Documents

Oral argument — Mark Parsons v. DOJ

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 18, 2015

This is a rule or a rule equivalent under the Administrative Procedures Act as we read the text of the Administrative Procedures Act. So you want notice-and-comment rulemaking? Is that what it is? … So I don't think that there should be open notice and comment hearings or an internal way for us to comment ahead of time about whether or not the DOJ should designate someone as a gang.

Oral argument — Mucha v. Board of Fire and Police Commissioners of the Village of Oak Brook

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 11, 2011

Who takes the extraordinary step of coming clean as the Linda Lucinda, but then taking the Fifth Amendment, which is his right, as to a number of other things. … And depending on its actual allegations, the chief commenting on what's actually there accurately wouldn't necessarily be a problem.

Oral argument — Hawkins v. The Workers' Compensation Commission

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 15, 2010

Just drawn out of the air. No response. … Just a couple of comments, Your Honors. In common language, you addressed his public policy purposes of the act analysis that he says militates against your position.

Oral argument — United States v. Jose Helguera-Del Rio

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 17, 2019

In this instance, there were three different acts of misconduct in the closing arguments made by the prosecutor. … I understand, Your Honor, and I guess I would disagree, of course, with the government that this was a stray comment or a minor comment.

Oral argument — State of California v. Alex Azar, II

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 23, 2019

So just to be clear, though, from your position, I want to make sure I understand your position, which is that counseling does not include referrals, period, end of story? … But the Congress defined the term non-directed counseling in the HHS Appropriation Act and Section 254C6A1 of the Public Health Service Act.

Oral argument — Southwest Airlines v. TSA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 8, 2026

It's very similar to what happened in the Turkey Hull bankruptcy case that the Supreme Court decided, where they looked at a provision on the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act that specifically said something … And second of all, I want to just point to the July 11, 2017 email exchange that TSA relies on here, because that email exchange, which by the way comes after the first audit period is over and into the

Oral argument — United States v. Gonzalez

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 11, 2008

There might have been other evidence that she acts in her own self-interest. There might have been other evidence that her demeanor was off. … But it was certainly not speculation for me, just out of thin air, to think that there was something influencing her testimony.

Oral argument — Veterans Justice Group, LLC v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 8, 2015

So let me ask you, what was the state of the comment of the record in the rulemaking about comments? … I think that the Army and the Air Force is in similar statistical groupings. We have to look at the practical aspects of this rulemaking.

Oral argument — The American Legion v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 8, 2015

So let me ask you, what was the state of the comment of the record in the rulemaking about comments? … I think that the Army and the Air Force is in similar statistical groupings. We have to look at the practical aspects of this rulemaking.

Oral argument — 02 Micro Intl v. Monolithic Power

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 7, 2006

But the development of the theory and coming up with the O2 infringement theory was still ongoing during that period. … You're just pulling a middle of March out of the air? What happened the day before the middle of March that would trigger the duty to file right away? There's no particular date.

Oral argument — Perry v. Merit Systems Protection Bd.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 17, 2017

You know, the Clean Water Act, you know, you can only proceed if the company is discharging water into navigable water. But the system always works by the fact it has to start with an allegation. … Now, that would be a nice, clean rule, right? Individuals would know that their civil service disputes go to the Federal Circuit. And discrimination claims go to district court.

Oral argument — Santana-Vargas v. Banco Santander Puerto Rico

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 7, 2019

such period. … Modolfino's comment, who was the former president of Santander Financial, that comment also is too remote in time.

Oral argument — United States v. O'Sullivan

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 3, 2024

. – committed good acts and therefore – But I guess you're just saying there's lots of records and this was just overlooked. That's, I think, a fair way to state that. … I'd like to offer two minutes of final comments on conscious avoidance.

Oral argument — United States v. Sepetu

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 6, 2026

So we have one email over a period of years, and we have a personal relationship? With the scammer, yes. … And so if somebody did a really good job and kept their papers clean, that can't be enough.

Oral argument — Riley's American Heritage Farms v. James Elsasser

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 3, 2024

There has to be a legislative act, something that has... But what can they do? The school board, the school board adopts... Didn't they sort of already do that? I'm sorry? … I think your, I thought your argument was, yeah, but that's all been, that's all been cleaned up by these subsequent actions. Not exactly. Dr.

Oral argument — Black Mesa Water Coalition v. Sally Jewell

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 21, 2014

We also raised those in public comment. … Is it substantial evidence or is it clear air or is it abusive discretion or something else?

Oral argument — United States v. Ramirez-Martinez

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 5, 2009

error because it is a single comment, a single isolated comment. … by basically requiring a futile act to go back and do it over again?

Oral argument — Jason Laible v. Timothy Lanter

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 8, 2023

There is no question that if Sergeant Scaff had been acting under the direction and control of ATF on an ATF only operation, that there would be Westfall Act immunity. … For example, had there been an open-air assault on Meyer as he left the residence and headed toward a vehicle, that was ATF's responsibility.

Oral argument — Anna Swan v. Bank of America

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 9, 2009

Swan's claim under the Federal Age Discrimination Act is untimely. … Under the facts of this case, which are — which are briefed in our brief, that's simply too long of a period of time.

Oral argument — United States v. Reggie Pettus

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 19, 2023

So I think that the court certainly couldn't have clearly aired. And I would say the same thing, Judge Boardman. … Pettis acted in self-defense.