Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad Corporation Construction Into The Powder River Basin

Federal RegisterApr 20, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Surface Transportation Board

[STB Finance Docket No. 33407]

Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad Corporation Construction

Into The Powder River Basin

AGENCIES: Lead: Surface Transportation Board.

Cooperating:

U.S.D.A. Forest Service.

U.S.D.I. Bureau of Land Management.

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

ACTION: Notice to the parties providing an extension of time to submit

comments on alternatives and reply comments.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

On March 10, 1999, the Final Scope of Study for the Environmental

Impact Statement (EIS) and Request for Comments on 1) the Modified

Proposed Action, referred to as Alternative C, and 2) the City of

Rochester, Minnesota's South Bypass Proposal was issued in this

proceeding. The Final Scope provided a 30 day comment period for

interested parties to submit comments on the two new proposed

alternatives listed above, while making it clear that the 30 day

comment period, which was due to expire on April 10, 1999, was in

addition to, not a substitute for, the comment period that will be

provided on all aspects of the Draft Environmental Impact Statement

(DEIS) when that document is made available.

The Board and cooperating agencies have received requests to extend

the April 10, 1999 comment date. Some of the requests seek an extension

in which to comment on a number of potential environmental impacts and

others seek additional time to permit development of bypass alternative

proposals.

As discussed below, we will provide a limited additional comment

period for interested communities to develop bypass proposals. As we

stated in the Final Scope, we are mindful of our obligations under the

National Environmental Policy Act, 16 U.S.C. 4321-4335 (NEPA) to

explore and evaluate in the EIS a reasonable range of alternatives

designed to meet the purpose and need of the applicant's proposal.

Citizens Against Burlington, Inc. v. Busey, 938 F.2d 190 (D.C. Cir.

1991). At the same time, we are aware that we cannot let the

environmental review process indefinitely delay the Board's final

decision on this matter.

In the Final Scope, we made a preliminary determination, based on

the City of Rochester's engineering study and cost estimates, that the

City had met an initial burden of showing that its

[[Page 19408]]

proposed south bypass may be a feasible routing alternative.

Accordingly, we requested comments from the railroad and other

concerned parties on whether the south bypass proposal was feasible, or

would simply shift the potential environmental consequences of the

applicant's proposal to different communities and populations. Having

provided this opportunity in Rochester, we believe that we should

afford other interested communities the same opportunity to submit

specific bypass designs.

Therefore, we will extend the comment period established in the

Final Scope for an additional 60 days, or until June 10, 1999, to

provide time for any other interested community to submit a bypass

proposal. Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad or any interested party

or person who may be affected by a proposed bypass would then have 30

days, or until July 12, 1999, to respond. In addition, parties may use

the additional time to submit comments on other alternatives described

in the Final Scope.

We note that the information we receive from any community

regarding a bypass must be detailed enough for us to determine whether

a specific bypass proposal constitutes a reasonable and feasible

alternative to the applicant's proposal or merely relocates the

potential environmental consequences of the applicant's proposed

action. To that end, any bypass proposal submitted by a community must,

at a minimum, contain the following information: detailed maps showing

where the route would be located; quantified impacts to wetlands; cut

and fill requirements to permit design and operation of a railroad;

roads that would be crossed and their average daily traffic levels;

proximity of the bypass any sensitive structures (for example, schools,

libraries, hospitals, residences, retirement communities, and nursing

homes); and impacts to landowners and farmlands.

Also, in considering bypass proposals that may be submitted to the

Board and determining whether they constitute reasonable, feasible

alternatives, we will take into account the applicant's goal to create

a more efficient route by which to transport coal. A circuitous route

that bypasses numerous communities could add so many additional miles

that it would be unlikely to allow applicant to achieve its goal of

providing efficient rail transportation. However, before arriving at a

final decision on the range of alternatives to be addressed in the

DEIS, we will carefully consider any specific bypass proposal and all

responses to such a proposal.

Finally, we must balance our responsibility to analyze a reasonable

range of alternatives with the need to move the environmental review

process forward without undue delay. To allow us to issue the DEIS in a

timely manner, we will not grant further extensions of time.

The requests for additional time to provide comments on potential

environmental impacts will be denied. As the Board and its cooperating

agencies stated in the Final Scope, we are in the process of preparing

a DEIS analyzing all potential environmental effects discovered during

the course of the environmental review process, including concerns

identified during scoping. The DEIS will be made available upon its

completion for public review and comment. Accordingly, there is no need

to provide an additional comment period on potential environmental

impacts at this point.

Bypass proposals and comments on alternatives described in the

Final Scope must be submitted to the Board by June 10, 1999. Replies or

responses must be submitted by July 12, 1999. Comments should be sent

to: Office of the Secretary, Case Control Unit, STB Finance Docket No.

33407, Surface Transportation Board, 1925 K Street, NW, Washington, DC

20423-0001.

To ensure proper handling of your comments, you must mark your

submission:

Attention: Elaine K. Kaiser, Chief, Section of Environmental

Analysis, Environmental Filing.

By the Board, Elaine K. Kaiser, Chief, Section of Environmental

Analysis.

Vernon A. Williams,

Secretary.

[FR Doc. 99-9860 Filed 4-19-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4915-00-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.