Documents

Oral argument — Troy Chemical Corporation v. EPA

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 9, 2020

Well, the finding expired, right, the finding was, would have allowed construction without violating the Clean Water Act, in other words, without being considered to be filling wetlands, up to 10 months … Given the Clean Water Act definition, it probably is as a practical matter. Who owns the creek bed? I don't know.

Oral argument — Inland Empire Waterkeeper v. Corona Clay Co.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 4, 2021

under the Clean Water Act. … Why wouldn't there be a Clean Water Act claim?

Oral argument — Matson Navigation Company v. DOT

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 11, 2023

It's not a statute like the Hobbs Act where there are specific provisions granting original jurisdiction, like in the Clean Water Act. … And so the agency, as a matter of administrative grace, allowed the parties a limited period to comment on the application for the Dakar. And that was in 2016.

Oral argument — In Re: Janet Tingling

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 2, 2021

Tingling, by the way, acting pro se, and that may have been the first mistake, but not a legal one in this case, she accepted their entry into the case, but she did not accept when they entered the case … These stipulated facts did not come out of the air. They weren't sua sponte by the bankruptcy court judge. They were the result of a conference at the pretrial conference between the parties.

Oral argument — Hecate Energy LLC v. FERC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 6, 2024

FERC acted arbitrarily when it approved PJM's $5 million upgrade cost threshold for two reasons. … And that's in the face of industry commenters who said, no, that's just not the case.

Oral argument — County of St. Clair v. Caseyville Rifle and Pistol Club

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 14, 2010

Corridor, County Air Corridor Protection Act, says that the county may use eminent domain. … But this overriding argument that he makes is an attempt to get a pass from Section 20 of the Air Protection Act, notwithstanding any other provision of this act, any power granted under this act to acquire

Oral argument — Concord Air, Inc. v. Malarz

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 6, 2015

My name is Adam Ansari, Counsel for the Appellate, Concord Air, Inc. … Just judgment as to Concord Air. I mean, it's the appellant's opinion that, you know, the judgment on the borrower, appellant doesn't, can't necessarily comment or indicate whether.

Oral argument — Beatrice Lovett v. Cracker Barrel

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 22, 2017

That's what that six-month period reflects. It reflects we're simply trying to run a business. … And so ultimately, you know, I understand Judge King's question about what she said, but all it is is essentially this terrible comment that she's just thrown out of thin air on top of a bunch of demonstrable

Oral argument — In Interest of Tyler N. W.

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 2, 2011

And two acts are mentioned, one kissing on the lips, other touching of the private part. First, not a criminal act. The second, legally insufficient. … The mother says that she was shocked when she found out that the kids cleaned their room. One has to ask, why is the mother shocked when the kids cleaned their room?

Oral argument — People v. Scholes

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jun 12, 2013

Otherwise the court would be acting as a prosecutor. Absolutely. But then let's move forward. Okay. … And starting with Dublique in 1989 and the Illinois Supreme Court more recently, they started cleaning it up and there's a reason it needs to be cleaned up and this is it.

Oral argument — Willie Thompson v. G. Janda

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 14, 2018

Williams, which suggests that the prosecutor's appeal to the jury to act as the conscience of the community is acceptable, unless it's specifically designed to inflame the jury? … And in fact, the prosecutor said himself, this case is not about cleaning up Oakland. It's about cleaning up a neighborhood. It's not about cleaning up a neighborhood.

Oral argument — Kevin Clanton v. United States

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 11, 2019

That's why I say the plain and clear reading of this, and if we didn't have a comment, and the only thing we have is a comment to the model act, this is not a comment to the Illinois statutes themselves … This is a comment to a different act, which has absolutely some different language in it.

Oral argument — LUCKETT v. ADAMS

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 15, 2006

Well, okay, again, with Judge Kaczynski's comment is, of course, that doesn't have anything to do with ADIPA. Now, maybe your better argument is that Fisher is a post-ADIPA case. It is. … You don't talk about that, but then next she's in court and she sees the same guy now cleaned up for the jury.

Oral argument — Arbitrage Event-Driven Fund v. Tribune Media Company

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 16, 2020

The public comment period was May 21st to July 12th. So that's after all of the alleged statements in this case were made. … Um, that facts came to light during the public comment period. Paragraph 109 talks about the public comment period beginning.

Oral argument — Atlantic Richfield Company v. NL Industries

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 20, 2024

That consent decree would have required publication in the federal record, it would have required comment, and it would have required EPA to consider those comments, and ultimately, for that settlement … Remediation can include the act of further removal, I assume. When does the title change from removal to remediation?

Oral argument — National Parks & Con v. Kaiser Eagle Mtn.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 6, 2007

We believe it is redressable under both NEPA and under the Park Service's Organic Act and the Desert Protection Act. … , it should promptly make such comments.

Oral argument — Fireman's Fund Ins. Co. v. North Pac. Ins Co.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 14, 2011

We're inside the Oregon Environmental Cleanup Assistance Act. We want the insured, the gas station owner, to be on the hook, clean up the site, and be good for the people of Oregon. … Found that Nene did act reasonably, Your Honor. Oh, he acted reasonably. Did act reasonably. And no finding as to Fireman's Fund. Which goes into the procedural issues in this case.

Oral argument — George Jarkesy, Jr. v. SEC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 13, 2015

Under the 34 Act? Under the 34 Act, we could bring certain cases administratively. I just can't recall which class of cases. I think broker-dealer, probably. … And then in Tull, the Supreme Court ruled that when they were looking for $22 million, governments looking for $22 million in penalties for Clean Water Act violations because they had multipliers, just

Oral argument — Melissa Holyoak v. Google, Inc.

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 13, 2017

It's very consistent with the comment in 3.07, which says there should be a selection of the cipher recipients should be on the merits. That's what page 3.07 says. … What I believe is unprecedented in this period of time in getting insight for any of these elements is the court had over 100 pages of proposals before it. 100 pages of proposals? By whom?

Oral argument — Reyes v. Wenderlich

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 23, 2019

It simply removes air from the gallery. It doesn't cause the heat to circulate around the gallery. … There's no genuine dispute here that they acted with a sufficiently culpable state of mind akin to criminal recklessness.