Animal Welfare; Perimeter Fence Requirements

Federal RegisterOct 18, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service

9 CFR Part 3

[Docket No. 95-029-2]

Animal Welfare; Perimeter Fence Requirements

AGENCY: Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, USDA.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: We are amending the Animal Welfare regulations to require that

a perimeter fence be placed around outdoor housing facilities for

marine mammals and certain other regulated animals. Although it has

been our policy that such fences should be in place around outdoor

housing facilities for such animals, there have been no provisions in

the regulations specifically requiring their use. Adding the perimeter

fence requirement to the regulations for these additional categories of

animals will serve to protect the safety of the animals and provide for

their well-being.

DATES: Effective date: November 17, 1999.

Compliance date: May 17, 2000.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Dr. Barbara Kohn, Staff Veterinarian,

Animal Care, APHIS, 4700 River Road Unit 84, Riverdale, MD 20737-1234;

(301) 734-7833.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

The Animal Welfare regulations contained in 9 CFR chapter I,

subchapter A, part 3 (referred to below as the regulations), provide

specifications for the humane handling, care, treatment, and

transportation, by regulated entities, of animals covered by the Animal

Welfare Act (the Act) (7 U.S.C. 2131, et seq.). The regulations in part

3 are divided into six subparts, subparts A through F, each of which

contains facility and operating standards, animal health and husbandry

standards, and transportation standards for a specific category of

animals. These categories are: (A) Cats and dogs, (B) guinea pigs and

hamsters, (C) rabbits, (D) nonhuman primates, (E) marine mammals, and

(F) animals other than cats, dogs, guinea pigs, hamsters, rabbits,

nonhuman primates, and marine mammals.

On May 6, 1997, we published in the Federal Register (62 FR 24611-

24614, Docket No. 95-029-1) a proposal to amend the regulations in

subparts E and F of the regulations by requiring that perimeter fences

be placed around outdoor housing facilities for marine mammals and for

other animals covered by the regulations, other than cats, dogs, guinea

pigs, hamsters, and rabbits.

We proposed the following minimum perimeter fence heights:

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Minimum

perimeter

Type of facility fence

height

(feet)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Marine Mammals, other than Polar Bears..................... 6

Polar Bears................................................ 8

Other Nondangerous Animals................................. 6

Other Potentially Dangerous Animals........................ 8

------------------------------------------------------------------------

In our proposed rule, we stated that the perimeter fence would act

as a secondary containment system for the animals in the facility when

appropriate, reasonably restrict animals and unauthorized persons from

entering the facilities or having contact with the animals, and prevent

exposure to diseases. We intended these requirements to protect the

safety and provide for the well-being of the animals.

We also proposed a minimum distance of 3 feet between the perimeter

fence and any primary enclosure to prevent physical contact between

animals inside the enclosure and animals and persons outside the

perimeter fence.

We solicited comments concerning our proposal for 60 days ending

July 7, 1997. We received 23 comments by that date. They were from

exhibitors, exhibitor and trade associations, wildlife associations,

animal parks, humane organizations, and a Federal government agency,

among others. The comments are discussed below by topic.

Primary Enclosure and Perimeter Fencing

Several commenters opposed the installation of a perimeter fence

around each primary enclosure. Some were concerned that the perimeter

fence would obscure the public's view of the animals or detract from

the aesthetic draw of the facilities and decrease the number of

visitors. Another commenter stated that the perimeter fence would

interfere with the ability of the public to have physical contact with

animals in petting zoos. One commenter expressed concern that the

perimeter fence would conflict with the Americans with Disabilities Act

by impairing access to areas around the primary enclosures.

We believe these commenters misunderstood the proposal. The

perimeter fence would surround the area or areas where the outdoor

housing facilities are located. Each individual primary enclosure would

not have to be surrounded by a second fence. Therefore, a perimeter

fence would not obstruct the public's view of the animals, hinder the

petting of the animals at petting zoos, or impair access to the primary

enclosures by people with disabilities.

Height of the Perimeter Fence

One commenter asked how we determined that a perimeter fence should

be 8 feet high for potentially dangerous animals and 6 feet high for

marine mammals other than polar bears. This commenter stated that the

required heights were arbitrary and had no scientific basis. Several

commenters stated that an 8-foot fence would not provide security

against the escape of large felines or the entry of unwanted animals or

people and pointed out that certain animals and people would be

[[Page 56143]]

able to climb the perimeter fence. An additional commenter stated that

a 3\1/2\- or 4-foot perimeter fence would be sufficient to keep

unauthorized people away from the animals. Several commenters requested

alternative security methods to accomplish the goals set out in the

proposal. Another commenter stated that our rule should allow for

alternative measures that may not require structural changes to a

facility.

Perimeter fences are intended to provide reasonable protection to

animals from the unauthorized entry of persons and other animals,

protect animals from exposure to disease, and serve as a secondary

containment structure if one of the animals escapes from its primary

enclosure. As indicated in our proposal, perimeter fence requirements

have been our policy for many years with satisfactory results. The

perimeter fence height requirements are based on our experience of more

than 20 years with the protection and secondary containment of animals

at regulated facilities. Perimeter fences are not designed to prevent

all escapes or to keep out all persons that are determined to gain

access to a facility. Some potentially dangerous animals may be able to

climb or jump over an 8-foot fence. However, these animals' primary

enclosures should be constructed sufficiently to prevent their escape.

In the event of an escape, the perimeter fence would act as a secondary

containment system to impede escape from the facility.

If a facility wants to use a lower perimeter fence than required by

the regulations, the lower fence would have to be approved in writing

by the Administrator. Approval by the Administrator of a lower

perimeter fence would only be given if the lower fence, in conjunction

with the facility's alternative security measures, would provide the

same or an enhanced degree of protection from access by animals and

unauthorized persons, disease exposure, and animal escape.

With respect to alternative methods of accomplishing the goals

identified in the proposal, Sec. 3.103(c)(1) and (c)(2) and

Sec. 3.127(d)(1) and (d)(2) of this rule offer alternatives to a

perimeter fence. A perimeter fence is not required if the outside walls

of the primary enclosure are made of sturdy, durable material, which

may include certain types of concrete, wood, plastic, metal, or glass,

and are high enough and constructed in a manner that restricts entry by

animals and unauthorized persons and the Administrator gives written

approval. In addition, a perimeter fence is not required if the outdoor

housing facility is protected by an effective natural barrier that

restricts the marine mammals or other animals, as the case may be, to

the facility and restricts entry by animals and unauthorized persons

and the Administrator gives written approval.

We agree that there are other alternative security measures a

facility could employ that would provide the same or an enhanced

protection. Therefore, in this final rule, Sec. Sec. 3.103(c)(3) and

3.127(d)(3) provide that a perimeter fence is not required where

appropriate alternative security measures are employed and the

Administrator provides written approval.

In this final rule, we are also replacing the phrase ``impenetrable

natural barrier'' in Sec. Sec. 3.103(c)(2) and 3.127(d)(2) with the

phrase ``effective natural barrier.'' An effective natural barrier to

prevent the entry of unwanted animals and persons is more attainable

than an impenetrable natural barrier.

Several commenters stated that the existing requirements for farm

animals are sufficient as a secondary containment system and as a means

of preventing the unauthorized entry of animals and people into the

primary enclosures. These commenters stated that farm animals, such as

goats, sheep, horses, cows, and donkeys, should be excluded from the

perimeter fencing requirements.

We agree that the use of perimeter fencing may not be necessary at

all times to provide safety to farm animals. Therefore, we have decided

to add a new paragraph (d)(5) to Sec. 3.127 to provide an exclusion for

facilities housing only farm animals, such as, but not limited to,

goats, sheep, horses (for regulated purposes), cows, pigs, or donkeys,

where effective and customary containment and security measures are in

place for those animals.

Several commenters maintained that it was unnecessary to require an

8-foot perimeter fence, rather than a 6-foot fence, at facilities that

contain elephants because elephants cannot climb or jump a fence. One

commenter stated that the height of the fence would not keep elephants

contained.

Although elephants do not jump or climb well, they do rear up, and

we believe that an 8-foot fence is appropriate. Of course, we recognize

that a lower fence may be adequate in some circumstances. The rule

provides a procedure for the approval of alternative measures.

One commenter stated that an 8-foot fence should be required for

all marine mammals and potentially dangerous animals, mainly to prevent

the entry of unauthorized persons. Another commenter stated that a 6-

foot fence is sufficient for all animals except large felines, such as

tigers, lions, leopards, and cougars, and would keep unwanted people or

animals out. This commenter and several others also stated that there

may be zoning problems within communities for the placement of fences

higher than 6 feet.

A perimeter fence must be high enough to reasonably be expected to

keep animals and unauthorized persons out of the facility and to act as

a secondary containment system should an animal escape from its primary

enclosure. Based on our experience of more than 20 years with the

protection and secondary containment of animals at regulated

facilities, a fence measuring at least 8 feet in height is necessary

for potentially dangerous animals. As we stated in the proposal,

potentially dangerous animals may be subject to possibly dangerous, or

lethal, recapture and control methods if they escape captivity. One of

the purposes of a perimeter fence for potentially dangerous animals is

to act as a secondary containment system and reduce the possibility

that the animals will escape from the facility and be harmed during

recapture and control. We believe that, with the exception of polar

bears, marine mammals are not considered potentially dangerous animals

for the purposes of the perimeter fence requirements. Most marine

mammals are either confined to their pools (cetaceans) or cannot climb

or jump over a 6-foot fence. Therefore, we do not feel that an 8-foot

fence is necessary for marine mammals such as seals, sea lions,

walruses, dolphins, whales, sea otters, or manatees. Moreover, as

explained earlier, we recognize that a lower fence may be appropriate

in some circumstances. The rule provides for the use of a lower fence

with the written approval of the Administrator. If local zoning

requirements preclude a perimeter fence of the required height, then

alternative measures would have to be employed.

Several commenters questioned whether a fence 8 feet in height

would prevent small animals, such as dogs, skunks and raccoons, from

tunneling under or climbing over the fence. Some stated that small

rodents, birds, insects, and bats can transmit disease and would not be

deterred by the perimeter fence. Another commenter requested

documentation that demonstrates that the proposed perimeter fence

requirement would help prevent animals, especially marine mammals, from

being exposed to disease.

[[Page 56144]]

We realize that the perimeter fence may not prevent a determined

animal from entering the facility. We also realize that small rodents,

birds, insects, and bats may get under or over a perimeter fence and

transmit diseases. There are a number of ways a facility can deal with

these issues, including the use of effective pest control programs for

nuisance or potentially hazardous insects, birds, or other animals.

This rule is intended to supplement such control measures by minimizing

exposure to unwanted animals. A perimeter fence will help restrict

small animals' access to animals in a facility. Exclusion of these

small animals will help prevent confined animals from being exposed to

diseases such as rabies and distemper and to vectors such as ticks and

fleas. The use of a perimeter fence as a disease control measure is

based on epidemiological considerations, disease transmission theories,

and our experience of more than 20 years with the protection of animals

at regulated facilities. Obviously, fencing as a disease control

measure is more significant in some circumstances than others and

indeed may be insignificant in some circumstances.

One commenter requested the number of polar bears that have escaped

from a facility within the last 5 years. This commenter also wanted to

know if any polar bears were killed during recapture or control. The

commenter maintained that the proposed perimeter fence requirements for

polar bears were overly cautious and unwarranted. Another commenter

stated that perimeter fencing should be required only if there is a

known problem or history of problems at the facility.

We are promulgating this rule, in part, to prevent possible

problems due to the escape of animals and not as a response to the

escape of an animal. Our experience of more than 20 years with the

protection and secondary containment of animals at regulated facilities

has shown that the use of perimeter fences is effective as a secondary

containment system and as a means of protecting animals from the entry

of other animals and unauthorized persons. The purpose of the Animal

Welfare regulations is to provide for the humane handling, care,

treatment, and transportation of regulated animals with the intent of

preventing problems whenever possible rather than waiting for problems

to occur. We do not believe that polar bears are less dangerous than

other bears or that they should be treated differently in the context

of this rule.

Several commenters requested that the perimeter fence requirements

apply only to small, urban establishments because a 6-foot perimeter

fence may draw attention to a facility and prompt unauthorized people

to attempt to enter the facility. We do not believe that a perimeter

fence would make a facility less secure and, accordingly, do not adopt

this suggestion.

Several commenters asked how APHIS determined that a minimum space

of 3 feet between the primary enclosure and the perimeter fence was

sufficient. One commenter stated that the distance was arbitrary, and

another commenter stated that 3 feet was insufficient to prevent a

person from sticking a pole or other object through a fence to injure

an animal or allow adequate room for routine maintenance and repair.

The proposal identified 3 feet as the minimum distance between the

perimeter fence and any primary enclosure. This distance is based on

APHIS' experience at Animal Welfare Act regulated facilities. In

addition, this distance incorporates the minimum distance that allows

safe cleaning of the area between the perimeter fence and any primary

enclosures. This distance also provides sufficient distance to prevent

casual contact between someone or something outside the perimeter fence

and the animal within its primary enclosure.

One commenter stated that the best way to prevent an animal's

escape is to use double-gated and locked entrances rather than

perimeter fencing. The commenter also suggested that we require all

facilities to use double-gated and locked entrances.

We do not believe it is necessary to require one type of primary

enclosure containment system. We require all primary enclosures to be

of sufficient strength to contain the animals. The perimeter fence or

an approved alternative should be designed to prevent the entry of

animals and unauthorized persons, protect against disease exposure, and

act as a secondary containment system.

Temporary Versus Permanent Facilities

Several commenters questioned whether a perimeter fence is

necessary only for a permanent facility at which an animal is housed or

if it is also necessary for locations where traveling animal shows

temporarily house animals. Some of these commenters maintained that the

regulations should not include locations where traveling animal shows

temporarily house animals. One commenter stated that the regulations

should include requirements for marine mammals in traveling shows.

The intent of the Act is to provide for the humane handling, care,

treatment, and transportation of animals covered by the Act at all

times. This includes animals that are traveling and temporarily housed

outdoors. The proposed rule applied to all outdoor housing facilities

for marine mammals and certain other regulated animals, and did not

exclude temporary traveling facilities. However, for temporary

traveling facilities, equivalent alternatives may be more practical and

less burdensome than perimeter fencing. Further, unlike the situation

for operators of permanent facilities, it would be difficult for

traveling exhibitors to obtain advance approval for their alternative

security measures at each site. Accordingly, the proposed rule is

modified to provide flexibility to traveling facilities. This final

rule provides in Sec. 3.103(c)(4) for marine mammals and

Sec. 3.127(d)(4) for certain other animals that alternative security

measures may be used without prior approval. However, if the

alternative measures used by the traveling exhibitor are found to be

insufficient during an inspection, the exhibitor will be required to

employ compliant alternative measures.

Several commenters requested clarification regarding the area that

would need to be enclosed by a perimeter fence. As discussed above, the

area or areas where animals are in outdoor housing facilities would

have to be enclosed by one or more fences, unless an exception or

exemption applies.

Several commenters asked if ``outdoor facility'' meant outdoor

activities and stated that the rule should not include outdoor

activities. The regulation is intended to apply to facilities rather

than to the activities that may occur within them (or elsewhere). Thus,

it is not intended that a circus parade, for example, would have to be

enclosed by a fence. However, the occurrence of an activity, such as a

performance or other exhibition within a facility, would not remove the

facility from the requirements of this rule.

One of the commenters asked if ``outdoor facility'' included a

permanent facility. Outdoor facilities can be either temporary or

permanent (traveling facilities have been discussed above).

Exemptions from the Perimeter Fence Requirements

Several commenters asked how an exemption from the perimeter fence

requirements could be granted by the Administrator and whether an

[[Page 56145]]

exemption is one-time only or would be granted on an annual basis. One

commenter asked what occurs in the event that a facility's physical

environment does not allow the placement of a perimeter fence. An

additional commenter asked if an APHIS inspector will make a

recommendation to the Administrator for approval of the exemption.

If a facility wishes to use a perimeter fence that does not meet

the regulatory requirements, including, but not limited to, height

requirements, or if a facility wishes to use alternative security

measures, the facility must obtain written approval from the

Administrator. (As discussed above, traveling facilities may employ

alternative security measures without prior approval.) No particular

method of requesting approval for alternative fencing, natural

barriers, or alternative security measures is required. Requests may be

submitted to the facility's inspector, the regional director for Animal

Care in the area where the facility is located, or the Deputy

Administrator for Animal Care. All information relevant to the request

will be reviewed, including, but not limited to, supporting

documentation submitted by the facility and any relevant information

from the APHIS inspector responsible for the facility. Each evaluation

will take into account the alternative measures proposed, the species

of the animals involved, and any other relevant information. The

licensee or registrant will have to demonstrate that the proposed

alternative measures would accomplish the goals of providing a

secondary containment system for the animals and of preventing unwanted

animals and unauthorized persons from gaining access to the animals.

Because this determination is dependent upon the circumstances of each

case, approval may not be given for a specified period of time but must

be reevaluated if the circumstances change or if experience

demonstrates that the alternative measures are not, in fact, effective.

One commenter expressed concern that supporting documentation,

including security plans, submitted with a request for approval of

alternative fencing or security measures could be subject to disclosure

under the Freedom of Information Act.

APHIS recognizes this concern. However, we do not contemplate that

the request include documentation that, if revealed, would result in

the defeat of the security measures. If a licensee believes that

disclosure would pose a problem, the supporting documentation could be

reviewed on site by the inspector.

Wildlife Reserves

Several commenters stated that facilities, such as wildlife

reserves, that maintain animals on very large tracts of land and that

adequately contain such animals should be exempt from the perimeter

fence requirements. Another commenter asked whether such a facility

would need to install two fences, one as a primary enclosure and one

around the perimeter of its entire acreage. This commenter also asked

whether the naturally occurring wildlife within the facility would have

to be destroyed.

APHIS recognizes the existence of facilities such as wildlife

reserves where small mammals and hoofed animals such as deer may be

adequately confined by a fence rather than cages. APHIS also recognizes

that, in such circumstances, a perimeter fence 3 feet outside the

enclosure fence would add little to the security of the animals'

confinement. Further, animals roaming within a very large tract of land

require little protection from human or animal intruders. Thus, while a

deer caged in a typical zoo needs protection from human and animal

intruders, deer in a wildlife reserve would be able to flee unwanted

contact. As previously noted, this final rule provides alternatives and

exceptions to perimeter fencing requirements, and it should be possible

for facilities that consist of large tracts of land to comply with the

rule without incurring significant additional costs. However, because

the appropriateness of confining animals (other than farm animals)

simply by a fence is highly dependent upon the circumstances, it is

necessary to require that alternative security measures be submitted

and approved.

This rule does not require that naturally occurring wildlife be

eliminated from wildlife reserves. However, each facility is

responsible for the health and safety of the regulated animals

maintained on its premises. Facilities that experience problems as a

result of the naturally occurring wildlife must address such situations

appropriately.

Marine Mammal Enclosures

One commenter questioned why a perimeter fence is only necessary

for the land-side portion of a marine mammal enclosure and not the

waterside portion to prevent the escape of the captive marine mammals.

Two commenters questioned the need for the proposed perimeter fence

requirements for marine mammals. One commenter stated that the proposed

regulations were redundant. The other commenter pointed out that in

Sec. 3.101, paragraph (a)(1) already requires that outdoor facilities

contain the animals and restrict the entrance of unwanted animals, and

paragraph (a)(2) requires that all marine mammals be protected from

abuse and harassment by the viewing public by the use of a sufficient

number of employees or attendants to supervise the viewing public, or

by physical barriers, such as fences, walls, glass partitions, or

distance or both. This commenter also referred to language developed by

the Marine Mammal Negotiated Rulemaking Advisory Committee, which calls

for lagoons and similar natural seawater facilities to maintain

effective barrier fences, or other appropriate measures, on all sides

of the enclosure not contained by dry land. (The proposed rule that

contains the language developed by the Marine Mammal Negotiated

Rulemaking Advisory Committee was published in the Federal Register on

February 23, 1999 (64 FR 8735-8755, Docket No. 93-076-1)).

We gave careful consideration to these issues when we developed the

proposed rule. Based upon all available information, we believe that

the placement of a secondary barrier at natural seawater enclosures

creates unacceptable risks for the marine mammals contained within

them. All natural seawater enclosures for marine mammals, like land-

based enclosures, are required to contain the animals within them. This

includes, among other things, a barrier to prevent escape by contained

animals and access by unwanted animals. We believe that the placement

of a secondary barrier in the water has a higher risk of causing a

marine mammal to become entangled and hurt or drowned. A second barrier

also could impede the water circulation within the primary enclosure

and endanger the health of the marine mammals. The placement of a

perimeter fence around the land portion of a marine mammal facility

will provide protection from the entry of intruders.

One commenter maintained that the terms ``lagoon'' or ``natural

seawater facility'' should replace the term ``sea pen'' to maintain

consistency with the language used in the marine mammal negotiated

rulemaking. This commenter also said that the term ``surrounding land''

needed clarification.

We agree that the terms ``lagoon'' and ``natural seawater

facility'' more accurately reflect current industry terminology.

Therefore, this final rule uses the term lagoons or other natural

[[Page 56146]]

seawater facilities, rather than sea pens. Also, this final rule refers

to ``abutting land'' rather than ``surrounding land'' in reference to

lagoons or other natural seawater facilities that are not surrounded by

land. The perimeter fence is to be placed around this portion of the

land for facilities with lagoons or other natural seawater facilities

and may stop at the shoreline as defined by low tide.

Other Comments

One commenter asked if the perimeter fence had to be constructed of

chain link. The rule does not specify the type of materials with which

the perimeter fence must be constructed. However, the materials must be

adequate to accomplish the purposes of the fence. For example,

Sec. 3.125(a) requires that the facility, which would include the

perimeter fence, ``must be constructed of such material and of such

strength as appropriate for the animals involved.''

Several commenters stated that the rule should include a

``grandfather clause'' so that facilities that do not currently have

perimeter fencing are not required to install perimeter fencing. As

noted above, in order to provide flexibility to licensees and

registrants, the final rule provides alternatives to the use of a

perimeter fence.

One commenter stated that an animal's well-being is not measurable

and that the proposal should be based on measurable standards; however,

the commenter did not provide further information. We acknowledge that

well-being may not be tangibly measurable; however, perimeter fencing

will help prevent animals from being harmed by outside animals or

unauthorized persons, provide protection against exposure to disease,

and reduce the risk of the animals being harmed should they escape

their primary enclosure.

One commenter asked if bison, elk, emu, and ostriches are included

under the rule. The Act covers most warm-blooded species used for

regulated purposes. If elk and bison are maintained for regulated

purposes in outdoor housing facilities, then these facilities would be

subject to the provisions of this rule. However, at this time, birds,

including emu and ostriches, are not covered by the regulations.

One commenter stated that phrases such as ``potentially dangerous

animals'' and ``natural barrier'' were too broad or vague and needed

clarification. This commenter also asked what we considered a public

zoo. We do not believe that an exhaustive list of every potentially

dangerous animal would be helpful. We believe that the examples given

in the rule will be more helpful. We also believe that the meaning of

the term ``natural barrier'' is clear. As previously noted, this final

rule uses the term ``effective natural barrier'' rather than the term

``impenetrable natural barrier.'' Our use of the term ``public zoo''

was intended to refer to the common use of the term to indicate a zoo

that is open to the public.

Therefore, for the reasons given in the proposed rule and in this

final rule, we are adopting the proposed rule as a final rule, with the

changes discussed above, and with other nonsubstantive changes for

clarity.

Executive Order 12866 and Regulatory Flexibility Act

This final rule has been reviewed under Executive Order 12866. The

rule has been determined to be not significant for the purposes of

Executive Order 12866 and, therefore, has not been reviewed by the

Office of Management and Budget.

This final rule will amend the Animal Welfare regulations by

requiring that a perimeter fence be placed around outdoor housing

facilities for marine mammals and certain other regulated animals.

Class A and B dealers, Class C exhibitors, registered exhibitors,

and research facilities are the entities that will be affected by the

perimeter fence requirement. Class A dealers breed and raise animals to

sell for research, teaching, or exhibition; Class B dealers include

brokers and operators of auctions sales for animals; and Class C

licensees and registered exhibitors include exhibitors such as animal

acts, carnivals, circuses, and zoos. Research facilities include

schools, institutions, organizations, or persons who use live animals

in research, tests, or experiments.

There are about 4,000 licensed dealers, 2,200 regulated exhibitors,

and 1,300 registered research facilities. However, the vast majority of

the licensed dealers are involved only with dogs and cats and would not

be affected by this rule. Likewise, the vast majority of research

facilities do not use marine mammals or ``animals other than dogs,

cats, rabbits, hamsters, guinea pigs, nonhuman primates, and marine

mammals.'' Further, most of the research facilities that do hold

animals subject to this final rule would hold farm animals, for which

this rule imposes only minimal burdens. According to the Small Business

Administration (SBA) size standards, more than 50 percent of zoos are

considered large businesses. Although more than 50 percent of the zoos

are considered large businesses, most exhibitors would be considered

small businesses. Most dealers in ``exotic animals'' are also small

businesses.

This final rule has been modified in several respects in response

to the comments in order to reduce the burdens on small businesses.

Also, this rule provides that perimeter fences will not be required

until 6 months after the effective date of this rule in order to give

small entities additional time to comply.

We received several comments regarding the regulatory flexibility

analysis. These comments are discussed below.

One commenter requested clarification regarding the relationship

between wildlife and the Small Business Administration.

We assume that this commenter is referring to the Regulatory

Flexibility Act section of the proposed rule where we referenced the

SBA size standards of zoos. All regulatory actions must be evaluated

under the Regulatory Flexibility Act for their effect on small

entities.

Several commenters stated that the estimated cost of compliance

that we provided in the regulatory flexibility analysis was too low and

that installing a perimeter fence would be more burdensome and costly

than the analysis showed. These commenters stated that the proposal did

not consider physical limitations of a site or the costs for labor,

posts, rails, gates, and excavations.

These comments have been carefully considered, and the final rule

places a greater emphasis on alternative measures. However, based on

the comments we received, we realize that our estimate of the cost of

fencing in the proposal was too low. Based on current prices for fence

material only, a 6-foot-high, commercial-quality fence would cost

approximately $2 per linear foot, and an 8-foot-high, commercial-

quality fence would cost approximately $3 per linear foot. For typical

commercial installation, the cost would be about $10 to $15 per linear

foot for a 6-foot-high chain link fence and about $14 to $18 per linear

foot for an 8-foot-high chain link fence. (This would include fencing

hardware and installation.) However, we expect that most affected

entities would install the fencing themselves.

Another commenter expressed concern regarding the economic impact

on small entities. The commenter maintained that small entities would

be negatively affected. We believe that the burdens imposed by this

final rule are both minimal and necessary. Many of the small entities

affected by the rule would be traveling exhibitors. As

[[Page 56147]]

discussed above, we have provided great flexibility for traveling

exhibitions.

One commenter requested the number of large and small entities that

would be affected by this rule.

We recognize that this rule will affect each facility, regardless

of size, to a different degree. We believe that only 10 percent of

licensed dealers will be affected by this rule because the remaining 90

percent breed or trade animals, such as dogs and cats, that are not

subject to this final rule. Most of the dealers who would be subject to

the rule already have a perimeter fence or other measures that would be

satisfactory.

In addition, most research facilities will be unaffected by this

rule because they do not use outdoor housing facilities. In fact, we

estimate that greater than 90 percent of research facilities are solely

indoor facilities. Further, the vast majority of research facilities

that use animals subject to this rule would be using farm animals for

which only minimal burdens are imposed by this rule.

Several commenters stated that the cost of a perimeter fence could

be quite high. We have taken the cost of perimeter fencing under

careful consideration. This final rule provides for alternatives to

perimeter fencing that minimize costs to affected facilities.

Under these circumstances, the Administrator of the Animal and

Plant Health Inspection Service has determined that this action will

not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small

entities.

Executive Order 12372

This program/activity is listed in the Catalog of Federal Domestic

Assistance under No. 10.025 and is subject to Executive Order 12372,

which requires intergovernmental consultation with State and local

officials. (See 7 CFR part 3015, subpart V.)

Executive Order 12988

This final rule has been reviewed under Executive Order 12988,

Civil Justice Reform. It is not intended to have retroactive effect.

This rule will not preempt any State or local laws, regulations, or

policies, unless they present an irreconcilable conflict with this

rule. The Act does not provide administrative procedures which must be

exhausted prior to a judicial challenge to the provisions of this rule.

Paperwork Reduction Act

One commenter disagreed with the estimated burden of information

collection. The commenter stated that we underestimated the burden

because some respondents may require approval for alternatives to the

use of perimeter fencing for more than one outdoor facility.

Our estimated burden was based on a facility submitting one request

for approval of alternative fencing or alternative security measures.

If a facility has multiple sites that are geographically separated and

wishes to request approval for alternatives to the use of perimeter

fencing for each site, it may be necessary to submit more than one

request. However, we believe this scenario would be unusual, and that

the estimated burden is accurate. In fact, the burden should be

somewhat less than estimated in the proposed rule because of the

provisions for exemptions and other changes in this final rule.

In accordance with section 3507(d) of the Paperwork Reduction Act

of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.), the information collection or

recordkeeping requirements included in this final rule have been

approved by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). The assigned OMB

control number is 0579-0093.

List of Subjects in 9 CFR Part 3

Animal welfare, Marine mammals, Pets, Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements, Research, Transportation.

Accordingly, we are amending 9 CFR part 3 as follows:

PART 3--STANDARDS

1. The authority citation for part 3 continues to read as follows:

Authority: 7 U.S.C. 2131-2159; 7 CFR 2.22, 2.80, and 371.2(d).

2. Section 3.103 is amended by adding a new paragraph (c) to read

as follows:

Sec. 3.103 Facilities, outdoor.

* * * * *

(c) Perimeter fence. On and after May 17, 2000, all outdoor housing

facilities (i.e., facilities not entirely indoors) must be enclosed by

a perimeter fence that is of sufficient height to keep animals and

unauthorized persons out. Fences less than 8 feet high for polar bears

or less than 6 feet high for other marine mammals must be approved in

writing by the Administrator. The fence must be constructed so that it

protects marine mammals by restricting animals and unauthorized persons

from going through it or under it and having contact with the marine

mammals, and so that it can function as a secondary containment system

for the animals in the facility when appropriate. The fence must be of

sufficient distance from the outside of the primary enclosure to

prevent physical contact between animals inside the enclosure and

animals or persons outside the perimeter fence. Such fences less than 3

feet in distance from the primary enclosure must be approved in writing

by the Administrator. For natural seawater facilities, such as lagoons,

the perimeter fence must prevent access by animals and unauthorized

persons to the natural seawater facility from the abutting land, and

must encompass the land portion of the facility from one end of the

natural seawater facility shoreline as defined by low tide to the other

end of the natural seawater facility shoreline defined by low tide. A

perimeter fence is not required:

(1) Where the outside walls of the primary enclosure are made of

sturdy, durable material, which may include certain types of concrete,

wood, plastic, metal, or glass, and are high enough and constructed in

a manner that restricts entry by animals and unauthorized persons and

the Administrator gives written approval; or

(2) Where the outdoor housing facility is protected by an effective

natural barrier that restricts the marine mammals to the facility and

restricts entry by animals and unauthorized persons and the

Administrator gives written approval; or

(3) Where appropriate alternative security measures are employed

and the Administrator gives written approval; or

(4) For traveling facilities where appropriate alternative security

measures are employed.

3. Section 3.127 is amended by adding a new paragraph (d) to read

as follows:

Sec. 3.127 Facilities, outdoor.

* * * * *

(d) Perimeter fence. On or after May 17, 2000, all outdoor housing

facilities (i.e., facilities not entirely indoors) must be enclosed by

a perimeter fence that is of sufficient height to keep animals and

unauthorized persons out. Fences less than 8 feet high for potentially

dangerous animals, such as, but not limited to, large felines (e.g.,

lions, tigers, leopards, cougars, bobcats, etc.), bears, wolves,

rhinoceros, and elephants, or less than 6 feet high for other animals

must be approved in writing by the Administrator. The fence must be

constructed so that it protects the animals in the facility by

restricting animals and unauthorized persons from going through it or

under it and having contact with the animals in the facility, and so

that it can function as a secondary containment system for the animals

in the facility. It must be of sufficient distance from the outside of

the primary enclosure to prevent

[[Page 56148]]

physical contact between animals inside the enclosure and animals or

persons outside the perimeter fence. Such fences less than 3 feet in

distance from the primary enclosure must be approved in writing by the

Administrator. A perimeter fence is not required:

(1) Where the outside walls of the primary enclosure are made of

sturdy, durable material, which may include certain types of concrete,

wood, plastic, metal, or glass, and are high enough and constructed in

a manner that restricts entry by animals and unauthorized persons and

the Administrator gives written approval; or

(2) Where the outdoor housing facility is protected by an effective

natural barrier that restricts the animals to the facility and

restricts entry by animals and unauthorized persons and the

Administrator gives written approval; or

(3) Where appropriate alternative security measures are employed

and the Administrator gives written approval; or

(4) For traveling facilities where appropriate alternative security

measures are employed; or

(5) Where the outdoor housing facility houses only farm animals,

such as, but not limited to, cows, sheep, goats, pigs, horses (for

regulated purposes), or donkeys, and the facility has in place

effective and customary containment and security measures.

Done in Washington, DC, this 8th day of October 1999.

Craig A. Reed,

Administrator, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service.

[FR Doc. 99-27135 Filed 10-15-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3410-34-U

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.