

companies, with assets of $550 million

or less and $38.5 million or less,

respectively) and publishes its

certification and a brief explanatory

statement in the Federal Register

together with the rule.

The OCC currently supervises

approximately 956 small entities

ations promulgated by

the Small Business Administration

(SBA) to include commercial banks and

savings institutions, and trust

companies, with assets of $550 million

or less and $38.5 million or less,

respectively) and publishes its

certification and a brief explanatory

statement in the Federal Register

together with the rule.

The OCC currently supervises

approximately 956 small entities. Data

currently available to the OCC are not

sufficient to estimate how many OCC-

supervised small entities make CRE

loans in amounts that fall between the

current and proposed thresholds.

Therefore, we cannot estimate how

many small entities may be affected by

the increase threshold. However,

because the proposal does not contain

any new recordkeeping, reporting, or

compliance requirements, the proposal

will not impose costs on any OCC-

supervised institutions. Accordingly,

the OCC certifies that the proposed rule

will not have a significant economic

impact on a substantial number of small

entities.

Board: The RFA,69 requires an agency

either to provide an initial regulatory

flexibility analysis with a proposed rule

or certify that the proposed rule will not

have a significant economic impact on

a substantial number of small entities.

The proposed threshold increase applies

to certain IDIs and non-bank entities

that make loans secured by commercial

real estate.70 The SBA establishes size

standards that define which entities are

small businesses for purposes of the

RFA.71 The size standard to be

considered a small business is: $550

million or less in assets for banks and

other depository institutions; and $38.5

million or less in annual revenues for

the majority of non-bank entities that

are likely to be subject to the proposed

regulation.72 Based on the Board’s

analysis, and for the reasons stated

below, the proposed rule may have a

significant positive economic impact on

a substantial number of small entities

550

million or less in assets for banks and

other depository institutions; and $38.5

million or less in annual revenues for

the majority of non-bank entities that

are likely to be subject to the proposed

regulation.72 Based on the Board’s

analysis, and for the reasons stated

below, the proposed rule may have a

significant positive economic impact on

a substantial number of small entities.

Accordingly, the Board is publishing an

initial regulatory flexibility analysis.

The Board will conduct a final

regulatory flexibility analysis after

consideration of comments received

during the public comment period.

The Board requests public comment

on all aspects of this analysis.

1. Reasons for the Proposed Rule

In response to comments received in

the EGRPRA process, the agencies are

proposing to increase the threshold from

$250,000 to $400,000 at or below which

a Title XI appraisal is not required for

commercial real estate transactions.

Because commercial real estate prices

have increased since 1994, when the

current $250,000 threshold was

established, a smaller percentage of

commercial real estate transactions are

currently exempted from the Title XI

appraisal requirements than when the

threshold was established. This

threshold adjustment is intended to

reduce the regulatory burden associated

with extending credit secured by

commercial real estate in a manner that

is consistent with the safety and

soundness of financial institutions.

2. Statement of Objectives and Legal

Basis

As discussed above, the agencies’

objective in proposing this threshold

increase is to reduce the regulatory

burden associated with extending credit

in a safe and sound manner by reducing

the number of commercial real estate

transactions that are subject to the Title

XI appraisal requirements

the safety and

soundness of financial institutions.

2. Statement of Objectives and Legal

Basis

As discussed above, the agencies’

objective in proposing this threshold

increase is to reduce the regulatory

burden associated with extending credit

in a safe and sound manner by reducing

the number of commercial real estate

transactions that are subject to the Title

XI appraisal requirements.

Title XI explicitly authorizes the

agencies to establish a threshold level at

or below which a Title XI appraisal is

not required if the agencies determine in

writing that the threshold does not

represent a threat to the safety and

soundness of financial institutions and

receive concurrence from the CFPB that

such threshold level provides

reasonable protection for consumers

who purchase 1-to-4 unit single-family

homes.73 Based on available data and

supervisory experience, the agencies

tailored the size and scope of the

proposed threshold increase to ensure

that it would not pose a threat to the

safety and soundness of financial

institutions or erode protections for

consumers who purchase 1-to-4 unit

single-family homes.

The Board’s proposed rule would

apply to state chartered banks that are

members of the Federal Reserve System

(state member banks), as well as bank

holding companies and nonbank

subsidiaries of bank holding companies

that engage in lending. There are

approximately 601 state member banks

and 35 nonbank lenders regulated by

the Board that meet the SBA definition

of small entities and would be subject

to the proposed rule. Data currently

available to the Board do not allow for

a precise estimate of the number of

small entities that would be affected by

the proposed rule because the number

of small entities that will engage in

commercial real estate transactions

within the proposed threshold is

unknown.

3

y

the Board that meet the SBA definition

of small entities and would be subject

to the proposed rule. Data currently

available to the Board do not allow for

a precise estimate of the number of

small entities that would be affected by

the proposed rule because the number

of small entities that will engage in

commercial real estate transactions

within the proposed threshold is

unknown.

3. Projected Reporting, Recordkeeping

and Other Compliance Requirements

The proposed rule would reduce

reporting, recordkeeping, and other

compliance requirements for small

entities. For transactions at or below the

proposed threshold, regulated

institutions would be given the option

to obtain an evaluation of the property

instead of an appraisal. Unlike

appraisals, evaluations may be

performed by a lender’s own employees

and are not required to comply with

USPAP. As discussed in detail in

Section II.B of the SUPPLEMENTARY

INFORMATION, the cost of obtaining

appraisals and evaluations can vary

widely depending on the size and

complexity of the property, the party

performing the valuation, and market

conditions where the property is

located. Additionally, the costs of

obtaining appraisals and evaluations

may be passed on to borrowers. Because

of this variation in cost and practice, it

is not possible to precisely determine

the cost savings that regulated

institutions will experience due to the

decreased cost of obtaining an

evaluation rather than an appraisal.

However, based on information

available to the Board, it is likely that

small entities and borrowers engaging in

commercial real estate transactions

could experience significant cost

reductions.

In addition to costing less to obtain

than appraisals, evaluations also require

less time to review than appraisals

because they contain less detailed

information

ation rather than an appraisal.

However, based on information

available to the Board, it is likely that

small entities and borrowers engaging in

commercial real estate transactions

could experience significant cost

reductions.

In addition to costing less to obtain

than appraisals, evaluations also require

less time to review than appraisals

because they contain less detailed

information. As discussed further in

Section II.B of the SUPPLEMENTARY

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00021

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35489

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

74 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.

75 13 CFR 121.201 (as amended, effective

December 2, 2014).

76 FDIC-supervised institutions are set forth in 12

U.S.C. 1813(q)(2).

77 FDIC Call Report, March 31, 2017.

78 The proposed definition of ‘‘Commercial Real

Estate Transaction’’ would largely capture the

following four categories of loans secured by real

estate in the Call Report (FFIEC 031; RCFD 1410),

namely loans that are: (1) For construction, land

development, and other land loans; (2) secured by

farmland; (3) secured by residential properties with

five or more units; or (4) secured by nonfarm

nonresidential properties. However, loans that

provide both initial construction funding and

permanent financing and are reported as

construction, land development, and other land

loans during the construction phase would be

excluded from the definition.

79 FDIC Call Report data, March 31, 2017.

80 Multiplying $31.9 billion by 1.53 percent then

dividing the product by an average loan amount of

$325,000 equals 1,504 loans and multiplying $31.9

billion by 4.10 percent then dividing the product

by an average loan amount of $325,000 equals 4,040

loans.

INFORMATION, an appraisal takes

approximately forty minutes to review

and an evaluation takes approximately

ten minutes to review

7.

80 Multiplying $31.9 billion by 1.53 percent then

dividing the product by an average loan amount of

$325,000 equals 1,504 loans and multiplying $31.9

billion by 4.10 percent then dividing the product

by an average loan amount of $325,000 equals 4,040

loans.

INFORMATION, an appraisal takes

approximately forty minutes to review

and an evaluation takes approximately

ten minutes to review. Thus, the

proposed rule would alleviate

approximately thirty minutes of

employee time per affected transaction

for which the lender obtains an

evaluation instead of an appraisal.

As previously discussed, the Board

estimates that the percentage of

commercial real estate transactions that

would be exempted by the threshold is

expected to increase by approximately

11 percent under the proposed rule. The

Board expects this percentage to be

higher for small entities, because a

higher percentage of their loan

portfolios are likely to be made up of

small, below-threshold loans than those

of larger entities. Thus, while the

precise number of transactions that will

be affected and the precise cost

reduction per transaction cannot be

determined, the proposed rule is

expected to have a significant positive

economic impact on small entities that

engage in commercial real estate

lending.

4. Identification of Duplicative,

Overlapping, or Conflicting Federal

Regulations

The Board has not identified any

federal statutes or regulations that

would duplicate, overlap, or conflict

with the proposed revisions.

5. Discussion of Significant Alternatives

The agencies considered additional

burden-reducing measures, such as

increasing the commercial threshold to

a higher dollar amount and increasing

the residential and business loan

thresholds, but have not proposed such

measures at this time for the safety and

soundness and consumer protection

reasons previously discussed

h the proposed revisions.

5. Discussion of Significant Alternatives

The agencies considered additional

burden-reducing measures, such as

increasing the commercial threshold to

a higher dollar amount and increasing

the residential and business loan

thresholds, but have not proposed such

measures at this time for the safety and

soundness and consumer protection

reasons previously discussed. For

transactions exempted from the Title XI

appraisal requirements, the proposed

rule would require regulated

institutions to get an evaluation if they

do not get an appraisal. The agencies

believe this requirement is necessary to

protect the safety and soundness of

financial institutions, which is a legal

prerequisite to the establishment of any

threshold. The Board is not aware of any

other significant alternatives that would

reduce burden on small entities without

sacrificing the safety and soundness of

financial institutions or consumer

protections.

FDIC: The RFA generally requires

that, in connection with a notice of

proposed rulemaking, an agency prepare

and make available for public comment

an initial regulatory flexibility analysis

describing the impact of the proposed

rule on small entities.74 A regulatory

flexibility analysis is not required,

however, if the agency certifies that the

rule will not have a significant

economic impact on a substantial

number of small entities. The SBA has

defined ‘‘small entities’’ to include

banking organizations with total assets

less than or equal to $550 million.75 For

the reasons described below and

pursuant to section 605(b) of the RFA,

the FDIC certifies that the final rule will

not have a significant economic impact

on a substantial number of small

entities

nt

economic impact on a substantial

number of small entities. The SBA has

defined ‘‘small entities’’ to include

banking organizations with total assets

less than or equal to $550 million.75 For

the reasons described below and

pursuant to section 605(b) of the RFA,

the FDIC certifies that the final rule will

not have a significant economic impact

on a substantial number of small

entities.

The FDIC supervises 3,744 depository

institutions,76 of which, 3,028 are

defined as small banking entities by the

terms of the RFA.77 According to the

Call Report, 3,010 small entities

reported holding some volume of real

estate related financial transactions that

meet the proposed rule’s definition of a

commercial real estate transaction.78

Therefore, 3,010 small entities could be

affected by the proposed rule.

The proposed rule will raise the

appraisal threshold for commercial real

estate transactions from $250,000 to

$400,000. Any commercial real estate

transaction with a value in excess of the

$400,000 threshold is required to have

an appraisal by a state licensed or state

certified appraiser. Any commercial real

estate transaction at or below the

$400,000 threshold requires an

evaluation.

To estimate the dollar volume of

commercial real estate transactions the

proposed change could potentially

affect, the FDIC used information on the

dollar volume and number of loans in

the Call Report for small institutions

from two categories of loans included in

the definition of a commercial real

estate transaction. The Call Report data

reflect that 4.55 percent of the dollar

volume of nonfarm, nonresidential

loans secured by real estate has an

original loan amount between $1 and

$250,000, while 11.81 percent have an

original loan amount between $250,000

and $1,000,000

Call Report for small institutions

from two categories of loans included in

the definition of a commercial real

estate transaction. The Call Report data

reflect that 4.55 percent of the dollar

volume of nonfarm, nonresidential

loans secured by real estate has an

original loan amount between $1 and

$250,000, while 11.81 percent have an

original loan amount between $250,000

and $1,000,000. The Call Report data

also reflects that 8.85 percent of the

dollar volume of agricultural loans

secured by farmland has an original

loan amount between $1 and $250,000,

while 7.49 percent have an original loan

amount between $250,000 and

$500,000.79 Assuming that the original

amount of nonfarm, nonresidential

loans secured by real estate and the

original amount of agricultural loans

secured by farmland are normally

distributed, the FDIC estimates that

between 6.08 percent and 12.95 percent

of loan volume is at or below the

$400,000 threshold for these categories,

respectively.

Therefore, raising the appraisal

threshold from $250,000 to $400,000 for

commercial real estate transactions

could affect an estimated 1.53 percent to

4.10 percent of the dollar volume of all

commercial real estate transactions

originated each year. This estimate

assumes that the distribution of loans

for the other loan categories within the

proposed definition of commercial real

estate transactions is similar to those

loans secured by nonfarm,

nonresidential properties or farmland.

The proposed rule is likely to reduce

valuation review costs for covered

institutions. The FDIC estimates that it

takes a loan officer an average of 40

minutes to review an appraisal to ensure

that it meets that standards set forth in

Title XI, but 10 minutes to perform a

similar review of an evaluation, which

does not need to meet the Title XI

standards for appraisals

rties or farmland.

The proposed rule is likely to reduce

valuation review costs for covered

institutions. The FDIC estimates that it

takes a loan officer an average of 40

minutes to review an appraisal to ensure

that it meets that standards set forth in

Title XI, but 10 minutes to perform a

similar review of an evaluation, which

does not need to meet the Title XI

standards for appraisals. The proposed

rule increases the number of

commercial real estate transactions that

would require an evaluation by raising

the appraisal threshold from $250,000 to

$400,000. Assuming that 15 percent of

the outstanding balance of commercial

real estate transactions for small entities

gets renewed or replaced by new

originations each year, the FDIC

estimates that small entities originate

$31.9 billion in new commercial real

estate transactions each year. Assuming

that 1.53 percent to 4.10 percent of

annual originations represent loans with

an origination amount greater than

$250,000 but not more than $400,000,

the FDIC estimates that the proposed

rule will affect approximately 1,504 to

4,040 loans per year,80 or 0.5 percent to

1.33 percent of loans on average for

small FDIC-supervised institutions.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00022

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35490

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

81 The FDIC estimates that the average hourly

compensation for a loan officer is $68.65 an hour.

The hourly compensation estimate is based on

published compensation rates for Credit Counselors

and Loan Officers ($43.40). The estimate includes

the March 2017 75th percentile hourly wage rate

reported by the BLS, National Industry-Specific

Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates

osed Rules

81 The FDIC estimates that the average hourly

compensation for a loan officer is $68.65 an hour.

The hourly compensation estimate is based on

published compensation rates for Credit Counselors

and Loan Officers ($43.40). The estimate includes

the March 2017 75th percentile hourly wage rate

reported by the BLS, National Industry-Specific

Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates.

The reported hourly wage rate is adjusted for

changes in the CPI–U between May 2016 and March

2017 (1.83 percent) and grossed up by 155.3 percent

to account for non-monetary compensation as

reported by the March 2017 Employer Costs for

Employee Compensation Data. Based on this

estimate, loan review costs would decline between

$51,625 (1,504 loans multiplied by 30 minutes and

multiplied by $68.65 per hour) and $138,673 (4,040

loans multiplied by 30 minutes and multiplied by

$68.65 per hour).

82 Multiplying $31.9 billion by 1.53 percent then

dividing the product by an average loan amount of

$325,000 equals 1,504 loans and multiplying $31.9

billion by 4.10 percent then dividing the product

by an average loan amount of $325,000 equals 4,040

loans.

83 Multiplying 1,504 loans by $1,000 savings

equals $1.5 million and multiplying 4,040 loans by

$1,000 savings equals $4.0 million.

84 44 U.S.C. 3501–3521.

85 44 U.S.C. 3507(d).

86 5 CFR 1320.

87 National banks, federal savings associations,

SMBs and nonbank subsidiaries of BHCs, insured

state nonmember banks and state savings

associations, and insured state branches of foreign

banks.

Therefore, based on an estimated hourly

rate, the proposed rule would reduce

loan review costs for small entities by

$51,625 to $138,673, on average, each

year.81 If lenders opt to not utilize an

evaluation and require an appraisal on

commercial real estate transaction

greater than $250,000 but not more than

$400,000 any reduction in costs would

be smaller

ate branches of foreign

banks.

Therefore, based on an estimated hourly

rate, the proposed rule would reduce

loan review costs for small entities by

$51,625 to $138,673, on average, each

year.81 If lenders opt to not utilize an

evaluation and require an appraisal on

commercial real estate transaction

greater than $250,000 but not more than

$400,000 any reduction in costs would

be smaller.

Any associated recordkeeping costs

are unlikely to change for small FDIC-

supervised entities as the amount of

labor required to satisfy documentation

requirements for an evaluation or an

appraisal is estimated to be the same at

about five minutes for either an

appraisal or evaluation.

The proposed rule also is likely to

reduce the loan origination costs

associated with real estate appraisals for

commercial real estate borrowers. The

FDIC assumes that these costs are

always paid by the borrower for this

analysis. Anecdotal information from

industry participants indicates that a

commercial real estate appraisal costs

between $1,000 to over $3,000, or about

$2,000 on average, and a commercial

real estate evaluation costs between

$500 to over $1,500, or about $1,000 on

average. Based on the prior

assumptions, the FDIC estimates that

the proposed rule will affect

approximately 1,504 to 4,040

transactions per year,82 or 0.5 percent to

1.33 percent of loans on average for

small FDIC-supervised institutions.

Therefore, the proposed rule could

reduce loan origination costs for

borrowers doing business with small

entities by $1.5 to $4.0 million on

average per year.83

By lowering valuation costs on

commercial real estate transactions

greater than $250,000 but less than or

equal to $400,000 for small FDIC-

supervised institutions, the proposed

rule could marginally increase lending

activity. As discussed previously,

commenters in the EGRPRA review

noted that appraisals can be costly and

time consuming

ies by $1.5 to $4.0 million on

average per year.83

By lowering valuation costs on

commercial real estate transactions

greater than $250,000 but less than or

equal to $400,000 for small FDIC-

supervised institutions, the proposed

rule could marginally increase lending

activity. As discussed previously,

commenters in the EGRPRA review

noted that appraisals can be costly and

time consuming. By enabling small

FDIC-supervised institutions to utilize

evaluations for more commercial real

estate transactions, the proposed rule

will reduce transaction costs. The

reduction in loan origination fees could

marginally increase commercial real

estate lending activity for loans with an

origination value greater than $250,000

and not more than $400,000.

B. Paperwork Reduction Act

Certain provisions of the proposed

rule contain ‘‘collection of information’’

requirements within the meaning of the

Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA) of

1995.84 In accordance with the

requirements of the PRA, the agencies

may not conduct or sponsor, and the

respondent is not required to respond

to, an information collection unless it

displays a currently-valid Office of

Management and Budget (OMB) control

number. The OMB control number for

the OCC is 1557–0190, the Board is

7100–0250, and the FDIC is 3064–0103,

which would be extended, without

revision. The agencies have concluded

that the proposed rule does not contain

any changes to the current information

collections, however, the agencies are

revising the methodology for calculating

the burden estimates. The information

collection requirements contained in

this proposed rulemaking have been

submitted by the OCC and FDIC to OMB

for review and approval under section

3507(d) of the PRA 85 and section

1320.11 of the OMB’s implementing

regulations.86 The Board reviewed the

proposed rule under the authority

delegated to the Board by OMB

ing the methodology for calculating

the burden estimates. The information

collection requirements contained in

this proposed rulemaking have been

submitted by the OCC and FDIC to OMB

for review and approval under section

3507(d) of the PRA 85 and section

1320.11 of the OMB’s implementing

regulations.86 The Board reviewed the

proposed rule under the authority

delegated to the Board by OMB.

Proposed Information Collection

Title of Information Collection:

Recordkeeping Requirements

Associated with Real Estate Appraisals

and Evaluations.

Frequency of Response: Event

generated.

Affected Public: Businesses or other

for-profit.

Respondents:

OCC: National banks, Federal savings

associations.

Board: State member banks (SMBs)

and nonbank subsidiaries of bank

holding companies (BHCs).

FDIC: Insured state nonmember banks

and state savings associations, insured

state branches of foreign banks.

General Description of Report: For

federally related transactions, Title XI

requires regulated institutions 87 to

obtain appraisals prepared in

accordance with USPAP promulgated

by the Appraisal Standards Board of the

Appraisal Foundation. Generally, these

standards include the methods and

techniques used to estimate the market

value of a property as well as the

requirements for reporting such analysis

and a market value conclusion in the

appraisal. Regulated institutions are

expected to maintain records that

demonstrate that appraisals used in

their real estate-related lending

activities comply with these regulatory

requirements. For commercial real

estate transactions exempted from the

Title XI appraisal requirements by the

proposed rule, regulated institutions

would still be required to obtain an

evaluation to justify the transaction

amount. The agencies estimate that the

recordkeeping burden associated with

evaluations would be the same as the

recordkeeping burden associated with

appraisals for such transactions

r commercial real

estate transactions exempted from the

Title XI appraisal requirements by the

proposed rule, regulated institutions

would still be required to obtain an

evaluation to justify the transaction

amount. The agencies estimate that the

recordkeeping burden associated with

evaluations would be the same as the

recordkeeping burden associated with

appraisals for such transactions.

Current Action: The threshold change

in the proposed rule will result in

lenders being able to use evaluations

instead of appraisals for certain

transactions. It is estimated that the time

required to document the review of an

appraisal or an evaluation is the same.

While the rulemaking described in this

proposed rule would not change the

amount of time that institutions spend

complying with the Title XI appraisal

regulation, the agencies are using a more

accurate methodology for calculating

the burden of the information

collections based on the experience of

the agencies. Thus, the PRA burden

estimates shown here are different from

those previously reported. The agencies

are (1) using the average number of

loans per institution as the frequency

and (2) using 5 minutes as the estimated

time per response for the appraisals or

evaluations.

PRA Burden Estimates

Estimated average time per response:

5 minutes.

OCC

Number of Respondents: 1,284.

Annual Frequency: 1,488.

Total Estimated Annual Burden:

159,216 hours.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00023

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

ted

time per response for the appraisals or

evaluations.

PRA Burden Estimates

Estimated average time per response:

5 minutes.

OCC

Number of Respondents: 1,284.

Annual Frequency: 1,488.

Total Estimated Annual Burden:

159,216 hours.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00023

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35491

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

88 12 U.S.C. 4802(a).

89 12 U.S.C. 4802(b).

90 Pub. L. 106–102, section 722, 113 Stat. 1338

1471 (1999).

Board

Number of Respondents: 828 SMBs;

1,215 nonbank subsidiaries of BHCs.

Annual Frequency: 419; 25.

Total Estimated Annual Burden:

28,911 hours; 2,531 hours.

FDIC

Number of Respondents: 3,744.

Annual Frequency: 141.

Total Estimated Annual Burden:

43,992 hours.

Comments are invited on:

(a) Whether the collections of

information are necessary for the proper

performance of the agencies’ functions,

including whether the information has

practical utility;

(b) The accuracy of the estimates of

the burden of the information

collections, including the validity of the

methodology and assumptions used;

(c) Ways to enhance the quality,

utility, and clarity of the information to

be collected;

(d) Ways to minimize the burden of

the information collections on

respondents, including through the use

of automated collection techniques or

other forms of information technology;

and

s of

the burden of the information

collections, including the validity of the

methodology and assumptions used;

(c) Ways to enhance the quality,

utility, and clarity of the information to

be collected;

(d) Ways to minimize the burden of

the information collections on

respondents, including through the use

of automated collection techniques or

other forms of information technology;

and

(e) Estimates of capital or start-up

costs and costs of operation,

maintenance, and purchase of services

to provide information.

All comments will become a matter of

public record. Comments on aspects of

this notice that may affect reporting,

recordkeeping, or disclosure

requirements and burden estimates

should be sent to the addresses listed in

the ADDRESSES section of this document.

A copy of the comments may also be

submitted to the OMB desk officer for

the agencies: by mail to U.S. Office of

Management and Budget, 725 17th

Street NW., # 10235, Washington, DC

20503; by facsimile to (202) 395–5806;

or by email to: oira_submission@

omb.eop.gov, Attention, Federal

Banking Agency Desk Officer.

C. Riegle Act

The Riegle Act requires that each of

the agencies, in determining the

effective date and administrative

compliance requirements for new

regulations that impose additional

reporting, disclosure, or other

requirements on IDIs, consider,

consistent with principles of safety and

soundness and the public interest, any

administrative burdens that such

regulations would place on depository

institutions, including small depository

institutions, and customers of

depository institutions, as well as the

benefits of such regulations.88 In

addition, in order to provide an

adequate transition period, new

regulations that impose additional

reporting, disclosures, or other new

requirements on IDIs generally must

take effect on the first day of a calendar

quarter that begins on or after the date

on which the regulations are published

in final form.89

The proposed rule would reduce

burden an

benefits of such regulations.88 In

addition, in order to provide an

adequate transition period, new

regulations that impose additional

reporting, disclosures, or other new

requirements on IDIs generally must

take effect on the first day of a calendar

quarter that begins on or after the date

on which the regulations are published

in final form.89

The proposed rule would reduce

burden and would not impose any

reporting, disclosure, or other new

requirements on IDIs. For transactions

exempted from the Title XI appraisal

requirements by the proposed rule (i.e.,

commercial real estate transactions

between $250,000 and $400,000),

lenders would be required to get an

evaluation if they chose not to get an

appraisal. However, the agencies do not

view the option to obtain an evaluation

instead of an appraisal as a new or

additional requirement for purposes of

the Riegle Act. First, the process of

obtaining an evaluation is not new since

IDIs already get evaluations for

transactions at or below the current

$250,000-threshold. Second, for

commercial real estate transactions

between $250,000 and $400,000, IDIs

could continue to get appraisals instead

of evaluations. Because the proposed

rule would impose no new requirements

on IDIs, the agencies are not required by

the Riegle Act to consider the

administrative burdens and benefits of

the rule or delay its effective date.

Because delaying the effective date of

the rule is not required and would serve

no purpose, the agencies propose to

make the threshold increase effective on

the first day after publication of the final

rule in the Federal Register.

Additionally, although not required by

the Riegle Act, the agencies did consider

the administrative costs and benefits of

the rule while developing the proposal

ecause delaying the effective date of

the rule is not required and would serve

no purpose, the agencies propose to

make the threshold increase effective on

the first day after publication of the final

rule in the Federal Register.

Additionally, although not required by

the Riegle Act, the agencies did consider

the administrative costs and benefits of

the rule while developing the proposal.

In designing the scope of the threshold

increase, the agencies chose to align the

definition of commercial real estate

transaction with industry practice,

regulatory guidance, and the categories

used in the Call Report in order to

reduce the administrative burden of

determining which transactions were

exempted by the rule. The agencies also

considered the cost savings that IDIs

would experience by obtaining

evaluations instead of appraisals and set

the proposed threshold at a level

designed to provide significant burden

relief without sacrificing safety and

soundness. The agencies note that

comment on these matters has been

solicited in questions 2 through 14 in

Section II, and in the RFA discussion in

Section IV, of the SUPPLEMENTARY

INFORMATION, and that the requirements

of the Riegle Act will be considered as

part of the overall rulemaking process.

In addition, the agencies invite any

other comments that further will inform

the agencies’ consideration of the Riegle

Act.

D. Solicitation of Comments on Use of

Plain Language

Section 722 of the Gramm-Leach-

Bliley Act 90 requires the agencies to use

plain language in all proposed and final

rules published after January 1, 2000.

Agencies invite comment on how to

make these proposed rules easier to

understand

s invite any

other comments that further will inform

the agencies’ consideration of the Riegle

Act.

D. Solicitation of Comments on Use of

Plain Language

Section 722 of the Gramm-Leach-

Bliley Act 90 requires the agencies to use

plain language in all proposed and final

rules published after January 1, 2000.

Agencies invite comment on how to

make these proposed rules easier to

understand. For example:

• Have the agencies organized the

material to suit your needs? If not, how

could this material be better organized?

• Are the requirements in the

proposed rules clearly stated? If not,

how could the proposed rules be stated

more clearly?

• Do the proposed rules contain

language or jargon that is not clear? If

so, which language requires

clarification?

• Would a different format (grouping

and order of sections, use of headings,

paragraphing) make the proposed rules

easier to understand? If so, what

changes to the format would make the

proposed rules easier to understand?

• What else could the agencies do to

make the regulation easier to

understand?

E. Unfunded Mandates Act

OCC Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of

1995 Determination

The OCC has analyzed the proposed

rule under the factors in the Unfunded

Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA)

(2 U.S.C. 1532). Under this analysis, the

OCC considered whether the proposed

rule includes a federal mandate that

may result in the expenditure by state,

local, and tribal governments, in the

aggregate, or by the private sector, of

$100 million or more in any one year

(adjusted annually for inflation).

The proposed rule does not impose

new requirements or include new

mandates. Therefore, we conclude that

the proposed rule will not result in an

expenditure of $100 million or more by

state, local, and tribal governments, or

by the private sector, in any one year

rnments, in the

aggregate, or by the private sector, of

$100 million or more in any one year

(adjusted annually for inflation).

The proposed rule does not impose

new requirements or include new

mandates. Therefore, we conclude that

the proposed rule will not result in an

expenditure of $100 million or more by

state, local, and tribal governments, or

by the private sector, in any one year.

List of Subjects

12 CFR Part 34

Appraisal, Appraiser, Banks, Banking,

Consumer protection, Credit, Mortgages,

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00024

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35492

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

National banks, Reporting and

recordkeeping requirements, Savings

associations, Truth in lending.

12 CFR Part 225

Administrative practice and

procedure, Banks, banking, Federal

Reserve System, Capital planning,

Holding companies, Reporting and

recordkeeping requirements, Securities,

Stress testing

12 CFR Part 323

Banks, banking, Mortgages, Reporting

and recordkeeping requirements,

Savings associations.

Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency, 12 CFR Part 34

For the reasons set forth in the joint

preamble, the OCC proposes to amend

part 34 of chapter I of title 12 of the

Code of Federal Regulations as follows:

PART 34—REAL ESTATE LENDING

AND APPRISALS

■1. The authority citation for part 34

continues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 1, 25b, 29, 93a, 371,

1462a, 1463, 1464, 1465, 1701j–3, 1828(o),

3331 et seq., 5101 et seq., and 5412(b)(2)(B),

and 15 U.S.C. 1639h.

■2. Section 34.42 is amended by

redesignating paragraphs (e) through (m)

as paragraphs (f) through (n),

respectively, and by adding a new

paragraph (e) to read as follows:

§ 34.42

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

ntinues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 1, 25b, 29, 93a, 371,

1462a, 1463, 1464, 1465, 1701j–3, 1828(o),

3331 et seq., 5101 et seq., and 5412(b)(2)(B),

and 15 U.S.C. 1639h.

■2. Section 34.42 is amended by

redesignating paragraphs (e) through (m)

as paragraphs (f) through (n),

respectively, and by adding a new

paragraph (e) to read as follows:

§ 34.42

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(e) Commercial real estate transaction

means a real estate-related financial

transaction that is not secured by a 1-

to-4 family residential property. A real

estate-related financial transaction to

finance the initial construction of a 1-to-

4 family residential property that does

not include permanent financing is a

commercial real estate transaction.

*

*

*

*

*

■3. Section 34.43 is amended by:

■a. Removing the word ‘‘or’’ at the end

of paragraph (a)(11);

■b. Revising paragraph (a)(12);

■c. Adding paragraph (a)(13); and

■d. Revising paragraphs (b) and (d)(2).

The revisions and addition read as

follows:

§ 34.43

Appraisals required; transactions

requiring a State certified or licensed

appraiser.

(a) * * *

(12) The OCC determines that the

services of an appraiser are not

necessary in order to protect Federal

financial and public policy interests in

real estate-related financial transactions

or to protect the safety and soundness

of the institution; or

(13) The transaction is a commercial

real estate transaction that has a

transaction value of $400,000 or less.

(b) Evaluations required. For a

transaction that does not require the

services of a State certified or licensed

appraiser under paragraph (a)(1), (a)(5),

(a)(7), or (a)(13) of this section, the

institution shall obtain an appropriate

evaluation of real property collateral

that is consistent with safe and sound

banking practices.

*

*

*

*

*

as a

transaction value of $400,000 or less.

(b) Evaluations required. For a

transaction that does not require the

services of a State certified or licensed

appraiser under paragraph (a)(1), (a)(5),

(a)(7), or (a)(13) of this section, the

institution shall obtain an appropriate

evaluation of real property collateral

that is consistent with safe and sound

banking practices.

*

*

*

*

*

(d) * * *

(2) Commercial real estate

transactions of more than $400,000. All

federally related transactions that are

commercial real estate transactions

having a transaction value of more than

$400,000 shall require an appraisal

prepared by a State certified appraiser.

*

*

*

*

*

Federal Reserve Board, 12 CFR Part

225

For the reasons set forth in the joint

preamble, the Board amends part 225 of

chapter II of title 12 of the Code of

Federal Regulations as follows:

PART 225—BANK HOLDING

COMPANIES AND CHANGE IN BANK

CONTROL (REGULATION Y)

■4. The authority citation for part 225

continues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 1817(j)(13), 1818,

1828(o), 1831i, 1831p–1, 1843(c)(8), 1844(b),

1972(l), 3106, 3108, 3310, 3331–3351, 3906,

3907, and 3909; 15 U.S.C. 1681s, 1681w,

6801 and 6805.

■5. Section 225.62 is amended by

redesignating paragraphs (e) through (m)

as paragraphs (f) through (n),

respectively, and by adding a new

paragraph (e) to read as follows:

§ 225.62

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

rity: 12 U.S.C. 1817(j)(13), 1818,

1828(o), 1831i, 1831p–1, 1843(c)(8), 1844(b),

1972(l), 3106, 3108, 3310, 3331–3351, 3906,

3907, and 3909; 15 U.S.C. 1681s, 1681w,

6801 and 6805.

■5. Section 225.62 is amended by

redesignating paragraphs (e) through (m)

as paragraphs (f) through (n),

respectively, and by adding a new

paragraph (e) to read as follows:

§ 225.62

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(e) Commercial real estate transaction

means a real estate-related financial

transaction that is not secured by a 1-

to-4 family residential property. A real

estate-related financial transaction to

finance the initial construction of a 1-to-

4 family residential property that does

not include permanent financing is a

commercial real estate transaction.

*

*

*

*

*

■6. Section 225.63 is amended by:

■a. Removing the word ‘‘or’’ at the end

of paragraph (a)(12);

■b. Revising paragraph (a)(13);

■c. Adding paragraph (a)(14);

■d. Revising paragraph (b); and

■e. Revising paragraph (d)(2).

The revisions and addition read as

follows:

§ 225.63

Appraisals required; transactions

requiring a State certified or licensed

appraiser.

(a) * * *

(13) The Board determines that the

services of an appraiser are not

necessary in order to protect Federal

financial and public policy interests in

real estate-related financial transactions

or to protect the safety and soundness

of the institution; or

(14) The transaction is a commercial

real estate transaction that has a

transaction value of $400,000 or less.

(b) Evaluations required. For a

transaction that does not require the

services of a State certified or licensed

appraiser under paragraph (a)(1), (a)(5),

(a)(7), or (a)(14) of this section, the

institution shall obtain an appropriate

evaluation of real property collateral

that is consistent with safe and sound

banking practices.

*

*

*

*

*

as a

transaction value of $400,000 or less.

(b) Evaluations required. For a

transaction that does not require the

services of a State certified or licensed

appraiser under paragraph (a)(1), (a)(5),

(a)(7), or (a)(14) of this section, the

institution shall obtain an appropriate

evaluation of real property collateral

that is consistent with safe and sound

banking practices.

*

*

*

*

*

(d) * * *

(2) Commercial real estate

transactions of more than $400,000. All

federally related transactions that are

commercial real estate transactions

having a transaction value of more than

$400,000 shall require an appraisal

prepared by a State certified appraiser.

*

*

*

*

*

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation,

12 CFR Part 323

For the reasons set forth in the joint

preamble, the FDIC amends part 323 of

chapter III of title 12 of the Code of

Federal Regulations as follows:

PART 323—APPRAISALS

■7. Revise the authority citation for part

323 to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 1818, 1819

[‘‘Seventh’’ and ‘‘Tenth’’], 1831p–1 and 3331

et seq.

■8. Revise the authority citation for

subpart A of part 323 to read as follows:

Authority: This subpart is issued under 12

U.S.C. 1818, 1819 [‘‘Seventh’’ and ‘‘Tenth’’],

1831p–1 and title XI of the Financial

Institutions Reform, Recovery, and

Enforcement Act of 1989 (‘‘FIRREA’’) (Pub. L.

101–73, 103 Stat. 183, 12 U.S.C. 3331 et seq.

(1989)).

■9. Section 323.2 is amended by

redesignating paragraphs (e) through (m)

as paragraphs (f) through (n),

respectively, and by adding a new

paragraph (e) to read as follows:

§ 323.2

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

th’’],

1831p–1 and title XI of the Financial

Institutions Reform, Recovery, and

Enforcement Act of 1989 (‘‘FIRREA’’) (Pub. L.

101–73, 103 Stat. 183, 12 U.S.C. 3331 et seq.

(1989)).

■9. Section 323.2 is amended by

redesignating paragraphs (e) through (m)

as paragraphs (f) through (n),

respectively, and by adding a new

paragraph (e) to read as follows:

§ 323.2

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(e) Commercial real estate transaction

means a real estate-related financial

transaction that is not secured by a 1-

to-4 family residential property. A real

VerDate Sep<11>2014

16:29 Jul 28, 2017

Jkt 241001

PO 00000

Frm 00025

Fmt 4702

Sfmt 4702

E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM

31JYP1

sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35493

Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules

estate-related financial transaction to

finance the initial construction of a 1-to-

4 family residential property that does

not include permanent financing is a

commercial real estate transaction.

*

*

*

*

*

■4. Section 323.3 is amended by:

■a. Removing the word ‘‘or’’ at the end

of paragraph (a)(11);

■b. Revising paragraph (a)(12);

■c. Adding paragraph (a)(13);

■d. Revising paragraph (b); and

■e. Revising paragraph (d)(2).

The revisions and addition read as

follows:

§ 323.3

Appraisals required; transactions

requiring a State certified or licensed

appraiser.

(a) * * *

(12) The FDIC determines that the

services of an appraiser are not

necessary in order to protect Federal

financial and public policy interests in

real estate-related financial transactions

or to protect the safety and soundness

of the institution; or

(13) The transaction is a commercial

real estate transaction that has a

transaction value of $400,000 or less.

(b) Evaluations required. For a

transaction that does not require the

services of a State certified or licensed

appraiser under paragraph (a)(1), (a)(5),

policy interests in

real estate-related financial transactions

or to protect the safety and soundness

of the institution; or

(13) The transaction is a commercial

real estate transaction that has a

transaction value of $400,000 or less.

(b) Evaluations required. For a

transaction that does not require the

services of a State certified or licensed

appraiser under paragraph (a)(1), (a)(5),

(a)(7), or (a)(13) of this section, the

institution shall obtain an appropriate

evaluation of real property collateral

that is consistent with safe and sound

banking practices.

*

*

*

*

*

(d) * * *

(2) Commercial real estate

transactions of more than $400,000. All

federally related transactions that are

commercial real estate transactions

having a transaction value of more than

$400,000 shall require an appraisal

prepared by a State certified appraiser.

*

*

*

*

*

Dated: July 18, 2017.

Keith A. Noreika,

Acting Comptroller of the Currency.

By order of the Board of Governors of the

Federal Reserve System, July 18, 2017.

Margaret McCloskey Shanks,

Deputy Secretary of the Board.

Dated at Washington, DC, this 18th of July,

2017.

By order of the Board of Directors.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.

Robert E. Feldman,

Executive Secretary.

[FR Doc. 2017–15748 Filed 7–28–17; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE P

NATIONAL CREDIT UNION

ADMINISTRATION

12 CFR Part 701

RIN 3133–AE76

Emergency Mergers—Chartering and

Field of Membership

AGENCY: National Credit Union

Administration (NCUA).

ACTION: Proposed rule.

SUMMARY: The NCUA Board (Board)

proposes to amend in its Chartering and

Field of Membership Manual the

definition of the term ‘‘in danger of

insolvency’’ for emergency merger

purposes

ODE P

NATIONAL CREDIT UNION

ADMINISTRATION

12 CFR Part 701

RIN 3133–AE76

Emergency Mergers—Chartering and

Field of Membership

AGENCY: National Credit Union

Administration (NCUA).

ACTION: Proposed rule.

SUMMARY: The NCUA Board (Board)

proposes to amend in its Chartering and

Field of Membership Manual the

definition of the term ‘‘in danger of

insolvency’’ for emergency merger

purposes. The current definition

requires a credit union to fall into at

least one of three net worth categories

over a period of time to be ‘‘in danger

of insolvency.’’ For two of the three

categories, the Board proposes to

lengthen by six months the forecast

horizons, the time period in which

NCUA projects a credit union’s net

worth will decline to the point that it

falls into one of the categories. This will

extend the time period in which a credit

union’s net worth is projected to either

render it insolvent or drop below two

percent from 24 to 30 months and from

12 to 18 months, respectively.

Additionally, the Board proposes to add

a fourth category to the three existing

net worth categories to include credit

unions that have been granted or

received assistance under section 208 of

the Federal Credit Union Act (FCU Act)

in the 15 months prior to the Region’s

determination that the credit union is in

danger of insolvency.

DATES: Comments must be received on

or before September 29, 2017.

ADDRESSES: You may submit comments

by any of the following methods (Please

send comments by one method only):

• Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://

www.regulations.gov. Follow the

instructions for submitting comments.

• NCUA Web site: https://

www.ncua.gov/regulation-supervision/

Pages/rules/proposed.aspx. Follow the

instructions for submitting comments.

• Email: Address to regcomments@

ncua.gov. Include ‘‘[Your name]

Comments on Proposed Rule 701, In

Danger of Insolvency Definition’’ in the

email subject line.

• Fax: (703) 518–6319. Use the

subject line described above for email

r submitting comments.

• NCUA Web site: https://

www.ncua.gov/regulation-supervision/

Pages/rules/proposed.aspx. Follow the

instructions for submitting comments.

• Email: Address to regcomments@

ncua.gov. Include ‘‘[Your name]

Comments on Proposed Rule 701, In

Danger of Insolvency Definition’’ in the

email subject line.

• Fax: (703) 518–6319. Use the

subject line described above for email.

• Mail: Address to Gerard S. Poliquin,

Secretary of the Board, National Credit

Union Administration, 1775 Duke

Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314–

3428.

• Hand Delivery/Courier: Same as

mail address.

Public inspection: You may view all

public comments on NCUA’s Web site

at https://www.ncua.gov/regulation-

supervision/Pages/rules/proposed.aspx

as submitted, except for those we cannot

post for technical reasons. NCUA will

not edit or remove any identifying or

contact information from the public

comments submitted. You may inspect

paper copies of comments in NCUA’s

law library at 1775 Duke Street,

Alexandria, Virginia 22314, by

appointment weekdays between 9 a.m.

and 3 p.m. To make an appointment,

call (703) 518–6546 or send an email to

OGCMail@ncua.gov.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Thomas I. Zells, Staff Attorney, Office of

General Counsel, or Amanda Parkhill,

Loss/Risk Analysis Officer, Office of

Examination and Insurance, at 1775

Duke Street, Alexandria, VA 22314 or

telephone: (703) 548–2478 (Mr. Zells) or

ointment weekdays between 9 a.m.

and 3 p.m. To make an appointment,

call (703) 518–6546 or send an email to

OGCMail@ncua.gov.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Thomas I. Zells, Staff Attorney, Office of

General Counsel, or Amanda Parkhill,

Loss/Risk Analysis Officer, Office of

Examination and Insurance, at 1775

Duke Street, Alexandria, VA 22314 or

telephone: (703) 548–2478 (Mr. Zells) or

(703) 518–6385 (Ms. Parkhill).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

II. Summary of the Proposed Rule

III. Regulatory Procedures

I. Background

Credit unions that experience a sharp

decline in net worth have a much higher

likel

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Appraisal Threshold for Commercial Real Estate Transactions · FDIC FIL-29-2017 | Frix