Documents

Oral argument — Clean Water Action v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 1, 2019

Petitioners really rely on the Clean Air Act for that argument, but the Clean Air Act is different. … I mean, the Clean Air Act gives the stay authority. It's limited to a short time period, and even their courts have held you can't circumvent that limitation.

Oral argument — State of Texas v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 9, 2019

And those two words have different dictionary definitions, and in the Clean Air Act context, the Supreme Court in Michigan v. EPA and Union Electric v. … With respect to these costs in particular, though, I'd note that these are the costs that, you know, one commenter has raised as part of the comment period.

Oral argument — 16 Front Street, L.L.C. v. Mississippi Sili

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 31, 2016

Title V of the Clean Air Act is a totally different area. This is a Title I construction permit case. … What we're challenging is MDEQ's failure to comply with the Clean Air Act mandates in 165A2.

Oral argument — Sierra Club v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 13, 2019

And third, the plan fails to comply with the reasonable progress requirements of the Clean Air Act. … the 1977 amendments to the Clean Air Act.

Oral argument — State of Texas v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 7, 2024

The first is that although there are deadlines that are in the Clean Air Act, there is no statutory deadline in the Clean Air Act for voluntary reclassification. … If that's really true, then the Clean Air Act is not going to function. States have to be able to take the EPA at their word for what their obligations are under the Clean Air Act.

Oral argument — Outsourcing Facilities v. FDA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 30, 2026

I would point to, for example, the many fact-based determinations that the EPA makes under the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act that can include, for example, listing different types of source categories … Another one would be, for example, Clean Air Act Section 112, twice over, in fact.

Oral argument — State of Texas v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 22, 2016

Just last week, EPA issued another Clean Air Act rule involving Ohio and Indiana. … Grid reliability is one of the considerations that you're supposed to consider under the mandated Clean Air Act and under the mandates of the Clean Air Act. Where did you do that?

Oral argument — State of Texas v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 26, 2017

Under the Clean Air Act, there isn't such a mechanism. The Clean Air Act allows the EPA. Well, you're just saying that the D.C. … Our position is not that 2112 is never applicable in Clean Air Act cases.

Oral argument — Environmental Integrity Proj v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2019

Your Honors, Title V of the Clean Air Act is about operating permits. … But petitioners are asking to have the Title V petition process do the entire work of the Clean Air Act. Title V dropped in in 1990. There was a big Clean Air Act before that.

Oral argument — Shrimpers and Fishermen v. TX Cmsn on Env Q

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 8, 2020

The the time and the reason we're here is because of the language or a state administrating its administrative agency acting pursuant to federal law. And this is because the way the Clean Air Act. … Nobody here can get a contested case hearing and at the same time you have to go through a contested case hearing to how EPA interprets the Clean Air Act.

Oral argument — Indigenous Peoples v. U.S. Army Corps

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 3, 2024

period. … They only conduct a Clean Water Act analysis, and it is required under NEPA.

Oral argument — Sierra Club v. LDEQ

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 5, 2024

Air or Clean Water Act permit. … Water Act, Clean Air Act, and Coastal Zone Management Act permits.

Oral argument — State of Texas v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 4, 2025

Air Act. … It's not about simply about data, later data indicating the air was clean or not clean.

Oral argument — Env Tx Citizen Lobby v. ExxonMobil

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 16, 2023

Are you distinguishing the Clean Water Act, are you saying that it marches in lockstep with the Clean Air Act in this? … That's not what a clean air act citizen's suit is. A clean air act citizen's suit is essentially defendant, you are violating a permit limit, court, please stop defendant's violations.

Oral argument — USA v. Luminant Generation Co.,L.L.C., et a

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 5, 2018

air act and the prevention of significant deterioration anything about is that what you're saying well the injunction we can even if you disagree even if you follow the third circuit you agree with the … uh the concurrent remedies doctrine in the clean air act context but the court need not reach that issue because the supreme court has been clear that in the absence of clear congressional mandate a governmental

Oral argument — TX Medical Association v. HHS

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 24, 2025

May it please the Court, Stephen Shackelford for LifeNet and East Texas Air One, arguing on behalf of all the air ambulance plaintiffs. … I appreciate them, but I'm hopeful that we don't all need an air ambulance in our lives. Most of us, God willing, will not need an air ambulance.

Oral argument — East Fork Enterprises v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 3, 2025

How does EPA regulate methylene chloride under the Clean Air Act? There's a NESHAP, National Emission Standard for Hazardous Air Pollutants for Methylene Chloride. So what does that require? … Air Act regulations?

Oral argument — State of Texas v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 7, 2022

Air Act. … Circuit's recently decided Clean Air Wisconsin case. The EPA did so again here.

Oral argument — Gulf Restoration Network v. Gina McCarthy

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 4, 2014

It's happened roughly in the 40 years of the Clean Water Act about 10 times. … You can look at Section 101 of the Clean Water Act, which defines what the goals of water quality standards have to be, and then the Clean Water Act itself in Section 303, which actually begins with the

Oral argument — Env Texas Citizen Lobby, Inc. v. ExxonMobil

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 7, 2018

Altaverde and as the district court ruled, a claim in a citizen suit, in a Clean Water Act or Clean Air Act citizen suit context, is that the defendant is in violation of an emission limit. … First of all, the act of God defense is not in the state implementation plan, and therefore under the Clean Air Act it cannot be asserted in this case.