Documents

Oral argument — Renard Austin v. Michael Mosley

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 10, 2024

If Operation Clean Sweep predated this search warrant affidavit, I mean, I understand you'd have a really good argument there, but Operation Clean Sweep's report was three years after this affidavit. … It was a Operation Clean Sweep and the report. The report, I agree, didn't come out until 2021. But the evidence indicates that these improprieties were going on during earlier time periods.

Oral argument — Guenther v. BP Retr Accumulation

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 31, 2022

So for that whole period, we thought we'd have the opportunity to opt-out. … Morrison's arguments other than his comment about the class certification. I think fundamentally one of the key things the court needs to look at today is what is the class definition?

Oral argument — Cameron Parish v. Indian Harbor Ins

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 9, 2024

The answer to that question is undoubtedly yes, for at least two reasons, under both the Federal Arbitration Act and under the New York Convention. … And so I think you've got just a very clean question of law that you can decide. You have appellate jurisdiction through this refusal prong.

Oral argument — Overwell Harvest, Limited v. Trading Technologies Internati

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 15, 2024

And when you have a statute like the Clean Water Act, that wasn't around in England. So you have to figure out how would it have been treated or presented more than 200 years ago. … So in Tall versus the United States, we had a situation on the Clean Water Act. Somebody was polluting protected wetlands in Virginia. And the government sought $22 million in civil penalties.

Oral argument — Gary Vander Boegh v. EnergySolutions Inc

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 30, 2014

I've got a question as to our jurisdiction regarding the environmental statutes, the Drinking Water Act, the Clean Water Act, and the Toxic Substance Control Act. … Your honor is correct that if this were only, let's say, a Clean Air Act case or a Toxic Substance Control Act case or clean water, safe drinking water, we wouldn't have had the option to go to federal

Oral argument — Lobo IV, LLC v. V Land Chicago Canal, LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 17, 2019

How about clean hands? Is clean hands an element? Clean hands would be an affirmative defense to an equitable cause of action. … Scheid's comments, Lobo did not go out and hire just any appraiser. The permanent lender did.

Oral argument — United States v. George Renteria

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 6, 2020

We have your client, after the fact, acting in a fairly rational manner, apparently hiding evidence of the crime. … He didn't come out of thin air when he killed him. You're right. I misspoke. What I meant to say was there's no evidence that he brought the weapon to the scene.

Oral argument — Center for Biologica v. Marina Point

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 14, 2008

So I'm trying to find out first whether there was Clean Water Act jurisdiction. … And you have 60 days to start behaving yourself under the Clean Water Act or else we can sue you.

Oral argument — Daniels v. American West Airlines

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 2, 2006

The acts which occurred within the statutory time period are the fight with Peterson, the suspension, and the discharge. Yes. … So there were other comments made, including that comment, which I think is very important in this case.

Oral argument — United States v. APPEL

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 2, 2004

Cetron, was that the chemical and ecological functions of the areas surrounding a river are important and that the Clean Water Act should require protecting areas that funnel water into a river. … This is not a straightforward case that you normally would see in a Clean Water Act situation. So with that, I know I've run out of time, and I will not keep you any further. Thank you, counsel.

Oral argument — Susan Allan v. PA Higher Ed Assistance Agency

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 28, 2020

And in those public comments, as Judge Sutton noted, there were comments that were submitted by a company called Noble Communications, Noble Concepts. … One of the things to point out is what the purpose of this particular act was and it was indiscriminate filing and as opposing counsel noted yes there were there were comments about how 9-1-1 operators

Oral argument — City Brewing Co. v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 31, 2013

It is slow moving over a long period of time. Slow moving over a long period of time captures the meaning of the term gradual. … It's just the fact that in ordinary air, there is a – it's called – well, ordinary air is H2O. Water is air in a vapor form.

Oral argument — New Jersey Conservation Foundation v. FERC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 15, 2024

Why isn't there a Clean Air Act argument raised with respect to the air quality standards? I do not know. I mean, that is, you know, the EPA is the one that's going to enforce that. … They have another obligation under New Jersey law, which relates to the clean energy law.

Oral argument — Alaska Eskimo Whaling Comm. v. USEPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 13, 2015

I think the first and most fundamental instruction is that in Section 403 of the Clean Water Act, Congress articulated a criteria distinct from each other. … There is nothing in the Clean Water Act that says, if a whale migration might be deflected, you can't go forward with the permit.

Oral argument — Gary Pelican v. 3M Company

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 10, 2026

Employee Transfer Corporation to explain that, quote, when a plaintiff acts reasonably to discover the cause of a problem, the prescriptive period does not begin to run until he has a reasonable basis … I also agree with Judge Grander's comment. The Pelican case is particularly easy because the unfiled claims spreadsheet came more than a year before his lawsuit was filed.

Oral argument — Lorenzo Davis v. Billy Rook

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 12, 2023

Wasn't the morning comment something different that he felt threatened? The morning comment was with regards to them stealing from him as well. … All those cases say the officer acted reasonably even though the officer didn't take those same actions, Your Honor.

Oral argument — Kern Oil & Refining Co. v. USEPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 9, 2021

And then we have this language from the Clean Air Act regs about the disproportionate economic harm on remand. You're asking. A remand plus what? Yes, Your Honor. … Or what is the source of a requirement that they act in 90 days? Is there any precedent for that? I couldn't find any. Yes, Your Honor.

Oral argument — James v, Willis

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 10, 2022

But can we pursue, I think, the difference perhaps between the question that Judge Park is asking you and the comments of Judge Perez is discriminatory treatment on its own, right, is not an injury. … One of my questions was the alleged conspiracy to clean up and destroy the evidence in the synagogue.

Oral argument — Dayton Area Chamber of Comm v. Robert F Kennedy Jr

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 11, 2025

If Congress wanted to pass a statute like it has in the Clean Air Act, for example, that says national challenges have to be brought in D.C., Congress could do that. But there's no such statute. … Again, if the government wants to defend cases that are national in scope in D.C., it can ask Congress to pass a statute like Congress has in certain areas, like the Clean Air Act that says national in

Oral argument — Otter Products, LLC v. United States

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 6, 2016

And the cleaning cloth, you put them in there. … So you just set it down and you rub out the air bubbles and it stays on the front of your screen. So this, it comes around the phone.