In the Matter of Federal-State Joint Boar:d on Universal Service
FederalRulings
Ask Donna
How this section applies to your facts.
FCC Declaratory Rulings › In the Matter of Federal-State Joint Boar:d on Universal Service
Text
In the Matter of
Federal-State Joint Boar:d
on Universal Service
Federal Communications Commission
Before the
Federal Communications Commission
Washington, D.C. 20554
)
)
)
)
CC Docket No. 96-45
AADI USB File No. 98-37
DECLARATORY RULING
Adopted: January 29, 1999
Released: February 18, 1999
FCC 99-10
By the Commission: Commissioner Furchtgott-Roth dissenting and issuing a statement.
I. INTRODUCTION
1.
In this Declaratory Ruling, we address a petition by the Iowa
Telecommunications and Technology Commission ("ITTC"), operating the Iowa
Communications Network ("ICN"), 1 seeking a declaration that ICN is a "telecommunications
carrier" eligible to receive direct universal service support for the provision of discounted
telecommunications services to schools, libraries, and rural health care providers under
sections 254(h)(l)(A) and (B) of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended ("Act").2
2.
As we observed in the Universal Service Order and reiterated in the Fourth
Reconsideration Order, the Act permits only "telecommunications carriers" to receive direct
reimbursement from universal service support mechanisms for the provision of discounted
telecommunications services, and the term "telecommunications carrier" includes only carriers
that offer telecommunications on a common carriage basis.3 As we explain below, it is clear
See Letter from J.G. Harrington, counsel for Iowa Telecommunications and Technology Commission (ITTC),
to Magalie Roman Salas, FCC, dated Feb. 4, 1998 ("ICN petition").
See 47 U.S.C. §§ 254(h)(lXA) and (B).
Federal-State Joint Board on Universal Service, CC Docket No. 96-45, Repon and Order, 12 FCC Red
8776, 9177-78, 9005-23, 9084-90 (1997) (Universal Service Order), as corrected by Federal-State Joint Board on
Universal Service, Errata, CC Docket No. 96-45, FCC 97-157 (rel. June 4, 1997), appeal pending in Texas Office
of Public Utility Counsel v. FCC and USA, No. 97-60421 (5th Cir
lXA) and (B).
Federal-State Joint Board on Universal Service, CC Docket No. 96-45, Repon and Order, 12 FCC Red
8776, 9177-78, 9005-23, 9084-90 (1997) (Universal Service Order), as corrected by Federal-State Joint Board on
Universal Service, Errata, CC Docket No. 96-45, FCC 97-157 (rel. June 4, 1997), appeal pending in Texas Office
of Public Utility Counsel v. FCC and USA, No. 97-60421 (5th Cir. 1997); see also Federal-State Joint Board on
Universal Service, Access Charge Reform, Price Cap Performance Review for Local Exchange Carriers, Transpon
Rate Structure and Pricing, End User Common Line Charge, CC Docket Nos. 96-45, 96-262, 94-1, 91-213, 95-72,
Founh Order on Reconsideration, 13 FCC Red 5318, 5413-14 (1997) (Founh Reconsideration Order), as corrected
by Federal-State Joint Board on Universal Service, Errata, CC Docket Nos. 96-45, 96-262, 94-1, 91-213, 95-72, DA
3040
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
that ICN is not offering telecommunications on a common carrier basis and, therefore, is not
within the category of providers defined by Congress as being eligible to receive direct
reimbursement for the provision of discounted telecommunications services to schools,
libraries, and rural health care providers under section 254(h)(l) of the Act.
3.
While ICN is statutorily barred from receiving direct reimbursement for
discounted telecommunications that it provides over its own network, we reiterate,
nonetheless, that the Act does provide other avenues by which schools, libraries, and rural
health care providers may receive discounts for services obtained through a state network.
We note that state telecommunications networks may receive support for providing two types
of services to eligible schools, libraries, and rural health care providers: ( 1) discounted
telecommunications obtained by the state network acting as a consortium; and (2) non-
telecommunications services
d rural
health care providers may receive discounts for services obtained through a state network.
We note that state telecommunications networks may receive support for providing two types
of services to eligible schools, libraries, and rural health care providers: ( 1) discounted
telecommunications obtained by the state network acting as a consortium; and (2) non-
telecommunications services. First, schools, libraries, and rural health care providers are
specifically eligible to receive discounted telecommunications services from a state network
that acts as a consortium in aggregating and purchasing discounted telecommunications from a
telecommunications carrier that provides services over its network (as opposed to ICN's
network) to the schools, libraries, and rural health care providers that make up the
consortium. 4 The state network must distribute the discounts between all of the participating
recipients of the services.
4.
Second, we emphasize, consistent with the Fourth Reconsideration Order, that
state telecommunications networks, such as ICN, may secure direct reimbursements for their
provision of eligible discounted non-telecommunications services (i.e., Internet access and
internal connections) to schools and libraries.5 Alternatively, a state network may act as a
consortium in obtaining these non-telecommunciations services, and thus pass the discounts
through to the participating schools and libraries as described above.
II. BACKGROUND
5.
Section 254(e) generally provides that only an "eligible telecommunications
carrier"6 under section 214( e) is eligible to receive universal service support. 7 An entity must,
98-158 (rel. Jan 29, 1998), appeal pending in Alenco Communications, Inc., et al. v. FCC and USA, No. 98-60213
(5th Cir. 1998).
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-24.
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-24, 5428-29
des that only an "eligible telecommunications
carrier"6 under section 214( e) is eligible to receive universal service support. 7 An entity must,
98-158 (rel. Jan 29, 1998), appeal pending in Alenco Communications, Inc., et al. v. FCC and USA, No. 98-60213
(5th Cir. 1998).
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-24.
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-24, 5428-29. The ICN has applied for support for
provision of non-telecommunications services, in addition to telecommunications services.
6
See 41 U.S.C .. § 214(e)(2). Section 214(e)(l)(A) requires an eligible telecommunications carrier ("ETC")
to "offer the services that are supported by Federal universal service support mechanisms under section 254(c)."
Pursuant to section 254(c), the Commission, based on the recommendation of the Federal-State Joint Board,
3041
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
therefore, be an "eligible telecommunications carrier" for purposes of receiving universal
service support under section 254(h)( 1 )(A) for providing telecommunications services to rural
health care providers. 8 Co~gress carved out an exception in the case of schools and libraries,
however, by specifying that any "telecommunications carrier," even one that did not qualify as
an "eligible telecommunications carrier," is eligible for direct reimbursement for providing
discounted telecommunications services to schools and libraries.9 Notwithstanding this
distinction, Congress clearly provided that an entity be a "telecommunications carrier" of some
sort in order to receive universal service support for the provision of discounted
telecommunications services to either rural health care providers or ·to schools and libraries.
6
ect reimbursement for providing
discounted telecommunications services to schools and libraries.9 Notwithstanding this
distinction, Congress clearly provided that an entity be a "telecommunications carrier" of some
sort in order to receive universal service support for the provision of discounted
telecommunications services to either rural health care providers or ·to schools and libraries.
6.
Section 153( 44) of the Act defines a "telecommunications carrier" to be any
provider of "telecommunications services." 10 The Act states that "telecommunications
services" are the "offering ·of telecommunications for a fee directly to the public, or to such
classes of users as to be effectively available directly to the public, regardless of the facilities
used." 11 This definition mirrors the common law definition of a "common carrier," and thus
the Commission in the Universal Service Order determined that the term "telecommunications
services" encompasses only telecommunications provided on a common carrier basis. 12
Accordingly, consistent with the Act, a telecommunications carrier is an entity that provides
telecommunications on a common carrier basis.
determined that the following services or functionalities will be supported by universal service mechanisms: voice-
grade access to the public switched network; local usage; dual tone multi-frequency signaling; single-party service;
access to emergency services; access to operator services; access to interexchange service; access to directory
assistance; and toll limitation for qualifying low-income customers. See47 C.F.R. § 54.lOl{a)(l)-(9). In order to
be designated an ETC, therefore, a common carrier needs to be offering each of these services.
47 U.S.C. § 254(e).
See 47 U.S.C. § 254(h)(l)(A); Universal Service Order, 12 FCC Red at 9105-06
ervices; access to operator services; access to interexchange service; access to directory
assistance; and toll limitation for qualifying low-income customers. See47 C.F.R. § 54.lOl{a)(l)-(9). In order to
be designated an ETC, therefore, a common carrier needs to be offering each of these services.
47 U.S.C. § 254(e).
See 47 U.S.C. § 254(h)(l)(A); Universal Service Order, 12 FCC Red at 9105-06.
9
Because section 254(h)( 1 )(B)(ii) states that "notwithstanding the provisions of subsection [254](e) of this
section" a telecommunications carrier providing services to schools and libraries may receive reimbursement from
universal service support mechanisms, the Commission interpreted the Act to allow all "telecommunicationscarriers"
to be eligible for reimbursement under section254(h)(l){B). Universal Service Order, 12 FCC Red at 9015; see also
47 u.s.c. § 254(h)(l)(B)(ii).
10
47 u.s.c. § 153(44).
11
47 U.S.C. § 153(46). The term "telecommunications" is defined in the Act as the "transmission, between
or among points specified by the user, of information of the user's choosing, without change in the form or content
of the information as sent and received." 47 U.S.C. § 153(43).
12
Universal Service Order, 12 FCC Red at 9177-78; see also Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at
5413.
3042
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
7.
The Commission's rules define a common carrier as "any person engaged in
rendering communications ~rvices for hire to the public." 13 The Act requires common
carriers to furnish services upon "reasonable request therefor."
14 As the Commission noted in
the Universal Service Order, and the D.C
h Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at
5413.
3042
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
7.
The Commission's rules define a common carrier as "any person engaged in
rendering communications ~rvices for hire to the public." 13 The Act requires common
carriers to furnish services upon "reasonable request therefor."
14 As the Commission noted in
the Universal Service Order, and the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has held, a carrier may be
a common carrier if it holds itself out "to service indifferently all potential users," and that a
"carrier will not be a common carrier 'where its practice is to make individualized decisions
in particular cases whether and on what terms to serve.'"
15 The court determined that
"holding oneself out to serve indiscriminately appears to be an essential element, if one is to
draw a coherent line between common and private carriers. "16 In contrast, a carrier that
serves clients on an individualized basis,. determines whether and on what terms to serve each
client, and is under no regulatory compulsion to serve all indifferently, is a private carrier for
that particular service. 17
8.
As the foregoing discussion reveals, to achieve the goal of allowing schools and
libraries to obtain telecommunications services at discounted rates, Congress designed a
system by which common carriers, in the course of providing service to the public generally,
are required to offer discounted rates to those eligible entities. 18 Prior to the creation of this
federal scheme by Congress, a number of states had likewise sought to ensure that certain
entities, often including schools, libraries, and state agencies, could receive
telecommunications and related services at discounted rates. While pursuing the same goal as
Congress, a number of these states adopted an approach significantly different than the one
ultimately selected by Congress
of this
federal scheme by Congress, a number of states had likewise sought to ensure that certain
entities, often including schools, libraries, and state agencies, could receive
telecommunications and related services at discounted rates. While pursuing the same goal as
Congress, a number of these states adopted an approach significantly different than the one
ultimately selected by Congress. Rather than designing a system under which private entities,
independently engaged in the provision of telecommunications services to the public, would
be reimbursed for giving discounts to eligible beneficiaries, many of the states created
13
14
47 C.F.R. § 21.2.
47 U.S.C. § 201(a).
15
Universal Service Order, 12 FCC Red at 9177-78 (citing National Association of Regulatory Utility
Commissioners v. FCC, 533 F.2d 601, 608 (D.C. Cir. 1976) (NARUC fl)).
16
National Association of Regulatory Commissioners v. FCC, 525 F.2d 630, 642 (D.C. Cir.) (NARUC /), cert.
denied, 425 U.S. 992 (1976).
17
SoutlrwesternBe//TelephoneCo. v. FCC, 19 F.3d 1475, 1481 (D.C. Cir. 1994), citingNARUC II, 533 F.2d
at 609. Private carriers do not serve everyone on "equal terms." Some examples of private carriers are "cable TV
companies, [and] telecommunications carriers providing private lines to large users." Noam, Eli M., Wi/J Universal
Service and Common Carriage Survive the Telecommunications Act of 1996?, 91 Colum. L. Rev. 955 (May 1997).
11
The carriers shall offer the lowest corresponding price to eligible schools and libraries, and shall be
reimbursed by the universal service support mechanism for the difference between the lowest corresponding price
and the discount for which a school or library is qualified, pursuant to our rules. See Universal Service Order, 12
FCC Red at 9026-27; 9031-32.
3043
L. Rev. 955 (May 1997).
11
The carriers shall offer the lowest corresponding price to eligible schools and libraries, and shall be
reimbursed by the universal service support mechanism for the difference between the lowest corresponding price
and the discount for which a school or library is qualified, pursuant to our rules. See Universal Service Order, 12
FCC Red at 9026-27; 9031-32.
3043
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
government agencies and stand-alone state networks that offer service solely to state agencies,
schools, and other beneficiaries specifically designated by the state legislature, at rates
subsidized by the state. Some state networks own and operate their own facilities, while
others aggregate demand for telecommunications services by eligible entities throughout the
state and obtain volume discounts from independent carriers that actually provide the services
directly to the eligible entities. 19
9.
In the petition before us, ITTC seeks to secure for ICN the benefits of both the
federal and state support mechanisms. As a subsidized state network, ICN allows schools and
other beneficiaries to obtain telecommunications and related services at steep discounts. For
example, according to a 1998 memorandum to Iowa school district superintendents from the
Iowa Department of Education, ICN charges its schools and libraries only $5.00 per hour for
video rates, even though the cost of that service was represented to be approximately $75.20
ITTC seeks a declaration that ICN, in addition to being a state network, is also a
telecommunications carrier eligible for further support, or reimbursement of the state subsidy.
10
ict superintendents from the
Iowa Department of Education, ICN charges its schools and libraries only $5.00 per hour for
video rates, even though the cost of that service was represented to be approximately $75.20
ITTC seeks a declaration that ICN, in addition to being a state network, is also a
telecommunications carrier eligible for further support, or reimbursement of the state subsidy.
10.
In the Fourth Reconsideration Order, the Commission addressed, inter alia,
several petitions by state telecommunications networks, including ICN, concerning their
eligibility under section 254(h)(l)(B) for direct reimbursement from universal service support
mechanisms for provision of discounted telecommunications services to schools and libraries.21
If a state network qualified as a "telecommunications carrier," an eligible school, library, or
rural health care provider could obtain service directly from the state telecommunications
network at a discounted rate; the state network could then seek reimbursement from the
universal service support mechanism for the discounted portion of the service. In its
pleadings in the Fourth Reconsideration Order proceeding, ITTC specifically argued that ICN
is a telecommunications carrier and "therefore eligible for direct reimbursement from the
support mechanisms,"22 because ICN owns and operates its own network, and provides
services to "a wide variety of users, not just schools and libraries. "23
11.
The Commission decided in the Fourth Reconsideration Order that state
telecommunications networks are not eligible for direct reimbursement from the support
19
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5417.
20
See GTE reply comments at 6.
21
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5419-20.
22
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5418, 5421
st schools and libraries. "23
11.
The Commission decided in the Fourth Reconsideration Order that state
telecommunications networks are not eligible for direct reimbursement from the support
19
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5417.
20
See GTE reply comments at 6.
21
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5419-20.
22
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5418, 5421. IITC also noted that the ICN network includes
significant fiber capacity, switches, and high speed data hubs, in addition to services purchased from
telecommunications carriers for DS-3 level connections to school districts. Id at 5418.
23
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5421.
3044
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
mechanisms pursuant to section 254(h)( 1 ), because the record showed that state
telecommunications n~twor!cs do not offer service "for a fee directly to the public," or
"indifferently [to] all potential users," and instead, "offer services to specified classes of
entities. "24 Because there was no credible evidence that state telecommunications networks
"offer service indifferently to any requesting party," the Commission concluded that these
networks were not "telecommunications carriers," and thus would "not be eligible for
reimbursement from the support mechanisms pursuant to section 254(h)(l)."25
12.
As we have noted, the Act does not entirely prevent state telecommunications
networks from receiving discounted telecommunications services under universal service
support mechanisms
ng party," the Commission concluded that these
networks were not "telecommunications carriers," and thus would "not be eligible for
reimbursement from the support mechanisms pursuant to section 254(h)(l)."25
12.
As we have noted, the Act does not entirely prevent state telecommunications
networks from receiving discounted telecommunications services under universal service
support mechanisms. To the extent that a state telecommunications network procures
supported telecommunications services for schools and libraries, the network would be
eligible, as a consortium, to secure discounts on telecommunications services on behalf of
eligible schools and libraries and would be required to pass those discounts along to the
schools and libraries they serve.26 Moreover, pursuant to section 254(h)(2), state
telecommunications networks may secure discounts on Internet access and internal connections
in their capacity as consortia, or may receive direct reimbursement, as non-
telecommunications carriers, from universal service support mechanisms for providing such
services to eligible schools and libraries. 27
13.
On February 4, 1998, ITTC, operating ICN, filed a petition seeking a
determination from the Commission that I CN is eligible under section 254 of the Act, and the
Commission's rules, to receive direct reimbursement from universal service mechanisms for
the provision of telecommunications services to schools, libraries, and rural health care
providers. 28 ITTC argues that I CN is different from the state telecommunications networks
described in the Fourth Reconsideration Order because it in fact provides telecommunications
24
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5427.
25
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5426-28.
26
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-24
o schools, libraries, and rural health care
providers. 28 ITTC argues that I CN is different from the state telecommunications networks
described in the Fourth Reconsideration Order because it in fact provides telecommunications
24
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5427.
25
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5426-28.
26
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-24. We also noted in the Fourth Reconsideration Order
that parties "have not suggested any reason why state telecommunications networks should be treated differently from
other consortia and thus be allowed to receive support directly from the universal service support mechanisms for
providing telecommunications other than Internet access and internal connections." Fourth Reconsideration Order,
13 FCC Red at 5428.
27
Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-24, 5428-29.
21
ICN petition at 1.
3045
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
on a common carrier basis.29 On February 13, 1998, the Common Carrier Bureau ("Bureau")
requested public comment on ICN's petition.30 Several parties filed comments and reply
comments.31
III. ICN'S PETITION
14.
ICN is authorized by the state legislature to provide high-speed, high-quality
telecommunications and Internet services, and is operated by the ITTC. 32 The state legislature
provides funds to ITTC and subsidizes ICN's rates for its services.33 Some parts of the
network are state-owned and other portions are leased from private entities.34 For the most
part, ITTC leases the network to provide services to schools and libraries. 35 ITTC asserts that
ICN offers a variety of services, including long distance, distance learning, telemedicine, and
Internet services to "authorized users. "36
29
ICN petition at l.
Jo
Iowa Telecommunicationsand Technology Commission Seeks Determination that the Iowa Communications
Network is a Provider of Telecommunications Services to Schools, Libraries, and Rural Health Care Providers, CC
Docket No
ts that
ICN offers a variety of services, including long distance, distance learning, telemedicine, and
Internet services to "authorized users. "36
29
ICN petition at l.
Jo
Iowa Telecommunicationsand Technology Commission Seeks Determination that the Iowa Communications
Network is a Provider of Telecommunications Services to Schools, Libraries, and Rural Health Care Providers, CC
Docket No. 96-45, Public Notice, 13 FCC Red 3014 (1998).
JI
See. e.g., Ameritech comments; Bell Atlantic comments;
Iowa Utilites Boards ("IUB") comments;
Minnesota Equal Access Network Services, Inc. ("MEANS") comments; Rural Iowa Independent Telephone
Association ("RJITA") comments; US West comments; GTE reply comments; ICN reply comments; US West reply
comments.
J2
ICN reply comments at 1-3.
33
The Iowa statute provides that financing for the procurement costs of the network "shall be provided by the
state," and that ICN's funds are appropriated to the ITTC. Iowa Code§ 80.13. Members of the IITC are appointed
by the governor of the state and subject to the state senate's confirmation. Iowa Code § 80.3(2). GTE notes in its
reply comments that currently ICN's subsidized rate for video rates is $5.00 per hour. GTE reply comments at 6.
J4
ICN reply comments at 3; see also ICN ex parte submission, dated April 9, 1998, at l (JCN April 9 ex
parte).
3
~
There are three pans of the network: (I) Part I is state-owned and consists of the communications
connections between the central switching hub of the network and 15 community colleges, universities governed by
the board of regents and Iowa public television and other regional switching centers for the remainder of the network;
ubmission, dated April 9, 1998, at l (JCN April 9 ex
parte).
3
~
There are three pans of the network: (I) Part I is state-owned and consists of the communications
connections between the central switching hub of the network and 15 community colleges, universities governed by
the board of regents and Iowa public television and other regional switching centers for the remainder of the network;
(2) Part II is also state-owned and consists of communications connections between the Part I regional switching
centers and each of the 99 counties located in the state; and (3) Part III consists primarily of leased equipment and
telecommunicationsfacilities(with the exception of some state-owned sites) that provides communication connections
between the secondary switching centers and school districts and libraries and any other private or public agency
authorized by the general assembly to connect to the network. Iowa Adm in. Code § 751-7. I (80) (emphasis added).
J6
/CN April 9 ex parte.
3046
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
15.
Under Iowa statute, only entities that are "private or public agencies"37 may be
included in the category of "authorized users" of ICN.38 The Iowa statute divided the universe
of private and public agencies into three categories, and treated each category differently for
purposes of determining eligibility to take services from the ICN. First, certain private or
public agencies, including state and federal agencies, local school districts and nonpublic
schools, local libraries, judicial departments, hospitals and physician clinics, and certain
United States post offices, were automatically "authorized" by Iowa statute to receive ICN's
services as of May 18, 1994.39 Second, private or public agencies that were not in the first
group could certify their eligibility for the network by making the appropriate filing no later
than July 1, 1994.40 Third, a public or private agency that was not deemed authorized as of
May 18, 1994, and that did not certify its eligib
were automatically "authorized" by Iowa statute to receive ICN's
services as of May 18, 1994.39 Second, private or public agencies that were not in the first
group could certify their eligibility for the network by making the appropriate filing no later
than July 1, 1994.40 Third, a public or private agency that was not deemed authorized as of
May 18, 1994, and that did not certify its eligibility by July 1, 1994, is prohibited from
obtaining service from the ICN absent an act of the legislature.
41 As noted, entities that do
not qualify as private or public entities are absolutely barred from obtaining services from the
state network. By Iowa law, a private or public agency that "certified" to purchase services
from the network must use the network for all of its video, data, and voice requirements, and
may not purchase any services from other carriers. 42 A certified user may decide unilaterally
to terminate its relationship with the ICN in favor of another provider with 60 days' prior
37
A private agency under the Iowa code is an accredited nonpublic school, a nonprofit institution of higher
education eligible for tuition grants, or a hospital or physician clinic. Iowa Code§ 80.2(4). A public agency means
a "state agency, an institution under the control of the board of regents, the judicial department . . . a school
corporation, a city library, a regional library, ... an agency of the federal government, or a United States post office
which receives a federal grant for pilot and demonstration projects." Iowa Code § 80.2(5).
38
Iowa Code § 80.11 (2).
39
Included in this list are judicial district departments of correctional services and U.S. post offices that receive
federal grants for pilot and demonstration projects, but not those U.S. post offices that do not receive such grants.
Iowa Code § 80.9.
40
Iowa Code § 80.9(1) and (2)
ives a federal grant for pilot and demonstration projects." Iowa Code § 80.2(5).
38
Iowa Code § 80.11 (2).
39
Included in this list are judicial district departments of correctional services and U.S. post offices that receive
federal grants for pilot and demonstration projects, but not those U.S. post offices that do not receive such grants.
Iowa Code § 80.9.
40
Iowa Code § 80.9(1) and (2). Under Iowa's administrative law provisions, a "certified user" "means an
area education agency, a community college, a regents institution, and a private college." Iowa Ad.min. Law Code
§ 751-9.1(3) (80).
41
Any agency that obtains Iowa legislative approval to join the network after July 1, 1994, will also be treated
as a "public or private agency" under the section and all provisions of Iowa Code chapter 80. Iowa Ad.min. Code
§ 751-7.1(80).
42
Iowa Code § 80.9(1) and (2). The ITTC may waive the requirement for the agencies that certified to use
ICN if one of the following conditions is met: ( 1) the costs to the authorized user for services provided on the
network are not competitive with the same services provided by another provider; (2) the authorized user is under
contract with another provider for such services, and the contract was entered into prior to April l, 1994; or (3) the
authorized user entered into an agreement with ITTC to become part of the network prior to June l, 1994, and that
agreement did not require the agency to use the network for all of its video, data, and voice requirements. Iowa
Code § 80.9(2).
3047
he authorized user is under
contract with another provider for such services, and the contract was entered into prior to April l, 1994; or (3) the
authorized user entered into an agreement with ITTC to become part of the network prior to June l, 1994, and that
agreement did not require the agency to use the network for all of its video, data, and voice requirements. Iowa
Code § 80.9(2).
3047
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
written notice, but will then have to seek permission of the Iowa General Assembly to
recertify. 43
16.
In the petition, ITTC argues that ICN is a "telecommunications carrier,"
offering telecommunications on a common carrier basis, for the following reasons: ( 1) "it
holds itself out to all of its potential customers for those services" or it serves indifferently its
"chosen class of customers;" (2) it offers its services on generally available terms and
conditions and does not negotiate individually with any of its customers; and (3) it serves a
large number of customers and, accordingly, is different from private carriers that have
contracts with a small number of customers.44 Moreover, ITTC argues that the Commission
should defer to the comments of the Iowa Utilities Board (IUB), in which the IUB supports a
finding that ICN is a common carrier.45 Finally, ITTC argues that the public interest compels
a finding that ICN is a telecommunications carrier because such a ruling would "ensure that
all Iowa schools, libraries and rural health care facilities have access to the advanced services
contemplated by section 254(h) on equitable terms and conditions. "46
17.
Two parties, in addition to the IUB, provided comments in support of ICN's
request, noting that ICN "provides valuable services to Iowa [s]chools," and that, in order to
43
Iowa Admin. Law Code§ 751-9.8(80).
44
ICN petition at 2-4; see also Letter from Kenneth 0. Salomon, counsel for ITIC, to William E
anced services
contemplated by section 254(h) on equitable terms and conditions. "46
17.
Two parties, in addition to the IUB, provided comments in support of ICN's
request, noting that ICN "provides valuable services to Iowa [s]chools," and that, in order to
43
Iowa Admin. Law Code§ 751-9.8(80).
44
ICN petition at 2-4; see also Letter from Kenneth 0. Salomon, counsel for ITIC, to William E. Kennard,
Chairman, FCC, dated December 23, 1998, at 2 (asserting that ICN does not engage in individual negotiations with
its customers, and that ICN holds itself out indifferently to its particular class of customers).
• 5
ICN reply comments at 5; see also IUB comments at 1-3. The IUB is the regulatory agency that generally
oversees the rates and services of public utilities in Iowa, with certain exceptions. Iowa law exempts from IUB
regulation any "public utility in furnishing a telecommunications service or facility to the [ITIC] for the Iowa
Communications Network. or to any authorized user of the Iowa Communications Network for such authorized user's
connection to the network." Iowa Code § 80.13(18).
46
ICN reply comments at 2-3. Although ITIC previously contended that ICN did not have to contribute to
universal service support mechanisms, it acknowledges in its current request that being recognized as eligible for
direct reimbursement under section 254(h)( 1 )(B)(ii). "also will subject ICN to certain obligations." ICN petition at
4. ITIC notes that these obligations include "making universal service contributions as a telecommunications carrier
and complying with other state and federal regulatory'requirements." ICN petition at 4. We note that ICN has filed
contribution worksheets and has made universal service contributions
nder section 254(h)( 1 )(B)(ii). "also will subject ICN to certain obligations." ICN petition at
4. ITIC notes that these obligations include "making universal service contributions as a telecommunications carrier
and complying with other state and federal regulatory'requirements." ICN petition at 4. We note that ICN has filed
contribution worksheets and has made universal service contributions.
In the Universal Service Order, the
Commission concluded that, pursuant to section 254(d), non-common carriers that are "other providers of interstate
telecommunications," including "private service providers that offer interstate telecommunications to others for a fee
and payphone aggregators," must contribute to universal service support mechanisms. Universal Service Order, 12
FCC Red at 9182-86.
3048
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
prevent inequities among schools, "all schools served by the ICN [should] be eligible to
receive" universal service support for telecommunications services.'
17
18.
Several commenters argue that ICN does not meet the definition of a
telecommunications carrier because it does not offer telecommunications on a common carrier
basis by holding itself out indifferently to all potential customers.48 The Iowa Telephone
Association notes that the "Iowa legislature has had ample opportunity to revise the charter of
ICN since the adoption of section 254(h)(l)(A) if it wanted ICN to be a common carrier."49
To date, the legislature has not yet done so
carrier because it does not offer telecommunications on a common carrier
basis by holding itself out indifferently to all potential customers.48 The Iowa Telephone
Association notes that the "Iowa legislature has had ample opportunity to revise the charter of
ICN since the adoption of section 254(h)(l)(A) if it wanted ICN to be a common carrier."49
To date, the legislature has not yet done so. GTE noted that ITTC intends to "have users of
the network proffer bills not for the expenses which they actually incur but rather based upon
ICN's purported overall cost structure," adding that Iowa's Department of Education stated in
a memorandum to Iowa's schools that "[u]sing the non-subsidized rate [on the school and
libraries application form] will help the State of Iowa recoup some of its ICN operating
costs."5° Commenters also assert that the Commission should dismiss ICN's request because it
simply seeks a repetitive reconsideration of the Commission's previous determination in the
Fourth Reconsideration Order that state telecommunications networks are not
"telecommunications carriers" under section 254(h)(l)(B) of the Act. 51
IV. DISCUSSION
19.
As a preliminary matter, we address comments by some parties that ICN's
petition is simply a repetitive petition for reconsideration that should be dismissed because it
presents no new facts or arguments.52 We find that ICN's request for a "determination from
the Commission," however, should be treated as a petition for a declaratory ruling under
47
See IUB comments; James Jess comments and Jerry Schnabel comments submitted with Lener from J.G.
Harrington, ITTC, to Irene Flannery, FCC, dated March 18, 1998.
41
See, e.g., RIITA commentsat3; National TelephoneCooperativeAssociation(NTCA) comments at 5; GTE
reply comments at 2; US West reply comments at 3; Ameritech comments at 2-3.
49
See Iowa Telephone Association ex pane, dated May 5, 1998 at 1 (!TA May 5 ex pane)
comments and Jerry Schnabel comments submitted with Lener from J.G.
Harrington, ITTC, to Irene Flannery, FCC, dated March 18, 1998.
41
See, e.g., RIITA commentsat3; National TelephoneCooperativeAssociation(NTCA) comments at 5; GTE
reply comments at 2; US West reply comments at 3; Ameritech comments at 2-3.
49
See Iowa Telephone Association ex pane, dated May 5, 1998 at 1 (!TA May 5 ex pane). Moreover, the
Iowa Telephone Association asserts that ICN has not asked to be treated as an "eligible telecommunications carrier"
for purposes of providing telecommunications services to rural health care providers. /TA May 5 ex pane at 1.
so
GTE reply comments at 6 (emphasis added in part).
si
See NTCA comments at 4; United States Telephone Association (UST A) comments at 2; GTE reply
comments at 7.
s2
See UST A comments at 2; GTE comments at 7; NTCA comments at 3-4. ICN's only new argument,
contends NTCA, is that it has now agreed to contribute to universal service support mechanisms. NTCA comments
at 4.
3049
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
section 1.2 of the Commission's rules.53 We are persuaded by ICN's contention that the
Fourth Reconsideration _Orcf.er does not entirely preclude the possibility that, under certain
circumstances a state telecommunications network might qualify as a "telecommunications
carrier."
20.
The primary issue before us is whether ICN is a "telecommunications carrier"
within the meaning of the Act and is, therefore, eligible to receive direct reimbursement from
universal service support mechanisms for the provision of discounted telecommunications
services to schools, libraries, and rural health care providers pursuant to section 254(h)( 1 ). s4
We conclude that ICN does not meet the statutory definition of a "telecommunications carrier"
because it does not offer telecommunications on a common carrier basis. ss
21
o receive direct reimbursement from
universal service support mechanisms for the provision of discounted telecommunications
services to schools, libraries, and rural health care providers pursuant to section 254(h)( 1 ). s4
We conclude that ICN does not meet the statutory definition of a "telecommunications carrier"
because it does not offer telecommunications on a common carrier basis. ss
21.
Generally, the test of common carriage, as set forth in the NARUC cases,
analyzes the following factors: ( 1) whether the carrier "holds himself out to serve
indifferently all potential users;" and (2) whether the carrier allows "customers to transmit
intelligence of their own design and choosing."56 Consistent with the D.C. Circuit's statement
that the first requirement of holding oneself out to serve indifferently is a "key factor" in
determining common carrier status,57 our analysis focuses on that first prong of the NARUC
test. We conclude that ICN fails to hold itself out to serve indifferently all potential users
because of the particular facts and circumstances surrounding ICN's operation.58
22.
The evidence shows that ICN fails to "hold itself out" at all, contrary to a
common carrier's duty to hold itself out "to the public" or to a party upon "reasonable
s3
Section 1.2 of our rules provides that the Commission may "on motion, or its own motion, issue a
declaratory ruling terminating a controversy or removing uncertainty." 47 C.F.R. § 1.2.
54
See 41 U.S.C. §§ 254(h)(l)(A) and 254(h)(l)(B)(ii). As noted, an "eligible telecommunications carrier" is
a "common carrier" that is designated an eligible telecommunications carrier by a state commission. See 41 U.S.C.
§ 214(e). Because we determine that ICN is not a common carrier, ICN cannot be designated an "eligible
telecommunications carrier," and is not, therefore, eligible for universal service support under section 254(h)( 1 )(A)
for providing services to rural health care providers.
SS
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5427
lecommunications carrier by a state commission. See 41 U.S.C.
§ 214(e). Because we determine that ICN is not a common carrier, ICN cannot be designated an "eligible
telecommunications carrier," and is not, therefore, eligible for universal service support under section 254(h)( 1 )(A)
for providing services to rural health care providers.
SS
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5427.
s6
Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. v. FCC, l 9 F.3d at 1480 (citing NARUC II, 533 F.2d at 608-09); see also
NARUC /, 525 F.2d at 640-641 ("NARUC cases").
S7
NARUC /, 525 F.2d at 642.
sa
Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. v. FCC, 19 F.3d 1475, 1480 (stating that "[w]hether an entity in a given
case is to be considered a common carrier or a private carrier turns on the particular practice under surveillance").
3050
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
request."59
ICN does not offer its services to the public, nor does it even offer its services to
any requesting party. In fa9t .. ICN serves only an established and stable clientele60 that has
been previously selected by the Iowa legislature. ICN's customer base is closed, except for
those public or private agencies that could request approval from the Iowa legislature to be an
"authorized" user. Both case law and Commission precedent establish that an entity with such
a pre-selected and stable customer base is a private carrier that does not make "any sort of
holding out to the public at all. "
61
23.
Further, ICN does not even "hold [itself] out indiscriminately to the clientele
[it] is suited to serve,"62 because it does not serve indifferently the class of private or public
agencies that comprises its clientele. As noted, the universe of private and public agencies is
divided into three subcategories, each of which is treated differently for eligibility purposes.
Only a select group of private or public agencies were designated as "authorized" as of May
18, 1994
le
[it] is suited to serve,"62 because it does not serve indifferently the class of private or public
agencies that comprises its clientele. As noted, the universe of private and public agencies is
divided into three subcategories, each of which is treated differently for eligibility purposes.
Only a select group of private or public agencies were designated as "authorized" as of May
18, 1994. This group apparently did not need to certify to ICN that it wished to use the
network. A second group, comprised of remaining private or public agencies that were not
deemed "authorized" in the first group, were required to make the appropriate filing and
certify to ITTC by July 1, 1994 that they intended to use the network. Those private and
public agencies that failed to certify to ITTC by July 1, 1994 to be "authorized" could only
use the network by thereafter petitioning the state legislature.63 There are further distinctions
even within these subcategories. By law, for example, ICN serves only federal post offices
that have federal grants for demonstration projects, but not other federal post offices. 64
Moreover, ICN treats its "certified users" differently from its "authorized" users, in that its
"certified users," unlike ICN's other users, are bound by an exclusive statutory arrangement,
in which they must purchase all their telecommunications services from ICN, and must
specifically petition the ITTC in order to be released from taking some of their services from
S9
See 47 U.S.C. §§ 153(46) and 20l(a).
60
See NARUC /, 525 F.2d at 643 (finding that stable clientele, with few new clients, is characteristic of a
private carrier, and not entity that makes "any sort of holding out to the public at all.") See also Noam, Eli M., Will
Universal Service and Common Carriage Survive the Telecommunications Act of 1996?, 97 Colum. L. Rev
me of their services from
S9
See 47 U.S.C. §§ 153(46) and 20l(a).
60
See NARUC /, 525 F.2d at 643 (finding that stable clientele, with few new clients, is characteristic of a
private carrier, and not entity that makes "any sort of holding out to the public at all.") See also Noam, Eli M., Will
Universal Service and Common Carriage Survive the Telecommunications Act of 1996?, 97 Colum. L. Rev. 955, 963
(May 1997) (noting that a common carrier "offer[s] service on a non-discriminatory basis, neutral as to use and
user.")
61
See NARUC I, 525 F.2d at 643; In the Matter ofNorlight, Declaratory Ruling, 2 FCC Red 132, at para.
23, recon. denied, 2 FCC Red 5167 (1987) (finding that a carrier's proposed fiber optic network operation would
constitute private carriage because the record showed that the carrier screened potential customers before allowing
them to use the network).
62
See NARUC /, 525 F.2d at 641-642.
63
Iowa Code§ 80.9, and Iowa Admin. Code§ 751-7.1(80).
64
Iowa Code § 80.9.
3051
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
ICN.65 These requirements clearly indicate that ICN differentiates among various private and
public agencies in the state. For all intents and purposes, ICN appears to be a private carrier,
because it is under no regulatory compulsion to serve indifferently, and in fact, is under
compulsion by state law to discriminate and serve only a highly restricted, individualized
group of users. 66
24.
We reject ITTC's argument reciting the D.C. Circuit's holding that "a
specialized carrier whose service is of possible use to only a fraction of the population may
nonetheless be a common carrier, if he holds himself out to serve indifferently all potential
users."67 As noted, ICN does not hold itself out at all to any group whatsover. At best, the
only remaining category of "potential users" consists of public and private agencies not
previously authorized (either directly by Iowa statute or by the certification process that
terminated on July 1, 1994)
nonetheless be a common carrier, if he holds himself out to serve indifferently all potential
users."67 As noted, ICN does not hold itself out at all to any group whatsover. At best, the
only remaining category of "potential users" consists of public and private agencies not
previously authorized (either directly by Iowa statute or by the certification process that
terminated on July 1, 1994). ICN does not, however, hold itself out to serve these potential
users and must, in fact, deny service requests from them, absent an act of the legislature.
More broadly, ICN clearly fails to hold itself out indifferently "to furnish its services to many
other individuals or entities that could potentially use these services,68 that is, to those that are
not private or public agencies. We find unpersuasive ITTC's argument in a written ex parte
that ICN's distance learning services are so specialized as to be potentially useful to only
those agencies to whom ICN offers service.69 Elsewhere, ICN concedes that its distance
learning services are "pure transmission services, "70 which undermines its assertion that the
services are so specialized as to be of use to only its authorized users. Businesses,
individuals, and other associations not falling within ICN's select group of authorized users
could use ICN's distance learning and telecommunications services, yet they are denied access
to those services. We conclude that ICN fails to show how it serves indifferently all users
that could potentially use its services.
65
See Iowa Code § 80.9(2). Further, the certified user that petitions the ITTC for a waiver of the requirement
to use ICN for all its telecommunications needs must also go through a limited discovery period and a hearing before
the ITTC. See Iowa Admin. Law Code §§ 751-9.4-9.6(80). The ITTC's decision constitutes "final agency action"
that, if appealed, is resolved through alternative dispute resolution. Iowa Admin. Law Code § 751-9.6(2)(80)
d user that petitions the ITTC for a waiver of the requirement
to use ICN for all its telecommunications needs must also go through a limited discovery period and a hearing before
the ITTC. See Iowa Admin. Law Code §§ 751-9.4-9.6(80). The ITTC's decision constitutes "final agency action"
that, if appealed, is resolved through alternative dispute resolution. Iowa Admin. Law Code § 751-9.6(2)(80).
66
NARUC II, 533 F.2d at 1481 (noting that factors supporting a finding that a carrier is a private carrier
include, among other things, there being "no specific regulatory compulsion to serve all indifferently," and the carrier
choosing its clients on an individual basis).
67
NARVC II, 53.3 F.2d at 608-609.
61
See Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. v. FCC, 19 F.3d at 1480.
69
See Lener from J.G. Harrington, ITTC, to Magalie Roman Salas, FCC, dated May 7, 1998 (ICN May ex
parte) at 3.
10
ICN describes the distance learning and telemedicine services as "pure transmission services." ICN reply
comments at 7.
3052
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
25.
We also find no merit in ITTC's contention that there have previously been
instances in which the_ Commission recognized service to limited groups as common carriage.
ITTC cites, for instance: teiephone companies' provision of "common carrier channel service"
to franchised cable operators.
71 In the channel service cases, local telephone companies were
allowed to build out video distribution facilities and services to provide channel service,
which links "a cable operator's headend to subscriber premises."72 The Commission required
the carriers to provide the channel service on "an indiscriminate basis . .
sion of "common carrier channel service"
to franchised cable operators.
71 In the channel service cases, local telephone companies were
allowed to build out video distribution facilities and services to provide channel service,
which links "a cable operator's headend to subscriber premises."72 The Commission required
the carriers to provide the channel service on "an indiscriminate basis . . . to any and all
similarly-situated companies or members of the public."73 A programmer, however, that
wished to deliver video and cable services to subscribers via the channel service, had to obtain
a Title VI cable franchise, as required of all cable operators providing cable service over a
cable system.74 The channel service cases are distinguishable from ICN's case because the
Commission did not restrict the class of users that could receive the underlying channel
service, and in fact, required carriers offering the channel service to provide it on an
"indiscriminate basis." Thus, although the Commission required entities that received the
channel service and provided the cable services that channel service supports to obtain a cable
franchise, the carrier offering the underlying channel service could not discriminate among
potential users. In contrast, in ICN's case, state law clearly requires ICN's services to be
provided on a discriminatory basis, and restricts the group of customers for the services. 7s
71
ICN April 9 ex parte case list at 2 (arguing that the FCC "authorized telephone companies to acquire cable
facilites for the limited purpose of providing common carrier channel service to a limited class of users -- franchised
cable operators - via those facilites subject to section 214 certification").
72
In the Matter of Telephone Company-Cable Television Cross-Ownership Rules, Sections 63.54-63.58, CC
Docket No. 87-266, Memorandum Opinion and Order on Reconsideration and Third Further Notice of Proposed
Rulemaking, 10 FCC Red 244, 247 (1994). See, e.g.
er channel service to a limited class of users -- franchised
cable operators - via those facilites subject to section 214 certification").
72
In the Matter of Telephone Company-Cable Television Cross-Ownership Rules, Sections 63.54-63.58, CC
Docket No. 87-266, Memorandum Opinion and Order on Reconsideration and Third Further Notice of Proposed
Rulemaking, 10 FCC Red 244, 247 (1994). See, e.g.. In re the Application, the Ohio Bell Telephone Company, DA
86-220, Memorandum Opinion, Order and Certificate, l FCC Red 942 (1986) (emphasis added). Sections 63.54-
63.55 of the Commission's rules existed to "generally prohibit telephone common carriers from directly, or indirectly,
constructing cable television facilities and providing video programming to subscribers within their telephone service
areas," but the rules did not "prohibit telephone companies from constructing facilities to provide channel distribution
service for use by others in their telephone service areas." Id at 944. Sections 63.54 and 63.55 no longer exist
because the Telecommunications Act of 1996 repealed the prohibition against telephone common carriers owning
and operating cable television systems. In the Matter of Telephone Company-Cable Television Cross-Ownership
Rules, Sections 63.54-63.58, Report and Order, 11 FCC Red 14639, 14683 (1996).
73
Northwestern Indiana Telephone Co., Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission, 872 F.2d465, 468 (D.C.
Cir. 1989) (emphasis added).
74
In the Matter of Entertainment Connections, Inc., Motion for Declaratory Ruling, Memorandum Opinion
and Order, FCC 98-111, 1998 WL 344168, at para. 11 (rel. June 30, 1998); citing National Cable Television
Association, Inc., v. Federal Communications Commission, 33 F.3d 66, 71-74 (D.C. Cir. 1994).
75
We also reject ITTC's attempts to analogize its case to other examples even more tenuous than the channel
service cases. See /CN April 9 ex parte case list
eclaratory Ruling, Memorandum Opinion
and Order, FCC 98-111, 1998 WL 344168, at para. 11 (rel. June 30, 1998); citing National Cable Television
Association, Inc., v. Federal Communications Commission, 33 F.3d 66, 71-74 (D.C. Cir. 1994).
75
We also reject ITTC's attempts to analogize its case to other examples even more tenuous than the channel
service cases. See /CN April 9 ex parte case list. For example, ITTC erroneously compares its case to Commission
cases that allow common carriers to limit the scope of their services. As we noted above, we find that ICN is not
3053
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
26.
ITTC's reliance on the IUB's comments asserting that ICN is a common carrier
is misplaced.76 The IUB's support of ICN's position that it is a "common carrier" is not
controlling or legally dispositive.n As the D.C. Circuit stated in NARUC I, the "common law
definition of common carrier is sufficiently definite as not to admit of agency discretion in the
classification of operating communications entities. . . . [an entity] is a common carrier by
virtue of its functions, rather than because it is declared to be so."78 Moreover, IUB's
assertion that ICN is a common carrier because it provides services on its network and does
not simply buy or lease facilities from underlying carriers is irrelevant to the determination of
common carrier status. As case law states, a "common carrier is one which undertakes
indifferently to provide communications service to the public for hire, regardless of the actual
ownership or operation of the facilities involved. "79
27
rier because it provides services on its network and does
not simply buy or lease facilities from underlying carriers is irrelevant to the determination of
common carrier status. As case law states, a "common carrier is one which undertakes
indifferently to provide communications service to the public for hire, regardless of the actual
ownership or operation of the facilities involved. "79
27.
Finally, ITTC contends that the public interest would be harmed by an
unfavorable ruling to ICN because there would be: (1) inequitable treatment between Iowa's
schools and libraries and other states' schools and libraries; and (2) inequitable treatment
among ICN's own schools and libraries since some of ICN's services are provided over its
own facilities (and not eligible for direct reimbursement) and other ICN services are provided
over resold facilities (and potentially discounted from other common carriers).80 We reject
ITTC' s argument that the public interest compels a conclusion that ICN is eligible to receive
a common carrier not because it limits its scope of services, but because it serves a restricted class of customers.
Further, ITTC incorrectly compares ICN to Comsat and Amtrak, carriers that have been charged by federal statute
to be common carriers. See 47 U.S.C. §§ 701-02, 49 U.S.C. § 2430l(a)(l). ICN, in contrast to these carriers, was
never deemed to be a common carrier by Iowa statute. Moreover, ITTC incorrectly analogizes its case to a
Commission grant of a Section 214 application for a satellite station to operate on common carrier frequencies even
though the company was serving only one affiliated cable system. See Jn re Application of Tower Communication
Systems Corporation, Memorandum Opinion and Order, 59 FCC 2d 130 ( 1976)
deemed to be a common carrier by Iowa statute. Moreover, ITTC incorrectly analogizes its case to a
Commission grant of a Section 214 application for a satellite station to operate on common carrier frequencies even
though the company was serving only one affiliated cable system. See Jn re Application of Tower Communication
Systems Corporation, Memorandum Opinion and Order, 59 FCC 2d 130 ( 1976). In granting the license in this case,
the Commission noted, however, that the company had filed a request to construct and operate two additional
channels to provide service to a non-affiliated customer and thus, that the company would be providing services
indifferently to other entities that wished to use the service. See id
76
See ICN reply comments at 5. The IUB notes that ICN is a common carrier because it provides services
to all authorized end users and that ICN is "significantly different from other state networks that buy or lease
facilities from underlying carriers and can thus obtain discounts on behalfoftheir ultimate school, library, and health
provider customers." IUB comments at 2.
n
See also Letter from Keith Townsend, USTA, to Magalie Roman Salas, FCC, dated August 31, 1998, at
3 (stating that "there is no indication in the record of this proceeding that the Board even has jurisdiction over ICN
.... The Commission clearly is not bound by [IUB's comments)").
78
NARUC I, 525 F.2d at 644.
79
See AT&T v. FCC, 572 F.2d 17, 24 (2d Cir. 1978) (emphasis added).
80
See ITTC May 7 ex parte at 5 and ITTC reply comments at 3.
3054
oman Salas, FCC, dated August 31, 1998, at
3 (stating that "there is no indication in the record of this proceeding that the Board even has jurisdiction over ICN
.... The Commission clearly is not bound by [IUB's comments)").
78
NARUC I, 525 F.2d at 644.
79
See AT&T v. FCC, 572 F.2d 17, 24 (2d Cir. 1978) (emphasis added).
80
See ITTC May 7 ex parte at 5 and ITTC reply comments at 3.
3054
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
direct reimbursement from universal service support mechanisms under section 254(h)( 1) of
the Act. 81 The Act explicitly provides that only "telecommunications carriers" are eligible for
direct reimbursement plirsuant to section 254(h )(I )(B) and for universal service support
pursuant to section 254(h)(l)(A). Congress did not give the Commission discretion to allow
non-common carriers to receive direct reimbursement or universal service support pursuant to
section 254(h)(l). Iowa's schools and libraries, therefore, are treated no differently from
other states' schools and libraries, in that the Act provides for direct reimbursement of
discounted telecommunications services under section 254(h)( I) to eligible common carriers.
Although the efforts of Iowa and other states that have established state telecommunications
networks to ensure affordable telecommunications services for schools and libraries are
laudable, Congress did not create the federal universal service support mechanism for schools
and libraries specifically in order to support or supplement these state networks, and in fact,
state programs such as Iowa's are incompatible with the federal program. We note, however,
that under the Commission's rules, ICN may receive direct reimbursement for the provision of
the non-telecommunications services of Internet and internal connections to schools and
libraries, and that ICN may act as a consortium in purchasing and passing along discounted
telecommunications services to the schools and libraries that it serves. 82
28
with the federal program. We note, however,
that under the Commission's rules, ICN may receive direct reimbursement for the provision of
the non-telecommunications services of Internet and internal connections to schools and
libraries, and that ICN may act as a consortium in purchasing and passing along discounted
telecommunications services to the schools and libraries that it serves. 82
28.
Moreover, ICN's schools and libraries currently receive low rates, which are
subsidized by funding to ICN from the General Assembly of Iowa 83 For example, we note
that ICN's schools and libraries are charged only $5.00 per hour for video rates, even though
the cost of that service is represented to be approximately $75.00.84 Therefore, we find that
there is nothing in the record to indicate that an unfavorable ruling to I CN would create
unaffordable telecommunications services or inequitable conditions for Iowa's and ICN's
schools and libraries. ICN itself has noted that the competitive bidding process required by
the Commission's rules will ensure that its schools and libraries take their services from the
most competitive providers.85 Finally, we note that our ruling on this issue is consistent with
the Commission's commitment to maintaining a support mechanism that is no larger than
necessary to accomplish Congress' goal in enacting section 254(h)(l)(B) of the Act.
11
See IUB comments at 2; ICN petition at 5; ICN reply comments at 2-4. Further, NTCA notes that because
ICN is subsidized by the state, its low rates provide ICN with a competitive advantage and therefore are inconsistent
with the Commission's goals of competitive neutrality and competitive bidding under Section 254. NTCA comments
at 9.
12
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-25; 47 U.S.C. § 254(hX2); 47 C.F.R.
§ 54.50l(d)(3).
83
See
ICN
webpage,
Frequently
Asked
Questions
about
the
ICN
and
Internet,
at
http://www.icn.state.ia.us/ICN/HTML/F AQs.hnn.
See GTE reply comments at 6
nt
with the Commission's goals of competitive neutrality and competitive bidding under Section 254. NTCA comments
at 9.
12
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5423-25; 47 U.S.C. § 254(hX2); 47 C.F.R.
§ 54.50l(d)(3).
83
See
ICN
webpage,
Frequently
Asked
Questions
about
the
ICN
and
Internet,
at
http://www.icn.state.ia.us/ICN/HTML/F AQs.hnn.
See GTE reply comments at 6.
IS
ICN reply comments at 4.
3055
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
29.
Based on the above analysis, we find that ICN does not meet the test of
common carriage and,~ therefore, is not a "telecommunications carrier." Specifically, I CN does
not hold itself out at all~ let alone offer its services indifferently to its potential users or the
clientele it is suited to serve. 86 Our conclusion is supported by the fact that ICN: (1) serves a
limited and stable group of entities; (2) does not serve additional entities that may seek to
obtain service, absent specific legislative authorization; and (3) treats its customers differently.
Because we find that I CN fails an essential element of common carriage and is not acting as a
"telecommunications carrier," we need not consider ITTC's additional arguments that ICN
offers services on generally available terms and conditions and serves a large number of
customers. We do note that the D.C. Circuit has specifically found that even a tariff filing
with the Commission was not dispositive of whether a service was a common carrier offering,
and thus ITTC' s contention that it offers services on generally available terms and conditions
is not probative of its common carrier status. 87 Moreover, ITTC's assertion regarding the size
of ICN's customer base is irrelevant.88 Finally, because ICN has failed to satisfy the first
element of common carriage, we need not consider whether ICN meets the second element of
the test of common carriage, of allowing its "customers to transmit intelligence of their own
design and choosing. "89
V. CONCLUSION
30
its common carrier status. 87 Moreover, ITTC's assertion regarding the size
of ICN's customer base is irrelevant.88 Finally, because ICN has failed to satisfy the first
element of common carriage, we need not consider whether ICN meets the second element of
the test of common carriage, of allowing its "customers to transmit intelligence of their own
design and choosing. "89
V. CONCLUSION
30.
We conclude that ICN is not a "telecommunications carrier" under Section
254(h) because ICN does not offer telecommunications on a common carrier basis.90 We find,
therefore, that ICN is not eligible for direct reimbursement from universal service support
mechanisms for the provision of discounted telecommunications services to schools and
libraries under section 254(h)(l)(B)(ii), nor is it eligible to receive a credit against its
&6
See NARVC /, 525 F.2d at 641-42.
87
See Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. v. FCC, 19 F.3d at 1483 (holding that "the Commission short-circuited
any analysis of whether petitioners held themselves out indifferently to all potential users of dark fiber," by relying
on an "insupportable per se rule" that a tariff filing with the Commission constitutes a common carrier offering.)
11
See RIITA comments at 4; USTA reply at 2. Contrary to ICN's assertions that the Commission previously
relied on the size of the customer base to conclude Norlight was a private carrier, the Commission actually noted
that Norlight's proposed fiber optic network operation would constitute private carriage because the record did not
show that Norlight would hold its services out indiscriminately to the user public; and instead showed that Norlight
would screen potential customers before allowing them to use the network.
See In the Matter of Norlight,
Declaratory Ruling, 2 FCC Red 132, 135, recon. denied, 2 FCC Red 5167 (1987).
19
See Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. v
onstitute private carriage because the record did not
show that Norlight would hold its services out indiscriminately to the user public; and instead showed that Norlight
would screen potential customers before allowing them to use the network.
See In the Matter of Norlight,
Declaratory Ruling, 2 FCC Red 132, 135, recon. denied, 2 FCC Red 5167 (1987).
19
See Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. v. FCC, 19 F.3d at 1480-1483 (finding that the Commission had not
adequately met the first part of the test and remanding orders to the Commission for consideration of whether dark
fiber offering had been made "indifferently to all potential users").
90
See Fourth Reconsideration Order, 13 FCC Red at 5427.
3056
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
contribution obligation for the provision of telecommunications services to rural health care
providers under section .254(h)(l)(A).
91
VI. ORDERING CLAUSE
31.
Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED, pursuant to sections 4(i), (j), 254, and 403 of
the Act, 47 U.S.C. §§ 154(i), (j), 254, and 403, and section 1.2 of the Commission's rules, 47
C.F .R. § 1.2, that the relief sought in the Petition for Declaratory Ruling filed by the Iowa
Telecommunications and Technology Commission, is DENIED.
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Magalie Roman Salas
Secretary
91
See 41 C.F.R. § 1.2; 47 U.S.C. §§ 254(h)(l)(A) and 254(h)(l)(B).
3057
Federal Communications Commission
DISSENTING STATEMENT OF
COMMISSIONER HAROLD FURCHTGOTT-ROTH
FCC 99-10
Re:
Declaratory Ruling Regarding the Iowa Communications Network in Federal-State
Joint Board on Universal Service, CC Docket 96-45.
I dissent from today's decision finding that the Iowa Communications Network is
ineligible for receiving direct universal service support for the provision of discounted
telecommunications services to schools, libraries, and rural health care providers under
sections 254(h)(l )(A) and (B)
rding the Iowa Communications Network in Federal-State
Joint Board on Universal Service, CC Docket 96-45.
I dissent from today's decision finding that the Iowa Communications Network is
ineligible for receiving direct universal service support for the provision of discounted
telecommunications services to schools, libraries, and rural health care providers under
sections 254(h)(l )(A) and (B). I cannot support such a strict interpretation of our rules that
disadvantages state-based networks while the Commission continues to allow non-carriers,
such as large computer companies, to receive money for providing other services under
Section 254. I believe that such state telecommunications networks are closer to the kinds of
eligible receivers that Congress had envisioned than many of the numerous beneficiaries of
the fund today.
The history of the Commission's interpretation of Section 254 is not a happy one. For
almost two years, the Commission has established programs and promulgated rules under the
guise of Section 254. But these programs and rules, while perhaps engendered with noble
intent, have not met the exacting requirements of Section 254. Indeed, many of these
programs and rules are clearly outside of Section 254, and clearly outside of Commission
authority. I have noted just a few of these many peculiar circumstances in several statements
over the past year: 92
92
See Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgott-Roth Regarding Federal
State Joint Board on Universal Service, CC Docket 96-45, Third Order on Reconsideration, 12
FCC Red 22801 (1997); Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgon-Roth Regarding the
Second Quarter 1998 Universal Service Contribution Factors, rel. March 20, 1998; Dissenting
Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgon-Roth Regarding the Federal-State Joint Board
Report to Congress, rel
garding Federal
State Joint Board on Universal Service, CC Docket 96-45, Third Order on Reconsideration, 12
FCC Red 22801 (1997); Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgon-Roth Regarding the
Second Quarter 1998 Universal Service Contribution Factors, rel. March 20, 1998; Dissenting
Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgon-Roth Regarding the Federal-State Joint Board
Report to Congress, rel. April 10, 1998; Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Harold
Furchtgon-Roth Regarding the Report to Congress in Response to Senate Bill 1768 and
Conference Report on H.R. 3579, rel. May 8,1998; Statement of Commissioner Harold
Furchtgon-Roth Regarding the Common Carrier Bureau's
Proposed Revisions of 1998
Collection Amounts For Schools and Libraries and Rural Health Care Universal Service Support
Mechanisms, rel. May 13, 1998; Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgon-Roth Regarding
the Common Carrier Bureau's Clarification of "Services" Eligible for Discounts to Schools and
Libraries, rel. June 11, 1998; Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgon-Roth Regarding the
Common Carrier Bureau's Third Quarter 1998 Universal Service Contribution Factors, rel. June
12, 1998; Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Harold Furchtgon-Roth Regarding Federal
3058
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
Many parties come before the Commission with disputes about how best to interpret
for specific circumstances <;ommission rules under Section 254.
Iowa has presented the
Commission with an issue that, at least on the surface, seems have substantial merit: that it
would be inequitable to disallow Iowa's schools and libraries from receiving universal service
support for telecommunications services just because those services are being provided by a
state telecommunications network
pecific circumstances <;ommission rules under Section 254.
Iowa has presented the
Commission with an issue that, at least on the surface, seems have substantial merit: that it
would be inequitable to disallow Iowa's schools and libraries from receiving universal service
support for telecommunications services just because those services are being provided by a
state telecommunications network.
The majority's responds that "The Act explicitly provides that only
'telecommunications carriers' are eligible for direct reimbursement pursuant to 254(h)(l)(B)
and for universal service support pursuant to section 254(h)(l)(A)."93 Usually I would
applaud such a straightforward reading of the statute's requirements. But these are the same
requirements that have been ignored by this Com.mission on repeated occasions.
For example, the Commission acknowledges that Section 254(e)'s requirement that
only "eligible telecommunications carriers" receive universal service support applies to Section
254(h) generally.94 Indeed, it limits the recipients of support for providing
telecommunications service to rural health care providers under section 254(h)(l )(A) to those
eligible carriers under 254(e). But then that provision should also apply to the other
provisions of 254(h), at least unless specifically excepted. Thus, Section 254(h)( 1 )(B), which
expressly permits recipients to be "telecommunications carriers," is more specific than 254( e)
and could take precedence. But the provisions of section 254(e) -- which require that only
eligible telecommunications carriers be able to receive federal universal service support --
apply fully to section 254(h)(2). Thus, the requirements for being able to receive funds in
conjunction with section 254(h)(2) are actually stricter -- a recipient would have to be
designated an eligible telecommunications carrier. But the Commission has ignored this
restriction
which require that only
eligible telecommunications carriers be able to receive federal universal service support --
apply fully to section 254(h)(2). Thus, the requirements for being able to receive funds in
conjunction with section 254(h)(2) are actually stricter -- a recipient would have to be
designated an eligible telecommunications carrier. But the Commission has ignored this
restriction.
As one can see, to form an opinion about this issue, one must suspend disbelief in the
legality of the underlying programs and rules. That is, how does one best interpret a statute
for a particular circumstance under a rule that appears to be inconsistent with the statute? If I
were able to suspend disbelief, I would applaud the strict statutory construction: only
telecommunications carriers, which must be common carriers, appear to be eligible to receive
discounts under Section 254(h)(l)(B). The unfortunate result under this program, however, is
that states that had been more forward-looking than most and that had invested substantial
State Joint Board on Universal Service, Fifth Order on Reconsideration and F ounh Repon and
Order Regarding the Federal-State Joint Board on Universal Service, rel. June 17, 1998.
93
Declaratory Ruling at par. 27.
Declaratory Ruling at par. 5.
3059
Federal Communications Commission
FCC 99-10
resources into developing education networks are disadvantaged. And, more importantly, it is
only now in this circ~ce that we are applying the actual requirements of Section 254.
I, for one, believe that these state educational networks, are closer to being eligible
telecommunications carriers than many of those receiving universal service support today.
Moreover, they are at least as close as the computer companies that are receiving support.
Thus, I do not agree with the majority that "state programs such as Iowa's are incompatible
with the federal program."95 Indeed, I find it ironic that· it is only now that some advocate a
strict interpretation of Section 254
nications carriers than many of those receiving universal service support today.
Moreover, they are at least as close as the computer companies that are receiving support.
Thus, I do not agree with the majority that "state programs such as Iowa's are incompatible
with the federal program."95 Indeed, I find it ironic that· it is only now that some advocate a
strict interpretation of Section 254.
Finally, I note that several Congressional leaders have called on the FCC to reconsider
its universal service programs and to start anew in a manner consistent with Section 254.
Any such renewed effort on universals should consider block grants to States and thereby
allow State rather than federal officials, to make final determinations about the assignment of
universal service funds. Such a system would remove FCC Commissioners from having to
repeat the awkward process -- not only of assigning funds among many competing private
companies -- but of resolving disputes in those assignments brought by State governments and
their agencies. Such a system would also allow states to provide support to the forward-
looking educational efforts that they have put in place.
Declaratory Ruling at par. 27.
3060
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.