Community Reinvestment Act Revisions to Interagency Regulations

FederalAgency guidance

Ask Donna

How this section applies to your facts.

FDIC Financial Institution Letters › Community Reinvestment Act Revisions to Interagency Regulations

This text was captured on Aug 14, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live feed, so check the official code before relying on it.

Text

79278

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

1 12 U.S.C. 2903.

2 See 12 CFR parts 25, 228, 345, and 563e.

E–2 CNMI Investor is eligible for

employment in the CNMI only;

*

*

*

*

*

Janet Napolitano,

Secretary.

[FR Doc. 2010–31652 Filed 12–17–10; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 9111–97–P

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY

Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency

12 CFR Part 25

[Docket ID OCC–2010–0021]

RIN 1557–AD34

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

12 CFR Part 228

[Docket No. R–1387]

RIN 7100–AD50

FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE

CORPORATION

12 CFR Part 345

RIN 3064–AD60

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY

Office of Thrift Supervision

12 CFR Part 563e

[Docket ID OTS–2010–0031]

RIN 1550–AC42

Community Reinvestment Act

Regulations

AGENCIES: Office of the Comptroller of

the Currency, Treasury (OCC); Board of

Governors of the Federal Reserve

System (Board); Federal Deposit

Insurance Corporation (FDIC); Office of

Thrift Supervision, Treasury (OTS).

ACTION: Joint final rule.

SUMMARY: The OCC, the Board, the

FDIC, and the OTS (collectively, ‘‘the

agencies’’) are adopting revisions to our

rules implementing the Community

Reinvestment Act (CRA). The agencies

are revising the term ‘‘community

development’’ to include loans,

investments, and services by financial

institutions that support, enable, or

facilitate projects or activities that meet

the ‘‘eligible uses’’ criteria described in

Section 2301(c) of the Housing and

Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA),

as amended, and are conducted in

designated target areas identified in

plans approved by the United States

Department of Housing and Urban

Development (HUD) under the

Neighborhood Stabilization Program

(NSP)

support, enable, or

facilitate projects or activities that meet

the ‘‘eligible uses’’ criteria described in

Section 2301(c) of the Housing and

Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA),

as amended, and are conducted in

designated target areas identified in

plans approved by the United States

Department of Housing and Urban

Development (HUD) under the

Neighborhood Stabilization Program

(NSP). The final rule provides favorable

CRA consideration of such activities

that, pursuant to the requirements of the

program, benefit low-, moderate-, and

middle-income individuals and

geographies in NSP target areas

designated as ‘‘areas of greatest need.’’

Covered activities are considered both

within an institution’s assessment

area(s) and outside of its assessment

area(s), as long as the institution has

adequately addressed the community

development needs of its assessment

area(s). Favorable consideration under

the revised rule will be available until

no later than two years after the last date

appropriated funds for the program are

required to be spent by the grantees. The

agencies will provide reasonable

advance notice to institutions in the

Federal Register regarding termination

of the rule once a date certain has been

identified.

DATES: Effective Date: This joint final

rule is effective January 19, 2011.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

OCC: Michael S. Bylsma, Director, or

Margaret Hesse, Special Counsel,

Community and Consumer Law

Division, (202) 874–5750; or Greg Nagel

or Brian Borkowicz, National Bank

Examiners, Compliance Policy, (202)

874–4428; Office of the Comptroller of

the Currency, 250 E Street, SW.,

Washington, DC 20219.

Board: Paul J. Robin, Manager,

Reserve Bank Oversight and Policy,

INFORMATION CONTACT:

OCC: Michael S. Bylsma, Director, or

Margaret Hesse, Special Counsel,

Community and Consumer Law

Division, (202) 874–5750; or Greg Nagel

or Brian Borkowicz, National Bank

Examiners, Compliance Policy, (202)

874–4428; Office of the Comptroller of

the Currency, 250 E Street, SW.,

Washington, DC 20219.

Board: Paul J. Robin, Manager,

Reserve Bank Oversight and Policy,

(202) 452–3140; or Jamie Z. Goodson,

Attorney, (202) 452–3667; Division of

Consumer and Community Affairs,

Board of Governors of the Federal

Reserve System, 20th Street and

Constitution Avenue, NW., Washington,

DC 20551.

FDIC: Janet Gordon, Senior Policy

Analyst, Division of Supervision and

Consumer Protection, (202) 898–3850 or

Richard Schwartz, Counsel, Legal

Division, (202) 898–7424; Federal

Deposit Insurance Corporation, 550 17th

Street, NW., Washington, DC 20429.

OTS: Stephanie M. Caputo, Senior

Compliance Program Analyst,

Compliance and Consumer Protection,

(202) 906–6549; or Richard Bennett,

Senior Compliance Counsel,

Regulations and Legislation Division,

(202) 906–7409; Office of Thrift

Supervision, 1700 G Street, NW.,

Washington, DC 20552.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

The Community Reinvestment Act

(CRA) requires the Federal banking and

thrift regulatory agencies to assess the

record of each insured depository

institution in helping to meet the credit

needs of its entire community,

including low- and moderate-income

neighborhoods, consistent with the safe

and sound operation of the institution,

and to take that record into account

when the agency evaluates an

application by the institution for a

deposit facility.1 The agencies have

promulgated substantially similar

regulations to implement the

requirements of the CRA.2

There is a pressing need to provide

housing-related assistance to stabilize

communities affected by high levels of

foreclosures

nd operation of the institution,

and to take that record into account

when the agency evaluates an

application by the institution for a

deposit facility.1 The agencies have

promulgated substantially similar

regulations to implement the

requirements of the CRA.2

There is a pressing need to provide

housing-related assistance to stabilize

communities affected by high levels of

foreclosures. High levels of foreclosures

have devastated communities and are

projected to continue into 2012 and

beyond with damaging spillover effects

for low- and moderate-income census

tracts, as well as middle-income census

tracts, affected by high levels of loan

delinquencies and foreclosures. Among

the many consequences of high levels of

foreclosures are growing inventories of

vacant foreclosed properties and

institution ‘‘other real estate owned’’

(OREO) properties, depreciating home

values, declining property tax bases,

and destabilization of communities

directly affected by high levels of

foreclosures and of adjacent and

surrounding neighborhoods.

Neighborhood Stabilization Program

(NSP)

Congress recognized the need to

provide emergency assistance to address

these problems with the establishment

of the Neighborhood Stabilization

Program (NSP) through Division B, Title

III, of the Housing and Economic

Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA), Public

Law 110–289 (2008). Under HERA,

emergency funds (‘‘NSP1’’) totaling

nearly $4 billion for the redevelopment

of abandoned and foreclosed properties

were distributed to States and localities

with the greatest need for such funds

according to a formula based on the

number and percentage of home

foreclosures, the number and percentage

of homes financed by a subprime

mortgage-related loan, and the number

and percentage of homes in default or

delinquency in each State or unit of

general local government

bandoned and foreclosed properties

were distributed to States and localities

with the greatest need for such funds

according to a formula based on the

number and percentage of home

foreclosures, the number and percentage

of homes financed by a subprime

mortgage-related loan, and the number

and percentage of homes in default or

delinquency in each State or unit of

general local government. Under NSP1,

each of the 50 States and Puerto Rico

received a minimum award of $19.6

million and 254 local areas received

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00018

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79279

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

3 See ‘‘Neighborhood Stabilization Grants,’’ http://

www.hud.gov/offices/cpd/communitydevelopment/

programs/neighborhoodspg/nsp1.cfm.

4 See ‘‘Neighborhood Stabilization Program 2,’’

http://www.hud.gov/offices/cpd/

communitydevelopment/programs/

neighborhoodspg/arrafactsheet.cfm.

5 74 FR 21377 (May 7, 2009); 73 FR 58330 (Oct.

6, 2008).

6 HUD published formula allocations and

program requirements for NSP3 grants on October

19, 2010. See 75 FR 64322 (Oct. 19, 2010).

7 NSP2 and NSP3 funds for redevelopment of

demolished or vacant properties may be used only

for housing.

8 Section 1497 of the Dodd-Frank Act amended

Section 2301(f)(3)(A) of HERA. Prior to this

amendment, applicable to NSP1 and NSP2, not less

than 25 percent of funds had to be used ‘‘for the

purchase and redevelopment of abandoned or

foreclosed homes and residential properties that

will be used’’ to house individuals and families

whose incomes do not exceed 50 percent of area

median income.

9 75 FR 36016 (Jun. 24, 2010).

10 70 FR 44256 (Aug. 2, 2005), and 71 FR 18614

(Apr. 12, 2006).

11 See HUD, NSP Frequently Asked Questions,

http://www.hud.gov/offices/cpd/

communitydevelopment/programs/

neighborhoodspg/pdf/

nsp_faq_formula_allocation.pdf

idential properties that

will be used’’ to house individuals and families

whose incomes do not exceed 50 percent of area

median income.

9 75 FR 36016 (Jun. 24, 2010).

10 70 FR 44256 (Aug. 2, 2005), and 71 FR 18614

(Apr. 12, 2006).

11 See HUD, NSP Frequently Asked Questions,

http://www.hud.gov/offices/cpd/

communitydevelopment/programs/

neighborhoodspg/pdf/

nsp_faq_formula_allocation.pdf.

grants totaling $1.86 billion ranging

from $2.0 million to $62.2 million.3

Using similar criteria, the American

Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009

(ARRA), Public Law 111–5 (2009),

provided supplementary NSP funding

(‘‘NSP2’’) to be awarded as grants,

through a competitive bidding process,

to State and local governments, as well

as to non-profit organizations and

consortia of non-profit entities. On

January 14, 2010, HUD awarded a

combined total of nearly $2 billion in

NSP2 grants.4 To receive NSP funding,

each grantee was required to submit an

action plan or application, including

any amendments thereto, to HUD

according to specific alternative

requirements set out by HUD in 2008

and 2009.5

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform

and Consumer Protection Act (the

Dodd-Frank Act), Public Law 111–203,

enacted July 21, 2010, provided $1

billion in additional NSP funding to be

allocated by a funding formula to be

established by HUD within 30 days after

enactment. Under the Dodd-Frank Act,

HUD’s funding formula will continue to

consider the same criteria regarding

foreclosure rates, subprime mortgages,

and home mortgage defaults and

delinquencies and each State will

receive not less than 0.5 percent of the

new funds

d $1

billion in additional NSP funding to be

allocated by a funding formula to be

established by HUD within 30 days after

enactment. Under the Dodd-Frank Act,

HUD’s funding formula will continue to

consider the same criteria regarding

foreclosure rates, subprime mortgages,

and home mortgage defaults and

delinquencies and each State will

receive not less than 0.5 percent of the

new funds. Each State or local

government grantee must establish

procedures to create preferences for the

development of affordable rental

housing for properties assisted with the

funds made available under the Dodd-

Frank Act.6 On September 8, 2010, HUD

announced the allocation of $970

million in NSP3 funding to 283 grantees

nationwide and has issued guidance to

grantees on the preparation and

submission of action plans.

Section 2301(c) of HERA, as amended,

establishes five activities that are

‘‘eligible uses’’ of NSP funds (for

purposes of this rule, designated as

‘‘NSP-eligible activities’’). NSP-eligible

activities are projects or activities that

use the NSP funds to: (1) Establish

financing mechanisms for purchase and

redevelopment of foreclosed upon

homes and residential properties,

including such mechanisms as soft-

seconds, loan loss reserves, and shared

equity loans for low- and moderate-

income homebuyers; (2) purchase and

rehabilitate homes and residential

properties that have been abandoned or

foreclosed upon, in order to sell, rent, or

redevelop such homes and properties;

sms for purchase and

redevelopment of foreclosed upon

homes and residential properties,

including such mechanisms as soft-

seconds, loan loss reserves, and shared

equity loans for low- and moderate-

income homebuyers; (2) purchase and

rehabilitate homes and residential

properties that have been abandoned or

foreclosed upon, in order to sell, rent, or

redevelop such homes and properties;

(3) establish and operate land banks for

homes and residential properties that

have been foreclosed upon; (4) demolish

blighted structures; and (5) redevelop

demolished or vacant properties.7 In

addition, Section 2301(f)(3)(A) of HERA,

as amended, provides that all NSP funds

must be used with respect to

individuals and families whose income

does not exceed 120 percent of the area

median income, and not less than 25

percent of funds must be used to house

individuals and families whose incomes

do not exceed 50 percent of area median

income.8

HUD approves NSP action plans and

applications, including amendments

thereto (hereinafter referred to as ‘‘NSP

plans’’ or ‘‘plans’’), for all NSP grantees.

These public documents must designate

‘‘areas of greatest need’’ for targeting

NSP-eligible activities, consistent with

statutory criteria. The vast majority of

NSP-targeted areas are listed on a map

database located on HUD’s Web site at:

http://www.hud.gov/nspmaps.

However, there may be a few NSP-

targeted geographies in HUD-approved

State NSP1 plans that are not identified

in the HUD census tract database.

Information about these targeted areas

may be found in the individual plans.

NSP3 targeting data will periodically be

added to these maps in a timely manner

following approval of grantee action

plans.

HUD has allocated NSP funds in a

way that assists communities with the

greatest need to address the adverse

consequences of elevated foreclosure

levels, consistent with Congressional

intent

nformation about these targeted areas

may be found in the individual plans.

NSP3 targeting data will periodically be

added to these maps in a timely manner

following approval of grantee action

plans.

HUD has allocated NSP funds in a

way that assists communities with the

greatest need to address the adverse

consequences of elevated foreclosure

levels, consistent with Congressional

intent. Allowing institutions to receive

CRA consideration for NSP-eligible

activities in NSP-targeted areas creates

an opportunity to leverage government

funding targeted to areas with high

foreclosure or vacancy rates.

Proposed Rule

The definition of ‘‘community

development’’ is a key definition in the

agencies’ CRA regulations. Financial

institutions receive positive

consideration in their CRA

examinations for community

development loans, qualified

investments, and community

development services which have a

primary purpose of ‘‘community

development.’’

The agencies proposed to revise the

interagency CRA regulations by adding

to the definition of ‘‘community

development’’ loans, investments, and

services that support, enable, or

facilitate NSP-eligible activities in

designated target areas identified in

plans approved by HUD under the

NSP.9 For example, under the proposed

revised definition of ‘‘community

development,’’ a financial institution

would receive favorable CRA

consideration for a donation of OREO

properties to non-profit housing

organizations in eligible middle-income,

as well as low- and moderate-income,

geographies. In addition, under the

proposal, institutions would receive

favorable CRA consideration if they

provided financing for the purchase and

rehabilitation of foreclosed, abandoned,

or vacant properties in targeted areas

favorable CRA

consideration for a donation of OREO

properties to non-profit housing

organizations in eligible middle-income,

as well as low- and moderate-income,

geographies. In addition, under the

proposal, institutions would receive

favorable CRA consideration if they

provided financing for the purchase and

rehabilitation of foreclosed, abandoned,

or vacant properties in targeted areas.

Other examples of activities that would

receive favorable CRA consideration

under the proposal are loans,

investments, and services that support

the redevelopment of demolished or

vacant properties in such areas,

consistent with eligible uses for NSP

funds.

Although the CRA rules expressly

encourage activities that benefit low- or

moderate-income individuals or

geographies, the agencies have created

limited exceptions to address certain

adverse circumstances that may affect

middle-income individuals and

geographies.10 The agencies believe that

the purposes of CRA can be served by

providing CRA incentives to institutions

to engage in community development

loans, investments and services that

meet the narrowly tailored requirements

of the NSP. First, HUD has stated that

its funding of these programs was

designed to satisfy Congressional intent

that the funds have maximum impact

and be targeted to States and local

communities with the greatest needs.11

In addition, while, by its statutory

terms, the NSP may benefit middle-

income individuals, grantees must use

at least 25 percent of their funds to

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00019

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

e maximum impact

and be targeted to States and local

communities with the greatest needs.11

In addition, while, by its statutory

terms, the NSP may benefit middle-

income individuals, grantees must use

at least 25 percent of their funds to

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00019

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79280

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

12 The Board also received over 650 other

comments that stated that banks should not receive

an ‘‘outstanding’’ rating if they contributed to

economic decline and should assist their

communities, should not be allowed to pick the

geographic area or affiliates considered, and should

get a ‘‘failing’’ rating if they discriminate against

African-American and Latino communities.

house low-income individuals and

families.

Under the current CRA rules, an

institution is evaluated primarily on

how well it helps meet the credit and

community development needs of its

CRA assessment area(s). However, the

agencies note that many foreclosed

residential properties owned by an

institution may be located in areas that

are outside of the institution’s CRA

assessment area(s). Restricting CRA

consideration of NSP-eligible activities

to an institution’s assessment area(s)

may not fully help to promote

Congress’s objectives for the NSP.

Therefore, the proposed rule provided

that an institution that has adequately

addressed the community development

needs of its assessment area(s) may

receive favorable consideration for NSP-

eligible activities under this provision

that are outside of its assessment area(s).

There is precedent for allowing

greater flexibility concerning the CRA

focus on assessment area(s) in certain

temporary and exigent circumstances

ovided

that an institution that has adequately

addressed the community development

needs of its assessment area(s) may

receive favorable consideration for NSP-

eligible activities under this provision

that are outside of its assessment area(s).

There is precedent for allowing

greater flexibility concerning the CRA

focus on assessment area(s) in certain

temporary and exigent circumstances.

For example, in 2006, the agencies

issued a supervisory policy statement

providing that an institution would

receive favorable CRA consideration for

engaging in activities that helped

revitalize or stabilize areas affected by

Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, even if

such areas were not in the institution’s

assessment area(s), provided the

institution had adequately met the CRA-

related needs of its assessment area(s).

Finally, the agencies stated their

intention that the proposed rule be

generally tied to the duration of the

NSP. As described more fully below, the

NSP does not have a ‘‘sunset’’ date.

Therefore, a specific termination date

for the regulatory provision was not

proposed. Instead, the proposed rule

provided that NSP-eligible activities

would receive favorable consideration

under the new rule if conducted no later

than two years after the last date

appropriated funds for the program are

required to be spent by the grantees. The

proposal indicated that the agencies will

provide reasonable advance notice to

institutions in the Federal Register

regarding termination of the rule once a

date certain has been identified.

The proposed rule would have

imposed no new requirements on

institutions. It simply would have

expanded the categories of activities

that qualify for CRA consideration as

‘‘community development.’’ No

institution would be required to provide

loans, investments, or services pursuant

to the proposed expanded definition

arding termination of the rule once a

date certain has been identified.

The proposed rule would have

imposed no new requirements on

institutions. It simply would have

expanded the categories of activities

that qualify for CRA consideration as

‘‘community development.’’ No

institution would be required to provide

loans, investments, or services pursuant

to the proposed expanded definition. In

addition, any community development

loans that may be made by large

institutions under the proposed new

provision would be covered under

existing loan reporting requirements. As

such, no new reporting requirements

and negligible, if any, administrative

costs would result from the proposed

rule if adopted. The agencies

anticipated that the proposal, if

finalized, would provide an incentive

for institutions to engage in activities

that stabilize foreclosure affected

communities approved for NSP projects.

Thus, the proposed rule would create an

opportunity to leverage government

funded projects with complementary

private financing in areas targeted for

assistance with minimal, if any,

regulatory burden or costs.

Review of Comments on the Proposed

Rule and Agencies’ Final Rule

Together, the agencies received 34

comments addressing the proposed

revision that would expand the

definition of ‘‘community

development.’’ 12 The commenters

represented a variety of industry,

consumer, community development,

and governmental entities. The

commenters generally supported

expanding the definition of ‘‘community

development’’ to encourage housing-

related assistance to stabilize

communities affected by high levels of

foreclosures and delinquencies.

In addition to a request for comments

generally, the agencies asked for and

received comment on five specific

issues in connection with the proposal

and governmental entities. The

commenters generally supported

expanding the definition of ‘‘community

development’’ to encourage housing-

related assistance to stabilize

communities affected by high levels of

foreclosures and delinquencies.

In addition to a request for comments

generally, the agencies asked for and

received comment on five specific

issues in connection with the proposal.

Activities Eligible for CRA

Consideration: Virtually all of the

commenters supported the intent of the

proposed rule to permit CRA

consideration, as a component of the

regulatory ‘‘community development’’

definition, of loans, investments, and

services that support activities that are

NSP-eligible and are conducted in NSP-

targeted areas. In particular, the

agencies requested comment on whether

favorable CRA consideration should be

limited to support of those activities

specified in a HUD-approved NSP plan

for the relevant area or support of

specific activities that have been funded

by the NSP. The commenters that

specifically addressed the question

opposed limiting CRA consideration to

such activities. For example, a

community development organization

stated that so limiting covered activities

would unduly burden banks and

examiners by requiring them to verify

that an activity was covered by a plan.

A few industry and government

commenters suggested that the agencies

adopt a broader rule that provides

express CRA consideration for activities

that are not NSP-eligible and/or are

outside of geographies covered in NSP-

targeted areas. Several other

commenters stated that the agencies

should provide consideration for

activities that are NSP-eligible, but are

not specifically covered in the

underlying NSP plans. By contrast, six

community development organizations

that target low- and moderate-income

communities stated that donations of

OREO in poor condition can carry

associated costs and liability for a

receiving organization

ther

commenters stated that the agencies

should provide consideration for

activities that are NSP-eligible, but are

not specifically covered in the

underlying NSP plans. By contrast, six

community development organizations

that target low- and moderate-income

communities stated that donations of

OREO in poor condition can carry

associated costs and liability for a

receiving organization. These

organizations recommended providing

favorable CRA consideration for such

donations only if they are consistent

with local and/or regional government

or nonprofit plans and the donor

institutions fund associated costs, such

as demolition and environmental

remediation costs. The agencies will

consider the credit given to donations of

OREO as part of their general regulatory

review of CRA regulations.

The agencies have considered the

comments on the scope of the

‘‘community development’’ definition

and are adopting the revision to the

definition as proposed, with only minor

changes to statutory references. This

revision to the definition of ‘‘community

development’’ is narrowly tailored to

encourage financial institutions to

support stabilization efforts in targeted

areas identified by the Federal

government as having greater need for

assistance as a result of the foreclosure

crisis. Commenters opposed limiting

favorable CRA consideration to those

NSP-eligible activities expressly

described in NSP plans or to those

funded by NSP programs, as discussed

above. The agencies note that the final

rule allows institutions to receive CRA

consideration for supporting, enabling,

or facilitating NSP-eligible activities in

the geographic areas targeted in NSP

program plans.

As noted above, the agencies believe

that allowing institutions to receive

CRA consideration for supporting,

enabling, or facilitating NSP-eligible

activities in NSP-targeted areas will

help to leverage scarce government

funding to those designated areas with

the greatest need for such activities

facilitating NSP-eligible activities in

the geographic areas targeted in NSP

program plans.

As noted above, the agencies believe

that allowing institutions to receive

CRA consideration for supporting,

enabling, or facilitating NSP-eligible

activities in NSP-targeted areas will

help to leverage scarce government

funding to those designated areas with

the greatest need for such activities.

Finalization of this rule will provide an

immediate incentive for institutions to

undertake activities that will support

the stabilization of areas targeted for

NSP-initiatives.

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00020

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79281

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

13 12 CFR 25.12(g)(4), 228.12(g)(4), 345.12(g)(4),

and 563e.12(g)(4).

14 Interagency Questions and Answers Regarding

Community Reinvestment (Questions and

Answers), 75 FR 11642, 11647, 11650–51, 11654–

55 (Mar. 11, 2010) (Q&As § ll.12(g)(4)(i)–1,

§ ll.12(i)–3, and § ll.22(a)–1).

15 Questions and Answers, 75 FR at 11652–53

(Q&A § ll.12(t)–5).

16 Questions and Answers, 75 FR at 11650–51,

11657 (Q&As § ll.12(i)–1, § ll.12(i)–3, and

§ ll.22(b)(5)–1).

17 Under the agencies’ current CRA regulations,

‘‘community development’’ includes activities

related to affordable multifamily housing, and a

‘‘community development loan’’ includes

construction and permanent financing of

multifamily rental property serving low- and

moderate-income persons. 12 CFR 25.12(g)(1),

228.12(g)(1), 345.12(g)(1), and 563e.12(g)(1);

Questions and Answers, 75 FR at 11648 (Q&A

§ ll.12(h)–1). Further, a ‘‘home mortgage loan’’

includes a multifamily dwelling loan, and a

‘‘qualified investment’’ includes an investment,

grant, deposit, or share in organizations engaged in

rehabilitating or constructing affordable multifamily

rental housing

te-income persons. 12 CFR 25.12(g)(1),

228.12(g)(1), 345.12(g)(1), and 563e.12(g)(1);

Questions and Answers, 75 FR at 11648 (Q&A

§ ll.12(h)–1). Further, a ‘‘home mortgage loan’’

includes a multifamily dwelling loan, and a

‘‘qualified investment’’ includes an investment,

grant, deposit, or share in organizations engaged in

rehabilitating or constructing affordable multifamily

rental housing. Questions and Answers, 75 FR at

11651–52 (Q&As § ll.12(l)–1 and § ll.12(t)–4).

18 Questions and Answers, 75 FR at 11652 (Q&A

§ ll.12(t)–4).

19 See 75 FR 35686 (Jun. 23, 2010).

20 In the proposed rule text, the agencies referred

to Section 2301(c)(3) of the HERA with regard to

that provision’s NSP ‘‘eligible uses’’ definition.

Section 2301(c)(3) was changed to 2301(c)(4) in the

Helping Families Save Their Homes Act of 2009,

Public Law 111–22, § 105(a) (2009). Rather than

change the reference in the regulatory text, and risk

having to change that reference in the future, the

agencies are using the term ‘‘eligible uses’’ and

referring to Section 2301(c) generally.

21 70 FR 44256 (Aug. 2, 2005) and 71 FR 18614

(Apr. 12, 2006).

In addition, the agencies note that,

under the current CRA rules and

interagency guidance, CRA

consideration is already available for

some neighborhood stabilization

activities. First, revitalization and

stabilization activities in low- and

moderate-income geographies or in

distressed or underserved

nonmetropolitan middle-income

geographies receive positive

consideration under the existing CRA

rules, regardless of whether these areas

are targeted areas under the NSP.13

Similarly, foreclosure prevention

programs may also receive positive CRA

consideration, for example, if they are

part of a loan program that is designed

to provide sustainable relief to

homeowners facing foreclosure on their

primary residences or if they help to

revitalize or stabilize low- or moderate-

income geographies.14 In addition,

below-market sales and donations of

OREO properties to non

y, foreclosure prevention

programs may also receive positive CRA

consideration, for example, if they are

part of a loan program that is designed

to provide sustainable relief to

homeowners facing foreclosure on their

primary residences or if they help to

revitalize or stabilize low- or moderate-

income geographies.14 In addition,

below-market sales and donations of

OREO properties to nonprofit

organizations, consistent with safe and

sound banking operations, also may

receive positive consideration under the

existing CRA rules. The CRA rules

provide favorable consideration for

grants, which would include an in-kind

donation of property. If these grants

have a primary purpose of community

development, such as to provide

affordable housing to low- and

moderate-income individuals, they also

would already receive positive CRA

consideration as a qualified

investment.15 Further, favorable CRA

consideration is given for technical

assistance about financial services to

community-based groups, local or Tribal

government agencies, or intermediaries

that help to meet the credit needs of

low- and moderate-income individuals

or small businesses and farms.16

Favorable CRA consideration also is

available for certain activities involving

multifamily housing.17 In addition,

economic development activities not

directly related to housing may qualify

for favorable CRA consideration. For

example, ‘‘qualified investments’’ for

which favorable CRA consideration may

be given include investments, grants,

deposits, or shares in or to organizations

supporting activities essential to the

capacity of low- and moderate-income

individuals or geographies to utilize

credit or to sustain economic

development.18

Finally, the agencies note that they

have begun a regulatory review of the

CRA rules generally, and as part of that

regulatory review, the agencies will

carefully consider any comments

received through this rulemaking that

may recommend further changes to the

definition of ‘‘community

nd moderate-income

individuals or geographies to utilize

credit or to sustain economic

development.18

Finally, the agencies note that they

have begun a regulatory review of the

CRA rules generally, and as part of that

regulatory review, the agencies will

carefully consider any comments

received through this rulemaking that

may recommend further changes to the

definition of ‘‘community

development.’’19

Reference to Statutes Appropriating

Funds to NSP: In the proposal, the

regulatory text specifically referred to

the two statutes that authorized funds

under NSP1 and NSP2, the HERA and

the American Recovery and

Reinvestment Act of 2009, respectively.

As stated above, since the agencies

issued their proposal, Congress

provided an additional $1 billion to the

NSP under the Dodd-Frank Act. Based

on this additional authorization and the

fact that the rule’s reference to the NSP

now covers any of that program’s

iterations (thus far NSP1, NSP2, and

NSP3), the agencies need to amend the

final regulatory language to account for

these funds. Rather than add a reference

to the Dodd-Frank Act, and thereafter

amend the rule whenever a statute

provides additional funds, the agencies

have revised § __.12(g)(5)(i) to refer

solely to HERA.20

Sunset: The duration of the agencies’

proposed rule was generally linked to

the duration of the NSP. Under NSP1,

grantees must expend NSP funds within

four years of the date the grant is

awarded. Under NSP2, grantees have

three years from that date to fully spend

the grant, and HUD was required to

obligate all funds appropriated for NSP2

in February 2010. The funds

appropriated in the Dodd-Frank Act also

must be fully expended by grantees

within three years after they receive

their grants, and HUD is required to

obligate all funds appropriated by the

Dodd-Frank Act by July 2011. Since the

NSP does not have a termination date,

Congress could appropriate additional

funds for the program in future years

ppropriated for NSP2

in February 2010. The funds

appropriated in the Dodd-Frank Act also

must be fully expended by grantees

within three years after they receive

their grants, and HUD is required to

obligate all funds appropriated by the

Dodd-Frank Act by July 2011. Since the

NSP does not have a termination date,

Congress could appropriate additional

funds for the program in future years.

Therefore, a specific termination date

for the regulatory provision was not

proposed. Instead, the proposed rule

provided that NSP-eligible activities

would receive favorable consideration

under the new rule if conducted no later

than two years after the last date

appropriated funds for the program are

required to be spent by the grantees.

Most commenters supported the

proposal to allow CRA consideration of

qualifying loans, investments, and

services that are provided no later than

two years after the last date

appropriated funds for the program are

required to be spent by grantees. A few

commenters stated that there should be

no ‘‘sunset’’ date. These commenters

asserted that need for NSP-eligible

activities will remain even after Federal

funding is no longer available;

continuing CRA consideration would

encourage financial institutions to help

to meet those needs.

The agencies carefully considered

these comments and are adopting the

revision as proposed. The agencies

believe that two years after the last date

appropriated funds for the program are

required to be spent by grantees

generally allows sufficient time for

institutions to engage in meaningful

community development activities in

NSP-targeted areas. As indicated in the

proposal, the agencies will provide

reasonable advance notice to

institutions in the Federal Register

regarding termination of the rule once a

certain date has been identified

iated funds for the program are

required to be spent by grantees

generally allows sufficient time for

institutions to engage in meaningful

community development activities in

NSP-targeted areas. As indicated in the

proposal, the agencies will provide

reasonable advance notice to

institutions in the Federal Register

regarding termination of the rule once a

certain date has been identified.

Benefit to Low-, Moderate-, and

Middle-Income Communities: As noted

above, the CRA rules expressly

encourage activities that benefit low- or

moderate-income individuals or

geographies. Nevertheless, to address

certain adverse circumstances, the

agencies have created limited

exceptions to permit favorable

consideration of activities that benefit

middle-income individuals and

geographies in addition to low- and

moderate-income individuals and

geographies.21

Most commenters supported the

expansion to permit CRA consideration

of activities that may benefit middle-

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00021

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79282

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

22 See 5 U.S.C. 603(a).

23 See 5 U.S.C. 605(b).

income individuals and communities,

consistent with the NSP program.

Although a few of these commenters

emphasized that the focus of CRA

should continue to be on low- and

moderate-income households and

neighborhoods, the commenters

supported the proposal to redefine

‘‘community development’’ to align with

NSP-eligible activities in designated

areas identified in plans approved by

HUD.

After careful review of these

comments and as proposed, the agencies

are including activities that benefit

middle-income individuals and

geographies among the activities for

which the agencies may provide

favorable CRA consideration under the

final rule

l to redefine

‘‘community development’’ to align with

NSP-eligible activities in designated

areas identified in plans approved by

HUD.

After careful review of these

comments and as proposed, the agencies

are including activities that benefit

middle-income individuals and

geographies among the activities for

which the agencies may provide

favorable CRA consideration under the

final rule.

Recognition of NSP–Eligible Activities

Outside of Assessment Area(s): Under

the current CRA rules, an institution is

evaluated primarily on how it helps

meet the credit and community

development needs of its CRA

assessment area(s). However, many

foreclosed properties owned by an

institution may be located in areas that

are outside of the institution’s CRA

assessment area(s). As noted in the

proposal, restricting CRA consideration

of NSP-eligible activities to an

institution’s assessment area(s) may not

fully help to promote Congress’s

objectives for the NSP. Therefore, the

proposed rule provided that an

institution that has adequately

addressed the community development

needs of its assessment area(s) may

receive favorable consideration for NSP-

eligible activities under this provision

that are outside of its assessment area(s).

The agencies also specifically asked for

comment on this aspect of the proposal.

The commenters that addressed this

issue unanimously supported allowing

CRA consideration for NSP projects

outside of an institution’s assessment

area(s), provided the institution has met

the community development needs

within its assessment area(s). Several

commenters suggested that the agencies

should issue additional guidance on, for

example, how financial institutions may

demonstrate that they have adequately

met the needs in their assessment

area(s) and how outside-the-assessment

area activities will be allocated toward

an institution’s State-wide and overall

CRA ratings

community development needs

within its assessment area(s). Several

commenters suggested that the agencies

should issue additional guidance on, for

example, how financial institutions may

demonstrate that they have adequately

met the needs in their assessment

area(s) and how outside-the-assessment

area activities will be allocated toward

an institution’s State-wide and overall

CRA ratings. One financial institution

trade association suggested that

community banks receive favorable CRA

consideration for NSP-eligible activities

in the banks’ assessment areas whether

or not the area is in an NSP-targeted

area.

The agencies carefully considered

these comments and are adopting the

rule as proposed. The final rule, like the

proposal, allows institutions to receive

favorable consideration for activities

that benefit low-, moderate-, and

middle-income individuals and

geographies in the institution’s

assessment area(s) or areas outside the

bank’s assessment area(s) provided the

institution has adequately addressed the

community development needs of its

assessment area(s). To the extent

additional guidance may be needed on

this provision, the agencies will

consider it in connection with a future

revision of the Interagency Questions

and Answers Regarding Community

Reinvestment or examination

procedures.

Potential Costs and Benefits: Only

five commenters directly responded to

the agencies’ request for comment on

the potential costs and benefits of the

proposed rule, if adopted. Most of these

commenters predicted there would be

only negligible costs associated with the

proposed revision, typically in the form

of additional administrative costs,

including capturing loan data, and

training. These commenters generally

thought that the rule would result in

some benefit to communities affected by

the foreclosure crisis

s and benefits of the

proposed rule, if adopted. Most of these

commenters predicted there would be

only negligible costs associated with the

proposed revision, typically in the form

of additional administrative costs,

including capturing loan data, and

training. These commenters generally

thought that the rule would result in

some benefit to communities affected by

the foreclosure crisis. A trade

association of community banks and a

financial institution stated that they

anticipate additional administrative

costs for loan documentation and

reporting and for staff training if the

proposed rule is adopted but did not

estimate those costs.

Effect on an Institution’s Decisions

about Community Development

Activities: The agencies also asked for

specific comment about whether and

the extent to which the proposed rule,

if adopted, would affect an institution’s

decisions about the amount, type, and

location of community development

loans, investments, and services it will

provide. Four of the five commenters

that addressed this request for comment

believed that the rule would affect

positively an institution’s decisions

about the types and amount of

community development activities it

will provide. The other commenter

stated that the rule would provide an

incentive for institutions to engage in

NSP-eligible activities, but might not

substantially alter institutions’ general

CRA decision-making.

Effective Date

The final rule becomes effective 30

days after publication in the Federal

Register. That effective date is

consistent with section 553 of the

Administrative Procedure Act, which

provides that a substantive rule may not

be made effective until 30 days after

publication in the Federal Register,

with specified exceptions. 5 U.S.C.

553(d)

utions’ general

CRA decision-making.

Effective Date

The final rule becomes effective 30

days after publication in the Federal

Register. That effective date is

consistent with section 553 of the

Administrative Procedure Act, which

provides that a substantive rule may not

be made effective until 30 days after

publication in the Federal Register,

with specified exceptions. 5 U.S.C.

553(d). Section 302 of the Riegle

Community Development and

Regulatory Improvement Act of 1994

(CDRI) provides that regulations

prescribed by a Federal banking agency

that contain additional reporting,

disclosure, or other new requirements

on insured depository institutions shall

take effect on the first day of a calendar

quarter that begins on or after the date

on which the regulations are published

in final form, with certain exceptions.

12 U.S.C. 4802(b). Section 302 of the

CDFR does not apply to this final rule

because the final rule does not prescribe

additional reporting, disclosures, or

other new requirements on insured

depository institutions. As discussed in

detail above in the SUPPLEMENTARY

INFORMATION, the final rule instead

expands the types of activities for which

such institutions may receive favorable

CRA consideration.

Regulatory Analysis

Paperwork Reduction Act

In accordance with the Paperwork

Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. Ch.

3506; 5 CFR part 1320 Appendix A.1),

each agency reviewed its final rule and

determined that there are no collections

of information. The final rule would

expand the types of activities that

qualify for CRA consideration, if an

institution chooses to engage in them,

but it would not impose any new

requirements, including paperwork

requirements. The overall cost of this

final rule is expected to be negligible, at

most. The amendments could have a

negligible effect on burden estimates for

existing information collections,

including recordkeeping requirements

for community development loans

RA consideration, if an

institution chooses to engage in them,

but it would not impose any new

requirements, including paperwork

requirements. The overall cost of this

final rule is expected to be negligible, at

most. The amendments could have a

negligible effect on burden estimates for

existing information collections,

including recordkeeping requirements

for community development loans.

Regulatory Flexibility Act

The Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA)

generally requires agencies that are

issuing a final rule to prepare and make

available for public comment a

regulatory flexibility analysis that

describes the impact of the final rule on

small entities.22 The RFA provides that

agencies are not required to prepare and

publish a regulatory flexibility act

analysis if the agencies certify that the

final rule will not, if promulgated, have

a significant economic impact on a

substantial number of small entities.23

The Small Business Administration

(SBA) has defined ‘‘small entities’’ for

banking purposes as a bank or savings

association with $175 million or less in

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00022

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79283

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

24 A financial institution’s assets are determined

by averaging the assets reported on its four

immediately preceding full quarterly financial

statements.

assets.24 13 CFR 121.201. Each agency

has reviewed the impact of this final

rule on the small entities subject to its

regulation and supervision and

addresses the RFA requirements, as

appropriate, below.

OCC: The OCC has reviewed the final

amendments to Part 25. The final rule

would expand the definition of the term

‘‘community development,’’ which is

applied in the CRA regulations’

performance tests

FR 121.201. Each agency

has reviewed the impact of this final

rule on the small entities subject to its

regulation and supervision and

addresses the RFA requirements, as

appropriate, below.

OCC: The OCC has reviewed the final

amendments to Part 25. The final rule

would expand the definition of the term

‘‘community development,’’ which is

applied in the CRA regulations’

performance tests. However, the final

rule does not impose new requirements

on small entities because the CRA

performance test for small entities (as

defined above) does not require

community development activities.

Rather, the final rule reduces burden by

expanding the types of community

development activities for which

institutions may receive CRA

consideration. Only 605 national banks

are small entities based on the SBA’s

general principles of affiliation (13 CFR

121.103(a)) and the size threshold for

commercial banks and trust companies.

The OCC reviewed national banks with

assets of less than $175 million that are

evaluated under the lending,

investment, and service tests, which are

normally applicable to large banks, the

community development test, which is

applicable to wholesale and limited

purpose banks, and the community

development performance factor

applicable to intermediate small banks.

As of June 30, 2010, only 13 of the 605

national banks that are small entities

would be evaluated on their community

development activities under these

examination types. The rest would be

evaluated under the small bank

examination procedures, which do not

require consideration of community

development activities. The OCC has

determined and therefore certifies,

pursuant to section 605(b) of the RFA,

that the final rule will not have a

significant economic impact on a

substantial number of small entities.

OTS: The OTS has reviewed the final

amendments to Part 563e

would be

evaluated under the small bank

examination procedures, which do not

require consideration of community

development activities. The OCC has

determined and therefore certifies,

pursuant to section 605(b) of the RFA,

that the final rule will not have a

significant economic impact on a

substantial number of small entities.

OTS: The OTS has reviewed the final

amendments to Part 563e. The final rule

would expand the definition of the term

‘‘community development,’’ which is

applied in the CRA regulations’

performance tests. However, the final

rule does not impose new requirements

on small entities because the CRA

performance test for small entities (as

defined above) does not require

community development activities.

Rather, the final rule reduces burden by

expanding the types of community

development activities for which

institutions may receive CRA

consideration. The Small Business

Administration (SBA) has defined

‘‘small entities’’ for banking purposes as

a savings association with $175 million

or less in assets. See 13 CFR 121.201. As

of September 23, 2010, only 361 OTS-

regulated thrifts are small entities with

assets of $175 million or less. However,

also as of that date, only three of those

small savings associations are wholesale

or limited purpose savings associations

whose community development

activities would be evaluated as an

automatic part of the CRA examination

process. Another three are special

purpose savings associations not subject

to CRA. The OTS has determined and

therefore certifies, pursuant to section

605(b) of the RFA, that the final rule

will not have a significant economic

impact on a substantial number of small

entities.

FDIC: The FDIC has reviewed the

proposed amendments to part 345. The

proposal does not impose new

requirements on small entities because

the CRA performance test for small

entities (as defined above) does not

require community development

activities

t to section

605(b) of the RFA, that the final rule

will not have a significant economic

impact on a substantial number of small

entities.

FDIC: The FDIC has reviewed the

proposed amendments to part 345. The

proposal does not impose new

requirements on small entities because

the CRA performance test for small

entities (as defined above) does not

require community development

activities. Rather, the proposed rule

reduces burden by expanding the types

of community development activities

for which institutions may receive CRA

consideration. As of June 30, 2010, FDIC

regulated entities under the SBA’s size

criteria, with assets of less than $175

million, totaled 2840. However, also as

of that date, only 5 of those banks that

are small entities would be required to

engage in community development

activities under the examination types

that include such consideration. The

FDIC has determined and therefore

certifies, pursuant to section 605(b) of

the RFA, that the final rule will not have

a significant economic impact on a

substantial number of small entities.

Board: The Regulatory Flexibility Act

(5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) (RFA) requires an

agency to perform an initial and final

regulatory flexibility analysis on the

impact a rule is expected to have on

small entities. The Small Business

Administration has defined ‘‘small

entities’’ for banking purposes as a

banking organization with $175 million

or less in assets. See 13 CFR 121.201.

The Board received no comments

directly addressing the initial regulatory

flexibility analysis. The Board has

prepared the following final regulatory

flexibility analysis pursuant to section

604 of the RFA.

1. Statement of the need for, and

objectives of, the final rule

all

entities’’ for banking purposes as a

banking organization with $175 million

or less in assets. See 13 CFR 121.201.

The Board received no comments

directly addressing the initial regulatory

flexibility analysis. The Board has

prepared the following final regulatory

flexibility analysis pursuant to section

604 of the RFA.

1. Statement of the need for, and

objectives of, the final rule. As

explained above in the supplementary

information, the Board believes that it is

desirable to expand eligibility for

favorable CRA consideration to NSP-

eligible activities and areas, in order to

provide financial institutions incentives

to leverage NSP funding by providing

loans, investments, and services in areas

with high foreclosure or vacancy rates.

The final rule expands the definition of

the term ‘‘community development,’’

which is applied in the CRA

regulations’ performance tests.

However, it does not impose new

requirements on small entities because

the CRA performance test for small

entities does not require community

development activities. Rather, the final

rule expands the types of community

development activities for which

institutions may receive CRA

consideration.

2. Summary of the significant issues

raised by public comment in response to

the Board’s initial analysis, the Board’s

assessment of such issues, and a

statement of any changes made as a

result of such comments. The Board

published an initial regulatory

flexibility analysis in connection with

the proposed rule and requested

comment on the effect of the proposed

rule on small entities. See 75 FR 36016,

36020 (Jun. 24, 2010). The Board

received no comments specifically

addressing the Board’s initial regulatory

flexibility analysis. A financial

institution trade association and a bank

stated that institutions that seek CRA

consideration for covered activities

under a final rule would incur

administrative costs, such as costs for

documentation of activities and

training

See 75 FR 36016,

36020 (Jun. 24, 2010). The Board

received no comments specifically

addressing the Board’s initial regulatory

flexibility analysis. A financial

institution trade association and a bank

stated that institutions that seek CRA

consideration for covered activities

under a final rule would incur

administrative costs, such as costs for

documentation of activities and

training. Those commenters did not

estimate those costs or indicate that they

especially affect small entities. The

Board made no changes to the proposed

rule based on public comment regarding

costs associated with the final rule,

because entities are not required to seek

CRA consideration for covered activities

under the final rule. Rather, entities may

continue to seek CRA consideration for

activities included in the definition of

‘‘community development’’ prior to the

expansion of that definition by this final

rule.

3. Small entities affected by the final

rule. As of June 2010, the Board

supervised 392 banking organizations

that meet the definition of small

entities, all of which are subject to the

final rule.

4. Recordkeeping, reporting, and

compliance requirements. The final rule

does not impose any new recordkeeping

or reporting requirements, as the final

rule does not require supervised

banking organizations to engage in

community development activities.

Institutions that elect to seek credit for

community development activities

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00023

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

any new recordkeeping

or reporting requirements, as the final

rule does not require supervised

banking organizations to engage in

community development activities.

Institutions that elect to seek credit for

community development activities

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00023

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79284

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

under the expanded ‘‘community

development’’ definition under the final

rule will need to maintain

documentation regarding those

activities.

5. Significant alternatives to the final

revisions. Given that the final rule does

not require institutions to fund NSP-

eligible activities and reduces burdens

and restrictions on CRA funding in

general, the Board does not believe any

other alternatives would accomplish the

stated objectives while minimizing

burden of the final rule. The legal basis

of the final rule is in CRA Section 806,

12 U.S.C. 2905. The final rule expands

the definition of the term ‘‘community

development,’’ which is applied in the

CRA regulations’ performance tests.

However, it does not impose new

requirements on small entities because

the CRA performance test for small

entities does not require community

development activities. Rather, the final

rule expands the types of community

development activities for which

institutions may receive CRA

consideration.

OTS Executive Order 12866

Consideration

Pursuant to Executive Order 12866,

OMB’s Office of Information and

Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) designated

the proposed rule to be significant but

did not determine whether the proposal

would have an annual effect on the

economy of $100 million or more. OTS

solicited comment on the costs and

benefits of the proposed rule, if adopted.

As summarized elsewhere in the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, five

commenters directly addressed the

issue

e of Information and

Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) designated

the proposed rule to be significant but

did not determine whether the proposal

would have an annual effect on the

economy of $100 million or more. OTS

solicited comment on the costs and

benefits of the proposed rule, if adopted.

As summarized elsewhere in the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, five

commenters directly addressed the

issue. In general, these commenters

predicted there would be only negligible

costs associated with the proposed

revision, typically in the form of

additional administrative costs,

including capturing loan data and

training. A trade association of

community banks and a financial

institution stated that they anticipate

additional administrative costs for loan

documentation and reporting and for

staff training if the proposed rule is

adopted but did not estimate those

costs. Another financial institution

indicated that since no new reporting

requirements would be imposed, it did

not foresee any incremental costs

beyond the cost of doing business.

Similarly, a trade association for home

builders indicated the costs would be

negligible since the rule would not

place any new requirements on

financial institutions. A State banking

department said there appears to be few,

if any, costs.

Even the potential negligible costs

would only apply to those savings

associations that choose to seek CRA

consideration for engaging in NSP-

eligible activities under the new

provision promulgated in today’s final

rule. As discussed elsewhere in the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, including

the Regulatory Flexibility Act Analysis,

many savings associations are not

evaluated for community development

activities

egligible costs

would only apply to those savings

associations that choose to seek CRA

consideration for engaging in NSP-

eligible activities under the new

provision promulgated in today’s final

rule. As discussed elsewhere in the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, including

the Regulatory Flexibility Act Analysis,

many savings associations are not

evaluated for community development

activities. Small savings associations

(currently defined as those with under

$274 million in assets, 12 CFR

563e.12(u)(1)) are only evaluated for

community development under the

small institution test ‘‘as appropriate,’’ in

other words, when it is necessary to

determine if they meet or exceed the

standards for a satisfactory rating or at

their request. 12 CFR part 563e;

Questions and Answers, 75 FR at 11662

(Q&A § ll.26(b)–2). Currently, 471 of

the 741 savings associations are small.

Further, as discussed elsewhere in the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, even

without the new provision in today’s

final rule, CRA consideration has

already been available for some

neighborhood stabilization activities

under the pre-existing CRA rules and

interagency guidance. Revitalization

and stabilization activities in low- and

moderate-income geographies or in

distressed or underserved

nonmetropolitan middle-income

geographies receive positive

consideration under the existing CRA

rules, regardless of whether these areas

are targeted areas under the NSP.

Foreclosure prevention programs may

also receive positive CRA consideration,

for example, if they are part of a loan

program that is designed to provide

sustainable relief to homeowners facing

foreclosure on their primary residences

or if they help to revitalize or stabilize

low- or moderate-income geographies.

Below-market sales and donations of

OREO properties to nonprofit

organizations, consistent with safe and

sound banking operations, also may

receive positive consideration under the

existing CRA rules

am that is designed to provide

sustainable relief to homeowners facing

foreclosure on their primary residences

or if they help to revitalize or stabilize

low- or moderate-income geographies.

Below-market sales and donations of

OREO properties to nonprofit

organizations, consistent with safe and

sound banking operations, also may

receive positive consideration under the

existing CRA rules. The CRA rules

provide favorable consideration for

grants, which would include an in-kind

donation of property; if these grants

have a primary purpose of community

development, such as to provide

affordable housing to low- and

moderate-income individuals, they also

would already receive positive CRA

consideration as a qualified investment.

Favorable CRA consideration is given

for technical assistance about financial

services to community-based groups,

local or Tribal government agencies, or

intermediaries that help to meet the

credit needs of low- and moderate-

income individuals or small businesses

and farms. Favorable CRA consideration

is available for certain activities

involving multifamily housing.

Economic development activities not

directly related to housing may qualify

for favorable CRA consideration.

These commenters generally thought

that the rule would result in some

benefit to communities affected by the

foreclosure crisis. Four of the five

commenters that addressed the issue

believed that the rule would affect

positively an institution’s decisions

about the types and amount of

community development activities it

will provide. These comments were

from a trade association for State

banking supervisors, a State banking

department, a trade association for

home builders, and a financial

institution. The other commenter,

another financial institution, indicated

that the rule would provide an incentive

for institutions to engage in NSP-eligible

activities, but might not substantially

alter institutions’ general CRA decision-

making

re

from a trade association for State

banking supervisors, a State banking

department, a trade association for

home builders, and a financial

institution. The other commenter,

another financial institution, indicated

that the rule would provide an incentive

for institutions to engage in NSP-eligible

activities, but might not substantially

alter institutions’ general CRA decision-

making.

As discussed elsewhere in the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, the

duration of the final rule is generally

linked to the duration of the NSP. Under

NSP1, grantees must expend NSP funds

within four years of the date the grant

is awarded. Under NSP2, grantees have

three years from that date to fully spend

the grant, and HUD was required to

obligate all funds appropriated for NSP2

in February 2010. The funds

appropriated in the Dodd-Frank Act also

must be fully expended by grantees

within three years after they receive

their grants, and HUD is required to

obligate all funds appropriated by the

Dodd-Frank Act by July 2011. The final

rule provides that NSP-eligible activities

will receive favorable consideration

under the new rule if conducted no later

than two years after the last date

appropriated funds for the program are

required to be spent by the grantees.

After that date, the rule will cease to

apply.

In light of the foregoing, OIRA has

designated the final rule to be

significant but not to have an annual

effect on the economy of $100 million

or more.

OCC and OTS Unfunded Mandates

Reform Act of 1995 Determination

Section 202 of the Unfunded

Mandates Reform Act of 1995

(Unfunded Mandates Act) (2 U.S.C.

1532) requires that covered agencies

prepare a budgetary impact statement

before promulgating a rule that includes

any Federal mandate that may result in

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00024

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

ion 202 of the Unfunded

Mandates Reform Act of 1995

(Unfunded Mandates Act) (2 U.S.C.

1532) requires that covered agencies

prepare a budgetary impact statement

before promulgating a rule that includes

any Federal mandate that may result in

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00024

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79285

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

the expenditure by State, local, and

Tribal governments, in the aggregate, or

by the private sector, of $100 million or

more in any one year. If a budgetary

impact statement is required, section

205 of the Unfunded Mandates Act also

requires covered agencies to identify

and consider a reasonable number of

regulatory alternatives before

promulgating a rule. The OCC and the

OTS have determined that this final rule

will not result in expenditures by State,

local, and Tribal governments, or by the

private sector, of $100 million or more

in any one year. Accordingly, neither

agency has prepared a budgetary impact

statement or specifically addressed the

regulatory alternatives considered.

The Treasury and General Government

Appropriations Act, 1999—Assessment

of Impact of Federal Regulation on

Families

The FDIC has determined that this

final rule will not affect family well-

being within the meaning of section 654

of the Treasury and General

Government Appropriations Act,

enacted as part of the Omnibus

Consolidated and Emergency

Supplemental Appropriations Act of

1999, Public Law 105–277 (5 U.S.C. 601

note).

List of Subjects

12 CFR Part 25

Community development, Credit,

Investments, National banks, Reporting

and recordkeeping requirements.

12 CFR Part 228

Banks, Banking, Community

development, Credit, Investments,

Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements.

12 CFR Part 345

Banks, Banking, Community

development, Credit, Investments,

Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements

S.C. 601

note).

List of Subjects

12 CFR Part 25

Community development, Credit,

Investments, National banks, Reporting

and recordkeeping requirements.

12 CFR Part 228

Banks, Banking, Community

development, Credit, Investments,

Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements.

12 CFR Part 345

Banks, Banking, Community

development, Credit, Investments,

Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements.

12 CFR Part 563e

Community development, Credit,

Investments, Reporting and

recordkeeping requirements, Savings

associations.

Department of the Treasury

Office of the Comptroller of the

Currency

12 CFR Chapter I

Authority and Issuance

For the reasons discussed in the joint

preamble, the Office of the Comptroller

of the Currency amends part 25 of

chapter I of title 12 of the Code of

Federal Regulations as follows:

PART 25—COMMUNITY

REINVESTMENT ACT AND

INTERSTATE DEPOSIT PRODUCTION

REGULATIONS

■1. The authority citation for part 25

continues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 21, 22, 26, 27, 30, 36,

93a, 161, 215, 215a, 481, 1814, 1816, 1828(c),

1835a, 2901 through 2907, and 3101 through

3111.

■2. In § 25.12:

■a. Republish the introductory text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5).

The republication and addition read as

follows:

§ 25.12

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(g) Community development means:

*

*

*

*

*

(5) Loans, investments, and services

that—

y text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5).

The republication and addition read as

follows:

§ 25.12

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(g) Community development means:

*

*

*

*

*

(5) Loans, investments, and services

that—

(i) Support, enable or facilitate

projects or activities that meet the

‘‘eligible uses’’ criteria described in

Section 2301(c) of the Housing and

Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA),

Public Law 110–289, 122 Stat. 2654, as

amended, and are conducted in

designated target areas identified in

plans approved by the United States

Department of Housing and Urban

Development in accordance with the

Neighborhood Stabilization Program

(NSP);

(ii) Are provided no later than two

years after the last date funds

appropriated for the NSP are required to

be spent by grantees; and

(iii) Benefit low-, moderate-, and

middle-income individuals and

geographies in the bank’s assessment

area(s) or areas outside the bank’s

assessment area(s) provided the bank

has adequately addressed the

community development needs of its

assessment area(s).

*

*

*

*

*

Federal Reserve System

12 CFR Chapter II

Authority and Issuance

■For the reasons set forth in the joint

preamble, the Board of Governors of the

Federal Reserve System amends part

228 of chapter II of title 12 of the Code

of Federal Regulations as follows:

PART 228—COMMUNITY

REINVESTMENT (REGULATION BB)

■1. The authority citation for part 228

continues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 321, 325, 1828(c),

1842, 1843, 1844, and 2901 et seq.

■2. In § 228.12:

■a. Republish the introductory text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5)

rity citation for part 228

continues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 321, 325, 1828(c),

1842, 1843, 1844, and 2901 et seq.

■2. In § 228.12:

■a. Republish the introductory text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5).

The republication and addition read as

follows:

§ 228.12

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(g) Community development means:

*

*

*

*

*

(5) Loans, investments, and services

that—

(i) Support, enable or facilitate

projects or activities that meet the

‘‘eligible uses’’ criteria described in

Section 2301(c) of the Housing and

Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA),

Public Law 110–289, 122 Stat. 2654, as

amended, and are conducted in

designated target areas identified in

plans approved by the United States

Department of Housing and Urban

Development in accordance with the

Neighborhood Stabilization Program

(NSP);

(ii) Are provided no later than two

years after the last date funds

appropriated for the NSP are required to

be spent by grantees; and

(iii) Benefit low-, moderate-, and

middle-income individuals and

geographies in the bank’s assessment

area(s) or areas outside the bank’s

assessment area(s) provided the bank

has adequately addressed the

community development needs of its

assessment area(s).

*

*

*

*

*

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation

12 CFR Chapter III

Authority and Issuance

■For the reasons set forth in the joint

preamble, the Board of Directors of the

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation

amends part 345 of chapter III of title 12

of the Code of Federal Regulations as

follows:

PART 345—COMMUNITY

REINVESTMENT

■1. The authority citation for part 345

continues to read as follows:

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00025

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

of the

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation

amends part 345 of chapter III of title 12

of the Code of Federal Regulations as

follows:

PART 345—COMMUNITY

REINVESTMENT

■1. The authority citation for part 345

continues to read as follows:

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00025

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

79286

Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 243 / Monday, December 20, 2010 / Rules and Regulations

1 Public Law 111–203, sec. 334(a), 124 Stat. 1376,

1539 (to be codified at 12 U.S.C. 1817(b)(3)(B)).

2 Public Law 111–203, sec. 334(d), 124 Stat. 1376,

1539 (to be codified at 12 U.S.C. 1817(nt)).

3 Public Law 111–203, sec. 334(e), 124 Stat. 1376,

1539 (to be codified at 12 U.S.C. 1817(nt)).

4 Public Law 111–203, sec. 332(d), 124 Stat. 1376,

1539 (to be codified at 12 U.S.C. 1817(e)).

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 1814–1817, 1819–

1920, 1828, 1831u and 2901–2907, 3103–

3104, and 3108(a).

■2. In § 345.12:

■a. Republish the introductory text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5).

The republication and addition read as

follows:

§ 345.12

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(g) Community development means:

*

*

*

*

*

(5) Loans, investments, and services

that—

text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5).

The republication and addition read as

follows:

§ 345.12

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(g) Community development means:

*

*

*

*

*

(5) Loans, investments, and services

that—

(i) Support, enable or facilitate

projects or activities that meet the

‘‘eligible uses’’ criteria described in

Section 2301(c) of the Housing and

Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA),

Public Law 110–289, 122 Stat. 2654, as

amended, and are conducted in

designated target areas identified in

plans approved by the United States

Department of Housing and Urban

Development in accordance with the

Neighborhood Stabilization Program

(NSP);

(ii) Are provided no later than two

years after the last date funds

appropriated for the NSP are required to

be spent by grantees; and

(iii) Benefit low-, moderate-, and

middle-income individuals and

geographies in the bank’s assessment

area(s) or areas outside the bank’s

assessment area(s) provided the bank

has adequately addressed the

community development needs of its

assessment area(s).

*

*

*

*

*

Department of the Treasury

Office of Thrift Supervision

12 CFR Chapter V

■For the reasons set forth in the joint

preamble, the Office of Thrift

Supervision amends part 563e of

chapter V of title 12 of the Code of

Federal Regulations as follows:

PART 563e—COMMUNITY

REINVESTMENT

■1. The authority citation for part 563e

continues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 1462a, 1463, 1464,

1467a, 1814, 1816, 1828(c), and 2901 through

2907.

■2. In § 563e.12:

■a. Republish the introductory text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5)

art 563e

continues to read as follows:

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 1462a, 1463, 1464,

1467a, 1814, 1816, 1828(c), and 2901 through

2907.

■2. In § 563e.12:

■a. Republish the introductory text of

paragraph (g);

■b. Remove the word ‘‘or’’ at the end of

paragraph (g)(3);

■c. Remove the period at the end of

paragraph (g)(4)(iii)(B) and add ‘‘; or’’ in

its place; and

■d. Add a new paragraph (g)(5).

The republication and addition read as

follows:

§ 563e.12

Definitions.

*

*

*

*

*

(g) Community development means:

*

*

*

*

*

(5) Loans, investments, and services

that—

(i) Support, enable or facilitate

projects or activities that meet the

‘‘eligible uses’’ criteria described in

Section 2301(c) of the Housing and

Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA),

Public Law 110–289, 122 Stat. 2654, as

amended, and are conducted in

designated target areas identified in

plans approved by the United States

Department of Housing and Urban

Development in accordance with the

Neighborhood Stabilization Program

(NSP);

(ii) Are provided no later than two

years after the last date funds

appropriated for the NSP are required to

be spent by grantees; and

(iii) Benefit low-, moderate-, and

middle-income individuals and

geographies in the savings association’s

assessment area(s) or areas outside the

savings association’s assessment area(s)

provided the savings association has

adequately addressed the community

development needs of its assessment

area(s).

*

*

*

*

*

Dated: December 8, 2010.

John Walsh,

Acting Comptroller of the Currency.

By order of the Board of Governors of the

Federal Reserve System, December 13, 2010.

Robert deV. Frierson,

Deputy Secretary of the Board.

Dated at Washington, DC, this 14th day of

December 2010.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.

Valerie J. Best,

Assistant Executive Secretary.

Dated: December 9, 2010.

By the Office of Thrift Supervision.

John E. Bowman,

Acting Director.

[FR Doc

.

By order of the Board of Governors of the

Federal Reserve System, December 13, 2010.

Robert deV. Frierson,

Deputy Secretary of the Board.

Dated at Washington, DC, this 14th day of

December 2010.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.

Valerie J. Best,

Assistant Executive Secretary.

Dated: December 9, 2010.

By the Office of Thrift Supervision.

John E. Bowman,

Acting Director.

[FR Doc. 2010–31818 Filed 12–17–10; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4810–33–P; 6210–01–P; 6714–01–P;

6720–01–P

FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE

CORPORATION

12 CFR Part 327

RIN 3064–AD69

Designated Reserve Ratio

AGENCY: Federal Deposit Insurance

Corporation (FDIC).

ACTION: Final rule.

SUMMARY: To implement a

comprehensive, long-range management

plan for the Deposit Insurance Fund

(DIF or fund), the FDIC is amending its

regulations to set the designated reserve

ratio (DRR) at 2 percent.

DATED: Effective Date: January 1, 2011.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Munsell St. Clair, Chief, Banking and

Regulatory Policy Section, (202) 898–

8967, Christopher Bellotto, Counsel,

(202) 898–3801, 550 17th Street, NW.,

Washington, DC 20429.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

A. Governing Statutes

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform

and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-

Frank), which was enacted on July 21,

2010, gave the FDIC much greater

discretion to manage the DIF, including

where to set the DRR. Among other

things, Dodd-Frank: (1) Raises the

minimum DRR, which the FDIC is

required to set each year, to 1.35 percent

(from the former minimum of 1.15

percent) and removes the upper limit on

the DRR (which was formerly capped at

1.5 percent) and consequently on the

size of the fund; 1 (2) requires that the

fund reserve ratio reach 1.35 percent by

September 30, 2020 (rather than 1.15

percent by the end of 2016, as formerly

required); 2 (3) requires that, in setting

assessments, the FDIC ‘‘offset the effect

of [requiring that the reserve ratio reach

1.35 percent by September 30, 2020

rather than 1.15 percent by the

1.5 percent) and consequently on the

size of the fund; 1 (2) requires that the

fund reserve ratio reach 1.35 percent by

September 30, 2020 (rather than 1.15

percent by the end of 2016, as formerly

required); 2 (3) requires that, in setting

assessments, the FDIC ‘‘offset the effect

of [requiring that the reserve ratio reach

1.35 percent by September 30, 2020

rather than 1.15 percent by the end of

2016] on insured depository institutions

with total consolidated assets of less

than $10,000,000,000’’; 3 (4) eliminates

the requirement that the FDIC provide

dividends from the fund when the

reserve ratio is between 1.35 percent

and 1.5 percent; 4 and (5) continues the

FDIC’s authority to declare dividends

when the reserve ratio at the end of a

VerDate Mar<15>2010

19:04 Dec 17, 2010

Jkt 223001

PO 00000

Frm 00026

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

E:\FR\FM\20DER1.SGM

20DER1

jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with RULES

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.