Documents

Oral argument — United States v. W.R. Grace

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 7, 2005

So then I went to the one thing that was listed, the Disaster Relief Act and Emergency Assistance Act, to see if that might be illuminating. … Well, you would have had to also prepare a feasibility study with a detailed analysis and allow for a notice and comment period, right? That's correct, Your Honor. There's more.

Oral argument — Rinnai America Corporation v. South Coast Air Quality Management District

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 5, 2026

Second, on the Clean Air Act, the district hasn't identified any provision of the Clean Air Act that would be repealed by applying EPCA preemption here, consistent with the CRA decision. … So I think the Clean Air Act already reconciles itself with other obligations under federal law when states are pursuing their obligations under the Clean Air Act. We'd ask this court to reverse.

Oral argument — Owner-Operator Ind. Drivers v. Richard Corey

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 19, 2017

Now, the association also argues that somehow dump truck is distinguishable because the USEPA did address Clean Air Act preemption issues when the dump truck case involved the F4A preemption issue. … But it didn't matter because that failure was because nobody raised it in comments.

Oral argument — Olson v. United States

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 10, 2004

They basically can't breathe very well because it's hot, and the forced air fans to try and move the air through create such noise that it's hard to hear. … I'm going to clean up my – I'm going to clean up my – I'm going to clean up my desk. I'm going to clean up my desk. I'm going to clean up my desk. I'm going to clean up my desk.

Oral argument — Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation v. Naples Restaurant Group, LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 6, 2024

So had Congress intended to cover Clean Water Act, for the Clean Water Act to cover fireworks, it certainly knew how to do so. … The Clean Air Act was contemplated to include fireworks, and then specifically Congress excluded them from that act. Fireworks are shot in the air, not at the water.

Oral argument — Christopher Curtis v. ABB Inc.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 20, 2015

There's testimony in the record about the use of compressed air to clean these asbestos components. … asbestos art shoots, using compressed air, and cleaning up after exploded asbestos products.

Oral argument — City of Mukilteo, Washington v. USDOT

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 18, 2014

Well, Your Honor, if you look at the table in Appendix P, you will note that just that 8,500 additional operations throws them out of conformity under the Clean Air Act. By what, three metric tons? … That would trigger the requirement under the Clean Air Act to perform a conformity analysis, which is just what it sounds like.

Oral argument — United Farm Workers of America v. Administrator, Environment

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 7, 2009

Clean Air Act, some issues are reviewed immediately in the Court of Appeals. … There are many Clean Air Acts. I had probably one of the biggest Clean Water Acts involving sewage. And it went through the district court. Yes, Your Honor, there are.

Oral argument — Compassion Over Killing v. FDA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 14, 2016

EPA, the critical point was the EPA had denied that it had the ability to regulate greenhouse gases as an air pollutant under the Clean Air Act. … Essential to the decision was the fact that the Clean Air Act had defined an air pollutant as, and it was emphasized multiple times in the opinion, any, the word any being of critical importance, any air

Oral argument — South Fork Band Council of We v. DOI

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2009

Unless there's some other violation, Clean Air Act, Endangered Species Act, case, you know, statutes this Court is very familiar with, we can't say no. … Sounds arcane, but it's a very harmful criteria pollutant in the Clean Air Act. And we argued in the comments, where is your analysis of PM 2.5? No analysis in the final EIS.

Oral argument — Compassion Over Killing v. FDA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 14, 2016

EPA, the critical point was the EPA had denied that it had the ability to regulate greenhouse gases as an air pollutant under the Clean Air Act. … Essential to the decision was the fact that the Clean Air Act had defined an air pollutant as, and it was emphasized multiple times in the opinion, any, the word any being of critical importance, any air

Oral argument — State of California v. USA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 25, 2026

Section 209A of the Clean Air Act. … Air Act.

Oral argument — Ronald Fleshman, Jr. v. Volkswagen, AG

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 7, 2017

We have come here to ask this Court to command compliance with the Clean Air Act by allowing Mr. … Air Act is a continuum.

Oral argument — Daniel Gonzalez v. Gregory Ahern

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 16, 2022

Because the impression one could get from reading some of the briefs is that it's just sort of this plastic sheeting that's been just opened to the outside air. But is that accurate? … I wanted to respond to one comment with regard to the question of whether or not the statute rises to a constitutional standard. And I want to cite Gray v.

Oral argument — Pacific Coast Fed'n of Fishermen's Ass'ns, Inc. v. Ernest Conant

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 21, 2024

The District Court failed to follow the Clean Water Act's express language, and this Court's careful ruling in PCFFA v. Glazer. … So from that perspective, in terms of the initial application of the Clean Water Act, where it enters the navigable waters is what counts.

Oral argument — CARSON HARBOR v. UNOCAL CORP.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 17, 2005

period. … period.

Oral argument — Alaska Wilderness League v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 21, 2013

In violation of the Clean Air Act, EPA granted Shell a permit without requiring Shell to demonstrate it would comply with so called increment standards intended to keep clean air clean. … When 504E tells a temporary source that it must assure compliance with all requirements of the Act, including National Ambient Air Quality Standards and applicable increments, did Congress mean all temporary

Oral argument — Alaska Eskimo Whaling Comm v. Ken Salazar

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 6, 2010

So assuming that Shell gets all of the permits it needs, that would be the- Are you still waiting for the Clean Air Act? You are there, still waiting for the Clean Air Act. Right. … There's Clean Air, there's National Marine Fisheries Service, Incidental Harassment Office. Any of those contingent on what happens with us? Are they just going forward?

Oral argument — Center for Biological Diversit v. Ken Salazar

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 18, 2012

Or Denison's predecessor, and then Denison, was required to comply with applicable Clean Air Act permitting requirements, Clean Water Act permits, state groundwater permits. … They had to obtain an Air Act permit, but the Clean Air Act has a NEPA exclusion. So EPA was not required to do a NEPA analysis on issuance of the air permit.

Oral argument — NAZI v. ASHCROFT

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 6, 2004

He was promoted to an Air Force major. … I'm coming in trying to clean up a record.