Documents

Oral argument — United States v. Enrique Lizano

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 25, 2024

as a standard or limitation on emissions under the Clean Air Act. … of EPA or, excuse me, of Clean Air Act standards and regulations.

Oral argument — Murray Energy Corporation v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 9, 2017

Our position is that even if there is a discrete requirement under the Clean Air Act, we satisfy it. … The first issue is that 304A2, so that's the Citizens' Subprovision of the Clean Air Act, is very straightforward.

Oral argument — Sierra Club v. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 28, 2018

Simply stated, MVP is ineligible for the Clean Water Act permit at issue. … The Corps' involvement in the Mountain Valley Pipeline approval should be seen as a Clean Water Act success story.

Oral argument — Maryland Chapter of the Sierra Club v. Federal Highway Administration

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 28, 2025

when it relies on the exact Clean Air Act regulations and statute that sets forth the substantive requirements for this. … The Clean Air Act is such a comprehensive statute, you can go onto EPA's website, airnow.com, and literally look at hour by hour levels of PM2.5 everywhere in the country.

Oral argument — Dan River Basin Association v. Virginia Department of Environmental Quality

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 28, 2026

of states under the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, and the Coastal Zone Management Act. … But here the state is acting pursuant to its Clean Water Act authority, and that's what I take the court to have said about preemption.

Oral argument — Friends of Buckingham v. State Air Pollution Control

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 29, 2019

They are insofar as under the EPA, the broader Clean Air Act scheme, a Best Available Control Technology analysis is not required for a minor source permit. … What that means is the only things that were incorporated into their decision related to site suitability had been set down by DEQ before the second comment period on environmental justice issues, before

Oral argument — State of North Carolina v. United States

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 5, 2021

That is not the case with the Clean Air Act. … First, the language in 7418 is not exactly the same in the Clean Air Act as the Clean Water Act.

Oral argument — Friends of Buckingham v. State Air Pollution Control

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 29, 2019

They are insofar as under the EPA, the broader Clean Air Act scheme, a Best Available Control Technology analysis is not required for a minor source permit. … What that means is the only things that were incorporated into their decision related to site suitability had been set down by DEQ before the second comment period on environmental justice issues, before

Oral argument — Haw River Assembly v. United States Army Corps of Engineers

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 13, 2026

And Congress made that clear when it preempted regulation of natural gas pipelines, except in the instance of the Clean Water Act, the Coastal Zone Management Act, and the Clean Air Act. … That's not the way the Clean Water Act is written.

Oral argument — State of West Virginia v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 27, 2023

In the Clean Air Act, Congress empowered states to take the lead in deciding how best to comply with the National Ambient Air Quality Standards. … That doesn't allow for the amount of discretion that the Clean Air Act contemplates. All right. Thank you. You have some rebuttal. Okay. Mr. Hardy.

Oral argument — United States v. Herbert Green

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 31, 2013

He was really nervous during the time period and got more nervous after the police had evidence of the protective order that had been issued. Then he started acting differently. … If I were writing on a clean slate, I'd say it had to be more than 50%. You're not on the Supreme Court, neither are we, so we're not writing on a clean slate.

Oral argument — The Courtland Company, Inc. v. Union Carbide Corporation

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 11, 2025

So as it relates to the Clean Water Act, and as you heard from Mr. Donovan, relating to the southern boundary ditch. … And what it did was it found that there were three violations of the Clean Water Act under 33 U.S.C. 1311A and 1342P.

Oral argument — Mayor and City Council of Balt v. BP P.L.C.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 11, 2019

We do have a preemption argument, Your Honor, but that relates to the Clean Air Act. … These cases are no more about emissions or regulation of emissions under the Clean Air Act or otherwise than are cases about opioids, about FDA approval of pain medication.

Oral argument — Lee Sommerville v. Union Carbide Corporation

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 29, 2025

Turning to the standing issue, I want to start with a comment that my friend, Mr. … But really, you want to know how much you put in the air, because that stuff is bad for you.

Oral argument — Mayor and City Council of Balt v. BP P.L.C.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 25, 2022

Even though the Clean Air Act or Clean Water Act displaced common law, you're still arguing that the source of law is common law? Yes, that is correct. … Air Act.

Oral argument — Bacardi and Company Limited v. United States Patent & Trademark Office

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 7, 2023

One might read the Supreme Court's decision in Hawks, which is dealing with the Clean Water Act, or Clean Air Act, one of the two, Clean Water Act, and there were two issues being reviewed. … And the court there said that the fact that the remedy was the same, no coverage by the Clean Water Act, doesn't mean that there was review. Do you disagree with that reading of Hawks?

Oral argument — United States v. David Chang

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 27, 2024

Chang's substantive rights because he'll be subject to supervised release for a much longer time period. … Chang had lived a great, I mean, the court said that, lived a great life, contributed to society, member of the Air Force.

Oral argument — Sierra Club v. North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 28, 2026

Remember that the Natural Gas Act preempts any state law or any state regulation of the pipeline that does not come from the Clean Air Act, the Coastal Zone Management Act, or the Clean Water Act. … They are not part of the Federal Clean Water Act program. And so thus they are preempted.

Oral argument — Ohio Valley Environmental Coal v. Fola Coal Company, LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 27, 2016

You can't kill the aquatic life that makes it necessary to comply with the Clean Water Act. … Permit noncompliance constitutes a violation of the Clean Water Act and is grounds for enforcement action.

Oral argument — Friends of the Capital C.T. v. United States Army Corps

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 11, 2021

They ask the Court to vacate the Section 404 permit issued under the Clean Water Act by the Corps of Engineers to the Maryland Transit Administration to degrade the waters and so that MTA can strengthen … At no point in the comments during the NEPA process, during the Clean Water Act analysis, have the appellants articulated exactly what they have in mind for the Corps to consider?