Northeast Nuclear Energy Company, et al.; Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Unit Nos. 2 and 3; Issuance of Final Director's Decision Under 10 CFR 2.206

Federal RegisterOct 4, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

[Docket Nos. 50-336 and 50-423]

Northeast Nuclear Energy Company, et al.; Millstone Nuclear Power

Station, Unit Nos. 2 and 3; Issuance of Final Director's Decision Under

10 CFR 2.206

Notice is hereby given that the Director of the Office of Nuclear

Reactor Regulation, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), has

issued a Final Director's Decision with regard to two related

Petitions, both dated April 14, 1999, submitted by Mr. Scott Cullen, on

behalf of Standing for Truth About Radiation, the Nuclear Information

Resource Service, New York State Senator Ken LaValle, and New York

State Assembly members Fred Thiele and Patricia Acampora (the

Petitioners), requesting action under Title 10 of the Code of Federal

Regulations, Section 2.206 (10 CFR 2.206). The Petitions pertain to the

Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Unit Nos. 2 and 3, operated by

Northeast Nuclear Energy Company (NNECO, or the licensee).

In the first Petition, the Petitioners requested that (1) the NRC

immediately suspend NNECO's licenses to operate the Millstone Nuclear

Power Station until there are reasonable assurances that adequate

protective measures for Fishers Island, New York, can and will be taken

in the event of a radiological emergency at Millstone, (2) the

operating licenses should be suspended until such time as ``a range of

protective actions have been developed for the plume exposure pathway

EPZ [emergency planning zone] for emergency workers and the public'',

and (3) these matters be the subject of a public hearing, with full

opportunity for public comment. The basis for the Petitioners' requests

is that the Millstone Nuclear Power Station is not in full compliance

with the law. Specifically, the Petitioners contend that the site is in

violation of 10 CFR 50.54(q) and 10 CFR 50.47 with regard to emergency

planning requirements because Fishers Island, New York, which is

located within the 10-mile EPZ for Millstone, has no functional

emergency plan.

In the second Petition, the Petitioners requested that the NRC

institute a proceeding, pursuant to 10 CFR 2.202, to suspend the

operating licenses for the Millstone Nuclear Power Station until the

facility is in full compliance with the law. Specifically, the

Petitioners maintain that all of the regulatory listed factors, that

is, ``demography, topography, land characteristics, access routes, and

jurisdictional boundaries,'' were ignored in establishing the 10-mile

plume exposure pathway EPZ (10-mile EPZ) for emergency planning at the

Millstone Nuclear Power Station and, as such, constitute a violation of

10 CFR 50.54(q) and 10 CFR 50.47.

By letter dated May 14, 1999, the NRC informed the Petitioners that

their request for the immediate suspension of the operating licenses

for the Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Unit Nos. 2 and 3 (first

Petition, Request 1), was denied. In that letter, the NRC also informed

the Petitioners that their request for an informal public hearing

(first Petition, Request 3) was denied. The NRC also told the

Petitioners in the May 14, 1999, letter that their request, in the

second Petition, to initiate a proceeding pursuant to 10 CFR 2.202 to

suspend the operating licenses for Millstone did not satisfy the

criteria for consideration as a 10 CFR 2.206 Petition. The reasons for

these decisions were explained in the May 14, 1999, letter and in the

``Final Director's Decision Pursuant to 10 CFR 2.206'' (DD-99-12).

As noted in the May 14, 1999, letter, the NRC stated that the areas

identified in the Petitions related to the adequacy of evacuation and

protective measures planning for Fishers Island, New York, would be

evaluated within a reasonable time. The staff has completed its review

of this area with the assistance of the Federal Emergency Management

Agency. For the reasons given in the Final Director's Decision, DD-99-

12, dated September 28, 1999, Request 2 of the first Petition is

denied.

Additional information is contained in the ``Final Director's

Decision Pursuant to 10 CFR 2.206'' (DD-99-12), the complete text of

which follows this notice and which is available for public inspection

at the Commission's Public Document Room, the Gelman Building, 2120 L

Street, NW., Washington, DC, and at the local public document rooms

located at the Learning Resources Center, Three Rivers Community-

Technical College, 574 New London Turnpike, Norwich, Connecticut, and

at the Waterford Library, 49 Rope Ferry Road, Waterford, Connecticut.

As provided in 10 CFR 2.206(c), a copy of this Final Director's

Decision will be filed with the Secretary of the

[[Page 53753]]

Commission for the Commission's review. This Final Director's Decision

will constitute the final action of the Commission 25 days after its

issuance, unless the Commission, on its own motion, institutes review

of the Decision within that time.

Dated at Rockville, Maryland, this 28th day of September 1999.

For the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

Samuel J. Collins,

Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.

Final Director's Decision Pursuant to 10 CFR 2.206

I. Introduction

By letter dated April 14, 1999, Mr. Scott Cullen, on behalf of

Standing for Truth About Radiation (STAR), the Nuclear Information

Resource Service (NIRS), New York State Senator Ken LaValle, and New

York State Assembly members Fred Thiele and Patricia Acampora (the

Petitioners) submitted two separate but related Petitions pursuant to

Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Sec. 2.206 (10 CFR 2.206).

In the first Petition, the Petitioners requested that (1) the U.S.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) immediately suspend Northeast

Nuclear Energy Company's (NNECO's) licenses to operate the Millstone

Nuclear Power Station until there are reasonable assurances that

adequate protective measures for Fishers Island, New York, can and will

be taken in the event of a radiological emergency at Millstone; (2) the

operating licenses should be suspended until such time as ``a range of

protective actions have been developed for the plume exposure pathway

EPZ [emergency planning zone] for emergency workers and the public'';

and (3) these matters be the subject of a public hearing, with full

opportunity for public comment. The basis for the Petitioners' requests

is that the Millstone Nuclear Power Station is not in full compliance

with the law. Specifically, the Petitioners contend that the site is in

violation of 10 CFR 50.54(q) and 10 CFR 50.47 with regard to emergency

planning requirements because Fishers Island, New York, which is

located within the 10-mile EPZ for Millstone, has no functional

emergency plan.

In the second Petition, the Petitioners requested that the NRC

institute a proceeding, pursuant to 10 CFR 2.202, to suspend the

operating licenses for the Millstone Nuclear Power Station until the

facility is in full compliance with the law. Specifically, the

Petitioners maintain that there are no mechanisms by which the

conditional factors of demography, topography, land characteristics,

access routes, and jurisdictional boundaries can be evaluated,

resulting in a complete lack of reasonable assurances that adequate

protective measures can and will be taken on Long Island in the event

of an accident at Millstone. The Petitioners' contend that this

constitutes a violation of 10 CFR 50.54(q) and 10 CFR 50.47.

The NRC informed the Petitioners in a letter to Mr. Cullen dated

May 14, 1999, that their request for immediate suspension of the

operating licenses for the Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Unit Nos. 2

and 3 (first Petition, Request 1), was denied. The denial was based on

the NRC's finding about the current state of emergency preparedness at

Millstone. The Federal agency with lead responsibility for assessing

the emergency preparedness of State and local governments within the

EPZs surrounding nuclear power plants is the Federal Emergency

Management Agency (FEMA). FEMA's responsibilities are defined in NRC's

and FEMA's regulations (10 CFR Part 50 and 44 CFR Part 350,

respectively) and in a memorandum of understanding between the two

agencies (58 FR 47996, September 14, 1993). The NRC evaluates onsite

emergency planning and reviews FEMA's evaluation of offsite emergency

preparedness for the purpose of making findings on the overall state of

emergency preparedness. As stated in 10 CFR 50.54(s)(3):

The NRC will base its finding on a review of the FEMA findings

and determinations as to whether State and local emergency plans are

adequate and capable of being implemented, and on the NRC assessment

as to whether the licensee's emergency plans are adequate and

capable of being implemented.

FEMA has reviewed the State of Connecticut's emergency plan. FEMA

has also reviewed the plans for the nine local communities within the

Millstone plume exposure pathway EPZ, including Fishers Island, New

York. Further, FEMA has evaluated several exercises of these plans.

FEMA originally provided its findings and determinations to the NRC in

October 1984 on the adequacy of offsite planning for Millstone, in

accordance with 44 CFR Part 350 of its regulations. Following the

latest exercise, FEMA confirmed that the offsite radiological emergency

response plans and procedures for the State of Connecticut and the

affected local jurisdictions, including Fishers Island, New York,

specific to the Millstone Nuclear Power Station, can be implemented and

are adequate to provide reasonable assurance that appropriate measures

can be taken to protect the health and safety of the public in the

event of a radiological emergency at Millstone. This was documented in

a December 29, 1997, letter from FEMA to the NRC. The letter forwarded

FEMA's report for the August 21, 1997, full-participation plume pathway

and the October 8-10, 1997, ingestion pathway exercises of the offsite

radiological emergency plans for Millstone. Regarding Fishers Island,

no deficiencies or areas requiring corrective action were identified in

the exercises.

Further, the NRC has found that the licensee's emergency plans are

an adequate basis for an acceptable state of onsite emergency

preparedness in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR 50.47(b) and

Appendix E to 10 CFR Part 50 as documented in the NRC's letter to the

licensee dated June 4, 1998.

In the first Petition, the Petitioners raised a concern about the

evacuation of Fishers Island residents to New London, Connecticut, a

direction closer to the site and to an area that may have already been

affected by a radiological emergency at Millstone. Fishers Island is

located about 7\1/2\ miles east/southeast of Millstone. The New London

port is located about 5 miles northeast of Millstone. As stated in the

NRC's May 14, 1999, letter to the Petitioners, the NRC found no prima

facie evidence in the information submitted by the Petitioners that the

protective action of evacuation to New London will not provide an

adequate level of protection to the public. Further, the Petitioners

did not submit any other information that would raise an immediate

concern with the NRC's finding regarding the adequacy of emergency

planning for Millstone. On the basis of a review of FEMA's findings and

determinations on the adequacy of offsite emergency preparedness and on

the NRC's assessment of the adequacy of onsite emergency preparedness,

the NRC determined that (1) there was reasonable assurance that

adequate protective measures can and will be taken in the event of a

radiological emergency and (2) there was insufficient evidence to grant

the Petitioners' request to immediately suspend the operating licenses

for Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Unit Nos. 2 and 3.

The Petitioners were also told in the May 14, 1999, acknowledgment

letter that their request for an informal public hearing (first

Petition, Request 3) was denied. The denial was based on the NRC's

finding about the current state of emergency preparedness at Millstone.

Specifically, the denial was based on the NRC staff's determination

that the information provided in the Petitions did not identify

deficiencies in offsite

[[Page 53754]]

emergency preparedness that would preclude the implementation of

adequate protective measures for the public in the event of a

radiological emergency at Millstone. Further, the NRC staff determined

that the issues did not rise to the level of significance that

justified conducting an informal hearing on the Petitions.

The Petitioners were told, however, that their Petition did raise

the potential that enhancements could be made to emergency planning for

Millstone that could improve the protection of public health and

safety. Further, the May 14, 1999, acknowledgment letter indicated that

the areas identified in the Petitions related to the adequacy of

evacuation and protective measures planning for Fishers Island would be

evaluated within a reasonable time. Since FEMA has the primary

responsibility for evaluating the emergency preparedness of State and

local governments, the NRC requested the assistance of FEMA, in a

letter dated June 4, 1999, in evaluating the potential enhancements

identified in the Petitions.

The NRC also told the Petitioners in the May 14, 1999, letter that

the request in their second Petition to initiate a proceeding, pursuant

to 10 CFR 2.202, to suspend the operating licenses for Millstone did

not satisfy the criteria for consideration as a 10 CFR 2.206 Petition.

Specifically, the NRC concluded that the referenced factors regarding

the determination of the 10-mile plume exposure pathway EPZ were

properly taken into account. The NRC determined that the second

Petition request did not contain sufficient information to warrant

further action by the NRC to require that the 10-mile EPZ be expanded

to include the eastern end of Long Island, New York.

II. Discussion

The Commission's regulations in 10 CFR 50.54(q) and (s) governing

emergency planning for operating nuclear power plants require the

submittal and implementation of licensee (onsite) and State and local

government (offsite) emergency plans that conform to the emergency

planning standards in 10 CFR 50.47(b) and the requirements in Appendix

E to 10 CFR Part 50. FEMA is the Federal agency with the lead

responsibility for evaluating offsite radiological emergency response

plans and preparedness.

Fishers Island, New York, is located within the 10-mile plume

exposure pathway EPZ for the Millstone Nuclear Power Station and is

included in the State of Connecticut's Radiological Emergency Response

Plan for Millstone. This plan has been approved by FEMA in accordance

with 44 CFR Part 350 of its regulations. The Connecticut emergency plan

(Revision 1, dated July 1997) contains the following information

regarding Fishers Island:

Fishers Island, located about 7\1/2\ miles east/southeast of

Millstone, is primarily residential with a small year-round

population of about 300 persons and a summer population estimated to

be approximately 3000 persons. On the Independence Day (July 4)

weekend, this transient population may peak at approximately 5000

persons. Fishers Island is a Hamlet, [a] political subdivision of

the Town of Southold, New York, which is in Suffolk County on Long

Island.

Because of the logistics associated with the island's location,

there has been a long-standing operational agreement between

officials of Fishers Island, the Town of Southold, Suffolk County,

the State of New York, and the State of Connecticut. Under this

agreement, the lead responsibility for assessing the initial

radiological impact of an incident on Fishers Island, and providing

assistance with the implementation of any protective actions,

belongs to the State of Connecticut. Officials of Fishers Island and

the Town of Southold, however, have the authority to implement

public protective actions.

The State of New York coordinates the assessment process and

resulting protective action recommendations made by the State of

Connecticut for Fishers Island, maintains communications with

Suffolk County, and provides support to Suffolk County and Fishers

Island, as necessary. The Town of Southold, as well as Suffolk

County, provides back-up communication capabilities and support, and

would lend additional emergency services to the island, if

requested.

The State of Connecticut offers resource support to Fishers

Island in the area of protective actions. Emergency Alerting System

(EAS) announcements for Fishers Island will be made over the

Connecticut Emergency Alerting System. The island relies on the

nearby Town of Groton, Connecticut, for back-up activation of the

public alerting system. Fishers Island residents are designated to

go to the host community of Windham[, Connecticut].

On September 2, 1999, FEMA responded to the NRC's request for

assistance, including a report prepared by the Regional Assistance

Committee (RAC) Chair of FEMA Region I, the FEMA region in which

Millstone is located. The RAC Chair is the leading staff technical

person with radiological emergency preparedness responsibilities in

each FEMA region. FEMA stated that they performed a thorough review and

assessment of the emergency evacuation planning for Fishers Island, New

York. FEMA noted that Fishers Island is included in the State of

Connecticut's approved radiological emergency response plan and that

the Fishers Island plan has been tested several times since it was

approved, most recently during the August 1997 exercise of the State of

Connecticut's plans for Millstone.

FEMA's report stated that in the unlikely event of a nuclear

incident at Millstone, the residents of Fishers Island would be

directed to shelter in place or to evacuate. If directed to evacuate,

the Fishers Island evacuees would be moved by ferry to New London, then

transported by bus to the host community in Windham, Connecticut. New

London was chosen as the ferry's destination because the Fishers Island

Ferry District, which would provide service in the event of an

evacuation, is based on Fishers Island and normal everyday traffic

travels between New London and Fishers Island. Should an incident at

Millstone require the evacuation of Fishers Island, residents would

evacuate the island using the regular ferry service, and would be

transported to the host community in Windham, Connecticut, by way of

the Port of New London. Should New London not be available to the

Fisher Island evacuees (i.e., if radiological conditions have resulted

in its evacuation), then the Connecticut Emergency Management Director

and the State of New York Emergency Management Office would jointly

choose to direct the ferry to another port, such as Stonington,

Connecticut, located northeast of Fishers Island and east of New

London. FEMA's report noted that the protective actions of sheltering

and evacuation are the same two protective actions that appear in all

other Connecticut emergency response plans.

With regard to the Petitioners' specific concern about the August

8, 1997, Millstone exercise, FEMA's report stated that the postulated

condition of the Millstone plant during the exercise was such that the

Governor of Connecticut ordered residents in all EPZ communities to

evacuate. With the postulated conditions, the protective action for

Fishers Island was to evacuate through New London. The Petitioners were

concerned that this was a direction that brought the evacuees closer to

the plant. FEMA indicated that the Fishers Island evacuees would not

have been at risk during the conduct of this protective action because

the plume, had it been real, was traveling in a westerly direction,

away from New London, according to the exercise scenario. As such,

during this scenario, the evacuees could pass through New London

without the threat of exposure to radiation. As discussed previously,

should New London not be available

[[Page 53755]]

(for example, the plume has passed over New London and adverse

radiological conditions exist), the ferry would be directed to another

port.

FEMA's report indicates that certain enhancements to the Fishers

Island plan are being considered and its September 2, 1999, report

summarized some of the ongoing emergency planning activities. In July

1998, Northeast Utilities (the licensee), the Connecticut Office of

Emergency Management, and FEMA Regions I and II, participated in a

demonstration of a ferry run from Fishers Island to Stonington,

Connecticut. The objective of this demonstration was to determine the

feasibility of having the ferry pick up people from Fishers Island and

take them to Stonington, which is located about 7 miles northeast of

Fishers Island. The plan and preparations for adding the Port of

Stonington, Connecticut, as a receiving port for Fishers Island

evacuees is projected to be completed by the end of 1999. Windham,

Connecticut, will continue to be used as the host community for Fishers

Island residents. FEMA will review changes to the offsite emergency

plans to ensure that the plans are adequate and capable of being

implemented.

FEMA's report stated that an agreement exists between the

Connecticut Office of Emergency Management and the Fishers Island Ferry

District for the exclusive use of their ferries in the event of an

incident at Millstone. Further, FEMA indicated that negotiations are in

progress for an agreement between the Connecticut Office of Emergency

Management and the Cross Sound Ferry Company for the use of five of

their ferries in the event of an emergency at Millstone.

FEMA's report also noted that in September 1998, a meeting between

Connecticut and New York State emergency management agencies was held

in Hartford, Connecticut, to discuss offsite emergency preparedness for

Millstone and the degree of coordination and communications. At the

meeting were representatives of the Connecticut Office of Emergency

Management, the New York State Emergency Management Office, Northeast

Utilities, FEMA, and the NRC. Further, in October 1998, the Connecticut

Office of Emergency Management and the New York State Emergency

Management Office met to discuss other ways of improving communications

in making appropriate protective action decisions for Fishers Island.

On June 22, 1999, the Connecticut Office of Emergency Management

held its quarterly emergency management director's meeting on Fishers

Island to discuss emergency response issues concerning Millstone. The

emergency management directors from the Millstone EPZ communities

attended this meeting, including those from Fishers Island, the Town of

Southold, New London, Stonington, and the host community of Windham,

Connecticut. This meeting gave these key emergency management directors

an opportunity to communicate directly.

In its September 2, 1999, letter to the NRC, FEMA stated that on

the basis of its assessment of emergency planning for the Millstone

Nuclear Power Station, there is continued reasonable assurance that

adequate protective measures can be taken to protect the public health

and safety in the event of a radiological emergency at Millstone.

III. Conclusion

After reviewing FEMA's findings and determinations on the adequacy

of offsite emergency preparedness and the NRC's assessment of onsite

emergency preparedness, the NRC has determined that there is continued

reasonable assurance that adequate protective measures can and will be

taken in the event of a radiological emergency at Millstone. In

addition, based on FEMA's findings on the adequacy of emergency

preparedness for Fishers Island, the NRC concludes that the Fishers

Island emergency plan is adequate and there is reasonable assurance

that it can be implemented. Further, the NRC recognizes that potential

enhancements are being implemented to improve the protection of the

health and safety of the population on Fishers Island. As a result of

these findings by FEMA and the NRC, the NRC has determined that the

Petitioner's request to suspend the operating licenses for Millstone

Unit Nos. 2 and 3 until a range of protective actions are developed for

the 10-mile EPZ (first Petition, Request 2) is denied.

A Copy of this Final Director's Decision will be placed in the

Commission's Public Document Room, the Gelman Building, 2120 L Street,

NW., Washington, DC, and at the local public document rooms located at

the Learning Resources Center, Three Rivers Community-Technical

College, 574 New London Turnpike, Norwich, Connecticut, and at the

Waterford Library, 49 Rope Ferry Road, Waterford, Connecticut.

As provided in 10 CFR 2.206(c), a copy of this Final Director's

Decision will be filed with the Secretary of the Commission for the

Commission's review. This Final Director's Decision will constitute the

final action of the Commission 25 days after its issuance, unless the

Commission, on its own motion, institutes review of the Decision within

that time.

Dated at Rockville, Maryland, this 28th day of September 1999.

For the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

Samuel J. Collins,

Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.

[FR Doc. 99-25716 Filed 10-1-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 7590-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.