Documents

Oral argument — Healthy Gulf v. FERC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 12, 2024

So a project that exceeds the SIL, where air quality will exceed the NAAQS, causes and contributes, and so cannot be permitted under the Clean Air Act. … So there was a two-stage modeling here where the modeling was done under the Clean Air Act, which FERC based its NEPA modeling on.

Oral argument — Beverly Zylstra v. DRV, LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 11, 2020

So this case is about the door lock, the screw, and the air antenna. … Also, I think it's important to remember that DRVs would not guarantee that they could clean out that sewage issue and fix it.

Oral argument — Beatrice Boler v. Darnell Earley

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 15, 2017

We have not recognized fundamental rights to clean drinking water or to clean air. That is just not something we've recognized as a constitutional right. … You commented on the savings clause. And I know Judge Levy's opinion was submitted to you guys. And I just wanted to make the quick comment because I know I'm way out of time.

Oral argument — NU-WAY CONCRETE v. DHS

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 7, 2011

Unfortunately, during this time period, it was a time period where there was a lot of trailers would be taken, and how clean they wanted those things to be, and how repaired they wanted them to be, versus … The four pages of the contract detail exactly how you go about cleaning out the sewage tanks. And it says to use pressurized air and to get the unit dry.

Oral argument — United States v. W.R. Grace

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 7, 2005

So then I went to the one thing that was listed, the Disaster Relief Act and Emergency Assistance Act, to see if that might be illuminating. … Well, you would have had to also prepare a feasibility study with a detailed analysis and allow for a notice and comment period, right? That's correct, Your Honor. There's more.

Oral argument — Sinclair Wyoming Refining Company LLC v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 3, 2023

So the Clean Air Act set presumptive annual volumes of most renewable fuels through 2022, but provided EPA multiple authorities to waive those circumstances. … Air Act.

Oral argument — Rinnai America Corporation v. South Coast Air Quality Management District

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 5, 2026

Second, on the Clean Air Act, the district hasn't identified any provision of the Clean Air Act that would be repealed by applying EPCA preemption here, consistent with the CRA decision. … So I think the Clean Air Act already reconciles itself with other obligations under federal law when states are pursuing their obligations under the Clean Air Act. We'd ask this court to reverse.

Oral argument — Ohio v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 21, 2024

With respect to the Clean Air Act itself, it ties publication in the Federal Register to final agency action that is reviewable under the Clean Air Act's judicial review provision. … Air Act, and the good neighbor plan that the EPA implemented.

Oral argument — Raritan v. NLIndustries

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 14, 2011

It passed an act that said that, whether Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, RCRA, there are many citizen suit provisions that allows citizen suits to supplement but not supplant. … The four-party settlement agreement was submitted for public comment or opportunity to comment on it. Not the settlement agreement. It was the agreement about the on-land. The on-land.

Oral argument — Haw River Assembly v. United States Army Corps of Engineers

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 13, 2026

And Congress made that clear when it preempted regulation of natural gas pipelines, except in the instance of the Clean Water Act, the Coastal Zone Management Act, and the Clean Air Act. … That's not the way the Clean Water Act is written.

Oral argument — Olson v. United States

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 10, 2004

They basically can't breathe very well because it's hot, and the forced air fans to try and move the air through create such noise that it's hard to hear. … I'm going to clean up my – I'm going to clean up my – I'm going to clean up my desk. I'm going to clean up my desk. I'm going to clean up my desk. I'm going to clean up my desk.

Oral argument — Owner-Operator Ind. Drivers v. Richard Corey

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 19, 2017

Now, the association also argues that somehow dump truck is distinguishable because the USEPA did address Clean Air Act preemption issues when the dump truck case involved the F4A preemption issue. … But it didn't matter because that failure was because nobody raised it in comments.

Oral argument — Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation v. Naples Restaurant Group, LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 6, 2024

So had Congress intended to cover Clean Water Act, for the Clean Water Act to cover fireworks, it certainly knew how to do so. … The Clean Air Act was contemplated to include fireworks, and then specifically Congress excluded them from that act. Fireworks are shot in the air, not at the water.

Oral argument — State of West Virginia v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 27, 2023

In the Clean Air Act, Congress empowered states to take the lead in deciding how best to comply with the National Ambient Air Quality Standards. … That doesn't allow for the amount of discretion that the Clean Air Act contemplates. All right. Thank you. You have some rebuttal. Okay. Mr. Hardy.

Oral argument — EPA v. Calumet Shreveport Refining, L.L.C.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 25, 2025

Chief Justice, and may it please the Court, this case provides a paradigmatic example of the result that the Clean Air Act's venue provision was intended to avoid. … I mean, it's a cooperative federalism system, the Clean Air Act. It wanted room for both, and we're now trying to figure out where the line is.

Oral argument — LATSCH v. DVA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 5, 2010

He had to have a clean rifle. He didn't clean it while he was on duty on the weekends, but he waited until Monday night to clean his rifle and oil it and have it ready for the next month. … And we would also note that, of course, the government is presumed to act in good faith.

Oral argument — City of Mukilteo, Washington v. USDOT

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 18, 2014

Well, Your Honor, if you look at the table in Appendix P, you will note that just that 8,500 additional operations throws them out of conformity under the Clean Air Act. By what, three metric tons? … That would trigger the requirement under the Clean Air Act to perform a conformity analysis, which is just what it sounds like.

Oral argument — Hearth, Patio & Barbecue Assoc v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 28, 2021

But if that were good enough, then EPA would always be able to dodge review in these sorts of cases, because remember the Clean Air Act requires that challenges to nationally applicable rules, such as … Both are substantive in this court's view, according to prior Clean Air Act precedents.

Oral argument — Christopher Curtis v. ABB Inc.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 20, 2015

There's testimony in the record about the use of compressed air to clean these asbestos components. … asbestos art shoots, using compressed air, and cleaning up after exploded asbestos products.

Oral argument — Oklahoma v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 25, 2025

This Court's landmark Clean Air Act cases, state implementation plan cases, train and Union Electric, both arose from circuit splits where different circuits were adjudicating different state plans, but … The Clean Air Act's venue provision channels challenges to national EPA actions to the D.C.