Dailey Body Company; Grant of Application for Temporary Exemption From Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 121

Federal RegisterJun 2, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

[Docket No. NHTSA 99-5287; Notice 2]

Dailey Body Company; Grant of Application for Temporary Exemption

From Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 121

We have decided to grant the application by Dailey Body Company of

Oakland, California, to exempt five trailers from Motor Vehicle Safety

Standard No. 121 Air Brake Systems. The statutory basis for our action

is that we have found that ``compliance would cause substantial

economic hardship to a manufacturer that has tried in good faith to

comply with the standard.'' 49 U.S.C. 30113.

We published notice of receipt of the application on March 22,

1999, and afforded an opportunity to comment (64 FR 13843). However, no

comments were received.

The discussion below is based upon the information that Dailey

provided in its application.

[[Page 29733]]

Why Dailey Needs an Exemption

Dailey requested an exemption for five ``special reel hauling''

trailers that it was unable to complete before March 1, 1998, because

of changes requested by its customer, Pacific Gas & Electric Co.,

(PG&E) during construction of the trailers. On March 1, 1998, an

amendment to Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 121 Air Brake

Systems became effective, requiring these trailers to be equipped with

an anti-lock brake system. According to the company, there is no after

market kit available to convert the air-over-hydraulic brake system to

meet the new requirements of S5.1.6.

Why Compliance Would Cause Dailey Substantial Economic Hardship

Since there is no aftermarket kit available to convert the trailers

to a conforming brake system, Dailey would be unable to sell them

absent an exemption. It has $250,000 of its operating capital tied up

in the trailers, and would have to absorb the loss. This figure is

almost equal to its combined net income for the years 1996 and 1997,

$252,519.

How Dailey Tried in Good Faith To Comply With Standard No. 121

Dailey's total trailer production in the 12-month period preceding

the filing of its application was 43. It was also the final-stage

manufacturer and certifier of 938 ``chassis with bodies.'' Other than

the five trailers for which it requests exemption, its trailers

manufactured since March 1, 1998, comply with Standard No. 121.

Why an Exemption for Dailey Would Be in the Public Interest and

Consistent With the Objectives of Motor Vehicle Safety

Dailey believes that it would be in the public interest ``to keep

from imposing a hardship, that could adversely affect employment, on a

company that has been successfully building truck body equipment for

over 50 years.'' Because only five trailers will be exempted, the risk

to the public will be small. The trailers were manufactured to conform

with regulations that existed at the time production was scheduled.

Our Finding That Compliance Would Cause Substantial Economic

Hardship to a Manufacturer That Has Tried in Good Faith To Comply

With Standard No. 121

If we denied Dailey's application, the company would be unable to

sell the five trailers. We assume that some of the $250,000 of its

operating capital tied up in the vehicles would not be totally lost as

Dailey indicates, but, in large part, could be reclaimed over time by

sales of components of the trailers as replacement parts. Nevertheless,

it is evident that the company's net income has been marginal in recent

years, and that recoupment of $250,000 plus profit from the sales of

the five trailers would make an immediate and material improvement in

its income statements. These trailers represent over 10 percent of its

annual trailer production.

With the exception of these trailers, Dailey's vehicles are

complying with Standard No. 121. These trailers also would have

complied had not the customer ordered changes during their production.

Dailey has sought, but not found, a means of bringing them into

conformity.

Our Finding That an Exemption Would Be in the Public Interest and

Consistent With the Objectives of Motor Vehicle Safety

Dailey argued that an exemption would be in the public interest as

avoiding an adverse effect upon employment. We agree that full

employment is in the public interest, and also conclude that the fact

that the vehicles are intended for work-performing use by a public

utility is also a factor in favor of an exemption. The presence of five

reel-hauling trailers on the public roads will not have a discernable

effect on motor vehicle safety. Further, the trailers will be certified

as meeting all other applicable Federal motor vehicle safety standards.

For the reasons discussed in the two sections above, it is hereby

found that compliance would cause substantial economic hardship to a

manufacturer that has tried in good faith to comply with the standard

from which it has requested exemption. It is further found that a

temporary exemption would be in the public interest and consistent with

the objectives of motor vehicle safety.

Accordingly, Dailey Body Company is hereby granted NHTSA Temporary

Exemption No. 99-6, from S5.1.6 of 49 CFR 571.121 Air Brake Systems, to

cover the manufacture for sale, sale, offer for sale, introduction into

interstate commerce, and delivery for introduction in interstate

commerce, of five reel-hauling trailers manufactured for Pacific Gas &

Electric Co., said exemption to expire when the last of the acts stated

above occurs with respect to the last trailer exempted by this notice,

or August 1, 1999, whichever first occurs.

Authority: 49 U.S.C. 30113; delegation of authority at 49 CFR

1.50.

Issued on: May 26, 1999.

Ricardo Martinez,

Administrator.

[FR Doc. 99-13894 Filed 6-1-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-59-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.