Documents

Oral argument — Life Partners Creditors' Trust v. Root Hosp

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 7, 2018

So it would not be futile on the Texas Securities Act. … When you keep saying this isn't air, that's the debated point. If Cassidy had no insight, it would be air.

Oral argument — United States Steel Corp. v. Scott Pruitt, Administrator

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 15, 2017

In addition to information they got through 114 requests, which are information collection requests under the Clean Air Act. … Your Honor, in this case, United States Steel is challenging a revised federal implementation plan, or FIPP, under the Clean Air Act's Regional Haze Program that revised emission limits for four taconite

Oral argument — Stone v. High Mountain Mining Company

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 18, 2023

That's not how the Clean Water Act works. You know, the Clean Water Act doesn't prohibit pollution. … You have a permit for it or you don't discharge it, period. That's what the Clean Water Act says. We don't need to thin slice it and slice and dice it to see what was in it.

Oral argument — United States v. David Han

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 4, 2013

Your Honor, I'm not familiar enough with that case to be able to comment. … Either Clean Air Act violation would amount to a... I'm sorry, either a violation of the work practice standard would be... Why isn't this case essentially the same?

Oral argument — Seigler v. Wal-Mart Stores TX

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 5, 2021

Or what was the consistency those questions never get asked, and a lay person is expected to pull those out of the air. … and inspecting, and if they had inspected or cleaned more, they should have seen the condition.

Oral argument — Victor Township Drainage Dist. 1 v. Lundeen Family Farm Partnership

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 19, 2014

period, which Mr. … Lundin to come to the meeting, they were acting upon his request. His request. Now, there was a comment in there somewhere by Mr.

Oral argument — Houston Aquarium, Incorporated v. OSHC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 2, 2020

The OSHA Act, Section 6D of the OSHA Act, provides that employers can seek a variance from any standard. OSHA has an entire office dedicated to processing variance applications. … To change an additional air supply takes longer than that. And not only that, the addition of bulkier equipment does affect the ability of the diver to observe what's going on.

Oral argument — Allco Finance Limited v. Klee

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 9, 2016

So the state here is acting as a regulator. Is that right? … My commissioner would have the right of commenting and saying we like it or don't, but I can't do anything at that point.

Oral argument — Klamath-Siskiyou Wildlands Ctr v. Rob MacWhorter

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 4, 2015

Because the case law on what constitutes sufficient notice speaks repeatedly about the purpose of these notice provisions that are a prominent feature not just of the Endangered Species Act, but the Clean … Water Act, the Clean Air Act, all these major federal environmental statutes, are designed to prevent litigation when at all possible by giving the federal agency a chance to correct its course of action

Oral argument — Housatonic River Initiative v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 6, 2023

So why doesn't the notice and comment period take place? Your Honor, because the essential terms were decided in the settlement negotiation. They took, they got 400 comments. … , again, I respectfully submit that was not an effective notice and comment period.

Oral argument — State of Tennessee v. Department of Education

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 26, 2023

In other words, if the EPA is enforcing the Clean Water Act or the Clean Air Act, they could, they're regs, but they're really enforcing the statute ultimately, right? … As Judge Nowandian said, in Chevron itself, like a stationary source was an interpretation of the Clean Air Act, right? So, I mean, that was a legislative rule.

Oral argument — Kenite Webb v. City of Venice, Florida

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 6, 2024

So when did the supervisor tell him to clean it up? I'm sorry? When did the supervisor tell him to clean it up? Upon report, she said, get some paint and go clean it up. That day. … I don't believe there's a case when you talk about proximity or severity over a period of time, various isolated statements over a period of years. This is six months later.

Oral argument — Cook Inletkeeper v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 27, 2010

The issues in this case go to the very heart of the Clean Water Act and what is required to protect water quality. … In the comment period, you mean, or in the briefing? Well, at any time, because the issue here is waiver. Have you waived this plan? I couldn't point you exactly in our comments.

Oral argument — California Dept. of Toxic Substances Control v. Northern Burlington

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 12, 2005

And the contamination is what's remained and has to be cleaned up. I'm sorry? The contamination is what has remained and has to be cleaned up. Correct. … That comes out of thin air. Counsel talked about DD being volatile.

Oral argument — Property I.D. Corporation v. Greenwich Insurance Company

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 9, 2010

The allegations and the claims in NDA involve different wrongful acts, different time periods, different parties. Sergio Siderman doesn't hold any of the NDA claims. … Just to briefly respond to counsel's comment concerning the definition of claim, two comments.

Oral argument — Wesco Insurance Company v. Brad Ingram Construction

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 13, 2023

The odd thing to me on the question of commonly considered pollution is obviously dust is considered a pollutant under the Clean Air Act and under California statutes, and near this wildfire in the San … What did injure somebody in this case was the operation to clean up those pollutants created by the campfire. Those are following acts.

Oral argument — Bering Strait Citiz v. USACE

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 26, 2007

The same is true of the Clean Water Act at 40 CFR section 230.10, a finding of no significant degradation. … I cannot speak to the Clean Water Act obligations for permittees with respect to that.

Oral argument — Rhonda Williams v. Mosaic Fertilizer, LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 19, 2018

You know, that's in the Clean Air Act itself, that the administrator must set a standard with a margin of safety. So, for Ms. Williams or Dr. … Mink to maintain that 75 is a benchmark, a threshold at which health effects will be felt, would necessarily mean that the administrator of EPA violated the Clean Air Act by setting a standard that has

Oral argument — George Pardo v. Stuart Sherman

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 11, 2018

But by the way, can I make a comment on that? The doctor who examined this child also missed those observations? … And then the next day, saying that he was horsing around with the child, tossing her in the air, and he dropped her.

Oral argument — PSA v. Port of Tacoma

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 7, 2022

The words of the permit matter, and the words of the Clean Water Act matter. … By October 23rd of 2017, PSA had got everything it wanted and compliance with the Clean Water Act had been achieved.