Documents

Oral argument — Sierra Club v. Federal Highway Administration

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 10, 2005

The statutes at issue in this case are Section 109H of the Federal Aid Highway Act and the National Environmental Policy Act. … If you didn't do a rule, we didn't really have a study or a comment period on the rule to say whether that would work, right? Right.

Oral argument — United States v. Robbins

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 20, 2025

And so what we have is a period of time from 1152 to 1336. So it's less than two minutes. … And and the inconsistency there was that one person said they were going to her uncle's ranch to help clean up.

Oral argument — United States v. Jose Jaime Lopez

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 26, 2018

The clean holding of Dickerson is that a guilty plea without a judgment in state court counts as a conviction for purposes of federal law. … Unfortunately, I don't know if Judge Bruce is unique in this particular circumstance, but this court is also clear that the harmless air standard applies to a failure to conduct a colloquy.

Oral argument — William Liebhart v. SPX Corporation

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 2, 2020

In SPX 1, this court defined standards under the standards under the citizen suit provisions of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act and the Toxic Act. … For example, if the defendant volunteered to put down an inch of fresh clean topsoil, would that do it?

Oral argument — Joyce Higgs, Appellee/Cross v. Costa Crosiere S.P.A., Company, Appellant/Cross

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 22, 2020

There was never a problem There was never a complaint about the way the buckets were you know They could never commit right negligence on this occasion because there was no prior act of negligence Your … I appreciate that If I could comment then on the setoff issue with my remaining time I think the we have no problem with the way the district court handled it the collateral source rule isn't Implicated

Oral argument — Mickey Dilts v. Penske Logistics LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Mar 3, 2014

Can you comment on the federal HOS rules and how they should play in our analysis? Sure. You know, I think my friend from the United States will obviously comment on that too. … That was an Air Transportation Association case, a Ninth Circuit decision.

Oral argument — Kelly O'Kell v. Deb Haaland

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 24, 2023

This was a GS-12 position, period. It did not say she's not qualified for a GS-12 position. … So the CLEAN SF-50, it ought to help her achieve that goal. It was intended to be the delta. Yes, that's correct. CLEAN, her federal-type job versus what was available in that eastern Washington.

Oral argument — Sturgeon v. Frost

Oral argument · Oral argument · Nov 5, 2018

methods of transportation, like air. … As we've talked about, the Clean Air Act applies, Coast Guard regulations apply, federal criminal law applies. These rivers are already significantly protected.

Oral argument — United States v. Alejandro Gutierrez

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 15, 2014

It does not contain the disparaging comments that you had in Morales in the first part of its sensing position. … Now, if I could just say the – because we're dealing with clean air reviews, so whether or not it affected substantial rights.

Oral argument — Confederated Salish v. Norton

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 6, 2003

And clearly, in the Flathead Act, there was an authorization, period, without discretionary language written by Congress. … For example, under 25 CFR 151, absent a legislative mandate, the local government is entitled to several different shots or shots, bites at the apple on comment period as well as review period.

Oral argument — Waterkeepers Chesapeake v. FERC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Oct 11, 2022

Well, the Clean Water Act simply doesn't address that. The Clean Water Act is talking about FERC's authority and the limitations on that authority. … There was a comment period. So what is the status of the settlement agreement if we were to vacate the Commission's license? The settlement agreement is being implemented.

Oral argument — Starlink Logistics Inc v. ACC LLC

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jan 31, 2024

Your Honors, the basic statutory prerequisites for Clean Water Act and RCRA citizen suits are notice and a waiting period. … That would be counts one under the Clean Water Act and counts three and four under RCRA.

Oral argument — Estate of Callahan v. Sledge

Oral argument · Oral argument · Aug 21, 2012

The doctor did say that he had seen that there appeared to be no new nose during this, I guess, two-week period or three-week period when they were administering the disease. … And I do want to respond to the comment that there was no opportunity to submit evidence to CMS on this.

Oral argument — Darby v. Greenman

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 7, 2020

Greenman acted with the necessary mental state. … Greenman acted with deliberate indifference. And what about Dr. Hamilton proposing a cleaning to deal with an abscess? Yeah. And Dr.

Oral argument — Gaymar Industries, Inc. v. Cincinnati Sub-zero Products

Oral argument · Oral argument · May 7, 2015

It violates the principles of the Patent Act. … Under the Lanham Act, you mean? No, under the Copyright Act.

Oral argument — Schultz v. The River Shore of Naperville Condominium Association

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 11, 2019

Her case brought to this panel and also brought to the trial court was, I think I slipped on ice, although I didn't see it, and the condition of the parking lot was deteriorating, period. … But it's clear that she fell in the air. She slipped and fell in an area that was uncovered with snow. Correct. Right. Correct.

Oral argument — MCGachey v. Air Force

Oral argument · Oral argument · Jul 9, 2010

This is not an individual with a clean disciplinary record who has for the first time violated an offense. Ms. … Force directive or Air Force instruction.

Oral argument — United States v. Ellis

Oral argument · Oral argument · Sep 8, 2003

I have one comment to make, and then I am done. This is from the Jump Sport decision. This is my concern about what EPA is doing in this case. … And it has to be balanced with the – with the statutes, the Resource Conservation Recovery Act and CERCLA, which require people to clean up waste.

Oral argument — Illinois Landowners Alliance v. Illinois Commerce Commission

Oral argument · Oral argument · Dec 1, 2015

And clean power is how you do that. … In this case, Rock Island Clean Line has come in and said, we're going to build this project.

Oral argument — United States v. Lewis Bell

Oral argument · Oral argument · Apr 20, 2016

Again, I'm back in plain air land. Why not say, for plain air purposes, a proper calculation, it would have received it? … But what's your answer to the plain air point that, you know, even if we accept your received argument that was a gift and there's no plain air here, there's no air at all, because if you do it correctly