Documents

Oral argument — United States v. Rose

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 28, 2007

up winning anyway even under the Plain Air statute. … I believe the government won even under Plain Air.

Oral argument — American Farm v. US Environmental

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 19, 2014

Congress had a purpose in mind when it enacted the Clean Water Act, and it put EPA at the head of efforts to achieve that purpose. … Instead, I think that the Clean Water Act, like the Clean Air Act that the Supreme Court interpreted last year in UARG, a utility regulatory group, is a complex technical statute that Congress necessarily

Oral argument — United States v. Vega

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 27, 2022

I think that goes to the point that Judge Hardiman has raised because you're here in plain air. Is it clear and obvious? Nobody's quite sure on this question. … Cocaine isomers was in the 1984 Criminal Justice Act. So by 1985, New Jersey was regulating it. And that language is cocaine isomers, optical and geometric.

Oral argument — Thomas v. Tice

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 16, 2019

Similarly, the the clean X-ray at J.A. 162 and J.A. 314, J.A. 162. My client testified to having been told by staff that he had had a clean X-ray. … But the X-ray had been clean.

Oral argument — USAv.Perez

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 16, 2013

You want us in your view to clean up Knight. Is that what this is all about? … I didn't just sort of snatch it out of thin air. How did you get into Night? Just tell me that.

Oral argument — Delaware Riverkeeper Network v. Sec PA Dept of Environmental Prot

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 7, 2017

It is a right protected by the Clean Water Act. The dissent, though, right? … federal requirements of the Clean Water Act.

Oral argument — Clark v. Governor State NJ

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 23, 2022

Regarding that time frame, I would note that the municipal court litigation was stayed for an extended period, I believe, at the request of the appellants. Eventually, that stay was lifted. … Power Plan, which was a generation-shifting theory under Section 111D of the Clean Air Act.

Oral argument — National Parks Conservation Association v. US Environmental Protection Agency

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 14, 2015

It requires a decision about how much that's going to benefit air quality, including from one plant to multiple park receptors, multiple parks that receive air pollution from that one plant. … Based on that following additional information, we think that the state is compliant with the Clean Air Act. Boom.

Oral argument — LITGO New Jersey Inc v. Commissioner NJ Dept of Environm Protection

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 14, 2013

Well, not if the party is specifically submitting plans to that agency, Your Honor, and getting the comments and directions from the agencies and then following those comments and directions, and there's … The DEP brought in a cleanup company, Clean Ventures, and they proceeded to clean up in a sloppy way, which caused spills. And Senzari was excluded from access to his own property during this period.

Oral argument — Hagan v. Rogers

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2009

There's nothing in Rule 21 that says every prisoner case shall be severed into separate acts. … Second, this case doesn't fairly present the question of the circuit split, alluding to some of Judge Gordon's comments just a few minutes ago. Well, maybe we can create a new circuit split.

Oral argument — Secof Labor v. Trinity

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 22, 2009

But as this court said in the Clean Ocean case, as long as that regulation is on the books, the Secretary of Labor is bound by it. … The fact that the Trinity failed to test, that's the reason we don't have air samples or monitoring data.

Oral argument — Vicaulic Comp v. Tieman

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2009

The Act, the Pennsylvania Trade Secrets Act, does provide for the potential of injunctive relief. … But an injunction was entered in Air Products, right?

Oral argument — 19-1946_USA v. Gardner

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 13, 2020

The question then is because the government was on notice and did not object, this must be reviewed for plain air. And there are two reasons why the government can't satisfy plain air in this case. … Kokas's initial comments. I don't disagree with there was a change in docketing here. This isn't something that just happened. This has been on the dockets a really long time.

Oral argument — Jill Sillelee v. Precision Airmotive Corp

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 26, 2015

But, you know, let me just clean apart what you said a little bit. You know, you said they result in inconsistent verdicts and standards, right? … It didn't talk about all air regulation.

Oral argument — Timofey V v. United States

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 9, 2026

And instead, he provided documents showing that he was only the registrant for a shorter period of time, an intermittent period of time. That's correct. … So we would request that- So you want to remand so that this can be aired? The essence of your argument is here that the district court jumped the gun.

Oral argument — United States v. Scott

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 13, 2021

So, this, this court is hardly applying clean air in the willy nilly fashion in a willy nilly fashion, and certainly in the sentencing context. … This is not air to say that Hobbs act robbery is a crime of violence under the career offender guideline. The, and the other courts are simply mistaken.

Oral argument — People Against Police Violence v. Cityof Pittsburgh

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2009

So you were protected during that period if they tried to put insurance requirements, cost recovery requirements, long waiting periods. That's all covered. … And it's no different than if you look at Pennsylvania versus Delaware Valley, the Supreme Court case where you're dealing with trying to get the state to fix Clean Air Act provisions.

Oral argument — Grossvs German Foundation

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2009

This one, I think, there's clean jurisdiction. This one, no amount of prayer will make the jurisdiction go away. … And with respect to Judge Stapleton, he wasn't right when he made his offhand comment from the bench.

Oral argument — Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line v. PA Environmental Hearing Board

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 19, 2023

There is no right in the Clean Water Act to an adjudicative hearing under the Clean Water Act. … under the Clean Water Act.

Oral argument — Vorchheimer v. The Philadelphia Owners Association

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 23, 2018

She can't stand for even short periods of time, so she requires the use of a walker. … It hasn't gone through notice and comment. It doesn't get Chevron deference. It gets Skidmore deference. Correct. I don't see anything in there that parses the statute.