Documents

Oral argument — Center for Biological Diversity v. BLM

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 12, 2023

Appellants represent people of color who have been systematically and consciously denied access to clean, affordable, and readily available water. … Preservation Act claims wouldn't support the court's vacatur decision.

Oral argument — United States v. Wilbert Tsosie

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 15, 2013

Maybe just I hate to keep diverting you, and maybe Judge Clifton will be, as an act of grace, give you a little more time. … And you could see the place was, you know, it wasn't clean. But it had been wiped. Okay? It looked like either bleach or TSP or something like that. That's all that was left in there in December.

Oral argument — Westmoreland Coal Company v. Jarrell Cochran

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 22, 2013

I don't know that the act would have to be amended. The act itself is much more general than the preamble. … I want to address Judge Winn's comments about if we had the technology to distinguish smoking from coal dust, would that change everything? And I think that that's a pertinent comment.

Oral argument — Mark Parsons v. DOJ

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 18, 2015

This is a rule or a rule equivalent under the Administrative Procedures Act as we read the text of the Administrative Procedures Act. So you want notice-and-comment rulemaking? Is that what it is? … So I don't think that there should be open notice and comment hearings or an internal way for us to comment ahead of time about whether or not the DOJ should designate someone as a gang.

Oral argument — North Cascades Conservation Council v. United States Forest Service

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 14, 2025

for further comments can you describe to me how long that period was how many comments came in give me some detail on that if you can and i and i don't want to uh mystique i may have been referring to … period and the comment period is a more informed and and thoughtful process which allows for backing it up with scientific evidence uh and that is just simply not the case when you have an after effect

Oral argument — Susan Morris v. Gina McCarthy

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 16, 2015

That was another comment she made. Administrator Johnson goes back to early 25, so that's a substantial period back. Okay. Well, yes, I'll give you that. … He was acting administrator for a period of time before that, I think January of 2005. But there's no support in the record that this was made in connection with the process.

Oral argument — United States v. Joel Ausbie

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 14, 2019

His counsel noted and commented on the record that the panel only had four African American jurors on it. … He's a retired Air Force service member, which would suggest sort of a law and order bent. This person had four children. His current hobby was working on family genealogy.

Oral argument — Ben Winch v. Director, OWCP, U.S. Department of Labor, Secretary, U.S. DOL, CSX Transportation, Inc., Intervenor

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 24, 2018

So now we have pilots, we have air traffic controllers, we have truck drivers, all who have these protections, these hours of service protections to prevent inattention that originated with railroad workers … Do they have any rulemaking authority under this act? Again, I believe most of it would just be procedural.

Oral argument — United States v. Joseph Haycock

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 3, 2015

Basically, you've got your client, he's over 18, check with the federal statute, and acting to gratify sexual desire of himself or a third party. That's also a sexual act, correct? Correct. … We're not just pulling this out of thin air.

Oral argument — Heartland Coca-Cola Bottling Co. v. Illinois Workers' Compensation Comm'n

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 19, 2026

The other case, absolute cleaning, was a clear issue of dispute. He said, she said. The issue was whether Dr. … It still comes down, two separate sections of the act.

Oral argument — United States v. Brissette

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 4, 2018

Now maybe the way this case is just coming to us, that issue isn't really before us and we just clean up this other point, but I'm not quite sure what its relevance is. … cases in which a public actor acts on behalf of the public interest, or acts to benefit a private party.

Oral argument — National Lifeline Association v. FCC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 25, 2018

, and we would have sought to reopen the comment period in light of the additional evidence. … Well, you say it never said that we have another notice and comment period.

Oral argument — Veterans Justice Group, LLC v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 8, 2015

So let me ask you, what was the state of the comment of the record in the rulemaking about comments? … I think that the Army and the Air Force is in similar statistical groupings. We have to look at the practical aspects of this rulemaking.

Oral argument — The American Legion v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 8, 2015

So let me ask you, what was the state of the comment of the record in the rulemaking about comments? … I think that the Army and the Air Force is in similar statistical groupings. We have to look at the practical aspects of this rulemaking.

Oral argument — Board of Education v. IL Educational Labor Board

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 4, 2013

The first is that this court has a clean slate to protect the student records, confidentiality of student records here, because the standard of review is novel. … You have a 14-day notice period. If you'd like to put a rebuttal in there, we'll send that right along, too. That's something we would have been willing to consider.

Oral argument — Harris v. Adame

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 19, 2014

Well, because Arthur conveyed as fee simple absolute under the Conveyances Act, and that's the key, because the Conveyances Act provides that when you convey by warranty deed, it's fee simple absolute, … The probate act is really clear that as far as Arnold's concerned, Arnold had no capacity to execute the deed. That's clear under the probate act.

Oral argument — Hawkins v. The Workers' Compensation Commission

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 15, 2010

Just drawn out of the air. No response. … Just a couple of comments, Your Honors. In common language, you addressed his public policy purposes of the act analysis that he says militates against your position.

Oral argument — M.D.C.G. v. United States

Oral argument · Oral argument · Feb 5, 2020

So it wasn't as if there wasn't an airing of the facts. … Actually, it's blanked out on it, but it's a one-hour time period they're supposed to do that.

Oral argument — Service Employees International Union v. ILRB, Local Panel

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 16, 2017

It makes sense that the General Assembly did not pull this very peculiar phrase out of thin air. It pulled it from Nacolni. And therefore, it should be interpreted in accordance with Nacolni. … It used it in other provisions, other sections of the Act.

Oral argument — Black Mesa Water Coalition v. Sally Jewell

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 21, 2014

We also raised those in public comment. … Is it substantial evidence or is it clear air or is it abusive discretion or something else?