Hazardous Materials: Revisions to the Incident Reporting Requirements and the Detailed Hazardous Materials Incident Report DOT Form F 5800.1

Federal RegisterMar 23, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

49 CFR Part 171

[Docket No. RSPA-99-5013 (HM-229)]

RIN 2137-AD21

Hazardous Materials: Revisions to the Incident Reporting

Requirements and the Detailed Hazardous Materials Incident Report DOT

Form F 5800.1

AGENCY: Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA), DOT.

ACTION: Advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM).

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This ANPRM solicits comments on the merits of revising the

current incident reporting requirements of the Hazardous Materials

Regulations and the Hazardous Materials Incident Report form (DOT Form

F 5800.1). The Federal hazardous material transportation law requires

the Secretary of Transportation to maintain a facility and technical

staff sufficient to maintain a central reporting system to develop a

statistical compilation on casualties and conduct reviews on hazardous

materials transportation. Any changes resulting from this rulemaking

are intended to increase the usefulness of data collected for risk

analysis and management by government and industry and, where possible,

provide relief from regulatory requirements.

DATES: Send your comments on or before June 21, 1999.

ADDRESSES: Address your comments to the Dockets Management System, U.S.

Department of Transportation, Room PL 401, 400 Seventh St., SW.,

Washington, DC 20590-0001. You must identify the docket number, RSPA-

99-5013 (HM-229) at the beginning of your comments, and you should

submit two copies of your comments. If you wish to receive confirmation

that RSPA has received your comments, include a self-addressed stamped

postcard. You may also submit your comments by E-mail to

[email protected]. The Dockets Unit is located on the Plaza Level of

the Nassif Building at the U.S. DOT at the above address. You may view

public dockets between the hours of 10 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through

Friday, except on Federal holidays.

Electronic Access

You may review all comments received by the Dockets Office on the

Internet at http://dms.dot.gov. It is available 24 hours a day, 365

days a year. An electronic copy of this document may be downloaded from

the Federal Register Electronic Bulletin Board Service at (202) 512-

1661. Internet users may reach the Federal Register's home page at:

http://www.nara.gov/nara/fedreg and the Government Printing Office's

database at http://www.access.gpo.gov/su__docs or the Office of

Hazardous Materials Safety at http://rspa.dot.dov/rulemake.htm. You may

obtain copies of DOT Form F 5800.1 and the instruction booklet for

completing DOT Form F 5800.1 at the Office of Hazardous Materials

Safety's web site at http://hazmat.dot.gov/spills.htm or http://

hazmat.dot.gov/ohmforms.htm#incidents.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Diane LaValle, at the Office of

Hazardous Materials Standards, telephone (202) 366-8553 or Kevin

Coburn, at the Office of Hazardous Materials Planning & Analysis,

telephone (202) 366-4555, Research and Special Programs Administration,

U.S. Department of Transportation, 400 Seventh Street, SW., Washington,

DC 20590-0001.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

On March 4, 1995, the President directed all Federal agencies to

perform an extensive review of each of their regulations and eliminate

or revise those requirements that are outdated or in need of reform. As

a result of its review of the Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMR; 49

CFR parts 171-180), the Research and Special Programs Administration

(RSPA, ``we'') is considering revisions to the incident reporting

requirements in Secs. 171.15 and 171.16 and the incident report form,

DOT Form F 5800.1.

Following a meeting between DOT and members of several trade

associations concerning hazardous materials incident reporting, the

Association of American Railroads sponsored a workgroup with segments

of the transportation community to discuss the DOT Form F 5800.1 and

reporting requirements of Secs. 171.15 and 171.16. The workgroup

meetings were held during the winter of 1997-98. Participants included

representatives of all four transportation modes, shippers, container

manufacturers, and labor. The workgroup drafted suggestions and

submitted them to RSPA. We developed questions based on input from

these meetings, the DOT modal agencies, other concerned individuals,

and our own initiative. We are now requesting comments on the merits of

revising the requirements of Secs. 171.15 and 171.16 for incident

reporting and revising DOT Form F 5800.1.

Currently Sec. 171.15 provides criteria requiring immediate

notification of unintentional hazardous materials releases to the

National Response Center. Each carrier making a report under

Sec. 171.15 is also required to fill out DOT Form F 5800.1 as required

by Sec. 171.16. Additionally, carriers are currently required to fill

out DOT Form F 5800.1 for unintentional releases when the conditions of

Sec. 171.16 are met. We use the data and information we collect:

As an aid in evaluating the effectiveness of the existing

regulations.

To assist in determining the need for regulatory changes

to cover changing transportation safety problems.

To determine major problem areas so that the attention of

the Department may be more suitably directed to those areas.

We are considering expanding the reporting requirements in

Secs. 171.15 and 171.16 to include circumstances that are not currently

required to be reported. For example, some questions concern reporting

of undeclared shipments of hazardous materials whether or not there is

a release. We are also considering expanding the reporting requirements

to persons other than carriers. Other questions concern reporting of

damage to packagings, especially bulk packagings such as cargo tanks,

whether or not there has been a release. We anticipate that a modest

increase in reporting potentially high-consequence incidents would be

offset by reduced reporting requirements for incidents with less

serious potential impacts.

This advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM) is designed to

evaluate the need for any change in reporting requirements, to obtain

more useful information from DOT Form F 5800.1 submissions and to

reduce the regulatory burden on industry. Any changes would be based on

both our own initiative and suggestions made by various members of

industry. This ANPRM is also consistent with the goals of the

President's Regulatory Reinvention Initiative.

II. Impact on Small Businesses

Section 610 of the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 (Pub. L. 96-

354), as amended by the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness

Act of 1996 (Pub. L. 104-121), requires agencies to conduct periodic

reviews of rules that have or will have a significant economic impact

on a substantial number of small business entities. The purpose of the

reviews is to determine

[[Page 13944]]

whether such rules should be continued without change, or should be

amended or rescinded, consistent with the objectives of applicable

statutes, to minimize any significant economic impact of the rules on a

substantial number of such small entities. The reviews are to consider:

(1) The continued need for the rule; (2) the nature of complaints or

comments received from the public; (3) the complexity of the rule; (4)

the extent to which the rule overlaps, duplicates, or conflicts with

other federal rules or with state or local government rules; and (5)

the length of time since the rule has been evaluated or the degree to

which technology, economic conditions, or other factors have changed in

the area affected by the rule. This ANPRM provides an opportunity for

small entities to submit information relevant to this review.

III. Plain Language

RSPA intends to revise the Hazardous Materials Incident Report and

Secs. 171.15 and 171.16 in plain language. Clearer rules will improve

both compliance and enforceability. Interested persons are encouraged

to submit draft regulatory language they believe clearly and simply

communicates regulatory requirements.

We request written comments from interested persons concerning

regulatory changes and clarifications that will simplify completion of

the Hazardous Materials Incident Report. Interested persons may submit

draft regulatory language and comments suggesting ways to write the

requirements for reporting hazardous materials incidents which would

promote understanding and compliance. Comments that provide reasons and

factual data are especially helpful.

IV. Questions

Questions on revising DOT Form F 5800.1 and the associated sections

of the HMR generally fall within five categories. These categories are:

General Issues.

Telephonic Notification.

Written Reports.

DOT Form F 5800.1.

Customer Uses and Needs.

National Transportation Safety Board recommendations.

An exact copy of the current DOT Form F 5800.1 is included with

this ANPRM as an aid to the reader. In addition, Secs. 171.15 and

171.16 are set forth in their entirety, as follows:

Sec. 171.15--Immediate Notice of Certain Hazardous Materials

Incidents

(a) At the earliest practicable moment, each carrier who

transports hazardous materials (including hazardous wastes) shall

give notice in accordance with paragraph (b) of this section after

each incident that occurs during the course of transportation

(including loading, unloading and temporary storage) in which:

(1) As a direct result of hazardous materials--

(i) A person is killed; or

(ii) A person receives injuries requiring his or her

hospitalization; or

(iii) Estimated carrier or other property damage exceeds

$50,000; or

(iv) An evacuation of the general public occurs lasting one or

more hours; or

(v) One or more major transportation arteries or facilities are

closed or shut down for one hour or more; or

(vi) The operational flight pattern or routine of an aircraft is

altered; or

(2) Fire, breakage, spillage, or suspected radioactive

contamination occurs involving shipment of radioactive material (see

also Secs. 174.45, 175.45, 176.48, and 177.807 of this subchapter);

or

(3) Fire, breakage, spillage, or suspected contamination occurs

involving shipment of infectious substances (etiologic agents); or

(4) There has been a release of a marine pollutant in a quantity

exceeding 450 L (119 gallons) for liquids or 400 kg (882 pounds) for

solids; or

(5) A situation exists of such a nature (e.g., a continuing

danger to life exists at the scene of the incident) that, in the

judgment of the carrier, it should be reported to the Department

even though it does not meet the criteria of paragraph (a) (1), (2)

or (3) of this section.

(b) Except for transportation by aircraft, each notice required

by paragraph (a) of this section shall be given to the Department by

telephone (toll-free) on 800-424-8802. Notice involving shipments

transported by aircraft must be given to the nearest FAA Civil

Aviation Security Office by telephone at the earliest practical

moment after each incident in place of the notice to the Department.

Notice involving etiologic agents may be given the Director, Centers

for Disease Control, U.S. Public Health Service, Atlanta, Ga., (800)

232-0124, in place of the notice to the Department or (toll call) on

202-267-2675. Each notice must include the following information:

(1) Name of reporter.

(2) Name and address of carrier represented by reporter.

(3) Phone number where reporter can be contacted.

(4) Date, time, and location of incident.

(5) The extent of injuries, if any.

(6) Classification, name, and quantity of hazardous materials

involved, if such information is available.

(7) Type of incident and nature of hazardous material

involvement and whether a continuing danger to life exists at the

scene.

(c) Each carrier making a report under this section shall also

make the report required by Sec. 171.16.

Note: Under 40 CFR 302.6 EPA requires persons in charge of

facilities (including transport vehicles, vessels and aircraft) to

report any release of a hazardous substance in a quantity equal to

or greater than its reportable quantity, as soon as that person has

knowledge of the release, to the U.S. Coast Guard National Response

Center at (toll free) 800-424-8802 or (toll) 202-267-2675.

Sec. 171.16--Detailed Hazardous Materials Incident Reports

(a) Each carrier who transports hazardous materials shall report

in writing, in duplicate, on DOT Form F 5800.1 (Rev. 6/89) to the

Department within 30 days of the date of discovery, each incident

that occurs during the course of transportation (including loading,

unloading, and temporary storage) in which any of the circumstances

set forth in 171.15(a) occurs or there has been an unintentional

release of hazardous materials from a package (including a tank) or

any quantity of hazardous waste has been discharged during

transportation. If a report pertains to a hazardous waste discharge:

(1) A copy of the hazardous waste manifest for the waste must be

attached to the report; and

(2) An estimate of the quantity of the waste removed from the

scene, the name and address of the facility to which it was taken,

and the manner of disposition of any removed waste must be entered

in Section IX of the report form (Form F 5800.1) (Rev. 6/89).

(b) Each carrier making a report under this section shall send

the report to the Information Systems Manager, DHM-63 , Research and

Special Programs Administration, Department of Transportation,

Washington, DC 20590-0001; and, for incidents involving

transportation by aircraft, a copy of the report shall also be sent

to the FAA Civil Aviation Security Office nearest the location of

the incident. A copy of the report shall be retained, for a period

of two years, at the carrier's principal place of business, or at

other places as authorized and approved in writing by an agency of

the Department of Transportation.

(c) Except as provided in paragraph (d) of this section, the

requirements of paragraph (a) of this section do not apply to

incidents involving the unintentional release of a hazardous

material--

(1) Transported under one of the following proper shipping

names:

(i) Consumer commodity.

(ii) Battery, electric storage, wet, filled with acid or alkali.

(iii) Paint and paint related material when shipped in

packagings of five gallons or less.

(2) Prepared and transported as a limited quantity shipment in

accordance with this subchapter.

(d) The exceptions to incident reporting provided in paragraph

(c) of this section do not apply to:

(1) Incidents required to be reported under 171.15(a);

(2) Incidents involving transportation aboard aircraft;

(3) Except for consumer commodities, materials in Packing Group

I; or

(4) Incidents involving the transportation of hazardous waste.

General Issues

1. Should the hazardous materials incident reporting requirements

be

[[Page 13945]]

extended to persons other than carriers (such as freight forwarders,

warehouse operators, consignees, etc.)?

2. Should RSPA require reporting of any incident involving

discovery of an undeclared shipment of a hazardous material whether or

not there is a release of the hazardous material? Should the expanded

requirement apply only to incidents discovered by a carrier during

transportation? Should the expanded requirement apply to discovery by a

consignee or other person during or following delivery of the material?

Telephonic Notification (see Sec. 171.15)

3. Currently, immediate notification is required for incidents

where estimated carrier or other property damage exceeds $50,000. Is

this monetary reporting threshold reasonable? Should it be modified or

eliminated? If modified, to what amount? Why?

4. Should any other current requirements for immediate notification

be modified or eliminated? If so, explain your suggested modification,

the reasons for the modification, and anticipated impacts.

5. Should RSPA require immediate telephonic notification for any

other type of incident?

6. In addition to notifying the National Response Center, should a

carrier also be required to give immediate telephonic notification of

an incident to the person who offered the hazardous material for

shipment?

7. If an incident requiring immediate telephonic notification

occurs at the location of an offeror or consignee, should the offeror

or consignee be required to provide the notification? Should such

notification be in addition to, or instead of notification from the

carrier? What would be the usefulness and burdens associated with such

a requirement?

Written Reports (see Sec. 171.16)

8. Is the current regulatory language clear as to when a written

incident report is required? If not, what changes should RSPA make?

9. To provide a broader perspective for risk management in more

critical hazardous material transportation situations, should

additional information be collected through the incident reporting

system to document successful performance and better gauge the

integrity of packaging? For instance, should information be collected

on certain highway accidents whether or not a hazardous material has

been released? Would an appropriate definition of ``accident'' for

reporting purposes be ``any collision, rollover, jack-knife, or

departure from the roadway''? Should additional reporting be limited to

certain packagings or materials such as--

Cargo tanks, portable tanks, and IM portable tanks with a

capacity greater than 1000 gallons;

Cylinders containing flammable gas with a water capacity

greater than 100 pounds;

Explosives in packaging greater than 50 pounds; or

Toxic-by-inhalation liquids or gases in any quantity and

packaging?

Should such additional reporting be limited to situations where there

is exposure to fire or damage to the packaging? Should reporting be

required for railway accidents that do not involve the unintentional

release of hazardous materials, or do mechanisms exist to adequately

capture this information apart from DOT Form F 5800.1?

10. Should RSPA expand the exceptions in Sec. 171.16(c) to include

any other hazardous material; class, division, or packing group; or

quantity limitations? If so, indicate the exception and why.

11. Is there a spill quantity of an excepted material that should

trigger incident reporting? For example, a spill of paint from a

packaging with a capacity of less than 5 gallons is not reportable.

Should a spill of a certain quantity of hazardous material be

reportable regardless of the capacity of the packaging in which it was

contained (e.g., a release from numerous small packagings)?

DOT Form F 5800.1 (See Appendix)

12. Should RSPA develop an abbreviated incident report form for

incidents of low severity? What criteria could be used as a threshold?

What minimal information should be required for a low severity

incident?

13. Should DOT Form F 5800.1 be structured to more accurately

describe the cause and manner of a packaging failure? How could this be

done to better capture human causal factors?

14. Would replacing the current check boxes on DOT Form F 5800.1,

sections V 24 and VI 25 thru 29, with numerically coded responses or

other means to better identify how the incident occurred, increase the

difficulty or lengthen the time it takes to complete the report?

15. Would replacing the boxes on DOT Form F 5800.1, section VIII

parts 41 thru 45, with numerically coded responses or other means to

identify the reasons why the packaging failed, increase the difficulty

or lengthen the time it takes to complete the report?

16. What additional fields, if any, should be included on the

report form to indicate the amount of hazardous material that was

initially in the package?

17. Would the information required by section VII of the report

form be easier to understand if column C was removed, column A was

renamed ``Inner Package'', and column B was renamed ``Outer Package''?

Why?

18. Should there be either separate sections on DOT Form F 5800.1

for reporting bulk and non-bulk packagings or a separate incident

report form for these packagings?

19. Should we require more specific incident location data, such as

mile-post or street address, if available? How difficult would it be to

obtain and report this information? What additional benefit would the

information provide?

20. How can better information be provided on DOT Form F 5800.1 as

to the transportation phase of an incident (e.g., when the incident

most likely occurred?)

21. Should RSPA require updates to Section V 18 through V 23, the

incident consequences fields, if additional or better data are

available after the incident report form was submitted to DOT? Should

RSPA set an amount or percentage change to trigger filing of a

supplemental report?

22. Should better information on release duration be collected (for

example, the length of time a vapor is dispersed)? How could this be

done?

23. How can RSPA acquire better information on failures, such as

estimated dimensions of cracks or punctures?

24. What burden would you incur from a requirement to submit copies

of photographs in your possession when specified criteria are met?

25. Should reporting of information concerning duration of an

evacuation be included on the incident report form?

26. Should RSPA add an additional section to the incident report

form to include information regarding who was injured or required

hospitalization (e.g., general public, employees, or emergency response

personnel)?

27. Should RSPA add a section to the incident report form to

identify the UN packing group, if any, of the hazardous material and

the packaging?

28. Are you aware of other Federal reporting forms that duplicate

information required by DOT Form F 5800.1? If so, how could RSPA link

the necessary transportation data to other required Federal reporting

forms?

[[Page 13946]]

Customer Uses and Needs

29. What data and information do you use from the incident report

form and for what purpose?

30. What additional data not now collected on the incident report

form should be collected and for what purpose would it be used?

31. Should access to incident data be available via the Internet?

If only select data could be provided because of cost or technology

considerations, what data would be most useful to you?

32. RSPA is considering optional electronic filing of incident

reports by facsimile (fax), electronic mail (e-mail), and Internet. Do

you have recommendations concerning implementation of electronic

filing? Are there other means of electronic filing that RSPA should

consider?

33. How would you use a tracking system for DOT Form F 5800.1

submissions and processing status?

National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Recommendations

Recommendation R-89-52 states that RSPA should:

Establish procedures that require carriers reporting hazardous

materials incidents under the provisions of 49 CFR 171.16 to notify

shippers whose hazardous materials shipments are involved.

34. In accordance with NTSB recommendation R-89-52, what would be

the potential benefits or impacts of requiring carriers (other than

private motor carriers) reporting hazardous materials incidents under

49 CFR 171.16 to notify shippers whose hazardous materials shipments

are involved in the incident being reported?

Recommendation H-92-6 states that RSPA should:

Implement, in cooperation with the Federal Highway

Administration, a program to collect information necessary to

identify patterns of cargo tank equipment failures, including the

reporting of all accidents involving DOT specification cargo tanks.

35. In accordance with NTSB recommendation H-92-6, how could RSPA,

in cooperation with FHWA, improve the current incident reporting

program to collect information identifying patterns of cargo tank

equipment failures, including reporting of all accidents involving a

DOT specification cargo tank, whether or not a release occurred?

V. Regulatory Analyses and Notices

A. Executive Order 12866 and DOT Regulatory Policies and Procedures

This ANPRM is not considered a significant regulatory action under

section 3(f) of Executive Order 12866 and, therefore, was not reviewed

by the Office of Management and Budget. This rule is not significant

under the Regulatory Policies and Procedures of the Department of

Transportation (44 FR 11034).

The costs and benefits associated with this rulemaking are

considered to be so minimal as to not warrant preparation of a

regulatory impact analysis or regulatory evaluation. This determination

may be revised as a result of public comment.

B. Executive Order 12612

This proposed rule has been analyzed in accordance with the

principles and criteria contained in Executive Order 12612

(``Federalism''). Federal law expressly preempts State, local, and

Indian tribe requirements applicable to the transportation of hazardous

material that cover certain subjects and are not substantively the same

as the Federal requirements. 49 U.S.C. 5125(b)(1). These subjects are:

(i) The designation, description, and classification of hazardous

material;

(ii) The packing, repacking, handling, labeling, marking, and

placarding of hazardous material;

(iii) The preparation, execution, and use of shipping documents

pertaining to hazardous material and requirements respecting the

number, content, and placement of those documents;

(iv) The written notification, recording, and reporting of the

unintentional release in transportation of hazardous material; or

(v) the design, manufacturing, fabrication, marking, maintenance,

reconditioning, repairing, or testing of a package or container which

is represented, marked, certified, or sold as qualified for use in the

transportation of hazardous material.

This proposed rule concerns the written notification, recording,

and reporting of the unintentional release in transportation of

hazardous materials. If adopted as final, this rule would preempt any

State, local, or Indian tribe requirements concerning this subject

unless the non-Federal requirements are ``substantively the same'' (see

49 CFR 107.202(d)) as the Federal requirements.

Federal law (49 U.S.C. 5125(b)(2)) provides that if DOT issues a

regulation concerning any of the covered subjects after November 16,

1990, DOT must determine and publish in the Federal Register the

effective date of Federal preemption. That effective date may not be

earlier than the 90th day following the date of issuance of the final

rule and not later than two years after the date of issuance. RSPA

requests comments on what the effective date of Federal preemption

should be for any new requirements RSPA may propose concerning the

specified covered subject.

C. Executive Order 13084

This proposed rule has been analyzed in accordance with the

principles and criteria contained in Executive order 13084

(``Consultation and Coordination with Indian Tribal Governments'').

Because this proposed rule would not significantly or uniquely affect

the Indian tribal communities, the funding and consultation

requirements of the Executive Order do not apply.

D. Regulatory Flexibility Act

This ANPRM requests information on a series of questions which will

be used to develop a proposal to amend provisions of the HMR addressing

incident reporting, including the report form. RSPA anticipates that

this rulemaking action will generally reduce burdens for most persons

required to submit hazardous materials incident reports, some of whom

are small entities. Since there are no specific proposals in this

ANPRM, there are not costs to be evaluated. If a rulemaking is

proposed, the impacts are anticipated to be so minimal as not to

warrant preparation of a regulatory impact analysis. Therefore, I

certify that this rulemaking action will not have a significant

economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.

E. Paperwork Reduction Act

Under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, no person is required to

respond to a collection of information unless it displays a valid OMB

control number. This ANPRM does not propose any new information

collection burdens.

F. Regulation Identifier Number (RIN)

A regulation identifier number (RIN) is assigned to each regulatory

action listed in the Unified Agenda of Federal Regulations. The

Regulatory Information Service Center publishes the Unified Agenda in

April and October of each year. The RIN number contained in the heading

of this document can be used to cross-reference this action with the

Unified Agenda.

G. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act

This rulemaking would not impose unfunded mandates under the

Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995. It would not result in costs of

$100 million or more to either State, local, or tribal governments, in

the aggregate, or to the private sector.

[[Page 13947]]

Issued in Washington, DC on March 17, 1999, under the authority

delegated in 49 CFR part 106.

Alan I. Roberts,

Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety.

[FR Doc. 99-7040 Filed 3-22-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.