Pipeline Safety: Qualification of Pipeline Personnel

Federal RegisterAug 27, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

49 CFR Parts 192 and 195

[Docket No. RSPA-98-3783; Amendment 192-86; 195-67]

RIN 2137-AB38

Pipeline Safety: Qualification of Pipeline Personnel

AGENCY: Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA); Office of

Pipeline Safety (OPS).

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This final rule requires pipeline operators to develop and

maintain a written qualification program for individuals performing

covered tasks on pipeline facilities. The intent of this qualification

rule is to ensure a qualified work force and to reduce the probability

and consequence of incidents caused by human error. This final rule

creates new subparts in the gas and hazardous liquid pipeline safety

regulations. It establishes qualification requirements for individuals

performing covered tasks, and amends certain training requirements in

the hazardous liquid regulations. This final rule was developed through

a negotiation process.

DATES: This final rule will be effective on October 26, 1999.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Eben M. Wyman, (202) 366-0918, or by

e-mail at [email protected], regarding the subject matter of this

final rule; or the Dockets Unit, (202) 366-4453, for copies of this

final rule or other material in the docket. All materials in this

docket may be accessed electronically at http://dms.dot.gov. General

information about the RSPA Office of Pipeline Safety can be obtained by

accessing OPS's Internet home page at http://ops.dot.gov.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Table of Contents for Supplementary Information

I. Introduction.

II. Statutory Authority and Regulatory History.

III. Negotiated Rulemaking.

A. Members of the RSPA Negotiated Rulemaking Committee.

B. Negotiated Rulemaking Committee Groundrules.

C. Committee Meetings.

IV. Discussion of Comments Received on Notice of Proposed

Rulemaking.

V. Scope.

A. Persons Covered by the Final Rule.

B. Operators are Responsible for Identifying Covered Tasks.

C. Identification of Covered Tasks.

1. Tasks Performed on a Pipeline Facility.

2. Operation or Maintenance Tasks.

3. Tasks Performed Pursuant to a Requirement in 49 CFR Part 192

or 195.

4. Tasks Affecting the Operation or Integrity of the Pipeline.

D. Amendments to Section 195.403.

VI. Definitions.

VII. Qualification program.

VIII. Recordkeeping.

IX. General.

I. Introduction

Although no regulatory program is capable of completely eliminating

human error, the objective of this final rule is to reduce the risk of

accidents on pipeline facilities attributable to human error. This

final rule for the qualification of individuals is intended to provide

an additional level of safety. This final rule does not replace

existing qualification requirements in 49 CFR Part 192. However, it

does remove the operations and maintenance training requirements of

195.403. The final rule does not diminish the importance of the safety

requirements already in the pipeline safety regulations. These include

requirements for safety design features, such as relief valves and

over-pressure protection devices, to provide protection against human

error and other causes of incidents and accidents.

The final rule requires operators of pipelines to develop a

qualification program to evaluate an individual's ability to perform

covered tasks, and to recognize and react to abnormal operating

conditions that may occur while performing covered tasks.

The final rule also sets recordkeeping requirements that operators

must follow to successfully demonstrate compliance, and the information

that must be maintained on each individual who has been evaluated and

deemed qualified to work on a pipeline facility. Finally, the final

rule specifies the deadlines by which operators must develop and

implement their qualification programs.

This final rule allows operators with existing programs to modify

those programs if necessary to ensure compliance with the minimum

requirements of this final rule. The final rule also requires operators

without a qualification program to establish a program to evaluate the

qualifications of individuals performing certain operation and

maintenance activities on those pipeline facilities that could affect

pipeline operation or integrity.

This final rule establishes a new Subpart N in 49 CFR Part 192 and

a new Subpart G in 49 CFR part 195. The final rule amends the training

regulations in

[[Page 46854]]

49 CFR 195.403. The emergency response training requirements remain as

they appear in 49 CFR 195.403.

II. Statutory Authority and Regulatory History

Sections 106 and 205 of the Pipeline Safety Act of 1992 (Pub. L.

No. 102-508) required the Department of Transportation to establish

regulations requiring that ``all individuals responsible for the

operation and maintenance of pipeline facilities be tested for

qualifications and certified to operate and maintain those

facilities.''

On August 3, 1994, RSPA published a notice of proposed rulemaking

to establish specific training requirements for the qualification of

pipeline workers (59 FR 39506). This proposal would have introduced

qualification standards for personnel that perform, or supervise

persons performing, regulated operations, maintenance, and emergency

response functions. The purpose of the proposal was to improve pipeline

safety by requiring operators to ensure the competency of pipeline

personnel through training, testing, and periodic refresher training.

In response to this notice, RSPA received 131 comments that

expressed a wide variety of interests and concerns. Most commenters

asserted that the proposal should have taken a more general approach to

qualification with broad requirements for persons performing ``safety

related'' functions. Commenters stated that the proposal was too

prescriptive and that the many references to training requirements

should be modified to focus the proposal on actual qualification,

rather than on the method(s) of achieving qualification.

OPS' technical advisory committees, the Technical Pipeline Safety

Standards Committee and the Technical Hazardous Liquid Pipeline Safety

Standards Committee, disapproved of the proposal. These Committees

passed several motions for amendments to the proposal. These motions

were generally consistent with the written comments.

Subsequently, the Pipeline Safety Act was amended to require that

``all individuals who operate and maintain pipeline facilities shall be

qualified to operate and maintain the pipeline facilities'' (49 U.S.C.

60102(a)). This Act also requires that the ``qualifications applicable

to an individual who operates and maintains a pipeline facility shall

address the ability to recognize and react appropriately to abnormal

operating conditions that may indicate a dangerous situation or a

condition exceeding design limits'' (49 U.S.C. 60102(a)).

Following review of the comments to the 1994 proposed rulemaking,

as well as recommendations by the Technical Advisory Committees, and a

petition for withdrawal and alternative proposal submitted collectively

by the American Gas Association, the American Public Gas Association,

and the Southern Gas Association, RSPA decided that a regulatory

process other than traditional rulemaking would better address the

issues surrounding operator qualifications. Consequently, RSPA issued a

Notice of Withdrawal of the 1994 proposed rulemaking (61 FR 34413; July

22, 1996) and simultaneously issued a Notice of Intent to form a

negotiated rulemaking committee to develop a final rule on the

qualification of pipeline personnel (61 FR 34410; July 22, 1996).

III. Negotiated Rulemaking

RSPA understands that effective regulatory solutions to certain

issues can be difficult for an agency to craft. In the typical

rulemaking process, the participants often develop adversarial

relationships that prevent effective communication and creative

solutions. Exchange of ideas that may lead to solutions that are

acceptable to all interested groups does not often occur in the

traditional notice and comment rulemaking procedure.

Negotiated rulemaking is conducted under authority of the

Negotiated Rulemaking Act of 1990 and the Federal Advisory Committee

Act. The process involves assembling representatives of the affected

interests to discuss a particular issue and all potential solutions.

The goal was to reach consensus and prepare a proposed rule for

consideration by the agency. On February 22-23, 1999, the group

reconvened to review received comments and make recommendations for the

final rule. This inclusive process was intended to make the rule more

acceptable to all affected interests and minimize the likelihood of

petitions for reconsideration and litigation.

RSPA believed that the negotiated rulemaking process would provide

ample opportunity for all affected parties to present their views and

to reach a consensus on a proposed qualification rule. Negotiated

rulemakings have been used successfully by the Department of

Transportation, including the Federal Aviation Administration, the

United States Coast Guard, the Federal Highway Administration, the

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, and the Federal

Railroad Administration. In addition, the Environmental Protection

Agency, and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration have

successfully used the process.

A. Members of the RSPA Negotiated Rulemaking Committee

The Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) served as the

convenor and facilitator for the RSPA Negotiated Rulemaking Committee

(Committee). FMCS chaired the negotiations, offered suggestions in

attempting to reach the desired consensus, and helped determine the

feasibility of negotiating particular issues. From the beginning of

this process, RSPA met with FMCS on several occasions to discuss the

issues that needed to be addressed and the interests that needed to be

represented on a Committee. After a comprehensive search, RSPA selected

the following organizations, representing broad interests, to serve on

the Committee:

1. American Gas Association (A.G.A.): represents a large number of

gas distribution and a few transmission companies in the pipeline

industry. A.G.A. members consist of both large and small operators.

2. American Petroleum Institute (API): represents the interests of

the hazardous liquid pipeline companies. API is the major trade

association in the petroleum industry, and also represents the

interests of operators of other hazardous liquid pipelines.

3. Interstate Natural Gas Association of America (INGAA):

represents the interests of the larger interstate gas transmission

pipeline companies in the natural gas transportation industry. INGAA

consists mainly of the larger interstate gas transmission pipelines.

4. American Public Gas Association (APGA): represents publicly-

owned and municipal gas companies. Although these public companies are

generally small, they operate a large number of the distribution

pipelines in American cities and suburbs.

5. National Propane Gas Association (NPGA): represents the

interests of propane marketing and distribution at the local level.

NPGA is made up of both large and small companies.

6. Association of Texas Intrastate Natural Gas Pipelines:

represents the interests of intrastate natural gas transmission

pipelines.

7. Midwest Energy Association (MEA): represents over 300 investor-

owned utilities, municipal utilities, contractors and manufacturers.

MEA brought considerable expertise in pipeline personnel training

issues.

8. NACE International, The Corrosion Society (NACE): an

organization of corrosion experts. NACE works

[[Page 46855]]

primarily on issues of corrosion and corrosion control systems.

9. National Association of Pipeline Safety Representatives (NAPSR):

represents state pipeline safety programs. Many of these organizations

will incorporate the final rule on operator qualifications into their

pipeline safety program.

10. National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners

(NARUC): represents the interests of the state utility commissioners,

who regulate gas rates and terms of service in most of the fifty

states.

11. National Association of State Fire Marshals (NASFM): represents

the interests of state fire officials in state safety programs and the

issue of qualification for emergency response.

12. International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE): represents

the interests of a substantial number of pipeline construction and

maintenance workers.

13. International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW):

represents over 21,000 gas industry workers.

14. Office of Pipeline Safety (OPS): served as the representative

of RSPA, and the Designated Federal Official on the Committee.

B. Negotiated Rulemaking Committee Ground Rules

Most of the procedures and protocols followed in the negotiation

were established by the Committee. A set of Committee ``ground rules''

was developed by participants at the initial meeting. Issues discussed

and agreed upon by the Committee included: how discussions would be

conducted, possibility of subgroups to work on particular issues,

expectations of Committee members, the Committee's role throughout the

rulemaking process, audience participation, and other topics. The

following are some of the more significant ground rules established by

the Committee:

1. Membership: All organizations were allowed one seat at the

table, and permitted to name one alternate to serve in their absence.

2. Good faith: All participants were expected to act in good faith

on behalf of their organization. OPS agreed to issue the Committee's

proposed rule as long as it was not in conflict with any other legal

requirements. In turn, the Committee agreed to support the proposal

following publication in the Federal Register. It was agreed that the

Committee would be actively involved through publication of the final

rule.

3. Conduct of meetings: Committee members reserved the right to

bring constituents to the table to address the Committee, and could

quietly consult with constituents during the course of the negotiation.

All meetings were open to the public. The Committee agreed that there

would be time scheduled on every meeting agenda for comment by the

audience.

4. Public Record: RSPA kept a record of all Committee meetings.

This record was placed in the public docket (Docket No. PS-94) and is

publicly available.

5. Consensus: The goal of the negotiating process is consensus. The

Committee developed its own definition of consensus for the purposes of

this rulemaking, which was as follows: ``A decision which all members

or designated alternates present at the meeting can agree upon. The

decision may not be everyone's first choice, but they have heard it and

everyone can live with it.''

C. Committee Meetings

The Committee convened a total of eight times between May 1997, and

February 1999. Each negotiating session lasted a minimum of two days,

with two sessions convening for two and a half days. These meetings

resulted in an NPRM which was published in the Federal Register on

October 27, 1998, (63 FR 57269). The Committee reached final consensus

on the final rule in its last meeting in February 1999.

IV. Discussion of Comments in Response to NPRM

General Comments

RSPA received 41 comments to the NPRM. Comments were received from

nine pipeline-related trade associations, 25 pipeline operators, two

state government agencies, two union organizations, two independent

organizations, and the National Transportation Safety Board. Most

commenters expressed support for the rule.

Four commenters questioned the need for an operator qualification

rule. They said there is no evidence in the pipeline industry's safety

record to demonstrate the need for what they alleged would be a new

administrative burden. Another commenter expressed that it is

inappropriate to add a new subpart to the pipeline safety regulations.

However, RSPA was mandated by Congress to develop qualification

requirements in several pipeline safety reauthorization actions, most

recently in 1996. The mandate was supported by several entities,

including many state government agencies, the National Transportation

Safety Board, and others.

In addition, seven out of the 14 members of the Committee that

developed this rule represented various parts of the gas and hazardous

liquid pipeline industry. The Committee agreed to focus the rule on the

requirements of the 1996 Act, which called for the establishment of

``qualification'' requirements rather than ``training and

certification'' requirements that were mandated in the 1992 Pipeline

Reauthorization Act. RSPA believes the proposed rule addresses the

intent of the 1996 Act.

One commenter said that the goal of the rule could be better served

by implementing general language into the pipeline safety regulations,

such as ``all tasks required by Part 192 will be carried out by

qualified individuals.'' RSPA disagrees that this language would be

sufficient to ensure a qualified work force. This ambiguous language

would not satisfy the requirements called for in the 1996 Act.

A pipeline industry trade association recommended that RSPA conduct

a formal cost-benefit analysis as described in the 1996 Act. A cost-

benefit analysis was performed and is a part of the public docket. RSPA

is statutorily required to prepare a cost-benefit analysis, even if a

rule is developed by a negotiated rulemaking committee. RSPA worked

closely with the Committee on the regulatory analysis section of the

rule.

Another commenter said that RSPA did not adequately consider the

burdens imposed on the operator resulting from responsibility for

contractor qualification, and asked that RSPA exempt operators from

qualifying contractors. Another commenter noted that pipeline

contractors with in-house safety training will suffer because different

pipeline companies will have different qualification plans. As is the

case with all pipeline safety regulations, responsibility for

compliance lies with the pipeline operator. RSPA does not have

regulatory jurisdiction over pipeline contractors. However, to ensure

the qualification of the many contractor personnel that work regularly

on pipelines, the proposed rule covers all operator employees,

contractors, sub-contractors, or any other entities working on behalf

of the operator.

One commenter suggested that RSPA facilitate the development of a

``model qualification program,'' to assist small operators, and to

provide outreach and explanation of the rule to pipeline contractors

and sub-contractors. Another commenter said that RSPA should not

require compliance with ``model'' or ``industry standard''

qualification programs. RSPA believes the spirit of this rule is to

allow flexibility for operators to develop

[[Page 46856]]

specific qualification programs for their unique systems, and that a

compliance ``model'' would be inconsistent with the spirit of the rule.

However, RSPA will be working with state government agencies, and

pipeline industry groups to facilitate implementation of the

qualification rule. RSPA believes cooperative efforts with affected

parties will provide the necessary guidance for compliance with the

rule.

One commenter said there should be provisions for ``transitional

allowances,'' in situations where merging operators have inconsistent

qualification programs. RSPA believes the time frames provided allow

adequate time to resolve inconsistencies between qualification

programs. Program modifications are inevitable in the case of company

mergers. RSPA understands the problems that arise in the event of

company mergers, and will work with operators on a case by case basis

to ensure compliance with this rule.

Eleven commenters believed that the references to the existing

authority of inspectors to evaluate the adequacy of qualification

programs should be eliminated from the preamble of the final rule,

because this authority ``already exists.'' They insisted that existing

procedures provide administrative processes for resolution of

disagreements. The Committee discussed this issue at length, and agreed

that the references should be retained to remind all affected parties

that the increased flexibility provided in this rule does not limit the

authority of oversight agencies.

There were several comments regarding the implementation of this

rule, and on measuring performance. A commenter suggested that RSPA

provide the following provisions to mitigate the financial impact on

local government systems that must comply with the rule: (1) A

federally sponsored and funded training program to be administered on a

state/local level; and (2) federal funds necessary for local government

compliance. RSPA provides federal funds in the pipeline safety grant

program, which provides up to 50% of a state agency's program, if they

are considered a ``state partner'' to RSPA. Additional training

programs dealing with compliance with the rule are currently under

development and will be open to all interested parties, including local

government entities affected by the regulation. Further, federal

guidance documents such as the revised version of the ``Guidance Manual

for Operators of Small Gas Systems'' will help small operators achieve

compliance. Also, two commenters suggested that RSPA develop a

mechanism(s) to evaluate the rule's effectiveness. RSPA plans to

establish a periodic review with stakeholders regarding the

effectiveness of the qualification rule.

Finally, eleven commenters said that language should be implemented

in the preamble describing what process or procedure RSPA would use if

it became necessary to revise the qualification rule. They suggested

the following options: (1) Reconvene the Committee; (2) establish an

industry/government task team; (3) hold public meetings and/or

workshops; or (4) nominating stakeholders to form a peer review team.

RSPA cannot predict what changes might be necessary for this rule in

the future, but will periodically work with stakeholders to evaluate

the effectiveness of this rule.

One commenter was concerned with the effect of the proposed rule on

small operators, and suggested that RSPA provide guidance on compliance

with the rule to assist small operators, and state pipeline safety

inspection personnel. Another commenter believed master meter operators

should be exempt from qualification requirements, because many master

meter operators are small ``mom and pop'' operations. This commenter

asked how these small operators would be able to evaluate qualification

of the many contract personnel that work on their master meter systems.

The Committee discussed the issue of the effects of the rule on

small operators and master meter systems, and agreed that special

provisions would not be appropriate because the qualification of

workers at both large and small pipeline operators can impact safety.

Federal guidance documents such as the ``Guidance Manual for Operators

of Small Gas Systems'' will be revised to help small operators achieve

compliance. In addition, many training programs are currently under

development by government organizations and members of the pipeline

industry.

A commenter said RSPA should clarify how individuals involved in

emergency response, who do not perform covered tasks, would be subject

to the qualification requirements. The Committee agreed not to re-write

the qualification requirements of emergency response personnel. The

rule applies only to personnel performing operations and maintenance

activities.

Comments to Secs. 192.801/195.501--Scope

One pipeline operator suggested the reference to gas control

operations on page 57273 of the proposed rule be removed from the rule.

This operator claimed that monitoring is related to market response and

customer delivery, not overpressure protection, and would not

necessarily be a covered task. RSPA believes that controlling gas would

clearly have to be considered a covered task. Any handling of the noted

``physical and mechanical devices'' would require qualification. The

example remains in the final rule.

Thirty commenters were concerned with a paragraph on page 57273 of

the proposed rule dealing with tasks ``performed pursuant to

requirement in part 192 or 195,'' and the example of ``calibrations and

low-pressure shutdowns.'' These commenters believe this language

directly conflicts with the rule language, which describes a covered

task as one that is ``performed as a requirement of this Part.'' The

commenters noted RSPA added this paragraph to clarify the meaning of a

covered task, but that it appears to expand the criteria for

determining a covered task. These commenters also said that any

references to ``pursuant to'' a requirement in the pipeline safety

regulations should be revised to ``as required by'' to be consistent

throughout the preamble and rule language. This paragraph was intended

to provide further clarification of activities that would be considered

covered tasks, but apparently caused confusion. RSPA has deleted the

paragraph in the final rule.

Two commenters called for better guidance in identifying covered

tasks. For clarification, they believed the term ``pipeline facility''

should be defined in the rule, using the existing definition in the

pipeline safety regulations. The definition of the term ``pipeline

facility'' can be found in 192.3 and 195.2. These definitions apply

generally to those subparts of the pipeline safety regulations. RSPA

does not see any merit in adding the definition to the rule.

One commenter said the preamble should include a note of

clarification to distinguish the term ``task'' from ``covered task,''

as there could be some misinterpretation of the meaning of the term.

RSPA agrees with this comment and has revised any appropriate

references to ``task'' with ``covered tasks'' or replaced the term

``task'' with ``activity.''

Thirteen commenters expressed that under ``Tasks affecting the

operation or integrity of the pipeline,'' the term ``could'' should be

deleted where used in the generic sense in column 1 of page 57273 of

the proposed rule to match the language in the rule. RSPA agrees and

has made this change in the final rule.

[[Page 46857]]

Fourteen commenters wanted clarification of the ``examples'' in the

proposed rule used to describe the four-part test. These commenters

said that the spirit of the rule is to provide operators with

opportunity to identify covered tasks unique to their systems, but the

discussion of ``examples'' imply that these examples would always be

covered tasks under the rule. These commenters said the preamble should

be revised to express that the ``hypothetical examples,'' are not to

imply that they would necessarily be covered for all operators. RSPA

believes the term ``hypothetical'' speaks for itself. We believe no

change is necessary.

One pipeline operator had many problems with various provisions and

examples throughout the preamble. This operator incorrectly believed

that the example dealing with leak surveys on page 57273 of the NPRM

was inappropriate, because leak surveys do not affect the operation or

integrity of the pipeline. The commenter also incorrectly said use of

the term ``covered task'' is unnecessary because a covered task is

simply an operations and maintenance task. Activities such as painting

a pipeline for appearance reasons would not require qualification. This

operator also stated that the concept of a task not being covered when

performed on an unattached pipeline component was confusing, and asked

for clarification. The Committee decided that when pipeline facilities

are not physically attached to the pipeline, work on these facilities

should not be ``covered,'' such as a manufacturers repair work off

site.

This operator also alleged that the preamble does not explain that

the term ``integrity'' includes the potential long-term effects of an

activity. Also, this operator did not believe the example dealing with

the coating and jacketing of pipelines was appropriate to illustrate

the significance of tasks affecting the operation or integrity of a

pipeline. RSPA disagrees with this commenter in all of these areas. The

Committee discussed pipeline integrity considerably, and agreed that

the examples used were appropriate. Therefore RSPA does not believe any

changes are necessary.

Comments to 192.803/195.503--Definitions

Abnormal Operating Condition

Fourteen commenters suggested that the preamble should state that

the Committee determined that the current definition for ``Abnormal

Operation'' in part 192 would not satisfy the provisions in the 1996

Act. These commenters also claimed that this definition could be read

to require individuals to recognize and react to an abnormal operating

condition that is unrelated to their expertise. RSPA believes that all

persons performing covered tasks should be able to reasonably recognize

and react to abnormal operating conditions while performing their work.

The current definition of ``Abnormal Operation'' in part 192 does not

meet the requirements of the 1996 Act. Further, the Committee agreed

that a separate definition would be appropriate for the purposes of

this subpart.

One commenter said that the structure of Abnormal Operating

Condition definition is unclear and inconsistent with the structure of

other definitions. RSPA agrees and has revised the format of the

definition to provide clarity.

Evaluation

Eleven commenters said that Note 1 of the table on page 57274 of

the NPRM, should be clarified from ``during the period between the

effective date of the rule and the three-year compliance date'' to

``October 28, 2002.'' RSPA agrees and has made the appropriate change

in the final rule.

Twelve commenters said that RSPA should add the table to the rule

language because the description in the preamble is not sufficient

guidance for pipeline operators. RSPA does not believe the change is

warranted because the rule language provides clear guidance. The table

was included in the preamble for illustrative purposes only.

One commenter asked that RSPA clarify how operators should identify

and document covered tasks during ``transitional'' qualification. The

commenter said the reference to transitional qualification is confusing

because no covered tasks are required to be documented for 20 months.

It is clear that no worker may be qualified under this rule before an

operator has established a qualification program, including a covered

task list. Although a qualification program may be established at any

time, it must be completed and documented no later than 20 months after

the rule is published in the Federal Register. The use of the term

``transitional'' in the preamble to the rule merely highlights that

current workers can be qualified solely through use of a work

performance history review only during the period ending 38 months

after the rule is published.

Qualified

One commenter believed there was no need to define this term

because it will lead to confusion and inconsistency with other

regulations. However, the Committee agreed early in the negotiating

process that this term should be defined for the purposes of this rule,

so no changes have been made.

One commenter stated that RSPA may need to define ``Operations and

Maintenance'' or designate which sections of parts 192 and 195 are

covered by the proposed rule. The final rule describes covered tasks as

those identified by the operator using the ``four-part test.'' This

topic is discussed further in the discussion concerning identification

of covered tasks, in particular operations and maintenance tasks.

Therefore, RSPA does not believe that further description is warranted

in the final rule.

Comments to Secs. 192.805/195.505--Qualification Program

Two commenters did not agree with the language ``contributed to an

incident as defined in Part 191 of this chapter,'' because it includes

LNG facilities in the definition of ``incident.'' These commenters do

not believe the scope of the rule should include individuals that work

at or near LNG facilities. The scope section of this rule states that

the regulation would cover only Parts 192 or 195 of the pipeline safety

regulations.

Two commenters believed that there may be situations where a

covered task is simple or repetitive enough that a required re-

evaluation at any interval is not warranted. The commenters asked that

this be noted in the preamble. The Committee discussed this issue at

length, and agreed that simple repetition of a covered task does not

ensure that the task is performed safely and properly. Appropriate

intervals (as determined by the operator) will ensure that the person

performing a covered task is continually qualified. Thus, RSPA does not

believe a change is needed.

One commenter noted that the description of 192.805 allows

operators to add to the seven required elements of their qualification

program and makes clear that operators will not be held accountable for

the qualification of personnel performing non-covered tasks. However,

the commenter was concerned that attempts could be made to treat non-

covered tasks included in a qualification program as if they were

covered tasks. The commenter suggested that RSPA revise the preamble to

emphasize that voluntary tasks included

[[Page 46858]]

in a qualification program would not be treated as required covered

tasks. RSPA believes the rule is clear as written. If a task does not

meet the ``four-part test'' in Sec. 192.805 and Sec. 195.505, it is not

covered task, even if voluntarily included in the qualification

program.

Comments to Secs. 192.807/195.507--Recordkeeping

No comments were received regarding these sections.

Comments to Secs. 192.809/195.509--General

Thirteen commenters suggested that ``18 months'' should be changed

to ``20 months after publication of the final rule.'' They also asked

that RSPA change the final rule to clarify ``three years'' to ``38

months from the publication date of the final rule.'' RSPA agrees and

has made the appropriate change in the final rule.

Thirteen commenters said that the language stating that a

``qualification program would be effective for a minimum of 10 years''

is confusing. Commenters suggested that RSPA remove the sentence

because it could be subject to multiple interpretations. RSPA agrees

and has made the change in the final rule.

Comments to 195.403--Emergency Response Training

A petroleum trade association supported the proposed revisions in

195.403, which would remove prescriptive O&M training requirements and

provide consistency with gas regulations. However, the commenter

suggested that the preamble clarify that hazardous liquid operators may

modify or discontinue operations and maintenance training requirements

only when the qualification rule is fully implemented. RSPA agrees and

has added language in 195.403 to reflect this change.

RSPA has implemented several other suggested grammatical

corrections in the final rule.

Comments to rulemaking analysis and notices

RSPA worked closely with the Committee, as well as with several

representatives in the pipeline industry when developing the rulemaking

analysis. One commenter suggested RSPA should use simple annualized

costs, rather than amortized costs. However, amortized costs more

accurately reflect the costs incurred by the pipeline industry.

RSPA received several comments on the following paragraphs

regarding Executive Order 12866:

``However, the impact of inadequate qualification of pipeline

personnel is not always apparent. For example, incidents/accidents

that operators attribute to equipment failure or corrosion may

actually have been set in motion by poorly performed operation or

maintenance procedures.'' (63 FR 57276)

``In 1997, there were a total of 363 reportable pipeline

incidents/accidents. Of these, 105 were directly attributable to

human error.'' (63 FR 57276)

``In fact, human error frequently is not cited as a contributing

factor in incident/accident investigations, even though it is

recognized that human error underlies nearly all pipeline failures

to some degree.'' (63 FR 57276)

``Perhaps the most important factor to consider when assessing

the benefits of this proposal is that very few pipeline failures

occur without some degree of human failure.'' (63 FR 57277)

Twenty-two commenters contend that the above references are not

reasonable. They request that RSPA describe its methodology used to

reach these conclusions, and substantiate these statements with

sufficient and credible data, or delete them.

These commenters did not agree that human error is a contributing

factor to nearly all incidents. Further, human error is not always

related to lack of qualification. The commenters suggested that RSPA

remove or substantiate the ``non-quantifiable benefits,'' because they

questioned the assumption that the rule will improve ``work

productivity and down-time.''

``[I]n 1997, there were 88 reportable incidents attributed to

outside force damage in the natural gas pipeline industry. Although

the data reflects outside force damage as the cause of the

incidents, human error is inherently present in most outside force

damage. For instance, the outside force damage may have resulted

from a pipeline worker not following local one-call system

procedures or from improper marking of the pipeline prior to

excavation'' (63 FR 57277).

Seventeen commenters expressed that this discussion is misleading

and not supported by facts. They noted that the discussion referring to

``the difficulty in quantifying the benefits of this proposed rule * *

*'' were only made to narrow the gap between costs and benefits. They

believe that these assumptions were not substantiated and should be

deleted from the preamble. RSPA acknowledges that language was added to

the NPRM after the final review by the Committee. However, the cost/

benefit section was not part of the negotiated discussion by the entire

Committee during the development of this rulemaking. RSPA has

nonetheless considerably revised this discussion to take into

consideration the comments on this topic.

Two commenters argued that litigation costs may increase, not

decrease, as a result of this rule. RSPA has removed the reference to

litigation costs since it would be difficult to predict the effect of

this rule on litigation costs.

Eighteen commenters expressed that DOT's reference to the 1994 gas

pipeline incident in Edison, NJ is inappropriate. This incident was the

result of illegal third party activity. They requested that DOT delete

the paragraph. RSPA agrees with these commenters and has removed the

reference in this final rule.

Specific Comments on the Proposed Rule Language

Several comments were received regarding the regulatory language.

One commenter suggested that 192.801 does not need the phrase ``as

identified by the operator.'' Several industry representatives on the

Committee wanted this clarification to highlight that the operator is

responsible for identifying covered tasks. Therefore, RSPA has not made

the suggested change to the final rule.

Ten commenters said that 192.803 should be changed by adding the

phrase ``that may reasonably be anticipated to be encountered while

performing the covered task'' to the end of item #2 in the definition

of ``Qualified'' (63 FR 57278). The commenters believed this would be

consistent with the language in the preamble and thus does not obligate

pipeline personnel to know all types of potential abnormal conditions.

The Committee discussed this issue and concluded that no change to the

regulatory language is warranted.

Nine commenters suggested that 191.805(f) should have the word

``substantive'' between the words ``communicate'' and ``changes''.

Commenters believed this change would make the rule consistent with the

preamble (page 57275, 3rd column, 2nd full paragraph) where the term

``substantive'' is used and makes it clear that not every change must

be communicated. This issue was discussed by the Committee, and RSPA

does not believe change to the regulatory language is warranted.

Ten commenters noted that 192.809(a) should read ``20 months''

instead of ``2018 months''. This typographical error was corrected in

this final rule.

Eleven commenters said 192.803 should be revised to clarify that

the reference to ``other forms of assessment'' is distinct from

``observation during'' in the Evaluation definition. RSPA discussed

this with the Committee and revised the rule to distinguish the term

[[Page 46859]]

``observation'' from ``other forms of assessment.''

The term ``integrity'' in the Scope sections is unclear. This issue

was discussed by the Committee, and RSPA does not believe changes to

the regulatory language are warranted.

One commenter suggested that section 192.809 be revised to allow

extra time for operators to ensure qualification of contractor

personnel. This issue was discussed by the Committee, and RSPA does not

believe changes to the regulatory language are warranted.

One commenter suggested that an additional section be inserted in

the rule to measure the performance of the qualification rule. RSPA

plans to establish a periodic review with stakeholders regarding the

effectiveness of the qualification rule. RSPA does not believe changes

to the regulatory language are warranted.

V. Scope

The Accountable Pipeline Safety and Partnership Act of 1996

required RSPA to adopt regulations requiring that ``all individuals who

operate and maintain pipeline facilities shall be qualified to operate

and maintain the pipeline facilities'' and ``shall address the ability

to recognize and react appropriately to abnormal operating conditions

that may indicate a dangerous situation or a condition exceeding design

limits'' (49 U.S.C. 60102(a)). The Committee determined that a national

qualification program conducted by RSPA, another federal agency, or a

state agency, would not be an appropriate or practical response to the

1996 Act. Such a system offers the advantages of national consistency,

including the ability of contractor employees to work for different

operators under a single qualification regime. However, it was

determined that the complexity and cost of administering such a system,

coupled with the difficulty of devising a system appropriate for the

wide variations in the operations and maintenance procedures and

facilities of individual operators, precluded this from being an

effective option.

The Committee determined the mandate would best be met by a non-

prescriptive, performance based regulation requiring each operator to

develop, or have developed, a written program for the qualification of

individuals. This would allow each program to be tailored to the unique

operations and practices of each operator.

A. Persons Covered by the Final Rule

This final rule applies to operators subject to the requirements of

49 CFR parts 192 or 195. The rule applies to all individuals who

perform covered tasks, regardless of whether they are employed by the

operator, a contractor, a sub-contractor, or any other entity

performing covered tasks on behalf of the operator.

B. Operators are Responsible for Identifying Covered Tasks

Under this final rule, the operator is responsible for identifying

which activities performed on the pipeline facility are covered tasks.

The process for identifying covered tasks is set forth in 49 CFR

192.801 and 195.501 (``Scope'') of this final rule.

The Committee discussed whether the regulator or the operator

should be responsible for identifying covered tasks. Because of large

differences between operations of pipelines across the country, a

uniform list of covered tasks would not be useful, and could result in

overall increased costs. For example, some operators do not have

transmission lines in their systems, others operate only distribution

lines, and others do not have compressors, pump stations, or storage

facilities. Some operators perform a large number of covered tasks,

while other, smaller, operators may have only a limited number of tasks

that must be classified as covered tasks.

Identification of covered tasks is a key component of the

qualification requirements under this final rule. The Committee

proposed that it would be more effective and practical to let each

operator determine the covered tasks requiring qualification.

However, some Committee members were concerned that if operators

are allowed to determine the covered tasks, the final rule should also

ensure that the regulators retain the authority to review each

operator's determinations. Some Committee members objected to allowing

each operator to identify covered tasks requiring individuals to be

qualified. These members objected to the use of the words ``determined

by,'' which could be interpreted to preclude regulators from

questioning the operator's identification of covered tasks. The

Committee decided to use the words ``identified by'' to mean the

selection of covered tasks by the operator. The Committee concluded

that the authority to allow pipeline safety regulators to require

modifications to programs that fail to meet regulatory requirements was

already within the scope of federal and state jurisdiction, as was the

authority to question particular activities included as covered tasks

by the operator. The Committee concluded that covered tasks would be

activities identified by the operator.

Therefore, under this final rule, the operator of a pipeline

facility is responsible for identifying which activities performed on

that facility are covered tasks. The criteria for identifying covered

tasks on gas and hazardous liquid pipelines is set forth in 49 CFR

192.801 and 195.501, respectively.

Although operators are responsible for identifying covered tasks

for which individuals must be qualified, regulators remain responsible

for reviewing operator qualification programs and ensuring that federal

regulatory standards are applied and met nationwide. Regulators may

question an operator's inclusion and exclusion of particular activities

as covered tasks. Regulators may require modifications to programs that

fail to meet the requirements of the rule.

B. Identification of Covered Tasks

The final rule includes a four-part test that each operator must

use to determine whether an activity constitutes a covered task. A

covered task is: (1) Performed on a pipeline facility; (2) an

operations or maintenance task; (3) performed pursuant to a requirement

in 49 CFR part 192 or 195; and (4) affects the operation or integrity

of the pipeline.

1. Tasks Performed on a Pipeline Facility. The phrase ``performed

on a pipeline facility'' means an activity that is performed by an

individual whose performance directly impacts the pipeline facility. An

individual who works on a pipeline component that is physically

connected to the pipeline system is performing work ``on a pipeline

facility'' and may be subject to the final rules, regardless of whether

or not product is flowing through the pipeline. However, a person who

repairs a pipeline system or appurtenance, that has been removed from

the system, would not be performing work on the pipeline, and therefore

would not be performing a covered task.

2. Operations or Maintenance Tasks. The Federal pipeline safety law

requires that all individuals who operate and maintain pipeline

facilities be qualified to operate and maintain those facilities (49

U.S.C. 60102(a)(1)(C)).

Most of the operations and maintenance activities on pipeline

facilities are found in 49 CFR part 192, subparts L and M, or in 49 CFR

part 195, subpart F. In addition, the regulations contain other

subparts that include requirements for conducting operations and

maintenance activities. For example, part 192, Subpart I, establishes

[[Page 46860]]

requirements for protecting metallic pipelines from external, internal,

and atmospheric corrosion. The requirements to monitor corrosion

control systems are operations activities. The requirements to take

corrective action when deficiencies are found in a corrosion control

program are maintenance activities. Therefore, repairing pipelines

affected by corrosion is also a maintenance activity.

Certain tasks performed on pipeline facilities may be covered tasks

when performed in the course of operation and maintenance activities,

but may not be covered tasks in the course of other activities. For

example, ``welding'' could be a covered task when performed as an

operations and maintenance activity on a pipeline, such as when

installing a weld-over sleeve to repair an anomaly. However,

``welding'' is not a covered task under this subpart when performed

during the fabrication of new installations, because this would not be

an operations and maintenance task.

However, welders are currently subject to qualification

requirements in 49 CFR part 192, Subpart E, and Part 195, Subpart D. To

comply with the final rule, welders would have to be additionally

qualified to recognize and react to abnormal operating conditions when

welding as a covered task. This also applies to other activities such

as ``plastic pipe joining,'' for which the regulations contain specific

requirements.

3. Tasks Performed Pursuant to a Requirement in 49 CFR Part 192 or

195. Covered tasks include only those operations and maintenance

activities required by 49 CFR Part 192 or 195.

Examples of covered tasks might include:

purging a pipeline because it is specifically required by

49 CFR 192.629;

leakage surveys of distribution lines, required by 49 CFR

192.723;

starting, operating, and shutting down gas compressor

units, because 49 CFR 192.605(b)(7) specifically requires written

procedures on these activities, to provide safety during maintenance

and operations;

inspection of navigable water crossings under 49 CFR

195.412; and

inspection of breakout tanks required by 49 CFR 195.432.

Operators of pipeline facilities may voluntarily conduct operations

and maintenance activities that are not required by a specific

provision in 49 CFR parts 192 or 195. However, an activity does not

necessarily become a covered task simply because an operator develops

procedures for conducting the activity, and includes those procedures

in its Operations and Maintenance Plan. For example, an operator may

voluntarily choose to maintain a customer's buried piping, and include

procedures for this activity in its Operations and Maintenance Plan.

Because such maintenance is not specifically required by 49 CFR parts

192 or 195, the associated maintenance activities are not covered

tasks.

4. Tasks Affecting the Operation or Integrity of the Pipeline.

Under the final rule, covered tasks include only those activities that

affect the operation or integrity of the pipeline.

The main purpose of the final rule is to ensure safety of pipelines

through qualification of individuals. Initial discussions centered

around safety-related activities and the need to categorize covered

tasks as only those activities having safety implications. Some

Committee members argued that most of the provisions in parts 49 CFR

192 and 195 regulate safety-related activities. It would therefore be

redundant to include the word ``safe'' on pipeline operations addressed

under this criteria. Therefore, it was decided to use the phrase,

``operation or integrity,'' because some activities do not adversely

affect the operation or integrity of the pipeline, even though they

meet the other three criteria. The Committee decided to include a

fourth criteria that must be satisfied for an activity to be a covered

task, namely that the activity affects the operation or integrity of

the pipeline.

The Committee discussed the term ``operation'' as used here in the

safety context of normal versus abnormal operation, where the latter

could result in an unsafe condition. For example, the control of flow

and pressure in pipelines could result in abnormal operation, if the

pressure is allowed to rise above an acceptable limit. Therefore, in

this example, activities that include controlling flow and pressure on

a pipeline system would be considered covered tasks if the other three

criteria for covered tasks were met.

An additional example of an activity affecting the integrity of the

pipeline would be coating or jacketing of aboveground pipeline

components. In the event atmospheric corrosion is present, coating or

jacketing the component could affect the integrity of the pipeline.

However, painting a pipeline for aesthetic reasons would not affect the

integrity of the pipeline.

The ``integrity'' of the pipeline refers to the pipeline's ability

to operate safely and to withstand stresses imposed during operations.

An example of a short-term effect on integrity would be exceeding the

Maximum Allowable Operating Pressure (MAOP) for gas pipelines and

Maximum Operating Pressure (MOP) for liquid pipelines. An example of a

long-term effect would be failure from corrosion due to improper

coating after repair of a welded joint.

Because the term ``pipeline facility'' was used in the first

criterion, the Committee also considered whether it would be

appropriate to use the term ``pipeline facility'' in the fourth

criterion instead of the term ``pipeline.'' Although some argued that

consistency should be maintained, others stated that the primary goal

of the final rule is to ensure the safe operation and integrity of the

pipeline itself. Furthermore, the term ``pipeline'' as defined in 49

CFR parts 192 and 195 already encompasses the ``facilities'' targeted

by the final rule. The Committee therefore agreed that this criterion

should remain unchanged.

If an activity fails to meet any one of the four criteria, the

activity would not be considered a covered task under this final rule.

The following are hypothetical examples of how the four-part test can

be used to identify a covered task:

Example 1: Leakage surveys on gas transmission pipelines.

(1) Performed on a pipeline facility? Yes, because leakage surveys

are performed immediately above the pipeline and on the pipeline right-

of-way.

(2) Is an operations and maintenance task? Yes, leakage surveys are

conducted in the course of pipeline operations and maintenance

activities.

(3) Is performed as a requirement of this part? Yes, leakage

surveys are required by 49 CFR 192.706 and 192.723.

(4) Affects the operation or integrity of the pipeline? Yes, if a

leakage survey is not properly conducted, a leak might not be detected,

resulting in a potentially hazardous situation.

Since all four criteria are met, the leakage survey is a covered

task.

Example 2: Measuring pipe-to-soil potentials.

(1) Performed on a pipeline facility? Yes, pipe-to-soil potentials

are measured at cathodic test stations attached directly to the

pipeline.

(2) Is an operations and maintenance task? Yes, pipe-to-soil

potentials are read in the course of pipeline operations and

maintenance activities.

(3) Is performed as a requirement of this part? Yes, pipe-to-soil

potential measurements are required by 49 CFR 192.465 and 195.416.

(4) Affects the operation or integrity of the pipeline? Yes, pipe-

to-soil potential measurements, if taken improperly, will not

accurately reflect the level of cathodic protection being provided.

[[Page 46861]]

While not affecting the immediate operation of the pipeline, the future

integrity of the pipeline might be jeopardized (for example, corrosion

might develop), if inadequate cathodic protection is applied to the

pipeline over a period of time.

Since all four criteria are met, the measurement of pipe-to-soil

potentials is a covered task.

Example 3: Meter reading.

(1) Performed on a pipeline facility? Yes, a meter is a part of a

pipeline facility.

(2) Is an operations and maintenance task? Yes, meters are read in

the course of pipeline operations and maintenance activities.

(3) Is performed as a requirement of this part? No, meter reading

is not a requirement of 49 CFR part 192 or part 195.

(4) Affects the operation or integrity of the pipeline? No, meter

reading has no impact on pipeline operation or integrity.

Because meter reading fails at least one of the four criteria,

meter reading is not considered a covered task.

In identifying covered tasks, operators must consider specific

activities and not necessarily the job classification of individuals

performing the activities, because each job classification may

incorporate several activities. For example, an individual with the job

classification, ``meter reader,'' may be assigned activities other than

reading a meter, such as distribution line patrolling under 49 CFR Part

192.721, that could be covered tasks.

D. Amendments to Section 195.403 (Training).

Section 195.403 currently prescribes the training requirements for

operations, maintenance, and emergencies for operators of hazardous

liquid pipelines. Because the final rule includes a qualification

process for operations and maintenance activities, but does not address

emergency response qualification, 49 CFR Sec. 195.403 is amended to

retain emergency response training requirements. This rule removes the

specific operations and maintenance training requirements addressed in

49 CFR Sec. 195.403. Persons performing operations and maintenance

tasks need to be qualified in accordance with the final rule. This

amendment is not effective until October 28, 2002.

VI. Definitions

The definitions section of this final rule was developed to

facilitate common understanding of key terms. The Committee began using

a number of terms that were not commonly defined by all members. To

facilitate communication, these terms were defined and are provided in

the final rule.

Abnormal operating condition.

An abnormal operating condition, as defined in this final rule, is

``a condition identified by the operator that may indicate a

malfunction of a component or deviation from normal operations that

may:

(1) Indicate a condition exceeding design limits; or

(2) Result in a hazard(s) to persons, property, or the

environment.''

This definition is derived from Federal pipeline safety law (49

U.S.C. 60102) and from the pipeline safety regulations (49 CFR 192.605

(c)(1)(v) and 49 CFR 195.402(d)(1)(v)).

``Abnormal operating conditions'' is also referenced in the

definition of the term ``qualified''. To be qualified, an individual

needs to be able to properly perform assigned covered tasks and be able

to recognize and react to an abnormal operating condition that may be

encountered while performing the covered task. For example, this may

include notifying the responsible parties or taking corrective action

to mitigate the condition.

As an example, an individual who has been qualified to perform leak

surveys should be able to recognize and react to an abnormal operating

condition such as blowing gas. Likewise, an individual who is qualified

to perform control of gas pressure and flow should be able to recognize

and react to an abnormal operating pressure in a pipeline segment.

Not all atypical operating conditions are abnormal. An example of

an atypical operating condition that is not abnormal is a pipeline

which can (not to exceed MAOP or MOP) operate up to 200 pounds per

square inch (psig), but which typically operates at 50 psig. Operating

this pipeline at 150 psig could be atypical, but not abnormal. If

however the atypical operating condition would cause the pressure in

the pipeline to exceed its allowable limits or cause a hazard to

persons, property or the environment, an abnormal operating condition

would result. A qualified individual performing control of gas pressure

and flow who observes an unanticipated pressure increase in such a

pipeline segment should know to investigate the cause of the change

before it reaches the MAOP/MOP of the line.

Evaluation

An evaluation of an individual's ability to perform a covered task

is the process that assesses and documents the individual's

qualifications to perform the covered task. Although the definition

lists several acceptable methods for evaluation, the list is not all-

inclusive.

The evaluation of an individual's qualifications should be an

objective, consistent process that documents an individual's ability to

perform the covered task. This includes the individual's ability to

recognize and react to abnormal operating conditions that the operator

could reasonably anticipate the qualified individual will encounter

while performing the covered task. The operator should establish the

acceptance criteria for the evaluation method used (for example, for

on-the-job training spell out the performance criteria; for a written

exam establish the cutoff score). The following table was developed in

Committee discussion to illustrate acceptable evaluation methods for

``transitional'', ``initial'' and ``subsequent'' qualification,

although these terms do not appear in the rule:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

``Transitional'' ``Initial'' ``Subsequent''

Evaluation method qualification\1\ qualification\2\ qualification\3\

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Written exam........................ YES..................... YES.................... YES.

Oral exam........................... YES..................... YES.................... YES.

Work performance history review..... YES..................... May not be used as the May not be used as the

sole evaluation method. sole evaluation method

after the three-year

compliance date.

Performance on-the-job.............. YES..................... YES.................... YES.

On-the-Job Training................. YES..................... YES.................... YES.

Simulation.......................... YES..................... YES.................... YES.

Other............................... YES..................... YES.................... YES.

[[Page 46862]]

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Notes:

\1\ ``Transitional'' qualification means qualification completed by October 28, 2002, of individuals who have

been performing a covered task on a regular basis prior to the effective date of the rule.

\2\ ``Initial'' qualification means qualification, at any time, of individuals who were not performing a covered

task on a regular basis prior to the effective date of the rule.

\3\ ``Subsequent'' qualification means evaluation of an individual's qualification, after ``transitional'' or

``initial'' qualification, at the interval established by the operator.

Under 49 CFR Secs. 192.809(c) and 195.509(c), a work performance

history review may not be used as a sole evaluation method after

October 28, 2002. ``Transitional'' qualification may rely on a work

performance history review as the sole evaluation method. ``Initial''

qualification may not rely on only a work performance history review.

``Subsequent'' qualifications may rely on work performance history

review if used in conjunction with at least one other evaluation

method.

Prior to the three year compliance date operators may use work

performance history review as the sole method for evaluation when

qualifying individuals. After the three year compliance date, if work

performance history review is used, it must be combined with at least

one other form of assessment. Any of the other forms of assessment

specified in the definition of evaluation may be used as the sole

method of evaluation both before and after the three year compliance

date. When an operator has qualified an individual prior to the three

year compliance date and used work performance history review as the

sole method of evaluation, the operator is not required to re-evaluate

each individual using additional criteria until the next scheduled

evaluation, which may vary by covered task.

The operator must establish the parameters for the work performance

history review. For example, a work performance history review may

include:

(1) A search of existing records for documentation of an

individual's past satisfactory performance of a covered task(s);

(2) verification that the individual's work performance history

contains no indications of substandard work or involvement in an

incident (part 192) or accident (part 195), caused by an error in

performing a covered task; and,

(3) verification that the individual has successfully performed the

covered task on a regular basis prior to the effective date of the

rule.

Qualified

Qualified, means that an individual has been evaluated and is able

to properly perform a covered task(s), and recognize and react to

abnormal operating conditions that may be encountered during the

performance of the covered task(s). An individual may be qualified

using any of the evaluation methods specified in the operator's written

qualification program.

VII. Qualification program

The Committee identified the following seven elements as

requirements in the operator's qualification program:

Paragraph (a) of 49 CFR 192.805 and 195.505 requires operators to

identify the covered tasks to be included in the qualification program.

Whether an activity is a covered task would be determined using the

four criteria in 49 CFR 192.801(b) or 195.501(b). Because operators are

responsible for identifying covered tasks, variations among

qualification programs are expected.

A concern of the Committee was whether periodic review of covered

tasks should be required. Although a periodic review requirement was

not included in the final rule, an operator may consider a periodic

review to ensure the accuracy of its covered task list.

Paragraph (b) requires that the qualification program include

provisions to ensure through evaluation that individuals performing

covered tasks are qualified. This would set forth the evaluation

methods to determine if an individual is qualified.

The Committee discussed contractor personnel and who is responsible

for their qualification and compliance under this rule. Some members

believed contractors should not be subject to this final rule and that

OPS should be responsible for ensuring the qualification of contractor

personnel. OPS does not have the authority to directly enforce

compliance by contractors with this rule. The pipeline operator is

responsible for all individuals working on their pipeline systems. This

includes operator and contractor personnel.

The Committee discussed the role of those performing evaluations.

Members agreed not to include a provision in the rule to require that

evaluators be ``qualified'' to evaluate. However, persons performing

evaluations should possess the required knowledge (1) to ascertain an

individual's ability to perform covered tasks and (2) to substantiate

an individual's ability to recognize and react to abnormal operating

conditions that might surface while performing those activities. This

does not necessarily mean that the persons performing evaluations

should be physically able to perform the covered tasks themselves.

The Committee discussed the concerns and options available to the

operator regarding who should evaluate the individuals performing

covered tasks. Because the operator is responsible for the development

and implementation of the evaluation methods, the Committee thought

that the operator should also be responsible for selecting

appropriately knowledgeable individuals to perform evaluations. The

final rule requires a qualification program that focuses on ensuring an

individual can properly perform a covered task(s) rather than the

credentials of persons conducting evaluations.

Paragraph (c) allows for performance of covered tasks by

individuals who are not qualified as long as a qualified individual

directly observes the non-qualified individual(s), and is able to take

immediate corrective actions when necessary. For example, an operator

may use a three-person crew to repair gas leaks. Two of the crew

members could be non-qualified. The crew excavates and repairs leaking

gas mains and services under the direct and close observation of the

qualified member of the crew. The intent of this provision is to ensure

that non-qualified individuals performing covered tasks are subject to

close observation by a qualified individual. Ultimately, the qualified

member of the crew is responsible for the repair. The ratio of non-

qualified individuals to ``qualified'' individuals should be kept to a

minimum.

Paragraph (d) requires the operator to evaluate an individual if

the operator has reason to believe that the individual's performance of

a covered task could have contributed to an incident as defined in 49

CFR part 191 or accident as defined in 49 CFR part 195. If so, the

individual's qualification should be evaluated to determine if the

individual continues to be qualified to perform the covered task.

Paragraph (e) requires the operator to evaluate an individual if

there is reason to believe that the individual is no longer qualified

to perform a covered task. This could occur if the individual displays

unsatisfactory performance of

[[Page 46863]]

the task or if there is reason to believe the individual can no longer

perform the covered task. The operator's qualification program must

include provisions for evaluating an individual's qualification if the

circumstances warrant.

Paragraph (f) recognizes that changes may occur that impact how a

covered task is performed. Changes that may need to be communicated to

individuals performing covered tasks may include:

Modifications to company policies or procedures.

Changes in state or Federal regulations.

Utilization of new equipment and/or technology.

New information from equipment or product manufacturers.

The final rule requires that the qualification program include

provisions for communicating information on substantive changes to the

individuals performing the affected covered tasks. When significant

changes occur, the operator should consider whether additional

qualification requirements are necessary and whether individuals

performing the covered task should be evaluated again.

Paragraph (g) addresses the identification of covered tasks, and

the frequency of evaluation intervals for each covered task. The

appropriate interval may vary depending on the covered task. It was

therefore left to the operator to determine which covered tasks and the

interval at which subsequent qualification of an individual performing

a covered task will occur. The Committee felt that the evaluation

intervals could be specified in units of time, frequency of performance

or other appropriate units. The Committee recognized that subsequent

evaluation methods may differ from initial qualification methods.

This rule does not require that the written qualification program

be incorporated into an operator's Operations and Maintenance Plan. The

operator may expand any of the seven required elements and add

additional elements to their program but will only be held accountable

to meet the requirements of this Subpart.

VIII. Recordkeeping

Under the final rule, each operator is required to maintain records

that demonstrate compliance. The Committee had considerable discussion

regarding records content, records to be retained, and length of

retention.

The records that support an individual's qualifications must

include the identity of each qualified individual (for example, name,

social security number, or employee number), identification of each

covered task for which qualified, date(s) of current qualification and

qualification methods(s). Records of an individual's current

qualifications must be maintained while the individual is performing

the covered tasks for which qualified. When an individual is evaluated

for subsequent qualification, the prior qualification records must be

maintained for a period of five years. Also, when an individual stops

performing a covered task (for example, the individual retires or is

promoted) the individual's qualification records must be retained for a

period of five years. The Committee selected five years to be

consistent with other regulatory time periods. The records may be kept

in paper, electronic, or any other appropriate format. The records may

be kept at a central location or at multiple locations.

The final rule does not address whether a certification or other

record of qualification need be issued to each qualified individual.

This matter is solely within the discretion of the operator.

IX. General

Development and implementation of a qualification program will take

some operators longer than others. Many operators currently have

adequate processes or programs to ensure the qualification of

individuals working on their pipeline systems. However, to ensure that

this final rule is enforceable, definitive time frames must be

specified. The Committee decided that 18 months would be sufficient

time to develop a written qualification program.

An operator will have 38 months from the effective date of the

final rule to complete the qualification of all individuals performing

covered tasks on its system. This will allow operators with more

limited resources and differing budget cycles adequate time to complete

the qualification process. Those operators who are able to comply

before the mandatory compliance date are encouraged to do so. The rule

does not intend to penalize early compliance. Therefore, the starting

time for subsequent evaluation intervals determined by the operator is

not required to begin until the compliance date.

Finally, work performance history review will only be allowed as

the sole method of evaluation during the three-year period prior to

mandatory compliance with the rule. After this time, work performance

history review will be an acceptable method of evaluating individuals

only in combination with another evaluation method.

Rulemaking Analyses and Notices

Executive Order 12866

This final rule is considered a significant regulatory action under

section 3(f) of Executive Order 12866 and, therefore, is subject to

review by the Office of Management and Budget. The final rule is

considered significant under the Department of Transportation Policies

and Procedures (44 FR 1103; February 26, 1979) because of the

substantial interest expressed by the pipeline industry, state and

Federal agencies, and Congress. This section summarizes the conclusions

of the regulatory evaluation. Copies of the regulatory evaluation are

available in the docket. Several groups, including the Congress, the

National Transportation Safety Board, and the National Association of

State Pipeline Safety Representatives, have called repeatedly for a

pipeline personnel qualification rule.

This final rule is the product of a negotiated rulemaking in which

representatives of all interested parties participated, including

pipeline trade associations, pipeline operators both large and small,

organized labor, state pipeline safety representatives, and the Federal

government. The members of the negotiated rulemaking committee agreed

that this process ensured adoption of a cost-effective standard for

pipeline personnel qualification. The American Gas Association (AGA)

and other participants in the negotiated rulemaking contributed to

estimates of the cost of this proposal. RSPA adjusted the cost

estimates to provide an annualized cost estimate for the entire

pipeline industry. Based on an estimated 175,000 covered pipeline

employees, including both operator employees and contractors, the

industry and the Committee identified three major cost categories for

implementation and compliance with the rule by gas and hazardous liquid

pipeline operators:

1. Cost for qualification program set-up, $210 million

2. Cost of transitional evaluation and qualification, $140 million

3. Cost of subsequent evaluation and qualification, $87.5 million

RSPA determined that the program set-up costs should be amortized

over 9 years. Therefore, RSPA amortized the set-up costs over 9 years

using a 7% interest rate for an annualized cost of $29.3 million for

program development and initial qualification.

[[Page 46864]]

The transitional qualification costs were amortized over a six year

period (three years before the effective date of the regulation that

requires initial qualification, and an estimated three years before

subsequent qualification) using a 7% interest rate for an annualized

transitional qualification cost of $28.6 million.

The Committee estimated that qualification for various covered

tasks would be reviewed approximately every three years, although the

length of time between evaluations for a particular covered task and

pipeline operator might vary widely. Therefore, the next qualification

(and each subsequent qualification) is amortized over three years at 7%

or an annual subsequent qualification cost of $32.4 million.

The result of these calculations is a cost of $57.9 million per

year for the years 1-6 ($29.3 million + $28.6 million) and a cost of

$61.7 million per year for years 7-9 ($29.3 million + $32.4 million).

The average annual cost for compliance with the rule is approximately

$59 million.

The preamble to this final rule notes that the intent of the

qualification rule is to ensure a qualified workforce and to reduce the

probability and consequences of accidents caused by human error.

Investigations of pipeline incidents/accidents clearly attributable to

human error often indicate either a deficiency of knowledge or skill

(for example, lack of qualification) or an error in judgement on the

part of pipeline personnel. However, the impact of inadequate

qualification of pipeline personnel is not always apparent. For

example, incidents/accidents that operators attribute to equipment

failure or corrosion may actually have been set in motion by poorly

performed operation or maintenance procedures. Although many state

pipeline safety representatives have stated that this rule will reduce

incidents/accidents by ensuring a qualified workforce, they concede

that the task of quantifying that reduction is very difficult.

Perhaps the most important factor to consider when assessing the

benefits of this rule is that human error is frequently not cited as an

element contributing to an incident/accident. Available data does not

always capture the contribution of human error to incidents/accidents.

In 1997, there were 354 reportable pipeline incidents/accidents. Of

these, 87 gas pipeline incidents and 40 hazardous liquid pipeline

accidents were attributed to outside force damage. Although most

outside force damage is caused by persons not covered by this rule--as

when a third party disregards one-call procedures--damage sometimes

results when a pipeline worker fails to follow one-call system

procedures or from improper marking of the pipeline prior to

excavation. Consequently, while third parties causing damage will not

be better prepared to prevent pipeline damage, they will potentially

reap the benefits of this rule by working around pipelines that are

more clearly marked.

These scenarios show the difficulty in quantifying the benefits of

this rule. Nonetheless, it is clear that some incidents/accidents could

be avoided as a result of implementation of this rule, and that the

cost of these incidents/accidents is substantial. Total outside force

incidents/accidents resulted in 7 fatalities ($19 million), 38 injuries

($18.5 million), and $27 million in property damage. This results in a

total monetized loss of $ 64.5 million in 1997. Monetization of

fatalities and injuries employed DOT's ``willingness to pay''

estimates. Because the record keeping and reporting system of OPS lacks

detailed data, it is not possible to accurately quantify the percentage

of accidents that will be avoided as a result of this rule.

Although quantifying all the benefits of an operator qualification

rule is impossible, most of the Committee members agreed that this

rule, as written, is as cost beneficial as practicable, and RSPA

believes that the overall benefits justify the costs of the rule.

Furthermore, although relatively few fatalities and injuries occur each

year from pipeline failures, the potential exists for significant, and

very costly, disasters.

In addition, even a small reduction in overall pipeline expenses

resulting from a fully-qualified workforce could result in significant

savings that could offset the costs of this rule. If standardizing

qualification procedures increases productivity and reduces operating

expenses by one-half of one percent per year, the annual expenses of

the major pipeline operators could drop by more than $68 million (FERC

Form 2, page 116, reports $13.77 billion in total 1996 operating

expenses for 53 large pipeline operators).

Other nonquantifiable benefits of this rule may include:

1. Reducing the likelihood of incorrectly following procedures;

2. Eliminating and correcting inadequate operating and maintenance

procedures;

3. Reducing or eliminating the occurrence of sending inadequately

prepared individuals into the field to perform covered tasks;

4. Increasing the formal communications between operator and

workers;

5. Increasing the attention and oversight on safety-related

procedures; and

6. Improving the documentation that ensures a qualified workforce.

These nonquantifiable benefits could translate into reduced

operating expenses. Finally, documentation of a qualified workforce

could improve operator public relations. RSPA provides further analysis

for its conclusion that this rule will have a positive benefit/cost in

its ``Regulatory Evaluation,'' which is included in the docket.

Regulatory Flexibility Act

Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.), RSPA

must consider whether a rulemaking would have a significant economic

impact on a substantial number of small entities. Based on the

regulatory evaluation, RSPA has determined that the rule will not have

a significant impact on a substantial number of small entities. The

Committee unanimously agreed that all operators, regardless of size,

should be subject to the final rule because the qualification of

workers at both large and small pipeline operators can impact safety.

One of the participants in the negotiated rulemaking was a

representative of the American Public Gas Association (APGA). The APGA

represents municipal gas distribution companies, the main group of

small entities in the pipeline industry. Hazardous liquid and gas

transmission companies tend to be quite large. As a result, there are

not a substantial number of small hazardous liquid pipeline entities.

In conversations between RSPA and APGA, APGA indicated that as a trade

association it would make itself available to assist its members in

complying with this final rule.

As indicated in the regulatory evaluation, many resources exist to

assist both small and large operators in compliance with this rule,

including classes from DOT's Transportation Safety Institute, nonprofit

industry associations, as well as for-profit companies. Additionally,

while some costs, such as the development of the qualification program,

are on a per company basis, the actual qualification will be on a per-

employee basis. As a result, costs incurred by smaller companies should

not be significant.

Further, the Committee considered the flexibility that this final

rule allows in terms of permitting each company to tailor its worker

qualification program

[[Page 46865]]

to its own unique needs, and would allow small operators to interact

with inspectors to evaluate and modify their qualification programs if

necessary. Because of this flexibility, the availability of assistance

in developing qualification plans, the fact that much of the cost will

be proportionate to the number of employees, and the fact that very few

small entities can be found among hazardous liquid and gas transmission

companies, I certify that this final rule will not have a significant

impact on a substantial number of small entities.

Paperwork Reduction Act

This Final Rule contains information collection requirements. As

required by the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3507(d)),

the information collection requirements in the rule have been submitted

to the Office of Management and Budget for their review and have been

approved under OMB #2139-0600.

Executive Order 12612

This final rule has been analyzed with the principles and criteria

in Executive Order 12612 (``Federalism'') (52 FR 41685), and does not

have sufficient federalism impacts to warrant the preparation of a

federalism assessment.

Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995

This final rule does not impose unfunded mandates under the

Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995. It does not result in costs of

$100 million or more to either State, local, or tribal governments, in

the aggregate, or to the private sector, and is the least burdensome

alternative that achieves the objective of the final rule.

National Environmental Policy Act

We have analyzed the final rule for purposes of the National

Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.). Requiring all gas

and hazardous liquid pipeline operators to adopt the operator personnel

qualification regulation should result in a reduction of pipeline

incidents that are caused by human error. This should result in reduced

fatalities, injuries, property damage, and environmental damage.

Furthermore, this regulation will not have a detrimental impact on the

environment. Thus, we have determined that the final rule will not

significantly affect the quality of the human environment. An

environmental assessment document is available for review in the

docket.

Impact on Business Processes and Computer Systems

Many computers that use two digits to keep track of dates will, on

January 1, 2000, recognize ``double zero'' not as 2000 but as 1900.

This glitch, the Year 2000 problem, could cause computers to stop

running or to start generating erroneous data. The Year 2000 problem

poses a threat to the global economy in which Americans live and work.

With the help of the President's Council on Year 2000 Conversion,

Federal agencies are reaching out to increase awareness of the problem

and to offer support. We do not want to impose new requirements that

would mandate business process changes when the resources necessary to

implement those requirements would otherwise be applied to the Year

2000 Problem.

This final rule does not require business process changes or

require modifications to computer systems. Because this final rule

should not affect the ability of organizations to respond to the Year

2000 problem, we do not intend to delay the effectiveness of the rule

changes.

List of Subjects

49 CFR Part 192

Natural gas, Pipeline safety.

49 CFR Part 195

Anhydrous ammonia, Carbon dioxide, Hazardous liquids, Petroleum,

Pipeline safety.

In consideration of the foregoing, RSPA amends 49 CFR Parts 192 and

195 as follows:

PART 192 AMENDED

1. The authority citation for Part 192 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 49 U.S.C. 5103, 60102, 60104, 60108, 60109, 60110,

60113, and 60118; and 49 CFR 1.53.

2. Subpart N is added to read as follows:

Sec.

192.801 Scope.

192.803 Definitions.

192.805 Qualification Program.

192.807 Recordkeeping.

192.809 General.

192.801 Scope.

(a) This subpart prescribes the minimum requirements for operator

qualification of individuals performing covered tasks on a pipeline

facility.

(b) For the purpose of this subpart, a covered task is an activity,

identified by the operator, that:

(1) Is performed on a pipeline facility;

(2) Is an operations or maintenance task;

(3) Is performed as a requirement of this part; and

(4) Affects the operation or integrity of the pipeline.

Sec. 192.803 Definitions.

Abnormal operating condition means a condition identified by the

operator that may indicate a malfunction of a component or deviation

from normal operations that may:

(a) Indicate a condition exceeding design limits; or

(b) Result in a hazard(s) to persons, property, or the environment.

Evaluation means a process, established and documented by the

operator, to determine an individual's ability to perform a covered

task by any of the following:

(a) Written examination;

(b) Oral examination;

(c) Work performance history review;

(d) Observation during:

(e) Performance on the job,

(f) On the job training, or

(g) Simulations; or

(h) Other forms of assessment.

Qualified means that an individual has been evaluated and can:

(a) Perform assigned covered tasks; and

(b) Recognize and react to abnormal operating conditions.

Sec. 192.805 Qualification program.

Each operator shall have and follow a written qualification

program. The program shall include provisions to:

(a) Identify covered tasks;

(b) Ensure through evaluation that individuals performing covered

tasks are qualified;

(c) Allow individuals that are not qualified pursuant to this

subpart to perform a covered task if directed and observed by an

individual that is qualified;

(d) Evaluate an individual if the operator has reason to believe

that the individual's performance of a covered task contributed to an

incident as defined in Part 191;

(e) Evaluate an individual if the operator has reason to believe

that the individual is no longer qualified to perform a covered task;

(f) Communicate changes that affect covered tasks to individuals

performing those covered tasks; and

(g) Identify those covered tasks and the intervals at which

evaluation of the individual's qualifications is needed.

Sec. 192.807 Recordkeeping.

Each operator shall maintain records that demonstrate compliance

with this subpart.

(a) Qualification records shall include:

[[Page 46866]]

(1) Identification of qualified individual(s);

(2) Identification of the covered tasks the individual is qualified

to perform;

(3) Date(s) of current qualification; and

(4) Qualification method(s).

(b) Records supporting an individual's current qualification shall

be maintained while the individual is performing the covered task.

Records of prior qualification and records of individuals no longer

performing covered tasks shall be retained for a period of five years.

Sec. 192.809 General.

(a) Operators must have a written qualification program by April

27, 2001.

(b) Operators must complete the qualification of individuals

performing covered tasks by October 28, 2002.

(c) Work performance history review may be used as a sole

evaluation method for individuals who were performing a covered task

prior to August 27, 1999.

(d) After October 28, 2002, work performance history may not be

used as a sole evaluation method.

PART 195--AMENDED

3. The authority citation for Part 195 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 49 U.S.C. 5103, 60102, 60104, 60108, 60109, 60118;

and 49 CFR 1.53.

4. Section 195.403 is revised to read as follows:

This section becomes effective October 28, 2002.

Sec. 195.403 Emergency response training.

(a) Each operator shall establish and conduct a continuing training

program to instruct emergency response personnel to:

(1) Carry out the emergency procedures established under 195.402

that relate to their assignments;

(2) Know the characteristics and hazards of the hazardous liquids

or carbon dioxide transported, including, in case of flammable HVL,

flammability of mixtures with air, odorless vapors, and water

reactions;

(3) Recognize conditions that are likely to cause emergencies,

predict the consequences of facility malfunctions or failures and

hazardous liquids or carbon dioxide spills, and take appropriate

corrective action;

(4) Take steps necessary to control any accidental release of

hazardous liquid or carbon dioxide and to minimize the potential for

fire, explosion, toxicity, or environmental damage; and

(5) Learn the proper use of firefighting procedures and equipment,

fire suits, and breathing apparatus by utilizing, where feasible, a

simulated pipeline emergency condition.

(b) At the intervals not exceeding 15 months, but at least once

each calendar year, each operator shall:

(1) Review with personnel their performance in meeting the

objectives of the emergency response training program set forth in

paragraph (a) of this section; and

(2) Make appropriate changes to the emergency response training

program as necessary to ensure that it is effective.

(c) Each operator shall require and verify that its supervisors

maintain a thorough knowledge of that portion of the emergency response

procedures established under 195.402 for which they are responsible to

ensure compliance.

Subpart G--[Added]

5. Subpart G is added to read as follows:

Sec.

195.501 Scope.

195.503 Definitions.

195.505 Qualification Program.

195.507 Recordkeeping.

195.509 General.

Sec. 195.501 Scope.

(a) This subpart prescribes the minimum requirements for operator

qualification of individuals performing covered tasks on a pipeline

facility.

(b) For the purpose of this subpart, a covered task is an activity,

identified by the operator, that:

(1) Is performed on a pipeline facility;

(2) Is an operations or maintenance task;

(3) Is performed as a requirement of this part; and

(4) Affects the operation or integrity of the pipeline.

Sec. 195.503 Definitions.

Abnormal operating condition means a condition identified by the

operator that may indicate a malfunction of a component or deviation

from normal operations that may:

(a) indicate a condition exceeding design limits; or

(b) result in a hazard(s) to persons, property, or the environment.

Evaluation means a process, established and documented by the

operator, to determine an individual's ability to perform a covered

task by any of the following:

(a) written examination;

(b) oral examination;

(c) work performance history review;

(d) observation during:

(e) performance on the job,

(f) on the job training, or

(g) simulations; or

(h) other forms of assessment.

Qualified means that an individual has been evaluated and can:

(a) perform assigned covered tasks and

(b) recognize and react to abnormal operating conditions.

Sec. 195.505 Qualification program.

Each operator shall have and follow a written qualification

program. The program shall include provisions to:

(a) Identify covered tasks;

(b) Ensure through evaluation that individuals performing covered

tasks are qualified;

(c) Allow individuals that are not qualified pursuant to this

subpart to perform a covered task if directed and observed by an

individual that is qualified;

(d) Evaluate an individual if the operator has reason to believe

that the individual's performance of a covered task contributed to an

accident as defined in Part 195;

(e) Evaluate an individual if the operator has reason to believe

that the individual is no longer qualified to perform a covered task;

(f) Communicate changes that affect covered tasks to individuals

performing those covered tasks; and

(g) Identify those covered tasks and the intervals at which

evaluation of the individual's qualifications is needed.

Sec. 195.507 Recordkeeping.

Each operator shall maintain records that demonstrate compliance

with this subpart.

(a) Qualification records shall include:

(1) Identification of qualified individual(s);

(2) Identification of the covered tasks the individual is qualified

to perform;

(3) Date(s) of current qualification; and

(4) Qualification method(s).

(b) Records supporting an individual's current qualification shall

be maintained while the individual is performing the covered task.

Records of prior qualification and records of individuals no longer

performing covered tasks shall be retained for a period of five years.

Sec. 195.509 General.

(a) Operators must have a written qualification program by April

27, 2001.

(b) Operators must complete the qualification of individuals

performing covered tasks by October 28, 2002.

(c) Work performance history review may be used as a sole

evaluation method for individuals who were performing a covered task

prior to August 27, 1999.

[[Page 46867]]

(d) After October 28, 2002, work performance history may not be

used as a sole evaluation method.

Issued in Washington, DC, on August 20, 1999.

Kelley S. Coyner,

Administrator.

[FR Doc. 99-22208 Filed 8-26-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.