Shoreline Management Initiative (SMI), Reservoirs in Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia

Federal RegisterJun 4, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY

Shoreline Management Initiative (SMI), Reservoirs in Alabama,

Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia

AGENCY: Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA).

ACTION: Issuance of record of decision.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This notice is provided in accordance with the Council on

Environmental Quality's regulations (40 CFR parts 1500 to 1508) and

TVA's procedures implementing the National Environmental Policy Act. On

April 21, 1999, the TVA Board of Directors decided to adopt the

preferred alternative (Blended Alternative) identified in its Final

Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), Shoreline Management Initiative:

An Assessment of Residential Shoreline Development Impacts in the

Tennessee Valley. The Board's decision modified the Blended Alternative

by increasing the shoreline management zone (SMZ) from 25 to 50 feet.

The Final EIS was made available to the public in November 1998. A

Notice of Availability of the Final EIS was published in the Federal

Register on December 11, 1998. Under the Blended Alternative, TVA seeks

to balance residential shoreline development, recreation use, and

resource conservation needs in a way that maintains the quality of life

and other important values provided by its reservoir system. TVA has

decided to adopt a strategy of ``maintaining and gaining'' public

shoreline, continue to allow docks and other alterations along

shorelines now available for residential

[[Page 30093]]

access and establish uniform standards for these alterations, and

ensure that sensitive natural and cultural resources are conserved for

future generations.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Harold M. Draper, NEPA Specialist,

Environmental Management, Tennessee Valley Authority, 400 West Summit

Hill Drive, WT 8C, Knoxville, Tennessee 37902-1499; telephone (423)

632-6889 or e-mail [email protected].

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Residential shoreline development along TVA

reservoirs continues to increase. Currently, the amount of residential

shoreline development on individual TVA reservoirs ranges from none to

51 percent of the shoreline length. Of the 11,000 miles of total

shoreline, 13 percent have been developed for residential uses. From

1988 to 1997, TVA approved almost 19,000 applications for residential

shoreline alterations, such as docks, piers, boathouses, retaining

walls, and vegetation management. Residential shoreline use requests

substantially dominate all requests for other uses (e.g., commercial,

industrial) combined. During this period, the number of permits

increased at a rate of six percent per year. If these trends and

current shoreline management practices continue, TVA estimates that

over half the shoreline could be developed within the next 25 years.

This level of shoreline development could have unacceptable adverse

impacts on shoreline and aquatic ecology, water quality, scenic beauty,

and other valuable resources. TVA initiated the SMI project to review

existing permitting practices and establish a policy to better protect

shoreline and aquatic resources, while allowing adjacent residents

reasonable access to the water.

On May 27, 1994, TVA issued a Notice of Intent to prepare an EIS on

alternatives for management of TVA shoreline residential uses. Public

scoping meetings were held in 13 locations throughout the Tennessee

River Watershed in June and July of 1994. The Notice of Availability

for the Draft EIS was published on June 28, 1996. TVA subsequently held

16 public meetings throughout the Tennessee River Watershed and in

nearby major cities (Nashville and Memphis) in July, August, and

September 1996 to receive comments. Almost 10,000 written and oral

comments were recorded. The Notice of Availability for the Final EIS

was published on December 11, 1998.

Alternatives Considered

TVA initially considered six alternatives to respond to continuing

residential shoreline development along TVA shorelines. In response to

public comments on the Draft EIS, TVA developed a seventh alternative,

designated the Blended Alternative because it included features of

several of the previous alternatives. The alternatives were designed to

vary in the standards envisioned for residential shoreline alterations.

In addition, the alternatives varied in whether additional shoreline

could be opened for residential access.

Under Alternative A: Limited TVA Role Along Open Shoreline and

Additional Areas, there would be no predefined standards for facility

design or appearance, vegetation removal, or other shoreline

alterations. TVA would, however, review permit applications for

compliance with federal laws.

Under Alternative B1: Existing Guidelines Along Open Shoreline and

Additional Areas, TVA would continue approving docks and other

shoreline alterations using existing guidelines. These guidelines limit

the amount and type of vegetation that can be removed, limit the size

of boat dock construction and riprap, and open additional shoreline for

residential access on a case-by-case basis. These guidelines do not

define parameters for channel excavation and do not define a maximum

land/water surface area per lot. This is the No Action alternative.

Under Alternative B2: Existing Guidelines Along Open Shoreline

Only, residential shoreline alterations would be subject to the same

standards as with Alternative B1. However, TVA would limit

consideration of new applications for residential shoreline alterations

to the 38 percent of the shoreline where private access rights

currently exist.

Under Alternative C1: Managed Development Along Open Shoreline and

Additional Areas, TVA would enhance land management plans that are

prepared for each reservoir with a shoreline inventory and

categorization system and replace existing permitting guidelines with

new standards. In these plans, TVA would identify additional areas to

make available for residential access. The standards would maintain a

100-foot deep vegetative shoreline management zone on TVA property and

define the maximum land/water surface area that could be disturbed per

lot. Individual boat channels involving less than 150 cubic yards of

dredging would be considered. It was estimated that up to 48 percent of

the shoreline could be developed under this alternative. This was

identified as TVA's preferred alternative in the Draft EIS.

Under Alternative C2: Managed Development Along Open Shoreline

Only, residential shoreline alterations would be subject to the same

standards as with Alternative C1. However, TVA would limit

considerations of new applications to the 38 percent of the shoreline

where private access rights currently exist.

Under Alternative D: Minimum Disturbance Along Open Shoreline Only,

TVA would limit consideration of applications for residential shoreline

alterations to the 38 percent of the shoreline where access rights

currently exist. In addition, a shoreline categorization system would

be added to the reservoir land management plans prepared for individual

reservoirs. A comprehensive set of shoreline development standards

would be implemented, including a minimal access path, minimal

vegetation clearing within a 100-foot shoreline management zone, and a

low profile dock covering less than 300 square feet of surface area.

Channel excavation would be prohibited.

Under the Blended Alternative, TVA would adopt a shoreline

management policy that allows environmentally responsible development

of shorelands where residential access rights exist and preserves

public benefits along shorelines where residential access rights do not

exist. In addition, TVA would encourage voluntary conservation

commitments across some areas with outstanding residential access

rights. Standards under the Blended Alternative would include a 25-

foot-deep shoreline vegetation management (protection) zone with a 20-

foot access/visual corridor, limited vegetation disturbance outside of

the SMZ, and boat channels with 150 cubic yards of dredging or less.

For TVA residential access shoreland further than 25 feet from the

reservoir, TVA would only permit limited cutting of small trees and

selective removal of certain plants like poison ivy and invasive exotic

plants such as honeysuckle. Existing development and uses established

prior to the implementation date of the new alternative would be

grandfathered. Also, waivers could be requested by owners of property

within preexisting developments.

Response to Comments on Final EIS

Volume II of the Final EIS contains summaries of and responses to

the comments TVA received during the Draft EIS process. TVA received

almost 9,500 separate comments. Although not required, TVA gave the

public the opportunity to provide comments about the Final EIS and the

Blended Alternative. To facilitate this, TVA held 15 public information

sessions about the

[[Page 30094]]

Final EIS and the Blended Alternative and met with and briefed numerous

stakeholders including elected officials, lake associations, and

conservation and environmental groups.

A total of 215 comment forms and 27 letters were received on the

Final EIS. Most of these comments were similar to the comments that TVA

received on the Draft EIS, except for those that commented specifically

on the Blended Alternative. In general, the public supported the

Blended Alternative and viewed it as a substantial improvement over

TVA's earlier preferred alternative, Alternative C1. A number of

commenters suggested modifications to some of the Blended Alternative

standards (e.g., increasing the width of the SMZ), but these were

within the range of alternatives previously considered.

Decision

The TVA Board decided to modify the Blended Alternative to include

a 50-foot SMZ (an increase from 25 feet in the Final EIS). Other

components of the Blended Alternative were adopted. The Blended

Alternative appropriately balances residential shoreline development,

recreation use, and resource conservation needs in a way that maintains

the quality of life and other important values provided by the

reservoir system. It recognizes the reality that previous decisions

have already opened up 38 percent of TVA's shorelands to access, but

commits to holding the line at this level and possibly ``gaining'' back

some of the already opened lands in a way that would heighten their

protection. The Blended Alternative also responds well to the public

comments TVA received during the EIS process because it combines

features from other alternatives that were generally supported, while

not incorporating features that were controversial and highly

objectionable to some segments of the public. During the period

following publication of the Final EIS, a number of organizations

questioned the adequacy of the 25-foot SMZ. These included the

Department of the Interior, Kentucky Department for Fish and Wildlife

Resources, Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency, Tennessee Conservation

League, and Tennessee Citizens for Wilderness Planning. In response to

these comments, the Board decided to increase the size of the SMZ to 50

feet in order to further protect the Tennessee River system.

TVA will include the Blended Alternative standards in its

permitting regulations. The standards and policies identified in the

Blended Alternative, as modified by the April 21, 1999, Board of

Directors decision, apply to all TVA reservoirs and become effective

November 1, 1999.

Environmentally Preferable Alternative

TVA has concluded that Alternative D, which seeks minimum

disturbance along shoreline available for residential access and does

not allow additional shoreland to be opened, is the environmentally

preferable alternative. However, the purpose of SMI is to better

protect the environment while allowing reasonable access to the

shoreline by adjacent residents who hold outstanding access rights. The

Blended Alternative better addresses the broader objectives of SMI and

is also substantially better environmentally than current practices.

Environmental Consequences and Commitments

The Blended Alternative advances TVA's commitment to resource

stewardship and habitat protection through strong conservation

approaches, including a shoreline inventory and categorization system

designed to protect certain significant habitats. By limiting future

residential access to shorelines where private access rights already

exist and emphasizing the need to ``maintain and gain'' public

shoreline, TVA is offering a much higher degree of protection to public

shorelines than it has offered in the past. The Blended Alternative was

formulated using environmentally protective measures. These measures

include:

Protection of sensitive natural and cultural resources

through a shoreline inventory and categorization system designating

residential access shorelines into protection, mitigation, and managed

categories.

Promotion of conservation easements across shorelands to

protect scenic landscapes, encourage clustered development, or to

provide other public benefits.

Promotion of best management practices for the

construction of docks, management of vegetation, stabilization of

shoreline erosion, and other shoreline alterations.

Emphasis on education activities and incentives as

important components of shoreline management.

With the implementation of the above environmental protection

measures, TVA has determined that adverse environmental impacts of

future residential shoreline uses would be substantially reduced. These

protective measures represent all of the practicable measures to avoid

or minimize environmental harm that are associated with this

alternative. Alternative D has associated with it additional protective

measures such as a lower dock profile, less vegetation clearing, and a

prohibition on channel excavation. This alternative was rejected for

the reasons given above.

As the components of TVA's new shoreline management policy are

implemented, TVA will continue to work with all affected interests to

promote environmentally sound stewardship of public shorelands. TVA

will also monitor shoreline development trends in order to identify any

actions that may become necessary in the future.

Dated: May 24, 1999.

Ruben O. Hernandez,

Vice President, Resource Stewardship.

[FR Doc. 99-14199 Filed 6-3-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 8120-08-U

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.