Exemption From Registration as a Commodity Trading Advisor

Federal RegisterDec 7, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION

17 CFR Part 4

RIN 3038-AB48

Exemption From Registration as a Commodity Trading Advisor

AGENCY: Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Commodity Futures Trading Commission proposes to amend its

rules to create an exemption from registration requirements for

commodity trading advisors that provide advice by means of media such

as newsletters, Internet web sites, and non-customized computer

software.

DATES: Comments must be received by February 7, 2000.

ADDRESSES: Comments on the proposed rule may be sent to Jean A. Webb,

Secretary of the Commission, Commodity Futures Trading Commission,

Three Lafayette Centre, 1155 21st Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20581.

In addition, comments may be sent by facsimile transmission to

facsimile number (202) 418-5521, or by electronic mail to

[email protected]. Reference should be made to ``Exemption from

Registration as a Commodity Trading Advisor.''

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Martin White, Attorney, (202) 418-

5120, electronic mail: [email protected], Office of General Counsel,

Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Three Lafayette Centre, 1155 21st

Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20581; or Michael J. Garawski, (202)

418-5120, electronic mail: [email protected], Office of General

Counsel, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Three Lafayette Centre,

1155 21st Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20581.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

The Commission proposes to exempt certain commodity trading

advisors (``CTAs'') from Section 4m(1) of the Commodity Exchange Act

(``CEA'' or ``Act''), 7 U.S.C. 6m(1) (1994), which requires CTAs to

register with the Commission. The precise scope of the exemption is

described below. Generally speaking, the exemption is intended to apply

to CTAs that provide commodity trading advice by means of media such as

newsletters, Internet web sites, and non-customized computer

software.\1\ For purposes of convenience, these CTAs will be referred

to as ``Section 4.14(a)(9) CTAs.'' \2\

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ In this notice, the term ``commodity trading advice'' refers

to advice with respect to trading in a ``commodity interest,'' as

defined in Commission Rule 3.1(f), 17 CFR 3.1(f).

\2\ ``Section 4.14(a)(9)'' is a shorthand reference to Section

4.14(a)(9) of the Commission's Rules, 17 CFR 4.14(a)(9), at which

the proposed exemption would be codified, if promulgated.

A person that provides commodity trading advice by means of

newsletters, Internet web sites, or similar means falls within the

statutory definition of ``commodity trading advisor'' unless the

person is a ``publisher or producer of.. print or electronic data of

general and regular dissemination'' and the furnishing of commodity

trading advice is ``solely incidental to the conduct of their

business or profession.'' See Sections 1a(5) (B) and (C) of the Act,

7 U.S.C. 1a(5) (B) and (C) (1994); In re R&W Technical Services,

Ltd., [Current Transfer Binder] Comm. Fut. L. Rep. (CCH) para.

27,582 (CFTC Mar. 16, 1999); In re Armstrong, [1992-1994 Transfer

Binder] Comm. Fut. L. Rep. (CCH) para. 25,657 (CFTC Feb. 8, 1993).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Over the last several years, the Commission has been involved in

several litigated cases that address whether CTAs that provide advice

through newsletters, Internet web sites, or similar means can be

required to register under Section 4m(1) of the CEA. In two of those

cases, Taucher v. Born, 53 F. Supp. 2d 464 (D.D.C. 1999) (appeal

pending), and Commodity Trend Service v. CFTC, No. 97 C 2362 (N.D. Ill.

Sept. 28, 1999), federal district courts held that the Section 4m(1)

registration requirement constitutes an unconstitutional prior

restraint in violation of the First Amendment as applied to the

plaintiffs.\3\ In both cases, the plaintiffs provided only standardized

commodity trading advice through a variety of media, including Internet

web sites, computer software, voice recordings accessible by telephone,

e-mails, facsimiles, and periodicals. Moreover, the plaintiffs in these

cases did not have discretionary control over their clients' accounts,

did not provide advice tailored to the financial situation of any

specific client, and had no personal contact with their clients. All of

the information provided to each client was identical.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ Both district courts relied on Lowe v. SEC. 472 U.S. 181

(1985), in which the Supreme Court held that the Investment Advisers

Act of 1940, which regulates investment advisers in the securities

industry, should be interpreted to apply only to persons who provide

personalized advice. The district courts relied primarily on the

concurring opinion in Lowe, which rested on constitutional grounds.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Commission has not itself determined that applying Section

4m(1) to Section 4.14(a)(9) CTAs violates the Constitution or that the

district court decisions in Taucher and CTS represent a complete and

accurate statement of the constitutional limits of Congress's power

with respect to the regulation of Section 4.14(a)(9) CTAs. The

Commission has nevertheless determined that it may be appropriate to

exempt Section 4.14(a)(9) CTAs from registration for the following

reasons:

1. Taucher and CTS have created legal uncertainty as to whether

Section 4.14(a)(9) CTAs may be required to register with the

Commission. Absent a Supreme Court decision on the issue, continued

litigation is unlikely to eliminate this uncertainty for a considerable

period of time. Moreover, litigation of First Amendment issues has

required the expenditure of considerable resources by the Commission

and, in some instances, has complicated the investigation and

prosecution of fraud by CTAs.

2. Whatever the courts may determine to be the precise

constitutional limits of Congressional authority in this area, the

Commission believes that minimizing impact on speech, other than

deceptive or misleading speech, is a relevant policy consideration in

determining the Commission's regulatory approach toward CTAs whose

relationship with their clients is limited to communications through

media such as newsletters, Internet web sites, and non-customized

computer software.

II. The Proposed Rule

The proposed rule would add a new subsection to Commission Rule

4.14 to create an additional exemption from registration for certain

CTAs. The new exemption is expressed in negative terms: the rule

exempts CTAs that are not engaged in the types of advisory activities

specified in the new subsection. A CTA would have to meet all of the

specified conditions to qualify for the proposed exemption. The general

intent of the proposed rule is to retain the registration requirement

for CTAs whose advisory activities may be licensed even under the

constitutional standards implicit in the district court decisions in

Taucher and Commodity Trend Service.

Proposed Subsection 4.14(a)(9)(i) provides that, to qualify for the

exemption, a CTA may not direct client accounts. As defined by

Commission Rule 4.10(f), ``[d]irect, as used in the context of trading

commodity interest accounts, refers to agreements whereby a person is

authorized to cause transactions to be effected for a client's

commodity interest account without the client's specific

authorization.'' Such authority creates a business relationship between

the CTA and the client that clearly goes beyond speech. Registration of

CTAs that direct client accounts thus raises no First Amendment issue.

Proposed Subsection 4.14(a)(9)(ii) provides that a CTA qualifies

for the exemption only if it does not provide

[[Page 68305]]

commodity interest trading advice based on, or tailored to, the

commodity interest or cash market positions or other circumstances or

characteristics of particular clients. A CTA that provides this kind of

advice carries out a function comparable to that of a traditional

professional. See Lowe v. SEC, 472 U.S. 181, 232-33 (1985) (White, J.,

concurring). This provision is intended to preserve the registration

requirement for CTAs whose knowledge of their clients is limited to

information concerning a particular commodity interest account or

particular commodity interest trading activity, as well as to CTAs who

base their advice on a broader range of information about the client.

Moreover, so long as the CTA's advice was based on or tailored to such

information, the CTA would have to register even if it gave the same

advice to groups of similarly situated clients.

Proposed Subsection 4.14(a)(9)(iii) provides that a CTA qualifies

for the exemption only if it does not provide commodity interest

trading advice through personally interactive communications with

individual clients, such as face-to-face conversations; telephone

conversations; or electronic mail exchanges between individuals. The

use of such means of communications implies that the advisor is giving

advice in the context of a relationship with the client that is more

personal than the remote and standardized relationship between the

publisher of a newsletter or non-custom software and its readers or

users.

It is the intent of the Commission that a CTA that manages a

client's trading under some type of informal arrangement should be

required to register even if the CTA is not authorized to cause

transactions to be effected without the client's specific

authorization, and therefore does not ``direct'' the client's accounts.

The Commission, however, has not proposed that an explicit condition to

this effect be included in the proposed exemption rule. The Commission

believes that, in practice, a CTA that manages a client's trading, but

does not ``direct'' the client's account, would almost certainly fail

to meet the conditions set forth in the proposed subsections

4.14(a)(9)(ii) and 4.14(a)(9)(iii). As a result, the Commission does

not believe that a separate subsection dealing with CTAs that manage

their clients' trading under informal arrangements is necessary. The

Commission invites comments on whether this belief is accurate and on

whether a subsection dealing explicitly with CTAs that manage their

clients' trading under informal arrangements should be added to the

proposed exemption.

Under the proposed rule, any CTA that meets all of the conditions

of proposed Subsection 4.14(a)(9) would not be required to register

with the Commission as a requirement for doing business as a CTA. Such

a CTA, unless it chose to register voluntarily, also would be exempt

from the various regulatory requirements set forth in the CEA and the

Commission's rules that, by their terms, apply only to registrants or

persons required to be registered. For example, an exempt CTA would not

be subject to the recordkeeping and production requirements of Section

4n(3)(A) of the CEA and Commission Rule 4.33, the ethics training

requirement of Section 4p(b) of the CEA, or liability for reparations

under Section 14 of the CEA.

An exempt CTA would still be subject to those provisions of the CEA

andthe Commission's rules that, by their terms, apply to CTAs without

regard to registration. These include Section 4o of the CEA, which

prohibits fraud by CTAs; Commission Rule 4.30, which, broadly speaking,

prohibits CTAs from handling clients' funds; Commission Rule 4.41(a),

which prohibits deceptive advertising by CTAs; and Commission Rule

4.41(b), which requires representations concerning simulated or

hypothetical performance results by CTAs to be accompanied by

disclosures describing the limitations of such results as an indicator

of actual performance. Exempt CTAs also would be subject to those

provisions of the CEA that apply to any person, including, for example,

Section 4b of the CEA, which prohibits certain forms of fraud.

Similarly, the proposed exemption would not alter the duty of a Section

4.14(a)(9) CTA to register with the Commission in a capacity other than

as a CTA, if the CTA, in addition to its advisory activities, engages

in other business activities that require such registration.

Should the Commission proceed to adopt a final rule, an exempt CTA

that wanted to register or retain its current registration, for

example, to enhance the confidence of clients or potential clients,

would be entitled to register voluntarily.

III. Examples

In order to convey the intent of the proposed exemption, the

following examples illustrate how the proposed rule would operate in

specific situations:\4\

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\4\ In all of the following examples, the CTA remains subject to

requirements of the Act or the Commission's regulations that apply

to all CTAs without regard to registration, such as Section 4o of

the Act and Commission Rule 4.41(a) and (b), as well as to

provisions that apply to any person, such as Section 4b of the Act,

to the extent that the CTA's actions fall within the activities

proscribed by those provisions.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

A. A CTA provides commodity trading advice only through

newsletters, books, and periodicals. The advice includes specific

recommendations, such as recommendations to buy or sell specific

futures contracts should a particular price level be reached.

Recipients of publications all receive the same advice. The CTA does

not have powers of attorney from any of his clients to trade accounts.

Under proposed Rule 4.14(a)(9), this CTA would be exempt from the

Section 4m registration requirement.

B. A CTA provides specific commodity trading advice through e-

mails, facsimiles, and an Internet web site. The advice is based on a

computerized trading system, which also is available for purchase and

use on a personal computer. Such advice is provided on a daily basis

and is reactive to the latest market activity. The advice consists only

of an instruction to buy or sell a futures contract and where, if at

all, to place a stop order. The CTA's clients all receive the same

advice. The CTA does not have powers of attorney from any of his

clients to trade accounts, although many clients follow the CTA's

advice exactly. Under proposed Rule 4.14(a)(9), this CTA would be

exempt from the Section 4m registration requirement.

C. A CTA sells a computerized trading system like the system

described in example B. The CTA does not have powers of attorney from

any of its clients to trade accounts. In telephone conversations with

clients, the CTA discusses technical questions concerning the software,

such as how to install the application and computer memory

requirements. Such advice is not ``trading'' advice within the meaning

of proposed Rule 4.14(a)(9)(iii). Under proposed Rule 4.14(a)(9), this

CTA would be exempt from the Section 4m registration requirement.

D. A CTA provides commodity trading advice through a weekly print

periodical and invites readers to contact him by telephone with further

questions. Each week, several readers of the publication call the CTA

to inquire about the CTA's confidence in his published recommendations.

The CTA does not have a power of attorney to trade any of his

subscribers' accounts. The CTA responds to readers' questions

personally on the telephone but does so with no knowledge of the

reader's

[[Page 68306]]

investment portfolio, tolerance for risk, investment goals or other

personal characteristics. Under proposed Rule 4.14(a)(9)(iii), this CTA

would not be exempt from the Section 4m registration requirement,

because it provides commodity trading advice through interactive

communications with individual clients.

E. A CTA has a computerized trading system like the system

described in example B. The CTA meets with his clients individually and

face-to-face, and gives all of them identical trading advice that is

based on what the computer system advises. The CTA does not have a

power of attorney to trade any of his clients' accounts. Under proposed

Rule 4.14(a)(9)(iii), this CTA would not be exempt from the Section 4m

registration requirement, because he provides commodity trading advice

through interactive communications with individual clients.

F. A CTA advises his clients only through facsimile messages and

does not discuss his advice with them. The CTA does not have a power of

attorney to trade any of his clients' accounts. Before advising any

client, the CTA first gathers current knowledge about the client's

current futures holdings and net cash available for futures

investments. The CTA's advice is different for different clients,

depending on their profile. However, the CTA sends similar advice to

groups of clients with similar profiles. Under proposed Rule

4.14(a)(9)(ii), this CTA would not be exempt from the Section 4m

registration requirement, because he provides commodity trading advice

based on, or tailored to, the commodity interest or cash market

positions or other circumstances or characteristics of particular

clients.

IV. Request for Comments

The Commission specifically encourages members of the public to

submit comments on the following issues, in addition to all other

issues relevant to the proposed rule:

1. Should the rule include a provision explicitly stating that the

proposed exemption does not apply to CTAs that manage their clients'

commodity interest trading under informal arrangements? If so, what

language should be used to characterize such CTAs for purposes of the

exemption?

2. Should CTAs falling within the scope of the proposed exemption

be subject to any regulatory requirements beyond the requirements, such

as Section 4o of the CEA and Commission Rule 4.41, that apply to other

exempt CTAs? If so, what should those requirements be? For example,

should Section 4.14(a)(9) CTAs still be subject to recordkeeping

requirements?

3. Are there any categories of CTAs that are not included within

the scope of the proposed exemption but should be?

4. Are there any categories of CTAs that are included within the

scope of the proposed exemption but should not be?

V. Statutory Authority

Pursuant to Sections 4(c)(1) and 8a(5) of the CEA, 7 U.S.C. 6(c)

and 12a(5), the Commission has statutory authority to promulgate the

proposed rule. The proposed rulemaking would revise the authority

citation for Part 4 to include 7 U.S.C. 6(c).

VI. Related Matters

A. Regulatory Flexibility Act

The Regulatory Flexibility Act (``RFA''), 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.,

requires that agencies, in proposing rules, consider the impact of

those rules on small business. The Commission has previously

established certain definitions of ``small entities'' to be used by the

Commission in evaluating the impact of its rules on such entities in

accordance with the RFA.\5\ With respect to CTAs, the Commission has

stated that it would evaluate within the context of a particular rule

proposal whether all or some affected CTAs would be considered to be

small entities and, if so, the economic impact on them of any rule.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\5\ 47 FR 18618-21 (Apr. 30, 1982).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The proposed exemption would reduce or remove existing economic

burdens. Moreover, the registration requirements that would be affected

by the proposed rule involve only minimal economic burdens, except in

the case of the limited number of CTAs who may fail to qualify for

registration under Section 8a of the CEA because of disciplinary or

other disqualifying factors. Therefore, the Chairman of the Commission

hereby certifies, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 605(b), that the proposed rule

will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of

small entities. Such a certification is consistent with the regulatory

flexibility analysis conducted by the Commission in a previous

rulemaking exempting certain persons from the CTA registration

requirement.\6\ Nonetheless, the Commission specifically requests

comment on the impact this proposed rule may have on small entities.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\6\ See 52 FR 41983 n.57 (Nov. 2, 1987).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

B. Paperwork Reduction Act

Proposed Rule 4.14(a)(9) affects information collection

requirements. As required by the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44

U.S.C. 3507(d)), the Commission has submitted a copy of this section to

the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for its review.

1. Collection of Information: Rules Relating to the Operations and

Activities of Commodity Pool Operators and Commodity Trading Advisors

and to Monthly Reporting by Futures Commission Merchants, OMB Control

Number 3038-0005.

The expected effect of the proposed rule will be to reduce the

burden previously approved by OMB for this collection of information by

18,200 hours because it will exempt certain commodity trading advisors

from the registration requirement in Section 4m(1) of the Commodity

Exchange Act and associated recordkeeping requirements. Specifically

the burden associated with Commission Rule 4.33 is expected to be

reduced by 18,200 hours:

Estimated number of respondents (after proposed exemption): 2,000.

Annual responses by each respondent: 1.

Total annual responses: 2000.

Estimated average hours per response: 26.

Annual reporting burden: 52,000 hours.

This annual reporting burden of 52,000 hours represents a reduction of

18,200 hours as a result of the proposed new rule. (The estimated

burden figure of 52,000 hours for Rule 4.33 is higher than the Rule

4.33 burden figure previously reported to the Office of Management and

Budget. The Commission, however, believes that the previously reported

figure may be based on an incorrect figure for the number of CTAs.)

2. Collection of Information: Rules, Regulations and Forms for

Domestic and Foreign Futures and Options Relating to Registration with

the Commission, OMB Control Number 3038-0023.

The expected effect of the proposed rule will be to reduce the

burden previously approved by OMB for this collection of information by

311 hours because it will exempt certain commodity trading advisors

from the registration requirement in Section 4m(1) of the Commodity

Exchange Act and associated reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

Specifically:

The burden associated with Commission Rule 3.10(a), Form 7-R, as

applied to CTAs is expected to be reduced by 72 hours:

Estimated number of respondents (after proposed exemption): 350.

[[Page 68307]]

Annual responses by each respondent: 1.

Total annual responses: 350.

Estimated average hours per response: .40.

Annual reporting burden: 140 hours.

This annual reporting burden of 140 hours represents a reduction of 72

hours as a result of the proposed new rule.

The burden associated with Commission Rule 3.10(a), Form 8-R, is

expected to be reduced by 99 hours:

Estimated number of respondents (after proposed exemption): 2800.

Annual responses by each respondent: 1.

Total annual responses: 2800.

Estimated average hours per response: .33.

Annual reporting burden: 924 hours.

This annual reporting burden of 924 hours represents a reduction of 99

hours as a result of the proposed new rule.

The burden associated with Commission Rule 3.10(d) is expected to

be reduced by 140 hours:

Estimated number of respondents (after proposed exemption): 3100.

Annual responses by each respondent: 1.

Total annual responses: 3100.

Estimated average hours per response: .20.

Annual reporting burden: 620 hours.

This annual reporting burden of 620 hours represents a reduction of 140

hours as a result of the proposed new rule.

Organizations and individuals desiring to submit comments on the

information collection requirements should direct them to the Office of

Information and Regulatory Affairs, OMB, Room 10235, New Executive

Office Building, Washington, DC 20503; Attention: Desk Officer for the

Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

The Commission considers comments by the public on this proposed

collection of information in--

Evaluating whether the proposed collection of information

is necessary for the proper performance of the functions of the

Commission, including whether the information will have a practical

use;

Evaluating the accuracy of the Commission's estimate of

the burden of the proposed collection of information, including the

validity of the methodology and assumptions used;

Enhancing the quality, usefulness, and clarity of the

information to be collected; and

Minimizing the burden of collection of information on

those who are to respond, including through the use of appropriate

automated electronic, mechanical, or other technological collection

techniques or other forms of information technology; e.g., permitting

electronic submission of responses.

OMB is required to make a decision concerning the collection of

information contained in these proposed regulations between 30 and 60

days after publication of this document in the Federal Register.

Therefore, a comment to OMB is best assured of having its full effect

if OMB receives it within 30 days of publication. This does not affect

the deadline for the public to comment to the Commission on the

proposed regulations.

Copies of the information collection submission to OMB are

available from the CFTC Clearance Officer, 1155 21st Street, NW,

Washington DC 20581, (202) 418-5160.

List of Subjects in 17 CFR Part 4

Advertising, Brokers, Commodity futures, Commodity pool operators,

Commodity trading advisors, Consumer protection, Reporting and

recordkeeping requirements.

For the reasons stated in the preamble, the Commodity Futures

Trading Commission proposes to amend 17 CFR part 4 as follows:

PART 4--COMMODITY POOL OPERATORS AND COMMODITY TRADING ADVISORS

1. The authority citation for part 4 is revised to read as follows:

Authority: 7 U.S.C. 1a, 2, 4, 6, 6b, 6c, 6l, 6m, 6n, 6o, 12a and

23.

2. Section 4.14 is amended by adding paragraph (a)(9) to read as

follows:

Sec. 4.14 Exemption from registration as a commodity trading advisor.

(a) * * *

(9) It does not engage in any of the following activities:

(i) Direct client accounts;

(ii) Provide commodity interest trading advice based on, or

tailored to, the commodity interest or cash market positions or other

circumstances or characteristics of particular clients; or

(iii) Provide commodity interest trading advice through interactive

communications with individual clients, such as face-to-face or

telephone conversations or electronic mail exchanges between

individuals.

* * * * *

Dated: December 2, 1999.

Jean A. Webb,

Secretary of the Commission.

[FR Doc. 99-31687 Filed 12-6-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 6351-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.