Medicare Program; Telephone Requests for Review of Part B Initial Claim Determinations

Federal RegisterSep 30, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES

Health Care Financing Administration

42 CFR Part 405

[HCFA-4121-FC]

RIN 0938-AG48

Medicare Program; Telephone Requests for Review of Part B Initial

Claim Determinations

AGENCY: Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA), HHS.

ACTION: Final rule with comment period.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Currently, our regulations allow beneficiaries, providers, and

suppliers (defined as physicians or other practitioners, or entities

other than a provider), who are entitled to appeal Medicare Part B

initial claim determinations, to request a review of the carrier's

initial determination in writing. This final rule allows those review

requests to be made by telephone and allows the carrier to conduct the

review by telephone, if possible. The use of telephone requests

supplements, and does not replace, the current written procedures for

initiating appeals. This telephone option also improves carrier

relationships with the beneficiary, provider, and supplier communities

by providing quick and easy access to the appeals process. Carriers

will make accommodations to enable a hearing impaired individual access

to the telephone review process.

EFFECTIVE DATE: These regulations are effective on February 1, 2000.

Comment date: Comments will be considered if we receive them at the

appropriate address, as provided below, no later than 5 p.m. on

November 29, 1999.

ADDRESSES: Mail an original and 3 copies of written comments to the

following address: Health Care Financing Administration, Department of

Health and Human Services, Attention: HCFA-4121-FC, P.O. Box 9013,

Baltimore, MD 21244-9013.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Rosalind Little, (410) 786-6972.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

Under current Medicare regulations at 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart H, a

party (a person enrolled under Part B of Medicare, his or her assignee,

or other entity having standing to appeal the determination in

question), that indicates dissatisfaction with a Part B initial claim

determination by a carrier, is entitled to have a carrier review

conducted in accordance with regulations set forth in Sec. 405.807

(Review of initial determination) and section 12010 of the Medicare

Carriers Manual (MCM). However, if the appellant is not a proper party

or the request for appeal review is not filed timely, the appellant's

request may be dismissed.

Currently, a request for the carrier review of an initial claim

determination is to be made in writing and filed with us, at an office

of the carrier, or at an office of the Social Security Administration

(SSA). The carrier must provide a period of 6 months after the date of

the notice of its initial determination within which a party may

request review. The carrier may, upon request by the party affected,

extend the period for requesting the review.

On July 10, 1995, we published a proposed rule in the Federal

Register (60 FR 35544) that would change the Medicare regulations to

allow a party to request the carrier review of its Part B initial claim

determination by telephone or by electronic transmission, in addition

to the current provisions for a written request.

II. Provisions of the Proposed Rulemaking

In the proposed rule, we stated that the reason for allowing

parties to request the review of a carrier's initial claim

determination by telephone or electronic transmission, in addition to

submitting written requests, was that we recognized that both

physicians and beneficiaries often call the carrier to dispute a

determination, to ask for clarification, or to protest a denial. We

also recognized that the current review process requiring a party to

submit a written request for a review can take considerable time and

effort. This is because at times it can be difficult to properly

explain a problem or ask a question in writing. In addition, a written

request provides no opportunity for the dialogue that allows parties to

discuss the issues and provide detailed explanations.

The proposed rule stated that telephone or electronic requests for

review of Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and Peer Review

Organizations (PROs) Part B initial determinations must be made in

writing. This rule does not apply to HMO and PRO appeal determinations.

A party can initiate an appeal of a determination by an HMO under 42

CFR 417.616 and a determination by a PRO under 42 CFR 473.18(a).

The July 10, 1995 rule proposed to limit electronic requests for

review to those entities that electronically bill

[[Page 52666]]

their claims to a carrier system that has the capability to receive

claims electronically and, therefore, would also be able to receive

electronic requests for review.

We also proposed to change the current appeal period of 6 months to

180 days and to further provide a 150-day appeal period for telephone

requests for review within that 180-day period. We made this proposal

to allow an additional 30 days for the appellant to submit a written

request for review in the event they were unable to reach the carrier

by telephone.

The proposed rule also gave an overview of how we expected the

telephone and electronic process to work.

III. Analysis of and Responses to Public Comments

In response to the July 10, 1995 proposed rule, we received 14

timely items of correspondence. The majority of the commenters

supported our efforts to improve and expedite the review and appeals

process. Six of the 14 comments received concerned, in part, the

electronic request aspects of the proposed regulation. Since issuing

the proposed rule, we have determined that technical circumstances

beyond our control will not permit us to offer the option of

electronically requesting reviews of initial claims determinations, and

we are, therefore, withdrawing that provision of the proposed rule. In

the future, however, we may consider offering providers, physicians,

and suppliers the option of requesting a review of their intitial

determnation electronically. In order to offer this option we would

need to obtain an approved appeals data set from the ANSI X12 Committee

which then would need to be adopted by the DHHS as a HIPAA data

sandard. We are soliciting comments on the feasibility and benefit of

providing this option. We would also like to know any cost you believe

you would incur to use this option.

We are not responding in detail to specific comments relating to

the electronic requests. However, we provide the following overview of

those comments and our general response. Two commenters specifically

supported our desire to offer this option. One commenter suggested that

we should wait until the Medicare Transaction System comes online

before making this option available. As noted, we are not offering this

option due to technical circumstances beyond our control. There were

three technical comments. One comment concerned the cost of processing

electronic requests. The second comment concerned protecting the

privacy of the beneficiary. The third comment concerned the complexity

of handling non-assigned claims electronically.

With respect to the first comment, since we proposed to offer that

option only to those providers that bill electronically and only where

the carriers could receive and process claims electronically, there

would have been no additional costs to the supplier, provider, or

carrier. With respect to the second comment, we would protect the

privacy of the beneficiary by maintaining the requirement to have

either a letter signed by the beneficiary naming a representative, or

an Appointment of Representative form signed by the beneficiary to be

received by the carrier before any information could be released to

someone other than that beneficiary. Finally, the same document used to

verify assignment would have been required to be delivered to the

carrier by courier, by mail, or by facsimile before any non-assigned

claim would have been processed and before any Medicare payment would

have been released.

The following is a summary of those comments received pertaining to

telephone requests for reviews of initial claims determinations and our

response.

Comment: One commenter questioned whether the rule included the

Part B review process for Part A intermediaries.

Response: Yes, it does. For the purposes of 42 CFR part 405,

Subpart H, the term ``carrier'' also refers to an ``intermediary'' that

has entered into a contract with the Secretary under section 1816 of

the Social Security Act (the Act) and is authorized to make

determinations with respect to Part B provider or supplier services.

Comment: One commenter stated that currently HCFA determines the

timeliness of filing a request for a Part B review by the postmark on

the envelope of the written request and asked if timeliness of filing

requests by telephone would be determined by a telephone log.

Response: Carriers may record requests for reviews received by

telephone either in a manual log or in a computer database. The record

will show the date of the incoming request and other pertinent

information. The log date will be used to record whether the request

was received within the 6-month period, and will show how long it took

the carrier to complete the appeal.

Comment: One commenter recommended that the percentage of calls

monitored be set at the carrier's discretion instead of the 10 to 15

percent level indicated in the proposed MCM instructions addressing

this final rule that have been circulated to carriers.

Response: Issues dealing with how carriers will monitor telephone

calls and what percentage of calls will be monitored each month will be

included in forthcoming MCM instructions. When we issue the MCM

instructions for the telephone review process, they will state the

percentage of calls that must be monitored each month.

Comment: One commenter asked if we could outline what is considered

a reasonable timeframe for the processing of an appeal.

Response: In many cases, telephone reviews will be handled at the

time of the call. Some carriers do not have dedicated lines for

telephone reviews. In these cases, when the parties call in, someone

will take the information from the caller, then pass that information

to the section that will return the call. When possible, the review

will be performed at that time. When the telephone reviews are not

handled during the initial call, we expect the return call to be

processed within approximately 1 to 2 business days from the time of

the initial call.

Comment: Several commenters asked if specific contractor

performance evaluation (CPE) standards will be issued.

Response: We expect to establish CPE standards for telephone

reviews. These standards will be included in the MCM instructions that

will be issued at a later date.

Comment: One commenter asked how we will preserve confidentiality.

Another asked, more specifically, how we will prevent someone who does

not represent the provider from requesting a review.

Response: Carriers will be required to train their telephone

reviewers to meet the requirements of the Privacy Act. For calls from

individuals who purport to be the beneficiary involved or someone

representing the beneficiary, each caller will be asked to verify his

or her identity and, if necessary, his or her relationship to the

beneficiary. An Appointment of Representative form or a signed letter

from the beneficiary will be required when a caller purports to

represent the beneficiary. For calls from practitioners or other

suppliers regarding assigned claims, the carrier will verify the tax

identification number, name, and telephone number. The carrier will

give information only pertaining to the assigned claims of those

practitioners or suppliers. On nonassigned claims, the only information

the carrier will provide to

[[Page 52667]]

the physician or other supplier is the date the claim was processed,

unless the physician or supplier can provide the carrier with a

facsimile of a signed copy of the Appointment of Representative form or

a copy of a letter signed by the beneficiary. Regarding the issue of

preventing someone who does not represent the provider from making a

request for review, other individuals may request a review on behalf of

an appellant. The results of that review, however, will only be given

to the party enrolled under Part B, their assignee, other entities

having a standing to appeal the determination in question, or any

individual appointed as his or her representative (unless the

individual is disqualified or suspended from acting as a

representative).

Comment: One commenter asked if the Appointment of Representative

and Waiver of Right of Payment forms will be eliminated.

Response: We do not anticipate that the Appointment of

Representative and Waiver of Right of Payment forms will be eliminated.

Comment: One commenter asked whether all providers and suppliers

have the option of using telephone review procedures, or only those

providers and suppliers who accept Medicare assignment.

Response: Normally, telephone reviews will be available only to

providers and suppliers who accept assignment. That is, telephone

reviews are limited to providers and suppliers on assigned claims,

unless the beneficiary gives a nonparticipating supplier the right to

represent him or her and the nonparticipating supplier provides the

carrier with a signed copy of the Appointment of Representative form or

a signed letter from the beneficiary designating the nonparticipating

supplier to pursue the claim on behalf of the beneficiary. In those

instances in which a nonparticipating supplier is required to refund

any collected amount to the beneficiary in accordance with section

1842(l)(1)(A) of the Act, that supplier would have its own appeal

rights. Otherwise, carriers may take information from nonparticipating

suppliers, but cannot give any information concerning the result of the

review to that caller.

Comment: One commenter asked whether the rule will require that the

party who answers the telephone for the carrier be the primary receiver

of calls and if that party will be required to give his or her name, if

asked.

Response: Some carriers do not have dedicated lines for telephone

reviews. In those instances, the party who answers the telephone call

may only be obtaining certain information from the appellant (for

example, completing a form) and then will forward the form to the party

who will evaluate whether the request can be handled as a telephone

review. If so, the reviewer will telephone the appellant and perform

the review. We will also instruct the carriers to train their personnel

to give their names to the callers, if asked. In addition, we will

instruct the carriers that if the caller is requesting a telephone

review, and the carrier verifies that the request is a request for a

review, a confirmation number must be provided to the appellant at the

end of the telephone call. Furthermore, we will instruct the carriers

that their systems must record the date the appellant called as the

date of the request for a review. Having the system annotate the date

of the request and providing the appellant with a confirmation number

will protect the appellant's appeal rights.

Comment: One commenter recommended that beneficiary eligibility

and/or entitlement not be considered appropriate for telephone reviews.

The commenter was also concerned that allowing beneficiaries access to

the telephone review process will not be cost-effective since in most

cases the beneficiary will not have the information needed for the

review to be performed at the time of the review request.

Response: SSA handles all eligibility and/or entitlement issues.

The only entitlement issue that a Medicare carrier could handle during

a telephone review would be to advise the appellant that, as of a given

date, the records show that he or she does not have entitlement. The

forthcoming MCM instructions will list those issues we expect all

carriers to be able to resolve during a telephone review. We believe

that offering telephone reviews to beneficiaries will enhance customer

service to the beneficiary community. Even if the review cannot be

performed at the time that the telephone request is made, it is an

opportunity for the carrier to explain to the beneficiary how the

original claim was processed. Furthermore, we believe that with the

information available to the carrier in its computer database, it will

be able to effectively process many of the beneficiary requests for

review.

Comment: Several commenters asked if the MCM instructions will

impose a limit on the number of claims and reviews providers and

suppliers could request for review by telephone.

Response: Carriers will be allowed to determine how many claims per

review they can handle during each call. We anticipate that the

carriers will evaluate their workloads and staffing to determine the

number of claims their staff can handle. This self-imposed limit should

restrict the time involved for each call and, as a result, give more

appellants an opportunity to use the telephone review process.

Comment: One commenter asked if carriers should be required to have

sufficient capacity to receive a reasonable volume of telephone review

requests.

Response: As stated earlier, we will allow the carriers to

determine the number of claims that they are able to handle on each

call they receive so that the self-imposed limit will allow everyone to

request a review by telephone. We, therefore, expect carriers to have

sufficient staff to receive telephone requests for review. However, if

we determine that there is a need for additional resources, some

adjustments will be made. In addition, all parties will be informed

about the telephone review process in advance to enable them to make

effective use of this option.

Comment: One commenter questioned whether we intend for the carrier

representative who receives a telephone request for an appeal to merely

register the request, with the review itself occurring at a later date,

or to actually conduct the review at the time of the call.

Response: As stated earlier, we expect many carriers will perform

the review at the time of the initial call. There may be some carriers

that do not have dedicated lines for telephone reviews. In those cases,

parties will be informed in advance as to how that carrier will perform

the telephone review.

Comment: One commenter asked that the secondary claim review (the

commenter is referring to the first level of the appeal process) be

performed by someone other than the party who made the initial

determination.

Response: The original claim receives an initial determination. The

initial determination is the first determination made by a carrier or

intermediary following a request for Medicare payment for Part B claims

under title XVIII of the Act. The notice of the initial determination

informs each party of the determination and provides appropriate

appeals information to the parties having standing to appeal. The first

level of the Part B appeal is an independent review of the claim that

is performed by someone other than the party who made the initial

determination in accordance with current MCM instructions.

[[Page 52668]]

Comment: One commenter asked if we could modify existing Medicare

regulations to require that the review be conducted by a ``qualified

physician.''

Response: Reviews are conducted by contractor personnel who have

expertise in resolving claims disputes. A physician may be consulted in

an individual case. However, carriers do not normally employ physicians

to conduct reviews because it is not cost-effective.

Comment: One commenter asked if we will establish a mechanism to

guarantee that appellants initiating a telephone request for review are

able to reach the carrier.

Response: This rule will require all carriers to implement a

process by which they can receive telephone requests for review. We

will require all carriers to ensure that they have sufficient staff to

accommodate the number of calls they receive. If at any time it is

determined that this is not the case, we expect the carrier to re-

evaluate its process and take the necessary action to correct the

deficiency.

Comment: One commenter expressed concern that if appellants are not

limited by the number of appeals they can request per call, additional

resources (such as a 24-hour appeals hotline) or additional staff

should be provided.

Response: The forthcoming MCM telephone review instructions will

give the carriers some instructions to guide them in determining how

many claims can be appealed per call. The carrier will have to give

some consideration to whether the actual appeal will take place during

the initial call or whether the initial call will only be used to

gather information and the appeal will be handled at a later time.

Another issue that the carriers will have to consider is whether to set

a limit on the number of appeals allowed per call or a time limit per

call. We will not instruct the carriers to set a time limit, as this

might be construed as limiting the party's right to a full review of

his or her concerns. The carriers will inform the party in advance what

the requirements or limitations are for requesting a review via

telephone, as well as any limitations in those instances where the

review is performed during the initial call. The carriers will inform

the beneficiaries, providers, and suppliers via newsletters, stuffers,

seminars, customer service representatives, beneficiary and physician

advocacy groups, and others how the telephone process will work.

Comment: Several commenters asked about the specific documentation

requirements.

Response: The information the carrier receives during the telephone

review must be either: (1) documented on a review documentation form,

or (2) logged and maintained on a computer system so that the

information about the claim and request for review can be retrieved on

an on-line basis. All documentation must be assigned a review control

number (this can also be the confirmation number given to the appellant

at the end of the review). The confirmation number that the carriers

are required to provide an appellant can be their internal control

number, correspondence number, or document control number. The carrier

must be able to use the number to confirm the date of the appellant's

call. Other documentation requirements will be established in the

forthcoming MCM instructions.

Comment: One commenter stated that the rule does not indicate that

reopening of initial claim determinations, as permitted under

Sec. 405.841, can be done by telephone appeals.

Response: This rule does not permit parties to request reopenings

by telephone.

Comment: One commenter was concerned that, because carriers could

be overwhelmed with requests for review sent in by facsimile, the

option of submitting requests for review by facsimile should not be

advertised.

Response: This rule does not permit parties to request reviews by

facsimile. However, carriers may use facsimile machines to obtain

additional documentation from an appellant or the appellant's

representative. For example, carriers may use facsimile machines to

obtain a copy of the Appointment of Representative form or other

documentation.

Comment: One commenter asked whether, if the reviewer determines

that additional written information is needed to complete the review,

carriers have the option to suspend the review until that information

is received.

Response: In those cases in which the provider or supplier needs to

submit additional medical documentation and the information can be

supplied (for example, by facsimile) during the telephone review, or

within 24 hours of the telephone call, the carrier may suspend the

telephone review. The carrier must inform the appellant that the

telephone review will not be considered complete until the appellant

provides the requested additional information. If the appellant is

unable to provide the additional information during the telephone

review, or within 24 hours of the telephone call, the carrier has the

option to suspend the telephone review. If the information is not

provided within the allowed time the carrier will conduct a written

review or allow the appellant to call the carrier back when the

additional information becomes available. In either situation, the

carrier must provide the appellant with a confirmation number. If the

appellant is a beneficiary who does not have the additional information

on hand or does not have easy access to a facsimile machine, the

carrier must advise the appellant that the request for review will be

handled as a written review. In this instance also, the carrier must

provide the appellant with a confirmation number.

Comment: Several commenters expressed concern about the feasibility

and fairness of the 150-day limit for making requests for telephone

reviews.

Response: In the proposed rule, we suggested establishing a 150-day

timeframe after the date of the notice of the carrier's initial

determination within which a party may request a telephone review, and

a 180-day period for requesting reviews in writing, rather than the 6-

month period currently allowed. The proposal was an attempt to give

appellants, who we thought may be unsuccessful in their efforts to

reach the carrier by telephone, an additional opportunity to initiate a

request in writing before the time to appeal expired. We now believe

that the proposed 150-day timeframe for requesting telephone reviews is

confusing and that two different timeframes would not be cost-

effective. Furthermore, based on a survey of our carriers regarding the

timeframe within which they have been able to receive requests for

review by telephone after they send out initial determinations, we

believe that parties will not have difficulty reaching the carrier by

telephone. Therefore, we will retain the currently-specified 6-month

timeframe to request reviews of initial claims, regardless of the

method used to make the request. We will instruct our carriers to

advise parties, through their bulletins, workshops, and seminars to not

wait until the last day of the 6-month period to request a review by

telephone.

Comment: Several commenters were concerned that including details

of the telephone review process on the Explanation of Medicare

Benefits/Medicare Summary Notice (EOMB/MSN) and Remittance Advice forms

will be confusing for the beneficiaries.

Response: Details about the telephone review process will not be

provided on the EOMB/MSN or Remittance Advice forms; that information

will be provided by other means, such as in newsletters,

[[Page 52669]]

seminars, and envelope stuffers. However, there will be a general

statement on the EOMB/MSN form that informs the appellant that he or

she can telephone the carrier to request a review.

Comment: One commenter was concerned that the requirement to advise

the appellant of further appeal rights was redundant.

Response: We disagree. At the end of the review, the appellant

should be given information about how to proceed in the event that he

or she is still dissatisfied.

Comment: One commenter recommended that, if the telephone review is

an affirmation, the review determination letter should be sent

(following the telephone review) only when requested by the appellant.

Response: Whenever a review occurs, our current regulation at 42

CFR 405.811 requires the carrier to send a written notice of the review

determination to a party that states the basis of the determination and

advises the party of his or her appeal rights to a carrier hearing when

the amount in controversy is $100 or more.

Comment: One commenter recommended that to ensure adequate notice

of these new procedures, the notice sent with the carrier's initial

determination should (in addition to those items noted in the proposed

rule) clearly state that: (1) electronic transmissions may be submitted

only by those who submit their claims electronically; (2) electronic

transmission does not include facsimile transmissions; (3) if a request

is made to an SSA or HCFA office (rather than to a carrier), the

request must still be made in writing; (4) the carrier will resolve as

many issues as possible during the telephone request, but parties have

the opportunity to submit supporting documents; and (5) parties may

request, and be granted, an extension of time for filing a review

request if good cause is established by the carrier.

Response: As stated earlier, we are withdrawing the option of

requesting reviews of initial claims determinations electronically

(comment numbers (1) and (2)). With respect to comment (3), carriers

will be required to describe the telephone review process to all

beneficiaries, providers, and suppliers at least 30 days before

implementation. We do not believe that it is necessary or cost-

effective to describe in detail the telephone review procedures every

time the carrier issues an initial determination. There are a number of

ways the carrier can inform parties about the telephone review process,

such as through bulletins, newsletters, beneficiary, provider, and

supplier outreach seminars and meetings, or through contractor customer

service and inquiry departments. The opportunity to submit supporting

documentation (comment (4)) and the request for an extension of time

for filing a review request (comment (5)) are covered by existing

regulations. If circumstances warrant, parties will be advised of their

opportunity to submit supporting documentation and be granted an

extension of time.

Comment: Several commenters were concerned that requiring carriers

to send a written response when they have reviewed a request and

decided to pay a claim in full is an additional requirement.

Response: As stated earlier, whenever a review occurs, our current

regulations at 42 CFR 405.811 require that a notice of review

determination be sent to a party that states the basis for the

determination and advises the party of his or her right to a carrier

hearing when the amount in controversy is $100 or more. If the decision

results in full payment, the EOMB/MSN or Remittance Advice notice is no

longer sufficient unless it contains the basis of the determination and

advises the party of his or her right to a carrier hearing.

Comment: One commenter asked if telephone inquiries would be

screened to determine whether the party is requesting a review or is

just requesting an explanation of the initial determination.

Response: The carriers will be required to train their customer

service representatives and telephone reviewers to ask specific

questions to determine whether the caller is only requesting an

explanation of the initial determination or is requesting a review.

Comment: One commenter was concerned that, since payments as the

result of a telephone review are not subject to the payment floor, the

provider or supplier will be successful in receiving payment for these

claims in less time than if they initially filed a correct claim.

Response: All payments are subject to the payment floor (the

required waiting period that must occur before payment can be made) and

cannot be paid before that time expires. This is true for initial

claims, as well as for adjustments made as a result of a review. The

waiting period for an electronic claim is 14 days after the claim is

received, and the waiting period for a paper claim is 27 days after the

claim is received. Therefore, a provider or supplier should not receive

payment sooner, as the result of a telephone review, than he or she

would have received payment for the initial claim; that is, either 14

days for an electronic claim or 27 days for a paper claim.

Comment: One commenter asked if our intent is to offer telephone

reviews and electronic reviews as an option, or if our intent is to

require telephone reviews and offer electronic reviews as an option.

Response: When this rule becomes effective, beneficiaries,

providers, and suppliers will have the option of requesting a review by

telephone or in writing. As stated earlier, we are withdrawing the

option of requesting reviews of initial claims determinations

electronically.

IV. Provisions of the Final Regulations

For the most part, this final rule reflects the provisions of the

July 1995 proposed rule, except that we are withdrawing our proposals

to allow a party to request a review of a carrier's Part B initial

claim determination by electronic transmission and we are withdrawing

the proposed 150-day time period for a party to request a telephone

review.

In addition to establishing the provisions of the proposed rule,

except as noted above, this final rule: (1) continues the 6-month time

period currently in regulations for requesting a review of a carrier's

initial claim determination; (2) revises Sec. 405.805 of the

regulations to make a technical correction by removing the reference to

subparagraph ``(b)'' after Sec. 405.802; and (3) revises Sec. 405.807

of the regulations for consistency with the wording in Sec. 405.821(a).

V. Regulatory Impact Statement

We have examined the impacts of this final rule as required by

Executive Order 12866 and the Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA) (Public

Law 96-354). Executive Order 12866 directs agencies to assess all costs

and benefits of available regulatory alternatives and, when regulation

is necessary, to select regulatory approaches that maximize net

benefits (including potential economic, environmental, public health

and safety effects; distributive impacts; and equity). The RFA requires

agencies to analyze options for regulatory relief for small businesses.

For purposes of the RFA, carriers and beneficiaries are not considered

to be small entities. For purposes of the RFA, most hospitals, and most

other providers, physicians, and other health care suppliers are small

entities, either by nonprofit status or by having revenues of $5

million or less annually.

Under this final rule, beneficiaries, providers, and suppliers may

request a

[[Page 52670]]

review of an initial claim determination by telephone in addition to

the current writing procedure. A telephone review is the first level of

appeal for Part B claims and is performed by carrier staff who had no

part in making the initial claim determination in accordance with

current MCM instructions. A telephone review is considered to be less

costly to all parties and is a more expeditious way of handling appeals

than a written review.

Also, section 1102(b)(2) of the Act requires us to prepare a

regulatory impact analysis for any final rule that may have a

significant impact on the operations of a substantial number of small

rural hospitals. Such an analysis must conform to the provisions of

section 604 of the RFA. For purposes of section 1102(b) of the Act, we

define a small rural hospital as a hospital that is located outside a

Metropolitan Statistical Area and has fewer than 50 beds.

We are not preparing analyses for either the RFA or section

1102(b)(2) of the Act because we have determined and certify that this

final rule will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial

number of small entities or a significant impact on the operations of a

substantial number of small rural hospitals.

In accordance with the provisions of Executive Order 12866, this

final rule was reviewed by the Office of Management and Budget.

We have reviewed this notice under the threshold criteria of

Executive Order 12612, Federalism. We have determined that it does not

significantly affect the States rights, roles, and responsibilities.

List of Subjects in 42 CFR Part 405

Administrative practice and procedure, Health facilities, Health

professions, Kidney diseases, Medicare, Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements, Rural areas, X-rays.

For the reasons set forth in the preamble, 42 CFR chapter IV is

amended as set forth below:

PART 405--FEDERAL HEALTH INSURANCE FOR THE AGED AND DISABLED

Subpart H--Appeals Under the Medicare Part B Program

1. The authority citation for part 405, subpart H is revised to

read as follows:

Authority: Secs. 1102, 1842(b)(3)(C), 1869(b), and 1871 of the

Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 1302, 1395u(b)(3)(C), 1395ff(b), and

1395hh).

2. Section 405.805 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 405.805 Parties to the initial determination.

The parties to the initial determination (see Sec. 405.803) may be

any party described in Sec. 405.802.

3. Section 405.807 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 405.807 Request for review of initial determination.

(a) General. A party to an initial determination by a carrier, that

is dissatisfied with the initial determination and wants to appeal the

matter, may request that the carrier review the determination. The

request for review by the party to an initial determination must

clearly indicate that he or she is dissatisfied with the initial

determination and wants to appeal the matter. The request for review

does not constitute a waiver of the party's right to a hearing (under

Sec. 405.815) after the review.

(b) Place and method of filing a request. A request by a party for

a carrier to review the initial determination may be made in one of the

following ways:

(1) In writing and filed at an office of the carrier, SSA, or HCFA.

(2) By telephone to the telephone number designated by the carrier

as the appropriate number for the receipt of requests for review.

(c) Time of filing request. (1) The carrier must provide a period

of 6 months after the date of the notice of the initial determination

within which the party to the initial determination may request a

review.

(2) The carrier may, upon request by the party, extend the period

for requesting the review of the initial determination.

(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Program No. 93.774,

Medicare--Supplementary Medical Insurance Program)

Dated: October 6, 1998.

Nancy-Ann Min DeParle,

Administrator, Health Care Financing Administration.

Dated: February 22, 1999.

Donna E. Shalala,

Secretary.

Editorial Note: This document was received at the Office of the

Federal Register September 27, 1999.

[FR Doc. 99-25477 Filed 9-29-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4120-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.