Continuation Coverage Requirements Applicable to Group Health Plans

Federal RegisterFeb 3, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY

Internal Revenue Service

26 CFR Parts 54 and 602

[TD 8812]

RIN 1545-AI93

Continuation Coverage Requirements Applicable to Group Health

Plans

AGENCY: Internal Revenue Service (IRS), Treasury.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1985

(COBRA) added health care continuation requirements that apply to group

health plans. Coverage required to be provided under those requirements

is referred to as COBRA continuation coverage. Proposed regulations

interpreting the COBRA continuation coverage requirements were

published in the Federal Register of June 15, 1987 and of January 7,

1998. This document contains final regulations based on these two sets

of proposed regulations. The final regulations also reflect statutory

amendments to the COBRA continuation coverage requirements since COBRA

was enacted. A new set of proposed regulations addressing additional

issues under the COBRA continuation coverage provisions is being

published elsewhere in this issue of the Federal Register. The

regulations will generally affect sponsors of and participants in group

health plans, and they provide plan sponsors and plan administrators

with guidance necessary to comply with the law.

DATES: Effective Date: These regulations are effective February 3,

1999.

Applicability Dates: Sections 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8 apply

to group health plans with respect to qualifying events occurring in

plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2000. See the Effective

Date portion of this preamble and Q&A-2 of Sec. 54.4980B-1.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Yurlinda Mathis, 202-622-4695. This is

not a toll-free number.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Paperwork Reduction Act

The collections of information contained in these final regulations

have been reviewed and approved by the Office of Management and Budget

in accordance with the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3507)

under control number 1545-1581. Responses to these collections of

information are mandatory in some cases and required in order to obtain

a benefit in other cases. Group health plans are required to provide

certain individuals a notice of their COBRA continuation coverage

rights when certain qualifying events occur and are required to inform

health care providers who contact the plan to confirm the coverage of

certain individuals of the individuals' complete rights to coverage. To

obtain COBRA continuation coverage or extended coverage, certain

individuals are required to notify the plan administrator of certain

events or that they are electing COBRA continuation coverage, and plans

are required to notify certain individuals of insignificant

underpayments if the plan wishes to require the individuals to pay the

deficiency. This information will be used to advise employers and plan

administrators of their obligation to offer COBRA continuation

coverage, or an extended period of such coverage; to advise qualified

beneficiaries of their right to elect COBRA continuation coverage and

of insignificant errors in payment; and to inform health care providers

of individuals' rights to COBRA continuation coverage.

An agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required

to respond to, a collection of information unless the collection of

information displays a valid control number.

The estimated average annual burden per respondent varies from 30

seconds to 330 hours, depending on individual circumstances, with an

estimated average of 14 minutes.

Comments concerning the accuracy of this burden estimate and

suggestions for reducing this burden should be sent to the Internal

Revenue Service, Attn: IRS Reports Clearance Officer, OP:FS:FP,

Washington, DC 20224, and to the Office of Management and Budget, Attn:

Desk Officer for the Department of the Treasury, Office of Information

and Regulatory Affairs, Washington, DC 20503.

Books or records relating to these collections of information must

be retained as long as their contents may become material in the

administration of any internal revenue law. Generally, tax returns and

tax return information are confidential, as required by 26 U.S.C. 6103.

Background

On June 15, 1987, proposed regulations (EE-143-86) relating to

continuation coverage requirements applicable to group health plans

were published in the Federal Register (52 FR 22716). A public hearing

was held on November 4, 1987. Written comments were also received. A

supplemental set of proposed regulations (REG-209485-86) was published

in the Federal Register of January 7, 1998 (63 FR 708). No public

hearing was requested or held after the publication of the supplemental

proposed regulations; written comments were received. After

consideration of these comments, after review of the reported court

decisions under the parallel COBRA continuation coverage provisions of

the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) and the

Public Health Service Act, and based on the experience of the IRS in

administering the COBRA continuation coverage requirements, a portion

of the regulations proposed by EE-143-86 and REG-209485-86 is adopted

as revised by this Treasury decision. The revisions are summarized in

the explanation below. Also being published elsewhere in this issue of

the Federal Register is a new set of proposed regulations, which

addresses additional issues.

Explanation of Provisions

Overview

The regulations are intended to provide clear, administrable rules

regarding COBRA continuation coverage. The regulations give

comprehensive guidance on many questions under COBRA, with a view to

enhancing the certainty and reliance available to all parties--

including employees, qualified beneficiaries, employers, employee

organizations, and group health plans--in determining their COBRA

rights and obligations. The guidance is designed to further the

protective purposes of COBRA without undue administrative burdens or

costs on employers, employee organizations, or group health plans.

For example, the regulations:

Prevent group health plans from terminating COBRA

continuation coverage on the basis of other coverage that a qualified

beneficiary had prior to electing COBRA continuation coverage, in

accordance with the Supreme Court's

[[Page 5161]]

decision in Geissal v. Moore Medical Corp.

Give employers and employee organizations significant

flexibility in determining, for purposes of COBRA, the number of group

health plans they maintain. This will reduce burdens on employers and

employee organizations by permitting them to structure their group

health plans in an efficient and cost-effective manner and to satisfy

their COBRA obligations based upon that structure.

Provide baseline rules for determining the COBRA

liabilities of buyers and sellers of corporate stock and corporate

assets and permit buyers and sellers to reallocate and carry out those

liabilities by agreement. This will significantly enhance employers'

ability to negotiate and to plan appropriately for the treatment of

qualified beneficiaries in connection with mergers and acquisitions,

while protecting the rights of qualified beneficiaries affected by the

transactions.

Limit the application of COBRA for most health flexible

spending arrangements. This will ensure that COBRA continuation

coverage under health flexible spending arrangements is available in

appropriate cases without requiring continuation coverage where that

would not serve the statutory purposes.

Eliminate the requirement that group health plans offer

qualified beneficiaries the option to elect only core (health) coverage

under a group health plan that otherwise provides both core and noncore

(vision and dental) coverage.

Give employers, in determining whether the small-employer

plan exception applies, the option of counting by pay period rather

than by every business day, and provide, for that exception, for the

consistent treatment of part-time employees through the use of full-

time equivalents.

The COBRA continuation coverage requirements enacted on April 7,

1986 have been amended by the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1986

(OBRA 1986), the Tax Reform Act of 1986 (TRA 1986), the Technical and

Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988 (TAMRA), the Omnibus Budget

Reconciliation Act of 1989 (OBRA 1989), the Omnibus Budget

Reconciliation Act of 1990 (OBRA 1990), the Small Business Job

Protection Act of 1996 (SBJPA), and the Health Insurance Portability

and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA).\1\ These amendments made

numerous clarifications and modifications to the COBRA continuation

coverage requirements, moved the requirements from section 162(k) to

section 4980B, added various other features, such as the disability

extension to the required period of coverage, and significantly altered

the sanctions imposed on employers and plans for failing to comply with

the requirements. The specific changes made by these amendments are

discussed below in connection with the provisions of the regulations

that relate to them.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ The COBRA continuation coverage requirements have also been

affected by an amendment made to the definition of group health plan

by the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993 (OBRA 1993). OBRA

1993 amended the definition of group health plan in section

5000(b)(1), which the COBRA continuation coverage provisions of the

International Revenue Code incorporate by reference.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The legislative history of COBRA provides that the Department of

the Treasury has the authority to interpret the coverage and tax

sanction provisions of COBRA and that the Department of Labor has the

authority to interpret the reporting and disclosure provisions.

Accordingly, these regulations apply in interpreting the coverage

provisions of COBRA in Title I of ERISA, as well as those in the

Internal Revenue Code. With minor exceptions, the final regulations and

the new proposed regulations being published today do not address the

notice provisions of the COBRA continuation coverage requirements.

Organization

The final regulations being published today follow the structure of

the 1987 proposed regulations, with related questions-and-answers

grouped into topics. Each topic is now in a separate section, and

sections have been added to the new proposed regulations being

published today for (1) business reorganizations and employer

withdrawals from multiemployer plans and (2) the interaction of the

Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA) and COBRA. The substance of

the 1998 proposed regulations has been integrated into the questions-

and-answers of the 1987 proposed regulations. The ordering of some of

the questions-and-answers has changed, and all of the questions-and-

answers relating to the original statutory effective date have been

deleted. In addition, in a few cases, the content of two separate

questions-and-answers in the 1987 proposed regulations has been

combined into a single question-and-answer; in other cases the content

of a single question-and-answer has been expanded to two or more

questions-and-answers. These changes have resulted in the renumbering

of the questions-and-answers. The new proposed regulations being

published today are designed to fill gaps designated in the final

regulations as reserved.

Effective Date

The 1987 proposed regulations provide that they will be effective

upon publication as final regulations. Some commenters suggested that

the final regulations should have a delayed effective date. The final

regulations follow this suggestion; they apply with respect to

qualifying events occurring in plan years beginning on or after January

1, 2000. For any period before the effective date of the final

regulations, the plan and the employer must operate in good faith

compliance with a reasonable interpretation of the requirements in

section 4980B. For the period before the effective date of the final

regulations, the IRS will consider compliance with the proposed

regulations in Sec. 1.162-26 (the 1987 proposed regulations) and

Sec. 54.4980B-1 (the 1998 proposed regulations) to constitute good

faith compliance with a reasonable interpretation of the statutory

requirements for the topics that those proposed regulations address,

except to the extent inconsistent with a statutory amendment adopted

after the dates the proposed regulations were issued, during the period

the amendment is effective, or with a decision of the United States

Supreme Court released after the proposed regulations were issued,

during the period after the decision is released. For any period

beginning on or after the effective date of the final regulations with

respect to topics not addressed in the final regulations, such as how

to calculate the applicable premium, the plan and the employer must

operate in good faith compliance with a reasonable interpretation of

the requirements in section 4980B.

Compliance with the new proposed regulations will constitute good

faith compliance with a reasonable interpretation of the statutory

requirements addressed in the new proposed regulations until the new

proposed regulations are finalized. In addition, actions inconsistent

with the terms of the new proposed regulations will not necessarily

constitute a lack of good faith compliance with a reasonable

interpretation of the statutory requirements addressed in the new

proposed regulations; whether there has been good faith compliance with

a reasonable interpretation of the statutory requirements will depend

on

[[Page 5162]]

all the facts and circumstances of each case.

The IRS will not assess the excise tax with respect to a plan that

operates in good faith compliance with a reasonable interpretation of

the statutory requirements, as described in the preceding two

paragraphs. Note, however, that in the case of lawsuits brought by

qualified beneficiaries to enforce their COBRA continuation coverage

rights under ERISA or the Public Health Service Act, the courts

generally have not applied any good faith compliance standard.

Plans That Must Comply

The final regulations provide rules regarding which group health

plans are subject to COBRA. These rules are generally similar to those

set forth in the 1987 proposed regulations. However, the rules for

determining, for purposes of the COBRA continuation coverage

requirements, the number of group health plans maintained by an

employer have been deleted, and the new proposed regulations set forth

substantially different rules, which provide that employers and

employee organizations generally have broad discretion to determine the

number of group health plans that they maintain. Other significant

changes to the 1987 proposed regulations on this point (some of which

are set forth in the 1998 proposed regulations) include exceptions for

long-term care services and medical savings accounts and new rules

regarding the small-employer plan exception.

As in the 1987 proposed regulations, the final regulations provide

that, in general, all group health plans are subject to the COBRA

continuation coverage requirements. However, small-employer plans

(discussed below), church plans (within the meaning of section 414(e)),

and governmental plans (within the meaning of section 414(d)) are not

subject to COBRA. (The final regulations refer to these as plans

excepted from COBRA.) Plans excepted from COBRA are generally not

subject to the COBRA continuation coverage requirements or the COBRA

excise tax, although group health plans maintained by state or local

governments are subject to parallel continuation coverage requirements

in the Public Health Service Act (which is administered by the

Department of Health and Human Services). Also, the Federal Employees

Health Benefit Program is subject to generally similar, although not

parallel, temporary continuation of coverage provisions under the

Federal Employees Health Benefits Amendments Act of 1988.

The final regulations define group health plan in a manner

generally similar to that in the 1987 proposed regulations. However,

certain changes in terminology have been made to reflect the statutory

cross-reference to section 5000(b)(1) set forth in section 4980B(g)(2)

(such as the use of the term health care and the definition of

employee). Additionally, the final regulations, in accordance with

section 4980B(g)(2), provide that a plan is not a group health plan if

substantially all the coverage provided under the plan is for qualified

long-term care services (as defined in section 7702B(c)). The final

regulations allow plans to use any reasonable method in determining

whether a plan satisfies this exception. The final regulations also

provide, in accordance with section 106(b)(5), that amounts contributed

by an employer to a medical savings account (as defined in section

220(d)) are not considered part of a group health plan for purposes of

COBRA (although a high-deductible health plan will not fail to be a

group health plan simply because it covers a holder of a medical

savings account).

Under the final regulations, a group health plan is a plan

maintained by an employer or employee organization to provide health

care to individuals who have an employment-related connection to the

employer or employee organization or to the families of such

individuals. In accordance with section 5000(b)(1), these individuals

include employees, former employees, the employer, and others

associated or formerly associated with the employer or employee

organization in a business relationship. The final regulations

generally refer to all individuals covered under a plan by virtue of

the performance of services or by virtue of membership in an employee

organization as employees. (As discussed below, the term employee has a

narrower meaning for purposes of the small-employer plan exception.)

The final regulations use the term employer to refer to a person for

whom an individual performs services. Pursuant to section 414(t), the

term employer also includes, with respect to such a person, any member

of a group described in section 414(b), (c), (m), or (o) that includes

the person (a controlled group) as well as any successor of the person

or of a member of the controlled group.

Under the final regulations, as under the 1987 proposed

regulations, a plan generally is considered to provide health care

whether it does so directly or through insurance, reimbursement, or

other means and whether it does so through an on-site facility or a

cafeteria or other flexible benefit arrangement. Insurance includes

group insurance policies and one or more individual policies under an

arrangement maintained by the employer or employee organization to

provide health care to two or more employees. Under the final

regulations, as under the 1987 proposed regulations, in the case of a

cafeteria plan or other flexible benefit arrangement, the COBRA

continuation coverage requirements apply only to the health care

benefits under the cafeteria plan or other flexible benefit arrangement

that an employee has actually chosen to receive.

Many commenters on the 1987 proposed regulations requested

clarification of the application of COBRA to health care benefits

provided under flexible spending arrangements (health FSAs). Some

commentators argued that health FSAs should not be subject to COBRA.

Health FSAs satisfy the definition of group health plan in section

5000(b)(1) and, accordingly, are generally subject to the COBRA

continuation coverage requirements. However, COBRA is intended to

ensure that a qualified beneficiary has guaranteed access to coverage

under a group health plan and that the cost of that coverage is no

greater than 102 percent of the applicable premium.

The IRS and Treasury believe that the purposes of COBRA are not

furthered by requiring an employer to offer COBRA for a plan year if

the amount that the employer could require to be paid for the COBRA

coverage for the plan year would exceed the maximum benefit that the

qualified beneficiary could receive under the FSA for that plan year

and if the qualified beneficiary could not avoid a break in coverage,

for purposes of the HIPAA portability provisions,\2\ by electing COBRA

coverage under the FSA. Accordingly, the new proposed regulations

contain a rule limiting the application of the COBRA continuation

coverage requirements in the case of health FSAs.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\2\ Under HIPAA, a qualified beneficiary who maintains coverage

after termination of employment under a group health plan that is

subject to HIPAA can avoid a break in coverage and thereby avoid

becoming subject to a preexisting condition exclusion upon later

becoming covered by another group health plan.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Under this rule, if the health FSA satisfies two conditions, the

health FSA need not make COBRA continuation coverage available to a

qualified beneficiary for any plan year after the plan year in which

the qualifying event occurs. The first condition that the health FSA

must satisfy for this exception to apply is that the health FSA is not

subject to the HIPAA portability provisions in sections 9801

[[Page 5163]]

though 9833 because the benefits provided under the health FSA are

excepted benefits. (See sections 9831 and 9832.) \3\ The second

condition is that, in the plan year in which the qualifying event of a

qualified beneficiary occurs, the maximum amount that the health FSA

could require to be paid for a full plan year of COBRA continuation

coverage equals or exceeds the maximum benefit available under the

health FSA for the year. It is contemplated that this second condition

will be satisfied in most cases.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ The IRS and Treasury, together with the U.S. Department of

Labor and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, have

issued a notice (62 FR 67688) holding that a health FSA is exempt

from HIPAA because the benefits provided under it are excepted

benefits under sections 9831 and 9832 if the employer also provides

another group health plan, the benefits under the other plan are not

limited to excepted benefits, and the maximum reimbursement under

the health FSA is not greater than two times the employee's salary

reduction election (or if greater, the employee's salary reduction

election plus five hundred dollars.)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Moreover, if a third condition is satisfied, the health FSA need

not make COBRA continuation coverage available with respect to a

qualified beneficiary at all. This third condition is satisfied if, as

of the date of the qualifying event, the maximum benefit available to

the qualified beneficiary under the health FSA for the remainder of the

plan year is not more than the maximum amount that the plan could

require as payment for the remainder of that year to maintain coverage

under the health FSA.

A plan is maintained by an employer or employee organization even

if the employer or employee organization does not directly or

indirectly contribute to it if coverage under the plan would not be

available to an individual at the same cost if the individual did not

have an employment-related connection to the employer or employee

organization. The final regulations, for purposes of the definition of

a group health plan, use the term health care instead of the term

medical care (which was used in the 1987 proposed regulations). This

change reflects the change in the definition of group health plan made

by OBRA 1989. However, the final regulations provide that health care

has the same meaning as the term medical care under section 213(d).

Like the 1987 proposed regulations, the final regulations set forth a

summary of items that do and do not constitute health care.

The final regulations, generally following the 1987 proposed

regulations, set forth rules for determining whether a group health

plan is a small-employer plan. In general, a group health plan other

than a multiemployer plan is a small-employer plan if it is maintained

for a calendar year by an employer that normally employed fewer than 20

employees during the preceding calendar year, and a group health plan

that is a multiemployer plan is a small-employer plan if each of the

employers contributing to the plan for a calendar year normally

employed fewer than 20 employees during the preceding calendar year.

Whether the plan is a multiemployer plan or not, the term employer

includes all members of a controlled group. An example in the final

regulations clarifies that the controlled group includes foreign

members, and thus a U.S. subsidiary with fewer than 20 employees is

subject to COBRA if the controlled group has 20 or more employees

world-wide. The final regulations set forth additional rules for the

application of the small-employer plan exception to multiemployer

plans, and the new proposed regulations contain the same definition of

multiemployer plan that is in section 414(f).

Under the final regulations, an employer is considered to have

normally employed fewer than 20 employees during a particular calendar

year if it had fewer than 20 employees on at least 50 percent of its

typical business days during that year. This rule differs from the rule

in the 1987 proposed regulations in two ways. First, the 1987 proposed

regulations use the term working days, whereas the final regulations

use the statutory term typical business days.

The second difference relates to the term employee. Under the 1987

proposed regulations, self-employed individuals and independent

contractors are counted as employees for purposes of the small-employer

plan exception if they are covered under a plan of the employer.

Commenters argued that only common law employees should be counted for

this purpose. Unlike the definition of covered employee (amended by

OBRA 1989 to make clear that individuals who are not common law

employees but who are covered under the group health plan of an

employer or employee organization by virtue of the performance of

services are still considered covered employees) and the definition of

group health plan (amended by OBRA 1993 to make clear that a health

plan covering individuals who are not common law employees of the

employer or employee organization, and who are not family members of

common law employees, is still a group health plan) the reference to

employees for purposes of the small-employer plan exception have not

been amended to include individuals who are not common law employees.

Consequently, under the final regulations, only common law employees

are taken into account for purposes of the small-employer plan

exception; self-employed individuals, independent contractors, and

directors are not counted.

Although a small-employer plan is generally excepted from COBRA, a

plan that is not a small-employer plan for a period remains subject to

COBRA for qualifying events that occurred during that period, even if

it subsequently becomes a small-employer plan.

In determining whether a plan is eligible for the small-employer

plan exception, part-time employees, as well as full-time employees,

must be taken into account. Several commenters on the 1987 proposed

regulations requested clarification of how to count part-time employees

for the small-employer plan exception, and the new proposed regulations

provide guidance on this issue. Under the new proposed regulations,

instead of each part-time employee counting as a full employee, each

part-time employee counts as a fraction of an employee, with the

fraction equal to the number of hours that the part-time employee works

for the employer divided by the number of hours that an employee must

work in order to be considered a full-time employee. The number of

hours that must be worked to be considered a full-time employee is

determined in a manner consistent with the employer's general

employment practices, although for this purpose not more than eight

hours a day or 40 hours a week may be used. An employer may count

employees for each typical business day or may count employees for a

pay period and attribute the total number of employees for that pay

period to each typical business day that falls within the pay period.

The employer must use the same method for all employees and for the

entire year for which the small-employer plan determination is made.

In determining whether a multiemployer plan satisfies the

requirements for the small-employer plan exception, the 1987 proposed

regulations provide a special rule permitting the multiemployer plan to

be considered a small-employer plan for a year if any contributing

employer that grew to be too large to qualify for the exception during

the preceding year ceases to contribute to the plan by February 1 of

the current year. Questions have been raised about the need for and the

authority for this special rule, and one commenter pointed out the

uncertainty of how to

[[Page 5164]]

deal with a qualified beneficiary experiencing a qualifying event under

such a plan in January of the current year if the qualified beneficiary

needed confirmation of coverage for urgent services before it was clear

that the too-large employer would cease contributing to the

multiemployer plan by February 1. Based on these concerns, the final

regulations eliminate this special rule for multiemployer plans.

The new proposed regulations provide guidance, for purposes of the

COBRA continuation coverage requirements, on how to determine the

number of group health plans that an employer or employee organization

maintains. Under these rules, the employer or employee organization is

generally permitted to establish the separate identity and number of

group health plans under which it provides health care benefits to

employees. Thus, if an employer or employee organization provides a

variety of health care benefits to employees, it generally may

aggregate the benefits into a single group health plan or disaggregate

benefits into separate group health plans. The status of health care

benefits as part of a single group health plan or as separate plans is

determined by reference to the instruments governing those

arrangements. If it is not clear from the instruments governing an

arrangement or arrangements to provide health care benefits whether the

benefits are provided under one plan or more than one plan, or if there

are no instruments governing the arrangement or arrangements, all such

health care benefits (other than those for qualified long-term care

services) provided by a single entity (determined without regard to the

controlled group) constitute a single group health plan.

Under the new proposed regulations, a multiemployer plan and a plan

other than a multiemployer plan are always separate plans. In addition,

any treatment of health care benefits as constituting separate group

health plans will be disregarded if a principal purpose of the

treatment is to evade any requirement of law. Of course, an employer's

flexibility to treat benefits as part of separate plans may be limited

by the operation of other laws, such as the prohibition in section 9802

on conditioning eligibility to enroll in a group health plan on the

basis of any health factor of an individual.

The final regulations modify the rules set forth in the 1987

proposed regulations for determining the plan year of a group health

plan under COBRA. These modifications are made to be consistent with

the rules in the temporary regulations under HIPAA. The definition of

plan year is important in applying, for example, the effective date

provisions under the final regulations and the rules for health FSAs

under the new proposed regulations. Under the final regulations, the

plan year is the year designated as such in the plan documents. If the

plan documents do not designate a plan year (or if there are no plan

documents), the plan year is the deductible/limit year used by the

plan. If the plan does not impose deductibles or limits on an annual

basis, the plan year is the policy year. If the plan does not impose

deductibles or limits on an annual basis and the plan is not insured

(or the insurance policy is not renewed annually), the plan year is the

taxable year of the employer. In any other case, the plan year is the

calendar year.

The final regulations reflect the statutory provisions that provide

for the imposition of an excise tax in the event of a failure by a

group health plan to comply with the COBRA continuation coverage

requirements of section 4980B(f). In the case of a multiemployer plan,

the excise tax is imposed on the plan; \4\ in the case of any other

plan, the excise tax is imposed on the employer maintaining the plan.

In certain circumstances, the excise tax can be imposed on other

persons involved with the provision of benefits under the plan, such as

an insurer providing benefits under the plan or a third party

administrator administering claims under the plan. Separate, non-tax

remedies may be available in the case of a plan that fails to comply

with the COBRA continuation coverage requirements in ERISA.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\4\ In this regard, the U.S. Department of labor has advised the

IRS and Treasury that to the extent a plan fiduciary subjects a plan

to liability for the COBRA excise tax on account of her or his

imprudent actions, the plan fiduciary may be held personally liable

under Title I of ERISA for the amount of the tax.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Qualified Beneficiaries

The rules in the final regulations for determining who is a

qualified beneficiary generally follow those set forth in the 1987

proposed regulations, as well as those set forth in the 1998 proposed

regulations regarding the status of newborn and adopted children as

qualified beneficiaries. However, certain provisions have been added to

the final regulations to reflect the special statutory rules that apply

in the case of bankruptcy of the employer as a qualifying event.

Modifications have also been made to reflect the decision of the

Supreme Court in Geissal v. Moore Medical Corp., 118 S. Ct. 1869

(1998), which held that an individual covered under another group

health plan at the time she or he elects COBRA continuation coverage

cannot be denied COBRA continuation coverage on the basis of that other

coverage.

Under the final regulations, a qualified beneficiary is, in

general: (1) any individual who, on the day before a qualifying event,

is covered under a group health plan either as a covered employee, the

spouse of a covered employee, or the dependent child of a covered

employee; or (2) any child born to or placed for adoption with a

covered employee during a period of COBRA continuation coverage. (The

final regulations retain the definitions of the terms placement for

adoption and being placed for adoption that were in the 1998 proposed

regulations.) For a qualifying event that is the bankruptcy of the

employer, any covered employee who retired on or before the date of any

substantial elimination of group health plan coverage is a qualified

beneficiary; the spouse, surviving spouse, or dependent child of the

retired covered employee is also a qualified beneficiary if the spouse,

surviving spouse, or dependent child was a beneficiary under the plan

on the day before the bankruptcy qualifying event. The final

regulations add a provision clarifying that if an individual is denied

coverage under a group health plan in violation of applicable law

(including HIPAA) and experiences an event that would be a qualifying

event if the coverage had not been wrongfully denied, the individual is

considered a qualified beneficiary.

A covered employee can be a qualified beneficiary only in

connection with a qualifying event that is the termination (or

reduction of hours) of the covered employee's employment or the

employer's bankruptcy. As under the 1987 proposed regulations, the

final regulations provide that a covered employee is not a qualified

beneficiary if her or his status as a covered employee is attributable

to certain periods in which she or he was a nonresident alien (in which

case the covered employee's spouse and dependent children are also not

qualified beneficiaries). Although a child born to or placed for

adoption with a covered employee during a period of COBRA continuation

coverage is a qualified beneficiary, a child born to or placed for

adoption with a qualified beneficiary other than the covered employee

after a qualifying event, or a person who becomes the spouse of a

qualified beneficiary (regardless of whether the qualified beneficiary

is the covered employee) after a qualifying event is not a qualified

[[Page 5165]]

beneficiary. The final regulations retain the rule of the 1987 proposed

regulations under which an individual is not a qualified beneficiary

if, on the day before the qualifying event, the individual is covered

under the group health plan solely because of another individual's

election of COBRA continuation coverage. However, consistent with

Geissal, the final regulations eliminate the rule in the 1987 proposed

regulations that an individual is not a qualified beneficiary if, on

the day before the qualifying event, the individual was entitled to

Medicare benefits.

An individual ceases to be a qualified beneficiary if she or he

does not elect COBRA continuation coverage by the end of the election

period (discussed below). The final regulations clarify that an

individual who elects COBRA continuation coverage ceases to be a

qualified beneficiary once the plan's obligation to provide COBRA

continuation coverage has ended.

The term covered employee is defined in the final regulations in a

manner substantially the same as in the 1987 proposed regulations.

Although some commenters on the 1987 proposed regulations objected to

the inclusion in this definition of individuals other than common law

employees, the statutory definition was amended by OBRA 1989 to include

such individuals.

Under the final regulations, a covered employee generally includes

any individual who is or has been provided coverage under a group

health plan (other than one excepted from COBRA as of the date of what

would otherwise be a qualifying event) because of her or his present or

past performance of services for the employer maintaining the group

health plan (or by reason of membership in the employee organization

maintaining the plan). Thus, retirees and former employees covered by a

group health plan are covered employees if the coverage is provided in

whole or in part because of the previous employment. Any individual who

performs services for the employer maintaining the plan or who is a

member of the employee organization maintaining the plan may be a

covered employee. Thus, common law employees, self-employed

individuals, independent contractors, and corporate directors can be

covered employees. Generally, mere eligibility for coverage--as opposed

to actual coverage--does not make an individual a covered employee.

However, if an individual who otherwise would be a covered employee is

denied coverage under a group health plan in violation of applicable

law (including HIPAA), the individual is considered a covered employee.

Qualifying Events

The rules regarding qualifying events under the final regulations

generally are the same as those in the 1987 proposed regulations. Under

the final regulations, a qualifying event is any of a set of specified

events that occurs while a group health plan is subject to COBRA and

that causes a covered employee (or the spouse or dependent child of the

covered employee) to lose coverage under the plan. These specified

events are: the death of a covered employee; the termination (other

than by reason of gross misconduct), or reduction of hours, of a

covered employee's employment; the divorce or legal separation of a

covered employee from the covered employee's spouse; a covered

employee's becoming entitled to Medicare benefits under Title XVIII of

the Social Security Act; a dependent child's ceasing to be a dependent

child of the covered employee under the plan; and a proceeding in

bankruptcy under Title 11 of the United States Code with respect to an

employer from whose employment a covered employee retired at any time.

The addition of employer bankruptcy as a qualifying event reflects the

amendments made to COBRA by OBRA 1986.

The reasons for which an employee has a termination of employment

or a reduction of hours of employment generally are not relevant in

determining whether the termination or reduction of hours is a

qualifying event. Thus, a voluntary termination, a strike, a lockout, a

layoff, or an involuntary discharge each may constitute a qualifying

event. However, if an employee is discharged for gross misconduct, the

termination of employment does not constitute a qualifying event. The

final regulations clarify that a reduction of hours of a covered

employee's employment includes any decrease in the number of hours that

a covered employee works or is required to work that does not

constitute a termination of employment. Thus, if a covered employee

takes a leave of absence, is laid off, or otherwise performs no hours

of work during a period, the covered employee has experienced a

reduction in hours that, if the other applicable requirements are

satisfied, constitutes a qualifying event. (But see Notice 94-103

(1994-2 C.B. 569) and the new proposed regulations, described below,

for special rules regarding FMLA leave.) A covered employee's loss of

coverage by reason of a failure to work the minimum number of hours

required for coverage constitutes a reduction of hours of employment.

Under the final regulations, to lose coverage means to cease to be

covered under the same terms and conditions as in effect immediately

before the event. The final regulations clarify that a loss of coverage

includes an increase in an employee premium or contribution resulting

from one of the events described above. The loss of coverage need not

be concurrent with the event; it is enough that the loss of coverage

occur at any time before the end of the maximum coverage period

(described below). For employer bankruptcies, the term to lose coverage

also includes a substantial elimination of coverage that occurs within

12 months before or after the date on which the bankruptcy proceeding

begins.

Under the final regulations, as under the 1987 proposed

regulations, reductions or eliminations in coverage in anticipation of

an event are disregarded in determining whether the event results in a

loss of coverage. Although several commenters objected to this rule,

the final regulations retain the provision in order to protect

qualified beneficiaries from being deprived of their COBRA rights

because an employer or employee organization transposes a loss or

reduction of coverage to a time before the qualifying event. This rule

also applies in cases where a covered employee discontinues the

coverage of a spouse in anticipation of a divorce or legal separation.

In such a case, upon receiving notice of the divorce or legal

separation, a plan is required to make COBRA continuation coverage

available, effective on the date of the divorce or legal separation

(but not for any period before the date of the divorce or legal

separation).

Under the final regulations, as under the 1987 proposed

regulations, an event must occur while the group health plan is subject

to COBRA in order to constitute a qualifying event. A plan that is

excepted from COBRA (for example, by reason of the small-employer plan

exception) and that later becomes subject to COBRA is not required to

provide COBRA continuation coverage to individuals who experienced what

would otherwise be a qualifying event during the period when the plan

was not subject to COBRA.

Finally, in the case of a child born to or placed for adoption with

a covered employee during a period of COBRA continuation coverage, the

qualifying event that gives rise to that period of COBRA continuation

coverage is the qualifying event applicable to that child. Thus, if a

second qualifying event has

[[Page 5166]]

occurred before such a child is born (for example, if the covered

employee dies), the second qualifying event also applies to the newborn

child.

COBRA Continuation Coverage

The 1987 proposed regulations generally refer to the coverage that

a qualified beneficiary is entitled to as the coverage that was in

effect on the day before the qualifying event. While that is generally

true, the final regulations have been revised to incorporate the

statutory standard that a qualified beneficiary is entitled to the

coverage made available to similarly situated beneficiaries with

respect to whom a qualifying event has not occurred. The final

regulations generally use as a shorthand for this statutory language

the phrase ``similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries'' instead of the

phrase ``similarly situated active employees'' used in the 1987

proposed regulations. In certain contexts in the final regulations,

though, the phrase ``similarly situated active employees'' is still

used because in those contexts--such as the right to make an

independent election for COBRA continuation coverage--qualified

beneficiaries who are spouses and dependent children of covered

employees are entitled to the rights that employees have (and in those

contexts, spouses and dependent children who are not qualified

beneficiaries typically do not have the rights that employees have).

The 1987 proposed regulations address in a separate question-and-

answer the type of coverage that must be made available to qualified

beneficiaries if a change is made in the coverage provided to similarly

situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries. The final regulations include this

rule in the question-and-answer that defines COBRA continuation

coverage. In doing so, the final regulations delete several specific

requirements in the 1987 proposed regulations. For example, if coverage

for the similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries is changed or

eliminated, the 1987 proposed regulations require that qualified

beneficiaries be permitted to elect coverage under any remaining plan

made available to the similarly situated active employees. Many

commenters objected that in the case of a mere change in benefits, the

requirement to give qualified beneficiaries an election among other

plans would give them greater rights than those active employees might

have. The final regulations follow the suggestion of the commenters in

providing that the general principle--that qualified beneficiaries have

the same rights as similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries--applies

in this situation. The same principle also applies in determining

whether credit for deductibles must be carried over from a discontinued

plan to a new plan. Nevertheless, if an employer or employee

organization providing more than one plan to a group of similarly

situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries eliminates benefits under one plan

without giving the similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries the right

to enroll in another plan, that option would still have to be made

available to qualified beneficiaries if the employer continued to

maintain a group health plan because of the employer's obligation to

continue to make COBRA continuation coverage available.

The 1987 proposed regulations include detailed rules requiring that

qualified beneficiaries generally be offered the option of electing

only core coverage or both core and noncore coverage. These rules were

based on a reference in the conference report to the Tax Reform Act of

1986. Many commenters expressed the opinion that the reference in the

conference report is an insufficient basis for including this concept

in the regulations when nothing in the statute itself suggests a

distinction between core and noncore coverage. Commenters also

contended that the core/noncore distinction would create undue

administrative complexity and promote adverse selection. After careful

consideration, the IRS and Treasury have decided not to include in

either the final or the new proposed regulations any such requirement

to offer for core coverage separately. However, comments are invited on

whether such a requirement should be adopted.

The 1987 proposed regulations establish standards for determining

the deductibles and limits that apply to COBRA continuation coverage in

a period in which an individual or a group of family members has

coverage that is not COBRA continuation coverage and then elects COBRA

continuation coverage. (Of course, during a period in which an

individual or group of family members had only COBRA continuation

coverage, the rules for deductibles and limits would apply to them in

the same manner as they would to similarly situated nonCOBRA

beneficiaries.) Some commenters objected to the provisions of the 1987

proposed regulations for computing deductibles or limits on a family

basis in the case of a qualifying event (such as divorce) that splits a

family into two (or more) units. The 1987 proposed regulations would

require that each resulting family unit be credited with all the

expenses incurred by the entire family before the qualifying event. The

final regulations revise this rule. Under the final regulations, in

computing deductibles and limits for the family unit receiving COBRA

coverage, the plan is required to take into account only those expenses

incurred before the qualifying event by family members who are part of

the resulting family unit after the qualifying event.

The 1987 proposed regulations provide that qualified beneficiaries

moving outside the area served by a region-specific plan must be given

the right to obtain other coverage from the employer maintaining the

region-specific plan. The rule conditions the right to other coverage

on the employer having employees in the area to which the qualified

beneficiary is moving. This proposed rule unduly limits the application

of the rule in the case of an employer or employee organization that

could provide other coverage to the qualified beneficiary without

having to establish a new plan or enter into a new group insurance

contract even though the employer did not have employees or the

employee organization did not have members in the area that the

qualified beneficiary was moving to. This might be the case, for

example, if the employer or employee organization maintained a self-

insured plan or maintained an insured plan through an insurance company

licensed to provide that same product in the area that the qualified

beneficiary was moving to. The final regulations eliminate the

condition that an employer have employees in the area to which the

qualified beneficiary is moving and instead require that coverage be

made available to the qualified beneficiary if the employer or employee

organization would be able to provide coverage to the qualified

beneficiary under one of its existing plans. Generally the coverage

that must be made available is that made available to the similarly

situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries. If, however, the coverage made

available to the similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries cannot be

made available in the area that the qualified beneficiary is moving to,

then the coverage that must be made available is coverage provided to

other employees.

The 1987 proposed regulations require, in the case of a plan

providing open enrollment rights, that open enrollment rights be

extended to qualified beneficiaries if an employer maintains two or

more plans. Thus, that rule, by its terms, does not require that open

enrollment rights be given if an

[[Page 5167]]

employer maintains a single plan and allows active employees during

open enrollment to switch between categories of coverage such as single

and family or among categories such as employee-only, employee-plus-

one-dependent, or employee-plus-two-or-more-dependents. The final

regulations eliminate the condition that an employer or employee

organization maintain two or more plans for a qualified beneficiary to

have open enrollment rights. Thus, open enrollment rights must be

extended to qualified beneficiaries in any case in which they are

extended to similarly situated active employees. (Note that the open

enrollment right of employees to enroll when not previously enrolled

would not have to be extended to individuals who previously did not

elect to receive COBRA continuation coverage because an individual

ceases to be a qualified beneficiary if COBRA continuation coverage is

not elected.)

The 1987 proposed regulations require that qualified beneficiaries

be given the same right to add new family members that similarly

situated active employees have. Many commenters objected to this rule,

arguing that it requires more than a mere continuation of coverage.

However, COBRA continuation coverage is more than just a continuation

of the coverage a qualified beneficiary had before the qualifying

event; it includes the same procedural rights to expand or change

coverage that similarly situated active employees have. Moreover, the

policy behind the 1987 proposed regulations is reflected in the HIPAA

amendment to COBRA creating special qualified beneficiary status for

certain newborn and adopted children as well as in the HIPAA special

enrollment rights in section 9801(f) for new spouses and for newborn

and adopted children. Accordingly, the final regulations provide

guidance on the application of the HIPAA special enrollment rights to

qualified beneficiaries and retain the rule in the 1987 proposed

regulations regarding the right of qualified beneficiaries to add new

family members (even though not eligible for the HIPAA special

enrollment rights) to the same extent that active employees are

permitted to add new family members.

Electing COBRA Continuation Coverage

The final regulations set forth rules regarding elections of COBRA

continuation coverage by qualified beneficiaries. In general, a group

health plan is required to offer a qualified beneficiary the

opportunity to elect COBRA continuation coverage at any time during the

election period. The election period begins not later than the date the

qualified beneficiary would lose coverage by reason of a qualifying

event and ends not earlier than 60 days after the later of that date or

60 days after the date on which the qualified beneficiary is provided

notice of her or his right to elect COBRA continuation coverage. For

purposes of determining whether a qualified beneficiary's election of

COBRA continuation coverage is timely, the election is deemed to be

made on the date it is sent to the employer or plan administrator. The

final regulations clarify that a qualified beneficiary need not herself

or himself elect COBRA continuation coverage; that election can be made

on behalf of the qualified beneficiary by a third party (including a

third party that is not a qualified beneficiary).

Generally, the employer or plan administrator must determine when a

qualifying event has occurred, and a qualified beneficiary is not

required to give notice of the event. However, a covered employee or

qualified beneficiary is required to notify the plan administrator of a

qualifying event that is a divorce or legal separation of the covered

employee or a dependent child's ceasing to be a dependent child under

the plan terms. The 1987 proposed regulations prescribe that the

notification should be given to the employer or other plan

administrator. The final regulations simply require that the notice be

provided to the plan administrator.

The notice must be provided within 60 days after the date of the

qualifying event or the date on which the qualified beneficiary would

lose coverage because of the qualifying event, whichever is later. If

the notice is not provided, the group health plan is not required to

make COBRA continuation coverage available to the qualified

beneficiary.\5\ In the case of the covered employee's divorce or legal

separation, a single notice sent by or on behalf of the covered

employee or any one of the qualified beneficiaries (that is, the spouse

or a dependent child) satisfies the notice requirement for all those

who become qualified beneficiaries as a result of the divorce or legal

separation.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\5\ The U.S. Department of Labor has advised the IRS and

Treasury that, if a covered employee or qualified beneficiary has

not been adequately informed of the obligation to provide notice in

the case of a qualifying event that is the divorce or legal

separation of the covered employee or that is a dependent child's

ceasing to be covered under the generally applicable requirements of

the plan, the covered employee's or qualified beneficiary's failure

to provide timely notice to the plan administrator will not affect

the plan's obligation to make continuation coverage available upon

receiving notice of such event.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The group health plan must make COBRA continuation coverage

available for the entire election period if the qualified beneficiary

elects coverage prior to the end of the period (except in the case of a

revoked waiver, as discussed below). An employer or employee

organization maintaining a group health plan using an indemnity or

reimbursement arrangement can satisfy this requirement by continuing

the qualified beneficiary's coverage during the election period or by

discontinuing the coverage until the qualified beneficiary elects COBRA

and then retroactively reinstating the qualified beneficiary's

coverage. Under the final regulations, as under the 1987 proposed

regulations, the date of the qualifying event (and thus, the beginning

of the maximum coverage period) is not delayed merely because a plan

provides coverage during the election period. Claims incurred by the

qualified beneficiary during the election period do not have to be paid

until COBRA continuation coverage is elected and any payment required

for coverage is made.

For a group health plan providing health services--including a

health maintenance organization or a walk-in clinic--a qualified

beneficiary who has not elected and paid for COBRA continuation

coverage can be required to choose either to elect and to pay for

coverage or to pay a reasonable and customary charge for plan services

(but only if the qualified beneficiary will be reimbursed for that

charge within 30 days after she or he elects COBRA continuation

coverage and makes any payment for coverage). Alternatively, the plan

can treat the qualified beneficiary's use of the plan's health services

as a constructive election of COBRA continuation coverage and, if it so

notifies the qualified beneficiary prior to the use of services, can

require payment for COBRA continuation coverage.

The final regulations adopt the position in Communications Workers

of America v. NYNEX Corp., 898 F.2d 887 (2d Cir. 1989), regarding the

responses that a group health plan must make with respect to the rights

of a qualified beneficiary during that qualified beneficiary's election

period. Specifically, the final regulations require that the plan make

a complete response to any inquiry from a health care provider

regarding the qualified beneficiary's right to coverage under the plan

during the election period. Thus, if the qualified beneficiary has not

yet elected COBRA continuation coverage

[[Page 5168]]

but remains covered under the plan during the election period (subject

to retroactive cancellation if no election is made), the plan must so

inform the health care provider. Conversely, if the qualified

beneficiary is not covered during the election period prior to her or

his election, the plan must inform the health care provider that the

qualified beneficiary does not have current coverage but will have

retroactive coverage if COBRA continuation coverage is elected. (The

final regulations also include similar requirements with respect to

inquiries made by health care providers during the 30- and 45-day grace

periods for paying for COBRA continuation coverage.)

A qualified beneficiary who waives COBRA continuation coverage

during the election period can revoke the waiver before the end of the

election period, but the group health plan is not then required to

provide coverage as of any date prior to the revocation. Although

several commenters objected to the rule in the 1987 proposed

regulations allowing the revocation during the election period of any

previous waiver, the final regulations retain this rule. If the rule

permitted irrevocable waivers, plans might induce qualified

beneficiaries to execute waivers hastily before becoming fully informed

of their rights and having the opportunity to carefully consider

whether to elect COBRA. As with the election of COBRA continuation

coverage, a waiver or a revocation of a waiver is deemed to be made on

the date sent. The employer or employee organization maintaining the

group health plan is not permitted to withhold money, benefits, or

anything else to which the qualified beneficiary is entitled under any

law or agreement in order to induce a qualified beneficiary to make

payment for COBRA continuation coverage or to surrender any rights

under COBRA. Any waiver of COBRA continuation coverage rights obtained

through such means will be invalid. However, the general rules for

coverage during the election period apply in the case of waivers and

revocations of waivers. Thus, in the case of an indemnity arrangement,

the plan can deny coverage for claims until payment for the coverage

has been made (as can also be done with those health maintenance

organizations or walk-in clinics that adopt this method for complying

with the COBRA continuation coverage requirements during the election

period).

A group health plan must offer each qualified beneficiary the

opportunity to make an independent election to receive COBRA

continuation coverage and, during an open enrollment period, to choose

among any options available to similarly situated active employees.

This requirement also applies to any child born to or placed for

adoption with a covered employee during a period of COBRA continuation

coverage. (An election for a minor child may be made by the child's

parent or legal guardian.) If a covered employee or the spouse of a

covered employee elects COBRA continuation coverage and the election

does not specify whether the election is for self-only coverage, the

election is deemed to include an election of COBRA continuation

coverage on behalf of other qualified beneficiaries with respect to

that qualifying event.

Duration of COBRA Continuation Coverage

The 1987 proposed regulations incorporate the statutory bases for

terminating COBRA continuation coverage except the rule (added by OBRA

1989 and amended by HIPAA) that COBRA coverage can be terminated in the

month that is more than 30 days after a final determination that a

qualified beneficiary is no longer disabled. The new proposed

regulations add this statutory basis for terminating COBRA coverage,

with two clarifications. First, the new proposed regulations clarify

that a determination that a qualified beneficiary is no longer disabled

allows termination of COBRA continuation coverage for all qualified

beneficiaries who were entitled to the disability extension by reason

of the disability of the qualified beneficiary who has been determined

to no longer be disabled. Second, the new proposed regulations clarify

that such a determination does not allow termination of the COBRA

continuation coverage of a qualified beneficiary before the end of the

maximum coverage period that would apply without regard to the

disability extension.

Section 4980B(f)(2)(B)(iv) provides that a qualified beneficiary's

right to COBRA continuation coverage may be terminated when the

qualified beneficiary ``first becomes,'' after the date of the COBRA

election, covered under another group health plan (subject to certain

additional conditions) or entitled to Medicare benefits. The final

regulations add two new questions-and-answers that provide guidance on

this provision.

The 1987 proposed regulations substitute ``is'' for the statutory

phrase ``first becomes.'' The effect of this substitution was to permit

an employer to cut off a qualified beneficiary's right to COBRA

continuation coverage based upon other group health plan coverage that

the qualified beneficiary first became covered under before she or he

elected COBRA coverage. In the case of entitlement to Medicare

benefits, the 1987 proposed regulations not only shift the statutory

``becomes'' to ``is,'' they also exclude from the definition of

qualified beneficiary anyone who is entitled to Medicare benefits on

the day before the qualifying event. After careful consideration, the

IRS and Treasury concluded that the better interpretation of the

statute is that other group health plan coverage that a qualified

beneficiary has before the COBRA election is not a basis for cutting

off the qualified beneficiary's right to COBRA continuation coverage.

(The same rule applies for entitlement to Medicare benefits.)

Based upon the recommendation of the IRS, the Solicitor General

filed an amicus brief before the Supreme Court urging this position,

which was unanimously adopted by the Supreme Court in Geissal v. Moore

Medical Corp., 118 S. Ct. 1869 (1998). The final regulations adopt the

position urged by the IRS and Treasury and adopted by the Court in

Geissal. They provide that an employer may cut off the right to COBRA

continuation coverage based upon other group health plan coverage or

entitlement to Medicare benefits only if the qualified beneficiary

first becomes covered under the other group health plan coverage or

entitled to the Medicare benefits after the date of the COBRA election.

The statutory rule allowing a plan to discontinue COBRA

continuation coverage on account of coverage under another group health

plan was amended by OBRA 1989 to prohibit the discontinuance if the

qualified beneficiary's other coverage was subject to a preexisting

condition exclusion. This amendment was further modified by HIPAA to

allow discontinuance of COBRA continuation coverage if the preexisting

condition exclusion does not apply or is satisfied by reason of the

limitations on preexisting condition exclusions in section 9801. The

final regulations reflect this amendment and clarify that coverage

under another group health plan includes coverage under a governmental

plan.

Many commenters asked whether mere eligibility for Medicare

justifies a discontinuance of COBRA continuation coverage. In addition,

many inquiries have been received that ask whether the qualified

beneficiary must be entitled to both Part A and B of Medicare. The

final regulations clarify that entitlement to Medicare benefits means

being enrolled

[[Page 5169]]

in Medicare and does not mean merely being eligible to enroll in

Medicare. The final regulations also clarify that being entitled to

either Part A or B is sufficient for the plan to discontinue COBRA

continuation coverage (assuming that the entitlement to Medicare

benefits first arises after COBRA continuation coverage has been

elected).

The 1987 proposed regulations allow a plan to discontinue providing

COBRA continuation coverage to a qualified beneficiary for cause on the

same basis that the plan could terminate for cause the coverage of a

similarly situated active employee (except for payments that would be

untimely if made by a nonCOBRA beneficiary but that are made within the

grace periods provided by COBRA). The final regulations provide that,

for example, if a plan terminates the coverage of similarly situated

active employees for the submission of a fraudulent claim, then the

COBRA continuation coverage of a qualified beneficiary can also be

terminated for the submission of a fraudulent claim.

The 1987 proposed regulations reflect the statutory rules that were

then in effect for the maximum period that a plan is required to make

COBRA continuation coverage available. Since then the statute has been

amended to add the disability extension, to permit plans to extend the

notice period if the maximum coverage period is also extended (referred

to as the optional extension of the required periods), and to add a

special rule in the case of Medicare entitlement preceding a qualifying

event that is the termination or reduction of hours of employment. The

new proposed regulations reflect these statutory changes. The maximum

coverage period for a qualifying event that is the bankruptcy of the

employer has also been added to the new proposed regulations.

The 1998 proposed regulations set forth the requirements for a

disability extension to apply to a qualified beneficiary. Those

requirements have been incorporated into the final regulations, with

one clarification. One of the conditions for a disability extension to

apply is that the qualified beneficiary be disabled during the first 60

days of COBRA continuation coverage. In the case of a qualified

beneficiary who is born to or placed for adoption with a covered

employee during a period of COBRA continuation coverage, the final

regulations clarify that the 60-day period is measured from the date of

the child's birth or placement for adoption.

The 1987 proposed regulations set forth standards for expanding the

maximum coverage period in the case of multiple qualifying events.

Since 1987, the statutory rules for multiple qualifying events have

been affected by the addition of the disability extension and the

optional extension of required periods. The final regulations reflect

the statutory changes.

In addition, the final regulations clarify that a termination of

employment following a qualifying event that is a reduction of hours of

employment does not expand the maximum coverage period. Accord, Burgess

v. Adams Tool & Engineering, Inc., 908 F. Supp. 473 (W.D. Mich. 1995);

contra, Gibbs v. Anchorage School District, 1995 U.S. LEXIS 6290 (D.

Ark. 1995). The underlying pattern in the statute is generally to

require 18 months (or 29 months, in the case of a disability extension)

of coverage for qualifying events that are the termination or reduction

of hours of a covered employee's employment and 36 months for other

qualifying events. The statutory provision for expansion of the 18-

month period to 36 months upon the occurrence of a second qualifying

event generally follows this pattern by allowing a qualified

beneficiary who would have been entitled to 36 months of coverage if

the second qualifying event had occurred first to get a total of 36

months of COBRA continuation coverage. The statute lists six categories

of qualifying events, and termination of employment and reduction of

hours of employment are in the same category (just as divorce and legal

separation are in the same category of qualifying event). Treating a

reduction of hours of employment and a termination of employment as

variations of a single qualifying event rather than as two distinct

qualifying events is consistent with the overall design of the statute.

The 1987 proposed regulations address situations in which,

following a qualifying event, an employer provides alternative

coverage, rather than COBRA continuation coverage, to a former employee

and her or his spouse and dependent children. The 1987 proposed

regulations provide that if the alternative coverage does not satisfy

the requirements for COBRA continuation coverage, each qualified

beneficiary must be given the opportunity to elect COBRA continuation

coverage instead of the alternative coverage. If, however, the

alternative coverage would satisfy the requirements for COBRA

continuation coverage, the 1987 proposed regulations provide that, at

the time of the original qualifying event, the employee, spouse, and

dependent children need not be provided with the opportunity to elect

COBRA continuation coverage. The final regulations generally retain

these rules but also clarify that if the employer increases the

employee share of premiums upon the occurrence of a qualifying event,

the qualified beneficiaries must be offered the opportunity to elect

COBRA continuation coverage.

The 1987 proposed regulations further provide that, if the

alternative coverage does not satisfy the requirements for COBRA

continuation coverage and if, after the original qualifying event, a

qualifying event occurs that would cause a spouse or dependent child to

lose the alternative coverage, the spouse or child must be offered

COBRA continuation coverage. However, if the alternative coverage

satisfies the requirements for COBRA continuation coverage, and if

another qualifying event that causes the spouse or dependent child to

lose the alternative coverage occurs more than 18 months after the

original qualifying event, the 1987 proposed regulations provide that

the spouse or dependent child need not be offered COBRA continuation

coverage. The final regulations modify the 1987 proposed regulations

and provide that if an event such as the death of or divorce from the

covered employee would end the right of a spouse or dependent child to

receive the alternative coverage (whether during or after the first 18

months of COBRA continuation coverage), then that event is a qualifying

event, regardless of whether the alternative coverage would satisfy the

requirements for COBRA continuation coverage.

The Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of

1994 (USERRA) gives certain members of the military reserves the right

to up to 18 months of continuation coverage when they are called to

active duty. Many people have asked if the USERRA and COBRA periods of

continuation coverage run concurrently or consecutively. The final

regulations clarify that USERRA coverage is alternative coverage. Thus,

the periods run concurrently.

The 1987 proposed regulations include the statutory rule requiring

that a conversion option otherwise made available under the plan be

made available within 180 days before the end of the maximum coverage

period. The final regulations adopt this rule without change.

Paying for COBRA Continuation Coverage

The 1987 proposed regulations identify the qualified beneficiary as

the person that can be required to pay the

[[Page 5170]]

applicable premium. Many plans and employers have asked whether they

must accept payment on behalf of a qualified beneficiary from third

parties, such as a hospital or a new employer. Nothing in the statute

requires the qualified beneficiary to pay the amount required by the

plan; the statute merely permits the plan to require that payment be

made. In order to make clear that any person may make the required

payment on behalf of a qualified beneficiary, the final regulations

modify the rule in the 1987 proposed regulations to refer to the

payment requirement without identifying the person who makes the

payment.

The 1998 proposed regulations address the amount that a plan can

require to be paid for COBRA continuation coverage during the

disability extension. This amount is 150 percent of the applicable

premium instead of the limit of 102 percent of the applicable premium

that applies for coverage outside the disability extension. The 1998

proposed regulations specifically reserve the issue of the amount a

plan could require to be paid in a case where only nondisabled family

members of the disabled individual receive COBRA continuation coverage

during the disability extension. The preamble to the 1998 proposed

regulations solicited comments on this issue. Commenters suggested that

the 150 percent rate could be required if the disabled individual was

part of the coverage group but that the limit could be the 102 percent

rate if only nondisabled qualified beneficiaries were in the coverage

group. The final regulations adopt this suggestion.

The 1987 proposed regulations provide that the amount required to

be paid for a qualified beneficiary's COBRA continuation coverage must

be fixed in advance for each 12-month determination period. Many

commenters suggested exceptions that could be made to this general

rule. Section 4980B(f)(4)(C) explicitly requires that the determination

of the applicable premium be made for a period of 12 months and that

the determination be made before the beginning. Therefore, the final

regulations do not permit an increase in the applicable premium during

the 12-month determination period. However, the final regulations do

revise the general rule from the 1987 proposed regulations to recognize

the difference between the applicable premium (which may not be

increased during a 12-month determination period and which is the basis

for calculating the maximum amount that the plan can require to be paid

for COBRA continuation coverage) and the maximum amount that the plan

can require to be paid for COBRA continuation coverage. Thus, the final

regulations permit a plan to increase the amount it requires to be paid

for COBRA continuation coverage during a determination period to take

into account the permitted increases during the disability extension,

to explicitly permit a plan that is requiring payment of less than the

maximum permissible amount to increase the amount required to be paid

during the 12-month determination period, and to permit an increase if

a qualified beneficiary changes to more expensive coverage (but also to

require a reduction if the qualified beneficiary changes to less

expensive coverage).

The 1987 proposed regulations set forth the statutory requirement

that qualified beneficiaries be allowed to pay for COBRA coverage in

monthly installments. The 1987 proposed regulations add that plans may

allow payment to be made at other intervals, and specifically mention

quarterly or semiannual payment as examples. The final regulations

adopt the rule in the 1987 proposed regulations, but the final

regulations add weekly payment as an example to make clear that shorter

than monthly installments are also permitted.

The 1987 proposed regulations provide that the first payment for

COBRA continuation coverage does not apply prospectively only. In order

to make clear that a plan is not precluded from allowing a qualified

beneficiary to apply the first payment prospectively only, the final

regulations provide that qualified beneficiaries need not be given the

option of having the first payment for COBRA continuation coverage

apply prospectively only.

The 1987 proposed regulations address the issue of timely payment

for COBRA continuation coverage, including an interpretation of the

statutory grace periods of 45 days for the initial payment and 30 days

for all other payments. Commenters pointed out that the application of

the statutory grace period rules could produce an anomalous result in

some situations, such as allowing a plan to require payment for the

third month of COBRA continuation coverage earlier than the plan could

require payment for the first two months. OBRA 1989 amended the 45-day

grace period rule to prevent this, and the final regulations conform to

the OBRA 1989 change. The final regulations also clarify that payment

is considered made on the date it is sent.

The final regulations also add a requirement (similar to the one

described above for the election period) relating to the response that

a plan must give when a health care provider, such as a physician, a

hospital, or a pharmacy, contacts the plan to confirm coverage of a

qualified beneficiary with respect to whom the required payment has not

been made for the current period (but for whom any applicable grace

period has not expired). In such a case, the plan is required to inform

the health care provider of all of the details of the qualified

beneficiary's right to coverage during the applicable grace periods.

Many individuals have inquired about a plan's right to discontinue

their COBRA continuation coverage because the amount of the payment

made was short by an amount that is not significant. Sometimes the

error has been clearly one of transposed digits on a check tendered for

payment; in other instances, payment has been short by such a small

amount that it would be unreasonable to attribute the shortfall to

anything other than mistake. The final regulations establish a

mechanism for the treatment of payments that are short by an

insignificant amount. Either the plan must treat the payment as

satisfying the plan's payment requirement or it must notify the

qualified beneficiary of the amount of the deficiency and grant the

qualified beneficiary a reasonable period of time for the deficiency to

be paid. The final regulations provide that, as a safe harbor, a period

of 30 days is deemed to be a reasonable period for this purpose.

Business Reorganizations

The 1987 proposed regulations provide little direct guidance on the

allocation of responsibility for COBRA continuation coverage in the

event of corporate transactions, such as a sale of stock of a

subsidiary or a sale of substantial assets. Commenters on the 1987

proposed regulations requested further guidance on corporate

transactions, pointing out that the existing degree of uncertainty

tends to drive up the costs and risks of a transaction to both buyers

and sellers. The IRS and Treasury share this view and believe also that

greater certainty helps to protect the rights of qualified

beneficiaries in these transactions. The IRS has been contacted by many

qualified beneficiaries whose COBRA continuation coverage has been

dropped or denied in the context of a corporate transaction. In many

cases, these qualified beneficiaries have been told by each of the

buyer and the seller that the other party is the one responsible for

providing them with COBRA continuation coverage.

[[Page 5171]]

The preamble to the 1998 proposed regulations requested comments on

a possible approach to allocating responsibility for COBRA continuation

coverage in corporate transactions. Commenters suggested that, in a

stock sale, as in an asset sale, it would be consistent with standard

commercial practice to provide that the seller retains liability for

all existing qualified beneficiaries, including those formerly

associated with the subsidiary being sold. The IRS and Treasury have

studied the comments and given consideration to several alternatives

with a view to establishing rules that will minimize the administrative

burden and transaction costs for the parties to transactions while

protecting the rights of qualified beneficiaries and maintaining

consistency with the statute.

Accordingly, the new proposed regulations make clear that the

parties to a transaction are free to allocate the responsibility for

providing COBRA continuation coverage by contract, even if the contract

imposes responsibility on a different party than would the new proposed

regulations. So long as the party to whom the contract allocates

responsibility performs its obligations, the other party will have no

responsibility for providing COBRA continuation coverage. If, however,

the party allocated responsibility under the contract defaults on its

obligation, and if, under the new proposed regulations, the other party

would have the obligation to provide COBRA continuation coverage in the

absence of a contractual provision, then the other party would retain

that obligation. This approach would avoid prejudicing the rights of

qualified beneficiaries to COBRA continuation coverage based upon the

provisions of a contract to which they were not a party and under which

the employer with the underlying obligation under the regulations to

provide COBRA continuation coverage could otherwise contract away that

obligation to a party that fails to perform. Moreover, the party with

the underlying responsibility under the regulations can insist on

appropriate security and, of course, could pursue contractual remedies

against the defaulting party.

The new proposed regulations provide, for both sales of stock and

sales of substantial assets, such as a division or plant or

substantially all the assets of a trade or business, that the seller

retains the obligation to make COBRA continuation coverage available to

existing qualified beneficiaries. In addition, in situations in which

the seller ceases to provide any group health plan to any employee in

connection with the sale whether such a cessation is in connection with

the sale is determined on the basis of the facts and circumstances of

each case and thus is not responsible for providing COBRA continuation

coverage, the new proposed regulations provide that the buyer is

responsible for providing COBRA continuation coverage to existing

qualified beneficiaries. This secondary liability for the buyer applies

in all stock sales and in all sales of substantial assets in which the

buyer continues the business operations associated with the assets

without interruption or substantial change.

A particular type of asset sale raises issues for which the new

proposed regulations do not provide any special rules. (Thus, the

general rules in the new proposed regulations for business

reorganizations would apply to this type of transaction.) This type of

asset sale is one in which, after purchasing a business as a going

concern, the buyer continues to employ the employees of that business

and continues to provide those employees exactly the same health

coverage that they had before the sale (either by providing coverage

through the same insurance contract or by establishing a plan that

mirrors the one that provided benefits before the sale). The

application of the rules in the new proposed regulations to this type

of asset sale would require the seller to make COBRA continuation

coverage available to the employees continuing in employment with the

buyer (and to other family members who are qualified beneficiaries).

Ordinarily, the continuing employees (or their family members) would be

very unlikely to elect COBRA continuation coverage from the seller when

they can receive the same coverage (usually at much lower cost) as

active employees of the buyer.

Consideration is being given to whether, under appropriate

circumstances, such an asset sale would be considered not to result in

a loss of coverage for those employees who continue in employment with

the buyer after the sale. A countervailing concern, however, relates to

those qualified beneficiaries who might have a reason to elect COBRA

continuation coverage from the seller. An example of such a qualified

beneficiary would be an employee who continues in employment with the

buyer, whose family is likely to have medical expenses that exceed the

cost of COBRA coverage, and who has significant questions about the

solvency of the buyer or other concerns about how long the buyer might

continue to provide the same health coverage.

Under one possible approach, a loss of coverage would be considered

not to have occurred so long as the purchasing employer in an asset

sale continued to maintain the same group health plan coverage that the

seller maintained before the sale without charging the employees any

greater percentage of the total cost of coverage than the seller had

charged before the sale. For this purpose, the coverage would be

considered unchanged if there was no obligation to provide a summary of

material modifications within 60 days after the change due to a

material reduction in covered services or benefits under the rules that

apply under Title I of ERISA. If these conditions were satisfied for

the maximum coverage period that would otherwise apply to the seller's

termination of employment of the continuing employees (generally 18

months from the date of the sale), then those terminations of

employment would never be considered qualifying events. If the

conditions were not satisfied for the full maximum coverage period,

then on the date when they ceased to be satisfied the seller would be

obligated to make COBRA continuation coverage available for the balance

of the maximum coverage period.

Comments are invited on the utility of such a rule, either in

situations in which the seller retains an ownership interest in the

buyer after the sale (for example, a sale of assets from a 100-percent

owned subsidiary to a 75-percent owned subsidiary) or, more generally,

in situations in which the seller and the buyer are unrelated.

Suggestions are also solicited for other rules that would protect

qualified beneficiaries while providing relief to employers in these

situations.

Although the new proposed regulations address how COBRA obligations

are affected by a sale of stock (and a sale of substantial assets), the

new proposed regulations do not address how the obligation to make

COBRA continuation coverage available is affected by the transfer of an

ownership interest in a noncorporate entity that causes the

noncorporate entity to cease to be a member of a group of trades or

businesses under common control (whether or not it becomes a member of

a different group of trades or business under common control). Comments

are invited on this issue.

[[Page 5172]]

Employer Withdrawals From Multiemployer Plans

The new proposed regulations also address COBRA obligations in

connection with an employer's cessation of contributions to a

multiemployer group health plan. The new proposed regulations provide

that the multiemployer plan generally continues to have the obligation

to make COBRA continuation coverage available to qualified

beneficiaries associated with that employer. (There generally would not

be any obligation to make COBRA continuation coverage available to

continuing employees in this situation because a cessation of

contributions is not a qualifying event.) However, once the employer

provides group health coverage to a significant number of employees who

were formerly covered under the multiemployer plan, or starts

contributing to another multiemployer plan on their behalf, the

employer's plan (or the new multiemployer plan) would have the

obligation to make COBRA continuation coverage available to the

existing qualified beneficiaries. This rule is contrary to the holding

in In re Appletree Markets, Inc., 19 F.3d 969 (5th Cir. 1994), which

held that the multiemployer plan continued to have the COBRA

obligations with respect to existing qualified beneficiaries after the

withdrawing employer established a plan for the same class of employees

previously covered under the multiemployer plan.

Interaction of FMLA and COBRA

The new proposed regulations set forth rules regarding the

interaction of the COBRA continuation coverage requirements with the

provisions of the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA). The

rules under the new proposed regulations are substantially the same as

those set forth in Notice 94-103. The last two questions-and-answers in

that notice have not been included in the new proposed regulations

because they relate to general subject matter that is addressed

elsewhere in the regulations.

Under the new proposed regulations, the taking of FMLA leave by a

covered employee is not itself a qualifying event. Instead, a

qualifying event occurs when an employee who is covered under a group

health plan immediately prior to FMLA leave (or who becomes covered

under a group health plan during FMLA leave) does not return to work

with the employer at the end of FMLA leave and would, but for COBRA

continuation coverage, lose coverage under the group health plan. (As

under the general rules of COBRA, this would also constitute a

qualifying event with respect to the spouse or any dependent child of

the employee.) The qualifying event is deemed to occur on the last day

of the employee's FMLA leave, and the maximum coverage period generally

begins on that day. (The new proposed regulations provide a special

rule for cases where coverage is not lost until a later date and the

plan provides for the optional extension of the required periods.) In

the case of such a qualifying event, the employer cannot condition the

employee's rights to COBRA continuation coverage on the employee's

reimbursement of any premiums paid by the employer to maintain the

employee's group health plan coverage during the period of FMLA leave.

Any lapse of coverage under the group health plan during the period

of FMLA leave and any state or local law requiring that group health

plan coverage be provided for a period longer than that required by the

FMLA are disregarded in determining whether the employee has a

qualifying event on the last day of that leave. However, the employee's

loss of coverage at the end of FMLA leave will not constitute a

qualifying event if, prior to the employee's return from FMLA leave,

the employer has eliminated group health plan coverage for the class of

employees to which the employee would have belonged if she or he had

not taken FMLA leave.

Special Analyses.

It has been determined that this Treasury decision is not a

significant regulatory action as defined in Executive Order 12866.

Therefore, a regulatory assessment is not required. It is hereby

certified that the collections of information in these regulations will

not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small

entities. This certification is based upon the fact that employers with

fewer than 20 employees are not subject to the requirements set forth

in the final regulations and, thus, the very smallest employers are not

affected by the collection of information requirements. Moreover, even

for small entities with 20 or more employees who maintain group health

plans and who, thus, are subject to the requirements of COBRA, the

collections of information will not impose a substantial economic

impact. The only collections of information imposed on small entities

by the regulations are (1) to notify qualified beneficiaries of their

right to elect COBRA continuation coverage upon the occurrence of a

qualifying event and (2) to notify certain qualified beneficiaries that

make insignificant payment errors of those errors. With respect to this

first notice requirement, it is estimated that, on average, in a given

year, qualifying events will occur with respect to approximately 10

percent of all covered employees. Thus, an employer with 100 employees

would be required to send 10 notices to qualified beneficiaries each

year. The average cost of sending such a notice is estimated to be

$.50. Thus, the total estimated cost for 10 notices is $5.00, which is

the estimated annual average burden on an employer with 100 employees.

With respect to the second notice requirement, it is estimated that, on

average, at any time, the number of qualified beneficiaries is

approximately equal to two percent of an employer's workforce. Of that

number, approximately 1 in 10 will make an insignificant error in

payment each year that requires the employer to send such a notice. For

example, an employer with 100 employees will have an average of two

qualified beneficiaries at any time. Thus, the employer will receive an

insignificant underpayment about once every five years. Even if the

employer chose to send out a notice each time such an insignificant

underpayment occurred, this would amount to only one notice every five

years. The average cost of sending such a notice is estimated to be

$5.00, resulting in an average annual burden of $1.00 for an employer

with 100 employees. Thus, the total annual cost of these two notice

requirements for an employer with 100 employees is $6.00, which is not

a significant economic impact. Therefore, a Regulatory Flexibility

Analysis under the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 6) is

not required. It has also been determined that section 553(b) of the

Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 5) does not apply to

these regulations. Pursuant to section 7805(f) of the Internal Revenue

Code, the 1998 notice of proposed rulemaking preceding these final

regulations was submitted to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the

Small Business Administration for comment on its impact on small

business.

Drafting information. The principal author of these regulations is

Russ Weinheimer, Office of the Associate Chief Counsel (Employee

Benefits and Exempt Organizations), IRS. However, other personnel from

the IRS and Treasury Department participated in their development.

[[Page 5173]]

List of Subjects

26 CFR Part 54

Excise taxes, Health care, Health insurance, Pensions, Reporting

and recordkeeping requirements.

26 CFR Part 602

Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

Adoption of Amendments to the Regulations

Accordingly, 26 CFR parts 54 and 602 are amended as follows:

PART 54--PENSION EXCISE TAXES

Paragraph 1. The authority citation for part 54 is amended by

adding the following entries in numerical order to read as follows:

Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *

Section 54.4980B-1 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B.

Section 54.4980B-2 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B.

Section 54.4980B-3 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B.

Section 54.4980B-4 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B.

Section 54.4980B-5 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B.

Section 54.4980B-6 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B.

Section 54.4980B-7 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B.

Section 54.4980B-8 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 4980B. * * *

Par. 2. Sections 54.4980B-0, 54.4980B-1, 54.4980B-2, 54.4980B-3,

54.4980B-4, 54.4980B-5, 54.4980B-6, 54.4980B-7, and 54.4980B-8 are

added to read as follows:

Sec. 54.4980B-0 Table of contents.

This section contains first a list of the section headings and then

a list of the questions in each section in Secs. 54.4980B-1 through

54.4980B-8.

List of Sections

Sec. 54.4980B-1 COBRA in general.

Sec. 54.4980B-2 Plans that must comply.

Sec. 54.4980B-3 Qualified beneficiaries.

Sec. 54.4980B-4 Qualifying events.

Sec. 54.4980B-5 COBRA continuation coverage.

Sec. 54.4980B-6 Electing COBRA continuation coverage.

Sec. 54.4980B-7 Duration of COBRA continuation coverage.

Sec. 54.4980B-8 Paying for COBRA continuation coverage.

List of Questions

Sec. 54.4980B-1 COBRA in general.

Q-1: What are the health care continuation coverage requirements

contained in section 4980B of the Internal Revenue Code and in

ERISA?

Q-2: What is the effective date of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through

54.4980B-8?

Sec. 54.4980B-2 Plans that must comply.

Q-1: For purposes of section 4980B, what is a group health plan?

Q-2: For purposes of section 4980B, what is the employer?

Q-3: [Reserved]

Q-4: What group health plans are subject to COBRA?

Q-5: What is a small-employer plan?

Q-6: [Reserved]

Q-7: What is the plan year?

Q-8: How do the COBRA continuation coverage requirements apply

to cafeteria plans and other flexible benefit arrangements?

Q-9: What is the effect of a group health plan's failure to

comply with the requirements of section 4980B(f)?

Q-10: Who is liable for the excise tax if a group health plan

fails to comply with the requirements of section 4980B(f)?

Sec. 54.4980B-3 Qualified beneficiaries.

Q-1: Who is a qualified beneficiary?

Q-2: Who is an employee and who is a covered employee?

Q-3: Who are the similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries?

Sec. 54.4980B-4 Qualifying events.

Q-1: What is a qualifying event?

Q-2: Are the facts surrounding a termination of employment (such

as whether it was voluntary or involuntary) relevant in determining

whether the termination of employment is a qualifying event?

Sec. 54.4980B-5 COBRA continuation coverage.

Q-1: What is COBRA continuation coverage?

Q-2: What deductibles apply if COBRA continuation coverage is

elected?

Q-3: How do a plan's limits apply to COBRA continuation

coverage?

Q-4: Can a qualified beneficiary who elects COBRA continuation

coverage ever change from the coverage received by that individual

immediately before the qualifying event?

Q-5: Aside from open enrollment periods, can a qualified

beneficiary who has elected COBRA continuation coverage choose to

cover individuals (such as newborn children, adopted children, or

new spouses) who join the qualified beneficiary's family on or after

the date of the qualifying event?

4.4980B-6 Electing COBRA continuation coverage.

Q-1: What is the election period and how long must it last?

Q-2: Is a covered employee or qualified beneficiary responsible

for informing the plan administrator of the occurrence of a

qualifying event?

Q-3: During the election period and before the qualified

beneficiary has made an election, must coverage be provided?

Q-4: Is a waiver before the end of the election period effective

to end a qualified beneficiary's election rights?

Q-5: Can an employer or employee organization withhold money or

other benefits owed to a qualified beneficiary until the qualified

beneficiary either waives COBRA continuation coverage, elects and

pays for such coverage, or allows the election period to expire?

Q-6: Can each qualified beneficiary make an independent election

under COBRA?

54.4980B-7 Duration of COBRA continuation coverage.

Q-1: How long must COBRA continuation coverage be made available

to a qualified beneficiary?

Q-2: When may a plan terminate a qualified beneficiary's COBRA

continuation coverage due to coverage under another group health

plan?

Q-3: When may a plan terminate a qualified beneficiary's COBRA

continuation coverage due to the qualified beneficiary's entitlement

to Medicare benefits?

Q-4: [Reserved]

Q-5: How does a qualified beneficiary become entitled to a

disability extension?

Q-6: Under what circumstances can the maximum coverage period be

expanded?

Q-7: If health coverage is provided to a qualified beneficiary

after a qualifying event without regard to COBRA continuation

coverage (for example, as a result of state or local law, the

Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994

(38 U.S.C. 4315), industry practice, a collective bargaining

agreement, severance agreement, or plan procedure), will such

alternative coverage extend the maximum coverage period?

Q-8: Must a qualified beneficiary be given the right to enroll

in a conversion health plan at the end of the maximum coverage

period for COBRA continuation coverage?

54.4980B-8 Paying for COBRA continuation coverage.

Q-1: Can a group health plan require payment for COBRA

continuation coverage?

Q-2: When is the applicable premium determined and when can a

group health plan increase the amount it requires to be paid for

COBRA continuation coverage?

Q-3: Must a plan allow payment for COBRA continuation coverage

to be made in monthly installments?

Q-4: Is a plan required to allow a qualified beneficiary to

choose to have the first payment for COBRA continuation coverage

applied prospectively only?

Q-5: What is timely payment for COBRA continuation coverage?

Sec. 54.4980B-1 COBRA in general.

The COBRA continuation coverage requirements are described in

general in the following questions-and-answers:

Q-1: What are the health care continuation coverage requirements

contained in section 4980B of the Internal Revenue Code and in ERISA?

A-1: (a) Section 4980B provides generally that a group health plan

must offer each qualified beneficiary who would otherwise lose coverage

under the plan as a result of a qualifying event an opportunity to

elect, within the election period, continuation coverage under the

plan. The continuation coverage requirements were added to section 162

by the Consolidated

[[Page 5174]]

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1985 (COBRA), Public Law 99-272

(100 Stat. 222), and moved to section 4980B by the Technical and

Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988, Public Law 100-647 (102 Stat. 3342).

Continuation coverage required under section 4980B is referred to in

Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8 as COBRA continuation coverage.

(b) COBRA also added parallel continuation coverage requirements to

Part 6 of Subtitle B of Title I of the Employee Retirement Income

Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) (29 U.S.C. 1161-1168), which is

administered by the U.S. Department of Labor. If a plan does not comply

with the COBRA continuation coverage requirements, the Internal Revenue

Code imposes an excise tax on the employer maintaining the plan (or on

the plan itself), whereas ERISA gives certain parties--including

qualified beneficiaries who are participants or beneficiaries within

the meaning of Title I of ERISA, as well as the Department of Labor--

the right to file a lawsuit to redress the noncompliance. The rules in

Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8 apply for purposes of section 4980B

and generally also for purposes of the COBRA continuation coverage

requirements in Title I of ERISA. However, certain provisions of the

COBRA continuation coverage requirements (such as the definitions of

group health plan, employee, and employer) are not identical in the

Internal Revenue Code and Title I of ERISA. In those cases in which the

statutory language is not identical, the rules in Secs. 54.4980B-1

though 54.4980B-8 nonetheless apply to the COBRA continuation coverage

requirements of Title I of ERISA, except to the extent those rules are

inconsistent with the statutory language of Title I of ERISA.

(c) A group health plan that is subject to section 4980B (or the

parallel provisions under ERISA) is referred to as being subject to

COBRA. (See Q&A-4 of Sec. 54.4980B-2). A qualified beneficiary can be

required to pay for COBRA continuation coverage. The term qualified

beneficiary is defined in Q&A-1 of Sec. 54.4980B-3. The term qualifying

event is defined in Q&A-1 of Sec. 54.4980B-4. COBRA continuation

coverage is described in Sec. 54.4980B-5. The election procedures are

described in Sec. 54.4980B-6. Duration of COBRA continuation coverage

is addressed in Sec. 54.4980B-7, and payment for COBRA continuation

coverage is addressed in Sec. 54.4980B-8. Unless the context indicates

otherwise, any reference in Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8 to

COBRA refers to section 4980B (as amended) and to the parallel

provisions of ERISA.

Q-2: What is the effective date of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through

54.4980B-8?

A-2: Sections 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8 apply with respect to

qualifying events occurring in plan years beginning on or after January

1, 2000. For purposes of section 4980B, with respect to qualifying

events that occur in plan years beginning before that date, and with

respect to qualifying events that occur in plan years beginning on or

after that date for topics relating to the COBRA continuation coverage

requirements of section 4980B that are not addressed in Secs. 54.4980B-

1 through 54.4980B-8 (such as methods for calculating the applicable

premium), plans and employers must operate in good faith compliance

with a reasonable interpretation of the statutory requirements in

section 4980B.

Sec. 54.4980B-2 Plans that must comply.

The following questions-and-answers apply in determining which

plans must comply with the COBRA continuation coverage requirements:

Q-1: For purposes of section 4980B, what is a group health plan?

A-1: (a) For purposes of section 4980B, a group health plan is a

plan maintained by an employer or employee organization to provide

health care to individuals who have an employment-related connection to

the employer or employee organization or to their families. Individuals

who have an employment-related connection to the employer or employee

organization consist of employees, former employees, the employer, and

others associated or formerly associated with the employer or employee

organization in a business relationship (including members of a union

who are not currently employees). Health care is provided under a plan

whether provided directly or through insurance, reimbursement, or

otherwise, and whether or not provided through an on-site facility

(except as set forth in paragraph (d) of this Q&A-1), or through a

cafeteria plan (as defined in section 125) or other flexible benefit

arrangement. For purposes of this Q&A-1, insurance includes not only

group insurance policies but also one or more individual insurance

policies in any arrangement that involves the provision of health care

to two or more employees. A plan maintained by an employer or employee

organization is any plan of, or contributed to (directly or indirectly)

by, an employer or employee organization. Thus, a group health plan is

maintained by an employer or employee organization even if the employer

or employee organization does not contribute to it if coverage under

the plan would not be available at the same cost to an individual but

for the individual's employment-related connection to the employer or

employee organization. These rules are further explained in paragraphs

(b) through (d) of this Q&A-1. An exception for qualified long-term

care services is set forth in paragraph (e) of this Q&A-1, and for

medical savings accounts in paragraph (f) of this Q&A-1.

(b) For purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8, health

care has the same meaning as medical care under section 213(d). Thus,

health care generally includes the diagnosis, cure, mitigation,

treatment, or prevention of disease, and any other undertaking for the

purpose of affecting any structure or function of the body. Health care

also includes transportation primarily for and essential to health care

as described in the preceding sentence. However, health care does not

include anything that is merely beneficial to the general health of an

individual, such as a vacation. Thus, if an employer or employee

organization maintains a program that furthers general good health, but

the program does not relate to the relief or alleviation of health or

medical problems and is generally accessible to and used by employees

without regard to their physical condition or state of health, that

program is not considered a program that provides health care and so is

not a group health plan. For example, if an employer maintains a spa,

swimming pool, gymnasium, or other exercise/fitness program or facility

that is normally accessible to and used by employees for reasons other

than relief of health or medical problems, such a facility does not

constitute a program that provides health care and thus is not a group

health plan. In contrast, if an employer maintains a drug or alcohol

treatment program or a health clinic, or any other facility or program

that is intended to relieve or alleviate a physical condition or health

problem, the facility or program is considered to be the provision of

health care and so is considered a group health plan.

(c) Whether a benefit provided to employees constitutes health care

is not affected by whether the benefit is excludable from income under

section 132 (relating to certain fringe benefits). For example, if a

department store provides its employees discounted prices on all

merchandise, including health care items such as drugs or eyeglasses,

the mere fact that the discounted prices also apply to health care

items will not cause the program to

[[Page 5175]]

be a plan providing health care, so long as the discount program would

normally be accessible to and used by employees without regard to

health needs or physical condition. If, however, the employer

maintaining the discount program is a health clinic, so that the

program is used exclusively by employees with health or medical needs,

the program is considered to be a plan providing health care and so is

considered to be a group health plan.

(d) The provision of health care at a facility that is located on

the premises of an employer or employee organization does not

constitute a group health plan if--

(1) The health care consists primarily of first aid that is

provided during the employer's working hours for treatment of a health

condition, illness, or injury that occurs during those working hours;

(2) The health care is available only to current employees; and

(3) Employees are not charged for the use of the facility.

(e) A plan does not constitute a group health plan subject to COBRA

if substantially all of the coverage provided under the plan is for

qualified long-term care services (as defined in section 7702B(c)). For

this purpose, a plan is permitted to use any reasonable method in

determining whether substantially all of the coverage provided under

the plan is for qualified long-term care services.

(f) Under section 106(b)(5), amounts contributed by an employer to

a medical savings account (as defined in section 220(d)) are not

considered part of a group health plan subject to COBRA. Thus, a plan

is not required to make COBRA continuation coverage available with

respect to amounts contributed by an employer to a medical savings

account. A high deductible health plan does not fail to be a group

health plan subject to COBRA merely because it covers a medical savings

account holder.

Q-2: For purposes of section 4980B, what is the employer?

A-2: For purposes of section 4980B, employer refers to--

(a) A person for whom services are performed;

(b) Any other person that is a member of a group described in

section 414(b), (c), (m), or (o) that includes a person described in

paragraph (a) of this Q&A-2; and

(c) Any successor of a person described in paragraph (a) or (b) of

this Q&A-2.

Q-3: [Reserved]

A-3: [Reserved]

Q-4: What group health plans are subject to COBRA?

A-4: (a) All group health plans are subject to COBRA except group

health plans described in paragraph (b) of this Q&A-4. Group health

plans described in paragraph (b) of this Q&A-4 are referred to in

Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8 as excepted from COBRA.

(b) The following group health plans are excepted from COBRA--

(1) Small-employer plans (see Q&A-5 of this section);

(2) Church plans (within the meaning of section 414(e)); and

(3) Governmental plans (within the meaning of section 414(d)).

(c) The COBRA continuation coverage requirements generally do not

apply to group health plans that are excepted from COBRA. However, a

small-employer plan otherwise excepted from COBRA is nonetheless

subject to COBRA with respect to qualified beneficiaries who experience

a qualifying event during a period when the plan is not a small-

employer plan (see paragraph (g) of Q&A-5 of this section).

(d) Although governmental plans are not subject to the COBRA

continuation coverage requirements, group health plans maintained by

state or local governments are generally subject to parallel

continuation coverage requirements that were added by section 10003 of

COBRA to the Public Health Service Act (42 U.S.C. 300bb-1 through

300bb-8), which is administered by the U.S. Department of Health and

Human Services. Federal employees and their family members covered

under the Federal Employees Health Benefit Program are covered by

generally similar, but not parallel, temporary continuation of coverage

provisions enacted by the Federal Employees Health Benefits Amendments

Act of 1988. See 5 U.S.C. 8905a.

Q-5: What is a small-employer plan?

A-5: (a) Except in the case of a multiemployer plan, a small-

employer plan is a group health plan maintained by an employer (within

the meaning of Q&A-2 of this section) that normally employed fewer than

20 employees (within the meaning of paragraph (c) of this Q&A-5) during

the preceding calendar year. In the case of a multiemployer plan, a

small-employer plan is a group health plan under which each of the

employers contributing to the plan for a calendar year normally

employed fewer than 20 employees during the preceding calendar year.

The rules of this paragraph (a) are illustrated in the following

example:

Example. (i) Corporation S employs 12 employees, all of whom

work and reside in the United States. S maintains a group health

plan for its employees and their families. S is a wholly-owned

subsidiary of P. In the previous calendar year, the controlled group

of corporations including P and S employed more than 19 employees,

although the only employees in the United States of the controlled

group that includes P and S are the 12 employees of S.

(ii) Under Sec. 1.414(b)-1 of this chapter, foreign corporations

are not excluded from membership in a controlled group of

corporations. Consequently, the group health plan maintained by S is

not a small-employer plan during the current calendar year because

the controlled group including S normally employed at least 20

employees in the preceding calendar year.

(b) An employer is considered to have normally employed fewer than

20 employees during a particular calendar year if, and only if, it had

fewer than 20 employees on at least 50 percent of its typical business

days during that year.

(c) All full-time and part-time common law employees of an employer

are taken into account in determining whether an employer had fewer

than 20 employees; however, an individual who is not a common law

employee of the employer is not taken into account. Thus, the following

individuals are not counted as employees for purposes of this Q&A-5

even though they are referred to as employees for all other purposes of

Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8--

(1) Self-employed individuals (within the meaning of section

401(c)(1));

(2) Independent contractors (and their employees and independent

contractors); and

(3) Directors (in the case of a corporation).

(d) [Reserved]

(e) [Reserved]

(f) [Reserved]

(g) A small-employer plan is generally excepted from COBRA. If,

however, a plan that has been subject to COBRA (that is, was not a

small-employer plan) becomes a small-employer plan, the plan remains

subject to COBRA for qualifying events that occurred during the period

when the plan was subject to COBRA. The rules of this paragraph (g) are

illustrated by the following examples:

Example 1. An employer maintains a group health plan. The

employer employed 20 employees on more than 50 percent of its

working days during 2001, and consequently the plan is not excepted

from COBRA during 2002. Employee E resigns and does not work for the

employer after January 31, 2002. Under the terms of the plan, E is

no longer eligible for coverage upon the effective date of the

resignation, that is, February 1, 2002. The employer does not hire a

replacement for E. E timely elects and pays for COBRA continuation

coverage. The employer

[[Page 5176]]

employs 19 employees for the remainder of 2002, and consequently the

plan is not subject to COBRA in 2003. The plan must nevertheless

continue to make COBRA continuation coverage available to E during

2003 until the obligation to make COBRA continuation coverage

available ceases under the rules of Sec. 54.4980B-7. The obligation

could continue until August 1, 2003, the date that is 18 months

after the date of E's qualifying event, or longer if E is eligible

for a disability extension.

Example 2. The facts are the same as in Example 1. The employer

continues to employ 19 employees throughout 2003 and 2004 and

consequently the plan continues to be excepted from COBRA during

2004 and 2005. Spouse S is covered under the plan because S is

married to one of the employer's employees. On April 1, 2002, S is

divorced from that employee and ceases to be eligible for coverage

under the plan. The plan is subject to COBRA during 2002 because X

normally employed 20 employees during 2001. S timely notifies the

plan administrator of the divorce and timely elects and pays for

COBRA continuation coverage. Even though the plan is generally

excepted from COBRA during 2003, 2004, and 2005, it must

nevertheless continue to make COBRA continuation coverage available

to S during those years until the obligation to make COBRA

continuation coverage available ceases under the rules of

Sec. 54.4980B-7. The obligation could continue until April 1, 2005,

the date that is 36 months after the date of S's qualifying event.

Example 3. The facts are the same as in Example 2. C is a

dependent child of one of the employer's employees and is covered

under the plan. A dependent child is no longer eligible for coverage

under the plan upon the attainment of age 23. C attains age 23 on

November 16, 2005. The plan is excepted from COBRA with respect to C

during 2005 because the employer normally employed fewer than 20

employees during 2004. Consequently, the plan is not obligated to

make COBRA continuation coverage available to C (and would not be

obligated to make COBRA continuation coverage available to C even if

the plan later became subject to COBRA again).

Q-6: [Reserved]

A-6: [Reserved]

Q-7: What is the plan year?

A-7: (a) The plan year is the year that is designated as the plan

year in the plan documents.

(b) If the plan documents do not designate a plan year (or if there

are no plan documents), then the plan year is determined in accordance

with this paragraph (b).

(1) The plan year is the deductible/limit year used under the plan.

(2) If the plan does not impose deductibles or limits on an annual

basis, then the plan year is the policy year.

(3) If the plan does not impose deductibles or limits on an annual

basis, and either the plan is not insured or the insurance policy is

not renewed on an annual basis, then the plan year is the employer's

taxable year.

(4) In any other case, the plan year is the calendar year.

Q-8: How do the COBRA continuation coverage requirements apply to

cafeteria plans and other flexible benefit arrangements?

A-8: The provision of health care benefits does not fail to be a

group health plan merely because those benefits are offered under a

cafeteria plan (as defined in section 125) or under any other

arrangement under which an employee is offered a choice between health

care benefits and other taxable or nontaxable benefits. However, the

COBRA continuation coverage requirements apply only to the type and

level of coverage under the cafeteria plan or other flexible benefit

arrangement that a qualified beneficiary is actually receiving on the

day before the qualifying event. The rules of this Q&A-8 are

illustrated by the following example:

Example: (i) Under the terms of a cafeteria plan, employees can

choose among life insurance coverage, membership in a health

maintenance organization (HMO), coverage for medical expenses under

an indemnity arrangement, and cash compensation. Of these available

choices, the HMO and the indemnity arrangement are the arrangements

providing health care. The instruments governing the HMO and

indemnity arrangements indicate that they are separate group health

plans. These group health plans are subject to COBRA. The employer

does not provide any group health plan outside of the cafeteria

plan. B and C are unmarried employees. B has chosen the life

insurance coverage, and C has chosen the indemnity arrangement.

(ii) B does not have to be offered COBRA continuation coverage

upon terminating employment, nor is a subsequent open enrollment

period for active employees required to be made available to B.

However, if C terminates employment and the termination constitutes

a qualifying event, C must be offered an opportunity to elect COBRA

continuation coverage under the indemnity arrangement. If C makes

such an election and an open enrollment period for active employees

occurs while C is still receiving the COBRA continuation coverage, C

must be offered the opportunity to switch from the indemnity

arrangement to the HMO (but not to the life insurance coverage

because that does not constitute coverage provided under a group

health plan).

Q-9: What is the effect of a group health plan's failure to comply

with the requirements of section 4980B(f)?

A-9: Under section 4980B(a), if a group health plan subject to

COBRA fails to comply with section 4980B(f), an excise tax is imposed.

Moreover, non-tax remedies may be available if the plan fails to comply

with the parallel requirements in ERISA, which are administered by the

Department of Labor.

Q-10: Who is liable for the excise tax if a group health plan fails

to comply with the requirements of section 4980B(f)?

A-10: (a) In general, the excise tax is imposed on the employer

maintaining the plan, except that in the case of a multiemployer plan

the excise tax is imposed on the plan.

(b) In certain circumstances, the excise tax is also imposed on a

person involved with the provision of benefits under the plan (other

than in the capacity of an employee), such as an insurer providing

benefits under the plan or a third party administrator administering

claims under the plan. In general, such a person will be liable for the

excise tax if the person assumes, under a legally enforceable written

agreement, the responsibility for performing the act to which the

failure to comply with the COBRA continuation coverage requirements

relates. Such a person will be liable for the excise tax

notwithstanding the absence of a written agreement assuming

responsibility for complying with COBRA if the person provides coverage

under the plan to a similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiary (see Q&A-3

of Sec. 54.4980B-3 for a definition of similarly situated nonCOBRA

beneficiaries) and the employer or plan administrator submits a written

request to the person to provide to a qualified beneficiary the same

coverage that the person provides to the similarly situated nonCOBRA

beneficiary. If the person providing coverage under the plan to a

similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiary is the plan administrator and

the qualifying event is a divorce or legal separation or a dependent

child's ceasing to be covered under the generally applicable

requirements of the plan, the plan administrator will also be liable

for the excise tax if the qualified beneficiary submits a written

request for coverage.

Sec. 54.4980B-3 Qualified beneficiaries.

The determination of who is a qualified beneficiary, an employee,

or a covered employee, and of who are the similarly situated nonCOBRA

beneficiaries is addressed in the following questions-and-answers:

Q-1: Who is a qualified beneficiary?

A-1: (a)(1) Except as set forth in paragraphs (c) through (f) of

this Q&A-1, a qualified beneficiary is--

(i) Any individual who, on the day before a qualifying event, is

covered under a group health plan by virtue of being on that day either

a covered

[[Page 5177]]

employee, the spouse of a covered employee, or a dependent child of the

covered employee; or

(ii) Any child who is born to or placed for adoption with a covered

employee during a period of COBRA continuation coverage.

(2) In the case of a qualifying event that is the bankruptcy of the

employer, a covered employee who had retired on or before the date of

substantial elimination of group health plan coverage is also a

qualified beneficiary, as is any spouse, surviving spouse, or dependent

child of such a covered employee if, on the day before the bankruptcy

qualifying event, the spouse, surviving spouse, or dependent child is a

beneficiary under the plan.

(3) In general, an individual (other than a child who is born to or

placed for adoption with a covered employee during a period of COBRA

continuation coverage) who is not covered under a plan on the day

before the qualifying event cannot be a qualified beneficiary with

respect to that qualifying event, and the reason for the individual's

lack of actual coverage (such as the individual's having declined

participation in the plan or failed to satisfy the plan's conditions

for participation) is not relevant for this purpose. However, if the

individual is denied or not offered coverage under a plan under

circumstances in which the denial or failure to offer constitutes a

violation of applicable law (such as the Americans with Disabilities

Act, 42 U.S.C. 12101-12213, the special enrollment rules of section

9801, or the requirements of section 9802 prohibiting discrimination in

eligibility to enroll in a group health plan based on health status),

then, for purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8, the

individual will be considered to have had the coverage that was

wrongfully denied or not offered.

(4) Paragraph (b) of this Q&A-1 describes how certain family

members are not qualified beneficiaries even if they become covered

under the plan; paragraphs (c), (d), and (e) of this Q&A-1 place limits

on the general rules of this paragraph (a) concerning who is a

qualified beneficiary; paragraph (f) of this Q&A-1 provides when an

individual who has been a qualified beneficiary ceases to be a

qualified beneficiary; paragraph (g) of this Q&A-1 defines placed for

adoption; and paragraph (h) of this Q&A-1 contains examples.

(b) In contrast to a child who is born to or placed for adoption

with a covered employee during a period of COBRA continuation coverage,

an individual who marries any qualified beneficiary on or after the

date of the qualifying event and a newborn or adopted child (other than

one born to or placed for adoption with a covered employee) are not

qualified beneficiaries by virtue of the marriage, birth, or placement

for adoption or by virtue of the individual's status as the spouse or

the child's status as a dependent of the qualified beneficiary. These

new family members do not themselves become qualified beneficiaries

even if they become covered under the plan. (For situations in which a

plan is required to make coverage available to new family members of a

qualified beneficiary who is receiving COBRA continuation coverage, see

Q&A-5 of Sec. 54.4980B-5, paragraph (c) in Q&A-4 of Sec. 54.4980B-5,

section 9801(f)(2), and Sec. 54.9801-6T(b).)

(c) An individual is not a qualified beneficiary if, on the day

before the qualifying event referred to in paragraph (a) of this Q&A-1,

the individual is covered under the group health plan by reason of

another individual's election of COBRA continuation coverage and is not

already a qualified beneficiary by reason of a prior qualifying event.

(d) A covered employee can be a qualified beneficiary only in

connection with a qualifying event that is the termination, or

reduction of hours, of the covered employee's employment, or that is

the bankruptcy of the employer.

(e) An individual is not a qualified beneficiary if the

individual's status as a covered employee is attributable to a period

in which the individual was a nonresident alien who received from the

individual's employer no earned income (within the meaning of section

911(d)(2)) that constituted income from sources within the United

States (within the meaning of section 861(a)(3)). If, pursuant to the

preceding sentence, an individual is not a qualified beneficiary, then

a spouse or dependent child of the individual is not considered a

qualified beneficiary by virtue of the relationship to the individual.

(f) A qualified beneficiary who does not elect COBRA continuation

coverage in connection with a qualifying event ceases to be a qualified

beneficiary at the end of the election period (see Q&A-1 of

Sec. 54.4980B-6). Thus, for example, if such a former qualified

beneficiary is later added to a covered employee's coverage (e.g.,

during an open enrollment period) and then another qualifying event

occurs with respect to the covered employee, the former qualified

beneficiary does not become a qualified beneficiary by reason of the

second qualifying event. If a covered employee who is a qualified

beneficiary does not elect COBRA continuation coverage during the

election period, then any child born to or placed for adoption with the

covered employee on or after the date of the qualifying event is not a

qualified beneficiary. Once a plan's obligation to make COBRA

continuation coverage available to an individual who has been a

qualified beneficiary ceases under the rules of Sec. 54.4980B-7, the

individual ceases to be a qualified beneficiary.

(g) For purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8, placement

for adoption or being placed for adoption means the assumption and

retention by the covered employee of a legal obligation for total or

partial support of a child in anticipation of the adoption of the

child. The child's placement for adoption with the covered employee

terminates upon the termination of the legal obligation for total or

partial support. A child who is immediately adopted by the covered

employee without a preceding placement for adoption is considered to be

placed for adoption on the date of the adoption.

(h) The rules of this Q&A-1 are illustrated by the following

examples:

Example 1. (i) B is a single employee who voluntarily terminates

employment and elects COBRA continuation coverage under a group

health plan. To comply with the requirements of section 9801(f) and

Sec. 54.9801-6T(b), the plan permits a covered employee who marries

to have her or his spouse covered under the plan. One month after

electing COBRA continuation coverage, B marries and chooses to have

B's spouse covered under the plan.

(ii) B's spouse is not a qualified beneficiary. Thus, if B dies

during the period of COBRA continuation coverage, the plan does not

have to offer B's surviving spouse an opportunity to elect COBRA

continuation coverage.

Example 2. (i) C is a married employee who terminates

employment. C elects COBRA continuation coverage for C but not C's

spouse, and C's spouse declines to elect such coverage. C's spouse

thus ceases to be a qualified beneficiary. At the next open

enrollment period, C adds the spouse as a beneficiary under the

plan.

(ii) The addition of the spouse during the open enrollment

period does not make the spouse a qualified beneficiary. The plan

thus will not have to offer the spouse an opportunity to elect COBRA

continuation coverage upon a later divorce from or death of C.

Example 3. (i) Under the terms of a group health plan, a covered

employee's child, upon attaining age 19, ceases to be a dependent

eligible for coverage.

(ii) At that time, the child must be offered an opportunity to

elect COBRA continuation coverage. If the child elects COBRA

continuation coverage, the child marries during the period of the

COBRA continuation coverage, and the child's spouse becomes covered

under the group health plan, the child's spouse is not a qualified

beneficiary.

[[Page 5178]]

Example 4. (i) D is a single employee who, upon retirement, is

given the opportunity to elect COBRA continuation coverage but

declines it in favor of an alternative offer of 12 months of

employer-paid retiree health benefits. At the end of the election

period, D ceases to be a qualified beneficiary and will not have to

be given another opportunity to elect COBRA continuation coverage

(at the end of those 12 months or at any other time). D marries E

during the period of retiree health coverage and, under the terms of

that coverage, E becomes covered under the plan.

(ii) If a divorce from or death of D will result in E's losing

coverage, E will be a qualified beneficiary because E's coverage

under the plan on the day before the qualifying event (that is, the

divorce or death) will have been by reason of D's acceptance of 12

months of employer-paid coverage after the prior qualifying event

(D's retirement) rather than by reason of an election of COBRA

continuation coverage.

Example 5. (i) The facts are the same as in Example 4, except

that, under the terms of the plan, the divorce or death does not

cause E to lose coverage so that E continues to be covered for the

balance of the original 12-month period.

(ii) E does not have to be allowed to elect COBRA continuation

coverage because the loss of coverage at the end of the 12-month

period is not caused by the divorce or death, and thus the divorce

or death does not constitute a qualifying event. See Q&A-1 of

Sec. 54.4980B-4.

Q-2: Who is an employee and who is a covered employee?

A-2: (a)(1) For purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8

(except for purposes of Q&A-5 in Sec. 54.4980B-2, relating to the

exception from COBRA for plans maintained by an employer with fewer

than 20 employees), an employee is any individual who is eligible to be

covered under a group health plan by virtue of the performance of

services for the employer maintaining the plan or by virtue of

membership in the employee organization maintaining the plan. Thus, for

purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8 (except for purposes of

Q&A-5 in Sec. 54.4980B-2), the following individuals are employees if

their relationship to the employer maintaining the plan makes them

eligible to be covered under the plan--

(i) Self-employed individuals (within the meaning of section

401(c)(1));

(ii) Independent contractors (and their employees and independent

contractors); and

(iii) Directors (in the case of a corporation).

(2) Similarly, whenever reference is made in Secs. 54.4980B-1

through 54.4980B-8 (except in Q&A-5 of Sec. 54.4980B-2) to an

employment relationship (such as by referring to the termination of

employment of an employee or to an employee's being employed by an

employer), the reference includes the relationship of those individuals

who are employees within the meaning of this paragraph (a). See

paragraph (c) in Q&A-5 of Sec. 54.4980B-2 for a narrower meaning of

employee solely for purposes of Q&A-5 of Sec. 54.4980B-2.

(b) For purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8, a covered

employee is any individual who is (or was) provided coverage under a

group health plan (other than a plan that is excepted from COBRA on the

date of the qualifying event; see Q&A-4 of Sec. 54.4980B-2) by virtue

of being or having been an employee. For example, a retiree or former

employee who is covered by a group health plan is a covered employee if

the coverage results in whole or in part from her or his previous

employment. An employee (or former employee) who is merely eligible for

coverage under a group health plan is generally not a covered employee

if the employee (or former employee) is not actually covered under the

plan. In general, the reason for the employee's (or former employee's)

lack of actual coverage (such as having declined participation in the

plan or having failed to satisfy the plan's conditions for

participation) is not relevant for this purpose. However, if the

employee (or former employee) is denied or not offered coverage under

circumstances in which the denial or failure to offer constitutes a

violation of applicable law (such as the Americans with Disabilities

Act, 42 U.S.C. 12101 through 12213, the special enrollment rules of

section 9801, or the requirements of section 9802 prohibiting

discrimination in eligibility to enroll in a group health plan based on

health status), then, for purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through

54.4980B-8, the employee (or former employee) will be considered to

have had the coverage that was wrongfully denied or not offered.

Q-3: Who are the similarly situated non-COBRA beneficiaries?

A-3: For purposes of Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8, similarly

situated non-COBRA beneficiaries means the group of covered employees,

spouses of covered employees, or dependent children of covered

employees receiving coverage under a group health plan maintained by

the employer or employee organization who are receiving that coverage

for a reason other than the rights provided under the COBRA

continuation coverage requirements and who, based on all of the facts

and circumstances, are most similarly situated to the situation of the

qualified beneficiary immediately before the qualifying event.

Sec. 54.4980B-4 Qualifying events.

The determination of what constitutes a qualifying event is

addressed in the following questions and answers:

Q-1: What is a qualifying event?

A-1: (a) A qualifying event is an event that satisfies paragraphs

(b), (c), and (d) of this Q&A-1. Paragraph (e) of this Q&A-1 further

explains a reduction of hours of employment, paragraph (f) of this Q&A-

1 describes the treatment of children born to or placed for adoption

with a covered employee during a period of COBRA continuation coverage,

and paragraph (g) of this Q&A-1 contains examples.

(b) An event satisfies this paragraph (b) if the event is any of

the following--

(1) The death of a covered employee;

(2) The termination (other than by reason of the employee's gross

misconduct), or reduction of hours, of a covered employee's employment;

(3) The divorce or legal separation of a covered employee from the

employee's spouse;

(4) A covered employee's becoming entitled to Medicare benefits

under Title XVIII of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 1395-1395ggg);

(5) A dependent child's ceasing to be a dependent child of a

covered employee under the generally applicable requirements of the

plan; or

(6) A proceeding in bankruptcy under Title 11 of the United States

Code with respect to an employer from whose employment a covered

employee retired at any time.

(c) An event satisfies this paragraph (c) if, under the terms of

the group health plan, the event causes the covered employee, or the

spouse or a dependent child of the covered employee, to lose coverage

under the plan. For this purpose, to lose coverage means to cease to be

covered under the same terms and conditions as in effect immediately

before the qualifying event. Any increase in the premium or

contribution that must be paid by a covered employee (or the spouse or

dependent child of a covered employee) for coverage under a group

health plan that results from the occurrence of one of the events

listed in paragraph (b) of this Q&A-1 is a loss of coverage. In the

case of an event that is the bankruptcy of the employer, lose coverage

also means any substantial elimination of coverage under the plan,

occurring within 12 months before or after the date the bankruptcy

proceeding commences, for a covered employee who had retired on or

before the date of the substantial elimination of group health plan

coverage or for any spouse, surviving spouse, or dependent child of

such a covered employee if, on the day

[[Page 5179]]

before the bankruptcy qualifying event, the spouse, surviving spouse,

or dependent child is a beneficiary under the plan. For purposes of

this paragraph (c), a loss of coverage need not occur immediately after

the event, so long as the loss of coverage occurs before the end of the

maximum coverage period (see Q&A-1 and Q&A-6 of Sec. 54.4980B-7).

However, if neither the covered employee nor the spouse or a dependent

child of the covered employee loses coverage before the end of what

would be the maximum coverage period, the event does not satisfy this

paragraph (c). If coverage is reduced or eliminated in anticipation of

an event (for example, an employer's eliminating an employee's coverage

in anticipation of the termination of the employee's employment, or an

employee's eliminating the coverage of the employee's spouse in

anticipation of a divorce or legal separation), the reduction or

elimination is disregarded in determining whether the event causes a

loss of coverage.

(d) An event satisfies this paragraph (d) if it occurs while the

plan is subject to COBRA. Thus, an event will not satisfy this

paragraph (d) if it occurs while the plan is excepted from COBRA (see

Q&A-4 of Sec. 54.4980B-2). Even if the plan later becomes subject to

COBRA, it is not required to make COBRA continuation coverage available

to anyone whose coverage ends as a result of an event during a year in

which the plan is excepted from COBRA. For example, if a group health

plan is excepted from COBRA as a small-employer plan during the year

2001 (see Q&A-5 of Sec. 54.4980B-2) and an employee terminates

employment on December 31, 2001, the termination is not a qualifying

event and the plan is not required to permit the employee to elect

COBRA continuation coverage. This is the case even if the plan ceases

to be a small-employer plan as of January 1, 2002. Also, the same

result will follow even if the employee is given three months of

coverage beyond December 31 (that is, through March of 2002), because

there will be no qualifying event as of the termination of coverage in

March. However, if the employee's spouse is initially provided with the

three-month coverage through March 2002, but the spouse divorces the

employee before the end of the three months and loses coverage as a

result of the divorce, the divorce will constitute a qualifying event

during 2002 and so entitle the spouse to elect COBRA continuation

coverage. See Q&A-7 of Sec. 54.4980B-7 regarding the maximum coverage

period in such a case.

(e) A reduction of hours of a covered employee's employment occurs

whenever there is a decrease in the hours that a covered employee is

required to work or actually works, but only if the decrease is not

accompanied by an immediate termination of employment. This is true

regardless of whether the covered employee continues to perform

services following the reduction of hours of employment. For example,

an absence from work due to disability, a temporary layoff, or any

other reason is a reduction of hours of a covered employee's employment

if there is not an immediate termination of employment. If a group

health plan measures eligibility for the coverage of employees by the

number of hours worked in a given time period, such as the preceding

month or quarter, and an employee covered under the plan fails to work

the minimum number of hours during that time period, the failure to

work the minimum number of required hours is a reduction of hours of

that covered employee's employment.

(f) The qualifying event of a qualified beneficiary who is a child

born to or placed for adoption with a covered employee during a period

of COBRA continuation coverage is the qualifying event giving rise to

the period of COBRA continuation coverage during which the child is

born or placed for adoption. If a second qualifying event has occurred

before the child is born or placed for adoption (such as the death of

the covered employee), then the second qualifying event also applies to

the newborn or adopted child. See Q&A-6 of Sec. 54.4980B-7.

(g) The rules of this Q&A-1 are illustrated by the following

examples, in each of which the group health plan is subject to COBRA:

Example 1. (i) An employee who is covered by a group health plan

terminates employment (other than by reason of the employee's gross

misconduct) and, beginning with the day after the last day of

employment, is given 3 months of employer-paid coverage under the

same terms and conditions as before that date. At the end of the

three months, the coverage terminates.

(ii) The loss of coverage at the end of the three months results

from the termination of employment and, thus, the termination of

employment is a qualifying event.

Example 2. (i) An employee who is covered by a group health plan

retires (which is a termination of employment other than by reason

of the employee's gross misconduct) and, upon retirement, is

required to pay an increased amount for the same group health

coverage that the employee had before retirement.

(ii) The increase in the premium or contribution required for

coverage is a loss of coverage under paragraph (c) of this Q&A-1

and, thus, the retirement is a qualifying event.

Example 3. (i) An employee and the employee's spouse are covered

under an employer's group health plan. The employee retires and is

given identical coverage for life. However, the plan provides that

the spousal coverage will not be continued beyond six months unless

a higher premium for the spouse is paid to the plan.

(ii) The requirement for the spouse to pay a higher premium at

the end of the six months is a loss of coverage under paragraph (c)

of this Q&A-1. Thus, the retirement is a qualifying event and the

spouse must be given an opportunity to elect COBRA continuation

coverage.

Example 4. (i) F is a covered employee who is married to G, and

both are covered under a group health plan maintained by F's

employer. F and G are divorced. Under the terms of the plan, the

divorce causes G to lose coverage. The divorce is a qualifying

event, and G elects COBRA continuation coverage, remarries during

the period of COBRA continuation coverage, and G's new spouse

becomes covered under the plan. (See Q&A-5 in Sec. 54.4980B-5,

paragraph (c) in Q&A-4 of Sec. 54.4980B-5, section 9801(f)(2), and

Sec. 54.9801-6T(b).) G dies. Under the terms of the plan, the death

causes G's new spouse to lose coverage under the plan.

(ii) G's death is not a qualifying event because G is not a

covered employee.

Example 5. (i) An employer maintains a group health plan for

both active employees and retired employees (and their families).

The coverage for active employees and retired employees is

identical, and the employer does not require retirees to pay more

for coverage than active employees. The plan does not make COBRA

continuation coverage available when an employee retires (and is not

required to because the retired employee has not lost coverage under

the plan). The employer amends the plan to eliminate coverage for

retired employees effective January 1, 2002. On that date, several

retired employees (and their spouses and dependent children) have

been covered under the plan since their retirement for less than the

maximum coverage period that would apply to them in connection with

their retirement.

(ii) The elimination of retiree coverage under these

circumstances is a deferred loss of coverage for those retirees (and

their spouses and dependent children) under paragraph (c) of this

Q&A-1 and, thus, the retirement is a qualifying event. The plan must

make COBRA continuation coverage available to them for the balance

of the maximum coverage period that applies to them in connection

with the retirement.

Q-2: Are the facts surrounding a termination of employment (such as

whether it was voluntary or involuntary) relevant in determining

whether the termination of employment is a qualifying event?

A-2: Apart from facts constituting gross misconduct, the facts

surrounding the termination or reduction of hours are irrelevant in

determining whether a qualifying event has occurred. Thus, it

[[Page 5180]]

does not matter whether the employee voluntarily terminated or was

discharged. For example, a strike or a lockout is a termination or

reduction of hours that constitutes a qualifying event if the strike or

lockout results in a loss of coverage as described in paragraph (c) of

Q&A-1 of this section. Similarly, a layoff that results in such a loss

of coverage is a qualifying event.

Sec. 54.4980B-5 COBRA continuation coverage.

The following questions-and-answers address the requirements for

coverage to constitute COBRA continuation coverage:

Q-1: What is COBRA continuation coverage?

A-1: (a) If a qualifying event occurs, each qualified beneficiary

(other than a qualified beneficiary for whom the qualifying event will

not result in any immediate or deferred loss of coverage) must be

offered an opportunity to elect to receive the group health plan

coverage that is provided to similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries

(ordinarily, the same coverage that the qualified beneficiary had on

the day before the qualifying event). See Q&A-3 of Sec. 54.4980B-3 for

the definition of similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries. This

coverage is COBRA continuation coverage. If coverage under the plan is

modified for similarly situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries, then the

coverage made available to qualified beneficiaries is modified in the

same way. If the continuation coverage offered differs in any way from

the coverage made available to similarly situated nonCOBRA

beneficiaries, the coverage offered does not constitute COBRA

continuation coverage and the group health plan is not in compliance

with COBRA unless other coverage that does constitute COBRA

continuation coverage is also offered. Any elimination or reduction of

coverage in anticipation of an event described in paragraph (b) of Q&A-

1 of Sec. 54.4980B-4 is disregarded for purposes of this Q&A-1 and for

purposes of any other reference in Secs. 54.4980B-1 through 54.4980B-8

to coverage in effect immediately before (or on the day before) a

qualifying event. COBRA continuation coverage must not be conditioned

upon, or discriminate on the basis of lack of, evidence of

insurability.

(b) In the case of a qualified beneficiary who is a child born to

or placed for adoption with a covered employee during a period of COBRA

continuation coverage, the child is generally entitled to elect

immediately to have the same coverage that dependent children of active

employees receive under the benefit packages under which the covered

employee has coverage at the time of the birth or placement for

adoption. Such a child would be entitled to elect coverage different

from that elected by the covered employee during the next available

open enrollment period under the plan. See Q&A-4 of this section.

Q-2: What deductibles apply if COBRA continuation coverage is

elected?

A-2: (a) Qualified beneficiaries electing COBRA continuation

coverage generally are subject to the same deductibles as similarly

situated nonCOBRA beneficiaries. If a qualified beneficiary's COBRA

continuation coverage begins before the end of a period prescribed for

accumulating amounts toward deductibles, the qualified beneficiary must

retain credit for expenses incurred toward those deductibles before the

beginning of COBRA continuation coverage as though the qualifying event

had not occurred. The specific application of this rule depends on the

type of deductible, as set forth in paragraphs (b) through (d) of this

Q&A-2. Special rules are set forth in paragraph (e) of this Q&A-2, and

examples appear in paragraph (f) of this Q&A-2.

(b) If a deductible is computed separately for each individual

receiving coverage under the plan, each individual's remaining

deductible amount (if any) on the date COBRA continuation coverage

begins is equal to that individual's remaining deductible amount

immediately before that date.

(c) If a deductible is computed on a family basis, the remaining

deductible for the family on the date that COBRA continuation coverage

begins depends on the members of the family electing COBRA continuation

coverage. In computing the family deductible that remains on the date

COBRA continuation coverage begins, only the expenses of those family

members receiving COBRA continuation coverage need be taken into

account. If the qualifying event results in there being more than one

family unit (for example, because of a divorce), the family deductible

may be computed separately for each resulting family unit based on the

members in each unit. These rules apply regardless of whether the plan

provides that the family deductible is an alternative to individual

deductibles or an additional requirement.

(d) Deductibles that are not described in paragraph (b) or (c) of

this Q&A-2 must be treated in a manner consistent with the principles

set forth in those paragraphs.

(e) If a deductible is computed on the basis of a covered

employee's compensation instead of being a fixed dollar amount and the

employee remains employed during the period of COBRA continuation

coverage, the plan is permitted to choose whether to apply the

deductible by treating the employee's compensation as continuing

without change for the duration of the COBRA continuation coverage at

the level that was used to compute the deductible in effect immediately

before the COBRA continuation coverage began, or to apply the

deductible by taking the employee's actual compensation into account.

In applying a deductible that is computed on the basis of the covered

employee's compensation instead of being a fixed dollar amount, for

periods of COBRA continuation coverage in which the employee is not

employed by the employer, the plan is required to compute the

deductible by treating the employee's compensation as continuing

without change for the duration of the COBRA continuation coverage

either at the level that was used to compute the deductible in effect

immediately before the COBRA continuation coverage began or at the

level that was used to compute the deductible in effect immediately

before the employee's employment was terminated.

(f) The rules of this Q&A-2 are illustrated by the following

examples; in each example, deductibles under the plan are determined on

a calendar year basis:

Example 1. (i) A group health plan applies a separate $100

annual deductible to each individual it covers. The plan provides

that the spouse and dependent children of a covered employee will

lose coverage on the last day of the month after the month of the

covered employee's death. A covered employee dies on June 11, 2001.

The spouse and the two dependent children elect COBRA continuation

coverage, which will begin on August 1, 2001. As of July 31, 2001,

the spouse has incurred $80 of covered expenses, the older child has

incurred no covered expenses, and the younger one has incurred $120

of covered expenses (and therefore has already satisfied the

deductible).

(ii) At the beginning of COBRA continuation coverage on August

1, the spouse has a remaining deductible of $20, the older child

still has the full $100 deductible, and the younger one has no

further deductible.

Example 2. (i) A group health plan applies a separate $200

annual deductible to each individual it covers, except that each

family member is treated as having satisfied the individual

deductible once the family has incurred $500 of covered expenses

during the year. The plan provides that upon the divorce of a

covered employee, coverage will

[[Page 5181]]

end immediately for the employee's spouse and any children who do

not remain in the employee's custody. A covered employee with four

dependent children is divorced, the spouse obtains custody of the

two oldest children, and the spouse and those children all elect

COBRA continuation coverage to begin immediately. The family had

accumulated $420 of covered expenses before the divorce, as follows:

$70 by each parent, $200 by the oldest child, $80 by the youngest

child, and none by the other two children.

(ii) The resulting family consisting of the spouse and the two

oldest children accumulated a total of $270 of covered expenses, and

thus the remaining deductible for that family could be as high as

$230 (because the plan would not have to count the incurred expenses

of the covered employee and the youngest child). The remaining

d

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Continuation Coverage Requirements Applicable to Group Health Plans · 64 FR 5160 | Frix