Documents

Oral argument — Farchione Motors, Inc. v. Volkswagen Group of America

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 11, 2020

Air Act found that Volkswagen has potentially continuing and even if it's unexpected and enormous liability, the plain language text and structure as a matter of law can lead to that outcome. … So first, VW, acting as a claim administrator, makes an initial eligibility determination.

Oral argument — Vaad L'Hafotzas Sichos, Inc. v

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 22, 2017

In the Air Maze case, which is the case that we rely on, this circuit looked at a situation where a defendant was creating Air Maze knockoff bags and was advertising to the public that these were knockoffs … And that period of latches far exceeded the period of latches in this case. But the court was enforcing this public right not to be confused. Was there bad faith in Air Maze?

Oral argument — State of Alaska v. EDUC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 21, 2024

That's true for all the finance industries which rely on interest, and to say that there's not even a procedural injury that's such that they couldn't file comments in a notice and comment period would … EPA, it was whether they could make the clean air programs work, and they had to have a certain number of states to rate a critical mass, and they assumed that they were going to get that, and they didn't

Oral argument — Cent. Sierra Envtl. Res. Ctr. v. Stanislaus Nat'l Forest

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 14, 2020

Section 313 of the Clean Water Act requires federal agencies to comply fully with state and local water quality requirements. … It was adopted pursuant to notice and comment rule making. It was analyzed under the California Environmental Quality Act.

Oral argument — Union Pacific Railroad Company v. Intl. Assn. of SMART

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 17, 2020

Assn. of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail, and Transportation Workers Mr. … Lebsack's actions of purposefully defecating on the knuckle of his train and leaving his feces for others to clean up, somehow did not constitute conduct worthy of upholding his termination It is from

Oral argument — Waterkeeper Alliance v. United States Environmental Protection Agency

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 5, 2024

When Congress wrote the Clean Water Act in 1972, they made cleaning up the nation's and making our waters fishable and swimmable again. … And the Clean Water Act intends for those limits to keep pace with technology.

Oral argument — Milo Shammas v. Margaret Focarino

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 10, 2014

Some of them in the Lanham Act itself? That's right, Your Honor. There are five of them. Five of them in the Lanham Act itself. … So we're on a clean slate or we're the first one? I don't think you're on a clean slate. We're the first court of appeals? Pardon?

Oral argument — People v. Muth

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 26, 2014

Well, you told me he was cleaning with you, so you have to know. Well, yeah, he was cleaning. … My question is, proof beyond a reasonable doubt of more than two for each act.

Oral argument — United States v. Howard

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 14, 2004

What does a clean gun mean? All of those things I think were proper and the judge did not abuse his discretion in allowing that to come in. … Could you comment on the argument by the defendant that this is the equivalent of a one-photo display? Yes, Your Honor.

Oral argument — Delaware Riverkeeper Networketal. v. Sec of the Pennsylvania Dept

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 13, 2017

Well, I think that the interpretations of the Clean Streams Law mirror how the Clean Water Act has been interpreted. … It's a 30-day period under state law, under the Pennsylvania Clean Streams Law, the Dam Safety and Encroachments Act, and the implementing regulations concerning procedures before the Environmental Hearing

Oral argument — Environmental Integrity Proj. v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 10, 2017

provision of Section 308B of the Clean Water Act. … And it looked at the Clean Water Act and the Clean Air Act, and it considered it in connection with the Freedom of Information Act and said it only makes sense to read these two consistently.

Oral argument — City of Salisbury, North Carol v. FERC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 2, 2021

That's exactly what Congress did here in section 1341d of the Clean Water Act. … Well, I think Your Honor would be correct if we were not operating in the context of the Clean Water Act, but the Clean Water Act is built around the idea of federalism.

Oral argument — Sterling v. City of Jackson

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 12, 2026

Even in Querton, the majority, it's a 2-1 decision, said that there's no right to clean water. The issue was this lack of informed consent. … Again, that's a factual question, but based on the allegations, and that's what we're here on, they did not act responsibly. A few quick other points.

Oral argument — Annakutty Joseph v. Target Stores, Inc.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 8, 2023

It was an expert who was testifying that the slippery floor was created by probably a poor combination of cleaning products. … Does Virginia law comment on that issue?

Oral argument — United States v. Leal

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 16, 2007

Yes, his hands were clean. There were many, many things that do not add up to reasonable suspicion. … Leal for the period. You mentioned Atwater. It would have been okay to arrest him here under Pennsylvania law because of the tinted windows. You're not pursuing that.

Oral argument — Lighthiser v. Trump

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 13, 2026

or in the Clean Air Act that plaintiffs studiously avoid and omit from their complaint because they're not challenging any agency action. … Plaintiffs toss out a number of allegedly illegal statutory violations by federal agencies, but they don't bring challenges to any of these agency actions under the APA or the Clean Air Act, and instead

Oral argument — Kelly v. Cothern

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 4, 2019

Because at that point, really, the marriage was up in the air. They weren't divorced yet, correct? … Kelly was cleaning out her—not necessarily cleaning out, but was looking for, I believe, a life insurance document in her mother's room and happened to stumble across the trust. This was when?

Oral argument — Villareal v. Bureau of Prisons

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 13, 2018

And also made the comment... Now, these people that are testifying, were they former employees? Excuse me? This testimony that you're talking about, that was now, was in front of the arbitrator. … Okay, but this is during the seven-month period. Right. They have to show that... And this is all trying to decide whether a criminal act occurred? Well, yes.

Oral argument — Sierra Club v. FERC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 13, 2015

the impact of this increased production is on the air. … And that's true regardless of whether we're in the non-attainment context where there's a Clean Air Act conformity determination or just the general NEPA analysis.

Oral argument — United States v. Cruz

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2014

There were intermittent comments by Mr. Cruz. … You know, you're arguing plain air, and we asked the defense counsel about plain air. Judge Cowan alluded to it. Does it really make any difference here?